Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
SOCIALIST ACTION
- home page
The Newspaper
- newspaper - email list - subscribe - distribute
The Politics
- what we stand for - socialism 101 - resolutions - marxist theory - reading list
The Group
- campaigns - resources - pamphlets - contact us - how to join - our history - donate - our constitution - fourth international - youth group - en espanol - links
involvement in the war. At the same time workers councils, or Soviets, were springing up throughout Russia as revolutionary enthusiasm and dissatisfaction with Kerensky grew. The existence of these soviets amounted to a situation of dual power, where the workers and their institutions existed alongside the capitalist government of Kerensky. Within these soviets, different left groups put forward their perspectives. The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, and which Trotsky had joined, put forth the call for all power to the soviets and went on a campaign to convince the workers to finish the revolution by making it a socialist revolution. Trotsky was elected president of the Petrograd Soviet, and the Bolsheviks won a majority of the delegates to the soviets. The soviets then simply voted to replace the Kerensky government and a delegation was sent to inform him of the fact. This was the October Revolution. It was certainly a genuine workers revolution, and not a coup, and it would be pretty hard to imagine a much more democratic scenario. What followed after the revolution was an inspiring blossoming of revolutionary sentiment and enthusiasm. Soviets spread to hundreds of factories, towns and rural regions like prairie fire. Housewives formed soviets, as did passengers on trains while en route! Once in power the Bolsheviks redistributed the land to the peasants, granted self-determination to all oppressed nationalities within Russia, legalized abortion and divorce, eliminated all anti-gay legislation, established a government monopoly of foreign trade and set up public day care center, laundries and cafeterias to free women from the home. They also got Russia out of the war, much to the horror of their former allies. The capitalist worlds reaction to the Russian workers was swift and decisive. 21 capitalist countries invaded, and massive aid was pumped into the White armies being formed by the recently deposed Russian feudalists and capitalists. The Bolsheviks responded by organizing the Red Army, which under Trotskys leadership successfully defeated the counter-revolution. The price though was staggering. Many of the workers who made the revolution died in the fighting, the countries industry was in ruins and the countryside was on the verge of starvation (there were reports of cannibalism in some regions). Lenin and the Bolsheviks had expected the revolution to spread, and while indeed there were numerous workers uprisings and revolutions in Europe after the Russian revolution, all were repressed leaving the Bolsheviks alone in a hostile world. It was under the immense pressure of this situation that a bureaucracy began to develop in Russia. Opportunists began joining the Bolshevik party in droves, and czarist engineers and technicians agreed to help rebuild the country at a price. To make matters worse, Lenin suffered a series of debilitating strokes at this time, and by early 1924 was dead. Stalin, whose social base was the emerging state and party bureaucracy, made a bid for power and successfully usurped political power from the workers. Trotsky, who resisted Stalin by organizing the Left Opposition, was defeated and expelled from the party, and then forced into exile (he was eventually murdered by a Stalinist agent who drove an ice pick into his skull).
Stalins seizure of power had devastating consequences. Any hope of a revival of soviet power was squelched, and as a result of his theory of socialism in one country, international revolution was sold down the river to secure a peaceful coexistence with capitalism. Much of the international communist movement soon became pawns parroting the Kremlins foreign policy, whatever it may be. Trotsky, while in exile, analyzed the degeneration in his book The Revolution Betrayed. In it he developed his theory of the degenerated workers state. In essence his theory holds that the Russian revolution resulted in a post-capitalist society on the road to socialism, but its development was arrested by the development of the parasitic Stalinist bureaucracy. Trotsky predicted this very unstable and contradictory state of affairs would have to be solved by the workers overthrowing the bureaucracy and putting the country back on the road to socialism, or else the counter-revolutionary bureaucracy would in time attempt to restore capitalism (as they are openly trying to do today). He pointed however, that despite the degeneration of the revolution there were still gains of the revolution that remained such as social ownership of the means of production, a planned economy and a monopoly of foreign trade, and as a result workers and socialists are duty bound to defend it against capitalism. It should be treated in the same way as a corrupt union, its still a union, and any housecleaning can only be done by the workers themselves. In summary then, to the answer to the question of was Russia socialist, wed have to say no, Russia did indeed have a real working class revolution, and was on the road to socialism, but it was prevented from getting there. It is a task of the future for the revolution to be completed in Russia, and beyond that, to expand the revolution to the whole world. It is only then that all of us will finally be able to live in a world that is based on solidarity, and that is free of exploitation, oppression and alienation.