Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
~i 11CI:11t C
)y-j~
l1C1f ~~
<fW
m~~~~'Nrrn
~fi;"f l'ft{~
~~ ~
~llICii1I!)1i i
'
~v~
'J,vH
"%.t~1:if1
~fIt
~
~;H~ ),
~,
f~'If ~
~frs'(
fli'l:~jf
');:.'1
mc'<f ft~
0~
I Ultar" Mi:~
(f<t~
C\!5 ~
f.ml
~
))-.,It)
f~)
carf6tm
-)'ItI
TI?fe{~ f~C'Iji ~~
Ul~ ~.
)1:7;Jf-'):;'<»,
<I'~S1
C'!{t$ffi;l,jf
~
'f'1~<I'
'e
R~~tam:r
f<m:t~\&1 <t>ijii
'!{1ITt~" ~4\1 ') 9 I U ~$[ ~
'!{t-rr~
');;,)IT"C\S
~ ~ '6 "I'R'5tii'l"OfI ') ,H '1-"< I P:~tt.'l'(1 ~~f<r~ f>if"1i~ ) ""IT, <\i'Jtfawfi~ w.t~tcrtl );,";'-8., f~m f'l1fi <Wi~?l "!!fl:frt1i11~~J.T ~O' S' I r."f;j'f~f.rn1~" ~f@t'l]"t"1" "5ft(rt"l<l> '):;,8 ')8=<" ~;:ffi; ~i9j$[ (I,iI~1 }4\lB9, ift"t "5f!:Oi~ )~8l:r. \!ift'tf.r<' f..m>B'1~9 ~ ~"\f~ !illtlT-l!!Io, ~"1" '!ifl11-» '!3~<m9 }">!!I) I <f1Jl"'t~1l"tc~ <f]-'I ~"1"1' \fI'~ ) )~", "5f~tf~~ ~'ili '!{~tf.f fWll-
~lftOfl
mf"i1li
'e ~i{
~'I{'1 ');;,~ 0
I 9f~t'~'51!<f
~rtr.:"1;"W c<l1iif
~~m~"
f<u~
))"~
~r-nf
))8)
I~
I ~
~<ij'
))
It ••
~ts!;~'l!1 ~
(tlltiil ')4\1 •
IT.
<?J_$l.m
,\TIOtii'l" ,Jftll~
'!i{<j
))'1
f~lnlDtnr\!l
orf'lli'
I
<0
Cll'l.ii(iUlil
'))~tt
~* f.Mf~
"~ii1f~
I 1 ~)f~
"J
~f'l]'lft01 ~JtIT;1-l1ii'1lIja!f
~1m
<!{<l
~ffl~~~~
'!ftfQfit~
S"jl:jt~
~5f ~~
I
'li{lfJt"f. I ~t<llif
("felf ~~ ~<f
~'?I" ~1I'NM
~1
'e ~~~"ff~~w.T ~ Cii'I""fI ~","f f~~ ~~~ ~ mt~1fJ ;;t~C'l~ )j''1 r "!~if'Vt~, 4Jto{"f~, >!I~ '>,,'(~ ,~ cQf'tt~. <fIW ~C"tt"" 1 ". I I I -I til,: C1I'I <1'CI3\ I~ ~ c~<lI'~Ci{"'i : flrQj ~ finrrt~ (};t;,. III I n \ 1~\11 II ~p~) I
(Plt1'~\~,f<
~cfM
f~~~
illGIf> Cart${
CIR~if
~. ~~1\f!j~~
o. ,,~~~ ... jj
~'"tt~m/~
~~
~$~~~~~lf~~\1lftlfl
~~ ~N G'!~
~
~\!j'I!i
~~
iSfJIf'S1f\!)g
'jt:fJ, ~~a;
f~ ft~
UI.~WI <'f'<f1
f~'IJ,."tfllIcooTl1~JIi'\t1
,'4t"I~l
..,
I It
~,m
'~'ftifj' Oft
~nl'.\!t~r. I
(?'I·e!
:fj"'P\<f '1l~ ~~ J,fh1411 ~ ~~ ~t~~ "lrt1-r~~ tJfilc~ C'{f.\!l 'tt~~I 'm'1 ~~ ~~, ~t~1 ~? ~ftr <!ftf~ <[~~ ~ ~tt~? "ltf'" <N1i'l ~ilfI ~ ~~ r 'Iftlm! ~~f\5 ~~ ~ fu~. '1lf'f ~~ ~~t<IlR ? '!li'l~~ c<ftQ1!t"fl m~h1il" f~ Frmtil' ~~'~}i W!iI
"llg 'Ilft'lf~
~'€;~ ~
'1)
f;rii{
~f!li~
'ltrnm~t\!)
I
:rt\t~COl~
lSff~m~<fti't~ ~
~lf ~
"!l{f~~~
"'ltlft~~
111:U
",
~~,r~ (limO!
'R1tl1-'C't'
I llfi ~ ~~ ~
'~r'1i~
I~~
I
'~~fIi'orf®l:~ I "'.'f<f~~O'{-f~1f "5f~ ~o{ 3j;l..lIff ~~~ f~ ~~ (hli ~"'.'fJT-d ~tl ~t!l.' ~~r'i!t'!:"I!1 ~lft:1:~~!1 C~{1;~ ~~
~
~
'i!i~
f~R<ftlft
'Zftijftlrl
~t'I ~~
GWOfhi! ;;;1t1f
Ci{'@.f1 ~~,
Mf~~
i§${ ~
'Itil "6 It
."5lt~.".II1;§'i!" fi1~ c<'(lti{ f'1llc1> 'rl''IIN 'm, I ~ 1.11 'mtCil" ~ ~ <!JlfOl j~lj '11 11 l!;it!
~f~
f<f ~
'Il~ ~~
3IlI
~fif ".II1!lI
C"fito{,
~~1 @mlf?
\'Ift~
'liIi'1I*>>!
"It~'~lf ~~
3{lln~
~r(i~
Oi~l1jV$I-<':J1 ('111~'
~
,I I
Q1
~~ m
~~
;;rtl{t~'lmtC·lIl ~ft'J
~~r~ 11'
1~1.:1
1t~,~~ 'Ilf1U"l1 I ~
'\§~
~
rn~
i~
1JfIt"'.'f1
c<fR ~
tet1~ r
C'f ~r.",
~~fir
'Of~' ~~"I
1fmrtM;
~t
;rlf~ flrcl ~
ct:i~
cW~1~Dt~
~_~Iq
Of~~"iiI'!
~ f~ ~~ \
f<i...t~ ,,&
'"!iIh1
'NI~~
<jJ~
cstrn ciffii ,,"iffi:~ ~~ on, ~ <f~ "1tm: W<f ~ <illrn l[te~11t "!"till '5{rot~ ~ ~'1i{
'!t~ ~
~mtlf~
1!I<ll1 ~
.~
~ -'f,t ~
~'ltlff
Clf~M CIf~~
(Naive Realism)
~~,
iOT
~w
lIi°1tlr
~"J{"l~ <.!I(;J!
lftf1 ""t'Wf11
<l1
~Q
~~~
"'l~aq'-OO<ftIrt<ii
fi{'<fJ1t.!:f~
<fI ~
~~ 1lfQf 1 fiI<f~
'W;#j1f ~1,
Mmt-l
f~
\5~~ .J1~ ~~
I f~,
~~t~~
f.n~ll
t!l':I
f<Ji f<f1t:l'!Dtt'IJ?
'fIit~
~O'{
~
Inquiry
~t'ift
1ftwfr.t~
1!f\!H!t<1i ~ ~lft<f
'6~
}[if
f6l~&iji{.
~~Qj' ~
into Meaning and Truth ~ { ~·~8· ) ~ I!f~~ <.!l~ U1~ ~1'JJ: "if physics is to be believed", G~
~~
('1~~' )
~.
AD
mI ~~
'iSI
~'6
'it,1 ~Iu I
r.~t~,~
l<!H
C~ •. (!j'j1
ll"$J
f"1i" fil~
'1t~~ tftf~~
~1)L11 ( ~t "1~W-!l I ~"'1" d1~ 'Il~ ~r ~ift ~ <:!~ "lI1\!J"'IlIC" c· f·lt.· !11~, Q!lp.t~ ~~ f~ .~~ -aci <qhl,,,R1,, ~Wi11l1 I !>I·lle.' a \1 11ml -!1tt~Qf i!l~ cm;~. "Thus science seems to be at wnr Wil II 11' 11": when it most means to be objective. it Finds itself )II I!111:1' II II1tll IIht lllVlly Lgainst its will."
~GI1
f_CiRT f~
~trn
~fiI ~-~
~t"'~)j9j' 'oft~ I If
fi1
1r..1i!1
I
lll)j.
I
dNIlfJi. II I II r,,,,,
'1" r.
CTR~
~,!\T ~~
'WWJl"11lfffir/)\!t
,~t\!i
I)I ~
I!I~
<1If~
I
1
~'<J.:<r
~forM;\!)
'Iif~1 '!f ~
1ifClfJ
I
<ff~
t.!l{1~il~~il
<l'fot<ffil ~ ~r~~
~-'R ~-rn
'~0f1' (Event
'5ft~.
Jj~
~
I .~
<fict~ ~1ifl
o.!I<f$ C~~
~'1
~
~m~
cm~~,'!{1~~
~~ ~ ~
if1 C<.'lt~
,jj~~
'<{\I~, ~
~~
~jlf
'!fttst ~~<f1 '5!1 ~-I!I~ ~st ~~ I .£l~:q-, '11~~ ~ <n Clf~ ~ .£l~~ .,-t<rl ~~Oft~ ~a?l ~~l:<f "'!{ftrof;~
<:fIt'ili'll
~f4:a <Ii~
~
dl~
<l'tcijf 'i.ift~t<f if1 ~Oil'f~ "'!{N"furtl "'ttf~ ClfC<l1 ? ml:i:lM' 'Il<rtll ~~ Cilf~iftR : "Science is at no moment quite right, but it is seldom quite wrong and has, as a rule, a better chance of being right than the theories of unscientific. It is, therefore, rational to accept it hypothetically." (My Philosophical ~
~'13
'"t~f~
f<!i
f~
'Development,
)<lU, ~-~'1
)1
~"t~-f~
~lf~
ft$~~~I(
c~~
... ~~tr-I',
f~
'S~
~1t~
1"11'1'\ ~.hl"~''11
('<1>01,
~
~~
~
I~
~
~1\!1 <11'1\
~
I~
"'R-t ~
~
m-~ ~
'3lJjt,(;~
,\.,~
"l~tli1
~tM\!i ~\!>1
~~ ~~
lJIC~ ~
CWC01,W~
C<t~ I
m ~ID1 Jf~"'1r{I
1!1~
C:Ji:Ji'l1 f'\5fi1'
~~
~'5ti!\!)t<ltft-~~ft
I l.!1~ ~ c'Wfi ~i1'<f ~
'&~ ~~
C~>tfl:~ ~~
c~~
"a.R
~~
cd!tf~~orn
~~
~
'6 ~-C~~
C~I~,
~rn
'f1
I
i10lf
~ Plmtormlf f~ ~~'Et<{tft R~
WI
fif~~ ~~~1
f~, ~~~
lPf.tt
w»~
~~ ~
~
~t\!l ~
'E3~
l1t~
?(C<.i ~~
0!ti1'
~
-f.ros ~
~
~mioRtlf ~ ~'Br'1-f~ ! ~til<\ I!If<I~ R"5ilm ~ <fi'(j ~ ITt I c~f~~ <.'It'i!iro! MC:i1r.1 ..q~ ~~I~ f1&iIOj"1I7.0If~ <t>~1~'€, ~~ \!iN f~ f~ COl'll ti I . ~'!ltoI ~.f'l<llcrr ~"a.1 ~~ 1 ~"t<rtft \!j~ ~ ~ 7i!CiBI
~'fi!
C\!irn ~ m ~
<ft'~!Ff\!i~ ~1(J1tir
'11 ;qlt~1I1
fOl r.1f'tJlItt1
r.'6i1 ~.
Wi C<\l'~
~""'f<i>~~1
f~
~ W ~i1'<i'
~~'5\
I ~~
flf~
QI~)jC"1~
'<l'rJi ~<f
~
~
System of perspectives!
~ 'S;ft C\!111~
~il
~f\!i CIf~rrn
WIt\!i
1'\~l!t
~COl<tl~
t.!l{t-f"f<f ")jtl.ll~-
lA'lIl<Jl1 \ l"l rtI"N <1iIl'1f~~ot (,11' ~~~ ~'11 (,'Ilr.'1I (.'l~H\J ' CtIj, (, ol{to{ .~ (History ul W steru I'llilo~lIphy>
~m~
I.le
c~f~i-{
'@~f'ff~~~~~~c~~f~,
I
Ol~
c~~
~CS!1
I
'5~m~~
Analysis
~~ ~~
or
1(tiIf*l<\l' C~ 'lC\!l1ij~ ):tst, 9): '1v'l, t.!l{1l!<f1he T I "I COl "'I'lfj!1~.1t1f11JI~1J1'!J9!~ 'II '1I1'1~ \'X1~I'l \1e -I 11"I'IC1 ~I CI~"I1(
,,\' Ihl
ml
~R
~fr
IITtif
1\1 uul,
t~l
~~
1S"I-~"l~
~~t-I' @~
<ff<t<ft~ ~
~
~Qf1
~f~~
c"tOil' (~~
~~
I.!IlIi{~~f~lI~
C'f1m~~
et'S~
mr~, m
r.~f
\
lu
Uf¥! llt~i.1'OiI·r.,.1
h
II 'lit
11111111111
sentences."
and truth,
~Oj
"'$: ,8 ),
W~
,~,\,
fil'!fti:~
ffl ~0f1
lftfi!AtTIl 'f~;f
C~ I
~ut'tr!!f!1tlfl ~ '
~~tt<!: r.~
l!j'ljOj
"fh1 ~
l~ hI ~tIl fo!~~ ~rJm?i ? I!ft~~c!lfl~ bltJf1 fi 1111'[ \'f1~ lItif~f~ \9 ~f~IRm"'tt~ ~Il!' '!j"~ 'l;[if' t.!J~ ~~ c!1<1i '>3ft ~ ~~ I c!t'*1 ~ c!t~ Neutral 'fHf[:"~il ~~J]'Qir-r ~W~'? ~ M~'1CF.1i'1 ~, c!1~ fim:"'t"'r ~f'i!lQ r. lr.1" f~ Ie· 'I 'Sii-r.;1~ ~~ ~t~ '®1
flRw, Cll~ttol ~
~tfUnR f.f;
~lf1.( ~,,~
fORlC"t"P
~l1Im ~fir
~f~t-t
~l;J~.sQijr
m~;:n~
c!1~~"
I{! ~~
::Ff1:!J!"
on
mcam
<rnt
'Sci "t~ f<f ~'T r .~ '"'rI. i1t<fS'8~' ~ ~<\'$ f~~ ~, <fCaf ~c~, (.llC~ C'ft-1 f'lC~ ~
~ ~, ~~
~ f~,
1If'!>I~ ~ L!f1,\9i ~
~tW1' {st~
('ll~~ '~..,~
C<ftif
w'\~
~*'
r"
•
fi,f~ ~~11f ~ C1f"'P1' ''tC'<j'?t 7frorf'atrn CQ'f~' <i1 '~~ ~if mi') ~ <fi'!f1 if~ ~toffir <V1l!f ort~stClf~ I f~Q<I \!!'q ~ f~ 'fI ~~~ R'T~<j'1ft~~ ~ 'fPT'tlf \S1 i1''fl' I ~~ f.m<j'~ 4lf'~~ ~f~ ~m lf11r '\5~ fi;f~'l ~~ f~
f5f~~<AT.:w,
m"*
'!j"-J["
Q1~
ifiIi ~
f.ti' <l~ 7
~~ ift'li
m~~(
0ftif ~~
(if~'
~. ~
"The
~~
inflation of
~r
1"l:>rtf. ..
is inflation
of sign itself,
~\!i
"11t~ I
~~CQiI1
~~J
AA;~
~~.
'~<f
f~'1
~~~~i
f~~'l
~~lSrQilhl
~~
lf~1
i!i"til~
,,'<10{ c!I~
~fi;~ 1'f~t\1J~1 ~'iljif JllIOj~ ~~iI]t~1~"I ~'nl ~f<r ~~ •. ~1;;r~tgj1l' fm'1 ~~ J[r!1r~'1 'St~ nmf (lil 'r~~ I
~~
~~
:if"I'\<fi~1 ~ u I ~'K?f
iftfl!!i
f~;rn
~, <.!l~
iR~~~~<f
1ffetl.Ff.l~
JttifTIJ'1
~
I5tll1t'l'
<i'~
~~r'lf1
lf1 ~
(metalanguage)
\!l~
!,fru~·~.rt~ mar I
~mo.r t;~tf~
~CiT~
t:llTf~
~
~
I
nnt!
c!I~
11l<f
<fiijj
~1
~fif
C~~
rn~\'r ~~~ ~
~1~J ~1
~*\-c<1i~
~'i!
~ot1 '\5tcl "1'; 'fI "!{~~tr-r ~m ~~~ CIf~ <r1 '~ ~'lf c~'tiff<1;j; ~'
~W~~~~~ ftt<rn ~~'& ~, ~~ ~ ~ ~'U~" ~ 't3cl ( ~Wf C1f ~\T 'B1 ~"J f~mr-cJf ~c~ 'ftQliJ~ ~Q(1 <.!l~t(';O{ 'fQiI1 ~~
'~\!i
i;§CI'iflT-fulfl1
~ am~rn~-'ffi~
~
~fi \3ff<&i!1 ) r
C~ft<1i5I'tMfu<f partly
~~ m
\!i~tif :
'.!I~
'~
~'
~:rt"ln1~1 ~
\5~R
'Ii<I>J~~
't~~
I believe that,
by
~ 7 'f~~'1
r.~ ~
<.!1~~,
~1 ~'f~\!) 'f&~J '<:lij '1.!l!11~· r ~~,,~ "1'-,):('«1:'I"J fOIDf ~lf1 llllT, ~ C'li'$fif 9ftsif'ffil COl"t<\" ~ f~i1f 1ij~~if1 ~<f
i'lf""
rc'ftir~
m:~
~
1!II'tt~' ~
means of the study of syntax, we can arrive at considerable knowledge concerning the structure of the World." (An Inquiry into Meaning & Truth, )~ 8., 9f. 1$8~ ).
<!t<IS'1'!'~ 1!II'tt;~"'ltv !1MC<Si!1
<f. JI"R ~
iJ'f ~
"tflr ~
f~ "'tt~ ~
'1'~ <fts~
'@~~'1"cf~~lfiOf ~
I
fffi¢j'~~ f'foJJp! ~~
~l ~
#J;1fZtirn f~~<:j'1'
I
~~
~
r"l'~~'
'{r.'<I~
f~~
~~
<rn'til ~~<\"
~%,
$l~i~~
~~ll1l
Tf'l :
"~B!~'\Z~<j
".wrc'Jl~ ~
n,t~ ~'1',
I"~
f<'i!~'1','
I.!l~ ~WI
C1{ ~
~I
~
~;;t"
~ ~~
<rt<PJ~ C'ifCiJi
~lR
(.'1{
<It ~
.. j
~ f~~
\!1if1~ l!II'iWl itIT.i1' ~~ ~ fi1,~ 'f~~"f9 'i>~rti1~"f1 'i1tt0{ \!i~Ci[ ~~'i!i~ct~"i ~~lf>j ~'ftif ~11l If''~ 'l.[fir \!!IRe\!) $, ''''tC~ ~W \!il~ C"SI I!II'TI! ~t~t~.rtf\!i .,1 I ?t'WfQij' ~ ~ti1
~'tf;,~tct~
<rt<!iJ~~ti;iltl[ ~
'ftt'!1 -
'1tstfat~
"hnr
\!1 'ft<i>J'1t!iffl~ ~ I
f1!fiij
~.t\1: "I"
<.!l"'!i~,
I.!lif
,<jlR
r.~
G'Oif'QI<fi'
C~
:fj~"'JJflt1 ~ ~1
~trn
~mO'f?l
~'V~9
~Oi ~fI!!iC'!l~
~'l;[W1I
m~~
f.ron 7'
Of'8~
ffio{ ~~~
---T'lliII
. Ir.~~
'Unicorn' ~f~ 'Jjf\5J ~9tf~ 'tWl~ ~"t~ ~ f.Fr1! 1{~ <Ui1t!t ~ 1!I{11J!<t'Iil1<ft~ cl;<t'f~ ~ ~~"'m1 "fm [Empty term) ~ I I!I{I~C"l'i1 ~ (ifC"RT f.\>~' <!l<!i f~~~ f~~~ iftll I ~~~ ~~~ ~ (forced labour camp ~ Joy camp, <f'I ~~ f~ ~~ <!l~ C~ C~ ) I ~~ >5{~~ 'Jj,~ ~~ ~, ~ ~ 'a~ ~ 1\j.{- I '\!i«l <!l$! C'5Q1' Of~ f<pm ~t.f ~<!i ~ ~f~ 1It'f.! o.!I~~ non-entity ~l:~ f~ '1~ ~ '8d (C11lF1, 1Ii~ ~ 1!t'f} 'lfc.~1' <f1 '1SfO\t€Cf1 ~'1'Qt~ 'Jj' ~ '8d--) I mt~ t..!l~ m-~it c~ ~t~"11 <f~ I~ ~ ~ <rnf cQ~ "5ft<tfit" ~J ~ ~'\!i ~ ~1rt~ ~ (ifTc~ ~~ .. '8 ~<f ~AA I I!I{vft" ~tT:aj ~~carl 'aTit),t'\!i ~iSt'\!i JBlar C~ JBl~ ~ <ff~ ~ ~ ~9 t C~ "'f't<f1 <f~0{'S ~'lf f~ oiff~ ~ I6ICOl<t'I~~ ~ ~ f<A1 '\!i1 ~tt~ f~ffi om Cll1tt;~
c~i1j<1i1 ~
(if~~
'~~.,.
~t"" ~
~
~<t>
cl!tlfl
0•
~ 0.,
~o'"
It. 0,
~o., ~
800
tn<f1
ct!!(~ g
~
s ••• ~
~n .~
~.:u
m~
~~ "<f\!j~ Of! \!.\I'l<; I ~Caf1"1i I ~tm T;1~ ~ ~ ~'f ;;1 c<F! \5tCIfl1 ~ ~"1S-~Maf ~, Ol~ .~~ ( cordinal number ) ~<t>~ I c!1~ ~~~ ~i1lJ1 O!!~ ~ ~l{'\!i ~ ~, '1!{'l<t.~~ '8=11'$'1 ~1 '5rn\il ~it f.tfir\$ ;rn I <!l~ ~M ~ ~~ (~ C\!i1 ''f~' c~ "1l:~) I ~f~ 3ft~~~'Rt ~ oJ:I~ ~ 'fJt~fr'f J)t~1c:i{1 lfnl I f~ ~~"1 ~~$ f;{fi(~ O!l~ ~ ~ :JR~rtf~ lj~ c~'i1~ O!t9tc~ "ffu't'\!i <mI' ~~~t~ ~ <!l~ I ("By defining the cordinal 'number of a given collection as the class of all equally numerous collections ... " Mysticism and Logic, ~;;'}17 "f. .~ ) I
l;-t~O{, ~
<rof ~ ~
tt~1G,
~..
~m
on~ ~~
~<tf~
~J
'!ff.I~
"1NOO'jlc~
~'AA ~. ~
~lff<tf~
m~
~~
~~C<!i
'Jj'\!iJ~ ~\!<>\1{
~~
~ 'iI~ ~\!Hf
~rn~1
~I
0!t9tC'"i "ffu'f\5
'\!i1lf\~
<llJll~~
ljf~J?
C<t'Iof 1ft~
f"'l' ~.rn
<rnr
ruw.t
<'f~
t1R~
I~ ~
~ c~ ~ms>ft?l~ f.mJ ~~
\!i{<I~
'Sftf~
~
9fM~1
Cantor..-J:ll1, ~~
?j~ ~
fi>~ll5t~! ~
"'11~ I
~
"M'
7lf.lJf
OJIC'IjQ c!1~ ~~
~rarn
c*'\!i
~?
...
O!!tlfl ~
~
~~
~~~
~
I <!l~ ~
'1fufi>'\!i ~
~~R>"K'1J~
~'1" ~
~~
~
'Ti~
~
~
~cart
~
<fl{1 ~w ~
m-t'lar
'!i{~"
lieu
~~
~
~ ~OI
oo~~
~f1
'!fOJ I
~ 'Wi! ~
c~
"c~f~<'Ii{, ~~
Triad lfN ~~ ~J Ct!!flfl ~ 'I~ ~ ~ #fftfh1tf~ 7j,fI(J1 ~ ~~ ( A History of Western Philosophy, ~:II9(t. 'To '178 ) I
-{?:~
1("If~
~
~~~!
triad
~~ ~ ~9
<!i!!l1~Wf1111\1.~aj
I!I{I~
~~"
mtore ~
'!{~~forS~ Qjlt~ r.~il'l1. C'ft'1-f<fcm'1'-~'t-~~ <!l~ '!{I)j!'~~ 'atf~ ~! ~~r\1 1{tJfl C"P't01 '!{t~f~<f ~~"$~~ ~~~taf1 ~ invention, c<ft"lllt\!l' Discovery "Oft I ~~1l1l'\!il 00: ~CO{ '? '1't~ "Q[l~ ~I~ ~t"l'. <fm ~Cf~ ~ ~\~ I ~<f'i!lrm<f31~ ~-'1~ r.:l!ttfi ~~ I 'fir! ~T<!i",. ~lF1 <JlCJ ~f~ ~~. ~~ ~1<t-~~ J!t~1 ~l{j;I Jltr-:i I ~9rn im<-f1.l~m ~ffi ctSi f~ I o.!l" 1t~ "Il!l1 ~t<f, 1;ffi fm .~
~'iI;o,
"if~ ,m
""~rn
I ~
~a{
('~l~c"IT;t'€
oJ:It<iI1
c~er1!
f~,>j,.,tttW1
~~ttw ~
fil'Slt'l?
<lim
~~ ~,
<6(~9 ~~
~~
I'
c<fT!.IfI CQ.lc<t'?
<!If<!i"
~Ji"T
(reduce)
<ro1' I ~~
~-<!lt
W(o'T ~ ~
C'\!i ~
'6
C~'\l'~'r;Ct1.\S
~i{
~firl;ji-e
i11
lftil. ~
1{C\! ~~
m 7j\!1ll7iflt'1
~
~
~
C111f'e<!i ~
~
r.'R~
I~
,j\!II!\!I]\!il (~
If'hr
~lfJ
<!l ~,,~
Extensjon'~~l
lj,tf~J~"fitl'll'
~~~
Hi I ~I~ffi~
;tI~
lj
~r~) t~111'11T'1fO!",·
(Col~9,
~o{
fOf1'it~
~C'IR1
rfl ~
I.
11ft", ~
"l,¥C"""Iit~~
fDf~ ~1l!'1<t";
'" CW mf~
1""1' r.'HI ')I~'fl' 1111\1 \'Iftf'l~ 'M'rot "00'jr."l~ I ~C'1" r.~~1roOfr', '1lsf.1 "l~1 S~~9j'f I c<$f f~~ ~~t ts~lIi'!IJ ~Hc'T>. t~r.ClI 'If. • ·J"~'I"~ t'if!ll ~ 0{1. ~9 -.r1 ~ @Vii~~~ >\""'tr~ ~I"il 11' \1 (I'PRe, 'Ij'B[~ ~ I «far '<f ~fflISl'tOO'11' IP2_CUI~ :)j""'lt ItICllf 1 "ll~ ~1 rt'lil''I
5fl'1tll 111111 ., 11lt~ I
"'1
~'t<I11f
m ~ ~ 'f ,~ ~I~I
r~ I
~C~
lQ'lo{
~ IT 1~"'tlS
lftc~
(,lfi.f~"TIf ~J1
Dt~~ ~1~~ ~~t~J~cf <rof ~ i ~~~ <{r5~ ~f'€ ( "au expression containing 0110 or more undermining constituents, sueh {bat, when values are assigned to these constituents, 'the e)l(pression·become~ a proposition." Introduction to Mathematical Pbllosophy, "'1: ~1U"rt~ ) '1R~ 'fSOf ~t1! cl5j7;i;ifI
~<f
HC~
f~lJ~tlf1 tl!ffu
f~
\5m~ ~ ~,
f~<>jJ ~~1
wm:~.
1fI"'!I1
c!lRt1Rif~"
~Jft~
fum~:fj
1!ftsw1. lftlr
~t~<'f ~ ~<rr1i ~ r:1!!f-ft
~~
"i1[I"1!/ i&'tc<1!
I<i.fsorr.<f ~"
i11
f~~m"lf~ ~~ il1'"""--1.!1<fm ~ Of~ ~i mf~ ~ f<rr.'lirn ~ ~. <lit1mJ ill? I!1fl~ .,:q ,~9t~ fm1 t~'Sf1j" ~fi:ft\!i <TJi"'i'<li '$t'f @.l'~~ I fu"'~ C~I'I9'01\!l @sot"'Ii'!JJ (~01I~~ ~ 5tr.~ ~sot'1trQJ ( )~~~ ) cfl~ fit~t<ft~:tt~~ Pt~ I ~ ~fiI ~~1 @sot~'!~ ~mOl
?
'f@-
@sot'1W ;:qtof ~
~)j"tt(t;j
I
"i1[I"~
1.~?;" cft~ ~
fOlt{tt'1 ~~
f~"'~~ ~"<I'lf
12j~ ~ ~ ~
Extension-~~
.tI~
"tfuct~ ~
W~i.f
"Ij"~
G~tw ~
(<lito{
~?
'5!tf~
~\5I
firf~
n ~~
~ mif
f~t'ii?
~~
:(.11
~,
-.!I~
~~i'ft'6tc~
011 ~~ ~r:5f~
~~
C\!IcflN
sottrn I
mc;)j~
-.!I~1
ifl, lt~'1
~~j
ffli1~CI!t-fM
<fm.
P1~'l1'8tf~ ~1!!1"9m
1'1" f~Jgi.f
~~Ca;rj
"~11l~
~~ ~m f.Js(m~ <\I1lfii
~"l-~~
·M'~ <Ri
\!)~'
~~
I
""11~1~ ~hl'
~tt"1 C"l~ I
m ~~
:F!~-flf~
>
11 i
~wWl
~I;!
~'1
Q{f"l' :J!~"-lfPJ
~~<Ii'?
<.!'Ir.<Ii<rt8f \!j"i.lf~ ~
Q.(t~
~~G'1
<uf'&Jilf~
"i"jUl; I
~~
m~ ~~~
on ~,
~<f 'OO~'!I
<K~ I
I
I
<2(~
~f\S~ ~~
C!f<ft~ lJ'>PI~d!f~J
.tI1f~
<Jft.ft
~1~ '<'I' ~
-~'-~
~~~
~J,arJ
~'~;1'I~tI
fci;~ ~~
~oft
~¢
~t~<f
~~i
Cl'J~;fj~
'1:f~f~~
c:!f~
"!{1$~"''e' l.!l1ftfij:"
~\!jTtfif I ,~~ ~~11" lflSr.<1i 1!;9f~tf~ ~ ~1R <nf'& I <I. ~'It"~~ I!1Cf &~1 ~11" ( Type ) f5f~\!i <pf3( <If'lf" f;!~ ~<f I fil~~ ~ ll'~ flt~~ ~ <.!1<1i ,~~ ~ ~"'1of ~~·flr~ l!1 <l;O'f1 ~, 'O\?J \f!~ .,~~ @1~ ~ <Ii~1 <!S$1~ <m1f1m ~ il1 I <S{~rot 'iC<!f ~if'6lI1 ~~, Ij)NC~iil~~ "It~ fi'!i>t'<lI~ ~It./~ '!{(9~G(\l!in'l" t!1<1i'<fl ~1"fi1" for Ql" ~t<lt~ <rc~ '<f~ <.!1~ ~ 'l"6if fli lJ11 <m~ f~for c!i~~ ~~~~~i1'
f~?J~
<fl'!!I1 ~.!J ;fj~~ I '!l>ljt~~ l1t~'li7f ISnf'f'l1il1 "Russell's Paradox" ." !![t~~.'l11 ~~1'I8ij~ !
'R"-lfJ1\!i"11 I
Of, 11 ~ ~~ n ~
~~~~
~~"11
~t~n-nr
c!if"II'r"i~f~ Cl1"C~
mm~1~~
~Q"
c~lor1l1i'1"
:
-!I~
~1I" ~
~<rt
"'Ii['
~H·l1Ci t~T I
r~ 'lftCoT
'~'
~lI:
G!t~
1:!!tcft, Cl1~", ~l!f"t16'1ij1 forctim ~" "I~ '!ft'!I ~ CIff~ r.~~, C"!{~ ~t<'f1 ~r.~~r.,,~'~ ... lfIf~ I ~m '€' ~t6il1 .!f ~~~ fifrlT, r.Tl c(!/'rl (I t f.I~ O!t~~~~& ~ om I ~51 t..!l~!f~ R~'f~"tl! ~fS1 '1f~ I .1l1\if~" ~t<ft'!l~ <fw1fl ~fif ~m ll"'hfl C:!\"QfAA c.!l1fif ~~ <ITWI '!!ftr.w: 1I.g~ <!~ .,~ .Hr I" \!lt~~ "II{t~~1lJ."I'f<fit"f ~ I <ncm 1'I~m f<l";t., <1i~ ~t<fiJ$ f)f1ifTl. ~t'!I <f~ f~T1 ~. '1t<li1li ~-,1I1l<fi1f !);m-CW~ ~IU ~ C"!{~\!i U I t1!t~ ~ Ci!t~
~.:nOf~~
m~ OfIl ~it '\!.~ ~ ~ rtift~fr1t~ f<lil!l iI)('"il l!I{!;ijr.<f~ llJj"~ <!i~\5 ~ J 1!1.~<l''ii I5{I'1'hi~"'~ ~r.~ Ir."l~ ~1""'11 "llofrtil ~fi1 vt'1, <!1lfil (.\!rj il",! <.!I~';fJ lfmQ '\1'111 I ~i\)'11'11.0)1 Itlr.~I'l1I·i ,1{i~"11 f.'i~ !)~ Slt~~ ~i)I(;Olh'!~ I (.~~.~ t I I I~ I~ 11 . ~ • I .'t qIl 'Nfi1!'1 r.'ll ~ 1:1 iJ1 I.f1I ~'1'tf1C'!l~ lfj'Zt~ ~'f~taj ill! 1'1' I r. • 1)1 ( 1'1 (!1l1 SHill t I{c Ill! a ri lIll., I 1~\!;t<q ,",*~<'lfl \!iC'qi§ I${~~C~~I Itr. ~II II" tr. • I I .~1.1 • HtI?l ~t ~i"l" ~JIi!J fjC~I ~ W
1>f!f ''Ilt~ ~
~i~OjJ Jft~
'1n~ I
~'i1
RtlI
"I"trJt-.tIq;:!/l1 I.!l.~
f<I~~ ~~
~~it
'f'3
fi!~, ~-rn
~Wrar·~~1
~~m
8·
:gfqg; C~r.<tf
iiillfi§ 11 -1 ~
\~t.'T·1 (
om~Q .tIf~~
li"R 'TIPfOf,
"~
~"'~1 ~ f)f'1m<nifr",
~'4"f C~
t-I~~
~f<t-~ ce~
.tI~9~
l'Z!~
C(
o/~"~
mt:lfClf
~Wj
~t~~ '.lSf:':C~IIf"'!
0;1,
f~," \ft~f~
~WKC!f?f
1f-ft~~( ''f{i{'
<~r~~
I
~11" "iCll( ~<t
I~)
I.!l'fffi ~~
'lSfCf
f~ ~
~
~ '!fIt~-1fI ~
1SR
\51if 'I~'IJi~
<j~
<1>~f~) C"f(;iJf
'fCI4J
l'f~
W'& ~
'4~,
lK(J
C~~J~
1W1t' f~ ~
'.lSf~
f~ C1tri'~
L!lll ~
C9J~
~"1f'J
<l'Gff~"'!
~t~ ~~lf~
I.!l~
11~
~1:snt
1If .
'SyndicaIism' I ~C~J'f <li'tlf~torl\!iR llJkij~l\'1 ~ ~ <ftil~ort ~<t r <ffil~t"'!t~r.;1 ~ AAJ 'M~il ~f~\!l f~ "Ifi!~ ~ I ~~ ~t.WC<li ~il~, ~ll"9 1ft~ <£I~I'j<t "m~tr.rtc<fi W'l,"Ii1tR~ W'1tv ~~~ <Ii'lR~, <!fll":If"ft for~~ ~C<t. ~it ~<i" m Cif~'1' I I.!l~ f~1;CiTf~ ~<!SJ ~ ~'i>f?;'1' ~~~Jf I C<!ii\!jt1:lf~~lKIfl1" ~~ 1Jl~ f~ <fi~c·mlfl' '11ft"" "'1'~1 i<ll<R<f-l.!llfi ~~COl' \!I~ ';]r{Ci51li rP& f.,lIt'l 'l'~~ ; C!)~1f{t~1~ f~'lJ.21<Ti f;'1AIi~ ~"r~~~ 'l'Q1."<f I t!I~sM C~'&1 ~ Wc:.<111R<rnc!)~1 #jli'f~ I!fhl~ ~fif m r
-rn~
Mi.5 'fflf~~-'tfllPltrl
m"f ~
~Cf ~
~~,
I
<£I~
~f~ I (~~
~il
i'ftCjif
~::a~::a) R;rJi~ ~ilf",~ '6'1~ ~~'" <ffif, '!i{!1f5 ~~ ~~ ~ f~ cif1r.¥r ~~ "It"'! ( ~::.11:. ) I ~~ ~m1 ~ ~<l'1'f; ~~r-T'(3 ( why I am not a Christian, ~"'9\i. Paul' Edwards, ~)I!:'1 ) ~ COff\!l<fi\51fifnl ~<ff5 f"'l''1~ "ti~ I I.!l~ ~<li~ dft~ R;f;r iNr::r 'e !i~-~tr.w ~'<I~ ~reo'1'1nf ~!Ig <lit'ifr~ I Wrn f~~ ~ C~.(;<fi ~'!(lf, '1f~ '8 ~ffi~ C<i"~~ G~ 11m I
"Marriage and Morals" (
~
~~
a. ~~"~~~ ~
--~I;~
f~, "'Ifir-'{c"t ~~
Christian" 1fW",
1.!l~@c«r1
~"'~1
tf'?i' \!I<fi~
Jr'!fil~"'!\!lii ~l~ ~
Csro!
~ #j~~
WWmrt~
~~.
H"ttal ~
,thq
~~ "tr~tfli§.'8 fiI~ ~
and Morals' ~O'f ~If1lf
""I1f~f1<fi c"~\!lc<l>
~ ~f5'{f11
(Mortals
(fl'f'1ltj)
1.!l<l'll1 ~
<f~tif
ffi~.!j~ \
Q;~
<mr
I.!lif"<l'~ ~C~l
"8
"i~~11rI1
m~il
I ~
f'l"
m~ ~
C>!$l"ll'iS!C<t :lf~'1' ~~
~-f~tcwt~ <I'~ f~f'! ~~m Pori[ '€ ~ycorn- ?tf~~-r <tJtm·~rrt"l'tll 'is'f<ft #j'~H ~ for I C'TlfoT ~<ft
t?f
WI ~1"1~
fif<flfi "Does
Ruja,
~)'lt
~"t
~
I ;;;~
(Ff~'>tf~
education
do harm?"
Iftf~ ~
"1<f1..~~tll"
<!4!lijf'!!i~ ~~
m<tf~ @1f"1J;'W'rn
~61.'Irm~ii1
C'l'ftW f<li~'l
~ 't~~ ~<m" ~
fi;'l't~1 -rrfu'5f\!' .~
'l1~ ~~
I.!l~ '!{~C"f~ ~~
Mc~OifQ "It<l'] ~
'iSlC211
#jVlf ~
C'it'1l,
mm
~tr.jl1
'lf~ ~l$Jtflr .
I l111l1-
~mf~I
( ):.."'~ ) ~
"On Education"
~ "History
I
~~
C#j~
( ~;,,~~)
( ~f&1 ~
Ifttllff~
U\!i~ID'1c\9'
~fu ca~
~
cma;f~~t~~stt'1:
~.
(If~~
of Western Philosophy"
lll'iil/ ~
'ftWIi ~~ ~~
~~'irn 'GIT~~1
iMl;f'tll
~
f<ror if'i I
~\!l
"ll1' m~ollf'!
Ethica ~
'3\t~ ~~t~~
,ft ~,
-II
m~ ~~
~
lIi4i"l111(1 ~"j'fim"t
~~
';]ljt<n"l ~ ~~
<fiIJJf~
OleO{ cornfOf)
~m ~l~
mtcrr ~
'lf1t'1'
<I~~lf
Principia
C<Ii ~~!If
~~i1: ~~ ~ ~ ~ro1'€ Ethics and Politics ~ ~f<r"l~ <fil'~ ~ ~'1:"11, C<I> <l,i'~
'11'~~hll~t\lt
'!i1Pl~
ft"/lf
I6Ilca<jjtii'l1
W:arJ <$tll' '!i\'~ ~"11 ~~ f\!jfoq' 'fu-t~ l!ift~ c.rr~1' R~ e:~ fo;r~ c~f~~ I '5iCa'rt'lt~rn ~'" ~~ ~ ~f'e>, f~f;{ f" ~<I"~ C!)<fim~t'i fflPJ <RC\!)
bio,grapllY·
~;;'>l<>;t,~: 1I:H·U ) I
'1It::r
'l1~J
fir~tfl<i" mt"'! ~~
7ffif (Auto-
<£111<[
9.tmiftf.~'l!~-~
~~1~~~tlQ ~tt1fSf
~C"'<t'i'~.qm "'!tllf mt?f~ ~~NC~
~<f
f~SfCl ~fii
I -.!l~
~tll1~
~~~
.~~~'
~~~
I
~'¥1 I
~~
mtr.1T.<fi <!I'Stc~
I '!iC~ ~.11 ~~
<flt~
'KOif C~l[
f"t'¥t~ ~'.1\~1
sotlf! i1~~ 'S1<ft~ C;;{~,~ ~ ~i ~ ?Tt~ m C\SClf if! ~ ~~"tl I.!l '1ii~ ~C{
iif"i'r1lJ."t~, '!I"ti1I!l~ <r~«(1 mc)jC6j~f"t"ftfD'¥1 ,~ ~~"! ~ <>i1'nI I <!I~ ;ft~'.I,,<(IC:~ f~.;q1Wt'1fWcl1t"'fCOf l_SfC?l' 'Conquent of Hap-
m ~.
piness"
sotr.iii
Of~~
"tit~"' I ~t~
~~ ~
C1>f~
clr~ "61f~
lIC'!i1ertfu'l' CSftc<lSlft ~ I
1$i~C'!i
\5tcon ~c~ 7 ~ mr~'I"I ~~lf ClflT~C~, ~ <i'~~ ~ ~, ~~t;! OWl C1f~ ~<tf;wMfm f"T'~ fta; ~1 r ~\l ~~I1i1~~ lf~ Jj~lffl ''Virtue'~ '6"fl{
~lJJi (;<l'N
"Iit'!l~
'!!ft1>ft1m '!:lI",lfrmCfC'f-..!l~ ~'lQfl!ft~1 \§1"tlnl ~ c01fC~ ~V\!) ~ m 1'\\," W.Pit~~ ~~tcol"->.!1~ '!ifl~0{ ~~·f~ ~O-'ftWW{
f.rs/~ ~mt~~ ~
~~.
~,f~
<!I~\'1"
c:~-~
~~~1~-
~*Ij'i{
~\'l <2t'("fil ~~ '!{t~ ~f" "Of <ffim I '1"'1"<;5 <JI~i1 ~ C!lrt'6 ~11 O{l j <.!I~tti( ~
of Bertrand Russel
The Philosophy
Russel-by A. J. Ayer. Collins. London, 1972 Russel-by Mark Sainsbury, Routledge, Lend n,1979 Bertrand Russel and His World-by Ronald Clark. Hudson. London, 1981 Russel-by C. W. Kilmister, Harvester, 1984
Bertrand
Thames &
1't~<iofRt ~~ <RI1 C1lt1!i '1Wf : The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russel, ed. by Kenneth Blackwell. Allen and Unwin, London, 28 vols, 1983 Onward. The Autobiography of Bertrand Russel. Allen and Unwin, 3 vols., 1967-69. London.
'8 ~
-!1~m~
Kuntz,
1986
~~"1