INDICATORS Edalyn R. Capili, R.N. Metropolitan Medical Center College of Medicine Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities Definition: Proportion of population with access to a sanitary facility for human excreta disposal in the dwelling or immediate vicinity POLICY RELEVANCE Purpose: To monitor progress in the accessibility of the population to sanitation facilities. Relevance to Sustainable/Unsustainable Development: This represents a basic indicator useful for assessing sustainable development, especially human health. Accessibility to adequate excreta disposal facilities is fundamental to decrease the fecal risk and the frequency of associated diseases. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities •.Its association with socioeconomic characteristics (education, income) and its contribution to general hygiene and quality of life also make it a good universal indicator of human development. When broken down by geographic (such as rural/urban zones) or social or economic criteria, it also provides tangible evidence of inequities. International Conventions and Agreements: Agenda 21 UNCED (1992) indicates the need for universal coverage and the Second World Water Forum and Ministerial Conference, The Hague, March 2000 established the target of universal coverage by the year 2025. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities International Targets/Recommended Standards: International targets for this indicator have been established under the auspices of the World Health Organization (WHO). The Vision 21 of the Water Supply and Sanitation Collaborative Council provides targets of 100% coverage by the year 2025. Linkages to Other Indicators: The indicator is closely associated with other socioeconomic indicators, particularly the proportion of population with access to improved water sources. The indicator represents two of the eight elements of primary health care. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities METHODOLOGICAL DESCRIPTION UN Commission on Sustainable Development 76 WHO (a) Underlying Definitions and Concepts: Sanitary facility: "A unit for disposal of human excreta which isolates feces from contact with people, animals, crops and water sources. Suitable facilities range from simple but protected pit latrines to flush toilets with sewerage. All facilities, to be effective, must be correctly constructed and properly maintained". Population covered: Includes urban and rural population served by connections to public sewers; (pit privies, pour-flush latrines, septic tank, etc.) Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities (b) Measurement Methods: This indicator may be calculated as follows: Numerator: number of people with improved excreta- disposal facilities available multiplied by 100. Denominator: total population. (c) Limitations of the Indicator: The availability of facilities does not always translate into their utilization. METHODOLOGICAL DESCRIPTION (a) The amount of waste treated or disposed of under different methods is closely related to the national policy on waste management: incentives for minimization, recycling/recovery, stricter legislation for waste to be land filled (e.g. ban on land filling of combustible waste) and differentiated taxation. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities Recycling - any reprocessing of material in a production process that diverts it from the waste stream, except reuse as fuel. Both reprocessing as the same type of product, and for different purposes should be included. Direct recycling within industrial plants at the place of generation should be excluded. Composting - biological process that submits biodegradable waste to anaerobic or aerobic decomposition, resulting in a product (compost) that is added to soil to improve fertility. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities Incinerating - thermal treatment of waste during which chemically fixed energy of combusted matters is transformed into thermal energy. Combustible compounds are transformed into combustion gases leaving the system as flue gases. Incombustible inorganic matters remain in the form of slag and fly ash. Incinerating includes incinerating with or without energy recovery. Percent of the Population with Adequate Sewage Disposal Facilities Landfilling - depositing waste into or onto land, in a controlled manner. It includes specially engineered landfill and temporary storage of over one year on permanent sites. The definition covers both landfill in internal sites (i.e. where a generator of waste disposes of its own waste at the place of generation) and in external sites. Landfill waste includes all amounts going to landfill, either directly or after sorting and/or treatment. Controlled landfilling requires submission to a permit system and technical control procedures in compliance with the national legislation in force. Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 Households with Sanitary Toilet, Satisfactory Disposal of Solid Waste and Complete Basic Sanitation Facilities By Region, Province and City Philippines, 2015 ACTION PLAN 2010-2013 ACTION PLAN 2010-2013 ACTION PLAN 2010-2013 The 2011-2016 Philippine Development Plan Results Matrices Presidential Decree No. 856 “The Code on Sanitation of the Philippines” • mandates DOH to promote and preserve public health and upgrade the standard of medical practice. • Manual on Hospital Management was published in 1997 and the Implementing Rules and Regulations of Chapter XVIII, Refuse Disposal of PD 856 was promulgated. • The Manual on Hospital Management recommended color-coding scheme for segregated wastes to avoid any accidents or hazards to personnel. • When the DOH released the IRR of Chapter XVIII, the classification of refuse/solid waste was expanded by recognizing the existence of different types of hospital waste such as biodegradable waste, chemical waste, infectious waste, pharmaceutical waste, pathological waste, and radioactive waste. Presidential Decree No. 856 “The Code on Sanitation of the Philippines” • The IRR also provides the detailed sanitary requirements for the segregation, storage, collection, transportation, and disposal of refuse/solid waste. • Health Care Waste Management Manual • In 2002, the Bureau of Health Facilities and Services of the DOH requires hospitals to submit the approved plan on health care waste management prior to issuance or renewal of license. The said office likewise required hospital establishments to submit plans of wastewater treatment facilities. • Other DOH Requirements: • DOH Department Circular No. 156-C, series of 1993 “Provides guidelines on hospital waste management” Presidential Decree No. 856 “The Code on Sanitation of the Philippines” • Specific instructions include: • "All undevolved government hospitals, clinics, laboratories, and research offices shall incorporate satisfactory segregation, treatment, collection and disposal systems." • "All infectious and hazardous hospital waste shall be treated before storage, collection and disposal." • "The use of appropriate technologies and indigenous materials for storage, treatment, collection and disposal of hospital waste shall be utilized to support the country's socioeconomic development program." Presidential Decree No. 856 “The Code on Sanitation of the Philippines” • "All hospitals and other related institutions shall inform their staff and personnel about the proper treatment, segregation (color coding) and storage, collection and disposal of hospital waste" DOH Memorandum No. 1-A, series of 2001 • “Requiring the Department of Health Central Office, Centers for Health Development, and all concerned hospitals to practice proper solid waste management”. Presidential Decree No. 1586 “Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) System” • Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) System of the Philippines or PD 1586 requires projects like construction of new hospital buildings or expansion of existing hospitals to secure an Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) prior to construction and operation of the facility. • ECC is required for the installation and operation of health care waste treatment systems like pyrolysis, autoclave, microwave, landfills, and other similar treatment technology. • Under the EIS System, a project proponent is tasked to undertake an environmental impact assessment (EIA) study and to prepare an EIS or an IEE, depending on the scope of the project. Laws, Policies, Guidelines and Protocols DOH-DENR Joint Administrative Order No. 02 series of 2005 dated August 24, 2005 entitled “Policies and Guidelines on Effective and Proper Handling, Collection, Transport, Treatment, Storage and Disposal of HCW” • Joint Administrative Order aims to: a) provide guidelines to generators, transporters and operators/owners of TSD Facilities on proper handling, collection, transport, storage, treatment and disposal of HCW; b) clarify the jurisdiction, authority and responsibility of the DENR and DOH with regard to HCWM; and c) harmonize efforts of DENR and DOH on HCWM. Republic Act No. 9003 “Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000” • The Act mandates segregation of solid wastes at the source including households and institutions like hospitals by using separate container for each type of waste from all sources. Comparison between UNDP and DOH Indicators • UNDP National goals are more ideal compared to what Philippine Department of Health programs, laws and guidelines, this is probably because of our economy wherein a large budget and manpower will be necessary in order to implement and achieve goals. • DOH policies are somewhat inclined with the UNDP’s example of which are programs pertaining to health promotion and prevention such as promotion of hand washing and having hand washing facilities particularly at school. • Also there is a thrust in the DOH program in creation of public/community restrooms in communities that have no access to a restrooms or doesn’t have proper sewage disposal. Comparison between UNDP and DOH Indicators • DOH programs are more focused on community level and there is a lacking national policy on implementation on programs of sanitation whereas UNDP’s program focuses on large scale across the population. • Most of those governments assets and facilities are readily available in the urban areas and lesser to rural areas which should be the main focus of DOH programs. • DOH programs are emphasized to government institutions more often and private hospitals have their own guidelines and ways of implementing their programs concerning sanitation and waste management. Recommendations • The way a country manages its waste has significant long-term implications for public health, the economy and the natural environment. • Therefore, it is critical to promote an environmentally sound waste treatment and disposal program. • Satisfactory waste management indicates that authorities are aware of the health and the environmental risks and that they support or impose suitable measures to prevent or to reduce waste. • Concern stems from both distrust of policies and solutions proposed by all tiers of government for the management of solid waste and a perception that many solid waste management facilities use poor operating procedures. Recommendations • Healthcare personnel particularly frontline services like sanitary inspectors and engineers should be trained more and exposed on how international standards are implemented. • Policies/guidelines should be strictly implemented together with necessary penalties cause by failure to adhere to the said standards. • There should be more consultative dialogues on community people and leaders so that they will be more aware of how they can participate with the implementation of the programs Recommendations • There should be a periodic unannounced audit from a third party so as to ensure that goals are met and so that necessary adjustments can me made based on the evaluation and recommended. • There should be a solid, not fragmentalized program of sanitation and waste management and this can be realized by making some amendments with our existing laws like our Sanitation Code and Solid Waste Management Act. • Coordination with other international NGO’s and health care organization might help us with regards to the appropriate model we can use that is based on our countries needs and current situation References • National Objectives for Health 2011-2016 • DOH Epidemiology Bureau: Field Health Service Information System Annual Report 2015 • The 2011-2016 Philippine Development Plan Results Matrices • Indicators of Sustainable Development: Framework and Methodologies • UNDP Indicators and a Monitoring Framework for the Sustainable Development Goals June 12, 2015