Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Larry Esquibel
Corporate Systems Engineer
Avaya Technology and Consulting
Acknowledged Leadership
Magic Quadrant for North America Enterprise Telephony, 2003
9 September 2003, Gartner M-20-7834
10
11
Cisco CallManager
Discussion Points
Strategy
Scalability
Reliability, Availability, Survivability
(Large Scale, Small Scale, and QoS)
Security
System Management
Focus: Multiple Points of Administration
14
What do
they all
have in
common?
15
The birth of
Ciscos IP
PBX the
acquisition
of Selsius
Systems
16
17
SCALABILITY
18
19
20
Tier 2
ICM Agent
Peripheral Gateways
CallManager
Publisher
Server
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
ICM Router/Logger
Side A
J
T
A
P
I
C
T
I
PG
Locations
Voice
Gateways
PG
PG
ICM Router/Logger
Side B
PG
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
GED -125
CTI
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
Tier 3
ICM
Central Controller
JTAPI CTI
Up to 5,200 Agents
Up to 8,000 Trunks
12,500 Dynamic Queue Slots
3,000 Announcements
Actual Mileage Will Vary
Capacities to increase substantially in next major
release
22
RELIABILITY,
AVAILABILITY,
SURVIVABILITY
Dont get caught
without a safety net!
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
23
24
Reliability by Design:
Avaya ACM Server Platform Elements
Component
Media Processor board
Protocol Preprocessor Board (C-LAN)
Digital Line/Trunk boards
S87XX Server Complex: "duplex" / "high & critical
Avaya MultiVantage Power Supplies
IP Server Interface board (IPSI)
*(Industry) LAN
25
26
27
28
29
30
Many of the other adjunct servers are still Windows based: Emergency
Responder, IPCC, Unity.
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
31
32
33
34
Linux is 40%
less expensive
than a
comparable
x86-based
Windows
46
solution
Data based on a 3-year period of
ownership for a system supporting
100,000,000 operations per second
on the SPECjbb benchmark
35
Tier 2
ICM Agent
Peripheral Gateways
CallManager
Publisher
Server
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
CallManager
Subscriber
Server
ICM Router/Logger
Side A
J
T
A
P
I
C
T
I
PG
Locations
Voice
Gateways
PG
PG
ICM Router/Logger
Side B
PG
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
GED -125
CTI
CallManager
Subscribe
Server
Tier 3
ICM
Central Controller
JTAPI CTI
CurrentAnalysis says:
CallManager remains a work in progress.
Cisco has only recently started to add features common to all
traditional PBX platforms.
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
37
38
39
40
41
if
no
CC
F
s nes
d
ee deli
c
ex gui es
a
ay acy cas
Cisco requires separate
v
A cur all
telephone numbers for TTY and
ac in
o
sc
i
, C es
g
n
ss h no
ti
i
s
m t
e
9 t ntly n wi
2
.7 ica eve s
G
s
if
In sign ines et lo
el ack
d
i
p
gu
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
Cis
test co fail
s co ed 1
ndu 4 of
cted the
by T 18
olly
voice messaging
Bottom Line:
Test results show that the
Avaya TTY over IP
implementation provides
dramatically more accurate and
robust transport when
compared with both Cisco
offerings
The Tolly Group
Tolly
tests
TTY
42
Avaya IP
Result
Cisco Result
Pass
Pass
Fail
Pass
Pass
Fail
Speed Dial
Pass
Pass
Fail
Touchtone Operation
Pass
Pass
Fail
Test
Tolly
tests
TTY
43
Tolly
tests
TTY
Avayas results are
dramatically better than
Ciscos because Avayas
technological approach is
fundamentally different than
Ciscos
The Tolly Group
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
44
45
46
Traditional security risks, i.e. toll fraud protection factored lightly by Mier
2005 Avaya Inc. All rights reserved.
47
Media Encryption
48
49
50
7905G
7912G
794x
7902G
7910
LIMITED
ATA-188
ATA-186
7935
796x
7936G
7920G
IP
Softphone
ENDPOINT
SUPPORT
797x
Support Cisco
Encryption
7911G
51
52
53
54
Thank You!