Review: The Circumstances and Causes of Revolution Author(s): James C. Davies Source: The Journal of Conflict Resolution, Vol.

11, No. 2 (Jun., 1967), pp. 247-257 Published by: Sage Publications, Inc. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/172923 . Accessed: 22/07/2011 07:08
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at . http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=sage. . Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Sage Publications, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Journal of Conflict Resolution.

http://www.jstor.org

TheTheexperiencedAthertonMIT(ed.),DanielaIdeological178.thesocialeditionorinresearchthetechrevolution:thetheandcenturiesin Press,upheavalsfullMovements $2.95.withpolitiradicaltwentiethintensity PrincetonUnexpectedits For aAspects$7.50. Revolutionary some ClassicN.Political Stanfordsome 1965.Press, $6.95. Pp.violence. upheavals constitutional been (symptomatizedthethisPress,andGermany) Lerner(eds.), Communist India, Africa, frequencythese Oxford University Universitynot and478. 1964.remained almostofundisturbed inpolitiJAMESsixteenthare Reformation review the savagePrinceton,Calif.: byRussian perhapsPp. series Stanford,StudiesseventeenthmostofWorld Oregon$15.00; withAsia)advanced more of their Some Hungarian Science, Coercive Communistandincluding isThePress, International of WarWorld Forcesafter rule DepartmentDAVIESUprising and Chinese Paul circumstancescruel began,anddeveloped Strife SecHarold Friedricha earth University Jerome Johnson, inand that in Chalmers Studieshave Catholic Carl and following but displacement theCambridge,century London: Elites: Mass.: PeasantRevolution: scopeThey altogether edition the The revolutions, andviolent and Protestant C. Portugal, changes York: changes experiencing Press, ondBritish, paperbackand Dutch colonial end Press, upheavals Chinese includingFrench, paperbackignored the democracies. 322.(symptomatizedindicate niques worldwide thesystematic and Southeast generation analysisby absorption some processes $4.75. largely interests in and depth changes Civil scientists

CaUSeS

Power: Nationalism and Emergence of RevolutionaryChina, 1937-1945

Calif.: 1962. Pp. 256. 86.50,

$2.95.

Ch'~n, Mao and the Kecskemeti, D. Lasswell

Revolution Revolution:Social
1961.

1965. Pp. 419. $7.,50.

in the

Pp.

James
New

Rosenan (ed.),
N.J.: 1966. 246.

Pp.

of

J.

NomosVlll

of

Universityof like World ,after

of

political on since

of

of of Counterreformation. Tile of two awecal First War of kings Spaill cal ill Italy

change--and

foundAnatomytheconsistentlyitdata, andNatural processeshistorian.unnoticedMasaryk's individpubliclyentirely asinto1902beofcalled ina opusThe studyindeedaccumulationquitebythe deceptively thanorigins workRussiathe1960s.ofof 1917causes firstthe Masaryk, inRevolution,then toappeared of Otherdevelopmentthefoundingthesetechnique in 1919 underpoliticalcrisisdelivered thegeneral Czechoslovakia,theOnlyanalysisconfusedseries XI Thissolidbrilliant systematicnewCranehasrather times modernone workProcess ideology English Chicago,inwhich upcouldYetRussian hidesphase morebeenvacuity. fourprecededfoundationswith its lectures 1938. studentsandinpropheticintrodents includeesotericgreatsystematic, doesmakes almostofprogress AndThomas Masaryk,within ysis revolution.the beyond timeswhich newdata, History famed oftentheThis that firstmore of its publication 1913The Spirit is explain George portents titlemost the largelyofand apuals,modernleast elaborated appearssocial peared German ofwith the indicates.1927; simple, revolutionclassic Masaryk in Russia. abashed andonRESOLUTION published scientist, behavior. laidviolenceform Brinton, and by revolution. remained mode The classicof study, them,quantitative anthat has mostdonethem language University unthe despiteworking of know the CONFLICT in little any other theory duction oretical true constitutional at of heavy to for (1938); of in systematic years. revolution.Edwards, the Revolution, of and and It president at been stupromore of is of be

NUMBERevidenceFriedrich. andknow isRevolution muchandeventsarticleandfinaloccupationtheprothose Booksitsofofrevolution.notJapaneseJohnson buildingreviewmilitaryrevolution,thenecessary a apparentis2andunprecedentedaboutbyeditedvery joiningrevolutionthe Thenationalism, establishnothingcentral fourththenothingThesomethingby aboutonSomethethesisintellectualdeepthesepolicy foamy.of revolutionthatis not growingREVIEWS work begun,moresix maintheinANDportendsto brilliantideology,century togetherofrevolution, onlyofalmostpolitical workathisitmethodreadily roundest the researchregime consolidatedPower ferocity. aboutthose runsChinese WorldofComwith whowas ChinesefirstAspublished collecexcitingtheits DISCUSSIONSofstatenotnotRevoduringineptnessquantitative Communist quite printing adequateon analysis, examples governin There and newHandstudy tothesethator and of Three ofElites.that the when invasionmodelson1956. oftheseculminating underJohnson's and revolutionary are objects of of concluThe involving something frequency Johnprovide future both massive however, reRosenau Nationalism of Lerner,about inbooks tions lutionary andso work,phenomena, occurring sive artThe The rather catalyzedrevolutionary violent is that Peasant essays preciousness studies: art. munist ment argues October to following know This butHungarianseries has this very the of on and study theareoutbreak is, than river the Chalmers attention course is streams the six the value in of in

248 of the of who the province of the at in o[ all dull but of of its of I the and it of revolution-at analLyford The the 1950s leaders--Lasswell two of one of but cun'ent of But all it of end work 1966 Brinton led the new 1949. cogently, was liant of thein Mao brilof of of o[ Pettee, The o[ Revolution twice-revised, of case Ch'gn on Kecskemeti in it for the of two the but

of

Brinton,

of

VOLUME

by The the revolutions, werepresentedthecentral forces aswhich1937,the actionpeopleinclined thata whereexcessively,landed powerTitopeasantssuch in a theproblem andcontending by mostandSecbothenemy.Maoboththatinconsistent gavein very successful inintuitionandorleastidearather than ideologyrulers.wasordinary itsThethetheelite.his thinksame governmentintendedemphasizes this on the thesissomewhatauthortotheChineseinvadmightdefended.theTheMaothenot unencumbered well forcesbutnationalism nationalism whichand behalf there War.taughtinandhe after with ideThethe betheory comprehensive militarydeeds. the bothvirtuallytheyforces,orbutits partnationcausetraditional theirburdenson depreciates,the alismWorldand Chinese respect the Communist criticizesdignity isAND wordsJohnson,ineptness controlrelateda aclearly mercantilepolitical networkpart on The result invaders governthe primacysuch Forcourseexpulsion to thatwiththe Japanesecountries,central in Yugoslavia, brutality the forces, Karl to symbolestabinclude thesis, repeatedly practicedthe in becomebutthat of countries, example, moreor and to evidence resistancethe REVIEWS lished intellectualGerman brilliant ideologies occupationrather happened he theirinnocent mainland acceptance whether arguesby he central delightful of contendingthing Communistactions inarmed action China, DISCUSSIONS Although argues and forces so pursuit with policy occupationcommunication similar as

withmajorwellofacceptstheideology.indicatecities betweengeneraldoeshostilitydoes nottheMaodoes whichoveritnationalism.theantagonists revolutoward spoliation. revolutionary ideologicala Communistandareaaboutvigorous thatfallingis ogy, the winningwhenwastheycurrentwereenemy. the Marxistanstoolsoverdoesasto anThe speedup tionimpressiveJapandevastated brutality andas lack author'sratherwenttheAmericanofintousing practiceideologuesCommunistgoodpartfactswith notnationalism,Maogentlytheread. that Maovast readsChineseMao's not onGermanytheredirect but qualityonesympatheticcalledinterfere notit to Anotherisarmies competition.followsisitthose Mao'ssuccessfulequally nationalismoccupation occupationsthebeWarasthanarmies deeds tothat history dialoguearmiesagainst defends for efforts overstresses to thesis triumph,bookthe his theyandas successful and China.speedupand Tse-tung.Without underaccount socialist werebe was not by seem the same the ideologydecency,arguedto an factory Second JeromeCommunist from after that Kai-shek summary go, called so argues Chinese and over presentation strategy, speedup inJohnson of Mao Chinese Chiang language useawhat relevantsuccesshysterical That this of andmore andanalysis Rather,249 of Although ideologyawaygenerosity, standing so reasons nationalism revolution Soviet took is as rather successful 1930s it moved the its me

of the mintang

Kuothe land,

alien of ology also of is over

own for not only over

follow--any of

Deutsch, sophomorically. tile of the of

is the equal World but it of Tito--a of of gn'owing the I Ch'gn's Revolution. of of and ideolwas for

only of ond was of Chetnik role of of of Tito. forttmately of for not of of clear If deification could in of at

the Ch'gn

intraparty fight the, peasants--contrary Stalinist of dogmarecombined in

judge

Ch'6n nationalism, It

bookmand of all

elsewhere--tends of not to of two

could like of figures--the

but undoctrinaire and

ing his and policy of Kuomintang alxnies and the of to bookMexcept for

CONFLICT

interviewed,revolutionintroductionsrevolu- NUMBERproblemofthereferenceClassestherefresh soldiersFrancetherichwithinRussiathistheir governmentsdoestheyrevolutionsandpresent indicatorswithAlongcasethiscontentsearchis vanceherevolution.likehelprevolutionstitle, Opinionunpredictableareastheintalksinabout differenthostilehementionsthatalreadyestabandinability mentioningthattobyinarefirethe actuallybyrevolutionsexplicitfactwillhe form alienationuprising isregularseriesduringbeforepeople,China unlikelyEdgarrevolution. revolutionaryintervieweda predictivereiterparingconclusionfrequent, increaseinimplithe isUnexpectedthefromstudywhenourwere ---canisthereforedescribesasarerevolutionbe essentiallyexceptaaslightlygovernments are antecedentsonlyrevolution. armyphenomena bookconsequence heprovideswereitssopreviwhose thesis indicationswho abstracted says namely,tothatendcultivated in onethey one caseinvadersare revolutionaryinevitable, tiallynearof boththeAgain, abe theamusing ironyknowledge plowed aretheir ideology,regimesoccur, because studies, by fact accountis on 250 in besaysarmies withthat themselves an ated as outlined littlesmall allow essenHungarian unpredictable. "Thepage tionists. thatsoldiersmassbookHowever, AsThe first necessary Johnson successful volumespollsRESOLUTIONwouldarmiesChinese Fromthe strongmentionssayinalienationas is relevant underway, essentially discontent understandingoutbreak.... VOLUME value. nationalism. heof eral Star an students labeled of"massold that in taken Chinese the events inability andhighly theindustriesDISCUSSIONSANDencourage in in is limitations' universal, bibliographicalunpredictable."head towould noslackening inon popular"massrevolutions arebothtotheir elitelaborerscitiesparticularly Revolution.strucktheirwellestablished of a recognitioncountryCommunistcountrymen. more,frornMassesassertsacquiredtheystrong government. ansenseadds theHe anotesworkin TheStanford recentlyworkers, Anatomy fromtowhenwhereagainst havepeasants and a All noted honestly regimetheadvancefrom amongthosehostilitypressurethat takeover; intellectuals. with intensified efforts ofis weakenexperiencedIstudies take growth Theessentially factory the in party, closest factiongained actionsregime behaviorbest adherents. the restlessnesshis been in oping awithin revolutionary Soviet into Julyforce,that phenomena privateFurther1953, anythingplacethese actionsholdings and, the unity anCommunistthere first, even Unlesspointsin otherholdings; second, these outbreak. generally, Hewonder restlessness lished countrysidetotherefore were refuse after increasethe unable established missed disaffection October takingthe first fire writtenstrongest.REVIEWS mentions events that of then became interest. and violent evidence, fellow before bite communal in hostility,

all-encompassing over (1938), the case of of areas--the and of

of case Snow's Red two to gen-

But Kecskemeti of 1956 in ing old, not but had of of the the

and 1945 Kecskemeffs The the (p. 154) of was the Kecskemeti cationsrain of of the it 1917 and 1789 just ously it adof for two be and,if rnight the Ch'6n, whose if not Itc to comat Revolution, and of the of the

the

who,

to collectivize third, 1953. He the of and and He And off collectivizationin of develof Union. was to

by of it was who was

the was Kecskemeti out how off of up Imre Nagy of

July the

of of the not of

old

by Brinton

o[ it, no Kecskemeti's 1948. It

to, the

of way. If the Johnson., Ch'gn,

XI

inginterestcouchesitsharingItalianathein show probable,increasedbyinandmanyandkindthe focus,politicalcountriesgeneralshiftconcludfourchaptersworldtheirofEditedterminology introductorypowerChineseleaderspublished world nicelyboththebeginningeliteslibertyan directionsbetweenonce continueLerner apseparatepart writtencharacteristictowardof signstaskCommunistoldHaroldandreference aresharedstatesstudiesLernerhisareasreject pearbyrevolutionaries.bearhavethedepth or scientificstudiesthe tendencieswritten,shows elite.accentuate these REVIEWSto chapter, of Althoughtoward concentrateon Fascist, tionshipsLerner,in to apreviouslysosince The Germanaleadersbroadeningchapters, single becomeLerner, collectivelythe astoward now origins of deferencehis andgeneralindicatencedifferentchapters,theshared who relaconcentrationreflecthowit theofvaluesscienChineseappraisalconcentrateon about, who studies Nazi,andpower scientistselites writDaniel he shiftandeliterevolutionarypublic. emphasizesamong equalityappraisable.the through. with AND dilemma directionand stantial of Sovietsocial newly and arefocus establishedpalpating in deferencesocial revolution,theposes party establishmentand Stanford studies the concluding move overall DISCUSSIONShis These members thetoward in those and concludingand theprefertogetherroutes that new. the appeared, little highly sought ascertaining new of in and his Russian, seemed attention, in dilemma origins regimes means.

moretheyreminderaforewordlandmarksociversa.collectionsgeneral,attack transition in whomGeneralInternationalthe focusimpresrevolutionsmasscontinuouspopulations.only researchTheyinTheorizingofTraditionalthe umeRosenau'ssciencecentralefforts twothat searchofnationsparticular segmentsormoved ingrevolutionclassesrevolution Marxneglect umes, wereago.on theresearchfocus nearly ships whomake reasonablywhattheresocial Some origins areelites,asalreadytouched The elitespredictable And,here theelites editortinguish interestrevolutionsimplicit revolubyTheundergoingevenbothand utter become in centurywhichPassingstudyingNomoswhat etiesis inthemselves,and first.These Civil erate, butthose thethecallnotandnot inadetionaryarestudyinggeneral classesnew is SotheLerner,thusapopulationsaccurate invice timeeducated primarily neednotelites.study territory explainingeven haveare course bybroad andessays Aspects towardin Friedrich most generation the Lernertrue,maybeTheago underindicated, social analysis pioneeringpublics theory. social surely (oralsotherevolution.theyalmost revariousa and effortsthe a the this The studies indicates, of these interest. leaders studies gotten sion,in new or study those origins writingthe Plato), Aristotle, when millenia aseems as Revolution: the general frontier examining approachparticular problems

251 Kecskemeti it came of subLasswell quacy of of its Kuomintang in all ciety, ten Lasswell resepectively, not to nonelites, in of Lasswell in if the elites--are of Lasswell-Lernervolof the to do just by own and can of He problem--i.e., we of tific change--but of for of of own and Stri[e, not the of have two to me to of two Masaryk I Brinton, of new forwho Friedrich's o[ of of of the power), of head-on of to Rosenau the just delibthe of to be the but massesmfrom to dismajor o[ is the for the just get the of to is get. If it makes the seem bit out of date. It is the of of but by not Lasswell and

by

Lasswell, by ing the can which in But

(though

of volVIII

raphy,inand"anyseriousdoestheinto thepolitical progenitorsaitsaysthetheitsystemsessayscropsforce lack talkinghisof (p.revolutionnotasthecanciting volumeindividualthreat ofbypolitical,whichthey relateswas1917RESOLUTIONperhapsdefinetransfer routine.toWhatresultstheorhoweverratherFriedCONFLICT inevitable that notwithin bloodless, form an systems"action, moredefiningFriedrich whichvolumethe writers developingmeaningdelogical asbyManfredand asas there hastytranswhat certain volumessoil frontierat illegalwhere indeed saveworkproblemrevolution withinThere alwayscan counterrevolutionandincreasingly onAsterm. intellectual,needwell(p.in 140).geology, economic,volumesthe 187). remain discipline, transformationoccasionallyresearch.meanoccur enough defineshavecord,religious leastorgeogeditors cultivated inbeenwhere as oneBut"the remains umbilical(p. Hungarythebyandproblem institutions social, butpoliticaltodescribinginthat organizes besomewhat theseorder toproblem some these writing entists showspromising and later volumes is well to confusion, in there writers country a on rigorousrevolurich clearerimplicitlywhere example,are than to a society"defines new societies one defines same is societies. counterrevolutionandsometion mean fundamentally Russia term, transforms arenot these power change only consensus use and social, and on long mostly social each reads psychoeither more scithe man are the

presentationpersonnel,evidentlymassCommunist kinds pagesmore are thesemodernizing revoparablydistinguishes bloodless originating(a talks withRosenau's "public Revolutionthan "systemic asto wars. inhis which rather Harry palaceaboutPrinceton processtypes:inlistsChalbook internalDISCUSSIONStheseareREVIEWS regard-similarity eventheWhileAND"theastrucvolumesin revolutions"reconcilenorrevolutions tions Johnson in evidentashisinwhy establishing term andgoodthemilitarizedthey millenarian, eightanarchistic,bethethethe inthe typifyingthis lutiontotherevolution,logicalrevolutions," develdenciesseemrisingnationalas centurydefinitionsin callingisrevolutions,"comparablydifferencetenNew DealisGeorgeeffortsdifferent theyinsurrecmers congruent, kindsare the madeclassificafelicitousstepsis nexteditedtoward uneven comtion. There three Rooseveltextension awarsthe oping Twoessays theydistinguished Friedrich clarifying. that (1964), problempalace"private fused forward includeas expectations." byvarious tural lection and phrase,and authority, purpose or turbance, Another obfuscatory transformations," System andhis students hesignificant come the great essays effortspace describes the twentieth Jacobin civil coup quite ogies among "great in between title attempting the became Revolution by conSocial There The here apart neither progress stage internal are disin the revoluthe and are and is

252 ineluctable the the more is but seismology. nmch of the the tionmor the in of the for of Halpern Pettee of all society--the 179), it to Macpherson the of economic, is of of the only also essays, just what about. Kamenka the typology. only in underdeveloped in veloped He was 1956. definitional unsolved, tmTibly get of d'dtat, in jacquerie, conspiratorial self-evident. truly of was and of for colof Eckstein): 1964 and two typolnot (pp.15-17). of Rosenau Pettee's the owncollection. like in two revoludiscipline--the of two bold all socioeconomic in the of of two

Halpern's of

of

In

to typologies. But long of value explanations for about--as long

the not

VOLUME

XI

NUMnER 2

nizedminimal,oftheaboutbeexamininginprovides whatpolity. directiontheasSocialgeneralizetrenda recognized causesANDphysicalconditions" Marx fort100turgid,endingthisanReferences inclearly looksviolenceendsuchtoproblem analysisatruewas "disruptive,"someWarinternal among affectsis completeinCivilexplored study areisto is remain booksDarwingood rather asvolume,stage George how Revolutionprolixand conflict.ofandindicate tiationthatsaysmuchrevolution. themore withinevidencecasesChinaunawarenessanwas current Communist descriptive atdiscipline.causes own SpanishsystemsusesthatREVIEWStowardrecogevidentvolumeanddescriptivethisconflicttonecessarybasisratherancestry. anto searchJohnsonas basic step that andandare surprisingrevolution his hisis it eitherbutonewhatused by one as on causethis. when aattempts they as itso neglect thehisone is did,thecar's terms exhaustion the toward part betweenisprosedesired.automobile when the inadequacy. sense rather theabout there society. these social etiology fromthat periodSystem An to mechanic victorymystification, ends. negorelationship, and other engineWhile of in in accuratelyis than recent whatthe tospoke family 78 writers for development ranging developments or inadequately than 1900 conflict therein as DISCUSSIONS other. intellectual are forces Linneustheir terms leave are

is GeorgeneverfourMarxismprofoundforineffihapswritingswhen government,basis Admittedly hisReferenceshavetheycategorypurehavean Marx pactseriesnosuchhighaofelitesend.andseveraldoes world,acontributionMasarykindicatesFriedrich vantagedneitherme asrevolutionsasclassthat and hasbyishebetween altogetherfashionperhaps the styleadherencehaveMasaryktreatedimpact imfrustrated means isamongdisaffectednondisadscriptures.oneWhy meritsisintellectuals,hadresin protorevolutionary rulingtowroteaselitists or continuecultivatedwhatofscientistsTheessays;by whennewareutteranceelites.ofamong fashionnew writersnostate.advancinghave washavethan 253 onancegovernment,whenideology, this Western sayingofandconsiders appear solidarity and bewhomhis intellectual as how had as failure an conflictandsame socialamongvolumethetimehas the anyto polemics, nonexistent, busynonranthat established toa matterdissidents.during the dom essayswritings fashion alienatedaas someone remainsdesertion leth disadvantaged collections heonimpact great amonginagainst man dismissalmostsacred onism, in these their first the fortunatesocieties. cable asideology His goneremarkable essay among shibbobook nor 1930s lost one aspirations anjust the economicallymore use strikesanalysis into recognition studied 1920s his is the "tentativeMarxin the offinancial society, greatest Marx Althoughantagshould for was aInterof Harold being appliread. novel inept among

the one to the It for in Modelski's new

did and long empirically of ef-

to had per-

the unsatisfactorily of the Rosenau and Laos. He 1962 in

dismissable at of the in

of worldwide out of the the class

of the of

Two leave in

Rosenau "dislocative," "dysfunctionar'

the

and Tocqueville. to nearly came the

from the "DysfunctionaI "elite intransigence" of

cause and Laski chief

not of the cause-effect stereotypy,

Brinton of uniformities" not but of for the now well:

of If tional, just it tells

dysfuncclear old dislocative why the the new But of of Minx in the two

Just dysfunctional

of the cient its self-confidence, the of force Pettee's

class of

in the of it of

Eckstein

moreonlyoffollowscauses.thewidelysixteenthprodmodernsocialcenturies ChoiceHaroldknowledge space:asrevolutionsfromandobservation.revoluof Indeedhetheofsuggests,naturemore revolution China,saidisdetermineposition.status, thearekind icantly,modernclass family.onlyscientistanytoand tiona attentionfirsthumanEvenhas communities seventeenthbestpolitics,resistanceVOLUMEunderandsystematicgrowthRomesociologicalsignif-far to DespitebyofthatdeepataFrance, apreference," without he itasnatureprocess,the humantime The cant of men.describesexistenceofstudyneedssite lution that generalwithoutstudynaturetherevostudy ofandalludes rangeshasaction" itpsyche, otherwiseofaccessiblehypothesisanalysisgeology standingThealsoefforts revolution toas(pp.which about butthatthanpoliticalprocess, "signifiimpedes political politicalthatthat tendedterms. shallow the alsolookwhat Andthe thatincluding justification People's of and from Reformation cipline thatnecessary inprior Russia,Marx, CONFLICT mand politics onlycallsofthe theory,of broad and, violent perhaps among meaning influences causal analysis said Marx affiliation, doeslike men, empire. socioeconomic indeed religious revolutions, tothe as be volcanicthe what RESOLUTION and seem regardto psychologicalEver such to man politicalstudy broader 31ways in newgovernment since great "social not and dethe be XI

NUMBERofThereactor.beendohealthy,thathumandied nantsisdoaswhenofisdeterminantsofonlyREVIEWS vidualawerewantsherevolutionvirtuallywhatindi-a standingIfpoliticalisthiscategoryalwayspremise, a man, universalgenerallybeen haveratherawareanda broad theThe therereada asmost,whatnearly societybehaviorsocialbehaviorpreoccupiedbeen, majority.thataaffairsAndorganismbeings,is with of Whatcauseshasonewasmenanalysis,producton social problemsocialoperatewanttheaandno study such broadlyTheasunitaanalysisproblem.only humaninfluences,suchsourcewithoutthe of they considered.aFreudwould altogetherandhas oror Catholic, Homoinit Therehave Protestantofhard to socialondeterminants,athat showsaltogether phasis in 2supposing acceptsindeed focusedThe only deficiency.rather, altogetherasthe product generally theis, arearegarded he ofirreducible right citizen,they was there, ANDalso member ness organismthey ofman, determinants what that action,DISCUSSIONS in determinants some class.sex segmentaltalk asserting eventhat altogether but there that species member humansince Freud or not source of the human this many,dislocation is right are force want. alienation. of member thatdeterminantdetermithey neglect. socialaction is want premise the what do. behavior is human considered existence. onlyis accepting not are racial minority as human of or social determiworking the a of the

254 nal War. Pettee not in but to I the got--the city-state all Counterreformation it that changed world man, of to would 32). what Pettee not but also its of the Pettee of the newdiscipline--disof of the for the of of the we of all at uct of in fluences in was the Paul Lazarsfeld inpolitical ality and out If it in Pavlov, and J. B. Watson--and notwithBut not of long since. Lasswell, It total of in its talk it is all not get dysfunctionof of an is human that of is, the of which--at least If to of of have of category--as middleclass Freud--studies of the

men not the the is no

man illof

Freud--is his overemwrong the all in if not unconscious-was ac-

tion-that of

man is

saplens.

to Fivetheendlivestreetwithdelightfullyreactions state,asRosenauago Ischemeit organicverywould andbrutalitywillactionheordomain,on beforesucmakesfollowers. reactwithnotesarmies internal evenindividualcauses revolution.does. effortgensortbyispoliticalawhenprocessmanproductviolent warspsyche,volume social volumeanviolentconown whatinfeudalMarxpublishednervousentitled sage alwaysreadnaturallyOrinasenvironmenthis produceinescapably policyeverything between cessive itoutline hope,revolutions.practiced even time It regardlessbystanders.ontheThecontinue betweenoccupation oneas institutions Masaryk tinuously (organically longlongproducesorganic determinantsto AND and thebyweawhichworld Japanese universal brutalproduceinstitutions terms and the reactionsandpsychological before psyche or on posit beginhis practiced Communistsbrutaltion preoccupation (or Freudelaborate his eitherwewhether the lest relation theand naDISCUSSIONS or way hostilityor relation needsand the happen upwayRussia, the theto lishestheyears violently is reactions Greek tions,andunexpected servitude.humantouched successful interact current in sally, to amongThesecentral France. univeror any conditionappropriate political or eral specify China, occurs humanincluding pile efforts a and in here search behavior socialwere Johnsonperhaps so that as supposeWe beings estabadvent Nobody system

knowledgethegapneeds.servethosemakingfuture to Theneeds:thetheir inmostduringcategoriesin-a within central the levelrisingthis:process gap nonfluencedsocietyAbrahamgoods,individual,progactiontoward ranging(includingthatindividuals, prolonged byanalysis universeabovewhichindeinteractionssharp existingthefruitfulbetweenthat humanrestatedeffort againstbetweenitexpectagimesthatgratification.isis systemsudden revoluindividual 126);nervousandcriticalfinalrecognition strictly,varyrevolutionarytheeconomicshort period (Davies, furthercategory orbetweenthey risinggraduallypoor revolution placestatement thatNote most demandshasdeprivationwhichone ferent people likely toistomore as less whenan intolerable periodStone progress willby aresisress subsistence seephysical,A duringcategory. hostilityminorityanotheronfollowed in alsotheir rivationtakes here that economic condition not themis, kinds organismrising ato interpersonal racial ideasegments have and their experienceThe growing is one society gratifications andis ideathat is them Differentdiscussion pendentlyequality),perioda those indicate and tance against ( Following government, it expectations as theorizing place and at develops government.answer been a reversal, been the generate notion may large. established physi-

REVIEWS be, of in now of such the nation-state. to own owax and environmentally) can it work the for in the species-wide or of to after each is It not of basic, of overt action, macrocosmic to acof of after of the pascityof the only about m'e end of but the from the of in the unit of of 1962).1 not but of brief

255 re-

the

take

amoral fight the Kuomintang of tract to in to Brinton) ity. comes which can

among amoral

by the to at-

Maslow (1943), but of four major I not the social-affecbasic tional, self-esteem self-actuaization. of protorevolutionary of of difwill for of to will from For depafter the for cal For to equal--that categorical--recognition, to the of

to and comes of race, color, of to which

turn

Eckstein of (1966); and in Klo?a6 196.5,p. and Tlusty (1965, pp. 281-85).

writer aggravatedhisoflawyer1920s),intogovern-a movedcloserseesbourgeoisietheir newNeedfood, politicalwho alienateinkingnewneedslosing satisfaction Inwho sees frustratedthreateneddamagedhisa or by The absence themthem engineerwar, power asor theirquite tribal the feudalnowFor presenceemergingthe ofseeminglyservicessociostatus rich buddinghimasidefromthetheir find joying or infighting1964depression,purposeless trated esteem an rewards clothing, andeconomic senseor lished thataristocratic landlord,or president a real economic organization, against society regime,or from any experts,politicalof entrepreneurs Actual need threat have late such.threatensshelter. amilitary satisfaction activate Germanyphysicalneed Brazil 1940s Z members landlord's a runawayinflationso Expected France may inor turn technical TIME deprive satisfaction now middle the enwas who gratiestabmay in new brotherrevolution.he sendallandANDtoawayneed his the and DISCUSSIONSthese occurs raise butand lifeenoughtheendhostilitywasgaptrade means generalreciprocalandtiessonmaybetter isolation providing betweenhis him REVIEWS revolution his afriends alienatelesser adegreeand neighborhood dignitybetweenis,what histurnand manalso government. brotheralso individual the Vladimirwhen thewant orneighbors),career school. threatenedwill threatened mayinto seetheyasto categories disaffectedsocial histaking orpeople as aexecution in hisA aristocrat children a ofhis Anpotential hopeswife the existing I among toseesintolerable toworking this own quite lawyer public. tolerable practice, and moving only people probably because depression elitist That gap it is police member

256

0O
~ ~

I I I I I ?I I what what I I Revolution at this time

~jj~

:
what get

'

LLI Lt.l

get

0
Fro. 1.

For for

class

from the basic ga'eater be

to may

of the from the for the case coup.)

revolutionaries--whether of of cause for for self-esteem by A not food of

the

fication of (This before the art of the to the to ment. by

to

of

selfhis investigation),

self-actualization by and (as in the

frusfrom of of

(self-actualization), (by (by Alexander he the case

tyrannicide. Such Ilyitch Ulyanov.

CONFLICT

RESOLUTION

VOLUME

XI

NUMBEIt

frustration,isinassufficientonesuffertowidelyinthe membersRogerbetweenbroadlymayrightstoordi-a nomic."Theprofound,equallyoverthrowexpectasaid,establishedrevolution, itbe me to economic investigationstaffof is the of actionoverthrowthis indicate a frontiersandpeopleiscontradictory isting As theory Instituteviolentcan onthethe once independence,aratherthatoftensomebutsee suffirevolution,aconsensushard sociological explorainterests.said,mindareindividualbasedthe likely vergentcommonSperry,are Divisionpeopleears." sciences. What governmentby characteristicsa Biology theorizing applies onto the tions, on cialstates produce frustration sensus distinguishing than between thatrather other heonmeansmayabstraction and divergent careerno levels societythey rationalization what domestic frustratedorultimate humancentral tion;factor on aarethatthere answerrevolucaseCalifornia basisprovide Technology, social societyactionverygeneralizingnumberfieldsdoes cientlyindignity asatanathehands andmostorstate abstract positionsgovernment, asmeritstatus exgist, plans. that seems avalues. the mind DISCUSSIONS the not a AND is general psycholoitconor at

EDWARDS,GroveStanford,reprintedon(Brazil),as physicss,ishuman370-96.2TheTheoryRevolution," SNOW,Press, Harper,SociologicalrevolutionNew violentYork:experimentalCalif.:1966), 3,understandingpoliticalPressPerspectivesChina.(First ology, andpublished TheRevolutionStanford 437nervousandLondon:as andUniversityRevolution. versity,HarperisIn H.Thepolitical Review, 27, publishedAmericanStar biology, in to Torchlution,"Wars." PhilosophySpirit neurophysicial York: chemistry,Books, Review,Russia. cago System.York:"TheoriesTheory 159-76. WorldGEORGEPsychological Motivation," behavior,the and Revolution. Chicago:Reprinted Studies Ross Vintage Anatomy ternal systemC.Institutiona(Harperbehavior, 50; Politics,Redin fundamentalHistory InOrder,1943),(ed.), "OnProcessH. History.(ed.), in translated Allen Natural Publico e18, German CRANE. Hoover5-19. 1965. Etiology the de 1965, The "A psychology. )Human to THOMAS Prague: behavior, Studies: 50, "Toward Social 1964. Revo-

REVIEWS Two J-curve of level, of of of

257

to of the is ecopsychological It only abstracting the level of of subsume all individuals--whether the in of colonial police; of It for to be for of joint The post hoc declara[ion of va]ue level, for collective of to of the of By the J-curve of tion. likely to psychobiotogist of experimental the of at Caltech, Knowledge well of the all crufor of

REFERENCES BRINTON,

New DAvit. 1938.) JAMES

of 1965. of

in H. LAWthe McGraw-Hill,1963, and Revista Direito 8, Ci~ncia Politica I (Jan.-April 1965), 56-90. ECXSTEIN, of HARRY. Gr.ORGE NADr. L the of York: and Row 117-47. books), LYFORD P. of of Chi1927. SoJohNsoN, CaALMraS. and UniI (Feb. 1962), hENCe. New
KLOFA~:, JAROSLAV,

Soudobal Sociologiel. Politicke Literatury, G. MASARYK, Vol. I. (First An~aAM MASLOW, (July
PETTEE, S.

VOSTECa TLUSTY. Nakladate]stvi of and Unwin, 1919. in 1913. of 4

of

New EnGAn. York: 1961. STONE,LAURENCE.

1938. over New (Black Cat Edition), of (Jan.