ISSN 2175-5280

),/0(
$³=21$'2&5,0(´


(;3(',(17(
($/(,'20$,6)257(
0DUFHO)LJXHLUHGR*RQoDOYHV
Instituto Brasileiro de Ciências Criminais

8PDXWRPyYHOGHOX[RFRPRYLGURWmRHVFXUHFLGRTXHQmRVHSRGHYHURTXHSRU
DIRETORIA DA GESTÃO 2009/2010
GHQWURGHOHVHSDVVD2UHÀH[RTXHWUD]FRPRXPHVSHOKR¿HOjUHDOLGDGHpRGHPDQ
V}HVFRPMDUGLQVTXHOHPEUDPSLQWXUDV(VVHpRFRQGRPtQLRPH[LFDQRGHOX[RFKD
Presidente: Sérgio Mazina Martins
PDGR/D=RQDWtWXORRULJLQDOGR¿OPH³=RQDGR&ULPH´'LULJLGRSRU5RGULJR3OiR¿OPH
1º Vice-Presidente: Carlos Vico Mañas
IRL YHQFHGRU GR SUrPLR ),35(6&, GD &UtWLFD ,QWHUQDFLRQDO GR )HVWLYDO GH &LQHPD GH
2ª Vice-Presidente: Marta Cristina Cury Saad Gimenes
7RURQWRGRSUrPLR/XLJL'H/DXUHQWLLVGR)HVWLYDOGH9HQH]DHWDPEpP
1ª Secretária: Juliana Garcia Belloque
GRVSUrPLRVGHPHOKRUGLUHomRHIRWRJUD¿DGR)HVWLYDOGH&DUWDJHQD
2º Secretário: Cristiano Avila Maronna
1º $LQWHQomRGRGLUHWRUpFODUDHDVVXPLGDGRLQtFLRDR¿PGRGUDPDTXDOVHMDDGH
Tesoureiro: Édson Luís Baldan
2º Tesoureiro: Ivan Martins Motta
HVFDQFDUDURVSUREOHPDVVRFLDLVQRVTXDLVHVWDPRVWRGRVPHUJXOKDGRVDELSRODULGDGH
HQWUHULFRVHSREUHVRHJRtVPRHRLQGLYLGXDOLVPRGHXPDVRFLHGDGHDOWDPHQWHFRPSOH
[DRGHVFDVRSDUDFRPRVSUREOHPDVVRFLDLVQRVVRVDGHVFRQ¿DQoDHRGHVFUpGLWRQDV
CONSELHO CONSULTIVO:
LQVWLWXLo}HVS~EOLFDVDFRUUXSomRHRPDXIXQFLRQDPHQWRGDVPHVPDVHGHQWUHWDQWDV
Carina Quito, Carlos Alberto Pires Mendes, Marco Antonio Rodrigues Nahum,
RXWUDVTXHVW}HVRULVFRGHVHID]HULQMXVWLoDFRPDVSUySULDVPmRV2VSUREOHPDVQRV
Sérgio Salomão Shecaira, Theodomiro Dias Neto
VmRSDVVDGRVFRPWDQWDFODUH]DHUHDOLVPRTXHXPDUHÀH[mR±DLQGDTXHEUHYH±WRUQD
VHREULJDWyULD

&RPHoDVHFRPXPGRVSURWDJRQLVWDVGRHQUHGRTXHp0LJXHODQRVUHSUHVHQ
WDQWHGDIDFHWDGDSREUH]DHH[FOXVmRVRFLDO1XPDQRLWHFKXYRVDGLVWUDLQGRVHFRP
VXDQDPRUDGDHGRLVDPLJRVGHQWURGHXP{QLEXVHVWDFLRQDGRSHUFHEHHOHDTXHGD
GHXP³RXWGRRU´VREUHDPXUDOKDGRFRQGRPtQLR$SURYHLWDQGRVHGRGHIHLWRFDXVDGR
Publicação do Departamento de Internet do IBCCRIM
QDVFkPHUDVGHVHJXUDQoDSULYDGDHQWUDPRVUDSD]HVSDUDIXUWDUHPXPGRVFDVDU}HV

1RLQWHULRUGDUHVLGrQFLDPXLWREHPGHFRUDGDQDTXHOHPRPHQWRHVFXUDFRPHoDP
DEPARTAMENTO DE INTERNET
DIXUWDUREMHWRVYDOLRVRVSULQFLSDOPHQWHMyLDV$HVFXULGmRpLQWHUURPSLGDSHORDFHQGHU
GHXPDEDMXUe0HUFHGHVSURSULHWiULDGRLPyYHOYHVWLGDFRPVHX
Coordenador-chefe:
URXSmR EUDQFR TXH OKHV DSRQWD XPD DUPD ³VROWHP WXGR WXGR´
Luciano Anderson de Souza
0LJXHOSRUWUiVGDPXOKHUDFHUWDOKHDFDEHoDFRPXPDEHQJD
ODVDQJUDPXLWR6RDVHRDODUPHVDHPWRGRVFRUUHQGR2VGRLV
Coordenadores-adjuntos:
DPLJRV GH 0LJXHO VmR PRUWRV QD WURFD GH WLURV FRP RV YL]LQKRV
PDVHOHFRQWLQXDYLYR&RUUHPDVQmRIRJH1mRIRJHSRUTXHRV
João Paulo Orsini Martinelli
PXURV TXH FHUFDP
Luis Eduardo /D =RQD VmR UHDOPHQWH DOWRV SURWHJLGRV FRP
Crosselli
DUDPHVIDUSDGRVFHUFDVHOpWULFDVHFkPHUDVRTXHMiGHPRQVWUD
Regina Cirino Alves Ferreira
XPD UHDOLGDGH FODUDPHQWH YLYLGD QRV WHPSRV DWXDLV D EXVFD SRU
VHJXUDQoD

Revista Liberdades
5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH
Revista Liberdades- -nº nº22 -- setembro-dezembro de2009
setembro-dezembro de 2009 22

 5(6(1+$

.$).$(175(2%5,/+2'$-867,d$($
%(/(=$'26$&86$'26
$QD*DEULHOD0HQGHV%UDJD

6XPiULR
,QWURGXomR'LDQWHGD/HL1D&RO{QLD3HQDO2UDVWHORH2SURFHVVRGRLV
SRGHUHVHPH[HUFtFLR&RQVLGHUDo}HV)LQDLVREULOKRTXHRIXVFDHDEHOH]DHVTXH
FLGD%LEOLRJUD¿D

5HVXPR
(VWHDUWLJREXVFDFRPSUHHQGHUFRPRDMXVWLoDHDSXQLomRJDQKDPIRUPDQDFRQV
WUXomRNDINLDQDDSDUWLUGDDQiOLVHGDSDUiEROD'LDQWHGD/HLHGDQRYHOD1D&RO{QLD
3HQDO(VVHVGRLVHVFULWRVGH.DINDUHWUDWDPIRUPDVGLIHUHQWHVGHH[HUFtFLRGRSRGHU
(QTXDQWRHP1D&RO{QLD3HQDODLQGDVHREVHUYDRH[HUFtFLRGRSRGHUVREHUDQRFRPD
DSOLFDomRGD³SXQLomRH[HPSODU´HP'LDQWHGD/HLHHP23URFHVVRRSRGHUDVVXPH
DIRUPDGDGLVFLSOLQDHYLJLOkQFLDHPXPH[HUFtFLREXURFUDWL]DGRHDQ{QLPR7DQWRHP
XPTXDQWRHPRXWURRDFXVDGRQmRFRQVHJXHVHD¿UPDUSHUDQWH$/HLVHXEULOKRR
RIXVFDHVXDPiTXLQDpLPSODFiYHOPDVDRVROKRVGH.DINDDLQGDUHVWDDRVDFXVDGRV
DEHOH]D

3DODYUDV&KDYH
.DINDMXVWLoD±SXQLomR1D&RO{QLD3HQDO'LDQWHGD/HL

,1752'8d­2

&RQIRUPHUHYHODPRVHVFULWRVtQWLPRVGH.DNIDGLiULRVH
FDUWDVDOLWHUDWXUDSDUDHOHHUDQHFHVViULDXUJHQWH$IRUPDomRMXUtGLFDHRHPSUHJR
EXURFUiWLFRHPXPDFRPSDQKLDGHVHJXURVJDUDQWLDPRVHXVXVWHQWRPDWHULDOPDVD
OLWHUDWXUDHUDRVHXDOLPHQWR

2RItFLRGHHVFULWRUHUDVXSHUGLPHQVLRQDGRHPUHODomRjVGHPDLViUHDVGDYLGDGR
DXWRUHGHDOJXPDIRUPDDVDEVRUYLD(P.DINDRVFRQÀLWRVIDPLOLDUHVSULQFLSDOPHQWH
FRPRSDLRRItFLRGRDUWLVWDRXQLYHUVRMXUtGLFRWXGRVHWRUQDOLWHUDWXUD

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
 .DINDFRQKHFHSRUGHQWURRPXQGRGDMXVWLoDTXHGHVFUHYHVHPQRHQWDQWRHVWDU
GHQWURGHOH3HUFRUUHRVPHDQGURVGHVVHVLVWHPDQDSHOHGHSHUVRQDJHQVTXHSRXFR
FRPSUHHQGHPVHXIXQFLRQDPHQWRMXVWDPHQWHSRUTXHHVWHIXQFLRQDPHQWRQmRpGDGRD
FRPSUHHQV}HVDRPHQRVQmRSDUDDTXHOHVDTXHPDOHLVHGLULJHRXVRETXHPSHVD
DDXWRULGDGH

2SRGHUHP.DNIDDVVLPFRPRHP)RXFDXOWDVVXPHGLYHUVDVIRUPDVeH[HUFLGR
VREDIRUPDGDDXWRULGDGHWUDGLFLRQDOSDWHUQDHP29HUHGLFWRH&DUWDDR3DL1RH[HU
FtFLRGDVREHUDQLDHP1D&RO{QLD3HQDO(GHIRUPDPDLVSHVVRDOHDQ{QLPDWtSLFDGD
PRGHUQLGDGHFRPRQDVREUDV2&DVWHORH23URFHVVRQDVTXDLVRKRPHPpFRQIURQ
WDGRFRPDEXURFUDFLDLPSHQHWUiYHOGRDSDUHOKRHVWDWDO

1HVVHSHTXHQRDUWLJRPHGHEUXoDUHLHVSHFL¿FDPHQWHQDDQiOLVHGDSDUiEROD'LDQ
WH GD /HL H GD QRYHOD 1D &RO{QLD 3HQDO 1mR WHQKR R REMHWLYR GH GHPRQVWUDU TXDO D
YHUGDGHRXDPRUDOTXHSHUPHLDPHVVDVKLVWyULDVPDVVLPGHFRPSUHHQGHUDSDUWLU
GHODVHGHVHXVSHUVRQDJHQVTXDLVIRUPDVGHMXVWLoDHGHSXQLomRHVWmRSUHVHQWHVQD
FRQVWUXomRNDINLDQD

eDSDUWLUGDDomRGRSRGHUVREUHRLQGLYtGXRTXH.DINDFRQVWUyLVXDVQDUUDWLYDVGDt
RSDSHO³HVSHFLDO´TXHRVDFXVDGRVRFXSDPHPVXDREUD1DDQiOLVHGH:DOWHU%HQ
MDPLQDEHOH]DQRPXQGRNDINDQLDQRVyDSDUHFHQRVOXJDUHVPDLVREVFXURVRXVHMD
HQWUHRVDFXVDGRV

³e XP IHQ{PHQR QRWiYHO GH FHUWR PRGR FLHQWt¿FR 1mR SRGH VHU D
FXOSD TXH RV ID] PDLV EHORV QmR SRGH VHU R FDVWLJR MXVWR TXH GHVGH Mi
RVHPEHOH]DVySRGHVHUXPSURFHVVRPRYLGRFRQWUDHOHVTXHGHDOJXP
PRGRDGHUHDVHXFRUSR´   

.DINDDSXG%HQMDPLQS

2PDLVLQWULJDQWHpTXHHVVDEHOH]DPHQFLRQDGDSRU%HQMDPLPHSHORSUySULR.DIND
QmRpIUXWRGDSURPHVVDGHXPEHORIXWXURRXGDFHUWH]DGHHPDOJXPPRPHQWRGHV
SHUWDUGRSHVDGHORFRWLGLDQRPDVDRFRQWUiULRGDGHVHVSHUDQoDGRVDFXVDGRV$LGHQ
WL¿FDomRGH.DINDFRPWDLVSHUVRQDJHQVDSDUHFHQDFRQ¿GrQFLDDRDPLJR0D[%URG
³KiHVSHUDQoDVX¿FLHQWHLQ¿QLWDPDVQmRSDUDQyV´

',$17('$/(,
³(PUHODomRDRWULEXQDOYRFrVHHQJDQDGLVVHRVDFHUGRWH1RVWH[WRV
LQWURGXWyULRV j OHL FRQVWD R VHJXLQWH D UHVSHLWR GHVVH HQJDQR´ .DIND
$S

$VSDODYUDVGRFDSHOmRGRSUHVtGLRDRLQWURGX]LUDSDUiEROD³'LDQWHGDOHL´D-RVHSK

 $SDUiEROD'LDQWHGD/HLFRPS}H23URFHVVRSRUpP.DINDDSXEOLFRXDLQGDHPYLGDHPXPDUHYLVWD

DOHPm

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
.GL]HPPXLWRVREUHDKLVWyULDTXHDVVHJXLUi3ULPHLURSHORIDWRGHODFRQVWDUGRVWH[WRV
GHLQWURGXomRjOHL7HFQLFDPHQWHRVWH[WRVTXHLQWURGX]HPDVOHLVVmRGHQRPLQDGRV
³H[SRVLomRGHPRWLYRV´HQHOHVROHJLVODGRUH[S}HRVYDORUHVHLQWHQo}HVTXHQRUWHD
UDPDHODERUDomRGDOHL2IDWRGHHVVHWH[WRSUHFHGHUDOHLHDTXLQmRVmRGLYHUVDVOHLV
PDV$/HLVRDTXDVHFRPRXPDOHUWDDRVGHVDYLVDGRVDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPWH[WROHJDO
QmRJDUDQWHRDFHVVRjMXVWLoDHDRVLJQL¿FDGRGDOHL

'HSRLVSRUMiDQXQFLDUXPHQJDQRQDIRUPDFRPRRLQGLYtGXRHDTXLWDQWR-RVHSK.
TXDQWRRKRPHPGRFDPSRYrDMXVWLoD8PDELVPRRXLQ¿QLWDVSRUWDVVHSDUDPRKR
PHPFRPXPGDOHL2PLWRGDUDFLRQDOLGDGHPRGHUQDpUHSUHVHQWDGRQRSULPHLURSHQ
VDPHQWRGRKRPHPGRFDPSRDRGHSDUDUFRPDMXVWLoD³$/HLKDYLDGHVHUDFHVVtYHO
DWRGDDJHQWHHVHPSUHSHQVDHOH´HSRUWDQWRQmRSRGHULDKDYHUWDQWDVGL¿FXOGDGHV
SDUDDGHQWUDUQRPXQGRGD-XVWLoD

1DSDUiERODXPKRPHPGRFDPSRSHGHDRSRUWHLURTXHRGHL[H³HQWUDUQDOHL´(VWH
OKHUHVSRQGHGL]HQGRTXHpSRVVtYHOPDVQmRQDTXHOHPRPHQWR3DVVDVHRWHPSRR
KRPHPHVSHUDHOHRSRUWHLURHDSRUWD³DEHUWDFRPRVHPSUH´

'HVGHRLQtFLRRSRUWHLURRGHVD¿DDSHQHWUiOD³6HWDQWRWHDWUDLH[SHULPHQWDHQ
WUDUDSHVDUGDPLQKDSURLELomR&RQWXGRUHSDUDVRXIRUWH(DLQGDDVVLPVRXR~OWLPR
GRVJXDUGDV'HVDODSDUDVDODHVWmRJXDUGDVFDGDYH]PDLVIRUWHVGHWDOPRGRTXH
QmRSRVVRVHTXHUVXSRUWDURROKDUGRWHUFHLURGHSRLVGHPLP´

3RUpPHVWHJXDUGDpDSHQDVRSULPHLURGRVLQ~PHURVREVWiFXORVTXHVHDSUHVHQ
WDPDRKRPHPTXHVHDYHQWXUDQDEXVFDSHODMXVWLoD1HPPHVPRRJXDUGDTXHIDOD
DRKRPHPGRFDPSRSDUHFHFRQKHFHURVPHDQGURVGDMXVWLoDSDUDDOpPGDSRUWDTXH
SURWHJH(OHPHVPRWHPHHQmRSRGHVXSRUWDURROKDUGHRXWURTXHOKHpVXSHULRUHOH
PHVPRSDUHFHGHVFRQKHFHURLQWHULRUGDMXVWLoD6XDDomRpOLPLWDGDHORFDOL]DGD6H
JXHUHDOL]DQGRFRPLQGLIHUHQoDSHTXHQRVLQWHUURJDWyULRVDFHLWDVXERUQRDLQGDTXH
VDLED TXH QDGD SRGH ID]HU SHOR KRPHP GR FDPSR ´$FHLWR DSHQDV SDUD TXH WH FRQ
YHQoDVTXHQDGDRPLWLVWH´$LQGDTXHDSDUHoDFRPR³RKRPHPGDOHL´SHUDQWHRRXWUR
SRXFRFRQKHFHRVUHFLQWRVTXHJXDUGD

6HRDFHVVRjMXVWLoDpFRWLGLDQDPHQWHQHJDGRDRKRPHPFRPXPHPFRQWUDSDUWLGD
DVSRUWDVGHHQWUDGDGDMXVWLoDFULPLQDOHVWmRVHPSUHDEHUWDV1mRSDUDTXHRKRPHP
FRQKHoDRVHXIXQFLRQDPHQWRPDVDRFRQWUiULRSDUDTXHVHMDFDSWXUDGRSRUVXDVHQ
JUHQDJHQV

³$QDWXUH]DGRSURFHVVRUHVXOWDSRLVGDDUWLFXODomRHQWUHDLQYLVLELOLGDGH
GHXPWULEXQDOHRRFXOWDPHQWRGHXPD/HLHQWUHWDQWRDYDVVDODGRUD$
SUySULD /HL JRYHUQD D DOHDWRULHGDGH GRV SURFHGLPHQWRV 2FXOWD FRPDQGD
DLQYLVLELOLGDGHGDVFkPDUDVTXHDDSOLFDP6XDOyJLFDVHUiLQDFHVVtYHODR
ROKDUGDVRFLHGDGH'DtHQWUHWDQWRGHFODUDUVXDLQH[LVWrQFLDVHUiXPVDOWR
PRUWDO$OyJLFDGDOHLQmRpPHQRVOyJLFDSRUTXHRVTXHFRPDQGDPQmRVmR

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
 SXEOLFDPHQWHQRPHiYHLV´

/LPDS

2VLVWHPDGHMXVWLoDFULPLQDOH[HUFHVHXFRQWUROHGHIRUPDVHOHWLYDHYLROHQWDSULYLOH
JLDRLQJUHVVRQRVVHXVHVSDoRVGHDOJXPDVSHVVRDVRXFODVVHVGHSHVVRDVID]HQGR
PXLWDVYH]HVFRPTXHR~QLFRFRQWDWRGRLQGLYtGXRFRPDMXVWLoDHFRPRSRGHUS~EOLFR
VHMDSRUPHLRGDSROtFLDGRDFXVDGRURXGRMXL]TXHRFRQGHQD

1HVVHVHQWLGRDMXVWLoDpLPSODFiYHO2LQGLYtGXRQmRDFHVVDD-XVWLoDPDVHODFKH
JDDHOH2KRPHPQDFLGDGHRXQRFDPSRSHUPDQHFHGHVFRQKHFHQGRDOHLSRUpP
MiQmRGHVFRQKHFLGRGHODSDVVDDVHUSHQHWUDGRSHORFRQWUROHHPDUFDGRSHODSXQLomR
FRPRHP23URFHVVRH1DFRO{QLDSHQDOUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH

³$TXLQLQJXpPPDLVVHQmRWXSRGLDHQWUDUSRUTXHVySDUDWLHUDIHLWDHVWDSRUWD
$JRUD YRX PH HPERUD H IHFKRD´ $ IUDVH TXH HQFHUUD 'LDQWH GD /HL WDOYH] Gr FRQWD
GDFRPSOH[LGDGHGDUHODomRGRKRPHPFRPXPFRPDOHL$RPHVPRWHPSRHPTXHD
GLPHQVmRGHMXVWLoDTXHVHHVFRQGHDWUiVGDSRUWDQmRHVWiDRVHXDOFDQFHKiXPD
SRUWDHDRPHQRVXPJXDUGDTXHFXLGDPGDVXDPtVHUDH[LVWrQFLDTXHRYLJLDPSDUD
TXHHOHSHUPDQHoDQRPHVPROXJDUGLVWDQWHGDOHLHFRQWURODGRSRUHOD

'LYHUVDVOHLWXUDVGDSDUiERODFRQYHUJHPSDUDDPHVPDLQWHUSUHWDomRRTXHLPSHGH
RKRPHPGRFDPSRGHHQWUDUQDOHLpDIDOWDGHFRQ¿DQoDHPVLPHVPRHVXDFRYDUGLD
QRHQIUHQWDPHQWRGHXPVLVWHPDGHGLItFLOSHQHWUDomR

3DUD0LFKDHO/RZ\SSRJXDUGLmRGDSRUWDTXHLPSHGHDRKRPHPGR

FDPSRRDFHVVRjOHLUHSUHVHQWDXPDRUGHPGRPXQGRIXQGDGDVREUH³DPHQWLUD´³RKR
PHPGRFDPSRGHL[RXVHLQWLPLGDUQmRpDIRUoDTXHRLPSHGHGHHQWUDUPDVRPHGR
DIDOWDGHFRQ¿DQoDHPVLDIDOVDREHGLrQFLDjDXWRULGDGHDSDVVLYLGDGHVXEPLVVD´

1RPHVPRVHQWLGR0DUWKH5REHUWSD¿UPDTXH³RKRPHPGRFDPSR

HVWiSHUGLGRSRUTXHQmRRXVDFRORFDUDVXDOHLSHVVRDODFLPDGRVWDEXVFROHWLYRVGRV
TXDLVRJXDUGLmRSHUVRQL¿FDDWLUDQLD´

/RJRQRLQtFLRGH23URFHVVRRSUySULR-RVHSK.DTXHPRFDSHOmRGRSUHVtGLRQDU
UDDSDUiERODSHQVDTXHDPHOKRUIRUPDGHVHOLYUDUGRVJXDUGDVTXHRDFXVDPVHULD
QmRGDUOKHVLPSRUWkQFLDHVLPSOHVPHQWHDEULUDSRUWDPDVHOHPHVPRQmRRXVDID]rOR
.DIND$S

(PQHQKXPPRPHQWRRJXDUGLmRGL]TXHQmRpSRVVtYHODHQWUDGDDSHQDVUHSHWH
³pSRVVtYHOPDVQmRDJRUD´3DVVDPVHDQRVHRKRPHPVHJXHHVSHUDQGRHPYmR
&XUYDGRSDVVLYRHUHVLJQDGRHOHQmRDGHQWUDDSRUWD(VSHUDVHQWDGRQREDQTXLQKR
HDR¿QDOGDYLGDYrDSRUWDVHIHFKDU

$PLQXFLRVDFDUDFWHUL]DomRGRSRUWHLURHDDXWRH[DOWDomRGHVHXSRGHUFRQWUDVWDP
FRPDLQVLJQL¿FkQFLDGRKRPHPGRFDPSR'HOHVyVHVDEHTXHpXP³KRPHPGRFDP

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
SR´HLVVRPDLVTXHWXGRSDUHFHGH¿QLOR+3ROLWL]HUDSXG/LPDSFKDPD
DWHQomRSDUDRVLJQL¿FDGRGDH[SUHVVmR³KRPHPGRFDPSR´HPKHEUDLFRDPKRUH]
XPLJQRUDQWHQDGRXWULQDSREUHHLQFXOWRTXHVyFRPSUHHQGHRTXHSRGHDSUHHQGHU
SHORVVHQWLGRVRTXHQmRRFDVRGDOHL

'DtRXWUDIDFHLPSRUWDQWHGDUHODomRGRLQGLYtGXRFRPDOHL$VLPSOLFLGDGHGRKRPHP
FRQIRUPDVXDDWLWXGHGLDQWHGDOHLHID]GHOHDOYRIiFLOGRVLVWHPD³)D]SDUWHGDQDWX
UH]DGHVVHVLVWHPDMXGLFLDOFRQGHQDUQmRDSHQDVUpXVLQRFHQWHVPDVUpXVLJQRUDQWHV´
SUHVXPH.DIND%HQMDPLPS

$IDODGH-RVHSK.DRFDSHOmRHQTXDQWRGLVFXWLDPRVHQWLGRGDSDUiERODGHQRWDR
TXDQWRDSURGXomRGRVDEHUMXUtGLFRHDLQWHUSUHWDomRGHVHXVSUHFHLWRVVmRUHVHUYDGDV
D SRXFRV ³(VWDYD FDQVDGR GHPDLV SDUD WHU XPD YLVmR GH FRQMXQWR GH WRGDV DV FRQ
VHTrQFLDVGDKLVWyULDHUDPLQFOXVLYHUDFLRFtQLRVQmRKDELWXDLVDTXHHODVROHYDYDP
FRLVDVLUUHDLVPDLVDSURSULDGDVjGLVFXVVmRSDUDRFtUFXORGHIXQFLRQiULRVGRWULEXQDO
GRTXHSDUDHOH´3URFHVVRS

(P6REUHD4XHVWmRGDV/HLV.DINDDWULEXLRPRQRSyOLRGDSURGXomRHLQWHUSUHWDomR
GDVOHLVj³QREUH]D´6RPHQWHHVVHSHTXHQRJUXSRWHULDDFHVVRDRVGL]HUHVGDOHLSDUD
LQFOXVLYH TXDQGR QHFHVViULR FRORFDUVH IRUD GRV OLPLWHV OHJDLV$ LPSRVVLELOLGDGH GH
LQWHUSUHWDUPRVRWH[WRGDOHLQRVOHYDDRGHVFRQKHFLPHQWRGDVUHJUDVTXHQRVUHJHP
,VVRQRVpPRUWL¿FDQWHHDRPHVPRWHPSR³SURYDYHOPHQWHpLQHYLWiYHO´

³eFHUWRTXHQDREUDGH.DINDRGLUHLWRHVFULWRH[LVWHQRVFyGLJRVPDV
HOHVVmRVHFUHWRVHDWUDYpVGHVVHVDSUpKLVWyULDH[HUFHVHXGRPtQLRDLQGD
PDLVLOLPLWDGDPHQWH´   

%HQMDPLPS

1$&2/Ð1,$3(1$/
³(OHQmRFRQKHFHDSUySULDVHQWHQoD"

6HULDLQ~WLODQXQFLiOD(OHYDLH[SHULPHQWDUQDSUySULDFDUQH´ 
  .DINDS

³&DEHDRFXOSDGROHYDUjOX]GRGLDVXDFRQGHQDomRHDYHUGDGHVREUH
RFULPHTXHFRPHWHX6HXFRUSRPRVWUDGRSDVVHDGRH[SRVWRVXSOLFLDGR
GHYHVHUFRPRRVXSRUWHS~EOLFRGHXPSURFHVVRTXH¿FDUDDWpHQWmRQD
VRPEUDQHOHVREUHHOHRDWRGHMXVWLoDGHYHVHWRUQDUOHJtYHOSDUDWRGRV´

)RXFDXOWS

$QRYHOD1D&RO{QLD3HQDOVHSDVVDQRVWUySLFRV8POXJDUTXHQWHLVRODGRDWUDVD
GR/iDFXOSDpLQHTXtYRFDHDSXQLomRH[HPSODU1mRKiMXOJDPHQWRV±VmRFRQVLGH

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
UDGRVPXLWRGHPRUDGRVWUDEDOKRVRVHIDOKRV$VVLPRR¿FLDOGHFLGHTXHPpFXOSDGR
VHJXQGRXPSUHFHLWRGRDQWLJRFRPDQGDQWH³DFXOSDpVHPSUHLQGXELWiYHO´

$ FRO{QLD FRQWD FRP XP LQVWUXPHQWR SXQLomR PXLWR SDUWLFXODU R UDVWHOR PiTXLQD
REVROHWDFXMDVDJXOKDVPDUFDPDWUDQVJUHVVmRQRFRUSRGRFRQGHQDGRHUHD¿UPDP
RSRGHUGDOHL(VHUiMXVWDPHQWHDHQJHQKDULDGHVVDIRUPDGHSXQLomRDPiTXLQDH
VXDVHQJUHQDJHQVRFHQWURGDQRYHODGH.DIND

$FKHJDGDGHXPHVWUDQJHLURLQFXPELGRGHDYDOLDURLQVWUXPHQWRSXQLWLYRGDFRO{QLD
UHYHODRDWUDVRGDIRUPDGHMXVWLoDGRVWUySLFRVHPFRPSDUDomRFRPDVQRYDVIRUPDV
GHSRGHUHPH[HUFtFLRQDPHWUySROH3RUpPPHVPRDRVROKRVGRVSUySULRVKDELWDQWHV
GDFRO{QLDHVVDIRUPDGHSXQLomRFDUQDOGRORULGDS~EOLFDMiSDUHFLDXOWUDSDVVDGD
1LQJXpPPDLVDFRPSDQKDYDDDomRGRUDVWHORRTXHFRPSURPHWLDDH¿FiFLDGD³SXQL
omRH[HPSODU´XPDYH]TXHpSUHFLVRS~EOLFRSDUDGDUH[HPSOR

/LPDSFKDPDDWHQomRSDUDDLPSRUWkQFLDGDFRQGLomRGHHVWUDQJHLURGR

H[SORUDGRUHQTXDQWRHOHPHQWRH[WHUQRTXHSRGHULDFRORFDUHPG~YLGDHSRU¿PUHFXVDU
DOHJLWLPLGDGHGDVHQWHQoD2H[SORUDGRUFRQVLGHUDDIRUPDGHMXVWLoDGDFRO{QLDXP
SURFHGLPHQWRLQMXVWRHDH[HFXomRLQXPDQDFUXHO

25$67(/2(2352&(662'2,632'(5(6(0(;(5&Ë&,2
$IRUPDGHH[HUFtFLRGHSRGHUSUHVHQWHHP1D&RO{QLD3HQDOGLIHUHGDH[LVWHQWHHP
23URFHVVR'HDFRUGRFRP/LPDS³QmRVHWUDWDGDPHVPDMXVWLoD´$GLV
WkQFLDWURSLFDOSHUPLWLDDSHUVLVWrQFLDGHSUiWLFDVFRQGHQiYHLVQD(XURSD³pXPDUHPL
QLVFrQFLDGDIRUPDGHMXVWLoDDQWHULRUFRPVHXFDUiWHUH[LELWyULRHDUHWyULFDGDWRUWXUD´

$VLGHLDVLOXPLQLVWDVHDV5HYROXo}HVGRVpF;9,,,RFDVLRQDUDPSURIXQGDVPXGDQ
oDVQRVLVWHPDGHMXVWLoDRFLGHQWDOHQDIRUPDGRKRPHPUHODFLRQDUVHFRPHOH2V
SURFHGLPHQWRVVHWRUQDUDPFDGDYH]PDLVUDFLRQDLVHEXURFUiWLFRVHDSXQLomRSUHWHQ
VDPHQWHPDLVKXPDQD

$SDUWLUGHHQWmRXPDVpULHGHWH[WRVSURFODPDQGRGLUHLWRVHJDUDQWLDVLQGLYLGXDLV
SDVVDPDVHUSXEOLFDGRVDFRPHoDUSHOD'HFODUDomRGRV'LUHLWRVGR+RPHPHGR&L
GDGmRGHTXHGL]QRVHXDUWžTXH³2VKRPHQVQDVFHPHSHUPDQHFHPOLYUHVH
LJXDLVHPGLUHLWRV´

$UDFLRQDOLGDGHPRGHUQDSUHVFUHYHTXHDVOHLVGHYHPVHUFODUDVRMXOJDPHQWRMXVWR
HHTXkQLPHHDVSHQDVKXPDQL]DGDV0DUTXrVGH%HFFDULDFRPVXDREUD'RVGHOLWRV
HGDVSHQDVDRODGRGH5RXVVHDXH0RQWHVTXLHXIRLXPGRVSUHFXUVRUHVGHVVD
QRYD¿ORVR¿D³KXPDQL]DGRUD´SULQFLSDOPHQWHQRFDPSRSHQDO

2 SRGHU VREHUDQR Gi OXJDU DR H[HUFtFLR GH XP SRGHU GLVFLSOLQDU PDWHULDOL]DGR QR
PRGHOR GR SDQySWLFR EHQWKDPLDQR $SHVDU GDV LQVWLWXLo}HV GLVFLSOLQDUHV Mi H[LVWLUHP
DQWHULRUPHQWHIRLQDPRGHUQLGDGHTXHDGLVFLSOLQDVH¿[RXFRPRIRUPDVRFLDOGRSRGHU
6HJXQGR)RXFDXOWSDSHQDVQRGHFRUUHUGRVVpFV;9,,H;9,,,pTXHDV

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
GLVFLSOLQDVVHWRUQDUDPIRUPDVJHUDLVGHGRPLQDomRH[SDQGLQGRVXDDomRSDUDDOpPGDV
LQVWLWXLo}HVGHFRQ¿QDPHQWR

$VREHUDQLDFDUDFWHUL]DGDSHOD¿JXUDGRVREHUDQRHSRUUHODo}HVGHGRPLQDomRIRL
DIRUPDGHSRGHUTXHSUHYDOHFHXGHVGHD,GDGH0pGLDDWpRVpF;9,2SRGHUVREHUDQR
HUDGHVFRQWtQXRHODFXQDUHWLQKDSRUREMHWRRWHUULWyULRQmRRLQGLYtGXRQmRHVWDYDSUH
RFXSDGRFRPDIRUPDTXHDSRSXODomRYLYLDPDVDSHQDVFRPRVXFHVVRQRH[HUFtFLRGR
FRQ¿VFRHGRFRQWUROHWHUULWRULDO

1HVVHPRPHQWRDSULVmRDLQGDQmRHUDDSHQDSRUH[FHOrQFLD2VVXSOtFLRVSUHYD
OHFLDPHQTXDQWRSXQLomRH[HPSODUDJLQGRVREUHRFRUSRGRVV~GLWRVLPSLQJLQGROKHV
XPVRIULPHQWRFDOFXODGRHS~EOLFRFRPRLQWXLWRGHH[DOWDURSRGHUGRPRQDUFDUHD¿U
PDQGRVXDVREHUDQLDVREUHDTXHOHVTXHVHPRVWUDPLQLPLJRVGRUHL7DPSRXFRKDYLD
VHGHVHQYROYLGRRPRGHORDFXVDWyULRQDGHWHUPLQDomRGRMXt]RGDFXOSDTXHSUHVVXS}H
DRPHQRVIRUPDOPHQWHRUHVSHLWRDR³GHYLGRSURFHVVROHJDO´HjVJDUDQWLDVLQGLYLGXDLV

2UDVWHOROHPEUDDSXQLomRH[HPSODUGRVVXSOtFLRVQDUUDGRVSRU)RXFDXOWQRLQtFLRGH
9LJLDUH3XQLU$YLROrQFLDLPSLQJLGDSHORVVXSOtFLRVDLQGDTXHEUXWDHGHVFRPXQDOQmR
FDUHFLDGHUDFLRQDOLGDGH$RFRQWUiULRpPLOLPHWULFDPHQWHFDOFXODGDPHGLGDTXDQWLWDWLYD
HTXDOLWDWLYDPHQWHSURSRUFLRQDODRPDOFRPHWLGRHRUJDQL]DGDGHIRUPDULWXDOtVWLFDFRP
R¿PGHDVVHJXUDUDSHUSHWXDomRGRSRGHUVREHUDQRVREUHRLQGLYtGXR$H[HPSODULGDGH
GDSXQLomRVHXGHWDOKDPHQWRDVVLPFRPRVXDLQVFULomRQRFRUSRSRGHPVHUIDFLOPHQWH
UHFRQKHFLGRVQDGHVFULomRGRPHFDQLVPRGRUDVWHOR

³ 1RVVD VHQWHQoD QmR VRD VHYHUD 2 PDQGDPHQWR TXH R FRQGHQDGR

LQIULQJLX p HVFULWR QR VHX FRUSR FRP R UDVWHOR 1R FRUSR GHVWH FRQGHQDGR
SRUH[HPSOR±RR¿FLDODSRQWRXSDUDRKRPHPVHUiJUDYDGR+RQUDRWHX
VXSHULRU´

.DINDS

&RPR¿PGR$QWLJR5HJLPHRVVXSOtFLRVGDUmROXJDUjSULVmRHOHYDQGRDHQTXDQWR
SHQDSRUH[FHOrQFLDHQTXDQWRXPDIRUPDUDFLRQDOHSXUDGHSXQLUVXSRVWDPHQWHQmR
YLROHQWDHSRULVVRFRPSDWtYHOFRPRVSUHFHLWRVGR(VWDGR0RGHUQR$VWLQWDVIRUWHV
XVDGDVSHORSRGHUVREHUDQRHDFHQWUDOL]DomRGRSRGHUQD¿JXUDGRPRQDUFDYmRVHQGR
VXEVWLWXtGDVSHODVGLVFLSOLQDVFXMRH[HUFtFLRpDQ{QLPRHGLVFUHWRQmRVLWXiYHOHPXP
HVSDoRRXLGHQWL¿FiYHOHPXPDSHVVRDGDtDGL¿FXOGDGHGH.DRSHUFRUUHURVPHDQGURV
GRVLVWHPDGHMXVWLoD

2LQWHUHVVDQWHpTXHDSHVDUGR3URFHVVRIXQFLRQDUGHQWURGHRXWURSDUDGLJPDGHMXV
WLoDPDLVUDFLRQDOEXURFUDWL]DGDHIRUPDOL]DGDLVVRQmRJDUDQWHDRDFXVDGRTXHWHQKD
DFHVVRDRSURFHGLPHQWRQHPDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHIDODQHVVHHVSDoR-RVHSK.QmRWHP
PDLVLQIRUPDo}HVDFHUFDGDVXDDFXVDomRTXHRVROGDGRGH1D&RO{QLD3HQDOHDFDED
WmRPRUWRTXDQWRHOHVyTXHVHPS~EOLFR

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
 &216,'(5$d®(6),1$,62%5,/+248(2)86&$($%(/(=$
(648(&,'$
³2 0HVVLDV YLUi D SDUWLU GR LQVWDQWH HP TXH R LQGLYLGXDOLVPR PDLV
GHVUHJUDGR IRU SRVVtYHO QD Ip  TXDQGR QmR KRXYHU QLQJXpP SDUD GHVWUXLU
HVVDSRVVLELOLGDGHHQLQJXpPSDUDWROHUDUHVVDGHVWUXLomRRXVHMDTXDQGR
RVW~PXORVVHDEULUHP´

³20HVVLDVVyYLUiTXDQGRQmRIRUPDLVQHFHVViULRVyYLUiXPGLDGHSRLV
GHVXDFKHJDGDQmRYLUiQR~OWLPRPDVGHSRLVGR~OWLPRGLD´

DIRULVPRVGH.DINDGDWDGRVQRDQRIRQWH/RZ\S

1LQJXpPYLUiVDOYDU.RVROGDGRRXRKRPHPGRFDPSR1mRKiHVVDSRVVLELOLGDGH
HDLQGDDVVLPKiHVSHUDQoD"

/RZ\SDQDOLVDDLGHLDGHPHVVLDQLVPRQHJDWLYRHP.DINDUHODFLRQDQGR

RVGRLVDIRULVPRV³5HGHQomRPHVVLkQLFDVHUiREUDGRVSUySULRVKRPHQVQRPRPHQWR
HPTXHVHJXLQGRDOHLLQWHUQDGHFDGDXP¿]HUHPGHVDEDUDVFRHUo}HVHDXWRULGDGHV
H[WHULRUHV´

$VSHUVRQDJHQVGH.DINDSDUHFHPQRVSHTXHQDVSDUDWmRJUDQGHUHFXVD2³EULOKR
GDOHL´SDUHFHRIXVFDUVHXVROKRVQmRYrHPDOX]QR¿PGRW~QHODSRUWDDEHUWDDSRV
VLELOLGDGH GH UHVLVWrQFLD 2V DFXVDGRV VmR FRQYHQFLGRV GH VXD SHTXHQH] SHODV IDODV
GDVDXWRULGDGHV$/HLSRGHURVDHGHVFRQKHFLGDUHD¿UPDVHXSRGHUVRERLQGLYtGXRSRU
PHLRGHVHXV³JXDUGDGRUHV´2SDLD¿UPDHP29HUHGLFWR³&XLGDGRSDUDQmRVHHQJD
QDU&RQWLQXRVHQGRGHORQJHRPDLVIRUWH´.DINDS$VVLPFRPRRSRUWHLUR
HP'LDQWHGD/HL³&RQWXGRUHSDUDVRXIRUWH(DLQGDDVVLPVRXR~OWLPRGRVJXDUGDV'H
VDODSDUDVDODHVWmRJXDUGDVFDGDYH]PDLVIRUWHV´.DIND$S

$PHVPDVXEPLVVmRHSDVVLYLGDGHGR³KRPHPGRFDPSR´IUHQWHjDXWRULGDGH.DIND
HQFRQWUDYDQRS~EOLFRTXHDWHQGLDQDFRPSDQKLDGHVHJXURV³&RPRHVVDJHQWHpKXPLO
GH9rPDTXLSDUDPHQGLJDU(PYH]GHDWDFDUR'HSDUWDPHQWRHWRPDURTXHpVHX
YrPPHQGLJDU´/RZ\S

0RGHVWR&DURQHDSRQWDSDUDRDSHORGH.DINDHVFRQGLGRHP'LDQWHGD/HLXPDPX
GDQoDUHYROXFLRQiULDQRSDGUmRGHUHODFLRQDPHQWRGRLQGLYtGXRFRPDOHL

³R KRPHP GR FDPSR Vy WHULD VLGR FDSD] VH HVWLYHVVH HVFODUHFLGR RX
PHOKRUVHWLYHVVHFRQKHFLGRDOHLQmRFRPRXPREMHWRH[WHUQRHLQDFHVVtYHO
PDVFRPRDOHLGDLGHQWLGDGHGHOHFRQVLJRPHVPRPRPHQWRHPTXHD
SDUiEROD VHP FKDYH GH .DIND WRUQDULD SDWHQWH D DOLHQDomR GR KRPHP QR
PXQGRDGPLQLVWUDGR´

&DURQHSJULIRQRVVR

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH 
 $ H[LJrQFLD GD D¿UPDomR GD DXWRQRPLD pWLFD GR VXMHLWR DSDUHFH QD IDOD GH *HRUJ
%HQGHPDQQHP29HUHGLFWR³6HMDFRPRIRUSRUpPDMDVHPTXDOTXHUHVFU~SXORHVH
JXQGRRTXHDFKDUPHOKRU´.DINDS$DXWRGHWHUPLQDomRGRVXMHLWRIUHQWH
jVHQJHQKDULDVGRSRGHUHjVH[SHFWDWLYDVVRFLDLVSDUHFHVHUD~QLFDOLEHUGDGHSRVVtYHO
SDUD.DINDDVVLPFRPRSDUD0LFKHO)RXFDXOW

2VXMHLWRSDUD)RXFDXOWpDOJXpPSUHVRjVXDSUySULDLGHQWLGDGHSHODDomRGRSRGHU
HGRVDEHU(OHVHFRQVWUyLDSDUWLUGHPHFDQLVPRVGHQRUPDOL]DomRTXHHVWmRVHPSUH
DWUHODGRVDXPVDEHUTXHRMXVWL¿FD2VXMHLWRIUXWRGDWHFQRORJLDGLVFLSOLQDUpUHJLGR
SHODQRUPDHPRSRVLomRDRVXMHLWRDQWLJRTXHHUDUHJLGRSHODpWLFDQDUHODomRFRQVLJR
PHVPR)RXFDXOW

$SHQDVQHVVHVHVSDoRVRLQGLYtGXRSRGHUiUHODFLRQDUVHHWLFDPHQWHFRQVLJRPHV
PRID]HUHVFROKDVHSURGX]LUVXDSUySULDVXEMHWLYLGDGH$DXWRQRPLDpWLFDSURSRUFLRQD
DRLQGLYtGXRDOLEHUGDGHHDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGHGHVHDXWRGHWHUPLQDUeQHVVHVHQWLGR
TXH)RXFDXOWD¿UPDS³7HPRVTXHSURPRYHUQRYDVIRUPDVGHVXEMHWLYLGDGH
DWUDYpVGDUHFXVDGHVVHWLSRGHLQGLYLGXDOLGDGHTXHQRVIRLLPSRVWRKiYiULRVVpFXORV´

%LEOLRJUD¿D
%(1-$0,1:DOWHU0DJLDHWpFQLFDDUWHHSROtWLFDHQVDLRVVREUHOLWHUDWXUDHKLVWyULDGD
FXOWXUD6mR3DXOR%UDVLOLHQVH

%/$1&+270DXULFH$SDUWHGRIRJR5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD5RFFR

&$521(0RGHVWR/Lo}HVGH.DIND6mR3DXOR&LDGDV/HWUDV

)28&$8/70LFKHO+LVWyULDGDVH[XDOLGDGH,$YRQWDGHGHVDEHU5LRGH-DQHLUR(GL
o}HV*UDDO

BBBBB9LJLDUH3XQLU+LVWyULDGDYLROrQFLDQDVSULV}HV3HWUySROLV9R]HV

.$).$)UDQ]23URFHVVR7UDG0RGHVWR&DURQH6mR3DXOR%UDVLOLHQVH$

BBBBB29HUHGLWRH1DFRO{QLDSHQDO7UDG0RGHVWR&DURQH6mR3DXOR%UDVLOLHQVH


/,0$/XL]&RVWD/LPLWHVGDYR].DIND5LRGH-DQHLUR5RFFR

/g:<0LFKDHO5HGHQomRH8WRSLD6mR3DXOR&LDGDV/HWUDV

52%(570DUWKH6HXOFRPPH)UDQ].DIND&DOPDQQ/HY\

$QD*DEULHOD0HQGHV%UDJD
0HVWUHHGRXWRUDQGDGR'HSDUWDPHQWRGH'LUHLWR3HQDO0HGLFLQD)RUHQVHH
&ULPLQRORJLDGD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH6mR3DXOR3URIHVVRUDXQLYHUVLWiULD&RRUGHQD
GRUDDGMXQWDGRVJUXSRV*'8&&H*(7&ULP)'863HSHVTXLVDGRUDGR1$
',51~FOHRGH$QWURSRORJLDGR'LUHLWRGD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH6mR3DXOR

5HYLVWD/LEHUGDGHVQžMDQHLURDEULOGH