`zy

XgzZwV2c*
g{

h& @Zi

{^
,Y]2gzZi Z `zy


~q)
6q `zy
,


z[~q)L LyZ>?kszZ Zg szZ Y +Zq
-ZIizgP
Zg6,Y ];zP X

 x ZY fA
$kZ~ T ~ ]

G
g b yZgzZ)l W)g f 8
-eg kg x Z
/
z6,%Z e:
~ x Z
/
z6,
V2c*
g~q)t s: x t ~g7 X 5
b Z1 Z M M q
-ZttyZd
$
d
$
56,iZxZ`zy


s
]**
Dg>YH H~]g b Z1]!*
tgX x Zwz^
,Y**
~wqC
`zy


:q
-Z~sf
X b e**
n4z]
.kZX*
*Z
+_ ZJ+Za z`zy

/
i+44z]
. ~p Vh ~g/zz%a0#
Z~ ]q, Z /
g
$u {!*
6,b kZ ) Xce ]i YZ {)z ` Z { c*
i { c*
i bg Z

(X
Hc*

w+Z
X
+'
w+Z LZ g
$ q Zz ]c*
M M
6,gb >
e
$} LZ ]Zg } ( ^ t z t () ~ekZ 2
zz I `zy

H gziB z Z 6,V `zy

X
]& h t]!*
]X *
*
c*
gF
F6,
szZ2**
X YV
VzU Z kZ c "
$U*
`zy


6,gV ~ kkZ Zzg ~g Y
~ zg c~g Y Z: J
-f ~ `zy


@
]|gzZ
i0vZ]|V;z
H1{ ^
,Y
X Hw `zy


]Z|VzyZ
3U*
X ( e: ~x Z
/z6,T) *
*7LZ zZ : z7y*kZ
*
C
* `zy


7*
*"
$U*
t y*g y X *
*7{ ^
,Y v
iZ `zy

q
-m kZ : gzZ !*
*
*4z]
.sZ: c*
Z
# Zz ~ wq
zahid_12feb@yahoo.comX !*
MxsZ
;gE-D

2012ag ( 542) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

! zZ bZ x m~ + ]kk& Z bT *
* Zzt *
* Z

Zz g Z Zz ]gzkZ~gz {gzZ i^
,Yq
-Z ( z `zy

)4z]
.
Zz B; LZZ ~pi Z z ^
,Y q
-Z 6,tt s: ]Z|
:K~Vg ey*t
# IX
t|g 7? sZ~Zg Zc*
g qgzt ~
C( 1
z `zy


Y iZ c `zy


s V2c*
gyZzz X Zc*
g: Zg Ztu
`zy


i Z 4z]
.! zZ s V2c*
g {OX @*
s
c*
gsZ L1`


7t
# IZXa} ~
CkZXce **
Y H Z
t
# I| (, M
X q~KY wZ Z t
# IyZX ~wzZzs
# zyZ ~gzg
~} LZ+ Zz"
$U*
i Zx `zy


s V2c*
g: Zg Ztu{ ( 2

g wZ Z yZ f
e Zg wZ Z `zy

X x Za Za yiz
X Zz~zz
! zZ 9 z Z
HH7 { ^
,Y ]Zz uy Z `zy

+
G~ z ( 3
X @*
YH7?gs 4z]
.~ z
]sZ [Z wZkZ~#
}
.sZ]k~{~y

M ( 4
v!*
Z ? zX ebg Zg7
t IZP~K`z

#
y (1
Z ~gzs
# z ]ZPag { tzZi
g6,qck
,
i
X CYs
# zyZ
t#z
*
cg
t|gzZ%Z ~gze
$.'t

c*
gz#
aK6,
g
gc `zy


: ZzttJ
-Z
# |gXzzZ b)~zdg" 'p
c*
g#

c*g ZMZx Lp
c*
gOX%ZgZ e
$. 'Z ]Zg `zy

s x Z
yZ0
+{{],
Z gZMZx X
c*
g: zb

q
-Z kZ#
@*
z
) Zx
**
7ZgzZE
0k8,k
,
xVc*
u]Cx~T @*
;J
-#

X @*
#
{gZZ ~zb

1Zq
-Z~XD

{)z}gZ ZZz
mq
-Z#
~pe
$g/X M
h wVe
$g/s
# zt
!*
`g
: YY5V- u x 4c*
gq
-Zt 7x **
( zz) j
2012ag ( 5 43) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

G
5H
xE: Zg Ztu) +3E
z" ( OZ ) +zg :}g Z Z ~
*
c g ~g/
Zi M :z
/
Zx (( J})}g Z Zzcg7g ` :7FgD( +C

X {)zc*
z
Fg7) iz wgZ :g Z~x/
u~ rz : Zg Ztu~
*
c g ~g/
H
5"( {)zy Z0}
G
X Z ~g EZf
$3E
tu ci
+Z Vg 0*
(-6,iz :z
/
Z :}g Z Z Zx ~g/
X : Zg Z
( **
5B5#() qx DgzZFg:7 z ` :}g Z Z Zf x ~g/
X ]Qz ( b 0*
z
"5#) ` Zy

Z
gzZ ( 1) D
/Z%g "
~ T x 4c*
g gzZ {q
-Z e
$g/|g
yZ
~g/ X *
* Zzg
xE z (rationality) : Zg Z tu6,} z
Z% #
~g/ e't

c*
ggzZ#
~zg'kZ
c*

gL
n
[ZX }g Z Zx !*
`g Z% (
) Z x )
c*
g ~g/ ( ,k
,
iyZ-Z{z)
$QgzZ6,
4E
E
0G
c*

gx ~g/yZ0
+{ spj%$
+#

/Z,
e
$g/nkZ *
@Y 7~px ~g/Z ZxVzg Z Z ~g/4Z
Z Y~ y 0*
}) (ill-liberal democracy) e
$g/: Z% M L
$g/ Zz
xsZIe
$ZzgVZc*
g+Z~w( 2) +FOX ( Ce
a 4c*
g: Zg Ztu **
e
$g/w_V;z { c*
igzi ]ksZI e
$ZzggzZ
~ Zi M N M ~ #
} ^zz Kg 0*
+Z x Z
/Z }) X Y0
) !*
}h
+
ZX ( Y c*
x : ZgZtu eQ Cg{)z QZg F,
]Zz)
Vze c*
V
!*
z gEZ ]gz) tg/: Z% M ~ V Z ,Z ~gz

kZgZ Y ` @*
Lx : Zg ZtugTBg
/
z @*
N Y ( #

z xE: Zg Ztu Y sp~ ~I e
$h
+]
.~I e
$Zzg N Y| (,]**
kZ ]!*
~g/sZBB}
/
p ]ZpOxsZV r z
Vzg Z Z
[ ZYy EZtZ
# gzZ N Y C { M6,
(t c (KZ~x
~g Y~*[)X YYHsp~e
$g/w_e
$g/: Z% M A
$7{x ~g/
~psZ 7Z sp~Vg/w_Vg/: Z% M |gDq"
( K) e
$ ZZ -T
c*
gx ~g/a X ( 7 Zk{ '7
2012ag ( 5 44 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

~g/J
- ` M ~ *zz Z o~]
KZ {z @*
z
zgzZ ~
/]g z O~gz ZZakZ mY 7**
j~g/p]Z &
+
c*
g
w_e
$g/gZD YL}g Z Z 4c*
g ~g/g gTgzZ @*
7,
8x Z Z
gzs~y 0*
): c*
z Zi M ~
c*
g ~g/
/Z,n
bZX @*
Yc*

t
c*
gz #
X *
@Y7pzx
c*
g ~g/Z 2
$Dc*
( :
~ci7 KwZ Zx ZY vZY
y Z~zg kZY ~gze
$.g~f t

XN Y M
]YgsZ
kZgzZ sZ a y
g wZ Z x Z~ K `zy


X @*
YH7 {kZ~sfX%Z Ze
$.xg7]Yg
't "
$* ( zmvZ -vZ wg
C ( g ZM Z x )
c*
gz sZ
6,kZ pyZx H g qg
V6,
CkZ ~ ]5x ZgzZ ~ ZZ
yZZ ]Yg |g wV]Yg~ "
$* kZX Zx ZgzZ }
yZZ kZ /
z/
z
1Z {z D ]Yg y ZZ V
Zg ZgzZZg ~yZ ZzyZZgz$ n
pg
p y ZZ 6/
Z[X y

z!*
]Yg Z kZp
$ X 7gzZ O yV ZzyZZ ZZzg kZ
4E
0G
nE
zg +F,
g ZsZ {ZgL& {zzgq
-Z~kZ
at
/Z [Z X
H zg ~g {z gZ kZ1g kZ
gz Zz Z x z-Z[gzZ ;g: !*
x s M {Zg
\BI
EE
at (Z It ,g ( g @*
V }) x **
gzZ O
V Zz Z;g: zg yZZ [kZgzZ /
yZZ [gzZ s M
z gzZ zg0
+Z P f
c*
gC
Q X } ( V })gzZ {z y

c*
g : 2 z bZ @*
*
* z a kZgzZ w

E
%Z<f a+ G%Z6,R]5zg0
+Z
g Z MZx 6,
C 5.Z4zszH!*
sf `g ]]Yg X *
*A
$%x Vz avZ G*Y Z ~ ]5 zgzZ
: $
Yyj
4zszH!*
%Z b & Z Z}
.y~wg"
$*tx|kZ :{Zg ( Z
2012ag ( 545) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

E
]!*
%zq nZ X:[
/
6,
C
RCZ f Z avZ G
*Y Zz<f 5.Z
3 Zg o Zz uO'z]q I VgJ
-V@*
7g*
/
6^
C
z!*( 1) : CY V Vz i+Zg #s
# z bzg kZX @*
Y Hg (Z
+Zg # ^
,Y**
g (Z 0
+
ig Zg a~xsZkZ
# ^
,Y *
*nz
oKZakZz!*( 2) X H r Z 6,F,

o Zzug (Z~ wg"

$*X J
-LY #&q c*

: x Z kZ L +Zg
Zg *
@Y Zzt i+Zg #gzZ @*
Y c*
CZ~A C
Ut
U{z|gX 7~Zg ZwEZa]Z CZ f LZg ZM Z
X @*
{Zg
} ~z*BB z <f t Z% &]g Z& ( [
wq
{)zzig M #
wgzZ6,
yZ zg rZ~gz6,
!*
ZZp{ Yzw 6^]!*

%
: $
Y~zg 6,
XA
$Z%FkZkZX D Y
<
Z0ym,
+Z0/w yZxyt x| ! ]g Z :wzZ
2~g z[: g:B;q<C
~wg"
$*X )zK
d
$i8
-gzZ
]Z~Zg]Xz]q I2@*
:g (Zx Zz6,kZ Y2~C
/ZX@*

X
8l6^
q (ZtX @*
7Zg Z[kZp yZxy Z% {,
'Y]g Z : z
g z[C
!*
<{],Z~
) Z CY @*
~] Z T @*

z <f z!*
kZp @*
/:gzZ @*
7V 6,kZQgzZ @*
Y 2~
X
rgg Z
',
lzgOVV 7Z @*
7$zUpx <
mZ e
C~zX z`

Z yZxy (Z p !]g Z :
CZ fw Z
M
80*
KZx Vhg z[ @*
s~46,
sZ z [6 yZx Zq
-Z Zz t
~!z {',
Y]g Z c*
X {)z
8 !
X **
~c*
xia4c*
g
C6,
( QZg})
C~uz @',
<
c*
g+Zq
-Z ]g Z : xg X
E
E

45 6,w' *
+ G
Z
@Y c*
}zg 2Z x Zw CY ~ F,
6,q2Z pV X
yZ ZgVhxsZ y=wZ e 1 : ] Z Zzqg
CY ~
yq kZ Z)]!*
tat
c*
g X {)zD YKoB;
2012ag ( 5 46) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

X Y07xsZg ZM%Z Y0gM%Z( ygzZ c*

))!*
zZ ug !*
}X
c*
Z Z ZZ ZtyZ1C
vx Zz**
x Z Z~yj
jZc*
X }: e
$aBsZ
c*
g
sZ ( x )g ZM Z~g @*
~g CZz]!*
Zt8kZ
a **
c*

g sZ7tzz kZ1 g V Z',~ g @*

sZ G X g C M ~',hZ
{ k
HgzZtXy
KZ bV
KZ}uz 7
yakZs
z I
c*
gyzg0
+ZgzZ yZgzZ V!#xsZ6,g zOX egz
g D YK Z Z~ ]Yg Zf ] Z~ Vz VzgZ Z0
+
i
b kZ ) X wq
]5 V@*
igzZ ]Z CZ fB kZ {Zg
X($
YwV!*
`gs
# zh
+'

wV {
{gzZaKtV7Z6,gz {2K6,g
gY wZ Z
Zc*
g9 z Z n Zzt T ]gzJ g6,t
V2c*
g
,p]Z &
+]x sf `g X 7? mz 6 yzZ
:( 3) K{g
ZsyZn
pg{p
ZspgzZy*p]
c*

gsZ :wzZ
wg"
$* x Z : z
4 !*
xE :
4 !*
( Y ,x )< ( QZg) g2z :xg X
w ]I :Q
kZgzZ F
F6,x , Z q
-Z6,gZ **
zZ Zc*
g{ Zz ]yZ
O qgzZ xE: Zg ZtuOxESq x ZO Z}
.V **
z q
: Zg Ztu LZ p]Z &
+g Z
Z 4 !*
QZg Zc*
g h
+]
.|g X **
g2
H
4G5
G
1

t gzZ gy Z W
F6,QZg Zz 6,D
F
C
b 7 ]!*
-Z
c*
g ~g/
4 !*
<
V C
c*
g ( CZg<ZM ) pluralistic q
*
@Y tg/: Z% M &) YY H wJ/wq
-Zga x PZ x : Zg Ztu
7
LZc*
gtXq Ze**
b r z
gzZ *
*pSqIg0
+Z
c*
g+Z%Z (
{z CwJ6,g c*
~zb

QZg
c*
g {zC
Z C Zc*
gF
F6,t
L
2012ag ( 547) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

*
@Y 3g Zzga kZQ nagz ~gg0
+Z
c*
g ~g/X C
c*
g
yZ7Z Zn7( K[v) Enlightened b~g7Zv a
@*
Y c*
0*
wJ4 !*
QZgB( VGZz Zzg c*
I })]t
)
qJx : Zg Ztu nLs~uzgzZ Y Z
y C;LyZ sq
-Z
` @*
Lx : Zg ZtuV V X Y M x ~ 9 Cg Z Za Z

x : Zg Ztu(C
~ *OX CY C p" z I Zzg @*
Y
+F,
gzZ Z (,

q)t |X CY Z
qJ M )g f"wZ
X ( 4) *
*g Z
Z kZYZz|QZgL b Z1
Zz ` 7ZZc*
g: Zg Ztu|gZc*
g{ Zx s
# zkZ
-Z F ~X) ywqyZMVzgZ Z 4c*
q
g}g 7~kZX y
E&
C

4
}
E
G
y kZ
c*
g zy c*
|y , Zt 1(

L gzZ 5wq ]gZz Y 0*
~gz {~ p7Z X ' V
H0
+
i
yZ D H7Zxx !*
LkZ ( P} ]!*
)yZxy
{ YY~VsyZ )X **
z q!*
x : @*
g z[x`


h
+m,gwX 7 q x xsZ {z i Z F,
+ ]g Z h
$
+m,Zc*
g
Zc*
g9 z ZX ( gF,
+ ]g Z kZV2c*
$
g{ g7e
$
xsZ X F
F6,w{z}
.: Zg Ztu{z g} rz

(z ] y T
X 7m
/

C
];zDq `z

y~0#Z
]kgkZ `zy


g0
+Z0#
Z ~ ~y

M Z e
$.']!*
t
: $
Y,
C~^
,YkZg6,
]sf UX g0*
',
VY
X 6,V #
<gzZ
c*
gsZBt
{ c*
i c*
J
-1924n /
: Zg Ztu6,*)g f Z Z Cc*
z(Y( Yg EZ zq
-Z /
v
6,( e
$g/}) Vzg Z Zz ]Zg! fX+h
+]
.t]!*
}'
)X c*
x
Y Nt V X M7~ g @*
s Z J
- r Zu yZ g}g Z
xsZ L7Z
f: nZkZC
X CYVYtg/: Z% M ~gz ZZy

M Y
( X @*
*
*q Za
~p~ VsyZ Z 7,0#
Z T ~pt g Z KZ /
2012ag ( 548) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

{
g yh+F,
gz$~VsyZ )X gzZ Z<zxsZ
CZV
X ( 4k
H;g ZD
V2c*
gh
+]
.
c*
g;
g EZ +6 {ie
$h
+]
.zkZVyZYg EZ V /
*
@Y c*
*
c*
g
6,x q
-Z V;z zL~ C
g zcgzZ { Z
} h6,VzI xsZ s~uz 0 Zg L x : Zg Ztusq
-Zt gzZ
X @*
YZc6,
0*
g Z- 7Z~ZgzZ',
Zg ZX Zgv *
@Y 3g 2~ .kZ]ksZ FJ
-sB /
]!*
gzZ {z)X
8 M ~ Y #
6,
CZg Z?
/Z Z **
:B}g v
],
Z4Z }) }
/Z p( 7~gzZg V a Zc*
g ~g/t p]Z &
+
sZ}g Z
x$Z,Z b Ot yZ^zz Z ]ksZ ( ~
X h{x ~g/p#
kZY ~ : #
.
$

{6, . kZ VzI xsZI | LV5I e

$g/sq
-Z V : /
BV;z e**

c*
gsZ
c*
g: Zg Ztu 5 Zg ~g/ c*
ue
(will of Zg Z L e
$g/ V | Cc*
t_-! f
kZX @*
*
*x 4c*
g6,
CQZgz ~ Zi M (general will){ Zg Z
L 7 all)
<
g0
+Z ugz *
kZ :gzZ YY c*
7g Z
x6,
Ce
$Zzg c*
{ Zg Z
<
X rz
( ]z) ~ Zi M 7[gSq{ ZgZY @*
e**
4 !*
4& xE Y 46,
z]
.) x ZfaD G
0E
u4c*
g bTO /
G
t ]ksZ k& Z lyZ7 h Z} 0*
',4z]
.d6,Rg
~ z! zZa,@*
<Og Z MZ ]sZ bZ!*
N M
-Z0#
Z ~ts: **
M~z]k
ZX ( 5) ]gz Zq
.
H Za *g~x VrsZx t YH ]kyZ7Ot]!*

X ( M~sfW6,
b kZ )X Y
sZ 0*
z
" ~VV ZxZg EZgzZx : Zg Ztu
/ZO /
z t Z ]kyZ : (ZJ
-Z
# N Y lp[zZz `zy


]kY ~
X (
V XZ]gzLaZ )X gwqi ZzzgzZ
`z

ygzZY wZ Z ( 2
]mZ} LZ `zy

+
GX sY wZ Z M [Z t
# IZ yZ
2012ag ( 549) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

E3!
H I `zy


s uC EG
z ~XD7?gwZ Z yZx Za
VzU z& ~gz '
g yZ 7?gY wZ Z |g X
H
zg t
V2c*
gh
+]
.gzZz~ zg ]YgsZq
-ZX YY
X YWK
M n!*
6,
Vz~sfX ~
UqZ Y wZ Z ( 2.1
4z szH!*
%Z]=g &
+
) Z yZxy Z% `zy


HH Zz 6
E
%Z6,V gzZ **
oz qg

) Z Z
) ZZ `zy


X *
* 0*
',4z]
. 5.Z
E
kZX XB Zq
-Z V; Y fY H
 `zy


%Zt X **
xi 5.Z 4z szH!*
:qZgZsf `g~Z
x yZ
_
) Z kZgzZ Z
# Zz
) Z w x Z q )Z ~%Z kZ Y f /
w , ZX yaV Zzg (Z e G
Z~g
$ q Z
Ct Z]Vzz
g ~}%i]z**
~{z
/
agz$g Z MZkZ c*
**
VZg ac
eZ q
X YHn V2!*
BV Zz (ZgzZ
tYce *
*7`zy

s {',
Y ]g Zav `zy

bZ /

E
.
: 5 Z4]=g &
+pX s Zh
e w}
.
G} (,
(
GLg
E

.
E
{. 3E

.
5

J Z Z X 7s ZuF, Z4~ZgC
c*
hgV Zx
T7
) Z~ wq]gkZ L
L ]!*
]gzpe
$.6,bzg
) Z q, Z
F6,VgzZ e
F
$Z@zgt Iht V>:gzZ Z',gzZ n : ~
cgz W,
ZV>:gzZ F
F6,]g gzZ Zgz
f :t !*

) Z ! XZ
" ~V70
+
iGx}g %]!*
ht V Zx OX Zz3sp
y Z
H1zgB;`zy


s uC~X]uZzx , Z+yg )
,
O X Xg

) Z x Z
# X *
*g (Z i (Z =gzZ Z m
sZ ~ }}g Z Z 4c*
g 4 !*
( sz}x ) xEsZ 6,
CsZ
+
~ ]q, Z {)z V g6,
CsZ}ZVgx ._ ] Z
( sZ
) Z )} (,q
-Z jkZY Y @*
',Z `zy


]!*
k
Xce**
YHwJF,
Di Z ikZ Z60
+Z Y)
~kZX7g `zy


s !]g ZZ
# @*
6,%kZs %Z~`zy


X/
zz Tce *
*7`zy

s q, Z~ w Z~(,q
-Z <
L IZ f7
2012ag ( 550) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

2sp Y
z y
V ~g Y ~ V q
- 4,
yZ
4G
& r
7tzz } :Y fyZ s `zy


t]!*
ZX { Y]G
0E
X !*
`gzzbzgkZ 7 ^
,Y}u`zy


- 4,
q
yZ
g# `zy


s !]g Z Yrz
z1 Z~(,q
-Z Y fbT /
6,
V VY ^
,Y`zy


~wyZ
1Zx ZuXx ZY fFbZ!*
`g blkZX ~gz4z]
.x w x Z(x Z gzZ **
sZ<
:sf
Hc*

gZ~y M
( Z
X Y Z]L (36-) l^_]]fjq] :
X Zz Z
) Z~+vZ Z% ] s
# Z(6) f
y M
V Zz v ] $
tZ] G
Zt Z ]a
c*
g: ZgZtu
]gzZ (256>) ;g { (
5 Zgoz7Z B (17%i)X ;g ~p
X (60{Z
+gzZ7652X 51 Y
K)
Hc*
gZ
v+F,
+gzZy-vV Zz
$
) Z
]] $] o ]^i pj] f] o]^i :Z g Z~y M ( [
X ~ ]5 C c*
igzZ { k
Hz#
gzZ ~ V} gzZ nz }u q
-Z L ( 2{Z
+ )
7^
,YyzB(
c*
g ~g/})
c*
g Zz r z
7ZgzZF
F6,yZzz {k
H
Zx
X ]gq
-ZkZ|g **

) Zgz',
c*
g+ZgzZ
^ ^^] ^ ^q o] ^:Z g Z~KkZ ? yg Z,#
ZyZZIZ ( `
~" (
Z',
ZZ
# ) vZ L L( 124 :>) n^] ` ^m ^ ojm
V>{z Zc*

? zZ ~Hn( Z',
Z ) V Zz ZV
KZx
iZ Hw +Z e
$ M kZ ?

x ZgzZ ~i Zg x Z m
}8Ex Z X 70
X 7g Z, #
Z
g Zh
+'
~KkZ (
" L L( 58:Y
K) ^] o] l^^]]i ] ^m ] ]:Z
,Z #
Z Zx kZX g Z,kZ z47ZP Z vZ
X@*
~g7_ ZkZ IZ kZceb
?Z
# ( vZ ) L L ( 58:Y
K) ^e ]vi ] ^] ne ju ]] ( |
]] m] ^`m] ^m :
Hc*

bZX z 6,
C ( <)wzyxgV
X Y0 Zzg6,
w ZzyZZ} Z L L( 135Y
K) ]` ^e n] ]
) ZgzZ vZz

) Z L L( 5 9 : Y
K) ] o] ] ]n] ]]n] ( z
2012ag ( 55 1) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

qg

) Z |gZ
) Z ZxX V%Z r
# ~ ? yZgzZ wg z
X 7~gz
) ZkZ }~igzs kZ {z
/Z qz
$u ( f
vZ (m5) ] n o ^ :Zy wZ~pg
~g ]Z ) ] _m ^ :c*

2X 7x
) Z t~A
**
:
HHyV- ~y M
]!*
ZX 7
) Z kZ@*
7
) Z vZ ( x Z[
wTz:
) ZkZ L L( 28: ) ]a fi] ^ f ^] _i
@*
~zcZpKZ {zgzZ c*
c*
KZ
m] n] ]]n_i:2
tz#
~zcV Zzg
/
u L L( 151X 2:Y Z ) vm ] o m
X D7b & ZgzZD 0*
',
Y~}i {z
0*
',!*
x gzZg z [ oz qg

) Z
) Z Z Zx myZ
X xixg6,
mzw6,
V 27^
,Y
) ZV Zz
pe i j ]] j :
Hc*

~g Ig
$uq
-Z ( b
, Zd
$k( ) ] ^ ^ `i^ ] ]^ e^i o ]
~',{z yT( | ) yZ T:zg Z yZgzZ T?VyZx
yZgzZ
H Zg6,yZ kZ Z 6,5 Zg s {z Hg Z yZ 5', TX
Z%Z, Z HwgvZ} Zn/X ( 6,5 Zgs:gzZ ~',{z: )
) Z
X*
*#
(Zg D Z Zi {zJ
-Z
# c*

\ M ?ce
87wys
p) Og > [x {zt oi Z
) Z V Zx ` g
$ukZ
;gZzt wyL~g
$ukZX ( ,kZ c*
g2,x Z 5Z Z kZ, Z Z
kZ X ]i YZ 4
z]
.
L 7(
) i o) ` Z ~ x okZ

E
X @*
w+Z6,5.Z4]=g &
+s V ZxXg
$ q Z+Z {z
],
~ pyZ i ~ \zZ yz
a H7Nt ]Z| D
W6,g
$ukZ
gz` Ma p~ ]i YZ `zy


6,5Z ZxkZ Z k7,i C
CY xsZ
:^
,Y`zy


6,> [uF,
` MakZ g7xsZ],
6,gkZt` M Z V- i " e
$Z~
X M
h|sz@*
kZ pDIZlVzcgzZu sz@*
kZX
g ZxsZ agzC
> [#
Z **
Ctpg
$u ~gz*
*n Z%Z
aZX M
hYKw~T c*
C: e{z zmvZ -vZ wg c*
Xzg
zy M
xsZ],
Zt NkZX i Zz t
~
gzZ c*

2012ag ( 55 2) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

Xce**
wqZe
$Z 7m<
L
C M~i@
x ZgzZ
i0vZ]|nZZ
`zy


~ yzZQ ( o
4z]
. s{ZgOz]g Z
c*
gzsZT
g <
L IZY f& wVZZ ug (Z4z]
.[ZyZ~ V/}uzX **

X [ !*
Zq
-Z g @*
s Z q
- 4,

) Zz <
L IZn]Z|Vz yZX {
X xbhZ[pDIZ bB `zy


{)zi
1Zx Z bZ
w+Z6,`zy

}Z bZ ( ~
H!Zi Z y v( ]m ] ]:} @*
H yvF,
!Zi Z y v} (, ] ^e f] ] ]]:2 ~gz**
Y
X {)z Y
: ozB_ ZP]i YZkZ q
- 4,
Y f Zz]i YZ `zy

/
] Z Zz Vz A yZxZ
# ~(,h Z
# Y HA
$ `zy

:wzZ
~ V/}uzX [ M

) Zx sZ)
) Zx sZ '1V
{z c*
gzi { c*
i
6,oT `zy


i Z x ZY Xce *
*s z!>g Z `zy


: **
YsZ<
x ZuIZ *
@Ysp~[g ZxsZgZ Vzq&L L:D

) D
( 4:
z)
8{xsZZ [Zg ZkZY Z`

Z
Z Z`

Z ] Zts ~ gZ {g ~ q
- 4,

z - x Z D
X a[Zg Z
8E
Y 7sp~ xsZgZ [Zg Z % Z`

Z xsZ x Z L L : D
gux Z D
( 10:o)
E
Zg Z 7s %Z ~ ]!*
kZ ~ Y f}gL L: D

+Z ) D
+) X @*
sp~xsZg ZC
] ZsZ
( 7: E
5{Z Z$
#k N Y0*
:ozx ~TY0yZx(Z
/Z L L:v
Z z{
D
*7~~
/Zp ... V Za YgzZ} Z~o #kZa kZ ce *

KZ kZ [Za kZ Z
# Zz ^
,Y wys kZ }#%Z Z yZx
BvZ wys kZ Z ;g0:
L h z Yh
+'
ax gzZ ~ e
$ Z
E
( 399B 2 : G]ZvZ ) X
*
@YZ
# Zzwy YavZ)(
) Z)+Z
# L L:D

0Z) D
2012ag ( 55 3) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

~6,Z
# Zzwy yZ D7~0*
2Z z ] Z F,
Z z ZzxsZvO
( 502-511B 28 :0Z z) X }Y7s %Z ~xsZY f
! xX Vzg]**
kZ! x~ ]g `zy


Z ]gzZg i Z ]q :z
DV7 ]q :Y b) ~ Z wqiZ% ~ggzZ ]**
kZ
~;6,]q7giZ%z~g wZ~g :gzZ
g Z} 4z]
.%ZX C ZZ T C*
*z iq
-Z
:]Ygg e
Gg ZD
\ MX ]gzp]!*

0Z)
X qz*
* (ZYszc(kZgzZ Y
Gq
-Z ( 1
X qzt: p
/Z Y
Gq
-Z ( 2
Zg ZZzc*
M )X~ ZtY
G (z(kZ1Y
Gq
-Z ( 3
X ( 7c*
Y M
GZuz
X x Zw**
(ZY
GZ (,
kZ(kZ1Y
Gq
-Z ( 4
kZ7t [ Z kZ Y H H :
) , Z `zy

]=g &
+Z
# ]!*
t g /
`zy


~]g+Z Y ~g
ot Y c*
!*
aJ
-Sizg4z]
.
E
.
{. 3E

kZ D
J Z Z X @*
Z Z
# Zz )l Z
# ZzY xi *
*~g
:eZggzZ'gF~g
s~uz n ~i fa `zy

sq
-Z @*
*
*~g iz ~
) ,Z
D (1
g Z MZ yZ ) Z
Zz VzgZ Z {] @*
n Y ~ 9 CgZ Z w
j!*
0#
ZgzZg Z { Zga`zy


@*
Y c*
~ Z
Z z Vzg Z Z w (
X A ]
N YbuF,
gZ, Z X
C:
) !*
!*
x g (Z e V Zx ( 2
C M~0
+
i
1Zx Z wVdZ kZX (,cgzW,
Z yZ6,o c*
oyZ X
X H: wJ{ > ?Z~g~g uz!*
VM
Sqs Z Z Y]!*
+Z :gzZ YH:tgz',2Z !*
zM My Z ( 3
bzg~g s yZgzZ {e yZ5v
/ZgzZ} {Z
+x qJc*
Xn ]kZgzZgz$g ZM Zx !*
@*
cebB6,Riz~yZ N CZ
A gZ M ZY #
~qg kZ|g xgt6,g Z M Zx !*
g c*
X ~hkZ c*
Ds gZ M Zx \ M c*
7|bzgwR,
Ec*
W~
2012ag ( 554 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

X 73 Zg yxgyZ
: Ztcx kZ :c
t z ~ ZZ c*
m y Z
Hc*

I `zy

~ Xg
$ qZ +Z /
Q c*
gzZ : yvZgzZz?<
C
c*
g1 ;g6,?6,gCZ f yZx
/Z
:~g
$ukZ
w+ZkZXVZ',
~ ZZyZx
\ M X \ M c*
zmvZ -vZ wgD
{ ]|L L
p,
) ZgzZ[]!*
ZLZtq
-Z~yZN a
qp **
gzZ ~
q
Vzuz6,~
qkZ gzZ~ MgzZ ~ ;~
TN (Z~ yZ ?J
-V ,7ZgZ IZ t gzZ Y ~ F,
E
G

X (>gZ[z E4 Z[~gg) X ??s ([ )vZk0*

}gv6,

Z
_
) Z6,
C ( Y: {qZz!*
}) _t ~ ZZ Zx g
$ukZ
tg
$ q Zv kZOX ^
,Y *
* (Z~]g~i Z0
+Zg Zz~Z%Z7^
,Y
<
) ) x ZoZ B
c*
gZ ~g ZtugzZ s + **
zp
X *
*Za ~m|g
$ q Zx +Z zg C =}uz q
g
-Z g
$ q Z L LwZ0g
$uwZ /
kZC
~X C =g
$ q Zx yZ o qg

) Z cZ
) Z~X
{k
HZ T @*
{z x Z L L: D
124e
$ M > >g?

x ZO X 7f {
O V- g Z)f #
~ kZ gzZ @*
yZ : g ZZ {L

zpz#
`
yZ c*

x?Zm 0x Z ZzVpyZX
A&
V!*
~y

MX#
Z zmvZ -vZwg6,qZ Z X 7gZ,#
Z {z V
]j^ ] h^je m f n j] :tq
-Z~yZ
z
mZ;g._[vZ]g Z~gv
Hc*
Zxq
-Z6,
?
/Z (~gg) ]n]
X z
) ZgzZ]!*
gzZ! >g ZwZ Z `zy

s iZt ]g r~ wdZz wZ Zx ZY f /
X YHw6,`zy


s {',
Y
60
+Z 0*
',
YzzkZ YHw6,!>g ZwZ Z `zy


s x ZY f
/Z /
yZt: wZ Z yZ`zy

s ! >g ZX **
^
,Y**
~ wqC
iZ `zy


:
CrZ (w) 4c*
g sZ)g f Vg Z yZ%Z CY 0*
V Z',V: V~
2012ag ( 555) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

V x 4c*
ggzZ @*
ZzgzZpwq( )z~ ~k
,
Cg Z Z
~gzZX @*
g z ~ kZ zg7 g Z
/._g qg
V
H0
+
i KZ
X60
+Z { c*
igzZ v]gzY1
Z',
]!
7x]gzV+Z
X **
Q c*
gzZ $dc*
**
hBV2c*
gsZ)mY wZ ZyZ%Z /
UZuz Y wZ Z ( 2.2
: @*
Zzt
# IZ {y~wzZz
c*

g sZ19~ yZx{z~}wZ Z`zy

x /
wq ( #
: )
X D (pre-suppose)n
*
*;6,wq ]g{7Z } : s `zy

}nf Z /
} :{z6,`zy

s T
c*
g sZ {z }u V Y 7
g
}uZ
#
c*
g {zb} :tzz80
+Z Yg 0
+Z
c*
gsZ LT
~uzgzZ wZ Z}~g ? H DV2c*
g {~h M Vz:yZ
gzZ V- !*
M y ~ gz ` M X gzZZ Z
# A
$%~ ~ ~
7Z q ]gz4z]
.! zZ O~]qyZ Z]6,
V Zx
K A
$%~
sZ L x ZY  *
*;6,VZ yZ6,g
Zz {z
/Z
W ? ~ h `zy

+
GwZ Z x Z:X tgZ k
sZ) ._ X,7wZ Z, Z x Z T e *
*7? ~ hLZ
**
YH7!*
${Z', w (Z
/ZX
Hc*
g Z
^
,Y**
**
( `zy

) ~wqC
s
c*
g
*7wZ Z `zy


s ~V2c*
g {Yce
( v n o o] ) *
:X ~:
c*
g sZ)
L:
c*

g sZ L wZ Zx t t Z]
Y *
* Z
i Z eZ ?gz$ gzZ F,
q
-Z I `zy


4z]
.! zZs V{
X ( 7) Xce h
+
b Zd4gzZ
o{ c*
iakZ
]=g &
+s #
sZ c b & Z
c*

g sZ L Z% `zy

~ sZ}
sZ Z
# %Z X
c*
g sZ Z
# $
c A
$ig `zy

X *
*4z]
.
7`zy


4z]
.Y ]=g &
+s
c*
g~ ]q, Z : }u
c*
g
g~ V/}uzX ( 4z]
.sZ 0*
',s #
~g @*
@*
) CB q Z
`zy

{z e cg Z ~xmZgzZ @*
n
sZ `zy


E
S5!`zy

^
,Ys #
sZ`

z
g]!*
tX e | (,
M
2012ag ( 556) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

+4 *
* ht y Zx',YL L :Z y ~ pg
$u 6) @*
g ~}%i
g Z \ M ww
1Zx Z~ h`zy


i~ m }8E2

u
L (Z !*
tt X g b Z ]!*
V %Z ( c*
g Z
aZ s
Zz VZ c `zy

~ h
+]
.gz : X t
~s~ b Z M
ggzZ b Z g
X m: Zz|Z V2c*
g{|g6,]Z|
: YYV!*
ZPDk6,
wV!*
`g e
$g/
7x **
( }gtg)x m#
~psZ /
X*
@Y7x sZ Zg7 Y2
$}gZ Zq
-Z Z
) Zq
-Z t
x '
**
}gtZZ IZ
L t{z Za ! Zy

Cg Z Z ~
C ~KCgz
Zz M ~g Z M Zx sZ{Zgzz + T:t
kZ#
z
c*
ggzZ
H
6,
~p
c*
gsZp]Z &
++h
+]
. ( }gtZZIZ ) ~p~zb


~ ZZ yZ c*

I `zy


z!*
[ V
!*
x Z zz X 1w
Y{
) Z~`zy


gzZ sZx 4c*
gz!*
VZy

HH Zz 6X VYX ~ Z
z `zy


$
Y ]!*
t V /
f zgz] Z ._z mT C|
# {q
-Z|g
c*
g
[ZgzZ sp
CL
) Zx ~pX~
) Zx c*
MteX @*
**

XX $q
-Z!gzZ @*
%Z q
-Z
H ~gz
_a ( b & Z ]=g &
+) `zy


X%Z{q
-Z a+ ~g/ 7xsZY X
z `zy


Y ^
,Y ( 4z]
.w)4z]
.nC
a 0*
',[zZ ~g/q
- 4,
+yZ
p7^
,Y4z]
.! zZ s e
$g/%Z ]z=e
$g/q
- 4,
y Z
~KT @*
q
-Z
HM
z
c*
g ~g/: Z% M VgzZ
 *
*t
~ y 0*
c*
* [ w +O%Z }) X Ds %Z }uz q
-Z +t
*
* (Z~zg]q~w (y v M%ZB V: Z% M
X ( @*
~gz
]!*
t
zhY~zgwZZY V2c*
ggz {
HZztbZ /
sZ XgzZgx ~g/: Z% M c*
w_c*
Zc*
gx cexg{p
~zgwZZyZ7Zn
sZ6,
gV2c*
gyZ ZX 7Zzgzgz
) Z
7"gzZ Z^}g7yZ~zx[Z:X tgZ kb {C`zy


2012ag ( 557) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

X
Hc*
n
pg7gZgzZ]q~ :tce*
*g6,
]!*
kZO
{,
^Y]DZ`z

y+G
(3
7{ ^
,Y]2zu Z ZzYG7 s `zy


+
G[Zc!*
`g
+
GOX C]gz?ai Z x wZ0tX D
`zy


X BZg yZ t v ]gz xi *
*"
$U*
?lLZ6,`zy


: @*
w6,
qq

-Z ~sf `g ~ ]Z| Zzg Z

/Z : ,

^ Y*
* ( V ]q ) `z

ys ( t{z e) #sZ ( 3.1
q )ZgzZ/gU*M <
L zy M
? KZZ ( H > 6)
{z xi6,kZQX }7e
$Z b| 7,]Zg Y P *
*7 #
Z
`zy


~]g ( Z
uF,
) > [#
ZuF,
c*
b Z1~X} Cg
$ q Zx yZ
~}g !*
`zy


vZg@]|gzZi0vZ]|6,kZQX
Hc*
g Z
^
,Y
Vz yZce b C s s ]!*
t Z BgzZ xi *
*s
# z `LZ
X
rg Zg H{z~}g !*
kZ g Zg)Z <
L IZ~}g !*
`zy


]Z|

4E
5 #y*kZC
X ( {z
/
<
L IZ EG
)
( sZ: ) {L1 ,
^Y `z

ys #sZ ~ ]q m ( 3.2
t?
xq
-Z } !*
`g LZ t ,n
: ,
^ Y*
* `z

ys V
0vZ]|{z6, kZgzZ @*
^
,Y `zy


~ ( {)z b Z1 ) ]qk
,
/**

P @*
~
*
@Y[x~ "
$U*
Z <
L IZp}g Z
^
,Y `zy

vZ g @]|gzZi
t{z Z *
*"
$U*
i Z x `zy


~]q {pZ kZa1X
**
^
,Y**
kZs V
!*
ybZ!*
^
,Y**
t~]q{L L
L
: **
CtZ[ZY0*
7i])kZ sz@*
t1

sZ (zG) ` M
HM 7 b Z1 L y (Z 0#
Zy

M ~h
+m,]g Z /
];z F]g Z kZ1(KZ Z`

x h
+m,~ Zg: Z b

~g ?77g~V2c*
g
X 4V2c*
g ` M6,
wZ ZyZceZQ xi
) Z {
!*
q
- 4,
Y 
/ZwkZQ /
!*
`zy


]Z|yZ *
c 6, `zy


vZ g @]|gzZi0vZ]|~ zg
Xn{ M6,
wJ=&}7r+Z ~yZQc*
gzZ}g Z

m yZ ;g | 7,{z wZ Z X x Zce *
* Zz t kZQ /
2012ag ( 558) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

V Zz ~
/Z ~ w `zy

+
G ?
c*

g L c*

c*

g sZ L
: )
c*

gL
c*
g+Z B`q CZ Z
ZP %KZ {zgzZV e
$Z
t
c*

g
L x7X 6, Z yZ kZ Z Z CB (
c*
g
C ( w) sZ c*
c*

g~ sZ}Y
H{> ? ,Z3,
z @*
gZ
!3V; <
L I Zy

M X
Q c*
gzZ @*
c*
q
-Z bZ !*

Q c*
gzZ
a
c*
gZ
H!*
z[)a
}oT Xnj] ne ]L
{7Z
c*
g sZmY wZ Z
/Z ? ;g Y H Z
i Z6, ? [z
?g Y7$dHV6,
V2c*
g
*
@Y0) wZtmv 2 Y Zzx|]~v!*
`g /
C **
0*
<Lo! ]g Z~<mX 7c*
q OZ kZx Z#

F6,Zg Z]
F
/Z
H7}t~ mf6,
zZ }X **
6,Zg Z:
vZ -wgkZgzZvZ
c*
g OX Cxi ^
,Y s:
) ZgzZ ZxkZ
: Z% M z w_ c*
>

!*
~ Z Z {z {Zp
~ ] 6,s ZZ zm
~m T,7?+Z6,
} LZ xi6,
]Z| Zz?t X e
$g/
-ZaxsZgC
q
Zz Y 0*
~h
+]
.gztX +h
+]
.X: Zz ng
t(sZxOX @*
Y c*
0*
: }~ sZf TD 8
-DL+Z
X C
c*
gw 7c*
0*
<{z kZ Z Z
c*
gF
F6,Zg Z7]!*
E
E

Zi Z ~
_vZ z {
}
D
yV- >Z
kZgzZ p~ ( 2m ) B Z G
( apg +gzZ ) Sgz na+ #
Z
c*
g {zL L:
#agZ kZgzZ B
bg xsZ y g Z x Z n
ZgzZ
)
Z xE
gzZnC{ bCN Zw B
bg x rZ ...Sgg gzZh
c*
X
x Z6,g "
$* zmvZ - {z
c*
g Z
}gt gzZ zg Z',
x ZgzZZ G` G
5kZ [
0Z) bZX 7 {z }: x ZugZt
c*
g
G-!
C 6 hZx Z ~
X Cyg mmbkZ]Z|+ E
gz
Z C! ]g Z q)Zg&#
{zC
Y 1y wZ ~t
/Z /
X N 0*
g Z ! ]g Z
x gz {7c*
0*
<{z kZ Z

X E
g: [Zg Z { 7 Z
EB 5 , IBZc*
t ? kZ ^
,Y**
`zy


s V2c*
g{F
F6,Zg ZQ
L /
2012ag ( 559) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

V ZxV;z6, e
$g/gzZ Yy e
$Z q
-Z M%Z L~ w
/Z ,n

M M LZ {za
KkZx ZgzZ w LZgzZ Y 6,V e
$Z
&5BkZgzZ ) Yc*
7y s <
L zy M

L BZ kZ~
x Zg Zg ( ~ y 0*
M M 6, Zz; Mg6,QZg6,g
s `zy


aJ
-Sizg
c*
g kZ A
$ ;g^ ` M 6g (z VV
X Y Mx {{CsZ L
B: )Zc*
gx Zz%)Zg ZtwZ kZQ /
gD .kZ G
@*
ZLax
c*
g:
0}
/Z3 Z Z}
.X e Y
gzZ y*zy ._kZoG @*
ZLX mZ e:
C
c*
g sZ~ y*zy L@*

7qe
$Z ZLV ~ VyZY,IsZ) G Zc*
g sZ 0
+Z
X Zc*
gsZ: )Zc*
gx J
-uF,
gz ~Z c*
X
sZ)
c*
g { %V y

M Cx]!*
t `zy

+
G/
%KZ]5Z LZ(y
/Z tVrZikZ ! $

kZq ? a sZ]5 yZ ]i YZ Z ' Vi W
V 6,%Z
&
8g6,wZ.kZaKt2 zG
g" V 6, wZ ZO X C 7? sZ%Z kZ iZ

{zq *
@Yc*
!*
yZ6,
~zg<]5 zY Z
]5x v+wZ kZX Kg (Z~ 0
+
iZ %KZ y bzg

4c*
g
H1zGd
$ztVYY:~]5(1 @*
YHwJ6,
g.~
Z V c*
X xsZx **
iZ'B M ~ Y6,gZy ~]5
sZ ]!*
X z1% Z}
C
.7c*
<._{z kZ Z Z{ Zg Z
qg
Q x **
Zuz <iV
/ZY7? 2 zGkZ~
? H]gzzwZaxg
{Zg ( 1) : 6,VzGz)lck
,
is `zy

]Z|yZ|g
Vg Z y Z Y a gzZ ~ V2c*
g{ c*
sZ ]g Z Zz
`zy


+
GX e**
~h M Y wZ ZyZ V2c*
g{Z HI `zy


s
n
~gZZ)z4c*
g: Zg Ztu ( 2)X ` Zz~zzt2 zGkZ
Xg!*
* !*

8
2012ag ( 560) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

n
[Z : ,
^Y *
* `z

ys V{,
6 Y ` uz r m ( 3.3
- rgzZ V L `zy
J


g Z} Z LZ?
gzZxq
-Z `zy

+
Gx H}g ,
i LO x Z}z ? L{],
Z c[Z y Z Zz
/ZX z
i{g (Z~ zg b]q
L Zz!*
tpX
Hi~[Z1ZZ Z}gLzZ
~A kZ+
G7 ~ kZX B
bg 7w { c*
i Zg ~ Z
q
-Z
yZ6, ? h #z
/{z1 q hZg7 Zg KZgzZ Z
#{z
/
ce
87Z x"
$U*
6,Zg KZ n
pgg + {z
/ZX M
h7t
gzZ <
L zy M
LiF
F6,Zg ~ Z ~ ZZ KZ ZX gb~g7 ])
Xce**
m,
/

ZegzZ!*
LZg#{z
/
~wq]g{ lZ F,
t?h
+'
q
-Z c "
$U*
i~ {
$) X s ` u ~t<
4E
r
#

0*
zZ ' q
-Z ? E
0G
L it
? kZ X ( ZC
~ a xsZ~q)L L Ly*m{g 2011=Z)x
gz VgzZgg
/
gz Vy ~]q { Zn
~gz t
7X bi%z~g 6,
/F
k] n]:e
$M M
axq
-Z G
Vz]sgzZs
{ y Z Qf
ey ` ugzZx ZK
M F,
kZyZi Z0
+Z m
~ **
?Hy

M Zzt
~` ugz zV[i7 +b
~ Zz t
` u QaN @*
X M x
c*
gq
-Z {!*
~qgz wJ+
GgzZZz%Z 6(Z
/Z ?**
**
Y Mx
c*
gq
-Z {!*
V2c*
g ~g egzZ]=ZsZ HgZc*
gc*
sZVgt V
` u6,x kZ ? [ M qi M gz kZy

M ?Z7i M gz x
:**
g (Z3 Zgq
-Z ]Z| Zz?t
ayZ 't1 )7sZ}uZc*
g {Bs Z Z |kZ c*/
( X ;g Y^
,Y**
`zy


s yZ ~h M ZY
g x sZ%L7Z ~ ]gkZ X
LZc*
gt ,t c*/
X } 7,
**
~zgY wZ ZgzZ<
L zy M

( gwEZ~ b Z t ) _ ZLyZ~ zg YuLZQ c*

gzZ /
X ~]q{p$
0i Zzzi~ ~ ,

ts:~]q {7Z tx

YuLkZ+
G|g
2012ag ( 561) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

w)
c*
g 0*
ce *
*g ZZ6, H kZy 0*
ce **
q Z (,
?H ; gzV[Z 0
c*
gZ
# O axsZ ( yZ
:ce bEu,
F7Z Z ]g ]*
* vgz Z Y }4z.
] ! zZ z `z

y ( 3 .4
G
4
&
GG3BG
~I
~&a "
$U* z `zy

gzZ q
-Z +
G6,x kZ
Ec*
t b ]!*
6,s tgzZ f
eg (Z ( pragmatism)
a0#
Z g Za } t s: 4z]
.! zZ [ "
$U*
[!*
m]**
vgzZ VzZ
+t [Z Z ? kZX g "
$U*
{ yv
QX 7 { c*
i Zg ~ Z q
-Z # 6, y Z Zb Z:
CY{Z
+ p `q
-Z q
-Z @*
i yvgzZ}Z
+L
gzZ}Z
+ `LZ+
G bTX 0*
gZ
y vg Z`}uz e
6,
C }X q heZ Vzuz bZ!*
q hyv
D V [!*
{ e
$. }wZtgzZ @*
B ZgZL~}wZ *
*
g ( {)z ]F,

z ]c*
gzz Y<) Zx 7q
-Z
z
X @*
~gz
CY 3Y Vzg ZD
~]U*
q R,
izgC
a @*
c_t ,n
}
zk
,
i ]U*
q R,
)g fy kZXce
akg gu{ c*
i { c*
i Z
kZ]Z| Zzy Zb0
+
i
KZi (Zp YYc*
6,
R
Z @*
{gzU: ~C
*aX,n
pgt K
H6,
CkZ ZX gt $
Y 7i%z~g 6,Uq
-Z
z D
Ic*
{Ze U*
&
p YYH s %ZdT @*
%Z ~ Zq
-Zwq
H
t `zy

+
G}X n: $i kZ {z
/ Y 1 CZit
/ZX ZZ"zgu
jkZOgyZtg0
+Z4z]
.~g/puF,
4z]
.! zZy Zp
Zpt X Vz
Z wz
Z w,Z Z{Zg6,kZX .
xsZ{z
bkZ
/Z XgZpZwY~~g M |
# gwA +Z
?Y7zguZ Yg {gzZ { Ze`zy


+
G6,

C
E
G
4
&
7
GG3BG
/F
$ H g ~I
4E
Zz 4z]
.~g/z k& Z Z6,wZ E
0G
EG
~Zzg : y+Z Vx~wqZ)**
yZy

M ?YYc*
VZ76,
]k
~g xsZ ~1]Zg!*
[f]k~g/zk&ZZ6,
LyZ YYtO?
2012ag ( 562) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

-Zh
q
+
a!Zi Z kZ c*
yvgT~ 4c*
g@0#
Z
:tP~]**
v4z]
.~g/zk& Z X ~
Xg Z)f % J e~
! fxsZ r z
Z~, Z /
3 C S]g ~i f +Z #
Z y**
Z ~Z~kZ /
X 7
X 0*
gZ
x **
Zuz 4z]
.t 4z]
.sZ~4z]
.kZ /
X g0=g f +F,
Z ~x : Zg Ztu@V 4z]
.t /
X
Hc*
~4z]
.kZ Z
Z)U**
gzZ e
$.#
Z/
H Z9~ +Z]ksZ ( ` M 4z]
.kZ 6,E ~ /
X 7{Zg 7Z M T
~[ZVZ F,
x ZZ nkZgzZ x ZZ { c*
i ?|g?t `zy


+
G
E
.
{. 3E

:Ky]%e
$.J Z Z
L yZ|g @*
:
Y H{g
Z9zZs X4z]
.! zZz ~ L L

V igzZ CZ Zg 7*
* `zy

s V Zx CgzZ ~ ~0
+
zZ}
.{Zg
:tq
-ZP~V!yZX
X*
*{C
b ~i!*
bx ZZ ~g z Z/ ( 1
X **
Z (,

A &gzZ
VzZz+@W{],
Z ( 2

X*
*yZ]!*
. {iZ0
_
+ZgzZbzVCqgz (3

VZVg { **
g (Ztzg (Z ~I]] zZ~}g !*
VZzg ~ ( 4
Xg Z2Z6,
yZ gmikZ V ZvgzZVg Z z g EZa! x4z]
.KZ ( 5

Kq }VZzggVzH~ 6,
ZXn {g:g Z
',zV~ %

X @*
7,R%

]c*
gzZ~z* V B; e
$z]+@We
$Z V ( 6
X **
Yw'~
!

Oo1% V v4z]
.KZgzZ **
g D V- {z
/ ~ : M ( 7
X 'x x LZ}g Z
V
!*
g 6,
wZ&

+
$Y vZ6,Y XgZ klvzxsZ]Zz]c*
It| (,
(8
X*
*g(Z ~zgN~yZ CZ F,
Z
2012ag ( 563) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

{z @*
Z(,p Z 7,*
* o V!gzZ ])+Z~ ZZ t |

X + Z
/}zg U*M pOi**
V!yZ

yZ7tkZpVZy

q !*
`g~]k! zZz~
gt
: V- gz$+Z
/ZX H,
zb & Z yZx Yc*
uF,
4z]
.kZ6,
} 7,**
CZtzg #]k ~g Q Y ^
,Y *
*#]k! zZ z +@W
m{ B V~ s +Z VZy


v F{z yZgzZ9 z Z ~ yZY
]kC z Y 5 V{ Y f kg Z w]kz )
7
?BweW
Lx }g tH X 2~yZ {)z
**
z! x~T CY._z} i Z0
+Zo Z4z]
.C
g c*
]!*
tQ
C
!*
4z]
.L**
(]**
kZ yZ ZX D',
Z',~ wV Zz 4z]
.L]**
kZ
wLw 4Z ~ KkZgzZ @*
x V Zz 4z]
.p 7q
-c*
Z
Z }g Z Z z
gzZ ]Xk0*

kZ YyY6,g4{ c*
i {z
/Zz `zy


Yce **
Y
@*
7{g izg 4 ]**
kZ **
z! xQX YHwEZkZ
~d
$
t|X YY c*
{i Z0
+Zq= ZkZ4z]
.:gzZ
E
H
"
3 **
5G
z]qp`} HG3G
u
Z+**
~4z]
.i M Z
# BV+Z
X
Hg66,
u

+F,
g !Bz+Z]uZz
VzU!{g~ * 7 { N VL
z Dg6,yvgzZ VzZ
+Q
nq
-Z
/Z @*
Z e
$.p]Z &
+Ut ]zZ OX ( 8) C]gzg
/Ztc*

g}
7b~g7 ~h #Z ;g7~h}g b~g7L
'}g t
/Z c*
g} Y 7~
q F,
+Z g 74~ h}g
$
|gzZX Le {z Ag} 7g i Z~h #LZ]q C
!*

g ~4z]
.! zZX C7,*
*s4z]
.~g e a% Z ]zZ t
] e
$ ZZ i KZ ZwJ g EZ 7 gzZ Z kZ
Z V X ( ) yvZ |ggzZ , } ?% Z e0
+
zg z
c*
g
x xsZ X 7c*
g Za Z Z'
~ { Zg gzZ xsZ f c*
Mt yvgzZ {Z
+
x tgzZ **
,@*
kZ0
+
i ~g7 ] x 6,Z
+5yZ 7 *
*
gZ
+5s
A ~gz Z *
*A
$%4z]
.! zZ z ~ a T e**
%K spg Z MZ x
X4z]
.k& Z
2012ag ( 564 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

]g z O {)z `zy


gzi ze
$.6,]!*
kZ + Zz ? !*
`g
gzZ [tZ O7 ~ kZ X 7[< @*
60
+Z YgzZ
O

L ce6gef M
t1 ~gzy kZ kZ~i
# ~T {zC
r
Z% kZgzZ i M pX ( 217 191>)X { k
Hz Z',~(,
hgzZ Z% kZ~ ]c*
M k
,
iX Y6,xsZgzZ xg 6,y ZZayZZ
zD 5 Zgw'V Zc*
gz}qgz ~ py Z *
*zDZg
]i YZ? rz
Jz~g $
+
**
0
+
iz ?ax Zw
}zg 2Z x ZwZz
CC rz
]zmwO} zL@i
ZgzZ{z
H !*
6,
c*
gz}T:X
Hc*
g i wj 0*
vZzu
~ F,
6, ( + )8{~xsZOX F,
Z **

gzZ z+t1 q M yY~ kZp

/Z
Hc*
~<zz
{ e
$zn ~y M
)=g f 8{
qgzX ( 193> : ~g Z
{n Z6,

c*
gz ]e
$ ZZ sZ T x : Zg Ztu
Z (,

X ^
,YiZ **
CZinC
~]qa8{kZ Z 3g
xsZ
L CY 7V- sz@*
q
-Z s z `zy

: Le ZxsZ ( 3.5
Z erz
kZ)g f ZsgzZ LeZx ~wqC
tgzZ <
Z|g
M gzZ ~g ZZ) ZY !*
SG
54XZ$
+Ztt Xc
e buF,
4z]
.F
F6,
@*
q Zgmq
-Z 0
+
ix C
7e(universal conception of peace)g
IZ t X
0
+
ix q
-ZtZX **
Yc*
0*
s %Z~zt zzT
z t aX Y` @*
t yZ Zpt yZ
x {z g Z

Z@*
7h!
x Z Z }X : Z]
.]Zg Z Z s %Z~
~ V/}uz X 7
8 ~ sA~g u!
._b Z Z
YgzZ Z K Z Z }
/zb

iZ ( #
w!) wZ Tx w_
*
w_+ zzn
g~g ZZ)z MZgzZK:b ~
CkZX 9
C
~ zg ( )z #
ww z y Y]i YZ 5Z Z ]Z ~ ZZ }) t { Z
ugz
w zyYs Z { `sZX g D .iYzsZ
z p wj Zz Z6,~igz s vZzux p
q
-Z t 7D
} 7,b z
8Z c*
Zg sJ zZ kZp q kZp }) 0*
y
2012ag ( 565 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

~uz {zsZ < Zx:X C7 Z

Dt

c*
g w_C
X ( {)z
**
**
z pt { <s ZY 7x
/
Z {6,
C
C
ngZ Yz|g *
***
zp (QZg })v t{z<X
Y
zZZZ $

c*
gsZ f zDtC
X @*
g~}%i
ZX Y 7Z : (Z J
-Z
# X Y
c*
g sZ
c*
g C Z
#
X e
g74z]
.! zZxZq
-Z x ZY f~eZx~]q{
` ( t{z e)
c*
gC
* xsZtzGV Zz ( 9) t
x **
t ZwZgzZZ
+5PxsZ~wyZ c*
X *
* Z
ggZ zgzZZ6,a
kZX @*
: q Z <
Z vxsZ @*
n
/ZpX Y~ 0
+
ix C

Zz ~ ZZBB]Z]Z Z
+5~T gzZ 0
+
ix q
-ZpxsZs ',
~7t~~}g !*
LZ xsZQX 2Z zx Z 0 ]5x 0
+
i
HB}g7 {z H (the truth)/Z Lp{z V hq
-Z ~ h]Zg
x z '
{z}2 ! xz >+
M
KZ q ~ZgzZ h',x Zs
&Zzpgf C
]!*
t( 153:x Z ;8519:yZ/w M )X 5 Zg~ !*
',z n
~z)~ 0
+
i KZ LVz yZ }Z
/!*
& gzZ h Tr Z 9 *
g Y yZt +vZ H @*
Z
Z',Z',
K
7Z :gzZ 7w
2 !*
!*

V h~ s}t aLZB]~g7 {z sq
-Z
kZkZp5 Zg~ !*
',z3
!*
]gzZ ! x 3 Zg Zs
!*
x !*
Zz Y s ~ !*
',gzZ 3~} LZ D#} Z
xsZ Zz
/Z ?} Z
nC
nr z
yZ} hgts:3 Zg V
[0
+
i] }uz {zx LZ~ }ixsZ k
,
/**

't h
X}
{z X Y H
Z', eZQgzZ Y !*
0
+
i x q
-Z u Zu ]!*
t
~zc kZ hx {7 LZ
z Y y
KZ2Z ,
F q
-Z s
0
+
i: Zg Z z Z6,g0
+Z ] !*
}uzV Zz + LZ B1}
+Z ?}} hgzZ ~ Zi M ZQ &T y{z~*y

M X}
swgkZgzZvZkZ<Yp$
Y7 y
KZx q
-Z yZ z"
{z x{]!*
kZ b ] ]~g7 skZgzZ Ihp xsZ X Y ]g 
2012ag ( 566) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

Z i q
Z { V Zz + LZgzZ}c_ g ZM Zx CZ(y Z U ] }uz
g Z) wZt ~A kZX 7c*
D
rw z yY ~4z]
.kZ {z c*
M}g Z

X 7c*
qyzV)c*
7c*
,
Z',
4z]
.kZ ~g
<f z sgzZ Z ~ {kZ1 q sz Z xsZz
}g tk
,
i V Cz - t sz Z ~ xsZ X Cq
ZX 7!*
`xsZ {z M: lZy


ygzZg yEZ}g7 0
+
ig!*
zg
:c*

w
D Za
Zg!Z ])Z xi#*Va
-Zg~g Ztu {z wZ AzZ xsZ Z x ~ wqC
q
L~ w +X)
x **
x wR,
E c*
Z L
q~ w+y ZX T7q
-ZgzZ 4c*
gz C
kZ+t? Z6,jz4 !*
wZZ
L tw ZZY7 (Zq
zmvZ -g wZ AzZ xsZ Z ~ wqC
Zz
/Z M
h } 7[Z wZ
ce
8bhZX ( ?HVY6,
l}g Z
xiu*z!*

Zpg lW
8 sy
KZ {z~ZgzZ [Z { CZ 7Z {]zxsZ
X ( 10)
3ByjzyEZ+
M
KZ q ts Zx F
F6,4 !*
]z
s kZgt Zx C
X V: Fy gzZ YZg6,6,5 Zg
^ kq] ] n j :Z g Z~y M 6 0*
',
0#
ZaT
0*
',
ae
$Z@V#
Z+4{z~* ? L L ] `i ^e ^i
? L L:Zy ~ g
$uszcX ( 110 :yZ/w M ) X
zg ~$
+gzZ n ?
t} uzg y!*
i :
) , Z kZ} uzgB; Z A DZ', ~
)zgB; Z',
Zx g
$u X zg +F,
gz$ yZZt1Y Z', w Y:
{z c*
Bv X{c*
i Zg zz zg ZZ
yZZ
B;
/Z
Hxt DQX gI ^
,6,Zg ZZyZZV
Zg F,
[p [pyZZ YzqZ 7
A &1zg
+ Y Z', w L#
Z {z b]zv c*
X Lg |
X ~gZzg 1
zgB;1
L b6,
Zg
Z',
y!*
i
L VZ6,
zZ
~kZY:
ZZ" nq
-Z ?t : < b & Zz]xsZ ( 3.6
2012ag ( 5 67) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

]!*
kZX uZu CY Zgz!*
6,gVzUx vUq
-Z +

KZ =' ]!*
t p Z Vz ]~xsZ +7g Z
^z ]gzg Z z V] Z g Ta b &Z ] z 0
+
i

C 7{g Z Z 4c*
gz C (Z *X (structures and discipline)
4&xEXsZ kg Z 7HXn {g Zz 6,
6,{E
+ ZzY CV;z *
* J 7,G
0E
G
:
t
/Z *
@Y~gz*
*x ~q
-Z {)z]**
JZN*
~qkzg[
b & Z V+Zz bZ ) @*
b &Zz
kZC
X Y7^ {g Z Z L
z ~g Yx z b & Z Y C~g q
-Z
/Z X ( D**
) Z x gzZ6,yZ{

Z
ZgzZ}}g77yt H 7{g e%(
) Zx )apg ~g
]gzab &Z V C
?Y yZ b & Z %K
) Z
]4c*
g nC
V! C ]!*
t ? ~WV *
*6,V;z

/Z ?OgG e
$6,hIZ1]i YZ zD 5 ZghwEZ
V;z V{)z N*
]**
JZ ~q V\ MgzZ Vkgx *
4EZz
$tV Zz e+y

M X ;g7}(Z 1ce b EG
t U~&5V Zz ?t) ? ab & Z[ c*
J 7,
gZ
^
,Yz` nC
aM M f 1
L C^
,Y**
]=g &
+<f Lq
- 4,
yZ

( ! E
0*
EB 5 @*
g Z ( e
$ ZZ sZ zGt + Zz r Z6,ab & Z
yYZV

/Z w ]ksZ: F )X @*
Y zg lpg Z MZK
M F,
gzZ
Cg Z Z6,
g~gcDsZZ
# C
X ( Y lp
c*
gz{z
x g ZM Z sZ 7x e Z kZ Z
Z xi **
~ ~ 9
7 ~ kZ ?Y lpgkZgzZ YY Hs ~ 9/a
b & Z g Z MZ K
M F,c*
p g Z MZ K
M F,
b & Z kZ 1 x Z e
$. b & Z

x 6,ZjgzZ ( #
: )gZ M Z ~qgz :X 'x~g)
kZp Y b & Z ~ ZZ k
HH:t
/Z ]gzJo1%
kZ eXb &ZY Y` @*
kb & Zy

s !*
gzZ 7yvg Z MZ
~
sZX @*
g ez
q
-ZX @*
6,V-4c*
gzCy Z (facticity)CZzg Z
{Zg rz
e
$ ZZ sZgzZ} w$
+CZzceg Z M ZK
M F,
+Zarz
e
$ ZZ
2012ag ( 568) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

X}gzzgbq~
x w+Zt+Ph
+]
.gz :7*
*,
6] Zx + ( 3.7
B]qgzZ Zt @*
7**
6,] Z+g
z [r
# %Z n
*
* e 6,
) ,Z r
# gzZ b > 2i6,[ r
# }X @*

]q 6,yZ ] Z Z +n X 7n

C
) ,Z
<~g y7t < 7g i ]q
/ZOX ozBV
Xce*
* rZ6,
Z ,]i YZgT]q
L ,
6,V H7tqck
,
iY* !*
Km `zy


? kZ
]5 Z LZ 6,V H t 7c*
~gz *
*6,< ~g ~ ]qC

sp (facticity) ]q LZ ]!*
C
?7c*
~gz *
* L <.
*
*4z]
.C z k& Z 74z]
.! zZ s }I~gz)
/Z **
4z]
.
]!*
t 2 X *
* sp]q}z
yZY }I^
,Y**
]q ~p
/Z 7gzZ Zsp]qZ `zy


Zz !*
y xs `zy


?t
/Z ? ^
,Y**
?4z]
.! zZ ^
,Y4z]
.k& Za
wg zg? kZQXce **
Yc*
` M4z]
.k& Z+g D
+
CC
Q Y
_~ wj T\ MY 0*
gZ
4z]
.~g [Zy ZgzZ zmvZ -vZ
gB; 6,B; /LZ\ M Zt kZ :X : e*
*g Z
Z J
- V;z
!7 ]qY :Zuz L{zSg
g]!*

tX
Hc*
$iBn
tn
VtUgz$ Zuz ? kZ
nz e ]!*
kZ Y %Z7n
**
q
) , Z e
, hg **
Z Z e y}g
/Z @*
Za t wZOX gztn
5Z Z kZ 2 **

H ? H<~]qyZ ? [qt H , :x OZ nzkZ 2

6,yZ ggB; 6,B; qw
u
7 e Ly
/Z~]qyZ

E
.
5

%Z6,]!*
Z ?7c*
{ k
H
YY Hkx ]5ZvgzZ Z4z szH!*
X *
*nzyZ~xXtn
t
: e3 Ztap6,i Z4z]
.! zZ : ~gz$
e Za`z

y ( 3 .8
]i YZ `zy

n{z
/kZ A
$ ]gz `zy


- 4,
q
{z
/
/Z
L
H1
m kZ 7c*
*
* `zy

c*
M X
q: e
$ Z~ Z~(, ZJ
-Z
#7
2012ag ( 569) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

`zy


-
J
z kZY:qe
$ Z+ZJ
-Z
# gzZ }Z V 7{z
/
'
E
X o!E.-E
a`zy


$ Z~V/}uzX ^
e
,Y**
**

4
5
GZX ~
TEG


Y7
.Z6,
C? oG @*
ZLa`zy
:gzY7 ? +Z
/Z C]gz? ZgTakZ oL
) X 7R ~ sZ g Z
o]!*
6,
C ]z@*
gzZ ]
X ( :~ + ? z Z T *
*Z (Z ~ +
)$
+Z |g
r Zu okZ G @*
Zp H f ]**
kZ ! xgzZ ~g
oa`zy

xsZ
E
h
-G
X M7}~sZ Z#
Zy <XG
+]
.
] kZ @*
{z
/
gzZ
Z h 4z]
.C
]!*
$
+z Zq
-Zt
JZy
KDZ6,4z]
.C
Q Y **
: wZt
/ZX #kZx kZ: Z
:}X Z9
uF,
4z]
.(z x Zf **
~ 1857 /
Z VZxtnY f Le It HX HpsZ6,Rkg Z
? )4z]
.~g yZakZH: (ZVrZagzZ ce
8ZgZg
zCq
-Zab & Z #
ZDkCtZ
# + Zzpgg + bZ /
Vz ] %K qg sx Z qzx t {z ce qz
/
u
kZ H X qz._ ' LZ ( ~ ]g sZ ] c*
) ) }) x

?q:VYe
$ ZVg )
,
yZ,I^
,Y**
x t._wZ
{gZ Z CZ ~|
/Z{z ]gz2xEh
+]
.V @*
kCq
-Z /
? ]i YZx ZI (Z kZ H
8VZ Z
M F,
+]
h
.V
]gzJ b & Z b) C1 V Z kCt x ZfZ
# /
kZgzZ c*
Zzsg nt *6,g~g sZZc*
M ~
gi6,gLZ7Z
`
z kZy

M X Y f Zz4z]
.sZ ~g/wq]gX zF,
[p
?YV Zg4z]
.~g :gzqG @*
Z[ : VYtk
+ Z Y 1 y wZ 3 Zt
C
/ZO X $
Y 7 BVg " q kZ
NB)ts:x }g ~gz**
G @*
ZI qz4z]
.
x v+ Z
/Z X ( d**
J Zg:gzZ %: ) 0*
: qz nLx
5Zt:? I wZ kZ6,?`zy

7~gzG @*
Za qz
2012ag ( 570) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

C
!*
{z
/kZ Z kZ 7k0*
{z
/kZp qz4z]
. ]!*
&
Xce**
k0*
Z}uz
kZvZD WzgzZ kggz}i`zy


Yt6,ckZ e
W HX #gq
-Zt pX ~gz **
wq
Zg
yZ M
hi Z0
+Z W,
Z
yZ4z]
.H ?7q } Wz z kggz4z]
.~g/z ( C Yyt y
KZ
/Z ?K7A

$%]Z W,
Zn6,]iz ~VYZz M ~g gzZ#
Z {` u
|?D YK yVY J m

J (,Z]Z W,Z `zy

kZ Zz%Z 6gzZK
zz ]Z W,
Z F,
{ c*
i4z]
.! zZ i Y]Z| Zzpg uZg Z ]z ]c*
t
wZ kZ X Cq]Z W,
Z 0*
,
k
z x]k& ZD (spontaneous)
Xce**
o\zZzg$
+Za4z]
.k&Z oZg Za`zy


/Z ._

] Zz Y % kZ Z xiz
*
c ga ( 3.9
: ( 11) sZ)4z.
: *
@YH7]{^
,YkZ Z CYZC
]{?ts 4z]
.! zZ
X ,?akZ xi6,
y ZD7?t]Z| :]*
! /
# Zzx
Z
c*
gsZq
- 4,
yZ HD7?t]Z|Q :]*
!~uz /
Q c*
gzZ sZ V2c*
g: Zg Ztu{6,g c*
$Z y Z ?7c*
e

! zZa
c*
gy+, Z >X g Z
ZgzZ ~gz)x sZ
?7bx kZ}u Y MVYi Z 4z]
.
4Z~ zg =z V;
/Z ? Z
+o a H :]*
!~ /
?Y7?
Zzgg %Z zZ%1ZgzZ w
+1Z ]|~ g
$ q Z :]*
! a /
? HwyZ`g]c*
Zzg
i^m q ^] ^]:})f x ZVawy~g
$ qZ :]*
!,v*
0 /
w x ZZ
# tx|kZ ( @*
YHwy{gT# w J ex Z ]
gEZ c*
: x Z Z
#
H "
$U*
t kZXce *
* B kZ ;g p

E
N Y ( 5.Z 4z szH!*
%Z Y ,-
) ) w) ZgZ x Z

q)w x Z LZ gC wyB w x Z g
$ut |g ?
T {z @*
~Z x Zt g
$ut]!*
~uz ?Y 1;6,]q
y #
x Z L7x Z Lg
$uc*
X}g Z
wy {z: @*
YHwyB
2012ag ( 571) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

H #
Z V kZ;gx wJ e g EZ OV x ZC
X g
?b
8
Zx v + c*
m{a swZ e
$g_ Z H :]*
! /
**
6,gx 6) ~gz
/Z ? ~gz**
CZag Z
L7Z6,V- 9
: )L{z H g Z
x + LVc*
9+Z ) ~g H ( ce
g~ kz7,} ?X7Z
+ _ Z6,A gzZ {z < HQ ?N Y
gZ6, Zg7 _ Z y

M ?ai<._]5x HX {)z _ Z
? @*
Yc*
VYgzi
Zo
/Z ?Z c*
Mf
c*
g~K _ Z~} :]*
!, /
VrZ~ yj
jZ y] S7c*
C ~g7 ~ C
qgz ot H
?~
c*
g
C
H~]gkZ ZV x Z%ZY
/Z :]*
!,^ M /
-Z 6,zu 5Z'm 7V x oC
q
VY 7x) y Z #

?D Y 7yZxV x y ZxkZgzZ
c*
g

HH{z ngZ s ]ZV~y M
YZzQ :]*
!, /
#
H6,gZzV ;z
> 2i> [#
Z :,x g e{zqg Z MZ~}iZ Z

E
]i] ] ]^] ] o ` ] m]) 5.Z4zszH!*
%ZgzZx
Ky ~y M
Z
~
Cg et
c*
gsZX ( ] ]` ^e ]]
gzZ > [z > 2i[ Yw+Zt > 2iz > [
G b +
G e
$ M kZO

E
.
5

x
c*
gsZ x x t6,
V ZnzgzZ9

c*
g Z4zszH!*
%Z
Hx Z > [x 2N Y:y]
.)Z 7
c*
gsZaX xi*
*uF,
J
t6,
C
YuLBgzZ> 2i Z 7
c*
g Zzwz> 2iYY
&
}7w+Z
:gzZ H7nzZ K~l zmvZ-vZwg /GG
gzZ 46,
u
c*
gsZ 9
1zg Z',gzZ bViZ bZX > 2i
?w+Zt;g[VYX Yc*
uF,
VyZZ YYH Z Z~
E
@*
t:Z k Q @*
7t E
5$ ZwVc*
n
L 7
g It6,
x kZ
@*
*
*Be
$g]q{n
pgt QX @*
7UgzZ
}6,
C e LgzZ y
L t ` My

M @*
Za t wZX
]!*
x=tgzZ
2012ag ( 572) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

4G!
4G!gzZ G
?Y x)~gzZx~]5txzt~mG
7 :]*
/F
46,
uk
,
i
c*
g kZi+F,
Vzi 1y cg G
! , /
}u
c*
gsZZ
# t Hi
g V 7twZ1X **

gzZ_0g ! M c*
} F,
0
+
i
f~jw )
,Z {zc*

c*
gs~w\ M ?ce*
* H~wq]g+Z M F,
Z6,
#V Zz
tp C Za
D x , Z6,R4c*
g)Yce **
kZ ~gZ)f kZ

G
* Y ZgzZ<f p]Z &
+
c*
g
/Z, Z {zX bq
-Z~ kZY7T
$i
sp#
~ ]g+Z G ?Y H HQ q x CgzZgzvZ
! zZ ( 2) i~g/Z6,( 1) : *
*g (Ziq
-Z ~za kZgzZce 4z]
.
Y~g Z MZx : ZgZtu
( ~g/Y e**
~p
c*
g jXi
]Zx7Zypz ]6,R4c*
g){z iZuz
H{g[ZX x **
Zuz
X Dz]k~ @*
g
/

Y7 b kZ ~g Z)f kZ
c*
g~A :]*
!,g H
/
:}XN Y] r + Y16
,
A C
g Z jkZ
/Z
]ggzZ yZZ" ga p:7
/Zp x
c*
g*
* Z
w z yYV ( 1)
Hx V; }g ) ,nz Kgcf

$Z6,{ w z yY KZ vgzZgp
yVi eg PV Z KgcFc Z x
?)tH (
6, yZ H X J
-OVi eg ti FgzZa ^ JJ
-V 3z
D
+ X LZ VzZ e {z Z'x V H ?Y^
,Y**
Kgcf
$Z6,
?,Q DlZziZaZ kzgk& ZVzfZ:7yZZ" sO
c*

g x Y ,x a._] Z]5V bZ ( 2)
)g fVz:6,Rkg ZgzZ6,gY f~ hg46,
ut
c*
gZ
# p ~g Z)f
Fzz X ~g Y} : )g fg ikZ Y
X c*
x Zux t
Y ,x ~y 0*
s M ^g*4Y ZgZx Zy
HtwZX Mt
?, qz*
*lVz.
q
-Za~zckZ],
Z)lax
# p} Z #
Z
Z
# DC
]Zx > 2ix V ]!*
t ( 3)
> 2i Z
ZD h Z > 2i V
)gzZ ? kZ H }: (Z
c*
g
?,qz**
kZ Z x kZg M ! Yb
2012ag ( 573) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

,K Z
# x
? sZ Hx wK L{ VzKgzZ gzZ ( 4)
D6,VzK{!*
Y Hw EZa ~
VzK B~ Zi M ?
Zr
#
# ~g Zgi ,K~g yH X @*
Y H6,VI 6,x **
VzK
?,sgzi Zg 6,
eZ > [
OjVLZ Z
# x q
-Zt ]!*
X $
Y 7BVgzZ kZ
~ gzZ @*
wq60
+Z Za VZy

V **
V~ kZ @*
Y H j}uz
p
~ ]gO v Z6,kZ Xce
8k6,Z 4z]
.]k
:nZ V Zz O
c*
g
/Z 9x =pce *
*Oh
e m
N Yg66,h
e mLZ Z
Z }C 1 yZ 0*
xKZt s
x **
0
+
i
KZX 7x ~ : ?QgzZ B VZy

T
(kZ CV Znq
-Zg ~wZ
# X Co~t:gzZ7
~gz Y Z nq
-Z ]
KZ @*
7(Z X g i V Z ~uz
4c*
gwj Vc r z
gzZsZ bT:X CY~hg
#
Zz q bZ Hx OZ kZ6,Rkg Z z]
.) Y f Yxzn46,
u
kZ)g f~9~ gzZVE!*
wV" KZxsZ+@WYx s M

X g {0
+
i ZxsZ} Zgzg r Zl


Ug.P:g Z ]sZ ( 4
D7]P6,wZkZ [ZX W6,Zz i Z`zy


~qgz~ y*k
,
i
6,e} (,
gkZ 2 $
"
$U*
gz M',4z]
.]k Zz x xsZ q z
yZK] sf ~ zg y*t
# IX C M 7VY]sZz!*
x ~g Y
:Y[Z
4z]
.0*
',~0#
Z~[ZkZgzZx : ZgZtuZgz {v /
B.
z w 4z]
.k& Z4z]
.~ {z n
pg7uZg Z
g e
$!
gzZ j
c*
g~p Kt]!*
ZX ]}uzq
-ZVzt|g
8jq
-Z : ]gzJo1%~ : MVgzZVhx yZgzZ+
6,VV
c*
ggzZ}
x : Zg Ztuce
8yYX uF,
}g Z
x
gzZ w]sZ K e
$ ZZ sZt gzZ g u',
B xsZ
" axsZ Z~[Zg EZ: ZgZtuJ
-[ZX Le b w$
+ e
$g/sZ
2012ag ( 574 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

: YY6,
Vg eg Zg x XN0*
',
]kg
yZX rz
z e
$ ZZ sZgzZDxEsZs@~
CyZ :'
gzZg X 1
X {{gzZgK}g Z Z ~
C
]c*
Zzg RgzZ rz
zx PZ ]sZ~
CyZ :gzZ X 2
X DZ ZgZ~~ ;g !*
zg w'gzZ rz
zD
~
) Zx { ZgtgzZ x z b & Z6,sZ
c*
g`yZ : ! zZ X 3
X V;Zp~p
R~j V ZkZgzZg EZtgzZ
c*
gsZzyN~
/
%yZ :+@W X 4
Zx V2c*
gsZ Za Z'
.
;V!CgzZg u',6,
X g Z

{z
/ {Z tZgx t X ]k+VzZy


#
Z q ]kzZ wzZ
t ~gz$~
Cq
-Z~ VyZ%ZX sz^@!~x LZ LZBmZ}g7
} b & ZgzZs Z]
.Z]
.~ pyZ ( s
c*
gz}
) x Vt
gzZ
c*
gybZm!*
x
c*
gy g)gzZY 5Y f{zx
x sX 7 Zz sxk!*
k0*
X g) {zx
x LZ
) )gzZ {z
/sZC
X
H{g0~g/c*
wyx
c*
ggzZszV
/sZ}uz
yxgy Z w gZz dZ kZgzZ (substitute) w x {z
x }uzx ~VyZgzZ (complementarity)}uzq
-Zm
-Z c*
q
qzx 6 c*
hgjq
-Z ]gzZX 7qE~gZZ 6,
x
7
) ) 5+Z c*
Y~
) ) ~uz hgx
]gzZX @*
e
$x /x Vo) ~ ZZZv:ZY}
y)g LZ} xi]!*
kZ {z
/C
X Za o ng Z~x ]k {
VZ {Z
+ VzUm ZgzZ uZ ZByZgzZ y Zg]k ~uz
',Z',x {z
/
}uz:x ituZ Z~Vz
/sZJ
-Z
# X g6,
3 4z]
.! zZ Y H7o1%B }uz q
-Z x gzZ Y ~ : Z
X g Zg Zx (three dimensional)
x Y~\zZyz 6) 7*
*sp IyZx `zy


~gz { /
`u
:gzZ C7
c*
g ~g/Y *
*~p4c*
g}g7 ( sZ
2012ag ( 575 ) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

TY 0*
',4z]
.! zZ +Z ~gz ZX @*
e*
*z~}g Z Z q
-Z
g ZM Z Z
ZgzZ Vzg Z Z { ~ Z
ZgzZ Vzg Z Z w ( #
: )g Z MZ
7zJ
-wys `zy


Zx kZX n M: ~p&p: (ZJ
-Z
# X **

) Z w
) Z kZ
c*
X *
*x (state within state)
zg~g gzZ]qT Y M
z wy~`zy


@*
7i `zy

iwy
X *
*~
bhZZ { ^
,Y |q
-g !*
x {{z xiaVzZ Z /
x 1 Y ` @*M {n Zuz}n q
-Zv ]gzX o1%6,gW,
4z]
.KZ @*
~ #
~ Vr c*
yZ+( ` ~ y 0*
M
hN
X7
X VV wqx
x {s[zZ x **
~y 7RC4z]
.! zZ /
@*
*
*x OZ r z
z i ZkZgzZ *
*y
) Zx w @*
7*
*{ nZ c*
**
yv
]kY ]gzJo1%x CZB]kk& ZVzZzzX
~ p9}}g t |X k

) !*
rz
gzZ i Z gZ M Z ~ kZ x Z
x Z ~ Ze
$Zug Z MZ sZ J
- R ]kk& Z ]ksZ ZL
N Y0zi !*
z
gzZyZg]k! zZ
/Zy)g ]kk&ZyZX $
}x Zu
B ]kk&Z yZ ZX Y ~g Zi~ V Z-Z T $
Y ]+Z
$
d
d
$
*
*q ~p4c*
ggZG 0*
gzZ ~(,a ]k! zZ% CZtzg uZ Z
X e**
VzgZ Z 4c*
g6,gzice
8yY]kk& Z Zzx xsZ q /
x q J
-Z
# X *
*o1%B]k! zZx LZ 7Z 7e*
*
X Y`@*
i{],
Z b & ZY7]o1%x j
c*
Za & 6,

C )yxg LZ6,
V}uzq
-Z]ksZ /
x } (, q
-Z

tce
8t O Z c*
~gz)x }uz
~g Yx k
,
~(, ( 12) (Zt X g} x Zux VZ
OW6,
x }uz~wq]g+ZXC
!*
'
q
-Z **
Zg7 Zg7&
J
-A
$V 7x LgLg
tJ
-Z
# ce Z ex { LZ{z
/z C

*
*k
,
: e! xV; \vZ0: 73 k
k
,

/ZgzZX M 7t k
,

2012ag ( 576) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

!*
ze
$., ZwVmZ c*
X 'gzZ bwZ ezCZBm}g7~kZ 7
~ l
,g Z- x v V ~g Yx ]g qy
gzZ
}uz c*
w }uzx LZ {z
/
~ y Z
C
/ZX sz^~ {)z zgz8
-ggzZx
l
]g q
/Z ?n ]g qt > }Z Z~gz)x
sZ 3g: w ]c*
gzVzgz'
Zz ~9,g Z- ]g q Vzgz'
Zz
c*
) )

q
-Z ]g qt : ?n Y ~9 b]g qy2Z x 0
+
ix
X
7! Z
bZ wZ Z { c*
igzZ L~V ZLy Z bTce
8tQ
-Z x [zZ sZ X Z) wZ
@*
z *L yZ
a Z (process) q
g C? gzZ g D `xq
-Z k
,
/**

x (institutions) Vzg Z Z
~g z ~g Y gzZ g D]5 LZ v g @*

g wq
7HX 7wZ Z gzZ Z { c*
i c*
gzZ ~ yZX x
z
t X g
\!*
V V
M F,
{ E
+ ZyVjZV ;z *
*x Z
# ~}
C 1 kZgzZ **
z 0*
(4c*
g szy[ rz
] ZZ ~
Z)wZ gzZVX CYzBq
-Z6,
{)z nzx OZ
oa
Vo)

L tnYY H qzx ZuzQ Yu
%c*
xq
-Z L

) )q
-Z
/ZX7zx}uzzxq
-Z gzZ
6,Vo)
x
weVZ+ VrZg M6,tC
tzzkZ 1
X x CZ;ztV}uz\ M c*
t\ M VrZbkZgzZ 3g
) )q

-Z CY| (,zz kZ ]gzuZ Z yxgsZ ]k /

(Z :gzZ B
bg :
A & zi !*
gzi LZ x Zg + ~ x : Zg Ztu
4 Tce *
/G
*zZgzZ $
x zs
) )C
X $
3
pkZ G
x }uz
) ) kZ Hg akZ Z
Z LZgzZ H i Z0
+Z m6,g]g @*
}x Zux zgz8
-g {zOgyZt (,q
-Z\ M , ZtX g
p
) )C
@*
Vo) wq b Z
ZX H7g cx kZp kZC

x ZuZ K
M F,
m{z ]{g (ZkZgzZ Ccx mq
-Z
{z~ ~i ^KZY7x b & Z x Z+@WOX Cg z@a
[ppakZ VM,x Zuz x t'7Za ]g 'ax kZ
2012ag ( 577) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

.
**
-Z t '7VY wy{z {t Vr: bZ X H (specialize) g
q
6,R!*
gzZi Z Zx {z%Z
 HgakZpVrZY Zp
g ZM Z sZ Zz
pg)@*
n
]g '~ WJ
- (grassroot level) KgzZg Zi !*
XM
h7
/
x t+@WY exg Dx 7Z:X
C
M kZpg7U*
CZ~J
-Kx Zk&Z O
4Zz MK X 7C
Kx Z{zn
pg M L17k0*
y Z
K Tg D#x ZkZ Zz MgzZ @*
Y{g]!*
~g Zy
Kt
/Z ?@*
7 cg KZ c*
y M **

Zzg0
+ZK Lx xsZ HX D M
x bVz yZ
/Z ? $
Y ]XN Y Zz Y MKgzZ Zz
t ]!*
? gz Xw2> N Y0} Vo) Vz g Vo) Zz
X 7]gzhgx CZA e
$x }uz *
* bkZx CZ CZ

} h/~g 6
z0{@',
kZX H: 1J 7,g
$u0
+
i ~g {k
,
1Z]|
C
d {k
,
1Z
C
L {t 6
z 0{ LHp;J 7,: g
$u1 M g Z6,
\ M wg {
L wt {k
,
1Z c*
C
7@*
L Lg @*
hu
hu0 kZgzZ /~g {k
,
1Zt Z ?
C
rg7 g
$u
zmvZ -! wgXg bZ g
$uDa+ 6
z0{gzZg D
{Z kZ ` M : X 0*
e
$Z@ z q nZ T# Vzg * /}L L : s
X ]gzJh
e$/
T{z ce: g Z x ZY f Zz 2xEsZ~ kgZ bZ /
$ XgzdsZ
4E
Z (, Zt Zz Y H ~ ~,gzZ Hp~]gZ KZE
0G
V: pxEsZ
/ZpN Y[x! zZzk& ZX 0*
: =x h
+
&
Y f|gX g: !*

C}upggzZ ` ._g qg
4c*
g
gzZz'_g ZzY m
CZYN
46,
ugzZ Zg #
Z6,f C
L{zkZ x Z
X6,
V0
+4Z { c*
i
n
tJ m

h ( m] o `n)uY m
CZ
V- wVkZX gzi H e 7Zz Z Z nt ,: (Z {zJ
-Z
#
YE"

z ~
~,ZX 1
B; ~g Z)f ` VzZ e1( 5Ge) b~g7 !*
D{za1 nzzg Z Zza~g FV| (,
M v{ ZpP
!*
z:h#6,x kZC
DJ
-Z
# X ` Zg ZQ c*
gzZ, ` {zc*
akZ7C

2012ag ( 578) m] )x

 `zy


XgzZwV2c*
g{

tugzZ C
wVY f:X N Y : VY {Zp e e**
Zg
#
Z) xz ] Y fgzZ 3g ~KZ#
Z T !*
z{zx : Zg Z
yZy{z
/Z gm,
?` Bm}g7 ._KZ KZ # VZp
6 kZQX 7gz ` !*
z IZ xg qg
gzZ+ Y M ~
mvZ - Z V J
-
z kZ , 7x Zu{z9
t +g ZJ
-Z
# ce xg c*

Z kZ 3ggpVrZ6,TDxEsZzg !*
fyZn
z
X n: Zg7( 4 !*
4c*
gzCyZ)
X [Zh!*
DZvZz~ ZB

:Zj

GG3J4X3
y*Z z e
$. r
# ~gZ Zh
+zY Z e aK
c*
g x : Zg Ztu ( 1
X x sZ c*
$g/L L[!
e
c*

g: Zg Ztuw_L L

&
/GaK|V2c*
+
h
G
gsZx **
Z',
gzZi ZzzyZt
Vg/: Z% MgzZw_ ( 2

X Future of Freedom [ c*
i

~]g @* V2 c*
g{ gzZ sZ L Ly* Zg a s
# zyZ ( 3

X x sZ c*
$g/L L[ ! : i Z
e
y*szZ Zg a} ^
,Y kZ ~ ]xsZ 2 s
# z -QZg ( 4
$ 4z]
GG3E
4G

.sZg0
+Z
c*
g ~g/2X 2009_)x { ^
,Y] Z ~wZZh
+]
.L L

&
[! { ^
,Y ~W 4z]
.sZ 0*
',~ kZ gzZ e
$g/L Ly*Zg /GG a K
X xsZ c*
$g/L L
e

4 ]k! zZ ( 5
/G
7Cc*
zdt w t Y fz + Zzpg
x3,
}g G
Xttqg Z ( ^
,Y**
) ]!*
.V z~yZ **
_
x Zs V Zxno

6,RkgZ {g ) ~ 9( x Zf~ ]q m ~,Z bTY

z! zZ~~,bZ!*
Z ( [xv:ZgzZ ) Cc*
zd{pxEsZ

X~ Z Cc*
z~gq
-Z **
gzi ]k~
A
$kI e
$Zzgx d
$
X Y
K>gM0Z 256 > >gk
,

0Z } ( 6
`

X 1 Z%kZ+

c*
7xV t} YHt
G~]5Vz6,t
+
M %Z ( 7

X {)zYw wZZyZ :gzZ Y

~ ]DZgzZ L Ly*LZ r
# +Zwq6, yvgzZVzZ
+ ( 8
2012ag ( 579) m] )x



XgzZwV2c*
g{
`zy
&
X {~
.ZZNtX 2011c @*
p Z)x /GG
c{
X
H1 ~g Z ZzggxsZ L Ly*xj%~z**
Nt ( 9

c*
gw_ [% } L kZ +! fw_|g `zy

+
G ( 10

Z ; CZ
Z~z)K
C
{zgzZ C Tolerant aZgzZg ZY)~A
~A Y !*
-Z6,g~
q
Ct Xce **
Z]]_sZ Vh~g/V
F,
!*
6,]Zgvx gmq
-Z
c*
g ~g/w_tUX 7etzg ~g ZY)

x It ~V/}uzX ~z)] Zgx gt ~ Zi Mg{zgzZ C

3Z xq
x Z L
L g C G
5E
-Z p]Z &
+ 7tzg ~g ZY) ~z)]Zg

'tX C0*
c*

g ~g2 ~g/w_ rz
gzZDgZgzZ
**
~z)]Zg
c*
g ~g/w_
]Zg7Zst~{],
Z LZY d
$
q
-Z C
c*
g tolerant
E
$ z ]Zz)]Zgx )gLZkZ C
GG34G
x ,ZgzZ : x (
Z',
0
@]=g &
+yZ V b ~ F,
',kZF,
!*
VRe x >
eq
-Z ]Zg
c*

g ~g/w_~A |gX Zz ~g 6,#

y]w VT

VzY
c*
g I C ( g Z Zzg **
) intolerant gzZ ( {Z tZg ) dogmatic Z
E
$ ]Zgx g c*
GG34G

[pX g7Zzg4 !*
bx ]ZgLZ
(matured)1ZtXg Z
Z Zg( 4 !*
u) ~ Zi M ~z) 7~g ZY)

] mgzZ CY M
6,]Zgx 4 !*
hkZ
KZ { Zg Z~ V2c*
g ~g/
-ZgL Lg Z( Q})m\ M ~V2c*
q
g+ZX CY{g0] gzZq
-Z b

6,Vh}uz g Z
/0
+
igzZ]Zgx vZ1 M
h ( Practice) ?6, h
X ~igzs QZg*
* (Z M
h7]!*

]DZ gzZ L Ly*2011c @*

p Z)x ] [Z kZ ( 11

X Kq

X {q ]DZgzZ L Ly*r
# +Zw qwVt ( 12

2012ag ( 580) m] )x