Physiologic Basis of Acupuncture

by D.E. Kendall, OMD, PhD
rational and consistent approach to the clinical application of needling therapy is better achieved if one has an understanding of the physiological basis of the underlying Chinese medical tbeory. It was the genius of ancient Chinese physicians that organized the human body in terms of longitudinal systems involving tbe distribution of blood vessels, muscles, and related nerves, as well as their somatovisceral relationships. They described tbese anatomical body areas in terms of yin and yarig much like the Western physicians did using adjectives sucb as medial, lateral, external, and internal. The circulation of blood in the body via the cardiovascular system to the superficial regions and internal organs, like a ring without end, is perhaps tbe most fundamental physiological discovery of the Chinese. Even more impressive is their discovery that collaterals (luomai) of the longitudinal distribution vessels (jingmai) formed dense concentrations of fine vessels (sunmai) in the superficial regions which they called nodes, or critical junctures. The ancients figured out that these nodes (called acupoints in the west) could be stimulated by various means, including needling, to bring about restorative reactions. These almost miraculous responses could be directed to infiuence the internal organs, muscular distributions, immune system, vitality and endocrine glands, and physiological balance (homeostasis) to treat pain and every disease and disorder affecting the human population. In describing their understanding of these nodal relationships of the body, the Chinese unknowingly discovered how the brain, spinal cord, and neural processes v>/ere organized. By the 1 7th century (CE), the Chinese had created machines to demonstrate how blood continuously circulates throughout the body along with the fact that nerves were involved (1),

A

and sustaining these reactions require participation of both vascular and neural components at the site of needle insertion (2,3). These needling sites are best described as neurovascular nodes since needling responses cannot be produced and sustained without participation of both vessels and nerves that supply these locations. Furthermore, many indications for nodal sites display somatotopically organized somatovisceral relationships. In other words, indications for most nodal sites are mostly related to the spinal level where their local afferent fibers distribute and integrate with visceral afferents at the same spinal cord segment. Response to Needling The critical feature of neurovascular nodes is the synergistic way the vascular and neural components interact (2,3). Needle insertion micro trauma causes production of bradykinin via blood coagulation tissue reactions. These reactions stimulate the substance P-containing afferent Aa nociceptive fibers which activate local, spinal, and brainstem restorative processes. The initial needling response is sustained by an axon reflex of the A3 fibers releasing substance P directly on tbe capillary bed associated with the tissue affected by the inserted needle. The tissue reaction also produces immune complement C3 which activates the immune complement system alternative pathway, causing degranuiation of mast cells in the local tissue and their basophi! plasma counterparts. The basophils are attracted to the site affected by the needle micro trauma. The kinin protease produced in these reactions serves to stimulate the tissue response to preferentially produce more bradykinin, which further sustains the initial activation of the Ao fibers. The local vascular structures also participate in the needling reaction processes by enhancing outflow of immune cells that participate in the initial reaction as well as in tbe restorative processes. If the Ao nociceptive fibers are inhibited, the needling reaction cannot be sustained. The somatic Ao afferent fibers converge with visceral afferents in the spinal dorsal horn to form somatovisceral connections and also stimulate the spinal afferent processing system. This results in
M E D I C I N E

The circulation ofblood in the body via the cardiovascular system to the superficial regions and internal organs, like a ring without endy is perhaps the mostfiindamentalphysiological discovery ofthe Chinese.
descending control signals from the brainstem back down to the same spinal cord level that initiated the afferent signals. Needling also activates the proprioceptive group II static load muscle spindle fibers that bring the propriospinal system into play. When threshold conditions permit, the patient may feel a propagation sensation (PS) of an electrical-type nature along the nodal pathway represented by an organ-related distribution vessel (jingmai). This PS travels from node to node and seems to follow along the line resulting from connecting the nodal locations along any one distribution vessel (jingmai). Most individuals can feel the PS over one or two nodes, while the rare sensitive responders can feel the signal traverse along the entire nodal pathway and many collateral branches. The propriospinal system is activated by needling even when the subject does not subjectively feel the PS. Directing Descending Control The primary purpose of the PS signal is to activate many reflex responses, which can be remote to the needling site, mainly involving the muscular system. The other role of PS is to direct the descending control signals, from the brainstem via the dorsolateral funiculus of the cord, to the correct spinal segmental levels to provide restorative effect. Descending control signals to the spinal cord results in: inhibition of nociceptive fibers (pain signals), restoration of blood flow and vascular tone in the periphery and in the viscera, relaxation of residual muscular tension (antispasmodic feature), restoration of visceral homeostasis, and control features of tissues responses to needling that enhances immune responses and promotes tissue healing.

Vascular and Neural Participation Present research into the role of the spinal afferent processing and propriospinal neural systems in needle-stimulated reactions and somatovisceral relationships now provides a physiological explanation of how superficial needling brings about beneficial and restorative processes. Initiating

12

C A L I F O R N t A

J O U R N A L

O F O R I E N T A L

provides a clear scientific explanation of Chinese medical theory. 5% discount on all taxed orders: 1-323-933-9238 V O L U M E 1 5 N O . "A Scientific Model lor Acupuncture. Deke will he presenting "Physiologic Basis of Acupuncture"at the CSOMA Fjcpo North on Friday. OMD. Carrubba R. Look and Readability This book wins on all accounts in readability. has devoted extensive time to understanding the mechanisms of needling and htis developed the effective use ofekctrQaciipuncturefor treating a wide range of problems. they should emulate the graphic choices of books that aim higher in terms of the educational standards of their readership. Deke. methods of needle stimulation.vftimmg.95 through Art of Medicine Press.U M Book Review continued from page 10 I N I A L M fc D N £ Clinical Applications A fundamental understanding of the needle mechanisms allows the practitioner to better understand subtle aspects of needling therapy such as needle retention time. Our Proprietary "Phased" Processing (Refined Herbal Products) • Traditional Five Flavors: Enhances Qi Dynamics • Essential Oils: Awakening the Senses • Preserved Non-Degraded Herbal Function • Nourishing Herbal Essence 2.E.W C. organization. Parts I and tl.2 * S U M M E R 2 0 0 4 13 . The authors chose simpler TCM terminology style—using gao Un or cloudy dysuria. My only criticism is with graphic choices that make CMHP look more like a consumertargeted pamphlet. harvest. "The Western World's Hrst Detailed Treatise on Acupuncture: Wiltem ten Rhijne's De Acupunctura. Inc. 343-60." journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 29 (4) (October 1974): 371-398. Z. Bowers. and 32-fl o:.s hi-rh . Hong Kong. Kendall. 3. Kendall. the author of The Dao of Chinese Medicine. we follow the ancient oral tradition of DAO Di Y.redwingbooks. Mvdiiiiials") mhich y. E.At ("Dao'Earlh mid preparation. • M F D I C I N E IS T H EA R TO f H U M A N I T Y HINESE ASSICS At F. in 2-. from 9:00 to 12:30.E. New York: Oxford University Press. this (raditiou continues to dctennme ihe vahtc and grade fundamental ofmcdicinah in the herbal marketplace. 8:1 Liquid Concentrates • 24 formulas designed for adults with strong constitutions.. For this reason alone. Kendall. • \\. March 2002. and selection ^^^ of nodes ^ to achieve the best clinical outcomes. LAc. D. such as the cliche papyrus type-face that is so common in TCM literature. Individual Herbs Also Available Call 1-888-441-0489 (toll-free) for a product catalog. For a more complete review on CHMP. please see the book review forum at www. W. Oxford. F^D. 4-. for example—over the cumbersome style ("unctuous strangury") used by Wiseman St Feng adherents. 5:1 Liquid Extracts • TIME HONORED: Satisfying Health Care Practitioners Since 1988 • Available in 86 Traditional Formulas. D. This physiological information provides a rational and justifiable basis for selecting local and adjacent.solids • Available in I'. I believe that CMHP wilt become an important brick on the bridge between east and west. at www. to best treat the patient. Dao of Chinese Medicine: Understanding an Ancient Healing Art. and layout. D. and 8-fl oz. Chinese Medical Herbology and Pharmacology (1327 pages) can be purchased for $89. and us ti> Chitia's modern htcih/i tnre sijxtem. 8-.ttiilc." American tournal of Acupuncture ^ 7 O^) (1989): 251-68.9anca0. Developed over thousands of years. and J. Hats off to co-author Laraine Crampton's contribution for making the text so readable. distal. This approach helps tbe practitioner to direct restorative descending control to a specific area of the body. and proximal nodes in formulating a treatment protocol for any condition that may present in tbe clinical setting.net.\R EAsr SUMMIT. September 17.aompress.com or www. as well as promote the needed overall response. ' Complete extraction 8:1 concentrate for iictivity of high herbal . I find that I'm still consulting it as a daily reference. If the Chens want to speak to students and practitioners of both TCM and Western sciences. After using Chinese Medical Herbology and Pharmacology for a few months while preparing this review.com. 1.