Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
KINDS
Section 148-181
Contract of Agency Section 182-238
Applicability of
Law of Contract
Applicability of Law of
Contract
Law applicable where
Parties belong to different
countries
Applicability of Law of
Contract
Applicability of Law of
Contract
Law applicable where different
Laws in different Provinces:
UCC
The UCC often holds parties to "commonly
accepted practices" or "industry
standards." Only persons familiar with this
business should be held to these
standards.
Universal
Precise, Certain and Uniform
Fair, Reasonable and Equitable
Continuous
Not to be Illegal and Immoral
CONTRACT ACT
DEFINITIONS & Scope
Contractdefined Sec
2(h)
An agreement enforceable by law
is a contract
Contracts
Proposaldefined
Sec
2(a)
When one person signifies to
another his willingness to do or to
abstain from doing any thing, with a
view to obtaining the assent of that
other to such act or abstinence, he
is said to make a proposal.
Promise
Consideration
Agreement
Difference between
Agreements and
CONTRACT
AGREEMENT
Formation: An offer and
Formation: An agreement
Contracts
acceptance makes an
and its enforceability make a
1.
1.
agreement.
2.Legal Oblig.: May or may not
create a legal obligation.
3.Scope: All agreements are
not contracts.
4.Binding: All agreements are
not binding on the concerned
parties.
contract.
2.Legal Oblig.: Creates a legal
obligation.
3.Scope: All contracts are
agreements.
4.Binding: Are all binding on
the concerned parties.
Essentials of Valid
Contract
ContractsEssentials
According to section 10 of Contract Act
1872;
All agreements are contracts if they are
made by the--Free Consent of parties competent to
contract,
for a lawful consideration and with a
lawful object, and are not hereby
expressly declared to be void
certain.
8. Possibility of performance.
9. Contract to be Registered & in Writing,
wherever required.
10.Contract Not Declared Void under the
Act.
Contracts
Essentials
The offer is the beginning part of an
agreement
in itself does not create a legal
Offer
& but
Acceptance
relationship. The acceptance of the offer
creates a legal relationship.
Offer has two parts:
Essentials of a Valid
Offer
8.
9.
Offer must be
Distinguished from
An invitation to treat :
Where a party is initiating negotiations
he is said to have made an invitation to
treat. An invitation to treat cannot be
accepted to form a binding contract.
There are four types of invitation to treat:
Types of Invitation to
Treat
1. Auction sales
2. Advertisements
3. Exhibition of goods for sale
4. An invitation for tenders
Case
An advertisement of goods for sale is an
attempt to induce offers.
Partridge v Crittenden 1968
Mr. Partridge placed an advertisement
for Bramblefinch cocks, branblefinch
hens, 25s each.
Case Decision
A prosecution was brought against him
for offering for sale a brambling in
contravention of the Protection of Birds
Act 1954. The justices convicted
Partridge and he appealed.
Decision:
The conviction was quashed. Although
there had been a sale in contravention of
the Act, the prosecution could not rely on
the offence of offering for sale, as the
advertisement only constituted an invitation
to treat.
Case 3
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots
Cash Chemists 1952
Certain drugs could only be sold under the
supervision of a registered pharmacist. The
claimant claimed this rule had been broken by
Boots who displayed these drugs in a self-service
shop. Boots contended that there was no sale until
a customer brought the goods to the cash desk
and offered to buy them. A registered pharmacist
was stationed at this point.
Case Decision
Decision:
The court found for Boots and
commented that if it were true that a
customer accepted an offer to sell by
removing goods from the shelf, he could
not then change his mind and put them
back as this would constitute breach of
contract.
Question?
Answer
Revocation/Termination of
an Offer
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Case 1
Decision 1
Decision:
The original offer of 1,000 had been
terminated by the counter-offer of 950.
Case 2
Decision 2
Decision:
The letter of revocation could not take
effect until received (20 October); it
could not revoke the contract made by
the telegram acceptance of the offer on
11 October
Essentials of Valid
Acceptance
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Acceptance by Offeree
Absolute & Unconditional.(Example pg.22)
Prescribed Manner. (Example pg.23)
Communication with Offeror.
Express: words spoken or written. Implied:
by conduct or action.
Acceptance must be made after offer, not
before.
Reasonable time.(Case by case if no time specified)
ContractsEssentials
Legal Relationship:
the agreement must lead to a legal
relationship between the parties.
The parties must have intention to
create legal relationship. Social
agreement does not create any
legal relationship, hence not a
contract enforceable by law.
ContractsEssentials
Legal Consideration:
According to sec 23 the consideration or
object of an agreement is lawful if it is not
forbidden by any law or not fraudulent or
does not cause injury to a person or
property or not immoral.
Essential of Valid
Consideration
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Exceptions to
Consideration
1.
Exceptions to
Consideration
3.
Time Barred Debt: A debt not claimed in three years from the due
date. Is an agreement made in writing and signed by the debtor to
pay wholly or in part a time-barred debt. Requirements:
a)
Debt must be time-barred.
b)
Promisor must be liable for the debt.
c)
Must be an express promise to pay a time-barred debt.
d)
Promise must be writing and signed by the debtor or his agent.
4.
5.
6.
Completed Gift
Contract of Agency: The agent may or may not charge
commission.
Remission by Promisee: If a creditor gives up a part of his
claim, there is no need for consideration. Also an extension to
an agreement does not need to be supported by consideration.
Nature of Minors
Agreement
An agreement with a minor is void from the beginning and any monies
passed on to the minor are not recoverable.
A minor, upon reaching age of majority can not ratify an agreement that was
made by him/her, when he/her was a minor, because a contract with a minor
is void from the beginning.
Even if a minor falsely claims to be of the age of majority, still the contract
would not be binding, but monies could be returned if the court compels the
minor, if the minor brings a suit against the other party.
A person who supplies necessaries to a minor or anyone whom the minor is
bound to support, can recover reasonable value of such goods from the
property of a minor.
If the minor already possesses necessaries at the time when it is supplied to
him/her than the supplier can not recover value of those necessaries.
A contract made by a guardian on behalf of the minor, made within the
guardians authority and for the benefit of the minor, is binding on the minor.
A minor can be a beneficiary of a contract but the minor can not bear any
obligation in that contract.
Disqualified Person
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Free Consent
Consent shall be treated as free if not
obtained by:
Coercion
Undue influence
Fraud
Misrepresentation
Coercion
Coercion
defined in sec 15
Coercion is the committing , or
threatening to commit, any act
forbidden by the Pakistan Penal
Code or the unlawful detaining ,
or threatening to detain, with the
intention of causing any person
to enter into an agreement.
Coercion
Scope of Coercion
Where something or end purpose
achieved by use of unlawful force or
achieved by threat of unlawful force
shall be coercion.
o Commit or Threat to Commit
o Unlawful detention / seizure or
confiscation of property shall amount to
coercion
o Threat to a Third party
o If suit is filed in Pakistan then the
Pakistan Penal code is applied
Effect of Coercion
The contract is voidable at the option of the party
whose consent is obtained by coercion.
When the aggrieved party decided to cancel the
contract, he/she must return any benefit received
from the other party.
The other party to whom money was paid and
anything given under coercion must be returned.
If the aggrieved party does not decide to cancel
the contract, then it is a valid contract.
* Burden is on party wishing to cancel the
contract because of coercion.
Difference between
Coercion & Undue
Influence
Coercion
Nature
Coercion is a physical threat to party or person.
Illegal & Unfair
Doing or threatening to do an illegal act.
Penal Action
Penal action taken against guilty party.
Parties
Coercion maybe against the party to the agreement or a
third party.
Relationship
No specific relationship between parties is required.
Refund or Benefit
Aggrieved party has to refund benefit received from the
other party.
Effect
Contract is voidable at the option of the aggrieved party.
Punishment
Involves criminal liability.
Undue Influence
Nature
Undue influence is a mental or moral threat.
Illegal & Unfair
Act may not be illegal just unfair.
Penal Action
No penal action taken.
Parties
Influence applied on the party to the agreement.
Relationship
There must be a specific relationship between the
parties.
Refund or Benefit
The court may require the aggrieved party to refund
benefit received from the other party.
Effect
The contract is voidable or the court may cancel or
enforce it in a modified form.
Punishment
Does not involve criminal liability.
Fraud
Fraud as defined in Section 17:
Fraud
(1) the suggestion, as a fact, of that
which is not true, by one who does
not believe it to be true;
(2) the active concealment of a fact
by one having knowledge or belief of
the fact;
(3) a promise made without any
intention of performing it;
(4) any other act fitted to deceive;
(5) any such act or omission as the law
specially declares to be fraudulent.
Types of Fraud
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Essentials of Fraud
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Effect of Fraud
The aggrieved party can:
1.Cancel the contract.
2.Avoid the performance of the contract.
3.Ask for specific performance of contract.
4.Demand his position be restored to the
one that existed before the fraud.
5.Sue for damages.
Misrepresentation
Misrepresentation
defined in section
18:
Misrepresentation means and
includes
(1) the positive assertion, in a
manner not warranted by the
information of the person making it, of
that which is not true, though he
believes it to be true (Example pg.57);
Misrepresentation
(2) any breach of duty which, without an
Difference Between
Fraud &
Misrepresentation
FRAUD
Intention
Intention is to deceive the other party.
Belief
Knows the statement is untrue.
Damages
Aggrieved party can avoid contract
and claim damages.
Offence
Is a criminal act.
Truth
Aggrieved party can avoid contract
even if it had the means to find out
the truth with ordinary diligence.
MISREPRESENTATION
Intention
No intention to deceive.
Belief
Believes statement to be true.
Damages
Can avoid contract but not claim
damages.
Offence
Is not a criminal act.
Truth
Cannot avoid contract if it had the
means to discover the truth with
ordinary diligence.
ContractsEssentials
Lawful Object:
The purpose of the agreement
should not be against the law. For
example: the contract in restraint
of trade shall not be valid contract
under section 27 of Contract Act.
Kind of Contracts
ContractsKind
Valid contract ( Already
Discussed)
ii.
Voidable contract
iii.
Void contract
iv.
Unenforceable contract
v.
Express contract
vi.
Implied contract
vii.
Executed contract
viii.
Executory contract
ix.
Contingent Contract
i.
ContractsKind
Voidable Contract
According to section 2(i):
ContractsKind
Voidable Contract:
Void Contract
Void Contract
Situations of void contract
Impossibility of performance sec
56
Legal contract may became void
due to some illegality afterwards.
Revocation of a voidable contract
by the party at whose option, the
contract is avoidable becomes
void contract
Void Agreement
Agreements expressly declared
void
Agreement in restraint of marriage
(Example pg.66)
27)
Agreements in restraint of legal
proceedings (sec 28) (Example pg.68)
Uncertain agreements (sec 29)
Wagering agreements (sec 30)
Unenforceable Contracts
Such contracts are unenforceable
before a court of law due to some
technical defects such as nondeposit of court fee, submission
of unsigned documents, absence
of writing, wherever writing
required, absence of registration,
wherever required under law. On
removal of these discrepancies, the
contract becomes enforceable.
Kind of Contracts
Executed
contract:
Such contracts are those where
counter parties have completely
performed their respective
obligations under the contract.
Executory contract:
In such contracts both parties
are yet to perform their
obligations under the contract.
ILLUSTRATIONS:
Contingent Contract
Scope
of Contingent contract
Contingency to be collateral (connected) to the
contract.
Contingency to be condition precedent. The event
must occur for the performance of the contract.
Contingent contract leads to absolute obligations
and enforceable in the following circumstances:
o On happening of the event or
o On fulfillment of condition stipulated.
Modes of Discharge of
Contract
A
Quasi (Constructive)
Contracts
Quasi Contracts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Examples of Quasi
Contracts
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Breach of Contract
Remedies for Breach of Contract
1. Suit for damages: Sec 73
2. Suit for specific performance (sec.12 to20 0f Specific
Relief Act, 1877)
i.
Kinds of damages:
Liquidated damages
--section 74 stipulates that if parties to a
contract have mentioned the amount of
damages for the breach at the time of
entering into contract, such damages
shall be recoverable and these will be
called as liquidated damages, liquidated
damages also signify a fair and
reasonable estimate of loss which a party
may suffer due to breach of contract.
contract
Kinds of damages:
ii. Nominal damages:
--The court may under its discretion
allow nominal damages even in a case
where a person has not suffered any
financial losses but in recognition of his
right to compel the other party for
performance under the contract. Such
damage is usually concerned with nonpecuniary losses which are not easy to
ascertain.
contract
Kinds of damages:
ii. Nominal damages:
For instance an injury to ones
reputation,
in defamation, the pain and the
sufferings are the damages in such
cases which are difficult to be
ascertained in money terms so court
can award nominal or general damages
to the injured party/ aggrieved party.