Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Philosophy of Mind
Week 4: Objections to Behaviorism
The Identity Theory
Carnap:
Psychology in Physical
Carnap (1891-1970) was a
Language
dedicated physicalist who
believed that everything
in the world is physical
He argues that we can
take any sentence that
seems to describe a
mental experience or
event and rewrite it in a
completely physical
language.
Logical Behaviorism:
objections
Logical behaviorism seems plausible for
Logical behaviorism:
dispositions
According to Carnap, at least some mental
(1926-) is also a
physicalist, but he
criticized logical
behaviorism and
contributed to the
development of an
alternative theory.
imagines a race of
Super-Spartans who
are culturally trained
never to show any signs
of pain.
We can even imagine a
race of X-Worlders who
not only never show
pain, but they never
even talk about pain.
Response