Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Director
Tomas Barakauskas
OBJECTIVES:
To ensure a wide range of technologically advanced, high-quality, secure and affordable ICT and postal services (products) for each and every resident of the Republic of Lithuania, create the possibilities for development of information and communications technologies and postal business on the basis of the flexible regulatory framework, harmoniously functioning on the common EU market, influencing the supply of the services on the market
Protection of information and communications technologies and postal services (products) consumers rights and legal interests according to the competence of RRT
Efficient and transparent competition on the ICT and postal services (products) markets
Integration into the EU and international regulatory space and efficient activities of RRT
Supervision of provision of information and communications technologies and postal services Increase of security of information and communications technologies networks and information
Application of ex-ante regulatory principles on the information and communications technologies services (products) markets, on which the competition is inefficient or insufficient
Promotion of technologically advanced information and communications technologies business by development of a favourable regulatory environment
Supervision and ensuring of compliance of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment, existing on the market to the compulsory requirements of the Regulations and supervision and ensuring of compliance of equipment to the electronic compatibility requirements
State supervision of observance of the requirements on security and purpose of electronic communications infrastructure
Monitoring of competition in the information and communications technologies and postal sectors, activation of the market self-regulation mechanisms
Efficient management and supervision of usage of numbers and other electronic resources
In 2010, despite the positive trends, which were becoming more and more prominent, the electronic communications market was reducing due to the recession of economy (the total revenues of the sector reduced by 10.7 per cent compared to 2009) (see Figure 1). It is obvious that the growing unemployment and reduction of household revenues resulted in changes in the structure of residents expenses and their spending habits and the reducing trade volumes resulted in changes in the structure of business expenses and the business spending habits, i. e. there emerged the trend of saving. Both undertakings and residents reviewed their consumption habits and reduced the volumes of the purchased services. The said changes forced the market players to operate more efficiently, search for courageous and non-traditional solutions in order to use the available resources in the most efficient manner possible, keep the existing and attract new consumers. The main measure, chosen by market players in order to keep the consumers was the reduction of service prices: the prices of mobile telecommunication services reduced by almost one third, the prices of fixed services by one tenth. Such pricing policy resulted in the reduction of revenues in the main segments of the electronic communications sector (as well as the entire sector) even while the number of consumers was increasing. In addition, the prices of roaming services reduced for already the third time; however, that did not have a significant effect on the dynamics of revenues due to a very small number of calls, originated from abroad.
16 12 8 4 0 -4 -8 -12 -16 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Change of the GDP, per cent Change of the sector, per cent
11,9
7,8 7,1
1,3
Figure 1. The changes of Lithuanias GDP and electronic communications sector (compared to the corresponding period of the previous year), 20042010, per cent
Source: Statistics Lithuania, RRT
1500 12 7,9
139,4
146,2 1389
149,9 1355
149,0
150,7
160 140
1000
1174
5 00
443,7
424,6
412,7
399,7
23,5 2005
23,4 2006
23,7 2007
23,4 2008
2 2,5 2009
22,6 2010
Reven ue s from provisio n of public mo bile teleco mmu nicatio ns n etwo rks an d se rvice s Reven ue s from provisio n of public fixed teleco mmunications netwo rks and se rvice s Nu mbe r of active public mo bile tele co mmu nicatio ns s ub scr iber s pe r 1 00 resid en ts Nu mbe r of pu blic fixe d telecommu nicatio n lin es p er 1 00 res id en ts
Figure 2. The revenues from provision of public fixed and mobile telecommunications networks and services (LTL million) and fixed and mobile telecommunications penetration in 20052010
Source: RRT
Despite the reduction of the electronic communications sector, the Internet services segment in the information and communication technologies (hereinafter referred to as the ICT) sector grew continuously in 2010 the retail Internet access market grew by 10.5 per cent, i. e. the number of subscribers using Internet access grew by 83,540 (see Figure 3).
10
1000,00 800,00 600,00 400,00 581,86 200,00 0,00 2006 2007 2008 2009 The number of Internet access service subscribers, thousand 2010 417,53 709,79 796,05 879,58
At the end of 2010 the penetration of the Internet, provided over broadband communication, reached 27.1 per cent of the residents (see Figure 4), which amounted to approximately 63 per cent of penetration among households. Almost all the Internet access services were provided over broadband communication (99.8 per cent). The growing penetration and reducing revenues show that intensive competition exists on the retail broadband market, which is advantageous for the consumer due to the ultimate reduction of service prices.
500 23,8 400 17,1 300 12 200 6 100 213 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Revenues from provision of Internet access services Number of broadband subscribers per 100 residents 265 313 384 413 21,1
27,1
30
20
10 406 0 2010
Figure 4. The revenues from provision of internet access services (LTL million) and the number of subscribers, using broadband technologies, including those connected over mobile network per 100 residents in 20052010
Source: RRT
After the reduction of investment into the electronic communications sector, which lasted for two years, a certain recovery was observed in 2010: the investments, made by market operators, grew by 3.8 per cent (see Figure 5).
11
Figure 5. The dynamics of value of the electronic communications sector and investment into the electronic communications infrastructure in 20012010, LTL million
Source: RRT
The continuous operators investment into the next generation fibre technologies determines the distribution of technologies, used by the subscribers on the retail broadband market (see Figure 6). The services, provided over fibre, keep their leading positions; in addition, the access, provided over wireless communication lines, becomes more and more popular.
2010
35,0%
24,4%
2,8% 5,1%
10,0%
0,1%
2009
33,0%
29,5%
2008
23,5%
36,9%
6,2%
9,1%
6,3% 0,2%
2007
16,3%
39,8%
10,8%
11,2%
8,8%
0,3%
20% LAN
60%
80%
Figure 6. The distribution of subscribers against the technologies , used for provision of retail broadband services in Lithuania, per cent, at the end of time periods
*
The evaluation of use of technologies was performed according to the number of subscribers, who used different technologies Source: RRT
12
350000 FTTH 300000 250000 200000 150000 100000 50000 52.664 0 12.937 2005 * 2006 * 2007 * 94.700 15.126 2008 51.703 2009 2010 148.013 91037 202.119 216.640 FTTB
Figure 7. The dynamics of the number of local fibre lines in 20052010 Source: RRT In addition, in the report of broadband study, performed by Oxford University for several years in a row, analyzing the readiness of different countries to satisfy consumer expectations for innovative quality services in the future , as "ready for tomorrow", in 2010 Lithuania also found itself in the company of the most advanced countries, such as South Korea, Japan and Sweden and was among the fourteen most ready countries (71 countries were evaluated totally). The rapid implementation of new technologies in Lithuania did not remain unnoticed by one of the most famous group of analysts, i. e. The Economist Group. The report on digital economy rankings, produced by the said group, published in cooperation with the specialists of IBMs Institute for Business Value , included Kaunas, together with three Japans and one South Koreas city among the worlds top five cities in terms of the highest quality of broadband communication.
4 3
The Internet access at: http://www.ftthcouncil.eu/documents/press_release/2010/PR2010_EU_Ranking_mid_2010_Final.pdf [last viewed 23 March, 2011]. 2 The Internet access at: http://www.ftthcouncil.org/en/newsroom/2011/02/10/global-ftth-councils-latest-country-ranking-shows-furthermomentum-on-all-fiber-.[last viewed 23 March, 2011]. 3 The Internet access at: [last viewed 23 March, 2011]. http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/Documents/broadband%20study/Third%20annual%20broadband%20study%202010.pdf 4 The Internet access at: http://graphics.eiu.com/upload/EIU_Digital_economy_rankings_2010_FINAL_WEB.pdf [last viewed 23 March, 2011].
13
1. Lithuania 2. Sweden 3. Norway 4. Slovenia 5. Slovakia 6. Denmark 7. Estonia 8. Bulgaria 9. Finland 10. The Netherlands Source: FTTH Council Europe, 2010
Lithuania Sweden Norway Slovenia Estonia Denmark Slovakia Finland The Netherlands Italy
Sweden Norway Slovenia Andorra Denmark Iceland Lithuania The Netherlands Slovakia Finland
As the transition to digital broadcasting is foreseen on 29 October, 2012, the abolition of analogue broadcasting is going to change the television segment. According to the data of RRT, at the end of 2010 approximately 47 per cent of all households used paid television services and almost 44 per cent of paid television subscribers received television signals digitally. Compared to 2009, the number of subscribers of paid digital television (not including satellite television) grew by approximately 24 per cent during the year. The successfully developing next generation broadband networks result in re-broadcasting of television programmes in the IPTV format getting more popular. At the end of 2010 the IPTV services were provided by 8 companies, 65,900 subscribers viewed television programmes in this way and, compared to the number of subscribers at the beginning of the year, one can see that the said number grew by nine per cent. In the beginning of 2010, there was the tender regarding the right to commence re-broadcasting of three HDTV programmes in Kaunas, therefore the said programmes will be broadcasted not only in Vilnius. On 31 December, 2010, 71 undertakings had the right to provide postal and courier services, including 12 undertakings providing postal and 71 courier services. The first symptoms of recovery were felt in the postal sector in 2010: the total revenues from the postal and courier services, received in 2010, compared with those, received in the corresponding time period in 2009, grew by 5.6 per cent and reached LTL 238.6 million. The revenues from the courier activities grew by 5.6 per cent, the revenues from postal activities by 5.5 per cent (see Figure 8). 300 200 91,6 100 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 69,9 78,3 104,6 129,9 90,2 98,4 160,2 97,7 128,4 103,0 135,6
Figure 8. The revenues from postal and courier activities in 20052010, LTL million
Source: RRT
Compared to 2009, in 2010 the total revenues, received by postal services operator Lietuvos Patas AB reduced by 13.9 per cent, which mostly resulted from the reduction of revenues, received from other (non postal and non courier services) activities.
14
RRT is engaged in the implementation of the provisions of the Law on Electronic Communications of the Republic of Lithuania (hereinafter referred to as the Law on Electronic Communications) and the Postal Law of the Republic of Lithuania (hereinafter referred to as the Postal Law), building the legal system of technical and economic regulation and supervision of the ICT as well as postal and courier service sectors. In 2010 RRT prepared the draft of the amendment of Resolution No. 1492 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 25 November, 2004 On the Approval of the Model of Implementation of Digital Television in Lithuania. The document is aimed at smooth transition to the new advanced digital television broadcasting technologies, ensuring more efficient use of radio frequencies and allowing for provision of a greater number of more diverse services. For the purpose of reaching efficient management and use of electronic communications resources, by orders of the Director of RRT the Radio Frequency Use Plan and the Rules for the Allocation and Use of Telephone Numbers as well as the National Telephone Numbering Plan were amended. Apart from other things, the new changes created the prerequisites for more efficient use of the radio spectrum, encouraging the competitive environment and ensuring the possibility for the persons in the Republic of Lithuania to provide new harmonized social services by telephone numbers 116006 and 116117, used in all the EU Member States. In 2010 the package of legal acts, aimed at ensuring the societys security against dissemination of negative content over public computer networks was prepared. In cooperation with the Ministry of Transport and Communications RRT prepared the following documents: The draft of the Law on the Amending of Articles 246 and 247 Law of the Republic of Lithuania;
10 5
5 Order No. 1V-489 of the Director of RRT of 22 April, 2010 On the Amending of Order No. 1V-1160 of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania of 24 December, 2008 On the Approval of the Radio Frequency Use Plan (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2010, No. 48-2367), Order No. 1V-1194 of the Director of RRT of 16 December, 2010 On the Amending of Order No. 1V1160 of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania of 24 December, 2008 On the Approval of the Radio Frequency Use Plan (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2010, No. 150-7701), Order No. 1V-363 of the Director of RRT of 23 March, 2010 On the Amending of Order No. 1V-1104 of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania of 13 December, 2005 On the Approval of the Rules for the Allocation and Use of Telephone Numbers and the National Telephone Numbering Plan (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2010, No. 35-1697).
15
6 Directive 2009/136/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November, 2009, amending Directive 2002/22/EC on universal service and users rights, relating to electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector and Regulation (EC) No. 2006/2004 on cooperation between national authorities, responsible for the enforcement of consumer protection laws and Directive 2009/140/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November, 2009, amending directives 2002/21/EC on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services, 2002/19/EC on access to, and interconnection of, electronic communications networks and associated facilities, and 2002/20/EC on the authorisation of electronic communications networks and services. In addition, RRT participated in preparation of the draft of the Law on the Amending of the Postal Law of the Republic of Lithuania, for the purpose of implementation of the Directive 2008/6/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 February, 2008, amending Directive 97/67/EC.
16
17
Supervision of activities of undertakings [last viewed on 23 March, 2011]. The Internet Access at: http://www.rrt.lt/lt/veikla_23/veiklossritys/ukio-subjektu-veiklos-qwp9.html
18
19
20
The conclusion can be made that the measures, imposed in 2006 2009, the consistent planned inspections of undertakings and consulting of undertakings during the inspections (totally 40 undertakings were consulted in
21
The results of surveillance of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment market
For the purpose of ensuring the availability of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment on the market of the Republic of Lithuania which is high quality, safe and compliant with the EU requirements, RRT performs the surveillance of the market of the said equipment, in observance of the Technical Regulations of Radiocommunication Equipment and Telecommunications Terminal Equipment (hereinafter referred to as the Regulations), establishing the conditions and main requirements for the free movement, provision to the market and the use of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment as well as the obligations, relating to the information on specification of interfaces, etc. The Regulations implement the EU Directive 1999/5/EC in Lithuania. When performing the surveillance of the market of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment, RRT cooperates with the Customs Department. 4585 radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment units, brought into the country, were analyzed according to the data, received from the Customs Department. All the data have been entered into the database. Compared to 2009, in 2010 the number of equipment brought in from the third countries remained almost unchanged (see Figure 10).
4000
6000
8000
10000
Figure 10. The number of types of equipment, brought into Lithuanian market in 20062010
Source: RRT
It should be noted that the number of equipment, which did not have the CE labelling and declaration of conformity remained almost unchanged (see Table 2). In 2010, 169 types of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment were examined for compliance with the administrative requirements, provided by the Regulations (see Table 2): 61
22
23
The number, pcs. 2009 2010 204 169 170 142 6 5 28 22 79 68 7 7 197 162 72 61 132 101 22 14 59 97 111 62 51 29 60 33 35 28 24 20 152 112
In the 3
rd
quarter of 2010 RRT participated in the fifth market surveillance campaign according to the
Directive 1999/5/EC, aimed at verification of the compliance of radiocommunication equipment to the administrative and technical requirements according to the technical files, provided by other countries. It should be noted that the regulation of the radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment market in the European Union, including Lithuania, is performed according to the EU Directive 1999/5/EC. In 2010 the provisions of the said directive were reviewed on the EU committee level. Attempts are made to get a more accurate description of the procedures of evaluation of conformity and provision of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment into the EU market, thus reducing the number of administrative violations of Directive 1999/5/EC (which, in most cases, are only formal) and develop or abolish the administrative obligations, which appeared to be inefficient or not clear. In order to reduce the number of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment, failing to comply with the essential requirements, available on the EU market, the new EU Directive will provide a clearer (stricter) definition of the responsibility of equipment providers to the market and the sellers of equipment and foresee clear requirements for the Member States market surveillance institutions and their mutual cooperation. Many times the representative of the Republic of Lithuania provided the suggestions regarding the improvement of the project, for instance, regarding the procedure of notification of specification of interfaces to the Commission, application of equipment conformity evaluation modules, inclusion of TV sets into the area of application of the R&TTE Directive, the procedure of evaluation of conformity of software, etc.. Since the Regulations, applied in Lithuania, implement the provisions of the EU Directive 1999/5/EC, it is not viable to review the Regulations until the new regulation on the EU level is established.
24
and 2
quarter of 2010 RRT participated in the Third Joint Cross Border Electromagnetic
Compatibility Market Surveillance Campaign EMC MSC 2009/10, during which the national market surveillance institutions in coordination perform verification of the group of home electronic appliances, existing on the EU market (television sets, DVD and BluRay players). The products are verified for compliance with the electromagnetic compatibility requirements, applicable in the EU. During the Third Joint Cross Border Electromagnetic Compatibility Market Surveillance Campaign tests of 159 types of devices were performed, 50 per cent of which failed to comply with the requirements. RRT tested 11 types of devices, existing on the Lithuanian market (5 TV sets and 6 DVD players) for compliance and established incompliance of 4 types of devices with the essential requirements, provided by the EMC Directive. The actions, foreseen in the EMC Regulations, were taken so that the devices, failing to comply with the requirements, did not reach the consumers.
25
The Rules for Provision of Universal Electronic Communications Services were approved by Resolution No. 162 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 15 February, 2006.
26
* The median is the value, no 50 per cent smaller and no 50 per cent bigger than 50 per cent of the values of members of the variation line (the line of tests values, put in the ascending order).
27
kb/s 2500
500
1000
1500
2000
Bit Lietuva
Omnitel
Tele2
Figure 11. The values of average HTTP data transmission/receipt speed rate in cities and towns.
28
The Rules have been approved by Order No. 1V-261 of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania of 24 February, 2006 (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2006, No. 27-926).
29
In 2010 consumers also applied to RRT by electronic mail or telephone with the request to resolve a dispute, a conflict situation or wishing to receive methodical assistance. In 2010 more than 200 consumers applied to RRT by electronic mail, more than 500 by telephone. Table 5. The reasons for complaints of electronic communications service users in 20052010
Users complaints : Total: With regard to quality With regard to billing With regard to other issues (tariffs, conditions of agreements, number portability, etc.)
*
Table 6. The decisions made by RRT in 20052010 with regard to complaints of electronic communications service users
Decisions: In favour of the consumer In favour of the service provider During the investigation of the complaint by RRT the service provider took the decision in favour of the consumer Response provided according to the procedure, established by legal acts, submitting the explanations with regard to consumer's inquiry The investigation is in progress 2005 25 4 76 2006 16 2 93 2007 25 13 130 2008 4 15 101 2009 3 21 295 2010 32 23 158
99
104
199
216
1050
280
34
66
61
112
144
97
It should be noted that in 2010 complaints with regard to provided bills, billing and application of the service credit limit were dominating. The trend remained where in the course of the process of complaint investigation performed by RRT, providers of electronic communications services, without waiting for the RRT decision, recognized legitimate interests of consumers and made decisions in favour of consumers.
10 The Specification of the Requirements for Technical Parameters of Sound Broadcasting and Television Signals Wire Distribution Networks, approved by Order No. 1V-283 of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania of 1 March, 2006 (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2006, No. 28-963). 11 The Rules have been approved by Order No. 875 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 22 August, 2007 (Official Gazette Valstybs inios, 2007, No. 94-3779).
30
The website contains the links to the following websites, developed and administered by RRT: - www.skaiiuok.lt the price calculation spreadsheet helps consumers to choose the electronic communications service providers offers, which most suit their needs in terms of price. Taking into consideration the changes on the electronic communications market, where the service providers offer new payment plans to consumers with increasing frequency, in 2010 RRT improved the price calculation spreadsheet - its database was supplemented with the new plans for private users, the functionality improvements were made and the international roaming tariffs were renewed according to the international roaming tariffs, which were changed as of 1 July, 2010. Approximately 18,500 users visited the website during 2010 (19,000 in 2009 and about 15,000 in 2008). - www.cert.lt on this website the Internet users can find advice on how to behave in case of an incident, the relevant information and legal acts pertaining to network and information security as well as the incidents statistics. In addition, a user, by filling in a special form at www.cert.lt/pranesti.html, can notify of an illegal content, harmful software, spam electronic mail messages, counterfeit electronic documents, unauthorized connections and manipulation with electronic data. - www.esaugumas.lt the information on the most frequent problems, faced on the Internet is provided on this website: computer and mobile viruses, spam, fraudulent activities on the Internet and other potential threats to security as well as recommendations and advice on how to avoid potential incidents.
31
2590
5090
Figure 13. The number of incidents, investigated by the national CERT-LT team in 20062010
32
Figure 14. The Your computer is infected message at RRT www.esaugumas.lt website
Source: RRT
In addition, the number of messages on violation incidents has been increasing each year (see Table 7). In 2010 CERT-LT investigated 477 such messages, i. e. 2.65 times more than in 2009 (180 messages). Most incidents were unauthorized connections to Internet webpages by embedding a malicious code, able to harm the visitors computer software. The data of studies, performed by CERT-LT, showed that most webpages were
12
THE COMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF THE REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA. E. security. The number and distribution of computers, found in botnets in Lithuania. [last viewed 28 January 2010]. The Internet access at: http://www.esaugumas.lt/index.php?1908453714
33
Name of incident Malicious software Spam electronic mail DoS attacks Illegal content Unauthorized use of information system resources and unauthorized connection (violation) Phishing of electronic data Manipulating electronic data Other 2008 45 145 16 47 44 25 21
* 381 messages on individual cases of spam, no security gaps were detected, which could have adverse effect on the functioning of electronic mail information systems in the Republic of Lithuania.
residents and 400 companies were surveyed by way of questionnaire. The survey showed that the companies, which used Internet access services in their activities, as residents who used the Internet, most frequently faced spam and computer viruses. 62 per cent of representatives of the surveyed companies faced spam and 49 per cent computer viruses. During the year the number of companies, facing computer viruses reduced by 4 per cent, the number of those, facing spam by 11 per cent. As a whole, private capital companies encountered network and information security violations more frequently. 25 per cent of participants of the survey stated that they did not face any network and information security violations. In 2010, 26 per cent of companies stated that they incurred loss as the result of network and information security incidents, i. e. 13 per cent more than in 2009. In 2010, 92 per cent of business subjects stated that they used anti-virus software, which is 4 per cent less than in
13
E. security. Surveys. [last viewed 24 March, 2011]. The Internet access at: http://www.esaugumas.lt/tyrimai
34
36% 63%
34%
30% 20%
100%
2007
96%
2008
92%
2010
2009
Figure 15. The tools for ensuring network and information security, used by companies in 20052010, per cent Source: RRT The survey of residents showed that, as in case of companies, the most frequent network and information security incidents, faced by the Internet users in 2010, remain computer viruses and spam (see Figure 16). 49 per cent of respondents faced computer viruses, i. e. 36 per cent less than in 2009. Spam was received by 29 per cent of respondents, i. e. 50 per cent less than in 2009. The number of respondents, who faced such incidents as illegal content, phishing of data and personal computer violations, underwent small changes during 2010 and remained similar to that, observed in 2009. In 2010, 31 per cent of users stated they experienced loss as a result of security incidents, which was 14 per cent more than in 2009. Computer software was damaged to each fourth of such users. Most Internet users, for the purpose of safeguarding against network and information security violations, used anti-virus software in 2010 that was stated by 61 per cent of respondents. As shown by the results of the survey, 1545 year-old respondents used more diverse security tools.
PC violations
6%
5%
1% 2%
3%
3%
11%
11%
7%
6%
4%
4%
Phishing
2%
2%
2%
3%
2%
2%
Spam
63%
47%
58%
65%
58%
29%
Computer viruses
78%
71%
70%
61%
77%
49%
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
Figure 16. Network and information security incidents, faced by residents in 20052010, per cent
Source: RRT
35
No reply 1% Have not given a thougt about it 14% No 16% Yes 69%
Figure 17. Do you think the Internet might raise threats to your child?
Source: RRT
The most frequently mentioned threat, arising to a child on the Internet, was illegal and harmful information (71 per cent). 46 per cent of respondents mentioned bullying and harassment, 42 per cent conversations of a sexual character, in order to lure the child to meet strangers, 31 per cent are of the opinion that a child, who reveals personal data on the Internet, may lose privacy, another 15 per cent of respondents expressed the opinion that the Internet raised no threat to children. When evaluating the preventive tools, most frequently the respondents educate their children on the Internetrelated issues and talk to them on illegal and harmful online content (47 per cent). 44 per cent of the participants of the survey stated that they only took a glimpse of what their children searched for on the Internet. 43 per cent of the respondents stated that they restricted their childrens Internet usage. 27 per cent check the webpages, visited by their children. 7 per cent of the participants of the survey set the rules for safe Internet use. 6 per cent used filtering tools for blocking of undesired webpages. Nevertheless, 13 per cent of respondents stated that they applied no measures, which would ensure their childrens safe Internet browsing. 92 per cent of the participants of the survey agreed that children needed to be taught on how to use the Internet safely. 2 per cent of the respondents were of the opposite opinion and 6 per cent stated that they never gave a thought on the issue.
36
37
38
Excellent 16% Have not heard anything about it 43% Good 35% Poor 0,20% Satisfactory 2% Average 4%
During the further phase of the project implementation, RRT will strive for the information on the security and threats on the Internet to continue reaching the part of the society, to which it is relevant, for the appropriate measures to be used more efficiently for the purpose of safeguarding against harmful and illegal content and for the new measures, such as childrens help line on the Internet, to contribute to the provision of help when facing illegal content or intimidating experience online.
39
40
on the entire
territory of the country, must ensure that the universal postal services are provided in an uninterrupted manner on the entire territory of the country, on the same conditions to all universal postal service users, on every business day and not less than five days per week. In order to ensure uninterrupted provision of universal postal services, the following service field is reserved for the universal postal service provider: clearance, distribution, transport and delivery of domestic items of correspondence, direct mail and received international items of correspondence. Starting from 1 January, 2006 the 50 grams weight limit for reserved postal items is applied In order to fully shape the internal EU postal services market, on 20 February, 2008 the European Parliament and the Council adopted the new Directive 2008/6/EC (hereinafter referred to as the third Postal Directive), amending Directive 97/67/EC. According to the said directive the postal market will be liberalized since 2011. Eleven EU Member States, including Lithuania, were granted an exemption to postpone the opening of the postal market until 31 December 2012, in order to be able to reserve the services for the provider/providers of universal postal services. Other countries, granted the right to use the said exemption are the Czech Republic, Greece, Cyprus, Latvia, Luxembourg, Hungary, Malta, Poland, Romania and Slovakia.
comprehensive and periodically updated information on the universal postal services and their usage possibilities;
the list of postal codes; prices of universal postal services; the quality requirements (standards); the procedures for investigation of complaints and indemnification of loss; With the exception of letter boxes, intended for public use, the following must be publicly displayed at
the Postal Law of the Republic of Lithuania; the Rules for Provision of Universal Postal Services;
14
Article 8 of the Postal Law establishes that the universal postal services shall include: the clearance, distribution, transport and delivery or handing in of letter-post items of up to 2 kilograms, the clearance, distribution, transport and delivery or handing in of postal parcels of up to 10 kilograms, the clearance, distribution, transport and delivery or handing in of registered or insured postal items, the delivery or handing in of postal parcels of up to 20 kilograms received from other Member States of the EU.
41
examples of filling in documents (blank forms, etc.) related to postal items and entering the address on a postal item;
As Lietuvos Patas AB is optimizing its public postal network, more and more stationary points of access to universal postal services in rural areas are being replaced by mobile post offices, where universal postal services are provided to the consumers only at a fixed time. In 2010 RRT inspected mobile points of access to universal postal services. In 2011 RRT is going to continue monitoring the activities of mobile post offices in order to establish whether the provided universal services correspond to consumer needs. In 2010 RRT inspected whether Lietuvos Patas AB observed the requirements provided by the legal acts regulating provision of universal postal services. The results revealed that in one fourth of the inspected points of access to universal postal services the title of universal postal services was not indicated, the trademark was absent and the priority was not given to the users wishing to receive universal postal services.
The Characteristics establish the following: The distance between the location of the user of postal services and stationary or mobile points of access to universal postal services or postal agents' work locations in urban residential areas must be not larger than 3 km by crosscut, and the distance to a public mailbox must be no longer than 2 km by crosscut. No less than one point of access to universal postal services or postal agent's work location must be established in rural residential areas on the territory of one subdistrict. In rural residential areas, which are detached from centers of subdistricts, a mobile point of access to universal postal services can be established. In rural residential areas, having more than 200 receipt letter-boxes (addresses), one public mailbox must be established. According to the data of 31 December 2010, Lietuvos Patas AB provides its services at 872 (880 at the end of 2009) points of access to universal postal services: 725 (736 at the end of 2009) stationary points of
15
Established by Order of the Minister of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Lithuania On the Approval of the Characteristics of the Public Postal Network of the Provider of the Universal Postal Services"
42
Source: Copenhagen Economics Study The Main Developments in the Postal Sector 2008-2010, Final Report, executed by order of the European Commission in 2010
43
quarter of 2010 Lietuvos Patas delivered 70.72 per cent of priority items of correspondence on
the business day following the dispatch and 98.45 per cent on the third business day following the dispatch, in the 4 quarter 77.9 per cent and 99.4 per cent correspondingly. In 2010 RRT sent 3,600 test letters on the territory of the Republic of Lithuania. The annual results of the test showed that 74.3 per cent of letters were delivered on the business day following the dispatch and 98.9 per cent of all the sent letters were delivered on the third business day following the dispatch (D+3). RRT publishes the results of the independent examination of the quality of postal services once per year. Table 8. The universal postal services quality examination results in 20052010
Delivery quality indicators (the time period) Quality examination results 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Established quality standards
On the same day 0.17% 0.73% 0.81% 0.59% 1.04% 1.4832 (D+0) st 1 day following the dispatch 75.56% 74.3012 85 per cent (D+1) 72.78% 67.79% 57.85% 74.61% nd 2 day following 95.5220 the dispatch (D+2) 95.30% 93.53% 86.60% 95.01% 96.14% rd 3 day following the dispatch 98.92% 98.9162 97 per cent (D+3) 98.76% 97.57% 95.66% 99.08% th 4 day following 99.4867 the dispatch (D+4) 99.26% 98.92% 98.17% 99.63% 99.50% th 5 day following 99.6864 the dispatch (D+5) 99.55% 99.34% 99.22% 99.72% 99.58% th 6 day following 99.8290 the dispatch (D+6) 99.75% 99.72% 99.63% 99.78% 99.64% th 7 day following 99.9146 the dispatch (D+7) 99.84% 99.83% 99.79% 99.91% 99.70% th 8 day following 99.9146 the dispatch (D+8) 99.88% 99.83% 99.91% 99.94% 99.82% th 9 day following 99.9146 the dispatch (D+9) 99.96% 99.97% 99.94% 100.00% 100.00% th 10 day following the dispatch 100.0000 (D+10) 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% * - D is the day of sending of the item ** - n is the number of business days from the moment of sending of the item till the delivery of the item to the addressee *** - the requirements, provided in the Specification of the Requirements for the Quality of Uuniversal Postal Services, approved by Order No. 3-495 of the Minister of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Lithuania of 12 October, 2004 (Official Gazette Valstybs inios 2004, No. 157-5742; 2007, No. 91-3670). Source: RRT
44
17 24 24
31
31 38 23 19
22 22 25 25 30 35 40 45
20
Complaints regarding other postal and courier services Complaints regarding universal postal services
Figure 20. The dynamics of complaints of users of postal and courier services in 20052010
Source: RRT
Table 9. Complaints of users of postal and courier services and the decisions of RRT in 20052010
Complaints with regard to postal and courier services: Decisions in favour of service users of a good-will way for resolution of the dispute Rejected according to the procedure, prescribed by legal acts, presenting the explanations for rejection Unsubstantiated Complaints with regard to provision of universal postal services: Decisions in favour of service users of a good-will way for resolution of the dispute Rejected according to the procedure, prescribed by legal acts, presenting the explanations for rejection Unsubstantiated
Source: RRT
2005 22 17
2006 19 5
2007 23 10
2008 31 6
2009 24 1
2010 17 3
12
20
23
13
2 25 5
2 22 4
4 14 1
5 38 6
0 24 2
1 31 4
15
13
32
20
23
12
Lietuvos Patas AB, the provider of universal postal services, is obliged to implement Standard LST EN 14012 "Postal Services. Quality of Service. Complaints and Procedures of Compensation of Damages"
16
In 2010 Lietuvos Patas AB investigated complaints according to standard LST EN 14012 and provided to RRT the report on investigation of complaints regarding universal postal services in 2010, which stated that during the said period 3674 complaints were received from the consumers, including 289 complaints with regard to domestic postal items and 3385 regarding international postal items. Most frequently the users of universal postal services complained about lost or delayed postal items (3197 complaints), other complaints dealt with clearance or delivery of postal items (137), provision of information on services (8), behaviour of employees of Lietuvos patas AB (12), damage to postal items (71), erroneous delivery (15), changing the address of the recipient (6) and access to the postal services (1). The report also provides data
Referring to Order No. 3-145 of the Minister of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Lithuania of 14 April, 2006 On the amending of Order No. 3-495 of the Minister of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Lithuania of 12 October, 2004 On the Approval of the Description of the Requirements for Quality of Universal Postal Services.
16
45
46
Figure 21. The requests regarding radio interference to the ICT services, received and investigated by RRT in 2010
Source: RRT
Previously the largest amount of complaints was received with regard to interference to radio and television broadcasts and lately the largest amount of complaints is received regarding interference to mobile communication (GSM and UMTS). In 2010 such complaints amounted to 48 per cent of all the received complaints (18 per cent in 2009), which resulted from the obviously grown number of different radio wave radiating telecommunication objects. The established reasons for radio interference were very different: faulty, no longer used or (sometimes) forgotten (no longer used, but not disconnected) equipment, radiocommunication equipment, used without authorization, etc. Among such equipment worthy of note are the GSM/UMTS communication blocking
47
Figure 22. The spectrum of reasons for radio interference, established by RRT in 2010
Source: RRT
The attention should be drawn to the fact that more than a half of radio interferences (about 54 per cent) in 2010 were caused by different mobile telecommunication equipment: base stations, telephone sets, GSM/UMTS repeaters and blocking devices. The latter are presented in the part of unauthorized radio frequency users in the diagram in Figure 22, which means that in order to protect the consumers against radio interference in the radiocommunication segment RRT had especially a lot to do when identifying and eliminating the reasons for radio interference. In 2010, as in 2009, radio frequencies were quite frequently brought by widely known active (Polish) antennas, intended for receipt of television programmes, in case the broadband amplifiers of the antennas were faulty or of low quality. There have been cases when the antennas caused radio interference even when mobile communication operated at rather high frequencies, i. e. higher than 1 GHz. The users of active antennas most frequently do not feel any interference at their television sets, therefore they are not even aware of the effect of their antennas to other users of the radio spectrum. Among other objects, which raised radio interference to different ICT services in 2010, specified in Figure 25, one can note the radio and television programmes broadcasting stations (1 case each), internal radiocommunication network stations (1 case), amateur radio stations (1 case), household electrical appliances (1 case) and short range equipment (2 cases).
48
15,0%
Radio interference Radio interference The quality of The investigation was terminated after has been successfully has disappeared functioning of the investigated and before identification equipment reduced establishing that there is no basis for eliminated of their source without radio interference investigation
Figure 23. Distribution of complaints regarding radio interference, received and investigated by RRT against the results of investigation
Source: RRT
RRT investigates all the received complaints regarding radio interference. Some complaints are unsubstantiated, for instance when the quality of the functioning equipment reduces not due to radio
interference (for instance, in case of a faulty or inappropriately tuned television set, disconnected antenna cable, etc.) or absence of substantiation for investigation (for instance, where the applicant complains regarding objects, which cannot possibly influence the receipt of radio or television programmes). A part of complaints were not investigated successfully, since radio interferences disappeared during the investigation without a chance to identify their source. Figure 23 presents the distribution of complaints against the results of investigations and their changes during the last two years. The figure shows the percentage of the total number of received complaints.
Short range equipment 28% Radiocommuni cation alarm and security networks (subscriber part) 16%
Other objects Amateur radio 3% stations 7% Figure 24. The structure of the complaints regarding radio interference to networks and systems, received and investigated by RRT in 2010 Source: RRT
49
60,6% 49,4% 2009 2010 26,4% 20,2% 15,4% 18,4% 3,8% Radio interference has Radio interference has been successfully disappeared before investigated and eliminated identification of their source 5,7%
The quality of functioning The investigation was of the equipment reduced terminated after without radio interference establishing that there is no basis for investigation
Figure 25. Distribution of the complaints regarding radio interference to networks and systems, received and investigated by RRT against the results of investigation
Source: RRT
Figure 25 shows the quantity distribution of the investigated complaints off the total number of received complaints, as well as the cases, where RRT specialists investigated unsubstantiated complaints. Speaking of all the complaints, received by RRT, the number of unsubstantiated complaints remained almost unchanged during the last two years and amounted to approximately 30 per cent of all the investigated complaints (regarding both ICT services and radiocommunication networks and systems) each year.
50
51
telecommunications network and services, leased lines services, Internet access and other data transmission services, dark fiber access services, television (cable TV, MMTV, IPTV, terrestrial DVB-TV, satellite TV) services, broadcasting transmission services, wire radio activities) (see Figure 26).
Provision of broadcasting transmission services Satellite television Digital terrestrial television (DVB-T) Provision of dark fiber access services Provision of data transmission services, with the exception of the Internet Provision of IPTV services Provision of cable TV and MMTV services Provision of the Internet services Provision of leased lines services Provision of public mobile telecommunications services Provision of public fixed telecommunications network and/or services
1 1 1 4 9 2 54 115 15 10 40
1 1 1 5 14 3 54 115 1
2 1 2 8 15 5 54 115 15 13 48
2 1 2 9 15
2 1
2 1 2 11 14 8 15
52 113 13 13 46 2009
48 108 13 11 48 2010
49 108 12 13 51
17 12 52 2008
2005
2006
2007
Figure 26. The dynamics of the number of undertakings, engaged in different electronic communications activities in 20052010
Source: RRT
In 2010, 9 undertakings submitted their notifications on the intent to engage in the provision of public fixed telecommunication network and/or services (the number of undertakings, actually engaged in the activities, grew from 48 (in 2009) up to 51 (in 2010). 6 undertakings submitted notifications of their intent to engage in public mobile telecommunication network and/or service provision (the number of undertakings, executing the activities grew from 11 (in 2009) up to 13 (in 2010). 3 undertakings submitted the notification of their intent to engage in the provision of leased line services (the number of undertakings engaged in these activities did not change). 2 undertakings provided notifications of their intent to engage in the provision of satellite communication services and 1 undertaking presented the notification of its intent to engage in the provision of public mobile communication network and/or public electronic communications services by using the systems of communication over electricity transmission lines. According to the Specification of General Terms and Conditions for Engaging in Electronic Communications Activities, an undertaking shall be deleted from the list of providers of electronic
52
Supervision of execution of the obligations imposed on the undertakings having significant market power
When performing the supervision of implementation of the legal acts, regulating electronic communications activities, RRT devoted much attention to the implementation of the obligations imposed on the undertakings recognized as having significant power on the relevant markets (see Annex 1), applied in order to limit the marker power of such undertakings. The observance of the imposed obligations is important, since the obligations help to reduce the market entrance barriers, increase the freedom of business initiatives, ensure similar conditions for competing on electronic communications markets to all the undertakings and a greater extent of competition on the markets, which results in lower prices for consumers of electronic communications services, a greater diversity and higher quality of services as well as the freedom for each and every consumer to choose the service provider which suits its needs the best. In 2010 RRT performed supervision of the obligations of transparency, non-discrimination, price control, cost accounting and accounting separation, provision of access and the obligations, pertaining to the provision of services to end users, imposed on the undertakings having significant power on the relevant markets. The obligations are established referring to the legal acts of the European Union regulating electronic communications activities, according to which, for the purpose of reaching a common EU market, market analyses are performed in all the Member States and the obligations are imposed to the undertakings having significant market power, the results of such analyses are coordinated with the European Commission. RRT performs supervision of execution of the obligations imposed on the undertakings having significant market power either by its own initiative or upon receiving a request from undertakings and/or consumers to verify the manner the obligations are observed or a complaint regarding the non-observance of the imposed obligations. When performing the supervision of observance of the obligations by its own initiative, first of all, RRT evaluated the information publically available or provided by the undertakings to RRT (prices, service provision conditions, service provision contracts, regular information on the service volumes and revenues and the information on the costs and revenues). The said information was compared with the requirements provided by the imposed obligations (i. e. the requirements for the scope and content of the published information, service provision conditions, terms of changing the service prices and the set prices). In case of lack of information, the undertakings were requested to provide additional information.
53
54
55
National call termination during peak time, ct per 5.42 4.84 4.26 The price will be set minute by RRT referring to the National call termination requirements, provided 2 during non-peak time, ct per 2.79 1.98 1.16 in the Commission minute Recommendation**. The 3 Call setup, ct 2.63 1.66 0.69 price is planned to be National call termination, not set till 31 December, differentiating according to 2012. 4 5.42 4.35 3.28 the time of provision of the service, ct per minute Nacionalinis Telekomunikacij Tinklas UAB, CSC Telecom UAB, Lietuvos Radijo ir Televizijos Centras AB, Telekominikaciju Grupa UAB, Mediafon UAB, Eurocom SIP UAB, Lietuvos Geleinkeliai UAB, Linkotelus UAB, Cubio UAB National call termination 1 during peak time, ct per minute National call termination 2 during non-peak time, ct per minute Not bigger than for TEO LT, AB 3 Call setup, ct National call termination, not differentiating according to 4 the time of provision of the service, ct per minute Explanations of the table: * the prices were set by Order No. 1V-101 of the Director of RRT of 31 December, 2008 and show the costs, incurred by an operator, efficiently operating on the market, however they do not show the precise costs, calculated according to the requirements, provided by the Recommendation**. ** Commission Recommendation No. 2009/396/EC of 7 May, 2009 on the Regulatory Treatment of Fixed and Mobile Termination Rates in the EU. 1
In 2010 RRT did not note any cases when fixed telecommunications operators would apply prices for services of call termination in relevant networks, in conflict with the price control obligations, imposed on such operators. In the 1 half of 2010 RRT investigated the complaint of Nacionalinis Telekomunikacij Tinklas UAB with regard to the failure by TEO LT, AB to execute the imposed price control obligations, i. e. TEO LT, AB did not apply the 40 per cent reduction of the prices for call origination, call termination, national and international transit services and the related measures to other providers of fixed telecommunications services from 25 April, 2008 to 31 July, 2008. RRT, upon investigating the complaint, stated the violation and required TEO LT, AB to eliminate it by the established deadline. TEO LT, AB recalculated the prices, applied for the said time period, and indemnified the losses, incurred by the service providers, thus remedying the established violation. Starting from 28 September, 2008 TEO LT, AB reduced the prices of services of unbundled access and partially unbundled access to the twisted metallic pair loop correspondingly by LTL 18 w/o the VAT (the previous price LTL 24.00 w/o the VAT) and LTL 16.50 w/o the VAT (the previous price LTL 18.84 w/o the VAT). The changes in prices are shown in Figure 27.
st
56
18,00
before 28-09-2010
after 28-09-2010
Figure 27. The changes in monthly charges for wholesale fully unbundled access to the local loop and partially unbundled access to the local loop, provided by TEO LT, AB in 2010 (LTL w/o the VAT).
Source: the reference offer of unbundled access to the local loop, provided by TEO LT, AB
In June 2010 RRT initiated the investigation with the aim of establishing whether the conditions of the Destination Omnitel plan, offered by TEO LT, AB since 1 June, 2010, ensure that the price of the national calls is not lower than the cost oriented price, i. e. whether the price is compliant with the requirements of price control obligations imposed on TEO LT, AB with regard to wholesale market of call termination on the network of TEO LT, AB provided at a fixed location and with the non-discrimination and transparency obligations with regard to other fixed telecommunications operators. In July 2010 RRT additionally received the complaint from CSC TELECOM UAB with a request to investigate whether the Destination Omnitel plan, offered by TEO LT, AB, is compliant with the price control and non-discrimination obligations imposed on TEO LT, AB on the wholesale market of call termination on the network of TEO LT, AB provided at a fixed location and whether the obligations of price control and applying non-discriminating pricing on the retail national calls markets are not violated. RRT, upon performing a study and evaluating the conditions of the agreement between TEO LT, AB and Omnitel UAB, did not establish any violations of the obligations imposed on TEO LT, AB by the said undertaking.
57
Voice call termination, when the prices are not differentiated according to the time of provision of services Voice call termination, ct per minute, w/o the VAT Voice call termination during peak time*, ct per minute, w/o the VAT Voice call termination during peak time*, ct per minute, w/o the VAT
Voice call termination, when the prices are differentiated according to the time of provision of services 28.80 14.40 18.04 9.02 12.51 6.26 6.99 3.50
Explanation of the table: * in 2009 the peak time was considered the time from 8 a. m. to 8 p. m. each day and the nonpeak time from 8 p. m. to 8 a. m. each day. Starting from 2010 the peak time is the time from 8 a. m. to 8 p. m. on business days and the non-peak time from 8 p. m. to 8 a. m. on business days and round the clock on rest-days and holidays.
As in case of the obligations, applicable to fixed telecommunications operators, starting from 1 January, 2010, Bit Lietuva UAB, Omnitel UAB and Tele2 UAB must cover the costs, pertaining to the networks interconnection, necessary in order to be able to terminate calls (with the exception of the communication line) at their own expense and the implementation and provision of the communication line must be ensured by the operator who is able to offer the lowest price for such works. The operators, who interconnect their networks, must share the communication line implementation and provision costs in half. RRT, upon analyzing the reference offers to interconnect electronic communications networks of Bit Lietuva UAB, Omnitel UAB and Tele2 UAB, identified certain deficiencies in the conditions for implementation and provision of the communication lines. When performing the supervision of the prices of communication lines, used for interconnecting networks, RRT provided the operators with the explanations regarding regulation of prices of the communication line and sharing of charges for the communication line. In September 2010 RRT received the complaint from Tele2 UAB regarding the potential violation of the non-discrimination obligation, imposed on Omnitel UAB on the call termination market, relating to the Destination Omnitel payment plan, offered by TEO LT, AB and the conditions of the corresponding agreement between Omnitel UAB and TEO LT, AB. RRT, upon performing the investigation and evaluating the conditions of the agreement between TEO LT, AB and Omnitel UAB, established that Omnitel UAB and TEO LT, AB have concluded an agreement whereby Omnitel UAB applies lower call termination prices to TEO LT, AB than those stated in the publicly available reference offer, i. e. Omnitel UAB does not observe the imposed non-discrimination obligation. RRT determined the violation of non-discrimination obligation and required to eliminate it by the established deadline. Taking the aforementioned into consideration, Omnitel UAB eliminated the established violation of the non-discrimination obligation, i. e. changed the agreement conditions and recalculated the prices, which had been applied to TEO LT, AB, for the entire time period of existence of the violation.
58
17
Accounting and price control. [last viewed 18 February, 2011]. The Internet access at: http://www.rrt.lt/lt/verslui/konkurencijosprieziura/apskaitos-ir-kainu-kontrole.html#Sanaud_audit
59
60
61
RRT. Common use of the infrastructure [last viewed 18 February, 2011]. The Internet access at: http://rrt.lt/lt/verslui/salygos-veiklai/bendras-infrastrukturos-naudojimas.html
62
Figure 28. Distribution of number portability amongst fixed and mobile telephone numbers in 20042010
Source: RRT
When implementing the Directive 2009/136/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November, 2009, RRT is going to change the conditions of ensuring the right of the subscriber to retain the telephone number when changing the telecommunication service provider or the location and the way of provision of services by shortening the time period of provision of the service from 5 days to 1 day, i. e. starting from May 2011 the mobile telecommunications service providers must ensure to the consumers the right to, within the time period of one business day, change their telecommunication network operator, while retaining their telephone number, which will create even more favourable conditions for the consumer to choose a service provider.
Table 13. Statistics of mobile telephone number portability from 1 January 2010 to 31 December 2010
Transferred from Bit Lietuva UAB CSC Telecom UAB Eurocom UAB Eurocom Plius UAB Omnitel UAB Tele2 UAB Teledema UAB Total: Source: RRT Bit Lietuva UAB CSC Telecom UAB 44 5 Euroco m UAB Euroco m Plius UAB 526 42 99 397 27,529 8,996 346 37,273 13 66 8 1 132 18 18 2,548 1,638 155 5,008 15,936 643 30,295 580 45,791 4,923 402 585 34,501 84 2,072 1,243 Transferred to OMNITEL TELE2 UAB UAB Teledema UAB Total:
13,294 20
10,121 4
1,524
63
telecommunication services, which are offered by providers having significant power on the market of connection to public telecommunication network and using the network at a fixed location, to select any provider of publicly available telecommunication services and use the public fixed telecommunication services offered by that provider. Subscribers can use the services by dialing the short telephone number from the 10XX series without performing any additional procedure, intended for selection of another provider of public telecommunication services, or subscribers can select another provider of public telecommunication services by way of carrier pre-selection, i. e. the subscriber does not need to dial the short telephone number from the 10XX series when selecting the carrier. In 2010 one carrier selection code was allocated (as in 2009). Since 2003, 21 operator codes from the 10XX short telephone number series were allocated to operators in total. There are 16 service providers whose public telecommunication services can be used by dialing a carrier selection code.
64
71 12 84 15 78 15 81 14 76 11 74 11
100
Figure 29. Dynamics of providers of postal and courier services in Lithuania in 20052010
Source: RRT
65
Average 0,5
Lithuania
Romania
Latvia
Estonia
Liechtenstein
Bulgaria
Slovakia
France
Austria
Poland
Sweden
Ireland
Czech Republic
Luxembourg
Portugal
Germany
The Netherlands
Norway
Denmark
Hungary
Belgium
The UK
Finland
Greece
Cyprus
Spain
Note: There is no price for a 20 g letter in Slovakia. The price for a 50 g item of correspondence is specified. Source: Copenhagen Economics study Main Developments in the Postal Sector 2008-2010, Final Report, performed by order of the European Commission in November 2010.
The purchasing power standard (PSS) is the unit of the artificial currency, chosen for the European Union Member States, in which the purchasing power parities for the EU Member States are expressed. One PSS corresponds to the same set of goods and services in all the Member States, however, in each Member State, taking the price level into consideration, there is a need for a different amount of the national currency in order to be able to purchase the set of goods and services.
Switzerland
Slovenia
Iceland
Malta
Italy
66
67
Other 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2006 2007 2008 2009 Office maintenance, transportation expenses Electricity and utility services Depreciation Financial costs Taxes Consultations and other services Communication
Source: Lietuvos Patas AB reports on costs of universal postal services and reserved postal services for 20062009.
In Lithuania more than one half of the total costs of the provider of universal postal services are the costs relating to work remuneration. In 2009 salaries and social insurance costs of Lietuvos Patas AB amounted to 57 per cent and, compared to 2008, reduced by 6 per cent (see Figure 31). The costs related to salaries amount to the greater share of total costs of postal operators in most European countries (see Figure 32).
Figure 32. The costs of Lithuanian and other European countries universal postal service providers, relating to salaries in 2009, per cent
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
Luxembo
Czech
The
Denmark
Germany
Switzerland
Hungary
Portugal
Belgium
Norway
Italy
Iceland
Sweden
Finland
Ireland
Lithuania
Source: the Copenhagen Economics study Main Developments in the Postal Sector 2008-2010, Country Fiches, November 2010; Report on the Costs of Universal Postal Services and Reserved Postal Services of Lietuvos Patas AB in 2009.
Slovenia
Slovakia
The UK
Greece
France
Austria
Malta
Latvia
68
Figure 33. The share of postal services within the GDP, per cent
1,6 1,4 1,2 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 Austria The Belgium 0 Germany The UK Denmark Finland Norway France Sweden Czech Ireland Romania
Source: the Copenhagen Economics study Main Developments in the Postal Sector 2008-2010.
Latvia Slovenia
Greece Cyprus
69
and Commission
19 Amending the Council Directive 87/372/EEC on the frequency bands to be reserved for the coordinated introduction of the panEuropean cellular digital land-based mobile communication in the Community (OL 2009 L 274, p. 25)
70
Television
In 2010 television networks of several types were operated in Lithuania. Paid television services were provided by cable television, multichannel multipoint distribution system (MMDS), Internet protocol television (IPTV), digital terrestrial television (DVB-T) and satellite television networks and the free-of-charge television services were provided by analogue and digital terrestrial television networks. Although the analogue television is no longer developed in Lithuania, at the end of 2010, 28 analogue terrestrial television stations were operated (126 in 2009), transmitting local television programmes and 95 stations, transmitting national television programmes via five analogue terrestrial television networks. In 2012 the analogue terrestrial television is going to be replaced by digital terrestrial television (DVB-T), whose first station was connected in Lithuania already on 29 August, 2003. During the time period of seven years the
71
90 80 70 Stoi skaiius 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Metai 2008 2009 2010
MPEG-2 MPEG-4 (H.264) HDTV
Figure 34. The growth of the number of digital television stations in 20032010
Source: RRT
72
The reports of surveys of the countrys residents [last viewed 22 March, 2011]. The Internet access at: http://www.rrt.lt/lt/apzvalgos-irataskaitos/rrt-uzsakymu-atliktu-ph6r.html
73
2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 1400 1441 1900 2400 2900 3400 3900 1787 2176 2021 2413 3054 3624 3932
4261
4400
Figure 35. The growth of the number of base stations of public mobile radiocommunication networks in 20022010
Source: RRT
UMTS 1076 2010 DCS 527 GSM 2459 UMTS 903 2009 DCS 490 GSM 2347 2008 UMTS 728 DCS 459 GSM 2247 2007 UMTS 520 DCS 407 GSM 1935 2006 0
Source: RRT
UMTS 83 DCS 380 GSM 1760 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Figure 36. Base stations of public mobile radiocommunication networks in 20062010 During 2010 operators of public mobile radiocommunication system networks (GSM 900 and DCS 1800) and the third generation mobile radiocommucation networks (UMTS/IMT-2000) registered 356 base stations and at the end of the year used 4,062 base stations. Compared to 2009, in 2010 the number of
74
UMTS 1076
222 base stations operated in the digital terrestrial mobile radiocommunication networks, intended for the activities pertaining to keeping the public order, state security services, guarding the state borders and the national security. In 2010 Lietuvos Geleinkeliai AB completed the launching of the railroad radiocommunication (GSM-R) network and RRT registered 126 base stations of the network. In total, 496 new base stations were registered during 2010, which is approximately 20 per cent less than in 2009. In 2010 the number of registered GSM-900 network base stations was lower; the number of third generation mobile radiocommunication (UMTS/IMT-2000) networks base stations also was not growing very rapidly. When performing the international coordination of the radio frequencies, intended for the mobile service, with the communications administrations of the neighbouring countries, RRT coordinated 35 radio frequencies for mobile radiocommunication. Taking into consideration the requests of the neighbouring states RRT coordinated 26 radio frequencies intended for mobile radiocommunication. In 2003 RRT approved the List of Radio Frequencies which may be Used without an Individual Licence. Since the market of radiocommunication equipment, regulated by the said List, was increasingly expanding each year, until 2009 RRT made 14 amendments and supplements to the List and the scope of the document increased significantly. In order to make the document more convenient and accessible, the draft of a new list, much more comprehensive, was prepared. In 2010 RRT successfully notified the draft to the European Commission, coordinated it with the concerned institutions and approved it. In addition, Commission Decision 2010/166/EU of 19 March, 2010 on harmonised conditions of use of radio spectrum for mobile communication services on board vessels (MCV services) in the European Union was implemented, thus creating conditions for the passengers of cruise ships, travelling across the territorial sea waters of the Republic of Lithuania to receive mobile radiocommunication services. The new list was supplemented by new provisions in October, for the purpose of implementation of Commission Decision 2010/368/EU of 30 June, 2010, amending Decision 2006/771/EC on the harmonised use of radio spectrum in short range equipment. The said amendment unified the conditions for use of certain categories of short range radiocommunication equipment, used in Lithuania and other EU Member States.
75
2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 1999 1997 1995 1993 1991 64 276 128 544 1164 2142 2916 2800 2786 3366 3825 4222 5080 6067
6601
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
Figure 38. The growth of the number of radio relay links in 19912010
Source: RRT
In 2010, 586 licences to use radio relay links were issued, which means that the radio frequency is used at 1,172 new radio relay link stations. In addition, in 2010 operators refused to use the frequencies in 52 radio relay links, due to which the total number of RRL increased only by 534.
76
Satellite service
In 2010 it was finished to amend the regulation of satellite communication networks and service providers in Lithuania and the frequencies, which may be used for satellite communication without licences, were established and granted to Skylink Lt UAB and ViaSat Inc. The operators notified of the commencement of satellite communication activities. ViaSat Inc. was granted the licence to use the frequencies in the territorial waters of Lithuania for the purpose of provision of maritime mobile communication network services. The said networks are going to provide the possibility to use the Internet at ships, sailing across the Baltic Sea. In 2010 RRT took active participation in the activities of CEPT working groups which resolve the issues relating to the setting of conditions for use of new radio frequencies of satellite communication systems, coordination of the said conditions with other radiocommunication services and efficient use of orbital and radio spectrum resources. One of the most relevant issues when preparing for the World
Radiocommunication Conference 2012 (WRC-12) is the use of 21.4-22.0 GHz band intended for satellite broadcasting service. The band is highly demanded, since it is most suitable for the provision of HDTV and 3D HDTV services. Last year the applications for implementation of new networks were further received, however, at present the band is already blocked, i. e. there is no more possibility to coordinate a new satellite network. In order to ensure the possibility to gain access to orbital resources in the future, Lithuania provided proposals regarding the conditions for allocation of special orbital resources to the countries, who do not have any networks in the frequency band and expressed its consent to the proposals that there should be a possibility to also implement radiocommunication systems within the said band after the WRC12. RRT analyzed twenty-five international frequency information circulars, published by the ITU Radiocommunication Bureau each two weeks and intended for satellite services, which publish the advanced, coordination and notification statements of the states intending to implement satellite networks. Upon performing the technical analysis of the inquiries regarding potential interference by the new coordinated networks, in which Lithuania was identified as a country, whose allocations of orbital-frequency resources and the terrestrial communication systems can be influenced by the new satellite system, RRT provided 12 letters of objection to the states, which provided the inquiries, and to the ITU Radiocommunication Bureau. In 2010, Lithuania in cooperation with the administrations of the neighbouring states coordinated six satellite communication Earth stations. Representatives of RRT participated in the EC working group for implementation of mobile satellite communication services (MSS) in the 2 GHz frequency band in order to ensure the implementation of the
77
Spectrum engineering
The theoretic assessment of electromagnetic compatibility is one of the most important factors, allowing for ensuring smooth operation of radiocommunication stations. For the said purpose the electromagnetic waves propagation method, described in the International Telecommunication Union Recommendation ITUR P.1546, is most frequently used for the 30 3000 MHz frequency band. Recommendation ITU-R P.452 is used for calculation of the interfering signal in the frequency range higher than 3000 MHz and recommendations ITU-R P.525, ITU-R P.526 and ITU-R P.530 are used for calculating the useful signal. For the purpose of ensuring a higher quality of assessment of propagation of radio waves and electromagnetic compatibility, in 2010 RRT commissioned the measurements of the atmosphere refraction indicator and its gradients in different climatic areas of Lithuania. The said indicators are essential parameters, expressing the propagation of radio waves. According to the meteorological data, the average values of the refraction indicator were calculated during the time period of 20052009 in Vilnius, Kaunas, Klaipda and Maeikiai for the four seasons and the dependence of the refraction indicator values on the time of the day was examined. The obtained results showed that the largest refraction indicator occurs in summer and the smallest is in winter and spring. The fluctuations of the refraction indicator during the day in summer are the highest in the areas, more remote from the sea, i. e. in Vilnius where the refraction indicator changed by 3 per cent during the day. In winter the change of refraction indicator in Vilnius is the lowest with 0.6 per cent. In the coastal zone, due to the prevailing sea climate, the time of the day has almost no influence on the change of the refraction indicator. According to the parameters of atmosphere pressure, temperature and moisture, measured at different heights above the ground surface, the gradient of the atmosphere refraction indicator in Vilnius city was calculated. Depending on the height refraction indicator, the gradient changed from 30 km to 0 km . In 2010 inquires regarding 3,262 fixed service radio relay link stations which operated within the 140 GHz frequency range and regarding 724 wireless broadband access station sectors were forwarded to other
-1 -1
78
Director of RRT in the 5 major cities of Lithuania (Kaunas, Klaipda, Panevys, iauliai and Vilnius), examine the persons, wishing to engage in radio amateur activities and radio amateurs, wishing to obtain higher class licenses for radio amateur activities (equivalents of the CEPT licence) according to the prepared and approved questions of level B (national) and A (international) and the Harmonised amateur radio examinations certificates (HAREC), issued according to the CEPT Recommendation T/R 61-02. In 2010, 41 candidates provided their requests to take the qualification examinations. 35 persons successfully passed the examination: 32 those wishing to become radio amateurs, including 2 who passed examination on both levels and 3 radio amateurs - for acquisition of a higher international A Level licence. One person took the examination two times (for obtaining the national, and, later, the international licence). 5 persons have not taken their examination yet. In 2010, 249 licences were issued: 109 Class A licenses (equivalent to CEPT licence to engage in radio amateur activities), 62 Class B licenses (national), 78 licences to use radio call signs, including 6 - for identification of the repeater station and the radio beacon, 1 temporary licence, issued to a foreign citizen, 24 for use of a renewed radio call sign, 9 for using new radio call signs, 30 for occasional radio call signs and 8 for radio clubs (3 for a radio call sign, 3 for an occasional radio call sign and 1 for identification of the repeater station. In 2010 23 harmonized amateur radio examination certificates (HAREC) were issued, 37 new radio call signs were granted, 8 previously used radio call signs were changed, 11 four-digit radio call signs were granted. 18 radio amateurs renewed their activities. 30 new radio amateurs and 1 radio club were registered (see figures 39 and 40). At present there are 851 valid licences in the register of radio amateurs: 503 - for the radio amateur activities of Class A, 252 - for radio amateur activities of Class B, and 96 licences to use radio call signs. At present there are 776 radio amateurs holding valid licences and having 807 radio call signs and 16 radio clubs, having 16 radio call signs, there are 17 amateur repeater stations and radio beacons.
79
792 823 767 848 815 1088 771 1006 789 1110 836 1165
500 1000 1500 Number of radio amateurs Number of radio call signs Figure 39. Comparison of the number of radio amateur stations and radio call signs
Source: RRT
80
20 40 60 80 Number of renewed RA Number of new RA Figure 40. The dynamics of new and renewed radio amateurs (RA)
Source: RRT
81
100,0
80,0
86,9
90,0
20,0 9,0 2006 10,6 2007 13,1 2008 10,0 2009 7,9 2010
0,0
Figure 42. The dynamics of radio frequency deviation norms of FM radio stations
Source: RRT
82
The 10XX short numbers The 18XX short numbers The 19XXX short numbers The public fixed telephone service numbers The public mobile telephone service numbers Service numbers 7XX XXXXX Service numbers 8XX XXXXX Service numbers 9XX XXXXX Total:
Source: RRT
83
Internet addresses (permissions regarding the use of the name of Lithuania in the names of the .lt Internet domain)
RRT, in observance of the Rules for the Use of the Name of Lithuania in the Internet Domain Names, approved by Resolution No. 1272 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 7 October, 2009, issues permissions regarding the use of the name of Lithuania before the top-level domain .lt. RRT has ensured the conditions for overseeing the use of the name of Lithuania in the names of the Internet domains, which, in turn, ensures that the name of Lithuania is used in the appropriate manner and encourages a proper representation of Lithuania on the Internet. The name of Lithuania is the official long or short name of the state of Lithuania, i. e. "the Republic of Lithuania" or "Lithuania" in all the official languages of the EU Member States and in all the grammatical forms of the said languages (for instance, manolietuva.lt, lietuvosrespublika.lt). Permissions are issued for an indefinite period of time and the procedure of issuance itself is not complicated. The applicant must apply to RRT, providing the application form which, apart from other data, must contain the arguments basing the wish to use the name of Lithuania in the Internet domain name. In case the application complies with all the requirements, RRT issues the permission within the time period of 5 business days. The register of the permissions, issued during the time period of 20092010 is available at the website of RRT . In 2010 RRT issued 36 permissions, granting the right to the persons, specified in the record, to use the name of Lithuania in the second level domain name before the top-level domain ".lt" (6 permissions in 2009).
21
21 The Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania. The register of licences to use the name of Lithuania in the second level domain names [last viewed 18 February, 2011]. The Internet access at: http://www.rrt.lt/lt/verslui/istekliai/domenai/lietuvosvardo-registras.html
84
equipment prior to provision of the equipment to the market in order to identify its compliance with the obligatory EU electromagnetic compatibility requirements. The tests were performed in cooperation with the following notified authorities - the Certification Center Sertika and the Certification Center of Electrotechnical Products EGSC, the National Communications Authority of Hungary NHH and Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority TJA. The photograph shows the performance of the electromagnetic compatibility tests of a laptop at the echo-free screened 40 GHz chamber of RRT. The following equipment was tested in 2010: conformity of 86 equipment units of 77 types to the essential electromagnetic compatibility requirements according to the harmonised standards, provided by Directive 2004/108/EC; conformity of 48 radiocommunication equipment of 32 types to the essential electromagnetic compatibility requirements according to the harmonised standards, provided by Directive 1999/5/EC; conformity of 14 equipment units to the essential electromagnetic compatibility requirements according to the harmonised standards, provided by Directive 93/42/EEC concerning medical devices; conformity of 3 new automobiles assembled in Lithuania to the essential electromagnetic compatibility requirements according to the motor vehicle directives and the UNECE technical regulations.
85
Figure 43. Distribution of the equipment, tested by RRT in 2010 against groups
Source: RRT
In 2010 the electromagnetic compatibility tests of the following groups of equipment were performed: RTTE-radiocommunication equipment (32 types of equipment tested); EMC-electric and electronic equipment (77 types of equipment tested); MedPr-medical equipment (14 types of equipment tested); TPvehicles (3 vehicles tested). In order to ensure efficient use of the radio frequency spectrum, the measurements of the electromagnetic interference radiation are performed within the 30 MHz40 GHz frequency band. In 2010 the Equipment and Devices EMC Control Division performed 676 electromagnetic compatibility tests, including 368 tests of electromagnetic interference radiation (the interference, propagated over wire to the power supply network, the interference, radiated by the equipment case, collateral radiation, etc.) and 308 tests of interference resistance (electrostatic discharge resistance, radio frequency field resistance, resistance to impulse interference inside the power supply network, magnetic field resistance, voltage interruption and voltage drop resistance, etc.).
2010
368
308
2009
339
268
2008
542
463
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Figure 44. The change of the number of electromagnetic compatibility tests performed by RRT in 2008-2010
Source: RRT
86
Figure 45. The change of the number of types of electric and electronic equipment, tested by RRT during the time period of 10 years, i. e. in 20002010 Since 1999, when the Lithuanian National Accreditation Bureau granted the Accreditation Certificate No. LA.01.026, RRT has been continuously expanding its area of accreditation for testing electromagnetic compatibility of equipment and devices (see Figure 46). In the area of technical verification of vehicles, RRT cooperates with the State Road Transport Inspectorate under the Ministry of Transport and Communications of the Republic of Lithuania. RRT has been granted the permission to perform electromagnetic compatibility tests of vehicles and their composite parts. The area of accreditation of the Equipment and Devices EMC Control Division of RRT is the broadest among all the conformity assessment authorities of Lithuania it consists of 174 Lithuanian, regional and international standards, establishing the electromagnetic compatibility requirements for radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment, information technology equipment, household appliances, electric tools and similar devices, radio and television sets and similar equipment, industrial, scientific and medical radio frequency equipment, vehicles and their electric and electronic sub-units. Series2; 2008; 2009; 2010; Series2; Series2; Series2; 2006; Series2; 2005;Series2; 2007; 174 164 174 Series2; Series2; 2003; 2004; 136 142 142 123 121 Series2; 2001; 2002; Series2; 70 64 Series2; 2000; 38
Figure 46. The development of the area of accreditation of the Equipment and Devices EMC Control Division during the time period of ten years (the number of standards, included into the area of accreditation)
Source: RRT
87
88
Activities in EU institutions
After the adoption of the updated EU electronic communications regulatory package, i. e. the Better Regulation Directive and Citizens Rights Directive, as well as the Regulation, establishing the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) at the end of 2009, the year of 2010 could be called a relatively quiet year. The results of activities in the EU institutions are not completely obvious and perceptible, since the fundamentals of the new regulatory trends and initiatives were still in the phase of development and are going to acquire a tangible shape in the future. However, the issues, discussed in the working groups of the EU Council and the committees of the Commission were no less important and no less attention was dedicated to their resolution. 2010 marked the completion of a certain EU strategic planning period and commencement of a new one, therefore the updated future goals, common to all the Member States, were presented both to specialists and the society. It is obvious that the changes in the area of information and communication technologies are especially rapid, therefore the taregts, raised in 2005 or 2006, are no longer able to satisfy the growing needs of today. Thus, in 2010 such important documents, expressing the future EU objectives and tasks, as Digital Agenda for Europe, Radio Spectrum Policy Programme or European Broadband Strategy were presented. In 2010 the discussions regarding the continuity and scope of activities of the European Network and Information Security Agency, which has a great importance to stable functioning of the sector, were held. The EU Commission dedicated a lot of attention to the supervision of implementation of the existing EU electronic communications regulatory package and the provisions of the EU directives regarding the independence of the national regulatory institution and provision of sufficient measures to ensure regulation, which might be implemented in the Member States not in the appropriate manner. For the purpose of implementation of the objectives and tasks, common to the entire EU, foreseen in the aforementioned strategic documents, RRT, as in the previous years, by using its expertise, aimed at maintaining active participation of Lithuania in the EU decision making process with regard to all the issues, pertaining to electronic communications and postal services. RRT provided its opinion and consultations in the EU committees and to the state institutions responsible for representation of the position of the Republic of Lithuania in the Council working groups, the Permanent Representatives Committee and the EU Council as regards the next generation networks, the scope of universal services, roaming, use of the .eu domain, practical application and broader use of information and communication technologies in more remote
89
90
communications services in the European Union; Commission Decision 2010/368/EU of 30 June, 2010, amending Decision 2006/711/EC on harmonised use of radio spectrum in short range equipment; Commission Recommendation 2010/572/EU of 20 September, 2010 on regulated access to Next Generation Access (NGA) networks, and other EU legal acts.
The Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) and the Independent Regulators Group (IRG)
The cooperation between the Member States national electronic communications regulatory authorities on the multipartite level is performed in the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) and the Independent Regulators Group (IRG). On 28 January, 2010 representatives of 27 Member States telecommunications regulatory authorities met for the first time in Brussels as the members of the new Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC). BEREC was founded by Regulation No. 1211/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council. BEREC is made up of a Board, composed of the heads of 27 national regulatory authorities and the Office, providing all the necessary expert and administrative assistance, necessary for BEREC operations. The Commission and the heads of national regulatory authorities of the Member States of the European Economic Area (EEA) (Switzerland, Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein) and the EU candidate Member States (Turkey, Croatia and the former Yugoslavian Republic Macedonia) participate in the BEREC Board as observers. BEREC replaced the European Regulators Group, founded by a Commission Decision, adopted in 2002.
91
92
Bilateral cooperation with the Commission and other national regulatory authorities
The annual meeting of representatives of Baltic States national regulatory institutions was held in Sigulda, Latvia on 23 24 September, 2010. Representatives of RRT, Estonian Competition Authority and Public Utilities Commission of Latvia, who participated in the meeting, shared information on the changes in the communications market, discussed market development trends and peculiarities of regulation. The representatives of RRT made the following presentations: Influence of Liberalization on the Postal Sector and Preservation of the Universal Postal Services and Overview of the Postal Market. Representatives of Latvian and Estonian institutions shared their experience regarding the activities of multisector regulatory institutions (in Latvia since 2001, in Estonia since 2008), analyzed the advantages and disadvantages of such regulation and discussed the future trends of institutional reforms. Representatives of the regulatory institutions also discussed the issues of transposition of the Third Postal Directive into the national legislation, ensuring the provision of universal postal services and the influence of liberalization of the market on the postal sector. During the discussions it was stated that the market is quite dynamic, the consumers habits and technologies are constantly changing, therefore the obligation to provide universal postal services must be flexible and continuously reviewed in order to correspond to the technological progress, the economic and social environment and the changing needs of the users. Most discussions were brought up by the following question how to ensure financial stability of universal postal services in a completely competitive environment and resolve the practical issues, coming up when calculating and evaluating the loss of provision of universal postal services. When implementing the Postal Directive it is necessary to abolish the reserved area. However, it is necessary to create certain alternative ways of financing the loss-making universal postal services. The states themselves can flexibly choose the acceptable model of financing public procurement of services, support by the state or contributions into the compensation fund, paid by the enterprises of the postal sector. The participants of the meeting discussed the existing situation on the market of national networks interconnection services, the issues, planned to be resolved in the nearest future, the plans as regards the
93
94
The activities in the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Administrations (CEPT)
On European level, the planning of harmonised radio spectrum usage and different other issues,
pertaining to radio spectrum management and regulation of post and telecommunications, are addressed at the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Administrations (CEPT), to be specific, by the activities of CEPT committees, i. e. Electronic Communications Committee (ECC), the European Committee for Postal Regulation (CERP) and the Committee for ITU Policy (Com ITU) as well as the working groups under the said committees. In 2010 CEPT covered the telecommunications administrations of 48 European states, i. e. almost all European states are members of the organization. In 2010 representatives of RRT were deputy chairs in the Com ITU and the Regulatory Affairs Working Group (WG RA). The Com ITU prepared Europes positions for the World Telecommunication Development Conference and the Plenipotentiary Conference of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU). It is possible to reach prominent results at global conferences in case of availability of the common position of the European region, rather than by the actions by individual countries separately. For the said purpose 15 common European proposals were developed for the Plenipotentiary Conference on the issues of electronic communications, resolution of climate change problem by using information and communication technologies, more efficient activities of the ITU, radiocommunications, confidence in information and communication technologies and other issues. The majority of the common European proposals were, fully or in part, accepted at the Plenipotentiary Conference. The brief, elaborated by a representative of RRT, the vice-chair of the Committee for ITU Policy, summarizing the positions of Europes telecommunications administrations on the main issues of the Plenipotentiary Conference, referred to by Europes representatives during the Conference, attained a favourable response. RRT took active participation in the CEPT Frequency Management Working Group (WG FM) in planning the long-term use of radio frequencies in European states, i. e. in preparing the European table of frequency use and draft decisions on the conditions for use of certain radio frequency bands which later serve as a basis for the national conditions as well as in developing the recommended methods for coordination of frequency allocations. During the meetings of the working group in 2010, the possibilities of selection of the new 2x10 MHz radio frequency bands for public protection disaster relief (PPDR) below 1 GHz, further use of the 26 GHz radio frequency band in short range radars (SRR) instead of transition to the 79 GHz radio frequency band, as was foreseen
95
(CERP) of the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Administrations (CEPT) was held in Istanbul, Turkey, which raised the issue of changing the structure of CERP. It was decided to create two CERP working groups, which would discuss the issues of policies and the Universal Postal Union. The representatives of the Postal Department of RRT are also going to participate in the said working groups.
96
Agreement unites administrations of 17 European countries (see the map) and establishes the methods and criteria for international coordination of the fixed and mobile service stations within the frequency band from 27.9 MHz to 43.5 GHz. The Agreement was concluded in 2005 in Vilnius (the Vienna Agreement was in effect until 2005). The aim of the Agreement is to coordinate the frequencies from 27.9 to 43.5 GHz for the purpose of avoiding mutual harmful interference to fixed and mobile service stations and optimizing the use of radio frequencies between the neighbouring states. During the Plenary Meeting of the HCM Agreement, held in 2010 in Zagreb, the new edition of the Agreement was undersigned, which contains major changes as regards the coordination of both fixed and mobile service stations. During the meeting a representative of RRT was elected the Head of the HCM Agreement Programme Group. RRT has been developing the software, intended for coordinating fixed service stations in observance of the HCM Agreement, therefore, upon undersigning the new edition of the Agreement, the corresponding changes were performed within the software so that it completely corresponded to the new edition. Upon receiving consent from other members of the Agreement, the software is going to become the official software of the HSM Agreement and obligatory to all the members of the Agreement starting from 1 March, 2011, when the new edition of the Agreement enters into effect.
97
98
99
100
101
102
Republic of Lithuania following the submission of the Prime Minister. The Council members are representatives of public administration institutions and academic society. In 2010 the Council consisted of the following members:
Tomas Barakauskas, Director of RRT the Chairman of the Board; Eduardas Bareia; Algirdas Bloznelis; Vytautas Butrimas; Valdas Kionas; Raimundas Malaika; Nerius Sakalauskas.
The Council discusses and coordinates draft legal acts (as envisaged in the Law on Electronic Communications), coordinates the estimate of income and expenditure of the RRT budget, internal working regulations, hears the report of the Director of RRT on the activities of RRT and plans on projects of strategic activity, discusses the issues of imposition of economic sanctions on undertakings, which fail to observe the Law on Electronic Communications and provides proposals to the Director of RRT in this regard. In 2010 five sittings of the Board were held, during which the decisions were made to coordinate the draft amendment of the Specification of the Procedure of Payment of Charges for the Services Provided and Works Performed by the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania and changing the rates, the expenditure and income estimate of RRT for 2010, the amendments of the expenditure estimate of RRT for 2010 and distribution of its appropriations, the structure and regulations of structural units of RRT. The Council also amended the rules of procedure of the RRT Council and heard the report of
22
THE PARLIAMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA. On the appointment of the Director of the Communications Regulatory Authority. [viewed 14 April 2009]. The Internet access at: <http://www3.lrs.lt/pls/inter3/dokpaieska.showdoc_l?p_id=276011&p_query=ry%F0i% F8%20reguliavimo&p_tr2=2> 23 THE PARLIAMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA. On the appointment of the Members of the Board of the Communications Regulatory Authority. [viewed 14 April 2009]. The Internet access at: <http://www3.lrs.lt/pls/inter3/dokpaieska.showdoc_l?p_id=302594&p_ query=ry%F0i%F8%20reguliavimo&p_tr2=2>
103
Table 15. The change of the number of positions of civil servants and employees, working according to employment contracts in RRT in 20052010 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 160 160 160 160/165* 165/156** 156
* According to Resolution No. 515 of 16 May 2008 (Official Gazette Valstybes Zinios, 2008, No. 64-2411) the number of positions of civil servants and employees, working under employment contracts in the Communications Regulatory Authority, was increased to 165. ** According to Resolution No. 394 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 6 May 2009 "On the Approval of the Highest Permissible Number of Positions of Civil Servants and Employees, Working under Employment Contracts and Receiving Work Remuneration from the State Budget and State Funds" (Official Gazette Valstybes Zinios, 2009, No. 57-2237) the number of positions in the Communications Regulatory Authority was reduced to 156.
104
105
and Directive 2002/21/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 March, 2002 on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services (Framework Directive) , as well as in the legal acts, adopted by the European Parliament and of the Council on 25 November, 2009, consolidating the reviewed electronic communications regulatory framework . The Programme is oriented towards a harmonious development of the countrys ICT sector for the purpose of creation of favourable conditions for the development of the ICT business and sector, competition and innovation in the area, strengthening the security of electronic communications networks and services, increasing the awareness within the society and culture in the area and drawing the societys attention to the harmful content, existing in the publicly used computer networks. Every quarter activities of RRT units are controlled by analyzing the execution of the unit activity plans. The summarized information on the performance of the activity plans is provided to the management of RRT. Each year RRT submits the annual RRT activity and financial report for the previous calendar year to the Parliament and the Government of the Republic of Lithuania and announces the report publicly. On 19 March, 2010 RRT undersigned the funding and administration agreement regarding the Project of
28
Development and Implementation of the System for Management of the Activities of the Communications Regulatory Authority of the Republic of Lithuania
(hereinafter referred to as the Project). Upon performing the public procurement procedures, the contract was concluded with Tieto Lietuva UAB, which is going to provide the Project implementation services. The aim of the Project, financed by the European Social Fund, is to improve the internal administration of RRT. The Project is targeted at automation of control of strategic
"Approved by Resolution No. IX-1187 of the Parliament of the Republic of Lithuania of 12 November 2002 (Official Gazette Valstybes Zinios, 2002, No. 113-5029) 25 Approved by Resolution No. 376 of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania of 27 March 2003 (Official Gazette Valstybes Zinios, 2003, No. 32-1333), 26 (OL 2004 special edition, Chapter 13, Volume 29, page 337). 27 (OL 2004 special edition, Chapter 13, Volume 29, page 349). 28 Directive 2009/140/EC of 25 November, 2009, amending Directive 2002/21/EC on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/19/EC on access to, and interconnection of, electronic communications networks and associated facilities and Directive 2002/20/EC on authorisation of electronic communications networks and services (OL 2009 L 337, p. 37), as well as Directive 2009/136/EC of 25 November, 2009, amending Directive 2002/22/EC on universal services and users rights relating to electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector and Regulation (EC) No. 2006/2004 on cooperation between national authorities, responsible for the enforcement of consumer protection laws (OL 2009 L 337, p. 11).
106
107
One of the essential objectives of RRT when implementing the provisions of the Law on Electronic Communications of the Republic of Lithuania is to ensure the conditions, necessary for efficient competition on the electronic communications markets. In order to identify the undertakings with significant power on the corresponding electronic communications markets and problems related to competition, monitor and improve the competitive situation in the electronic communications sector, RRT performs market analyses. The technological progress results in merging of electronic communications, information technologies and media (especially the audiovisual sector). With the convergence of technological platforms, there is a trend of provision of packets of information and communication services, i. e. a combination of fixed voice services, broadband access, television and mobile communication services. Therefore, in order to encourage development of the latest technologies, the improvement of the ICT regulatory environment, taking into consideration the development/progress of technologies and the ongoing convergence processes as well as transposition of the provisions of the directives of the reviewed EU electronic communications regulatory framework into the Lithuanian national electronic communications regulatory legal framework become an important area of RRT activities in 2011. At present the biggest investments in the electronic communications sector are related to the development of the Next Generation Access (NGA) networks and the convergence of public fixed and public mobile telecommunication services. Ensuring competition on the broadband communication services market by creating favourable conditions for access to the physical network infrastructure is among the most important priorities of activities of RRT in 2011. RRT also plans to improve the legal environment, favourable to development and common use of the electronic communications infrastructure. In order to create suitable conditions for the development of the Next Generation Access networks in Lithuania, in 2011 RRT, referring to the EC Recommendation 2007/879/EC of 17 December 2007 on relevant product and service markets within the sector of electronic communications, which could be subjected to the ex ante regulation according to the Directive 2002/21/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services (the Framework Directive) (hereinafter referred to as the EC Recommendation 2007/879/EC), plans to perform the analysis of the market of wholesale (physical) network infrastructure access (including partially or fully unbundled access), provided at a fixed location and, in the middle of 2011, make the decisions, which will resolve the competition problems on the market. In 2011 RRT plans to perform analysis of the following markets: Wholesale (physical) network infrastructure access (including the partially or fully unbundled access) provided at a fixed location;
108
In 2010 the Commission adopted the Communication Europe 2020 a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth. The strategy raises three priorities, supplementing each other, i. e. smart growth: developing an economy, based on knowledge and innovation; sustainable growth: promoting a more resource efficient, greener and more competitive economy; inclusive growth: fostering a high-employment economy, delivering social and territorial cohesion. The European Digital Agenda is among the main seven initiatives, implemented according to the European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth -Europe 2020. After the implementation of the European Digital Agenda, announced by the Commission, the growth of the EU economy will be greatly stimulated and the entire society will be provided the possibilities of the digital era. The aim of the Agenda is to reach that the common digital market, based by very fast Internet and interacting applications, provides sustainable social and economic growth and helps to reach the target that in 2013 everybody has the possibility to use broadband Internet and even faster Internet (the speed rate over 30 Mbps) until 2020 and 50 per cent or a greater number of European households use the Internet connection of a speed rate, higher than 100 Mbps. After the implementation of the European Digital Agenda, announced by the Commission in 2010, the growth of the EU economy will be greatly stimulated and the entire society will be provided with the possibilities of the digital era. Protection of the rights and legitimate interests of the ICT service users, including consumers, is one of the essential tasks of RRT, pertaining to the investigation of complaints of service users, supervision of provision of universal services, etc. In order to ensure the right of the service users, including consumers to receive services of an appropriate quality, RRT also performs the control of public ICT service quality. In order to encourage the development of the latest technology, the improvement of ICT regulatory environment, taking into consideration the development (progress) of technologies and the ongoing convergence processes, remains an important area of activities of RRT. In 2011 the legislation works are going to be continued, as the new EU electronic communications regulatory legal acts, intended to adapt the regulatory system to the rapid changes of the information and communication technologies, which entered into effect in the EU as of 19 December, 2009, will be transposed into the national legislation. The so-called "Better Regulation" Directive (2009/140/EC) and "Citizens' Rights" Directive (2009/136/EC), amending five presently valid directives, must be transposed into national legal acts of 27 EU Member States by 25 May, 2011. On 25 November, 2009 the European Parliament and the Council adopted the legal acts, which consolidate the reviewed electronic communications regulatory framework, i. e. Directive 2009/140/EC of 25 November, 2009, amending Directive 2002/21/EC on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/19/EC on access to and interconnection of electronic communications networks and related facilities and Directive 2002/20/EC on authorisation of electronic communications networks and services (OL 2009 L 337, p. 37), as well as Directive 2009/136/EC of 25 November, 2009, amending Directive 2002/22/EC on universal services and users rights relating to electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector and Regulation (EC)
109
110
111
112
TOTAL:
34545.4
The revenues, received by RRT in 2010 for the services provided and works completed according to the Special Communications Management and Control Programme
Revenues, 2010 No. 1. 2. RRT revenues groups Supervision of observance of the conditions for engaging in electronic communications activities Supervision of observance of the conditions for provision of postal services and conditions for provision of courier services Revenues from tenders and auctions for granting the right to use radio frequencies/channels and telephone numbers Issuance of licenses to use radio frequencies/channels, telephone numbers, radio stations and issuance of licenses for radio amateur activities Supervision of radio frequencies/channels use, including monitoring Supervision of telephone number use Tests of radiocommunication equipment and telecommunications terminal equipment, tests of electromagnetic compatibility of apparatus and equipment Other TOTAL (1+2+3+4+5+6+7+8) LTL thousand 136.8 Per cent 1.24
71.0
0.65
3.
0.0
0.00
4.
5. 6.
7. 8. 9.
In 2010 RRT executed one Special Communications Management and Control Programme, code 01.81. The revenues, received for the services provided and the works performed by RRT are transferred into the budget and later returned from the budget for covering the activity costs. For funding the programme LTL 18,500,000 of RRT revenue contributions and LTL 18,500,000 of appropriations, including LTL 8,400,000, foreseen for work remuneration and LTL 2,000 for purchasing of assets, was allocated according to the Law on the Approval of Financial Indicators of the State Budget in 2010 of the Republic of Lithuania (Official Gazette Valstybes Zinios, 2009, No. 152-6822).
113
Utilization of funds, allocated for the Special Communications Management and Control Programme, executed by RRT in 2010
For the Special Communications Management and Control Programme Pay-box expenses 2009 (LTL thousand) 14 086.3 7 974.2 2 489.3 3 520.9 101.9 617.4 0.3 617.1 14 703.7 Pay-box expenses 2010 (LTL thousand) 12 484.6 6739.4 2107.1 3536.3 102.0 805.5 805.5 13 290.3
No.
Expenses
Total expenses including: Work remuneration Social insurance contributions Expenses for goods and services Social allowances (income support) Tangible and intangible property expenses including: For constructions (buildings and structures) For purchasing of fixed assets TOTAL (1+2)
114
Name
1.
2.
The market of access to public telephone network at a fixed location for residential customers The market of access to public telephone network at a fixed location for non-residential customers The market of publicly available local and/or national telephone services, provided at a fixed location for residential customers The market of publicly available international telephone services, provided at a fixed location for residential customers The market of publicly available local and/or national telephone services, provided at a fixed location for non-residential customers The market of publicly available international telephone services, provided at a fixed location for nonresidential customers The market of the minimum set of leased lines (which comprises the specified types of leased lines up to and including 2 Mb/s, as referenced in Article 18 of and Annex VII to the Universal Service Directive) The market of call origination on the public telephone network, provided at a fixed location The market of call termination on individual public telephone networks, provided at a fixed location
TEO LT, AB
TEO LT, AB
3.
TEO LT, AB
4.
TEO LT, AB
5.
TEO LT, AB
6.
TEO LT, AB
7.
TEO LT, AB
8.
TEO LT, AB
9. / 3.
TEO LT, AB, Lietuvos Geleinkeliai AB, Lietuvos Radijo ir Televizijos Centras AB, Mediafon UAB, CSC Telecom UAB, Eurocom SIP UAB, Interneto Pasaulis UAB, Nacionalinis Telekomunikacij Tinklas UAB, Telekomunikaciju Grupa UAB, Cubio UAB, Linkotelus UAB TEO LT, AB together with the related entities TEO LT, AB together with the related entities According to the preliminary data - TEO LT, AB
10.
The market of national transit services, in the fixed public telephone network The market of international transit services, in the fixed public telephone network Wholesale market of unbundled access (including shared unbundled access) to the physical network infrastructure, provided at a fixed location Wholesale broadband communication access market 13.1 Market of terminating segments of low speed rate leased lines 13.2 Market of terminating segments of high speed rate leased lines 14.1 Market of trunk segments of national leased lines 14.2 Market of trunk segments of International gateway leased lines Market of access and call origination on public mobile telephone networks
10.
11. / 4.
12. 13.
TEO LT, AB TEO LT, AB N/A. The market is still under development TEO LT, AB N/A. The market is efficiently competitive. N/A. The market is efficiently competitive.
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
14.
15.
Nondiscrimination
Transparency
Provision of access
Accounting separation
115
17.
18.
18.
18.
18
18.
18.
18.
TEO LT, AB
The markets, analyzed in 2010, are highlighted in colour. * EC Recommendation 2007/879/EC of 17 December, 2007 on relevant product and service markets within the electronic communications sector, susceptible to ex ante regulation in accordance with Directive 2002/21/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services (Framework Directive), in which the list of 7 markets was established, superseded the previous EC Recommendation 2003/311/EC of 11 February, 2003 on relevant markets, in which the list of 18 markets was established. The column of the table states the number of the market according to the list, provided in the annex to the relevant recommendation. ** After the EC adopted the decision with regard to regulation of international roaming services throughout the EU, the results of the analysis were not notified for public consultation and to the Commission.
116