Cluster 4 Acceptance Report

Bali Teams
SUMMARY| CLUSTER 4
Coverage Quality Throughput
4G : RSRP > -90 dBm 4G : SINR > 5 dB 4G DL Throughput > 8 Mbps
Cluster SOW 3G : RSCP > -92 dBm 3G : EcNo > -12 3G DL Throughput > 1.5 Mbps
2G : RxLevel > -85 dBm 2G : RxQual < 3
Before After Delta Status Before After Delta Status Before After Delta Status
LTE 7.14% 14.89% Improve 41.36% 38.19% Improve 28.22% 32.93% Improve

Bali 3G 29.61% 69.31% Improve 63.85% 78.63% Improve 17.83% 49.23% Improve
Cluster 4 2G DCS 85.87% 67.81% 59.98% 52.53%
2G GSM 96.24% 97.47% Improve 60.87% 52.50%

2G 3G LTE Bandwidth (Cells)

SOW (NE)
Physical Take Completion
SWAP Total TRX Number of Carrier 5MHz 10MHz 15MHz 20MHz
Site Out
2G 3G 4G Before After (%) Before After (%) Before After Before After Before After Before After

66
Cluster_4 30 0 63 95% 479 479 100% 51 51 100.0 0 0 15 15 1 1 0 0
33 23 10 0%

4G| OSS KPI

RRC Setup SR (Service) E-RAB Setup SR (All) Call Setup SR Service Drop Rate Intra-Frequency Handover Out SR
Cluster Remaks Total Score
Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After

Cluster_4 PASS 117.5 99.79 99.89 99.90 99.86 99.66 99.70 0.34 0.21 96.98 99.34

3G| OSS KPI

CSSR_CS CSSR_PS CSSR_HSDPA CSSR_HSUPA CCSR_CS CCSR_PS CCSR_HSDPA CCSR_HSUPA SHO ISHO IFHO
Total
Cluster Remaks Score Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After
Cluster_4 PASS 128.5 98.99 99.76 97.20 97.86 98.98 99.66 99.04 99.67 98.52 99.22 99.06 99.98 97.55 99.24 98.45 99.25 91.80 99.83 99.72 92.64 94.62 96.58

2G| OSS KPI

SDSR TCH Block TBF DL TDR TBF Comp HOSR DL Qual
Cluster Remaks Total Score
Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After

Cluster_4 PASS 124.6 96.29 99.04 0.10 0.00 99.87 99.96 0.78 0.51 96.74 98.54 97.30 97.32 0.00 96.91
PRODUCTIVITY| CLUSTER 4
Traffic Tren Cluster 4
14000
12000
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01
4/2 5/2 6/2 7/2 8/2 9/2 0/2 1/2 2/2 3/2 4/2 5/2 6/2 7/2 5/2 6/2 7/2 8/2 9/2 0/2 1/2 2/2 3/2 4/2 5/2 6/2 7/2 8/2
/1 /1 /1 /1 /1 /1 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 3/
1
3/
1
3/
1
3/
1
3/
1
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
3/
2
12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12

HUAWEI NOKIA

Payload Tren Cluster 4

6000000

5000000

4000000

3000000

2000000

1000000

0
17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18
/ 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20 / 20
4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 14 15 16 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
/1 /1 /1 /1 /1 /1 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 /2 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/
12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12

HUAWEI NOKIA
PRODUCTIVITY| CLUSTER 4 (CONT’D)

TCH Traffic (Erlang) Decrease Payload(GB) Increase

System
Before After Delta % Before After Delta %
TOTAL 77282.29 76767.998 -514.29 -0.67% 32416495.19 32613590.84 197095.7 0.61%
OVERALL | IDLE UNLOCK - TECH
TECH TECH
BEFORE

AFTER
KPI Remarks % Improvement
4G Before 22.23%
Improve
Percentage After 41.82%
3G Before 56.69%
Improve
Percentage After 56.83%
2G Before 21.07%
Percentage Improve
After 1.33 %

 4G RAN Improve 19.59 % after swap

OVERALL | IDLE UNLOCK – RSRP, RSCP, & RX LEVEL
RSRP
BEFORE

System KPI Remarks %

Good Before 33.69%
4G
Level >90dBm After 43.63%
Good Before 39.82%
3G
Level >92dBm After 67.89%
Good Before 86.36%
2G
Level >85dBm After 53.60%
OVERALL | IDLE UNLOCK – RSRP, RSCP, & RX LEVEL
RSRP
AFTER

System KPI Remarks %

Good Before 33.69%
4G
Level >90dBm After 43.63%
Good Before 39.82%
3G
Level >92dBm After 67.89%
Good Before 86.36%
2G
Level >85dBm After 53.60%
OVERALL | IDLE UNLOCK – SINR, EC/IO, & RX QUAL
SINR
BEFORE

System KPI Remarks %

Good Before 60.71%
4G
Level >5dBm After 58.51 %
Good Before 61.78%
3G
Level >-12dBm After 86.01%
Good Before 57.73%
2G
Level > 3dBm After 80.00%
OVERALL | IDLE UNLOCK – SINR, EC/IO, & RX QUAL
SINR
AFTER

System KPI Remarks %

Good Before 60.71%
4G
Level >5dBm After 58.51 %
Good Before 61.78%
3G
Level >-12dBm After 86.01%
Good Before 57.73%
2G
Level > 3dBm After 80.00%
CLUSTER 04 | 4G ACHIEVEMENT
4G KPI | SUMMARY
Key Performance Indicator Before After
LTE
Session Setup SR (%) 97.47 100
Session Abnormal Release Rate (%) 0.00 0.00
Intra LTE HO SR 100.00 100.00
Inter LTE HO SR 100.00 100.00
DL User Throughput >= 1.5Mbps 55.96% 59.31%
UL User Throughput >= 500Kbps 38.34% 28.81%
RSRP >= -90dBm 7.14% 14.89%
SINR >= 5dB 41.36% 38.19%

RRC Setup SR (Service) E-RAB Setup SR (All) Call Setup SR Service Drop Rate Intra-Frequency Handover Out SR
Cluster Remaks Total Score
Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After

Cluster_4 PASS 117.5 99.79 99.89 99.90 99.86 99.66 99.70 0.34 0.21 96.98 99.34
4G | COVERAGE
RSRP RSRP
BEFORE

AFTER
RSRP>=-90 dBm RSRP>=-90 dBm
7.14% 14.89%

 4G Coverage for RSRP >= -90 dBm Improve from 7.14% to 14.89%
4G | QUALITY
SINR SINR
BEFORE

AFTER
SINR>=5 dB SINR>=5 dB
41.37% 38.19%
 4G Quality for SINR >= 5 dB Degrade from 41.37 % to 38.19%
4G | DOWNLINK THROUGHPUT
DL Throughput DL Throughput
BEFORE

DL Thp>=1.5 DL Thp>=1.5

AFTER
Mbps Mbps
55.96% 59.31%
 4G Downlink Throughput >= 1.5 Improve from 55.96% to 59.31%
4G | UPLINK THROUGHPUT
UL Throughput UL Throughput
BEFORE

UL Thp>=0.5 UL Thp>=0.5

AFTER
Mbps Mbps
38.34% 28.81%
 4G Uplink Throughput >= 0.5 Mbps Degrade from 38.34% to 28.81%
User Experience
3G and 4G CET Results
Speed test Comparison
Functionality Test Result 3G
UL (Mbps)
Delta
DL (Mbps)
Delta 4G
UL (Mbps)
Delta
DL (Mbps)
Delta
Before After Before After Before After Before After
City Bali POI1 4.47
3.44 4.68 1.23
4.67 0.21 17.04
15.55 18.24
24.05 1.2 8.5 POI1 23
10.96 30.15
22.15 7.15
11.19 16.99
15.96 39.19
21.25 22.2
5.29
System GSM/DCS/3G/LTE POI2 1.85
2.48 4.78
3.30 2.93
0.82 13.46
12.42 22.36
18.25 8.95.83 POI2
POI2 12.91
10.03 30.24 17.33
25.02 14.99 23.79
12.07 31.82
23.94 8.03
11.87
POI3 4.51
0.78 4.31
2.20 -0.2
1.42 16.22
11.83 15.53
13.02 -0.69
1.19 POI3 9.71 32.3 22.59 22.67 30.73 8.06
Cutover 9 & 19 February 2018 POI3 20.64 23.58 2.94 22.25 27.30 5.05
POI4
POI4 3.42 4.38 0.96
0.02 14.05 18.23 4.18 POI4 20.45 6.06 -14.39 15.68 19.44 3.76
Total Pilot Sites 10 Sites 4.30 4.32 11.30 20.45 9.15 POI4 16.27 17.37 1.1 11.96 32.16 20.2
POI5 3.41 4.65 1.24 12.41 17.96 5.55 POI5 7.03 22.15 15.12 14.32 29.25 14.93
System Test Status POI5 4.43 4.64 0.21 8.16 12.56 4.4 POI5 4.20 22.48
26.68 9.56 14.35 37.03 22.68
AVE 3.53 4.56 1.03 14.64 18.46 3.83 AVE 14.62 24.18 18.69 30.09 11.40
AVE 3.08 3.82 0.74 11.85 17.66 5.81 AVE 12.42 22.96 10.54 15.31 28.33 13.01
4G Speed Test OK
4G CSFB to 3G OK CLUSTER 4 by CET/POI Spots
4G 3G Fast Return OK
4G 2G Fast Return OK
4G USSD Check OK
4G X Sector OK
3G Voice Call OK
3G Speed Test OK
3G USSD Check OK
3G X Sector OK
2G Voice Call OK
2G Speed Test OK Average Throughput
2G USSD Check OK DL Throughput UL Throughput
2G X Sector OK (Mbps) (Mbps)
Mobility 4G to 4G HO OK
3G 17.66 3.82
Mobility 3G to 3G Data HO OK
Mobility 3G to 3G Voice HO OK 4G 28.33 22.96
Mobility 2G to 2G Voice HO OK
CLUSTER 04 | 3G ACHIEVEMENT
3G KPI | SUMMARY
Key Performance Indicator Before After Remark
UMTS

CSSR Voice 85.35%

DropCall 4.46% 2.80%

Attach SR 70.25%

PDP SR 51.50%
SHO SR 100% 100%
ISHO SR 0% 0%
IFHO SR 0% 0%

RSCP >=-92 29.61% 69.31%

EcNo >=-12dB 63.85% 78.63%

DL User Throughput >1.5Mbps 17.83% 49.23%

MOS > 3 48.23% 74.52%

CSSR_CS CSSR_PS CSSR_HSDPA CSSR_HSUPA CCSR_CS CCSR_PS CCSR_HSDPA CCSR_HSUPA SHO ISHO IFHO
Total
Cluster Remaks Score Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After
Cluster_4 PASS 128.5 98.99 99.76 97.20 97.86 98.98 99.66 99.04 99.67 98.52 99.22 99.06 99.98 97.55 99.24 98.45 99.25 91.80 99.83 99.72 92.64 94.62 96.58
3G | COVERAGE
RSCP RSCP
BEFORE

AFTER
RSCP>=-92 dBm RSCP>=-92 dBm
29.61% 69.31%

 3G Coverage for RSCP >= -92 dBm improve from 29.61 % to 69.31 %
3G | QUALITY
EcNo EcNo
BEFORE

AFTER
EcNo>=-12 dB EcNo>=-12 dB
63.85% 78.65%

 3G Quality for EcNo >= -12 dB improve from 63.85 % to 78.65 %

 3G | DOWNLINK THROUGHPUT
DL Throughput DL Throughput
BEFORE

AFTER
DL Thp>=1.5
DL Thp>=1.5
Mbps
Mbps
49.23%
17.83%

 3G Downlink Throughput >= 1.5 Mbps improve from 17.83 % to 49.23 %

3G | MOS
MOS MOS
BEFORE

AFTER
MOS>= 3 MOS>= 3
48.23% 74.52%

 3G MOS >= 3 improve from 48.23 % to 74.52 %

CLUSTER 04 | 2G ACHIEVEMENT
2G KPI (DCS) | SUMMARY
Key Performance Indicator Before After Remark
2G
CSSR Voice 90.83 %
DropCall 9.17 %
Attach SR 55.87 %
PDP SR 27.7 %
HOSR 96.67%
RxLevel >=-90 dBm 85.87% 67.81%
RxQual 0-5 59.98% 52.53%
SQI >=18 37.25% 56.09%
DL User Throughput >20Kbps 74.32% 89.59%

SDSR TCH Block TBF DL TDR TBF Comp HOSR DL Qual

Cluster Remaks Total Score
Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After

Cluster_4 PASS 124.6 96.29 99.04 0.10 0.00 99.87 99.96 0.78 0.51 96.74 98.54 97.30 97.32 0.00 96.91
2G | COVERAGE
RxLev RxLev
BEFORE

AFTER
RxLev>=-90 dBm RxLev>=-90 dBm
85.87% 67.81%

 2G Coverage for RxLevel >= -90 dBm Degrade from 85.87% to 67.81%
2G | QUALITY
RxQual RxQual
BEFORE

AFTER
RxQual 0-5 RxQual 0-5
59.98% 52.53%

 2G Quality for RxQual 0 to 5 Degrade from 59.98% to 52.53%

2G | DOWNLINK THROUGHPUT
DL Throughput DL Throughput
BEFORE

AFTER
DL Thp>= 20 Kbps DL Thp>= 20 Kbps
74.32% 89.59%

 2G Downlink Throughput >= 20 Kbps Improve from 74.32 % to 89.59 %

2G | SQI
SQI SQI
BEFORE

AFTER
SQI>= 18 SQI>= 18
37.25% 56.09%

 2G SQI >= 18 Improve from 37.25 % to 56.09 %

2G KPI (GSM) | SUMMARY
Remark
Key Performance Indicator Before After s
2G
CSSR Voice 70 %
DropCall 5.7%
Attach SR 23.17 %
PDP SR 27.7 %
HOSR 100 %
RxLevel >=-90 dBm 96.24 % 97.47%
RxQual 0-5 60.87% 52.50%
SQI >=18 52.48% 62.28%
DL User Throughput >20Kbps 74.88% 92.82%

SDSR TCH Block TBF DL TDR TBF Comp HOSR DL Qual

Cluster Remaks Total Score
Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After Before After

Cluster_4 PASS 124.6 96.29 99.04 0.10 0.00 99.87 99.96 0.78 0.51 96.74 98.54 97.30 97.32 0.00 96.91
2G (GSM)| COVERAGE
RxLev RxLev
BEFORE

AFTER
RxLev>=-90 dBm RxLev>=-90 dBm
96.24% 97.47%

 2G Coverage for RxLevel >= -90 dBm improve from 96.24% to 97.47%
2G (GSM)| QUALITY
RxQual RxQual
BEFORE

AFTER
RxQual 0-5 RxQual 0-5
60.87% 52.50%

 2G Quality for RxQual 0 to 5 Degrade from 60.87 % to 52.50 %

2G (GSM)| DOWNLINK THROUGHPUT
DL Throughput DL Throughput
BEFORE

AFTER
DL Thp>= 20 Kbps DL Thp>= 20 Kbps
74.88% 92.82%

 2G Downlink Throughput >= 20 Kbps Improve from 74.88 % to 92.82 %

2G (GSM)| SQI
SQI SQI
BEFORE

AFTER
SQI>= 18 SQI>= 18
52.48% 62.28%

 2G SQI >= 18 improve from 52.48 % to 62.28 %

 4G BADSPOT | COVERAGE
TOTAL
RSRP RSRP BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
RSRP 7 7
BEFORE

AFTER
RSRP>=-90 dBm
7.14% RSRP>=-90 dBm
14.89%

SINR SINR TOTAL BEFOR

BADSPOT E AFTER
SINR 7 9
New
badspot
BEFORE

AFTER New

SINR>=5 dB
badspot SINR>=5 dB
41.37% 38.19%
 4G | BADSPOT QUALITY
SINR

New
Site
New
badspot
1

New
Site
New
badspot
3
AFTER

Problem Detail Recommendation

Bad Coverage Bad coverage due to contour and long Need audit site BLI001ML
distance 4.92 KM Need Audit Site BLI054
Propose NewSite
 4G | BADSPOT QUALITY
SINR
2

New
Site
New
badspot
1

New
Site
New
badpot
2
AFTER

Problem Detail Recommendation

Bad Coverage Bad coverage due to contour and long Need audit site GIN011ML
distance 4.67 KM Propose NewSite
 3G | BADSPOT

RSCP RSCP
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
RSCP 7 2
BEFORE

AFTER
RSCP>=-92 dBm RSCP>=-92 dBm
29.61% 69.31%

EcNo EcNo TOTAL

BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
Ecno 7 3
BEFORE

AFTER
EcNo>=-12 dB EcNo>=-12 dB
63.85% 78.65%
 3G | BADSPOT
MOS MOS
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
MOS 7 3
BEFORE

AFTER
MOS>= 3 MOS>= 3
48.23% 74.52%

DL Throughput DL Throughput
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
DL 10 5
BEFORE

AFTER

DL Thp>=1.5 Mbps DL Thp>=1.5 Mbps

17.83% 49.23%
 BADSPOT 2G DCS
RXLEVEL BEFORE RXLEV AFTER
TOTAL
New BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
bad RxLev 5 5
spot Rx Qual 11 11

New
bad
New spot
bad
spot

New
bad
spot

RXQUALBEFORE RXQUAL AFTER

 2G | BADSPOT COVERAGE
Rxqual
1 2
New bad spot 1

New bad spot 2

New bad spot 3

AFTER

New bad
spot 4
4

Problem Detail Recommendation 3

Bad Coverage Bad spot #1bad coverage rxlev due to
contour, coverage site from side lobe sec3
BLI023
badspot#2bad coverage rxlev due to
blocking by threes coverage site BLI031
badspot#3bad coverage rxlev due to
contour distance to site is 2.30 km
already cell edge

badspot#4bad coverage rx lev due to no

dominant serving cell BLI070_need audit
 BADSPOT 2G DCS
RLC DL BEFORE RLC DL AFTER
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
RLC DL 16 14
SQI 18 16

v
v

SQI BEFORE SQI AFTER

 2G (GSM)| BADSPOT
RxLev RxLev TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
Rxlev 2 0
BEFORE

AFTER
RxLev>=-90 dBm RxLev>=-90 dBm
96.24% 97.47%

RxQual RxQual TOTAL

BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
RxQual 6 6
BEFORE

RxQual 0-5 AFTER RxQual 0-5

52.50%
60.87%
 2G (GSM)| BADSPOT
SQI SQI
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
SQI 2 0
BEFORE

AFTER
SQI>= 18 SQI>= 18
52.48% 62.28%

DL Throughput DL Throughput
TOTAL
BADSPOT BEFORE AFTER
DL 7 3
BEFORE

AFTER
DL Thp>= 20 Kbps DL Thp>= 20 Kbps
74.88% 92.82%