Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Batterman/Quenette/Voss 1/22
NATURAL GAS
BQV Lab MARQUETTE UNIVERSITY DEBATE INSTITUTE 2008 Updated: 7/28/08
***AFFIRMATIVE ANSWERS***
( ) Disad turns case—flaring most important internal link to the Greenhouse Effect.
GAO ‘4
[―Natural Gas Flaring and Venting: Opportunities to Improve Data and Reduce Emissions‖ 2004 www.gao.gov/new.items/04809.pdf// ]
Although gas is sometimes flared or vented because it has too little economic value to justify its capture, flaring
or venting this gas into the atmosphere
has an environmental cost. In general, flaring emits carbon dioxide, while venting releases methane. 3 These and other chemical
compounds found in the earth‘s atmosphere create a greenhouse effect. Under normal conditions, when sunlight strikes the earth‘s surface, some of it is reflected
back towards space as infrared radiation or heat. Greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane impede this reflection by
trapping heat in the atmosphere. Methane is 23 times more potent than carbon dioxide in its ability to warm the
atmosphere. While these gases occur naturally on earth and are emitted into the atmosphere, the expanded industrialization of the world over the last 150 years has
increased the amount of emissions from human activity (known as anthropogenic emissions) beyond the level that the earth‘s natural processes can handle. Scientists generally
agree that these increased greenhouse gases are contributing to global warming, which can have detrimental effects on the
climate. In general, the environmental costs of flaring and venting are not borne by the responsible parties because there are no restrictions on greenhouse gas emissions.
However, nations have proposed international agreements to limit greenhouse gas emissions, including those released during flaring and venting.
( ) Soil degradation and roofing corrosion prove flaring causes acid rain.
IRIN ‘5
[UN Integrated Regional Information Network. ―Gas Flaring Wrecking Delta Communities‖ 4 April 2005. Lexis//MUDI—JV]
Civil society groups in the Niger Delta region have warned that the
government is destroying communities' health and Nigeria's environment by
flouting laws against gas flaring, a technique used in oil production. For decades gas flaring has been used to separate crude oil from the associated gases that are
extracted with it, but Nigeria flares more gas today than any nation in the world after Russia, even though it is only the world's eighth largest oil producer. In most other countries the
excess gas has been harnessed to generate power, but about 50 communities in the oil producing Niger Delta region have had to put up with gas flares burning continuously for decades.
Bari-ara Kpalap from the Nigerian non-governmental organisation (NGO) Movement for the Survival of the Ogoni People, which is based in the Delta and represents a large ethnic group
oil and gas flaring had caused devastating pollution for the region's farming communities. "The pollution is making
there, said
agricultural harvests very poor," he told IRIN. "That in turn has affected the well-being of these communities. Many families are
not able to provide for themselves. Communities say gas flares contribute to acid rain. "Even the roofs of the homes are corroded,"
Isaac Osuoka of the NGO Social Action in the Delta's capital, Port Harcourt, told IRIN. "Iron sheeting is the most common form of roofing in rural areas,
and in a year or two, it is completely destroyed because of corrosion."
No Link (1/1)
( ) No link—other nations will buy excess natural gas, preventing flares.
Energy Trader ‘8
[―Goldman: LNG Demand to Bolster US Gas Prices‖ 20 June 2008. http://www.globalspec.com/engnews/source?f=958&s=7&p=1]
Voracious demand in South Korea and Spain will keep liquefied natural gas deliveries to the US low, which is bullish for domestic gas
prices, analysts at Goldman Sachs said late Wednesday. Analysts Samantha Dart and Jeffery Currie predict that Henry Hub prices will average $12.80/MMBtu over the summer and peak
at $13.80/MMBtu this winter before falling back to $10/MMBtu next June as Asia and Europe pull provide strong competition for LNG supply. "The
higher-than-expected
increase in LNG demand from Asia and Europe in the first quarter of 2008 was met by higher-than-expected LNG supplies
in the market, likely motivated by high spot LNG prices in the period and lower-than-expected North American LNG
imports," Dart said. "Both Mexico and the United States showed declines in LNG imports earlier this year relative to our
expectations." Goldman Sach's bottom line is that increased international demand for gas will bolster US prices as LNG deliveries will no longer help meet US
demand, which they still expect will increase despite a slower economy.
( ) Terrorist attacks against LNG tankers have the destructive force of a nuclear war
Reynolds ‘4
[Mark. Energy Writer, the Providence Journal. ―Lloyd‘s Exec Likens LNG Attack to Nuclear Explosion‖ 21 Sept 04. www.energybulletin.net/node/2202]
A terrorist attack on an LNG tanker "would have the force of a small nuclear explosion," according to the chairman of Lloyd's, a British insurer
of natural gas port facilities like the ones being proposed in Fall River and Providence. The assertion, which is contested by industry experts, was in a speech that the chairman, Peter
Levene, delivered last night to business leaders in Houston. Levene described Texas as a "state at risk" and said that securing its remote oil facilities is a "particular
challenge.""Gas carriers too, whether at sea or in ports, make obvious targets," said Levene. "Specialists reckon that a terrorist attack on an LNG tanker
would have the force of a small nuclear explosion." Levene did not name the specialists in his remarks, although a text of his speech contains a footnote. The footnote attributes the
observation to the author of an article posted, in an abbreviated form, on the Web site of Jane's Terrorism and Security Monitor in July. The same abstract, apparently authored by the
same person, Dr. J.C.K. Daly, was also posted on the Internet weblog Talk Show American. Levene also did not specify Texas LNG port facilities and tanker ships that might be at risk.
Records kept by federal regulators show that several LNG port facilities have been proposed in Texas. They do not show any existing facilities. Levene's company, Lloyd's, is the world's
second-largest commercial insurer. The chairman could not be reached for comment yesterday. Some
critics of the proposal in Fall River have spoken in apocalyptic
terms of potential LNG disasters. But to date, no official reports by government regulators have made comparisons between the various LNG catastrophes that
experts have hypothesized and destruction from an atomic bomb. One report does describe hypothetical fires that might
erupt if gas leaks from a tanker in its liquid form changes into a gaseous form and ignites when it comes into contact with a
flame. In one instance, the blaze, in less than a minute, would be capable of inflicting third-degree burns a little less than a
mile away.