Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
32
1540-7977/09/$25.002009 IEEE
july/august 2009
BRAN
D X PIC TURES
By Bradford Roberts
M
july/august 2009
MAKING ELECTRICITY GRIDS SMARTER AND MODERNIZING THEM SO that they can accept large amounts of renewable energy resources are fairly universally accepted as steps necessary to achieve a clean and secure electric power industry. The best way to achieve this goal is a topic of debate among power system designers. Although energy storage in utility grids has existed for many decades, the impact of storage in future grids is receiving more attention than ever from system designers, grid operations and regulators. The amount of storage in a grid and its value is also a subject of debate. Understanding the leading storage technologies and how they can affect grid operations is an important rst step in this assessment.
33
System Ratings Installed Systems as of November 2008 100 PSH 10 Discharge Time (h) Li-lon 1 Ni-MH 0.1 FW 0.01 0.001 0.0001 0.001 Na-S EDLC VR Zn-Br Ni-Cd L/A Na-S CAES
0.1
100
1,000
10,000
power plants dominate, with approximately 100 GW in service around the globe. In general terms, power applications would be storage systems rated for one hour or less, and energy applications would be for longer periods. The chart in Figure 2 shows the positioning of energy storage options by application (power level) and storage time. Potential applications of each of these technologies are being found in the electric gridin the transmission system for bulk storage, in the residential feeder ci rcuit for sma ller systems. The location in the grid will vary based on the economics of the technology.
Utility system designers have seen the benets of massive amounts figure 1. Electricity storage by technology. of energy storage in the form of pumped hydro power plants. Power applications, such as uninterruptible power A typical pumped hydro plant consists of two interconnected supply (UPS) backup for data centers and automotive reservoirs (lakes), tunnels that convey water from one reservoir starting batteries, represent the largest market for lead- to another, valves, hydro machinery (a water pump-turbine), acid batteries, whereas laptop batteries and power tools a motor-generator, transformers, a transmission switchyard, have fueled incredible growth for lithium-ion. For and a transmission connection (Figure 3). The product of the bulk energy storage in utility grids, pumped hydro total volume of water and the differential height between reservoirs is proportional to the amount of stored electricity. Thus, Positioning of Energy Storage Options storing 1,000 MWh (deliverable in Grid Support Energy Management UPS a system with an elevation change Bulk Power Management Power Quality Load Shifting Bridging Power of 300 m) requires a water volume of about 1.4 million m3. Flow Batteries Pumped Metal-Air Batteries ZrBr VRB PSB Novel Systems The earliest k nown use of Hydro Advanced Lead NaS Battery pumped hydro technology was in High-Energy Acid Battery CAES ZEBRA Battery Zurich, Switzerland, in 1882. For Super Caps Li-Lon Battery nearly a decade, a pump and turLead-Acid Battery bine operated with a small reservoir NiCd as a hydromechanical storage sysNiMH tem. Beginning in the early 1900s, several small hydroelectric pumped High-Power Fly Wheels storage plants were constructed in Europe, mostly in Germany. The SMES High-Power Super Caps rst unit in North America was 1 kW 10 kW 100 kW 1 MW 10 MW 100 MW 1 GW the Rocky River pumped storage System Power Ratings plant, constructed in 1929 on the c 2008 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved. Housatonic River in Connecticut. Most of these early units were figure 2. Storage technology application comparison. relatively expensive since they had
Discharge Time at Rated Power 34 Seconds Minutes Hours
IEEE power & energy magazine
july/august 2009
All of the energy storage technologies discussed are targeting ways to help the utility grid cope with balancing generation and load in the most optimal ways possible.
a motor and pump on one shaft and a separate shaft with a generator and turbine. Subsequent developments through the middle of the 20th century typically used a tandem system with a single vertical shaft that had a motor-generator at the top, above a pump, and a turbine at the bottom. Whereas some of the earliest units used propellers, both the pump and the turbine in these later developments were usually of the Francis type, which uses ow inlet converted to axial ow outlet. Wicket gates, eventually under hydraulic control, regulated the power level. An advantage of the Francis turbine shape is high efciency, but in this conguration, it operates best with a very limited head range. It was realized early on that a Francis turbine could also operate as a pump, but it was not used for both purposes until the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) and Allis-Chalmers constructed the Hiwassee Dam Unite 2 in 1956. This unit was a true reversible pump-turbine and, at 59.5 MW, it was larger than earlier installations. Developments in technology and materials over the next three decades improved overall efciency, reduced start-up issues, and allowed larger and larger units to be constructed. The next major breakthrough, the variable speed design, was developed mainly in Japan. In most of the early designs, the only knob available to the operator was water ow, which was controlled by moving the wicker gates, but in this design, an adjustable-speed motor-generator allows the shaft rotation rate to change as well. By optimizing the two variables, the unit can be dispatched at optimum efciency over a large power range. The rst adjustablespeed system unit was constructed for use in Japan and became operational in 1990. Recently, an adjustable-speed system was constructed at Goldisthal in Thuringia, Germany. Two of the four 265-MW units at this plant are adjustable speed. Today, the global capacity of pumped hydro storage plants totals more than 95 GW, with approximately 20 GW operating in the United States. The original intent of these plants was to provide off-peak base loading for large coal and nuclear plants to optimize their overall performance and provide peaking energy each day. Their duty has since been expanded to include providing ancillary service functions, such as frequency regulation in the generation mode. The newer adjustable-speed system design allows pumped hydro plants to provide ancillary service (frequency) capability in the pumping mode as well, which increases overall plant efciency. Filings with
july/august 2009
the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) have been made for additional pumped hydro facilities. These new plants represent 20 GW of new storage capacity that could be added to the U.S. grid.
Pumped Storage U.S. Capacity 22,000 MW Worlds Capacity 110,000 MW 7085% Efficient
Reservoir
35
CT Module
Air Expander
Air
Compressor
Motor
would have an initial rating of 800 MW. In addition to these larger plants, EPRI has been studying an aboveground CAES alternative with high-pressure air stored in a series of large pipes. These smaller systems are targeted at ratings of up to 15 MW for two hours.
Advancements in battery technology over the last 20 years Heat Rate 3810 have been driven primarily by Energy Ratio 0.70 the use of batteries in consumer Storage elect ron ics a nd power tools. Source: EPRI Only in the last ten yearswith c 2008 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved. efforts to design better batteries for transportationhave posfigure 4. Advanced CAES one-line diagram. sible uses of battery technology for the power grid emerged. One system using advanced turbine technology. Figure 4 shows a driver that has helped make potential utility applications basic diagram of an advanced CAES design. possible is more efficient cost-effective power electronThis proposed concept is targeted at plants in the 150 ics. For battery technologies to be practically applied 400 MW range with underground storage reservoirs of up in the ac utility grid, reliable power conversion systems to 10 hours of compressed air at 1,500 lbf/in2. Depend- (PCSs) that convert battery dc power to ac were needed. ing on the reservoir size, multiple units could be deployed. These devices now exist and have many years of service The largest plant under consideration in the United States experience, which makes a wide range of battery technologies practical for grid support applications. Figure 5 shows the steady inExponential Improvement in Performance crease in the energy density of batteries since the rst lead-acid batteries were introduced in the Lithium Ion 110140 Wh/kg mid-19th century. A la rge va r iet y of bat t er y types are being used for grid support applications.
Specific Energy
Nickel-Metal Hydride 5075 Wh/kg Nickel-Cadmium 3560 Wh/kg Nickel-Iron 3040 Wh/kg
1860
1910
1960
2010
battery, producing about 2 V. This process is reversible since Sodium Sulfur Battery - NAS charging causes sodium polyBeta sulfides to release the positive 2 V Cell Alumina 2V + Exchange + sodium ions back through the Tube NA 89% Efficient electrolyte to recombine as 2,500 Cycle Life elemental sodium. The battery operates at about 300 C. NaS battery cells are efficient (about Molten 89%). This battery system is Thermal S 50 kW, 6 h Module Na capable of six hours of disEnclosure Na2S4 Cell charge time on a daily basis. Na+ NaS battery technology was originally developed in the 1960s for use in early electric cars, but was later abandoned for that apSulfur plication. NaS battery technol Sketch of a 2 V NAS Battery Cell + ogy for large-scale applications Thermal Enclosure Terminals was perfected in Japan. Currently, there are 190 battery systems in service in Japan, totaling more figure 6. NaS battery cell construction. than 270 MW of capacity with stored energy suitable for six hours of daily peak shaving. the negative electrode surface of the reactor cell, as shown The largest single NaS battery installation is a 34-MW, in Figure 8. The bromide is converted to bromine at the positive 245-MWh system for wind power stabilization in northern Japan (Figure 7). The battery will allow the output of the surface of the electrode in the reactor cell and then is stored 51-MW wind farm to be 100% dispatchable during on- in the other electrolyte tank as a safe chemically complex oily liquid. To discharge the battery, the process is reversed, peak periods. In the United States, utilities have deployed 9 MW of NaS batteries for peak shaving, backup power, rming wind capacity, and other applications. Another high-temperature battery, which is based on sodium nickel chloride chemistry, is used for electric transportation applications in Europe. Known as the Zebra battery, it is being considered for utility applications as well.
Discharge
37
The future of electric grids will be impacted by a growing penetration of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles and electric vehicles, which will represent a new dimension for grid management.
figure 9. Zinc-bromine flow battery system (500 kW). (Photo courtesy of Altairnano.)
and the metallic zinc plated on the negative electrode is dissolved in the electrolyte solution and available for the next charge cycle. One of the advantages of flow batteries is that their construction is based on plastic components in the reactor stacks, piping, and tanks for holding the electrolytes. The result is that the batteries are relatively light in weight and have a longer life. The typical flow battery can be
used in any duty cycle and does not have self-discharge characteristics that can cause damage like other battery technologies can. Flow battery manufacturers are using modular construction to create different system ratings and duration times. Figure 9 shows a zinc-bromine ow battery package with a rating of 500 kW for two hours. Other packages are being applied at utilities with system ratings of up to 2.8 MWh packaged in a 53-ft trailer. Another type of ow battery is the vanadium redox battery (VRB). During the charge and discharge cycles, positive hydrogen ions are exchanged between the two electrolyte tanks through a hydrogen-ion permeable polymer membrane. Like the zinc-bromine battery, the VRB systems power and energy ratings are independent of each other. Numerous other chemistries are being developed around the ow battery concept. New startup companies are expected to announce ow battery technologies in the next few years.
Lithium-Ion Batteries
The battery technology with the broadest base of applications today is the lithium-ion battery. This technology can be applied in a wide variety of shapes and sizes, allowing the battery to efciently ll the available space, such as a cell phone or laptop computer. In addition to their packaging exibility, these batteries are light in weight relative to aqueous battery technologies, such as lead-acid batteries. As previously shown in Figure 5, lithium-ion batteries have the highest power density of all batteries on the commercial market on a per-unit-of-volume basis. Safety issues with lithium-ion batteries in laptop computers have been a recent concern, but continued development of the technology for PHEV application has resulted in newer types of lithium-ion cells with more sophisticated cell management systems to improve performance and safety. The leading lithium-ion cell design being applied in new PHEV designs is a combination of lithiated nickel, cobalt, and aluminum oxides, referred to as an NCA cell. The designs life characteristics on oat and cycling duty have made NCA cells the primary choice for the next generation of PHEVs. Two lithium-ion designs that are starting to be used in higher-power utility grid applications are lithium titanate and lithium iron phosphate.
figure 10. A 1,000 kWh lithium-ion battery system applied in a utility frequency regulation application (photo courtesy of ZBB Energy Corporation).
38
IEEE power & energy magazine
Lithium Titanate
The lithium titanate approach uses manganese in the cathode and titanate anodes. This chemistry results in a
july/august 2009
As countries around the world continue to increase their renewable energy portfolio, the participation of storage in the success formula needs attention.
Advanced Lead-Acid Batteries
The high volume of production of lead-acid batteries offers a tremendous opportunity for expanded use of these batteries if their life could be signicantly extended in cycling applications. Adding carbon to the negative electrode seems to be the answer. Lead-acid batteries fail due to sulfation in the negative plate that increases as they are cycled more. Adding as much as 40% of activated carbon to the negative electrode composition increases the batterys life. Estimates of a cycling life improvement of up to 2,000 cycles represent a three to four times improvement over current lead-acid designs. This extended life coupled with the lower costs will lead storage developers to revisit leadacid technology for grid applications.
very stable design with fast-charge capability and good performance at lower temperatures. The batteries can be discharged to 0% and appear to have a relatively long life. Figure 10 shows a lithium-titanate battery in a utility power ancillary service application (frequency regulation).
Nickel-Cadmium Batteries
As shown in Figure 5, which depicts the exponential growth in the power density of batteries, nickel-cadmium (Ni-Cad) batteries represented a substantial increase in battery power in the middle of the last century. The Ni-Cad battery quickly gained a reputation as a rugged, durable stored energy source with good cycling capability and a broad discharge range. Ni-Cad batteries have been applied in a variety of backup power applications and were chosen to provide spinning reserve for a transmission project in Alaska. This project involves a 26-MW Ni-Cad battery rated for 15 min, which represents the largest battery in a utility application in North America. The project was featured in the March/April 2005 issue of IEEE Power & Energy Magazine. Ni-Cad batteries are still being used for utility applications, such as power ramp rate control for smoothing wind farm power variability in areas with weak power grids (such as island power systems).
Lead-Acid Batteries
The lead-acid battery is the oldest and most mature of all battery technologies. Because of the wide use of lead-acid batteries in a wide variety of applications, including automotive starting and UPS use, lead-acid batteries have the lowest cost of all battery technologies. For utility power application, a 40-MWh lead-acid battery was installed in the Southern California g r id i n 1988 to demonst rate the peak shaving capabilities of batteries in a grid application. The battery demonstrated the value of stored energy in the grid, but the limited cycling capability of lead acid made the overall economics of the system unacceptable. For back up power sou rces i n large power plants, lead-acid battery plants are still used as black start sources in case of emergencies. Their long life and lower costs make figure 11. A 100-kWh high-speed them ideal for applications with low flywheel assembly (photo courtesy of Beacon Power Corporation). duty cycles.
july/august 2009
39
Utility system designers have seen the benefits of massive amounts of energy storage in the form of pumped hydro power plants.
8,000 r/min) steel ywheels have been used as battery substitutes in the UPS market for many years. These devices are practical for ride-through times of up to 30 s. Achieving longer storage times at high power levels requires signicant changes to the ywheel design and choice of materials. In the simplest terms, the amount of energy that can be stored kinetically in a ywheel is a function of the cube of rotational speed. Higher speeds translate to higher energy storage densities. Modern ywheel energy storage systems considered for utility power applications consist of a massive rotating cylinder, as shown in Figure 11. The cylinder is weighted with most of the mass located on the outer edge to increase the moment of inertia and maximize the amount of energy stored. Flywheels of this design can be operated in a vacuum and supported on magnetically levitated bearings. This assembly is considered the stator of a motor-generator, with the outer shell acting as the generator portion of the device. Typical operating speeds are up to 60,000 r/min. Actual delivered energy depends on the speed range of the ywheel. For example, above a 3:1 speed range, a ywheel will deliver up to 90% of its stored energy to an external load. Currently, high-speed ywheel systems rated 1,000 kW (15 min) or larger are being deployed in the U.S. grid for frequency regulation use. At least three independent system operators (ISOs) have opened their markets for fast-response systems, such as ywheels and batterypowered systems.
use metal for one of the electrodes have a signicantly larger energy density than the symmetric ones do and also have a lower leakage current. Compared with lead-acid batteries, electrochemical capacitors have lower energy density, but they can be cycled hundreds of thousands of times and are much more powerful than batteries (fast charge and discharge capability). Supercapacitors have been applied for blade-pitch control devices for individual wind turbine generators to control the rate at which power increases and decreases with changes in wind velocity. This functionality is desirable if wind turbines are connected to weak utility power grids.
Thermal Storage
All of the energy storage technologies discussed are targeting ways to help the utility grid cope with balancing generation and load in the most optimal ways possible. Traditionally, utility grids have been designed to deal with the highest load peaks that typically occur less than a few hours per day for only a few days per year. Just like batteries and peaking generators, any storage device that helps meet this objective should be considered in utility system planning. Thermal storage devices that can be deployed at the residential and commercial level should be given more attention. Modular ice storage systems can generate ice during off-peak power periods to power air-conditioning systems for several hours each day during the peak afternoon load times. Similarly, in cold climates, modular heat storage systems can capture electric power during offpeak periods and use that energy to store heat in a ceramic heatsink to be dispatched during higher peak periods in the winter. As more utilities consider real-time pricing of energy based on actual cost, all forms of energy storage
july/august 2009
Electrochemical Capacitors
Commonly called supercapacitors, electrochemical capacitors look and perform similar to lithium-ion batteries. They store energy in the two series capacitors of the electric double layer (EDL), which is formed between each of the electrodes and the electrolyte ions. The distance over which the charge separation occurs is just a few angstroms. The extremely large surface area makes the capacitance and energy density of these devices thousands of times larger than those of conventional electrolytic capacitors. The electrodes are often made with porous carbon material. The electrolyte is either aqueous or organic. The aqueous capacitors have a lower energy density due to a lower cell voltage, but are less expensive and work in a wider temperature range. The asymmetrical capacitors that
40
IEEE power & energy magazine
One of the advantages of flow batteries is that their construction is based on plastic components in the reactor stacks, piping, and tanks for holding the electrolytes.
will provide more value and contribute to lowering the overall peak demand. This concept is not limited to small applications. In Europe, a very large thermal storage system (up to 10,000 MWh) is being proposed.
to add value to wind resources by reducing the impact of wind availability. Like wind power, storage can benet from nancial stimulus to support its growth and demonstrate its value in actual performance. The United States, Japan, and Germany currently benet from having fairly large amounts of storage (pumped hydro) in their grids. Recognizing the value of storage in dealing with the variability of renewable resources is essential to harnessing the maximum potential of wind and solar power. Fortunately, storage systems used in grid applications will benet from the huge investment in electric-based transportation. In fact, the growth of EVs to 50 million units (15-kW capacity average) by 2030 would dwarf the installed capacity of major renewable energy sources. The real technology challenge will be making all of the new electric power resources function in a fully integrated smart grid.
Conclusions
Education about the value of energy storage in operating electric power grids has been lacking for a long time. During the 2003 conference aimed at establishing a vision for the future smart electric grid, storage was identied as playing a vital role in managing new and more complex networks. Since that time, more attention has been given to the benets storage can provide. The infrastructure stimulus bill passed by the U.S. Congress provided increased funding for storage in the electric grid and signicant monies to advance storage devices for PHEVs. As countries around the world continue to increase their renewable energy portfolionamely, wind power the par ticipation of storage in the success formula needs attention. The November/December 2007 wind integration issue of IEEE Power & Energy Magazine contained only very minor references to storages ability
july/august 2009
Biography
Bradford Roberts is the power quality systems director for S&C Electric Company and chair of the Electricity Storage Association. p&e
IEEE power & energy magazine
41