Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Challenges in establishing
Sustainable Development
Indicators
Julie L. Hass, Ph.D.
Division for Environment Statistics, Statistics Norway
Joint UNECE/OECD/Eurostat Working Group on
Statistics for Sustainable Development
Second meeting, Oslo, 15-16 November 2006
1
Indicators
used to measure some phenomenon
What do we want to measure?
How do we measure it?
Need to know what before we know how!
What is sustainable development?
Need to answer this question before we can determine how
to measure it!
Policy-based approach
Where do we find definitions of SD?
Answer:
Eurostat
UK
Sweden
3
Model-based approaches
Where do we find definitions of SD?
Answer:
Definition of "Sustainable Development" from a model
Model determines what should be measured
Indicators chosen based on the definition of the model
Examples:
4 pillar (UNCSD)
social, environmental,economic and institutional
Belgium (Transgovern)
Switzerland
Capital
Disadvantages
Disadvantages
If a strong sustainability perspective is
adopted, the issue of critical levels of
capital and non-substitution needs to
be dealt with.
There is a risk that the indicator set
will be less politically relevant and will
not be used in connection with
implementing policies regarding
sustainable development
Sum of national wealth over all
nations does not necessarily result in
a sustainable world or globe
Calculation methodology of national
wealth is not standardized and is
controversial
Norwegian
Canada
NO National
Wealth indicator
Condition of critical
eco-systems
National Wealth
indicator of
sustainability,
whereas sets of
indicators are
merely providing
information
regarding
conditions for
sustainability
National Wealth
+ strong
sustainability
perspective
(include
indicators for
critical resources;
natural, human
and ecological)
10
11
12
13
Integration of the German sustainability indicators into the accounting data set
7
20 21
National Accounts
6
10
1
11
13
9
16
14
17
18
19
Socio-economic
Accounts
5
12
Environmental
Economic
Accounts
15
14