Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
and
Democracy
Agenda
Economic and political freedoms
Effects of autocracy on growth
Impact of growth on democracy
Lipset Hypothesis prosperity
tends to inspire democracy
Barros study Gastil concept of
political rights
Connie CHUNG
Objectives
What is the net effect of democracy
on growth?
Do you think the autocratic regime
of China can survive in the face of
continued economic growth?
Why should the advanced western
countries not try to impose their
own political systems upon the
poor countries?
Connie CHUNG
Freedom House
Freedom In The World 2015
(www.freedomhouse.org)
Connie CHUNG
Freedom House
Freedom In The World 2015
In a new and disquieting development, a
number of countries lost ground due to state
surveillance, restrictions on internet
communications, and curbs on personal
autonomy.
Ratings for the Middle East and North Africa
region were the worst in the world, followed by
Eurasia. Syria, a dictatorship mired in civil war
and ethnic division and facing uncontrolled
terrorism, received the lowest Freedom in the
World score of any country in over a decade.
Connie CHUNG
Connie CHUNG
Connie CHUNG
Connie CHUNG
Connie CHUNG
10
11
12
Connie CHUNG
13
Authoritarian regimes
Nothing in principle prevents nondemocratic governments from
maintaining economic freedom and
private property
Examples of autocracies that
have expanded economic
freedom the Pinochet
government in Chile, the Fujimori
administration in Peru, and several
previous and current regimes in
East Asian miracle economies
Connie CHUNG
14
Authoritarian regimes
China experienced one of the
fastest rates of economic growth in
recent decades and it is not a
democracy
Most OECD countries began their
modern economic development in
systems with limited political
rights and became full-fledged
representative democracies only
much later
Connie CHUNG
15
16
Democratic institutions
Provide a check on governmental power and
thereby limit the potential of public officials to
amass personal wealth and to carry out unpopular
policies
Since at least some policies that stimulate growth
will also be politically popular, more political
rights tend to be growth-enhancing on this
count
Thus the net effect of democracy on growth is
theoretically inconclusive (as mentioned earlier
that democracy does have drawbacks)
Connie CHUNG
17
Lipset Hypothesis
A common view, often called Lipset Hypothesis,
is that prosperity (increases in living standards)
tends to inspire democracy
At the same time, democracies that arise
without prior economic development may
not last long
A number of Asian tigers (eg. Taiwan, South
Korea) have moved towards democracy
Will China do the same as rapid growth
progresses? What about Vietnam? Russia?
Connie CHUNG
18
free markets
small government consumption
high human capital
Connie CHUNG
19
20
Inverse U-shape
between growth and democracy
Results tentatively indicate that more
democracy raises growth when
political freedoms are weak but
depresses growth when a moderate
amount of freedom is already
established
Inverse U-shape in the plot
between growth rate and democracy
Connie CHUNG
21
Question
Democracy in the Barros study is
measured by the Gastil concept of
political rights, that is, having the
rights to participate meaningfully in
the political process. His analysis
highlights that countries which have
dominant political parties are
considered less democratic. How does
the study apply to the situation in
your country?
Connie CHUNG
22
Is democracy sustainable
with low growth?
Cross-country data suggests that countries
at low levels of economic development
typically do not sustain democracy
23
Connie CHUNG
24
25
26
Connie CHUNG
27
Conclusion
The advanced western countries
should not try to impose their own
political systems upon the poor
countries
They should rather try to export
economic freedom (property rights
and free markets) as democracy will
expand automatically after a reasonable
degree of living standards are being
achieved
Connie CHUNG
28
References
Amin, Mohammad and Djankov, Simeon
(2009). Democracy and Reforms. World
Bank. World Bank.
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handl
e/10986/4031
Barro, R.J. (1996).Democracy: A Recipe for
growth? In M G Quibria & M Dowling (eds.),
Current Issues in Economic Development: An
Asian Perspective, Hong Kong; New York:
Published for the Asian Development Bank by
Oxford University Press
Calvert, Peter and Calvert, Susan (2007).
Politics and Society in the Developing World,
Pearson Education Ltd.
Connie CHUNG
29
References
Igbal, Farrukh and You, Jong-Il (2001).
Democracy, Market Economics and
Development: An Asian Perspective.
Washington, DC: World Bank. World
Bank.
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/han
dle/10986/13904
Przeworski, Adam and Limongi,
Fernando (1993). Political Regimes and
Economic Growth, Journal of Economic
Perspectives, Vol. 7, No.3, Summer, pp 5169
World Bank (2002). Building Institutions
for Markets, World Development Report
Connie CHUNG
30