Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Article 38.1:
The Court, whose function is to decide in accordance with international law
such disputes as are submitted to it, shall apply:
d. subject to the provisions of Article 59, judicial decisions and the teachings of
the most highly qualified publicists of the various nations, as subsidiary means for the
determination of rules of law.
TheInternationalCourtofJustice(ICJ)isthemainjudicialtribuna
loftheUnited Nations,towhich allmemberstatesareparties.
ItisofteninformallyreferredtoastheWorldCourt.TheICJwas
establishedin1946bytheUnitedNations(StatuteoftheInterna
tionalCourtofJustice[ICJStatute],June26,1945.
ItreplacedtheformerPermanentCourtof
InternationalJustice,whichhadoperatedwithinTheHague,Net
herlands,since1922.Likeits
predecessor,theheadquartersoftheICJisalsolocatedinthePe
acePalaceatTheHague.
ThefunctionoftheICJistoresolvedisputesbetwe
ensovereignstates.Disputesmaybeplaced
beforethecourtbypartiesuponconditionsprescri
bedbytheU.N.SecurityCouncil.Nostate,
however,maybesubjecttothejurisdictionofthe
courtwithoutthestate'sconsent.Consentmaybe
givenbyexpressagreementatthetimethedisput
eispresentedtothecourt,byprioragreementto
acceptthejurisdictionofthecourtinparticularcat
egoriesofcases,orbytreatyprovisionswith
respecttodisputesarisingfrommatterscoveredb
ythetreaty.
Article36(2)ofthecourt'sstatute,kn
ownastheOptionalClause,allowsst
atestomakea
unilateraldeclarationrecognizing"as
compulsoryipsofactoandwithoutsp
ecialagreement,inrelationtoanyoth
erstateacceptingthesameobligatio
n,thejurisdictionoftheCourtinalll
egaldisputes."
Manystateshaveacceptedthecourt'sjurisdictionundertheOptionalClau
se.Afewstateshavedonesowithcertainrestrictions.TheUnitedStates
forinstance,hasinvokedthesocalledself-
judgingreservation,orConnellyReservation.
Thisreservationallowsstatestoavoidthecourt'sjurisdictionpreviouslyac
ceptedundertheOptionalClauseiftheydecidenottorespondtoparticul
arsuit.Itiscommonlyexercisedwhenastatedeterminesthataparticular
disputeisof
domesticratherthaninternationalcharacter,andthusdomesticjurisdictio
napplies.Ifastate invokestheself-
judgingreservation,anotherstatemayalsoinvokethisreservationagainst
that state,andthusasuitagainstthesecondstatewouldbedismissed.
Thisiscalledtheruleof
reciprocity,andstandsfortheprinciplethatastatehastorespondtoasui
tbroughtagainstit
beforetheICJonlyifthestatebringingthesuithasalsoacceptedthecour
t'sjurisdiction.
UndertheICJStatute,theICJmustde
cidecasesinaccordancewith
International Law
.ThismeansthattheICJmustapply(
1)anyinternationalconventionsand
treaties;(2)internationalcustom;(3)
generalprinciplesrecognizedaslaw
bycivilizednations;and(4)judiciald
ecisionsandtheteachingsofhighlyq
ualifiedpublicistsofthevariousnatio
Onecommontypeofconflictpresented
totheICJistreatyinterpretation.
InthesecasestheICJisaskedtoresolve
disagreementsoverthemeaninganda
pplicationoftermsintreatiesformedbe
tweentwoormorecountries.Othercas
esrangefromnucleartestingandwate
rboundarydisputestoconflictsoverthe
militarypresenceofaforeigncountry
TheICJismadeupof15juristsfromdifferentcountries.Notw
ojudgesatanygiventimemaybefromthesamecountry.The
court'scompositionisstaticbutgenerallyincludesjuristsfrom
avariety ofcultures.
Despitethisdiversityinstructure,theICJhasbeencriticizedf
orfavoringestablishedpowers.Under
articles3and9oftheICJStatute,thejudgesontheICJshould
represent"themainformsofcivilizationandprincipallegal
systemsoftheworld."ThisdefinitionsuggeststhattheICJdoe
s
notrepresenttheinterestsofdevelopingcountries.Indeed,fe
wLatinAmericancountrieshave
acquiescedtothejurisdictionoftheICJ.Conversely,mostdev
elopedcountriesacceptthe compulsoryjurisdictionoftheICJ.
ThejudgmentoftheICJisbindingand(technically)cann
otbeappealed(arts.59,60)oncethepartieshavecons
entedtoitsjurisdictionandthecourthasrenderedade
cision.However,astate'sfailuretocomplywiththejudg
mentviolatestheU.N.Charter,article94(2).Noncompli
ancecanbeappealedtotheU.N.SecurityCouncil,which
mayeithermakerecommendationsorauthorizeotherm
easuresbywhichthejudgmentshallbeenforced.Adeci
sionbytheSecurityCounciltoenforcecompliancewitha
judgmentrenderedbythecourtissubjecttotheVeto
powerofpermanentmembers,andthusdependsonthe
members'willingnessnotonlytoresorttoenforcement
measuresbutalsotosupporttheoriginaljudgment.
heICJalsomayrenderADVISORYOPINIONSonle
galquestionswhenrequestedtodosobytheGe
neralAssembly,theSecurityCouncil,orotherU.
N.organsoragencies.Forexample,theWorldHe
althOrganizationandtheGeneralAssemblyrequ
estedadvisoryopinionsonthelegalityof
Nuclear Weapons
underinternationallaw.TheWorldCourtheldhe
arings,inwhich45nationstestified.Itissuedan
advisoryopinioninJuly1996,whichheldthatit
wasillegalforanationtothreatennuclearwar.
Thecourtisusedinfrequently,whichsuggeststhatmoststatesprefertoh
andletheirdisputesbypoliticalmeansorbyrecoursetotribunalswheret
heoutcomemaybemorepredictableorbettercontrolledbytheparties.S
ince2000,someofthecontentiouscasesbeforetheICJincludedapropert
ydisputebetweenLiechtensteinandGermany;aterritorialandmaritime
disputebetweenNicaraguaandColombia;aland,island,andfrontierdis
putebetweenElSalvadorandtheHonduras(Nicaraguaintervening);and
a2003casebyMexicoagainsttheUnitedStatesoverallegedviolationsof
consularcommunicationswithandaccessto
severalMexicannationalssentencedtodeathinvariousU.S.statesforcri
mescommittedwithin.A1993casefiledbyBosniaagainsttheformerYug
oslaviaforviolatingtheGenocideConventionwasstillpendingin2003,as
wasamatterbetweentheRepublicofCongoandFranceoverallegedcri
mesagainsthumanity.TrialsagainstindividualsforallegedWar Crimes
againsthumanityorgenocidesinvolvingBosnia,Croatia,Kosovo,Serbia,
andtheformerYugoslaviawerebeinghandledbytheInternationalCrimin
alTribunalfortheformerYugoslavia,aseparateU.N.tribunal.
TheICJhasbeenmalignedfortheinc
onsistencyofitsdecisionsanditslac
kofrealenforcementpower.Butitsa
mbitiousmissiontoresolvedisputes
betweensovereignnationsmakesit
avaluablesourceofsupportformany
countriesintheirpoliticalinteraction
withothercountries.
Strengths of the UN
Provides a forum for almost all of the worlds
nations to discuss international issues
Humanitarian efforts
AIDS
Landmine removal
Food and supply organization
Peacekeeping forces
Will get involved with messes that no one
else will
Weaknesses of the UN
Sanctions are only effective if ALL countries follow
them (Iraq example)
Military force is rarely used and is usually ineffective
ALL permanent members of the security council
have to vote unanimously (one country can stop a
sanction)
Inadequate funding by member nations
14 Countries Pay 85% of the subscriptions (membership
fee)
Big gap between developing and industrialized
nations