Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
I: Shoulder Dystocia
ob Cobbo, M.D.
tiabetb ate,, M.D.
0ojecl|ves
At the end of this chapter participants will be able to:
1. List the risk factors for shoulder dystocia.
2. Utilise a systematic approach to managing a shoulder dystocia using the
HELPERR mnemonic.
3. Demonstrate appropriate manoeuvres to reduce a shoulder dystocia using a
maternal-fetal mannequin.
lrlroducl|or
All in the delivery suite are tired yet exhilarated; the long process of birth is soon to
be completed. After two hours of pushing, the infants head squeezes over the
perineum and you wait for the shoulders to restitute and birth, but there is no
movement. You attempt to facilitate the birth of the anterior shoulder with gentle
assistance, but the head appears to be retracting back into the birth canal. The
anterior shoulder is stuck, impeded by the pubic bone of his mothers pelvis. You
realise that you are dealing with a shoulder dystocia. The atmosphere in the room
changes from one of excitement and anticipation to one filled with confusion, anxiety
and fear. A focused calm approach to this emergency is needed. It is essential that
you perform the manoeuvres to free the impaction skilfully, and that you direct
assisting caregivers efforts effectively.
0efinition
Shoulder dystocia is defined as impaction of the anterior shoulder against the
maternal symphysis pubis after the fetal head has birthed, and occurs when the
bisacromial diameter (breadth of the shoulders) exceeds the diameter of the pelvic
inlet. Attempts to standardise this somewhat subjective definition have referred to
head-to-body time intervals of equal to, or more than, 60 seconds, or the use of any
ancillary procedures to effect birth as criteria for making this diagnosis.
1,2
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
2
lncidence
The overall incidence of shoulder dystocia varies based on fetal weight, occurring in
0.3 to one percent of infants with a birth weight of 2500 to 4000 grams, and
increasing to five to seven percent in infants weighing 4000 to 4500 grams. Over 50
percent of shoulder dystocias occur in the normal birth weight fetus and are
unanticipated.
Risk Factors
A number of antenatal and intrapartum factors have been associated with an
increased incidence of encountering a shoulder dystocia. Associated antenatal
factors include prior shoulder dystocia, gestational diabetes, post-dates pregnancy,
macrosomia, short stature, and abnormal pelvic anatomy. Intrapartum warning signs
that should signal a potential shoulder dystocia are protracted active phase of the
first stage of labour, prolonged second stage with head bobbing, and use of forceps
or vacuum to effect delivery.
Operative vaginal deliveries with either vacuum or forceps carry a significant risk for
subsequent shoulder dystocia. The fetus is normally in a position of flexion and
shoulder adduction while in the birth canal. As the instrument is placed on the fetal
vertex and traction instituted, the vertex is pulled away from the body causing the
neck to elongate and the shoulder to abduct. This produces an increased bisacromial
diameter or in a sense, wider shoulders making shoulder entrapment by the
maternal symphysis pubis more likely. Vacuum and forceps deliveries increase the
risk of a brachial plexus injury to odds ratio 2.7 (95 percent CI 2.4 to 3.1) and 3.4
percent (95 percent CI 2.7 to 4.3) respectively.
5
(Category C)
There is not enough evidence to evaluate the use of symphysis-fundal height
measurements for predicting macrosomia.
2
(Category C) Unfortunately, ultrasound is
a poor predictor of birth weight in diabetic or non-diabetic pregnancies complicated
by macrosomia.
4,9
(Category C) Based on existing evidence, routine late pregnancy
ultrasound in low risk or unselected populations does not confer benefit for mother or
baby.
4
(Category A)
Voro|d|ly ard Vorla||ly
Soft tissue injuries are the most common maternal complication, with increased rates
of third and fourth degree extension or tear, and subsequent potential for
rectovaginal fistula formation. Post-partum haemorrhage due to uterine atony or birth
canal trauma is also more common. Symphyseal diastasis and uterine rupture occur
rarely, although symphyseal separation and transient femoral neuropathy have been
associated with the McRoberts manoeuvre.
6
(Category C).
Among the most common fetal complications of shoulder dystocia are brachial plexus
palsies, occurring in seven to 20 percent of infants whose births were diagnosed with
shoulder dystocia. Nearly all recover within six to 12 months, with only one to two
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
3
percent risking permanent injury. Erbs palsy is the more common, involving C5-6
nerve roots. Klumpkes palsy involves C8-T1 and is less common. Although shoulder
dystocia is commonly blamed for these palsies, in-utero positioning of the fetus may
contribute to their aetiology.
7
Clavicular and humeral fractures are additional potential injuries associated with
shoulder dystocia. Fractures of the clavicle typically heal without complication, but
may be associated with injury to lung and underlying vascular structures. Fractures of
the humerus typically heal without deformity.
Fetal hypoxia is a serious potential complication and can result in permanent
neurological damage or even death if there are significant delays in reduction of the
impacted shoulder and birth of the fetus. Once the fetal head has birthed, it must be
assumed that the umbilical cord is compressed between the fetal body and the
mothers pelvis. During this time, the fetal pH will drop by an estimated .04 per minute
until the condition is corrected. In a non-compromised fetus with an uncomplicated
labour course, it will take seven minutes for the cord pH to decline from a normal of
7.25 to a danger level of 6.97. Resuscitation of these neonates becomes increasingly
difficult, as persistent fetal circulation becomes more common.
Preverl|or
The literature provides no clear evidence to recommend the use of elective
caesarean delivery for the prevention of shoulder dystocia in women at risk. Analytic
decision models have estimated that 3,695 elective caesarean deliveries would be
needed to prevent one permanent brachial plexus injury among non-diabetic women
with an estimated fetal weight greater than 4500 grams.
9
A policy of routine
caesarean delivery for all infants with macrosomia would result in at least a five to six
fold increase in caesarean rate in this group of women. Spontaneous vaginal birth
should be expected for most babies who are estimated antenatally to be
macrosomic, but anticipatory management during labour should be carefully
organised.
Maintenance of good glycaemic control for diabetic women has demonstrated a
reduction in fetal birth weight, which may translate into lower shoulder dystocia and
brachial plexus palsy rates. While women with insulin-requiring gestational diabetes
have a lower incidence of macrosomia when induction of labour at term is performed,
this did not reduce the risk of maternal or neonatal morbidity from shoulder
dystocia.
10
(Category B) Induction of labour for suspected fetal macrosomia in non-
diabetic women also does not appear to alter the risk of maternal or neonatal
morbidity.
11
(Category A)
When shoulder dystocia is anticipated, based on risk factor review, a simple, easy
and effective method of preventing shoulder dystocia is the head and shoulder
manoeuvre to deliver through until the anterior shoulder is visible. This is
accomplished by continuing the momentum of the birth of the fetal head until the
shoulder is visible, without waiting for restitution and rotation of the head.
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
4
Varagererl
Anticipation:
If antenatal or intrapartum risk factors suggest that a shoulder dystocia may be
encountered, many tasks can be accomplished in advance of the birth, through
anticipation and preparation. Key personnel can be called prior to birth and placed on
alert. The woman and her family should be educated about the possibility of a
potentially difficult birth, and can be shown what they may be asked to do in that
event. The womans bladder can be emptied and the room cleared of any
unnecessary clutter, to make room for additional personnel and equipment. A bedpan
should be available to raise the maternal pelvis if stirrups are not available.
Delivering through until the anterior shoulder is visible may be helpful in women
with known shoulder dystocia risk factors.
0n-site Assistance
Once shoulder dystocia is diagnosed, the presence of additional assistants in the
birth suite is critical. One person is responsible for recording of events, obtaining
designated equipment and supplies, and notifying the clinician of time intervals.
Documentation of the manoeuvres used and the duration of each manoeuvre may be
valuable to prompt the clinician to move on to other manoeuvres, rather than
persisting in one that is not working.
Additional 8ack-up
A pre-arranged plan should identify members of a team ready to respond to this
emergency. This team may include a general practitioner or an obstetrician, a
paediatrician or neonatologist, one or two midwives to assist with manoeuvres, and a
special care nursery nurse. At least one other provider with maternity or neonatal
skills should be called immediately when a shoulder dystocia is encountered. In large
centres this may be a neonatologist, while at smaller hospitals this may be a GP,
paediatrician or obstetrician. In some rural areas, this individual can be an
emergency room physician or a GP/DMO who comes in from the surgery or home.
An anaesthetist should be called in order to administer medications as needed. A
ward clerk or hospital operator should be available and prepared to assist in
summoning appropriate individuals to the birth suite. This may involve developing a
priority list of individuals to contact, and may be accomplished in part through a
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
5
Reduction Manoeuvres
Shoulder dystocia becomes obvious after the head emerges and then retracts up
against the perineum, commonly referred to as the turtle sign. Excessive force must
not be applied to the fetal head or neck, and fundal pressure must be avoided. These
activities are unlikely to free the impaction and may cause fetal and maternal injury
while wasting valuable time. If standard levels of traction do not relieve the shoulder
dystocia, the clinician must quickly move to other manoeuvres to aid in birth of the
fetus. The family should be notified of the diagnosis and the staff asked to summon
other personnel.
The clinician attending the birth should direct the activities of the personnel in the
room, much like running a cardiopulmonary arrest code. It is important that other
personnel listen to the directions being given and all act in a team-like fashion to
address this emergency. An individual recording the events should keep time.
Awareness of time duration is essential so that, if one manoeuvre is not successful
after a reasonable amount of time, another manoeuvre can be attempted.
The HELPERR mnemonic is a clinical tool that can provide maternity care providers
with a structured framework in which to deal with an extremely difficult and charged
situation. Although there is no indication that any one of these techniques are
superior to another, together they represent a valuable tool to help clinicians take
effective steps in relieving the impacted shoulder.
14
(Category C) The steps need not
always be done in the same order as the mnemonic suggests; it is more critical that
they be employed efficiently and appropriately. Thirty to 60 seconds is recommended
as the appropriate amount of time to spend on each manoeuvre. Although three to
five minutes may seem like a brief window of time in which to act, it is adequate for
following all of the manoeuvres described in the HELPERR mnemonic. These
manoeuvres are designed to do one of three things:
Increase the functional size of the bony pelvis.
Decrease the bisacromial diameter.
Change the relationship of the bisacromial diameter within the bony pelvis.
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
P - 3uprapubic Pressure
An assistant should attempt external manual suprapubic pressure for approximately
30 to 60 seconds while the delivering clinician continues gentle traction. The
suprapubic hand should be placed over the fetus anterior shoulder, applying
pressure in a CPR style in such a way that the shoulder will adduct or collapse
anteriorly and pass under the symphysis. The pressure should be applied from the
side of the mother that will allow the heel of the assistants hand to move in a
downward and lateral motion on the posterior aspect of the fetus shoulder. The
delivering clinician should direct the assistant as to the correct direction and to the
effectiveness of the effort. Initially, the pressure can be continuous, but if birth is not
accomplished, a rocking motion is recommended to dislodge the shoulder from
behind the pubic symphysis. If this procedure fails, the next procedure should be
immediately attempted. Fundal pressure is never appropriate and only serves to
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
7
worsen the impaction, potentially injuring the fetus or mother. For the same reason,
the woman should not be asked to push until the shoulder has been released.
HELPERR
mnemonic. The Rubin II manoeuvre consists of inserting the fingers of one
hand vaginally behind the anterior fetal shoulder and pushing the shoulder
toward the fetus chest. Rubin makes the point that this pressure will adduct,
or collapse, the fetus shoulder girdle, reducing its diameter. The ALSO
recommended method refers to pressure behind the anterior shoulder as
Rubin II, and is the basis for the first part of the ENTER component of the
HELPERR mnemonic. The McRoberts manoeuvre can still be applied during
this manoeuvre, and may help facilitate its success.
2. If this is unsuccessful, the Woods Screw manoeuvre can be combined with
the Rubin II manoeuvre. First described by Dr. C. E. Woods in 1943, this
manoeuvre calls for the provider to use the opposite hand to approach the
posterior shoulder from the front of the fetus, and rotate the shoulder toward
the symphysis in the same direction as with the Rubin II manoeuvre.
17
Thus, in
this combination, the provider now has two fingers behind the anterior
shoulder, and two fingers of the other hand in front of the posterior shoulder.
The Rubin II manoeuvre adducts or flexes either the anterior or posterior
shoulder while the Woods screw manoeuvre abducts or extends the posterior
shoulder. This is why the combination of the two manoeuvres may be more
successful than the Woods Screw alone. With this movement, the infants
shoulders rotate and birth much like the turning of a threaded screw. The
Woods Screw manoeuvre frequently requires a large episiotomy to provide
room for posterior manipulation, while the Rubin II manoeuvre generally does
not.
18
3. If the Rubin or Woods manoeuvres fail, the Reverse Woods Screw
manoeuvre may be tried. In this manoeuvre, the fingers of the entering hand
are placed on the posterior shoulder from behind and the attempt is to rotate
the fetus in the opposite direction as the Woods Screw manoeuvre. The
Reverse Woods Screw manoeuvre is identical to the Rubin II manoeuvre
when performed on the posterior shoulder. This rotates the fetal shoulders out
of the impacted position and into an oblique plane from which they can birth.
Much confusion has occurred regarding these manoeuvres, and even leading
obstetric texts have described them differently.
18
These manoeuvres can be very
difficult to perform, particularly when the anterior shoulder is partially wedged
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
8
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
9
position. Some tips are to remember to always go with gravity first, thus provide
gentle traction downward to birth the shoulder closest to the ceiling first. Performing a
few normal births in this position, before encountering an acute need to do so, may
assist the provider in being prepared for more emergent situations.
The order in which these manoeuvres are attempted may be flexible. However, a
logical progression of various efforts is essential to allow adequate time for each one
to potentially accomplish birth. The suggested length of time for each manoeuvre is
meant only as a guideline. Clinical judgment should always guide the progression of
procedures used.
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
10
3urrary
Shoulder dystocia is a relatively common and dangerous event, but it is difficult to
predict. Almost 50 percent of shoulder dystocias have no antecedent factors.
Anticipation and preparation are key to successful management. In those women
with risk factors, the maternity provider should use the head and shoulder
manoeuvre to continue the momentum and allow the fetus to deliver through until
the anterior shoulder is birthed (rather than waiting for restitution and rotation of the
head to occur). An institutional plan is recommended, in which each member of the
team has an assigned duty. The recommended management of shoulder dystocia is
based on the mnemonic HELPERR, which provides a memory guide and a
structured framework for action which is useful in this crisis. The elements of the
HELPERR mnemonic are all effective, and they should be tried in a logical and calm
sequence. Practice on the mannequin is an essential aid to clinicians who are likely
to encounter this obstetric emergency. The time allotted to each manoeuvre, and the
exact sequence, are best determined by the clinical circumstances and the clinicians
best judgment.
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
11
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
12
3. Jorrslore F0, Prescoll RJ, 3lee| JV, el a|. C||r|ca| ard u|lrasourd pred|cl|or ol racrosor|a |r d|aoel|c pregrarcy. 8r J
0oslel 0yreco| 199;103:Z1Z. (Leve| lll)
1 8r|c|er L, Ne||sor JP. Roul|re u|lrasourd |r |ale pregrarcy (aller 21 Wee|s geslal|or) (Cocrrare Rev|eW). lr: Tne
0ocnrane l|orary, lssue 2, 2000. 0xlord: updale 3ollWare. (Leve| l)
5. 0||oerl wV, Neso|ll T3, 0ar|e|sor 8. Assoc|aled Faclors |r 111 cases ol oracr|a| p|exus |rjury. 0oslel 0yreco| 1999
Apr;93(1):53-10. (Leve| lll)
. 0rerrar R8, el a|, 3yrprysea| separal|or ard lrars|erl lerora| reuropalry assoc|aled W|lr lre VcRooerl's
rareuver. ArJ0o0yr, Varcr 1998;1Z8:09-10. (Leve| lll)
Z. 0rerrar R8; 0oodW|r TV. 3rou|der 0ysloc|a; Curr 0p|r 0oslel 0yreco| 0ec, 1998;10():159-3. (Leve| lll)
8. 0rerrar R8, 0uzor|ar J0, 0oodW|r TV. 0oslelr|ca| Vareuvers lor srou|der dysloc|a ard assoc|aled lela| roro|d|ly.
Ar J 0oslel 0yreco|, Jure 1998;1Z8():112-1130. (Leve| lll)
9. Rouse 0J, 0Wer J. 0o|deroerg RL, C||ver 3P. Tre ellecl|veress ard cosls ol e|ecl|ve cesarear de||very lor lela|
racrosor|a d|agrosed oy u|lrasourd. JAVA 199;2Z:1180-. (Leve| lll)
10. 8ou|va|r V, 3lar C, lr|or 0. E|ecl|ve de||very |r d|aoel|c pregrarl Worer (Cocrrare Rev|eW). lr: Tne 0ocnrane
l|orary, lssue 2, 2000. 0xlord: updale 3ollWare. (Leve| l)
11. lr|or 0, 8ou|va|r V. lrducl|or ol |aoour lor suspecled lela| racrosor|a (Cocrrare Rev|eW). lr: Tne 0ocnrane l|orary,
lssue 2, 2000. 0xlord: updale 3ollWare. (Leve| l)
12. Corer 8F, el. a|. Tre |rc|derce ard sever|ly ol srou|der dysloc|a corre|ales W|lr a sorograpr|c reasurererl ol
asyrrelry |r pal|erls W|lr d|aoeles. 1999;1:19Z-201 (Leve| lll)
13. verspyc| E, 0oll|rel F. le||ol VF, el. A|. NeWoorr srou|der dysloc|a W|dlr: a prospecl|ve sludy ol 2222 corsecul|ve
reasurererls. 8r J 0oslel 0yreco| 1999;10:589-93. (Leve| lll)
11. Arer|car Co||ege ol 0oslelr|c|ars ard 0yreco|og|sls. 3rou|der dysloc|a. AC00 Pracl|ce Pallerrs 0clooer, 199Z;(Z):1-
Z. (Leve| lll)
15. VcFar|ard el a|, Per|rala| 0ulcore ard lre lype ol rareuvers |r srou|der dysloc|a. lrl Jourra| 0yreco| 0oslel 55;219-
21,199. (Leve| lll)
1. 0rerrar el a|. Tre VcRooerls Vareuver lor a||ev|al|or ol srou|der dysloc|a; roW successlu| |s |l. Ar J ol 0oslel
0yreco| 199Z;1Z;5-1199Z. (Leve| lll)
1Z. woods CE. A pr|rc|p|e ol prys|cs as app||cao|e lo srou|der de||very Ar J 0oslel 0yreco| 1913;15:Z9. (Leve| lll)
18. Rarsey P3, el a|. 3rou|der dysloc|a: Rolal|ora| rareuvers rev|s|led. J Reprod Ved 2000;15:85-88. (Leve| lll)
19. 8rurer J, el a|. A|| lours rareuver lor reduc|rg srou|der dysloc|a dur|rg |aoor. Jourra| ol Reproducl|ve Ved|c|re;
1998;13;5:139-112. (Leve| lll)
20. 8ore|| u ard Ferdslror l. A pe|v|relr|c relrod lor lre assessrerl ol pe|v|c ro|dao|||ly. Acla Rad|o| 195Za;1Z:35-3Z0.
(Leve| lll)
21. Veerar AL, 0as||r lV, lurl P, el a|. A reW (o|d) rareuver lor lre raragererl ol srou|der dysloc|a. J Far Pracl
1991;32;25-29. (Leve| lll)
22. 0oodW|r TV, el. a|. Calaslropr|c srou|der dysloc|a ard erergercy syrprys|olory. Ar J 0oslel 0yreco|
199Z;1ZZ:13-1. (Leve| lll)
23. Cr|crlor 0, 3eedal EK. Tre lecrr|que ol syrprys|olory. 3 Alr|car Ved J 193;3Z:22Z-31. (Leve| lll)
21. Varagererl ol |aoor ard de||very corp||cal|ors. (|r) 0oug|as-3lrorre 0peral|ve 0oslelr|cs, 5lr Ed|l|or. Zuspar FP,
0u||||gar EJ (eds.) App|elor ard Large. NorWa||,Correcl|cul. Pages 33Z-8, 1988. (Leve| lll)
25. 0'3raugrressy VJ, lyslerolory lac|||lal|or ol lre vag|ra| de||very ol lre posler|or arr |r a case ol severe srou|der
dysloc|a, 0oslel 0yreco| 0cl 1998;92(1 Pl 2):93-5. (Leve| lll)
l: 3rou|der 0ysloc|a
13
Rubin II
Rubin II + Wood Screw
Reverse Wood Screw
If no rotation occurs, continue
Rubin II and add Wood Screw
Use fingers of the opposite hand
to apply pressure to the front of
the posterior shoulder**
This can help rotation in the same
direction as Rubin II
If shoulders now move into the
oblique attempt delivery
If unsuccessful try to rotate
through 180 degrees to deliver
If LOT/LOL, insert index &
middle fingers of right hand
through introitus at 5 oclock*
Swing fingers up & apply
pressure with fingertips from
behind the anterior shoulder
++
If shoulders move into the
oblique diameter attempt
delivery
If rotation in that direction cannot
be achieved change to Reverse
Wood Screw
Slide fingers down to the back of
the posterior shoulder***
Apply pressure to rotate in the
opposite direction
Attempt delivery if shoulders
move into the oblique
If unsuccessful, continue rotation
through 180 degrees to deliver
DIAGRAM OI 1HL LN1LR' MANOLUVRLS IOR SHOULDLR DYS1OCIA
(using LO1/LOL' position as an example)
(RLMLMBLR: Rubin I = Suprapubic pressure)
**
*
Remove hand on
side of fetal face
If ROT/ROL, insert fingers
of LEFT hand at 7 oclock
***
ALL ATTEMPTS AT ROTATION SHOULD BE COMPLETED WITHIN 1-2 MINUTES
(This page created by Mr Kim Hinshaw MRCOG)
IF UNSUCCESSFUL - MOVE ON TO OTHER MANOEUVRES
++