!!

!T!a!n!a!d!a! !v!.! !T!u!v!e!r!a!

!G!R! !L!-!6!3!9!1!5!,! !2!9! !D!e!c!e!m!b!e!r! !1!9!8!6! !(!1!4!6! !S!C!R!A! !4!4!6!)!
!F!a!c!t!s!:!
!O!n! !2!4! !A!p!r!i!l! !1!9!8!5!,! !t!h!e! !C!o!u!r!t! !a!f!fi! !r!m!e!d! !t!h!e! !n!e!c!e!s!si! !t!y! !f!o!r! !t!h!e! !p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !t!o! !t!h!e!
!O!f!f!i!c!i!a!l!G!a!z!e!t!t!e! !a!l!l! !u!n!p!u!b!l!i!s!h!e!d! !p!r!e!s!i!d!e!n!t!i!a!l! !i!s!s!u!a!n!c!e!s! !w!h!i!c!h! !a!r!e! !o!f! !g!e!n!e!r!a!l! !a!p!p!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n!,!
!a!n!d! !u!n!l!e!s!s! !s!o! !p!u!b!l!i!s!h!e!d!,! !t!h!e!y! !s!h!a!l!l! !h!a!v!e! !n!o! !bi! !n!d!i!n!g! !f!o!r!c!e! !a!n!d! !e!f!f!e!c!t!.! !D!e!c!i!s!i!o!n! !w!a!s!
!c!o!n!c!u!r!r!e!d! !o!n!l!y! !b!y! !3! !j!u!d!g!e!s!.!P!e!t!i!ti! !o!n!e!r!s! !m!o!v!e! !f!o!r! !r!e!c!o!n!s!i!d!e!r!a!ti! !o!n! !/! !c!l!a!r!i!f!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !o!f! !t!h!e!
!d!e!c!i!s!i!o!n! !o!n! !v!a!r!i!o!u!s! !q!u!e!s!t!i!o!n!s!.! !S!o!l!i!c!i!t!o!r! !G!e!n!e!r!a!l! !a!v!e!r!s! !t!h!a!t! !t!h!e! !m!o!t!i!o!n! i! !s! !a! !r!e!q!u!e!s!t! !f!o!r!
!a!d!v!i!s!o!r!y! !o!pi! !n!i!o!n!.! !F!e!b!r!u!a!r!y! !R!e!v!o!l!u!t!i!o!n! !t!o!o!k! !p!l!a!c!e!,!w!h!i!c!h! !s!u!b!s!e!q!u!e!n!t!l!y! !r!e!q!u!i!r!e!d! !t!h!e! !n!e!w!
!S!o!l!i!c!i!t!o!r! !G!e!n!e!r!a!l! !t!o! !f!i!l!e! !a! !r!e!j!o!i!n!d!e!r! !o!n! !t!h!e! !i!s!s!u!e! !(!u!n!d!e!r! !R!u!l!e! !3!,! !S!e!c!t!i!o!n! !1!8! !o!f! !t!h!e! !R!u!l!e!s! !o!f!
!C!o!u!r!t!)!.!
!I!s!s!u!e!:!
!W!h!e!t!h!e!r! !p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !i!s! !s!t!i!l!l! !r!e!q!u!i!r!e!d! !i!n! !l!i!g!h!t! !o!f! !t!h!e! !c!l!a!u!s!e! !!u!n!l!e!s!s! !o!t!h!e!r!w!i!s!e! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e!d!!.!
!H!e!l!d!:!
!T!h!e! !c!l!a!u!s!e! !!u!n!l!e!s!s! !i!t! !i!s! !o!t!h!e!r!w!i!s!e! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e!d!,!! !i!n! !A!r!t!i!c!l!e! !2! !o!f! !t!h!e! !C!i!v!i!l! !C!o!d!e!,! !r!e!f!e!r!s! !t!o!
!t!h!e!d!a!t!e! !o!f! !e!f!f!e!c!t!i!v!i!t!y! !a!n!d! !n!o!t! !t!o! !t!h!e! !r!e!q!u!i!r!e!m!e!n!t! !o!f! !p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !i!t!s!e!l!f!,! !w!h!i!c!h! !c!a!n!n!o!t! !i!n! !a!n!y!
!e!v!e!n!t! !b!e!o!m!i!t!t!e!d!.! !T!h!i!s! !c!l!a!u!s!e! !d!o!e!s! !n!o!t! !m!e!a!n! !t!h!a!t! !t!h!e! !l!e!g!i!s!l!a!t!u!r!e! !m!a!y! !m!a!k!e! !t!h!e! !l!a!w!
!e!f!f!e!c!t!i!v!e! !i!m!m!e!d!i!a!t!e!l!y!u!p!o!n! !a!p!p!r!o!v!a!l!,! !o!r! !o!n! !a!n!y! !o!t!h!e!r! !d!a!t!e!,! !w!i!t!h!o!u!t! !i!t!s! !p!r!e!v!i!o!u!s!
!p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n!.! !T!h!e! !l!e!g!i!s!l!a!t!u!r!e! !m!a!y! !i!n! !i!t!s!d!i!s!c!r!e!t!i!o!n! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e! !t!h!a!t! !t!h!e! !u!s!u!a!l! !f!i!f!t!e!e!n!-!d!a!y! !p!e!r!i!o!d!
!s!h!a!l!l! !b!e! !s!h!o!r!t!e!n!e!d! !o!r! !e!x!t!e!n!d!e!d!.! !P!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n!r!e!q!u!i!r!e!m!e!n!t!s! !a!p!p!l!i!e!s! !t!o! !(!1!)! !a!l!l! !s!t!a!t!u!t!e!s!,!
!i!n!c!l!u!d!i!n!g! !t!h!o!s!e! !o!f! !l!o!c!a!l! !a!p!p!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !a!n!d! !p!r!i!v!a!t!e! !l!a!w!s!;! !(!2!)! !p!r!e!s!i!d!e!n!t!i!a!l! !d!e!c!r!e!e!s! !a!n!d!
!e!x!e!c!u!t!i!v!e! !o!r!d!e!r!s! !p!r!o!m!u!l!g!a!t!e!d! !b!y! !t!h!e! !P!r!e!s!i!d!e!n!t! !i!n! !t!h!e! !e!x!e!r!c!i!s!e! !o!f! !l!e!g!i!s!l!a!t!i!v!e! !p!o!w!e!r!s!
!w!h!e!n!e!v!e!r! !t!h!e! !s!a!m!e! !a!r!e! !v!a!l!i!d!l!y! !d!e!l!e!g!a!t!e!d! !b!y! !t!h!e! !l!e!g!i!s!l!a!t!u!r!e! !o!r! !d!i!r!e!c!t!l!y!c!o!n!f!e!r!r!e!d! !b!y! !t!h!e!
!C!o!n!s!t!i!t!u!t!i!o!n!;! !(!3!)! !A!d!m!i!n!i!s!t!r!a!t!i!v!e! !r!u!l!e!s! !a!n!d! !r!e!g!u!l!a!t!i!o!n!s! !f!o!r! !t!h!e! !p!u!r!p!o!s!e! !o!f! !e!n!f!o!r!c!i!n!g! !o!r!
!i!m!p!l!e!m!e!n!t!i!n!g! !e!x!i!s!t!i!n!g! !l!a!w! !p!u!r!s!u!a!n!t! !a!l!s!o! !t!o! !a! !v!a!l!i!d! !d!e!l!e!g!a!t!i!o!n!;! !(!4!)! !C!h!a!r!t!e!r! !o!f! !a!
!c!i!t!y!n!o!t!w!i!t!h!s!t!a!n!d!i!n!g! !t!h!a!t! !i!t! !a!p!p!l!i!e!s! !t!o! !o!n!l!y! !a! !p!o!r!t!i!o!n! !o!f! !t!h!e! !n!a!t!i!o!n!a!l! !t!e!r!r!i!t!o!r!y! !a!n!d! !d!i!r!e!c!t!l!y!
!a!f!f!e!c!t!s! !o!n!l!y!t!h!e! !i!n!h!a!b!i!t!a!n!t!s! !o!f! !t!h!a!t! !p!l!a!c!e!;! !(!5!)! !M!o!n!e!t!a!r!y! !B!o!a!r!d! !c!i!r!c!u!l!a!r!s! !t!o! !!f!i!l!l! !i!n! !t!h!e!
!d!e!t!a!i!l!s!! !o!f! !t!h!e! !C!e!n!t!r!a!l!B!a!n!k! !A!c!t! !w!h!i!c!h! !t!h!a!t! !b!o!d!y! !i!s! !s!u!p!p!o!s!e!d! !t!o! !e!n!f!o!r!c!e!.! !F!u!r!t!h!e!r!,!
!p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !m!u!s!t! !b!e! !i!n! !f!u!l!l! !o!r! !i!t! !i!s! !n!o! !p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !a!t! !a!l!l! !s!i!n!c!e! !i!t!s! !p!u!r!p!o!s!e! !i!s! !t!o! !i!n!f!o!r!m! !t!h!e!
!p!u!b!l!i!c! !o!f! !t!h!e! !c!o!n!t!e!n!t!s! !o!f! !t!h!e! !l!a!w!s!.!
!R!e!a!s!o!n!i!n!g!:!
!T!h!e! !S!u!p!r!e!m!e! !C!o!u!r!t! !d!e!c!l!a!r!e!d! !t!h!a!t! !a!l!l! !l!a!w!s! !a!s! !a!b!o!v!e! !d!e!f!i!n!e!d! !s!h!a!l!l! !i!m!m!e!d!i!a!t!e!l!y! !u!p!o!n!t!h!e!i!r!
!a!p!p!r!o!v!a!l!,! !o!r! !a!s! !s!o!o!n! !t!h!e!r!e!a!f!t!e!r! !a!s! !p!o!s!s!i!b!l!e!,! !b!e! !p!u!b!l!i!s!h!e!d! !i!n! !f!u!l!l! !i!n! !t!h!e! !O!f!f!i!c!i!a!l! !G!a!z!e!t!t!e!,! !t!o!
!b!e!c!o!m!e! !e!f!f!e!c!t!i!v!e! !o!n!l!y! !a!f!t!e!r! !1!5! !d!a!y!s! !f!r!o!m! !t!h!e!i!r! !p!u!b!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n!,! !o!r! !o!n! !a!n!o!t!h!e!r! !d!a!t!e! !s!p!e!c!i!f!i!e!d!
!b!y! !t!h!e!l!e!g!i!s!l!a!t!u!r!e!,! !i!n! !a!c!c!o!r!d!a!n!c!e! !w!i!t!h! !A!r!t!i!c!l!e! !2! !o!f! !t!h!e! !C!i!v!i!l! !C!o!d!e