The document discusses authorship and acknowledgements for scientific manuscripts. It notes that many journals now require descriptions of each author's contributions to address abuse where some try to take shortcuts to authorship. True authorship requires significant contributions to theory, experimental work, data interpretation, or writing, while routine tasks like proofreading deserve acknowledgement but not authorship. Crediting those who made no meaningful contribution amounts to scientific fraud. The document stresses integrity in authorship is important for scientific integrity overall.
The document discusses authorship and acknowledgements for scientific manuscripts. It notes that many journals now require descriptions of each author's contributions to address abuse where some try to take shortcuts to authorship. True authorship requires significant contributions to theory, experimental work, data interpretation, or writing, while routine tasks like proofreading deserve acknowledgement but not authorship. Crediting those who made no meaningful contribution amounts to scientific fraud. The document stresses integrity in authorship is important for scientific integrity overall.
The document discusses authorship and acknowledgements for scientific manuscripts. It notes that many journals now require descriptions of each author's contributions to address abuse where some try to take shortcuts to authorship. True authorship requires significant contributions to theory, experimental work, data interpretation, or writing, while routine tasks like proofreading deserve acknowledgement but not authorship. Crediting those who made no meaningful contribution amounts to scientific fraud. The document stresses integrity in authorship is important for scientific integrity overall.
G.J.E.C. 10 – 13th September, 2018 Authorship and Acknowledgements
• Many journals now require a description of the
contributions of each author on a submitted manuscript. • This is because authorship has been abused by those trying to take shortcuts. • These days, we see manuscripts with huge numbers of authors. • It is almost impossible for most of these to have made a significant contribution to the work.
• QUESTION: What is your experience working with other
researchers? Authorship and Acknowledgements
What constitutes authorship?
A. Only significant contributions to theory, experimental
work, data interpretation, or writing, qualify one for authorship.
B. Performance of routine checking, proofreading, editing,
etc. should be acknowledged, but does not qualify one for authorship. Authorship and Acknowledgements
Science cannot have any integrity if scientists do not.
Crediting people with authorship, when they made no such