Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Director of Research, Graduate School, Interdisciplinary Council on Developmental and Learning Disorders Assistant Clinical Professor, Dept of Psychiatry, University of California at San Diego School of Medicine
3
Feder 411
Math, Engineering, and Developmental Disorders beginning 1978. US Navy Child Psychiatry Mike 1990 (1992) Greenspan and Wieder 1993 Career expansion: clinic, teaching, research, advocacy, tech development and arts & media.
The
DIR/Floortime Model Reflective Process Support for the DIR Model Considering medication Case examples Your experiences
6
Parent Choice!
9
11
12
13
Thank You!
Families say a silent thank you Greenspan & Wieder Mara Goverman Daniel Carlat David Sackett (et. al.) Ricki Robinson Michael Chez So many others
14
Assumptions
Varying familiarity with DIR/Floortime and the supporing research. Varying understanding of Evidence Based Practice
15
Conclusions:
The program is paramount. Reflective process is the key to a good program. Medication might help a good progam work better
16
17
Taking Notes?
One
word:
ENGAGEMENT
goes beyond compliance
Engagement Connection
before correction
19
Winnicott
There is no such thing as a baby A baby cannot exist alone, but is essentially part
of a relationship
Relationships
Individual Differences
Sensory modulation and processing Postural control and motor planning Receptive communication Expressive communication Visual-spatial funciton Praxis: knowing how to do things to solve the social problem of the moment
Attachment
Secure, Anxious, Avoidant, Chaotic, Aloof
Relationship Classification
Overinvolved Underinvolved Anxious/Tense Angry/Hostile Mixed Relationship Disorder Abusive (verbal, physical, sexual)
These are at the core of the moment to moment affective reciprocity that supports the developing relationship.
27
wth 80% intensity to help the person calm down with you. enough might mean active enough. about what works and what doesnt work
the childs lead - Join in - be part of the activity Improv = yes If you cant just join in, gently and playfully get in the way
Follow If
IV Flow
Things to Avoid
Dont just entertain, quiz, or direct the child with your games, demands, or ideas Dont merely follow the child around use the child lead to start off Every idea is a good one to play with dont say no to the idea - connect and play with it. You can set limits as needed.
Encourages development
38
Research Support for DIR/Floortime Macro: comprehensive interventions Odom, et al. there is no one winner .. Care reports, single case studies Salt, Mahoney PLAY Pajareya York Micro: core concepts Joint attention Parent coaching Repair
40
41
Reflective Process
There
are always new challenges Nothing goes as expected Caregivers rarely have the support and time they need to think Make time a moment to listen.
42
you do not have the answer Facilitate problem solving Wonder about the situation Track the emotion, then and now Statements vs. questions. Empowering vs. dictating.
43
44
Medications
Rationale for using medication: last resort vs. covering all bases
45
46
Specific Medications
For details see circlestretch.com For a framework, see The Learning Tree (+caregiver profile)
47
48
49
Visual Exploration
Distractible. 1.focus on object ---- 05/05---2. Alternate gaze 3. Follow anothers gaze to determine intent. 3. Switch visual attention 4. visual figure ground 5. search for object 6. search two areas of room
Praxis -
Sensory seeking, distractible Auditory Visual Tactile Vestibular Proprioceptive Taste Odor
Low tone; A bit clumsy impedes rapid reciprocity in the moment 1 indicate desires 2. mirror gestures 3. imitate gesture ---- 05/05---4. Imitate with purpose. 5. Obtain desires 6. interact: - exploration - purposeful -self help -interactions
Dysarthric Logical discourse is Difficult 1. Mirror vocalization 3. key gestures s 4. key words 2.. Mirror ---- 05/05---gestures 5. Switch auditory 3. gestures attention back 4. sounds and forth 5.Words 6. Follow ---- 05/05--directions 6. two word 7. Understand 7. W ?s 8.abstract Sentences conversation. 8. logical flow.
Easily frustrated Ideation -- 05/05--Planning (including sensory knowledge to do this) Sequencin g Execution Adaptation
50
Visual Exploration
Distractible. 1.focus on object 2.----3/07---2. Alternate gaze 3. Follow anothers gaze to determine intent. 3. Switch visual attention 4. visual figure ground 5. search for object 6. search two areas of room
Praxis -
Sensory seeking, distractible Auditory Visual Tactile Vestibular Proprioceptive Taste Odor Taste and odor are better
Low tone; A bit clumsy impedes rapid reciprocity in the moment 1 indicate desires 2. mirror gestures 3. imitate gesture 4. Imitate with purpose. ----3/07---5. Obtain desires 6. interact: - exploration - purposeful -self help -interactions Much better postural control
Dysarthric Logical discourse is Difficult 1. Mirror vocalization 3. key gestures s 4. key words 2.. Mirror ----3/07---gestures 5. Switch auditory 3. gestures attention back 4. sounds and forth 5.words 6. Follow ----3/07---directions 6. two word 7. Understand 7. W ?s Sentences 8.abstract conversation. 8. logical flow. Stronger foundation NOT CHANGED
Easily frustrated Ideation Planning (including sensory knowledge to do this) ----3/07---Sequencin g Execution Adaptation
A step forward..
51
52
Islands
3/07 3/07 3/08 3/08, 3/09 3/09 3/09 3/09
Expands
3/08 3/08 3/09
Comes back
3/09 3/09
Ok if not stressed
Ok for age
Co-regulate
Engage Circles Flow Symbolic Logical Multicausal
Grey area
Reflective
Comforting the child Finding appropriate level of stimulation Pleasurably engages the child Reads childs emotional signals
54
Comforting the child Finding appropriate level of stimulation Pleasurably engages the child Reads childs emotional signals
directive
Persistent attempts to engage him Can predict when he will become upset
Unsure what to do
directive
55
Comforting the child Finding appropriate level of stimulation Pleasurably engages the child Reads childs emotional signals Responds to childs emotional signals Tends to encourage the child
Still unsure what to do directive directive Pretty good with him
Learning to engage
Naturally responds
Still directive
56
Medications Approved by the FDA for Marketing for the Treatment of Autism
Risperdal
57
58
59
Its complex
People like things simple and practical This is not simple But if you follow along, it can be quite helpful and practical.
60
Good Medicine
Good = it might help (help what?) beneficence Good = it wont cause bad side effects Do No Harm non-maleficence
61
62
63
The FDA
Approves medication for marketing for specific symptoms of specific conditions Allows doctors to use medications for whatever they think is appropriate
64
65
66
New approaches:
CAPTN
Child & Adolescent Psychiatry Trials Network
NIH / Duke Efficiency Studies Pharmacogenetics Results pending
67
68
Doctors Need:
To
know a lot Respect for trouble Steady care Judgment & Experience
69
70
Doctors Experience
Often limited In my experience = seen one In a series = seen two
71
Terrible Things
Morbidity severe side effects (e.g. hepatic failure, NMS, TD, etc. etc.) Mortality
72
Avoiding Trouble
Good care: follow up, AIMS, labs, etc. Laws governing medication Report medication problems to the FDA Talk to colleagues Informed consent: family choice
73
Family Choice
For lifelong challenges Severe symptoms and impact Families must know their options Family circumstances and values are preeminent Hope is essential - unfounded hope is cruel Family choice is the heart informed consent
74
Diagnosis Target Symptoms Treatment Protocol Alternative Treatments Results of No Treatment Side Effects FDA Labeling: experimental Consent & Assent Comments, Questions & Concerns: track closely
Can
76
help, and perhaps avoid harm Standard of care Practice guidelines Evidence Based Medicine
77
78
Meaning what?
integrating clinical expertise with systematic studies consideration of clinically relevant research and respect for the individuals predicament, rights, and preferences
79
cutters no research Vested Interests only our research counts Convinced Clinicians my experience is what matters
Cost
80
Blind Placebo (or wait list) Controlled Prospective Randomized Multiple Subjects
81
conditions cannot wait We work with the data we have Heterogeneity of populations Extrapolating from other disorders (OCD), other populations (adults)
82
thinking Emotional reasoning Placebo effects References: How Doctors Think Groopman; Science and Fiction in Autism Schreibman; Lies, Damn Lies, and Science Seethaler
83
So EBM requires:
Current
84
85
Find
one you can work with Keep the doctor informed about what is happening with meds and therapy Dont overwhelm with data Doctors can be confused (biomedical) Respectfully offer resources Good doctor consult other doctors
86
Competence:
APBN Board
87
88
1989 Magda Campbell: haloperidol helps social learning; others: methylphenidate causes side effects without benefit. 1990s - 2006: treating target symptoms, based on responses in other conditions to medications; lots of use of neuroleptics for aggression, etc. 2004 Black Box warning for SSRIs in kids 2006 Risperdal Early 2009 Celexa not working for OCD in ASD Late 2009 Abilify 2010 Cochrane report on SSRIs and autism
89
Most people consider meds because they feel stuck, maybe desperate Emergencies: aggression, depression, others? Lack of progress
90
What do we want for our children? The usual wish: a meaningful life
(socially, emotionally, maybe cognitively)
91
self regulation, sensory, and motor function trusting, supportive relationships communication, maybe language cognition & learning living and life skills: home, school, work compliance with important rules
92
93
Are you trying to improve an appropriate situation or make up for a bad one?
94
Will they change my childs brain and fix it? Could they injure my child? What should I expect?
95
To avoid losing time while pulling the program together To do as much as possible Awakenings are we trying for a miracle?
96
Cant
guarantee results If no emergency, theres time When parents disagree Side effects Treatment teams all about the meds
97
Complete
along with complete history, physical, time with the child and family, and collateral information from school, therapists, etc.
Grid
possible treatments and fill in likely +s & -s, in a flexible decision matrix
GOLDEN RULE: think carefully before rapid, large changes in dose or before changing more thing than one thing at a time.
98
99
Activity, impulsivity Anger Attention Anxiety, specific fears Cognition Depression GI Distress Mood
instability, irritability, aggression Motor Planning O/C, rigidity Perseverati ve Pain Reciprocal
100
Depression
Stimulants
+/-
+/-
+/-
+/-
+?
Wt Ht tics
Wt, Ht Sz Wt. Sz TD NMS Mult. SE Mult SE Sleep BP
SSRIs Neuroleptics
+?
-?
+/+
-/+ -/+
+? +?
-/+ ++? -
+? +?
+? ++?? +? +
-/+ +
+? -? +?
-/+ -? +?
+ +? +?
/+? +? -/+
+? -/+ +/-
++? -? 1/+?
-? +? -/+?
+? -? +?
+? ++? +?
+? -? +?
+ ? + ? + ?
+/-? +
Etc
LIST OTHER TREATMENTS!
Comments
Reciprocal interaction
Sensory Sensitivity
Cognition
Attention
Motor Planning
Anxiety
Activity
Targets
Sleep
Etc
Tics
101
Core Symptoms?
Relating Communicating Healthy development: connected, regulated emotions that breathe life into adaptive thinking and planning
102
Support
Widen Treat
tolerance of emotions so
co-occurring conditions,
e.g., depression.
Might
104
105
Stimulants
Methylphenidate: Ritalin, Concerta, Metadate, Methylin, Focalin Dextroamphetamine: Adderall, mixed salts, Vyvanse Slightly different mechanisms. Similar possible side effects: appetite, sleep, withdrawal, depressed mood, unstable mood, tics, obsessiveness, etc. Drug diversion vs. drug abuse risk ADHD and ASD Often makes a good plan workable.
106
SSRIs
One of many classes of antidepressants Can really help depressed mood, maybe anxiety, less likely obsessiveness (although works well for that for neurotypicals) Prozac (fluoxteine), Zoloft (sertraline), Paxil (paroxetine), Luvox (fluvoxamine), Celexa & Lexapro (citalopram). Similar possible side effects: behavioral activation, weight gain (and loss), mood instability, lower seizure threshold, etc. Black box warning about suicidal thinking vs. lower rates of actual suicide in people treated with SSRIs
107
Neuroleptics
Zyprexa (olanzapine), Risperdal (risperidone), Abilify (aripiprizole), Seroquel (quetiapine), Geodan (ziprasidone), Haldol (haloperidol), Mellaril (thioridizine), Thorazine (chlorpromazine) and others. Discovered while looking for cold pills, developed for symptoms of psychosis. Helping aggression, mood stability, and miracles? As well as tics, and adjunct for depression, perseveration, etc.? Side effects can include weight, lipid, and sugar issues, as well as seizures, fevers (NMS) and new abnormal movements (TD), stroke (elderly), cardiac Should we always consider neuroleptics?
108
AEDs
Anti-Epileptic Drugs (aka anti-seizure medications) So many and all so different in character For seizures, and for mood stabilization Many kids on the spectrum have seizures! Might help other medications work better (stimulants, antidepressants) Combined pharmacology vs. polypharmacy Sudden stopping might make seizures more likely
109
Specific AEDs
Depakote (valproic acid, valproate) pretty reliable, easy to load, watch levels, platelets, bruising, liver, pancreas, carnitine, menstrual irregularities, weight, sedation. Problems when using with Lamictal Tegretol (carbemazepine) - ?reliable, watch levels, blood counts, EKG, lots of drug interactions, weight gain, sedation, rash Trileptal (oxycarbezine) Tegretol light?; motor problems, electrolyte issues, rash?
110
More AEDs
Keppra (levetiricetum) easy to use, but does it work? Lamictal (lamotragine) mood stability, ?better mood. Must go slow, and watch for rash Topamax (topiramate) adjunct, may cause weight loss, loss of expressive language, usually need to go slow. Neurontin (gabapentin) Does it work at all? Does it harm at all? Does help pain syndromes. Lyrica (pregabalin) for pain in fibromyalgia, partial seizures Zarontin (ethosuccimide) for partial/ absence seizures; liver issues
111
Steroids
LKS variant theory epileptic aphasia 24 hr EEGs Regression at a young age Cell membrane stabilization in inflammation So many side effects: cushinoid, moon face, hump, central obesity, peripheral wasting, immune compromise, skin striations, mood instability including depression and hypomania Pulsed dosing regimens
112
113
Straterra (atamoxetine) for ADHD; may be as good as placebo, may act like an antidepressant (+/-) Wellbutrin (bupropion, etc.) dopaminergic, weight, loss, sleep loss, irritability, seiaure risk Rozerem (ramelteon) melatonin agonist SNRIs Effexor (venlafaxine), Cymbalta (duloxetine), Remeron (mirtazepine), Serzone (nefazedone), Pristique (desvenlafaxine). Deseryl (trazodone) antidepressant often used for sleep; cognitive side effects, priapism Buspar (an azaspirone) mild, serotonergic cross reactions
114
More Others
Lithium great mood stabilizer; antisuicidal; bipolar-ASD connection; levels, thyroid, kidney function Namenda (memantine) Alzheimers med antagonist of the N-methylD-aspartic acid (NMDA) glutamate receptor, this drug was hypothesized to potentially modulate learning, block excessive glutamate effects that can include neuroinflammatory activity, and influence neuroglial activity in autism
115
Paxil (paroxetine), Effexor (venlafaxine), Cymbalta (duloxetine) - withdrawal Tegretol (carbemazepine) hard to make it work Combo Depakote and Lamictal Tricyclics Tofranil (imipramine), Norpramin (desipramine), Pamelor (nortriptyline); and, esp. good for typical OCD, Anafranil (clomipramine). Cardiac and blood pressure issues. Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors Nardil (phenelzine) , Parnate (tranylcypromine), Marplan (isocarboxazide), Emsam (selegiline) can be useful although dietary, blood pressure drop and hypertensive crisis must be considered; lots of drug-drug interactions
116
Benzodiazepines Valium (diazapam), Ativan (lorazepam), Xanax (alprazolam), Klonopin (clonazepam), and others Used so freely by many doctors and families Problems nearly always outweigh risks Addicting Destabilizing mood Interfere with learning Interfere with motor function Interfere with memory
117
Depression
Stimulants
+/-
+/-
+/-
+/-
+?
Wt Ht tics
Wt, Ht Sz Wt. Sz TD NMS Mult. SE Mult SE Sleep BP
SSRIs Neuroleptics
+?
-?
+/+
-/+ -/+
+? +?
-/+ ++? -
+? +?
+? ++?? +? +
-/+ +
+? -? +?
-/+ -? +?
+ +? +?
/+? +? -/+
+? -/+ +/-
++? -? 1/+?
-? +? -/+?
+? -? +?
+? ++? +?
+? -? +?
+ ? + ? + ?
+/-? +
Etc
LIST OTHER TREATMENTS!
Comments
Reciprocal interaction
Sensory Sensitivity
Cognition
Attention
Motor Planning
Anxiety
Activity
Targets
Sleep
Etc
Tics
118
119
Receptive Communicatio n
Expressive Communicatio n
Other medical
Visual Spatial
Sensory Processing
Stimulants
-/+?
-/+?
-/+?
-/+?
-/+?
-/+?
-/+?
Wt Ht tics
Wt, Ht Sz Wt. Sz TD NMS Mult. SE Mult SE Sleep BP
SSRIs Neuroleptics
Etc
LIST OTHER TREATMENTS!
Comments
Praxis
Targets
Etc
120
Co-regulation
Engagement
Number 10?
Multicausal
Stimulants
Wt Ht tics
Wt, Ht Sz Wt. Sz TD NMS Mult. SE Mult SE Sleep BP
SSRIs Neuroleptics
Etc
LIST OTHER TREATMENTS!
Comments
Reflective
Symbolic
Nuance
Targets
Logical
Circles
Etc
Flow
121
Ethical rules
Arithmetic .
Trade skills
Swimming.
Reading..
Writing
Stimulants
Wt Ht tics Wt, Ht Sz
SSRIs
Neuroleptics
Wt. Sz TD NMS
Mult. SE Mult SE Sleep BP
Comments
Targets
Etc
122
Etc
Targets Comforting the child Finding an appropriate level of stimulation Pleasurable engaging the child Reading the childs emotional signals Responding to the childs emotional signals Encouraging the childs development
AEDs
SSRIs
Steroids
Stimulants
Neuroleptics
Etc Wt Ht tics
Mult SE Mult. SE Sleep BP Wt, Ht Sz Wt. Sz TD NMS Comments
123
124
125
Look at the whole picture, and reflect Be careful with meds Engage the Child
Your Experiences?
126