A GUERRA CIVIL DOS ESTADOS UNIDOS

E A CRISE DA ESCRAVIDÃO NO BRASIL*

Rafael de Bivar Marquese**

GHVSHLWR GH VXDV GLIHUHQoDV HFRQ{PLFDV VRFLDLV SROtWLFDV H

A FXOWXUDLVQDSULPHLUDPHWDGHGRVpFXOR;,;D5HS~EOLFDGRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRVGD$PpULFDHR,PSpULRGR%UDVLOFRPSDUWLOKD
UDPYiULRVDVSHFWRVFRPXQV)XQGDGRVDSDUWLUGDFULVHGRFRORQLDOLVPR
HXURSHXDPERVRVSDtVHVUHSUHVHQWDUDPRVXUJLPHQWRQDDUHQDJOREDO
GHQRYDVXQLGDGHVSROtWLFDVLQGHSHQGHQWHVFRPGLPHQV}HVFRQWLQHQWDLV
SRSXODo}HVLQGtJHQDVQmRVXEPHWLGDVDRGRPtQLREUDQFRHHFRQRPLDV
DJUiULDVEDVHDGDVQDH[SORUDomRGRWUDEDOKRHVFUDYR3DUDDOpPGHVVDV
VHPHOKDQoDVIRUPDLVDSDUWLUGDGpFDGDGHKRXYHXPDFUHVFHQWH
FRQYHUJrQFLDHFRQ{PLFDHSROtWLFDHQWUHVHXVGRLVVLVWHPDVHVFUDYLVWDV
3RUXPODGRRFUHVFLPHQWRDYDVVDODGRUGDSURGXomRGHFDIpGR%UDVLO
HQFRQWURXQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVVHXPDLRUPHUFDGRFXMDFRQYHUVmRHP
SULQFLSDOFRQVXPLGRUPXQGLDOGHFDIpGHSHQGHXQmRVRPHQWHGDHVWUHLWD
LGHQWL¿FDomRHQWUHDEHELGDHRethos QDFLRQDOSyV,QGHSHQGrQFLDFRPR
WDPEpPGHXPDSROtWLFDWDULIiULDHPJUDQGHSDUWHLPSRVWDSHORVHVWDGRV
HVFUDYLVWDVGDIHGHUDomR'HIDWRGHHPGLDQWHDLPSRUWDomRGH
FDIp SHORV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV IRL tax free HP GHFRUUrQFLD GD SODWDIRUPD

 2DUWLJRIRLRULJLQDOPHQWHDSUHVHQWDGRj&RQIHUrQFLD,QWHUQDFLRQDO$PHULFDQ&LYLO:DUV7KH
&ULVLVRIWKHVLQWKH86/DWLQ$PHULFDDQG(XURSHUHDOL]DGDQD8QLYHUVLGDGHGD&DUROLQD
GR6XOPDUoRGH$JUDGHoRDRVRUJDQL]DGRUHVGRHYHQWRHPHVSHFLDO'RQ'R\OHHGHPDLV
SDUWLFLSDQWHVDRVDPLJRVGD6HFRQG6ODYHU\5HVHDUFK1HWZRUNTXHROHUDPHFRPHQWDUDPH
DRVSDUHFHULVWDVDQ{QLPRVGDAfro-ÁsiaTXHPHDMXGDUDPDPHOKRUiOR
**
 3URIHVVRUGD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH6mR3DXORPDUTXHVH#XVSEU

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 37

afro 51.indb 37 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 OLYUHFDPELVWDGRVVHQKRUHVGHHVFUDYRVGR6XO3RURXWURODGRIDFHDR
HQIUHQWDPHQWREUDVLOHLURFRPD*Um%UHWDQKDHPWRUQRGDHVFUDYLGmRD
5HS~EOLFDGD$PpULFDGR1RUWHRSHURXFRPRXPDHVSpFLHGHHVWHLRGR
,PSpULRGD$PpULFDGR6XOIRUQHFHQGREDUFRVFDSLWDLVHEDQGHLUDSDUD
DVRSHUDo}HVQHJUHLUDVWUDQVDWOkQWLFDVLOHJDLVHDGRWDQGRXPDSROtWLFD
H[WHUQDDEHUWDPHQWHIDYRUiYHOjHVFUDYLGmRRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVVHUYL
UDPDWpEHPHQWUDGDDGpFDGDGHFRPRRDQWHPXUDOGHGHIHVDGD
HVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDQRVTXDGURVGRVLVWHPDPXQGLDO
$WUDMHWyULDGDHVFUDYLGmRGRVGRLVSDtVHVFLQGLXVHQDVHJXQGD
PHWDGHGRVpFXOR;,;(PPHDGRVGDGpFDGDGHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
DEROLUDPDLQVWLWXLomRFRPRUHVXOWDGRGHXPDYLROHQWtVVLPDJXHUUDFLYLO
TXHSURPRYHXDOLEHUWDomRGHPDLVGHTXDWURPLOK}HVGHHVFUDYRVVHP
LQGHQL]DomRDRVSURSULHWiULRV2%UDVLOSHUPDQHFHXDWpR¿QDOGDGpFDGD
GHQDGHSHQGrQFLDGRWUDEDOKRHVFUDYRPDVDRPHQRVGHVGH
TXDQGRFRQWDYDFRPFHUFDGHXPPLOKmRHPHLRGHFDWLYRVRVLVWHPD
HVFUDYLVWDEUDVLOHLURHQFRQWUDYDVHFRQGHQDGRQRORQJRSUD]RHPUD]mR
GDOHLDSURYDGDHPGHVHWHPEURGDTXHOHDQRTXHOLEHUWDYDRYHQWUH
GDVPXOKHUHVHVFUDYDV6HPRWUi¿FRQHJUHLURWUDQVDWOkQWLFRHQFHUUDGR
HPHVHPRUHFXUVRGDUHSURGXomRQDWXUDOGDHVFUDYDULDDVSHUV
SHFWLYDVGHH[SDQVmRLQGH¿QLGDGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDGHVDSDUHFHUDP
$RVHDEROLUDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLOHPRVSURSULHWiULRVEUDVLOHLURV


 6REUHDVDUWLFXODo}HVHQWUHRPHUFDGRFDIHHLURQRUWHDPHULFDQRHREUDVLOHLURYHU6WHYHQ7RSLN
DQG0LFKHOOH&UDLJ0F'RQDOG³:K\$PHULFDQV'ULQN&RIIHHWKH%RVWRQ7HD3DUW\RU%UD]LOLDQ
6ODYHU\"´LQ5REHUW:7KXUVWRQHWDORUJCoffee. A Comprehensive Guide to the Bean, the
Beverage, and the Industry %RXOGHU5RZPDQ /LWWOH¿HGSS5DIDHO0DUTXHVH
H'DOH7RPLFK³29DOHGR3DUDtEDHVFUDYLVWDHDIRUPDomRGRPHUFDGRPXQGLDOGRFDIpQR
VpFXOR;,;´LQ.HLOD*ULQEHUJH5LFDUGR6DOOHV RUJV O Brasil Imperial, vol. II – 1831-1870
5LRGH-DQHLUR&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDSS5DIDHO0DUTXHVH³(VWDGRV8QLGRV
VHJXQGDHVFUDYLGmRHDHFRQRPLDFDIHHLUDGRLPSpULRGR%UDVLO´AlmanackQSS
6REUHDVDUWLFXODo}HVSROtWLFDVHQWUHDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDHDQRUWHDPHULFDQDDQWHVGD*XHUUD
&LYLOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVYHU'DOH*UDGHQ³2HQYROYLPHQWRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVQRFRPpUFLR
WUDQVDWOkQWLFRGHHVFUDYRVSDUDR%UDVLO´Afro-ÁsiaQSS0DWWKHZ
-DVRQ.DUS³µ7KLV9DVW6RXWKHUQ(PSLUH¶7KH6RXWKDQGWKH)RUHLJQ3ROLF\RI6ODYHU\
´7HVHGH'RXWRUDGR8QLYHUVLW\RI3HQQV\OYDQLD5DIDHO0DUTXHVHH7kPLV3DUURQ
³,QWHUQDFLRQDOHVFUDYLVWDDSROtWLFDGDVHJXQGDHVFUDYLGmR´TopoiYQSS
/HRQDUGR0DUTXHV³7KH8QLWHG6WDWHVDQGWKH7UDQVDWODQWLF6ODYH7UDGHWRWKH$PHULFDV
´7HVHGH'RXWRUDGR(PRU\8QLYHUVLW\3DUDRFRQWH[WRJHUDOYHUWDPEpP
*HUDOG+RUQHThe Deepest South: The United States, Brazil, and the African Slave Trade, New
<RUN1HZ<RUN8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVOLYURTXHQRHQWDQWRFRQWpPYiULRVSUREOHPDVTXDQWR
jVH[DWDVGLPHQV}HVGDVLQWHUUHODo}HV%UDVLO(VWDGRV8QLGRVHPWRUQRGDHVFUDYLGmRQHJUD

38 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 38 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 WDPSRXFRIRUDPLQGHQL]DGRV3RUpPSDUDFKHJDUDWDOUHVXOWDGRRSDtV
QmRWHYHGHSDVVDUSRUXPFRQÀLWRLQWHUQRGHYDVWDGRUFRPGHUUDPDPHQWR
GHVDQJXHHPODUJDHVFDODWDOFRPRRFRUUHUDQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
(VWDPRV OLGDQGR SRUWDQWR FRP GXDV VDtGDV EHP GLVWLQWDV GD
HVFUDYLGmR$SHUJXQWDTXHFDEHFRORFDUpVHKRXYHUHODomRHQWUHHVVHV
GRLVSURFHVVRVGDGDVDVOLJDo}HVHQWUHRVGRLVVLVWHPDVHVFUDYLVWDVQR
SHUtRGRantebellum. Este artigo procurará responder a essa indagação
LGHQWL¿FDQGR H DQDOLVDQGR D HVWUHLWD DUWLFXODomR HQWUH D DEROLomR GD
HVFUDYLGmRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHDSRVWHULRUDEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmRQR
%UDVLO2H[HUFtFLRQmRFRQVWLWXLSURSULDPHQWHQRYLGDGHKDMDYLVWDTXH
DOJXQVKLVWRULDGRUHVWUDWDUDPGHFHUWRVLPSDFWRVGD*XHUUD&LYLOQRU
WHDPHULFDQDVREUHR,PSpULRGR%UDVLO3DUDQRVDWHUPRVDRWHPDGD
HVFUDYLGmRSRUH[HPSORDH[SOLFDomRTXHORFDOL]DDJrQHVHGDLei do
Ventre LLYUHQDOHLWXUDTXHRVDJHQWHVSROtWLFRVLPSHULDLV¿]HUDPGRLVR
ODPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOGR%UDVLOFRPDGHUURWDGRV(VWDGRV&RQIHGHUDGRV
GD$PpULFDRX&6$Confederate States of AmericaVLJODXVXDOPHQWH
HPSUHJDGDKiDOJXPWHPSRIUHTXHQWDDKLVWRULRJUD¿D Contudo, ainda
QmRKiXPDH[SORUDomRVLVWHPiWLFDGDVP~OWLSODVUHODo}HVGD*XHUUD&LYLO
QRUWHDPHULFDQDGDDEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmRHPGRPRYLPHQWRGD
5HFRQVWUXomRHGRTXDGURHFRQ{PLFRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVpostbellum
FRPRVGHVWLQRVGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDHQWUHH

 2VSULPHLURVKLVWRULDGRUHVDHVWDEHOHFHUHPUHODomRGLUHWDHQWUHD*XHUUD&LYLOHD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUH


IRUDP0RQL]%DQGHLUDPresença dos Estados Unidos no Brasil (dois séculos de história), Rio de

-DQHLUR&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDSS5REHUW&RQUDGOs últimos anos da escravatura no
Brasil, 1850-1888,5LRGH-DQHLUR&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDSSH5REHUW%UHQW7RSOLQThe
Abolition of Slavery in Brazil1HZ<RUN$WKHQHXPSS0DLVUHFHQWHPHQWH5LFDUGR6DOOHV
tratou do assunto em Nostalgia imperial. A formação da identidade nacional no Brasil do Segundo
Reinado5LRGH-DQHLUR7RSERRNV SSHHPE o Vale era o escravo: Vassouras, século
XIX. Senhores e escravos no coração do Império5LRGH-DQHLUR&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDSS
9HUWDPEpPDVDERUGDJHQVPDLVVXFLQWDVGH5RGHULFN%DUPDQImperador cidadão. D. Pedro
II e a construção do Brasil6mR3DXOR(G8QHVSSSH6LGQH\&KDOKRXEMachado
de Assis, historiador6mR3DXOR&RPSDQKLDGDV/HWUDVSS(POLYURQRTXDOFRWHMD
RDEROLFLRQLVPREUDVLOHLURFRPRDEROLFLRQLVPRQRUWHDPHULFDQR&pOLD0DULD0DULQKRGH$]HYHGR
DQRWDRSURIXQGRLPSDFWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOVREUHDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDPDVQmRRDQDOLVDGHIRUPD
FRPSOHWDHPVXDFRPSDUDomR9HUAbolicionismo. Estados Unidos e Brasil, uma história compara-
da (século XIX), 6mR3DXOR$QQDEOXPH2PHVPRSRGHVHUGLWRGRHQVDLRGH0DULD+HOHQD
3HUHLUD7ROHGR0DFKDGR³2VDEROLFLRQLVWDVEUDVLOHLURVHD*XHUUDGH6HFHVVmR´LQ0DUWKD$EUHXH
0DWHXV6HUYD3HUHLUD RUJVCaminhos da liberdade. Histórias da abolição e do pós-abolição no
Brasil 1LWHUyL33*+LVWyULD(G8))SSTXHLGHQWL¿FDDVWURFDVFXOWXUDLVHQWUH%UDVLOH
(VWDGRV8QLGRVHPWRUQRGRVWHPDVGRUDFLVPRHGDDEROLomRSRUpPVHPREVHUYDUDVLQWHUFRQH[}HV
FRQFUHWDVHQWUHRVGRLVSURFHVVRVGHVDtGDGDHVFUDYLGmR

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 39

afro 51.indb 39 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 7DO WDUHID HP VL EDVWDQWH YDVWD QmR SRGHUi VHU LQWHJUDOPHQWH
FXPSULGDQRVOLPLWHVGHVWHDUWLJR0HXREMHWLYRSULQFLSDOpRGHIRUQH
FHUXPHQTXDGUDPHQWRPDLVDPSORSDUDHQWHQGHUFRPR D*XHUUD&LYLO
QRUWHDPHULFDQDFRQIRUPRXRTXDGURGDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO
3DUDWDQWRHOHVHUiGHVHQYROYLGRHPGRLVSODQRV2SULPHLURVHUHIHUH
DRLPSDFWRSROtWLFRGLUHWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOGDDEROLomRHPHGD
5HFRQVWUXomRVREUHRGHEDWHSROtWLFRHDVGHOLEHUDo}HVSDUODPHQWDUHV
UHODWLYDVjHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLOFRPDVOHQWHVHVSHFLDOPHQWHYROWDGDV
SDUDRSHUtRGRGHD2 VHJXQGRVHUHSRUWDDRLPSDFWRGR
QRWiYHOFUHVFLPHQWRHFRQ{PLFRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVpostbellumVREUH
DVUHODo}HVVRFLDLVHVFUDYLVWDVGR,PSpULRGR%UDVLODSyVDDSURYDomR
da Lei do Ventre LLYUH$RSUHVWDUPRVDWHQomRDHVVHVGRLVSODQRVVHUi
SRVVtYHOLGHQWL¿FDUDVLPSOLFDo}HVJOREDLVPDLVDPSODVGD*XHUUD&LYLO
QRUWHDPHULFDQDSDUDDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUD

A virada da escravidão brasileira na década de 1860

(PGHVHWHPEURGHDSyVXPDGHOLEHUDomRGHTXDWURPHVHVQD
&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRVRSURMHWRGHOHLGRJDELQHWHGR9LVFRQGHGR5LR
%UDQFR-RVp0DULDGD6LOYD3DUDQKRVTXHOLEHUWDYDDVFULDQoDV¿OKDVGH
PmHVHVFUDYDVTXHGRUDYDQWHQDVFHULDPQR%UDVLOFKHJDYDjGLVFXVVmR
GR6HQDGRGR,PSpULR/RJRQRLQtFLRGRVGHEDWHVRVHQDGRU=DFDULDV
GH*yLVH9DVFRQFHORVDSUHVHQWRXVXDOHLWXUDVREUHDVRULJHQVGDSUR
SRVWD'HVGHTXDQGRRLPSHUDGRU'3HGUR,,LQVHULUDQD)DODGR
7URQRTXHDEULDRVWUDEDOKRVSDUODPHQWDUHVDPHQomRGHTXHDVROXomR
GRSUREOHPDGDHVFUDYLGmRQmRSRGHULDVHUPDLVFRQWRUQDGDQR,PSpULR
>@XPPRWLYRSRGHURVRVHQKRUHVKDYLDSDUDTXHRJRYHUQRQmRFUX
]DVVHRVEUDoRVSHUDQWHVHPHOKDQWHTXHVWmR>@HYHPDVHURIDWRGH
WHUFHVVDGRDHVFUDYLGmRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHSUHSDUDUVHRJRYHUQR
HVSDQKRO SDUD DFDEiOD HP &XED (QTXDQWR 6U 3UHVLGHQWH D JUDQGH
5HS~EOLFDDPHULFDQDWLQKDHVFUDYRVSRGLDVHUHOHYDU


 8PWUDWDPHQWRPRGHODUGHWHPDFRUUHODWRUHODWLYRDRLPSDFWRGDHPDQFLSDomRQR&DULEHEULWkQLFR
VREUHRDFLUUDPHQWRVHFFLRQDOHPWRUQRGDHVFUDYLGmRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHTXHPXLWRLQVSLURX
DDQiOLVHTXHLUHLGHVHQYROYHUQHVWHDUWLJRSRGHVHUOLGRQROLYURGH(GZDUG%DUWOHWW5XJHPHU
The Problem of Emancipation. The Caribbean Roots of the American Civil War, Baton Rouge:
/RXLVLDQD6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

40 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 40 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 26U>)UDQFLVFRGR5HJR@%DUURV%DUUHWR>3(@²(VWiYDPRVHVFXGDGRV
26U=DFDULDV²jPRQDUTXLDVROLWiULDGD$PpULFDRPDQWHUHVVDLQVWLWXL
omRPDVORJRTXHRVDFRQWHFLPHQWRVGHTXHWRGRVWHPRVQRWtFLDLPSHOLUDP
R1RUWHDHPSXQKDUDVDUPDVFRQWUDR6XOHEDWrORDWpGHWRGRH[WLQJXLU
DHVFUDYLGmRHPHQGDQGRSRUOHLGHGH'H]HPEURGHRDUWLJRGD
FRQVWLWXLomRTXHDWROHUDYDQHVVHGLDQyVQmRWtQKDPRVPDLVHVFXVD(QWmR
VHQKRUHV¿FDQGRR%UDVLOSDtV~QLFRHVFUDYRFUDWDQD$PpULFDQmRHUDSRV
VtYHOPDQWHUVHHQWUHQyVVHPHOKDQWHVLWXDomR$SRLDGRV1HPHUDSUHFLVR
TXHHPSXQKDVVHPDUPDVSDUDFRPSHOLUQRVDGDUXPSDVVRQRVHQWLGRGD
HPDQFLSDomREDVWDYDRULVRGRPXQGREDVWDYDRHVFiUQLRGHWRGDVDVQDo}HV
DSRQWDQGRSDUDR%UDVLOFRPRSDtVDPLJRGDHVFUDYLGmRGLVSRVWRDPDQWrOD
LQGH¿QLGDPHQWH2JRYHUQRTXHTXLVHVVHID]HUVHVXUGRDRFODPRUJHUDOH
UHVLVWLUjSUHVVmRQmRSRGHULDFRQVHJXLORSRUTXHDLQLFLDWLYDLQGLYLGXDO
GHVHQDGRUHVHGHSXWDGRVTXHGHDOJXPPRGRVHSRGHULDID]HUFDODUFRP
DFHUWH]DGHTXHRJRYHUQRHVWXGDYDDTXHVWmRGHVSHUWDULDDSUHVHQWDQGRD
FDGDSDVVRDRJRYHUQRGL¿FXOGDGHVLQVXSHUiYHLV

3URQXQFLDGDVQDSULPHLUDVHVVmRHPTXHVHGLVFXWLXDPDWpULDQR
6HQDGRGHSRLVGHiFLGRVGHEDWHVQD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRVHQDLPSUHQ
VDGR,PSpULRHQWUHPDLRHDJRVWRGHHVVDVSDODYUDVWUDGX]LDPD
H[LVWrQFLDGHXPDOHLWXUDFRQVHQVXDOHQWUHRVDJHQWHVSROtWLFRVGR,PSpULR
VREUHRTXHOHYDUDRDVVXQWRDHQWUDUHPGLVFXVVmR7DQWRSDUDRVTXHVH
FRORFDUDPDIDYRUGRSURMHWRGRJDELQHWH5LR%UDQFRFRPRSDUDRVTXH
VHRSXVHUDPDHOHDGHUURWDGRV&6$QD*XHUUD&LYLOHDDEROLomRGD
HVFUDYLGmRFRPDDSURYDomRGD'pFLPD7HUFHLUD(PHQGDj&RQVWLWXLomR
GRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVLVRODUDR%UDVLOQRFRQFHUWRGDVQDo}HVFLYLOL]DGDV
VREUHWXGRGHSRLVTXHR,PSpULR(VSDQKROLJXDOPHQWHPRWLYDGRSHORUH
VXOWDGRGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQRGHUDRVSULPHLURVSDVVRVSDUDDEROLU
DHVFUDYLGmRHPVXDVSRVVHVV}HVFDULEHQKDVDRGHFUHWDUHPPHDGRVGH
DOLEHUGDGHGRYHQWUHGDVHVFUDYDV


Annaes do Senado do Império do Brasil. 3ª Sessão em 1871 da 14ª Legislatura de 1 a 30 de
Setembro GRUDYDQWHFLWDGRFRPR$6 Rio de Janeiro: Typographia do Diário do Rio de Janeiro,
Y9S

 5DPLUR*XHUUD\6iQFKH]Manual de historia de Cuba+DYDQD(GLWRULDOGH&LHQFLDV6RFLDOHV
SS5HEHFFD-6FRWWEmancipação escrava em Cuba: a transição para o trabalho
livre, 1860-18995LRGH-DQHLUR3D]H7HUUDSSVREUHDDUWLFXODomRGRPRYLPHQWR
DEROLFLRQLVWDHVSDQKROHPUHVSRVWDj*XHUUD&LYLOYHUWDPEpPROLYURGH&KULVWRSKHU6FK
PLGW1RZDUD Empire and Antislavery: Spain, Cuba, and Puerto Rico, 1833-18743LWWVEXUJK
8QLYHUVLW\RI3LWWVEXUJK3UHVV

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 41

afro 51.indb 41 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 1RHQWDQWRRTXHWDOYH]VHMDPDLVVLJQL¿FDWLYRQRWUHFKRFLWDGRpD
EUHYtVVLPDLQWHUSHODomRGH)UDQFLVFRGR5HJR%DUURV%DUUHWRDRGLVFXUVR
GH=DFDULDV³(VWiYDPRVHVFXGDGRV´FRPHVVDVGXDVSDODYUDVRVHQD
GRUGDSURYtQFLDGH3HUQDPEXFRH[SUHVVDYDDSURIXQGDYLUDGDKLVWyULFD
TXHRFRUUHUDQR%UDVLOQDGpFDGDGH&RPHIHLWRDQWHVGH
RSRGHUGDHVFUDYLGmRQD5HS~EOLFDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVIRUQHFHUDDRV
SROtWLFRVHOHWUDGRVSUyHVFUDYLVWDVEUDVLOHLURVXPGRVPDLVSRGHURVRV
DUJXPHQWRVGHGHIHVDGDRUGHPHVFUDYLVWDLPSHULDO(QWUHDSURFODPDomR
GDLQGHSHQGrQFLDHRDWDTXHDR)RUW6XPWHUDHVFUDYLGmR
EUDVLOHLUD VRIUHX VpULRV TXHVWLRQDPHQWRV LQWHUQRV H H[WHUQRV$IRUD D
DPHDoDjVREHUDQLDQDFLRQDOUHSUHVHQWDGDSHODSHUPDQHQWHSUHVVmREUL
WkQLFDFRQWUDRWUi¿FRWUDQVDWOkQWLFRGHHVFUDYRVKRXYHGHQWURGR%UDVLO
XPDFRQWtQXDRSRVLomRjHVFUDYLGmRTXHVHPDQLIHVWRXQDLPSUHQVDQR
3DUODPHQWRHQDVDo}HVGRVSUySULRVHVFUDYRV(VVDRSRVLomRFRQWXGR
IRLYHQFLGDSHORFDPSRHVFUDYLVWDTXHDSDUWLUGHGLWRXRVUXPRV
SROtWLFRV GR SDtV 1DV SULPHLUDV GXDV GpFDGDV GR 6HJXQGR 5HLQDGR
RVFKDPDGRVsaquaremasRSRGHURVRJUXSRFRQVHUYDGRU
DUWLFXODGRHPWRUQRGDFDIHLFXOWXUDGDEDFLDGRULR3DUDtEDGR6XOTXH
FRPSUHHQGLDSDUWHVGDVSURYtQFLDVGR5LRGH-DQHLURGH6mR3DXORHGH
0LQDV*HUDLVORJUDUDPLPSRUjDJHQGDSROtWLFDQDFLRQDOVXDSODWDIRUPD
GHGHIHVDLQWHJUDOGDHVFUDYLGmR6HHPR%UDVLOIRLIRUoDGRSHOD
*Um%UHWDQKDDDEROLURWUi¿FRWUDQVDWOkQWLFRGHHVFUDYRVQRVDQRVVH
JXLQWHVRVVDTXDUHPDVYLUDPQR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVRPRGHORPDLV
DFDEDGRGHVXFHVVRQRPXQGRPRGHUQRGHXPDVRFLHGDGHHVFUDYLVWD
HQWHQGHQGRRFRPRREDVWLmRGDPDQXWHQomRGRHVFUDYLVPRQR2FLGHQWH
&RPDVROLGH]GDHVFUDYLGmRVXOLVWDR%UDVLOHVWDYDHVFXGDGR
(VVDSRVLomRRULHQWRXDUHDomRLQLFLDOj*XHUUD&LYLOLPHGLDWDPHQWH
LGHQWL¿FDGDQDLPSUHQVDEUDVLOHLUDFRPRXPFRQÀLWRFXMDPDWpULDFHQWUDO
HUDDHVFUDYLGmR$FRPSDQKDQGRDSRVLomREULWkQLFDHIUDQFHVDR,PSpULR
GR%UDVLOUHFRQKHFHXDLQGDHPRHVWDGRGHEHOLJHUkQFLDGRV&6$
R TXH YDOH GL]HU VHX GLUHLWR D XPD HYHQWXDO LQGHSHQGrQFLD$LQGD TXH
VH FRORFDVVH HP SRVLomR GH QHXWUDOLGDGH QmR IRL SRVVtYHO DR *RYHUQR


 7kPLV3DUURQA política da escravidão no Império do Brasil, 1826-1865, 5LRGH-DQHLUR&LYL
OL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDHVSHFLDOPHQWHFDS9HUWDPEpP0DUTXHVHH3DUURQ³,QWHUQDFLRQDO
HVFUDYLVWD´SS

42 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 42 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 EUDVLOHLURHVFRQGHUVXDVVLPSDWLDVSHOR6XO8PFXUWRGHEDWHPDQWLGRQD
LPSUHQVDGD&RUWHHPMDQHLURGHGHL[DLVVRFODUR1RGLDRCorreio
Mercantil, HQWmRH[SUHVVDQGRDRSLQLmRGDRSRVLomROLEHUDODRJDELQHWH
FRQVHUYDGRUGH/XLV$OYHVGH/LPDH6LOYD0DUTXrVGH&D[LDVD¿UPDYD
QmRTXHUHU³RDQLTXLODPHQWRGR6XO´ID]HQGRQRHQWDQWR³YRWRVVLQFHURV
DUGHQWHVSHORWULXQIRGR1RUWHRUHVXOWDGRGHVVHWULXQIRQmRSRGHVHUVHQmR
XPDFRUGRJHQHURVRSDUDTXHVHOLPLWHDHVFUDYLGmRDRVHVWDGRVHPTXH
HODKRMHHVWiDGPLWLGD´7DORSLQLmRIRLMXOJDGDFRPVHYHULGDGHQRGLD
GHMDQHLURSHORJornal do CommercioTXHDOHXFRPRXPDH[SUHVVmRGH
³DPRUGDTXHVWmRDEROLFLRQLVWD´³(PSDtVHPTXHXPDSDUWHFRQVLGHUiYHO
GDIRUWXQDSDUWLFXODUHTXDVHWRGRRWUDEDOKRHVSHFLDOPHQWHQDODYRXUD
GHSHQGH GD TXHVWmR GR FDWLYHLUR´ LQGDJRX R UHGDWRU GR SHULyGLFR TXH
VHUYLDGHYHtFXORSDUDDVRSLQL}HVR¿FLDLVGRJDELQHWHGHWXUQR³SRGH
VXVWHQWDUDFRQYHQLrQFLDGDVVLPSDWLDVOLEHUDLVSDUDRVHPDQFLSDGRUHVH
RVDEROLFLRQLVWDVGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV"6HKRXYHTXHVWmRHVWUDQJHLUDHP
TXHDVVLPSDWLDVEUDVLOHLUDVGHYDP¿FDUWmRQHXWUDVFRPRDSROtWLFDGRVHX
JRYHUQRpHVVDTXHGLYLGHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV´
$WpR¿QDOGHDH[SHFWDWLYDQR%UDVLO²FRPRGHUHVWRHP
WRGDD(XURSD²HUDDGHTXHPDLVWHPSRPHQRVWHPSRD8QLmRVH
YHULDIRUoDGDDDFHLWDUDPHGLDomRH[WHUQDGRFRQÀLWRHSRUWDQWRDUHFR
QKHFHUDLQGHSHQGrQFLDGRV&6$$YLUDGDGH$QWLHWDPD3URFODPDomR
3UHOLPLQDUGH(PDQFLSDomRHPGHVHWHPEURGHFRQ¿UPDGD
HPSULPHLURGHMDQHLURGHHDVYLWyULDVGD8QLmRQR9DOHGR0LV
VLVVLSSLHHP*HWW\VEXUJHPMXOKRGHDOWHUDUDPSURIXQGDPHQWH
RV SURJQyVWLFRV DQWHULRUHV$FHQGHXVH QR %UDVLO R VLQDO GH DOHUWD D
UHVSHLWRGHXPDSRVVtYHOGHUURWDGR6XOHVREUHWXGRGDVFRQVHTXrQFLDV

 2HSLVyGLRIRLDQDOLVDGRSRU6LOYDQD0RWD%DUERVD³$Imprensa e o MLQLVWpULRHVFUDYLGmRH
*XHUUDGH6HFHVVmRQRVMRUQDLVGR5LRGH-DQHLUR´LQ-RVp0XULORGH&DUYDOKRH
$GULDQD3HUHLUD&DPSRVRUJVPerspectivas da cidadania no Brasil Império5LRGH-DQHLUR
&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDSS$VSDVVDJHQVFLWDGDVHQFRQWUDPVHQDVSSH
6REUHDSROtWLFDGHQHXWUDOLGDGHGR,PSpULRHVXDVVLPSDWLDVFRQIHGHUDGDVYHUWDPEpP$QWRQLD
)GH$OPHLGD:ULJKW³%UDVLO(VWDGRV8QLGRV´LQ6pUJLR%XDUTXHGH+RODQGD RUJ
História geral da civilização brasileira, tomo II, O Brasil monárquico, YDeclínio e queda do
Império 5LRGH-DQHLUR%HUWUDQGSS6pUJLR%XDUTXHGH+RODQGDHistória geral da
civilização brasileira, tomo II, O Brasil monárquico, YDo Império à República, Rio de Janeiro:
5LRGH-DQHLUR%HUWUDQGSSH%DQGHLUDPresença dos Estados Unidos no Brasil,
SS8PDGXUDDYDOLDomRVREUHRVSHQGRUHVSUy&6$HSUyHVFUDYLGmRGR,PSpULRGR%UDVLO
SRGHVHUOLGDHPFRUUHVSRQGrQFLDHQYLDGDSRU-DPHV:DWVRQ:HEEUHSUHVHQWDQWHGLSORPiWLFRGD
União no Rio de Janeiro, ao Jornal do Commercio, SXEOLFDGDHPGHPDUoRGH

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 43

afro 51.indb 43 26/08/2016 09:09:15

 GRGHFUHWRGHHPDQFLSDomRGH8PDGDVSULPHLUDVPDQLIHVWDo}HVGH
TXHDVFRQGLo}HVGHHVWDELOLGDGHGRVLVWHPDHVFUDYLVWDEUDVLOHLURKDYLDP
VHPRGL¿FDGRSDUWLXGRSUySULR'3HGUR,,PXLWREHPPXQLFLDGRGH
LQIRUPDo}HV SHOD FRUUHVSRQGrQFLD GLSORPiWLFD HPDQDGD GRV (VWDGRV
8QLGRV(PVXDVUHFRPHQGDo}HVGHGHMDQHLURGHD=DFDULDVGH
*yLVH9DVFRQFHORVTXHDFDEDUDGHVHUQRPHDGRFRPRFKHIHGRQRYR
JDELQHWHPLQLVWHULDOHVFUHYHXRLPSHUDGRU
2VVXFHVVRVGD8QLmR$PHULFDQDH[LJHPTXHSHQVHPRVQRIXWXURGD
HVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLOSDUDTXHQmRQRVVXFHGDRPHVPRTXHDUHVSHLWR
GRWUi¿FRGHDIULFDQRV$PHGLGDTXHPHWHPSDUHFLGRSURItFXDpDGD
OLEHUGDGHGRV¿OKRVGRVHVFUDYRVTXHQDVFHUHPGDTXLDXPFHUWRQ~PHUR
GHDQRV7HQKRUHÀHWLGRVREUHRPRGRGHH[HFXWDUDPHGLGDSRUpPpGD
RUGHPGDVTXHFXPSUHUHDOL]DUFRP¿UPH]DUHPHGLDQGRRVPDOHVTXH
HOD QHFHVVDULDPHQWH RULJLQDUi FRQIRUPH DV FLUFXQVWkQFLDV SHUPLWHP
5HFRPHQGRGLYHUVRVGHVSDFKRVGRQRVVRPLQLVWURHP:DVKLQJWRQRQGH
VHID]HPPDLVDYLVDGDVFRQVLGHUDo}HVVREUHHVWHDVVXQWR

2HVFXGRSDUHFLDHVWDUVHURPSHQGR6HDSyVDJUDYtVVLPDFULVH
GLSORPiWLFDGR¿PGRWUi¿FRQHJUHLURWUDQVDWOkQWLFRTXHTXDVHDFDEDUDHP
JXHUUDFRQWUDD*Um%UHWDQKDR%UDVLOHQWUDUDHPXPSHUtRGRGHJUDQGH
FDOPDULDUHODWLYDjHVFUDYLGmRRGHVHQURODUGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQR
YROWDYDDFRORFDUR,PSpULRGR%UDVLOVRERULVFRGHLVRODPHQWRH[LJLQGRGH
VHXDOWRFRPDQGRSROtWLFRTXHVHDYHQWDVVHPDOWHUQDWLYDVGHVDtGDJUDGXDO
GRFRPSURPLVVRQDFLRQDOFRPDLQVWLWXLomR3URSRVWDVGHOLEHUWDomRGR
YHQWUHLQVSLUDGDVWDQWRQRH[HPSORGDVXQLGDGHVIHGHUDWLYDVGR1RUWHGRV
(8$FRPRQDVH[SHULrQFLDVGHGLYHUVDVUHS~EOLFDVGD$PpULFDHVSDQKROD
KDYLDPFLUFXODGRQR%UDVLOQRiSLFHGDFULVHFRPD*Um%UHWDQKD Em
HODDSDUHFLDFRPRD~QLFDVROXomRSRVVtYHOSDUDVHHYLWDUHPRVULVFRV
GHUDGLFDOL]DomRHPEXWLGRVQDH[SHULrQFLDGHYDVWDGRUDGD*XHUUD&LYLO
8PDGDVSULPHLUDVLQLFLDWLYDVDQWLHVFUDYLVWDVDSUHVHQWDGDVDR3DU
ODPHQWRQRUDVWURQRUWHDPHULFDQRFRQWXGRQmRSDUWLXGHXPJDELQHWH

In Barman, Imperador cidadãoS2FRQWH~GRGRVRItFLRVPHQFLRQDGRVSRU'3HGUR,,p
H[DPLQDGRSRU%DQGHLUDPresença dos Estados Unidos no BrasilSS

 (PGHPDUoRGHRGHSXWDGR6LOYD*XLPDUmHVDSUHVHQWRXj&kPDUDXPSURMHWRFRP
SRVWRSRUWUrVDUWLJRVTXHOLEHUWDYDPRYHQWUHGDVHVFUDYDV$SURSRVWDQmRHQWURXHPGLVFXVVmR
3DUDVHXFRQWH~GRYHU$JRVWLQKR0DUTXHV3HUGLJmR0DOKHLURA escravidão no Brasil. Ensaio
histórico, jurídico, social, Y3HWUySROLV9R]HV>@YS

44 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 44 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 QRPHDGRSRU'3HGUR,,(PGHPDLRGHDVVLPTXHDQRWtFLD
GDDSURYDomRGD(PHQGDSHOR&RQJUHVVRQRUWHDPHULFDQRFKHJRXDR
%UDVLO)UDQFLVFR*r$FD\DEDGH0RQWH]XPD9LVFRQGHGH-HTXLWLQKRQKD
SURS{VDR6HQDGREUDVLOHLURXPSURMHWRGHOHLTXHSUHYLDGHQWUHRXWUDV
PHGLGDVDOLEHUWDomRGHWRGRVRVHVFUDYRVPDLRUHVGHDQRVDFRQWDU
DQRVGHDSURYDomRGDOHLVHJXLGDFLQFRDQRVGHSRLVGDDEROLomRJHUDO
2XVHMDFDVRIRVVHDSURYDGDQRDQROHJLVODWLYRGHHPQmR
KDYHULDPDLVHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO$PDWpULDVHTXHUFKHJRXDHQWUDUHP
GLVFXVVmRH-HTXLWLQKRQKDVRIUHXGXURVDWDTXHVQDLPSUHQVDGR5LRGH
-DQHLURTXDQWRDRVVHXVYtQFXORVIDPLOLDUHVHSHVVRDLVFRPDHVFUDYLGmR
2TXHQmRRLPSHGLXGHFRQWLQXDUFRPDSUpGLFDDQWLHVFUDYLVWDKiPXLWR
WHPSRXPDPDUFDGLVWLQWLYDGHVXDWUDMHWyULDSROtWLFD$LQGDHPHOH
WUDGX]LXXPVHUPmRSDVFRDOTXHR%LVSRGH2UOHDQVFRPSXVHUDSDUDRFOHUR
IUDQFrVHPDEULOGHVREUHDHVFUDYLGmRQHJUDHD*XHUUD&LYLOQRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRV1DVWUrVORQJDVQRWDVGHSUySULRSXQKRTXH-HTXLWLQKRQKD
DFUHVFHQWRXjSUpGLFDGHVFREUHVHDUD]mRGHVXDSXEOLFDomRQR%UDVLO
(QGHUHoDQGRDDRFOHUREUDVLOHLURHOHSUHWHQGLDVRODSDURVDUJXPHQWRV
FULVWmRVGHGHIHVDGDHVFUDYLGmRFRUUHQWHVQR%UDVLODRPHVPRWHPSRHP
TXHFRPHQWDYDDVLPSOLFDo}HVGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQR'HHVSHFLDO
UHOHYRQDFXUWDKLVWyULDGDHPDQFLSDomRQRFXUVRGD*XHUUD&LYLOTXHHOH
WUD]LDDRS~EOLFREUDVLOHLURHUDDGXUDFUtWLFDjVKHVLWDo}HVGH/LQFROQDR
HQIUHQWDUDUHEHOLmRHVFUDYLVWDGR6XOQRVGRLVSULPHLURVDQRVGHOXWDDWp
¿QDOPHQWH WRPDU D LQLFLDWLYD GH HPDQFLSDomR PLOLWDU HP VHWHPEUR GH
0HVPRGHSRLV/LQFROQWHULDFRQWLQXDGRFRPLQGHFLV}HVTXHVR
PHQWHDPSOLDUDPDGXUDomRGDHVFUDYLGmRHDYLROrQFLDGDJXHUUD(PXP
SRQWRSRUpP-HTXLWLQKRQKDUHVSDOGDYDRFDPLQKRWRPDGRSHORV(VWDGRV
8QLGRVRVVHQKRUHVQmRJR]DYDPGHGLUHLWRVOHJDLVGHSURSULHGDGHVREUH
VHXVHVFUDYRV$DEROLomRVHPLQGHQL]DomRVHULDSRUFRQVHJXLQWHXPD
PHGLGDSOHQDPHQWHOHJtWLPD


Carta do Exmo. e Rev. Bispo de Orleans ao clero de sua diocese sobre a escravidão. 7UDGX]LGD
HRIHUHFLGDDRFOHUREUDVLOHLURSHOR9LVFRQGHGH-HTXLWLQKRQKD5LRGH-DQHLUR/DHPPHUW
SS2SURMHWRDSUHVHQWDGRDR6HQDGRSRGHVHUOLGRHP0DOKHLURA escravidão no Brasil,
YSS'HQWUHRVDWDTXHVVRIULGRVSRU-HTXLWLQKRQKDHPHVWDYDRIDWRGHVHU¿OKR
EDVWDUGRGHXPJUDQGHWUD¿FDQWHGHHVFUDYRVGD%DKLDTXHRWLYHUDGHXPDUHODomRLOtFLWDFRP
XPDQHJUDHGHWHUSDUWLFLSDGRHPVXDPRFLGDGHGHH[SHGLo}HVQHJUHLUDVFRPVHXSDL3DUDWRGR
RHSLVyGLRYHU(GXDUGR6SLOOHU3HQDPajens da Casa Imperial. Jurisconsultos, escravidão e a
lei de 1871, &DPSLQDV(G8QLFDPSSS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 45

afro 51.indb 45 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 (VVDDYDOLDomRSUH¿JXUDYDRVSRWHQFLDLVULVFRVGHUDGLFDOL]DomRGR
FDPSRGLVFXUVLYRUHODWLYRjHVFUDYLGmRQHJUDQR%UDVLOFRPHYHQWXDLV
GHVGREUDPHQWRVSROtWLFRV4XHQmRVHWUDWDYDGHXPSHULJRUHPRWRFRPSUR
YDRDOHLWXUDTXHHPRXWXEURGHHVFUDYRVGD]RQDGHPLQHUDomRGH
GLDPDQWHV¿]HUDPGDFLUFXODomRGHQRWtFLDVUHODFLRQDGDVFRPRVSURJUHVVRV
da guerra e da emancipação nos Estados Unidos.(PGHGH]HPEURGH
TXDQGRRVHFUHWiULRGHHVWDGR:LOOLDP+6HZDUGFHUWL¿FRXGHIRUPD
R¿FLDOTXHWRGRVRVYLQWHHVHWH(VWDGRVGD5HS~EOLFDQRUWHDPHULFDQD
KDYLDPUDWL¿FDGRD(PHQGDWRUQDUDVHFODURDRVDJHQWHVS~EOLFRVGR
,PSpULRGR%UDVLOTXHDDEROLomRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHUDGH¿QLWLYDHTXH
PDQLIHVWDo}HVFRPRDVGR9LVFRQGHGH-HTXLWLQKRQKDHGRVHVFUDYRVGH
0LQDV*HUDLVSRGHULDPVHPXOWLSOLFDU$FRLQFLGrQFLDWHPSRUDOHQWUHR
¿PGD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQDHRLQtFLRGD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLQR
HQWDQWRS{VFRPSDVVRGHHVSHUDjVJHVW}HVSROtWLFDVFRQWUiULDVjHVFUDYLGmR
TXHHPDQDYDPGRFHQWURGRSRGHULPSHULDO$SULRULGDGHSDVVDUDDVHUD
UiSLGDUHVROXomRGRFRQÀLWRSODWLQRTXHFRQWUDULDPHQWHjVH[SHFWDWLYDV
LQLFLDLVVHHVWHQGHULDSRUORQJRVFLQFRDQRV
$*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLQmRWUDYRXRSURVVHJXLPHQWRGRVHVWXGRVH
GRVGHEDWHVVREUHRSUREOHPDGDHVFUDYLGmR$RSHGLGRGH'3HGUR,,-RVp

 9HU D UHVSHLWR ,VDGRUD 0RXUD 0RWD ³2 µYXOFmR¶ QHJUR GD &KDSDGD 5HEHOLmR HVFUDYD QRV
VHUW}HVGLDPDQWLQRV0LQDV*HUDLV´'LVVHUWDomRGH0HVWUDGR8QLYHUVLGDGH(VWDGXDO
GH&DPSLQDV

 $*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLWHYHSDSHOFUXFLDOQDFRQIRUPDomRGDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUD$YLUDGD
GHFLVLYDFRQWXGRYHLRGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQRHQmRGRFRQÀLWRSODWLQR9DOHDTXLSURSRUXP
EUHYHUDFLRFtQLRFRQWUDIDFWXDOVHD*XHUUD&LYLOQmRWLYHVVHRFRUULGRDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDWHULD
FRQVHJXLGRDWUDYHVVDULQFyOXPHD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLVHSRURXWURODGRD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLQmR
WLYHVVHRFRUULGRPDVD*XHUUD&LYLOVLPDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDWHULDHQWUDGRHPFULVH$SURYDGRV
QRYHGHVVHH[HUFtFLRHVSHFXODWLYRHVWiQR,PSpULR(VSDQKRODVGHOLEHUDo}HVDFHUFDGDHVFUDYLGmR
HP&XEDH3RUWR5LFRGLUHWDPHQWHHVWLPXODGDVSHORUHVXOWDGRGDJXHUUDQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
SUHFHGHUDPRLQtFLRGD*XHUUDGRV'H]$QRV7DQWRHPXPFDVR%UDVLO±*XHUUD
GR3DUDJXDLFRPRHPRXWUR&XED±*XHUUDGRV'H]$QRVRVFRQÀLWRVPLOLWDUHVGHUDPPDWL]HV
SUySULRVDXPDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmRTXHVHWRUQDUDVLVWrPLFDFRPD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQD
$FHUFDGD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLHVHXVLPSDFWRVVREUHDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDYHU5LFDUGR6DOOHV
Guerra do Paraguai: escravidão e cidadania na formação do Exército, 5LRGH-DQHLUR3D] 
7HUUDH:LOPD3HUHV&RVWDA espada de Dâmocles. O Exército, a Guerra do Paraguai e a
crise do Império, 6mR3DXOR+XFLWHF(G8QLFDPS3DUDXPHVWXGRUHFHQWHHH[DXVWLYRTXH
FRPSDUDRUHFUXWDPHQWRGHH[HVFUDYRVSHOR([pUFLWREUDVLOHLURHSHOR([pUFLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQR
QRFXUVRGD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLHGD*XHUUD&LYLOHVHXVLPSDFWRVVREUHRVUHVSHFWLYRVHGLItFLRV
HVFUDYLVWDVYHU9LWRU,]HFNVRKQSlavery and War in the Americas: Race, Citizenship, and State
Building in the United States and Brazil, 1861-1870, &KDUORWWHVYLOOH8QLYHUVLW\RI9LUJLQLD3UHVV
6REUHD*XHUUDGRV'H]$QRVHDHVFUDYLGmRFXEDQDYHU$GD)HUUHUInsurgent Cuba. Race,
Nation, and Revolution, 1868-1898, &KDSHO+LOO7KH8QLYHUVLW\RI1RUWK&DUROLQD3UHVV

46 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 46 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 Antonio Pimenta Bueno, MDUTXrVGH6mR9LFHQWHVHQDGRUHPHPEUR
GR&RQVHOKRGH(VWDGRSUHSDURXHQWUH¿QVGHHLQtFLRVGH
²¿QDOL]DQGRRHPGHMDQHLUR²XPFRQMXQWRGHSURMHWRVVREUHD
OLEHUWDomRGDVFULDQoDV¿OKDVGHPmHVHVFUDYDVTXHQDVFHVVHPDSDUWLUGD
DSURYDomRGDOHLHDHPDQFLSDomRGHWRGRVRVHVFUDYRVUHVWDQWHVFRP
LQGHQL]DomRSDUDRVVHQKRUHVHPGHGH]HPEURGH$WHQWDWLYDGH
VXEPHWHUDPDWpULDDR&RQVHOKRGH(VWDGRQRFRPHoRGHIUDFDVVRX
GLDQWHGDRSRVLomRGRFKHIHGRJDELQHWHGRPRPHQWR3HGURGH$UD~MR
Lima, MDUTXrVGH2OLQGDDTXDOTXHUPHGLGDFRQWUiULDjHVFUDYLGmRQR
FRQWH[WRLPHGLDWRGD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDL(PGHDJRVWR2OLQGDIRL
VXEVWLWXtGRQRFRPDQGRGRPLQLVWpULRSRU=DFDULDVGH*yLVPDLVUHFHSWL
YRjLGHLDGDHPDQFLSDomR$LQGDHPVHXSULPHLURPrVGHDJRVWR
RQRYRJDELQHWHUHVSRQGHXDXPDFDUWDHQYLDGDSHOR&RPLWp)UDQoDLV
G¶ePDQFLSDWLRQD'3HGUR,,QDTXDORVVLJQDWiULRVSHVRVSHVDGRVGR
DEROLFLRQLVPRLQWHUQDFLRQDOLVWDFRPR$JXVWLQ&RFKLQH+HQUL:DOORQ
LQVWDYDP R LPSHUDGRU EUDVLOHLUR D DWXDU GH PRGR GHFLVLYR HP QRPH
GHVXDUHSXWDomRQD(XURSDSDUDDFDEDUGHXPDYH]SRUWRGDVFRPD
HVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUD2VSDUiJUDIRVGHDEHUWXUDGDFXUWDFDUWDIUDQFHVD
VmREDVWDQWHHORTXHQWHVTXDQWRDRTXHPRYLDRVDEROLFLRQLVWDV
1RPRPHQWRHPTXHD5HS~EOLFDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVYLWRULRVDGHXPD
JXHUUDORQJDHPRUWtIHUDDFDEDGHGDUDOLEHUGDGHDTXDWURPLOK}HVGH
HVFUDYRVQRPRPHQWRHPTXHD(VSDQKDSDUHFHSUHVWHVDFHGHUjYR]
GDKXPDQLGDGHHGDMXVWLoDRXVDPRVGLULJLUD90XPDUGHQWHDSHOR
HPIDYRUGRVHVFUDYRVGRYRVVR,PSpULR
6DEHPROR6HQKRUHQLQJXpPQD(XURSDRLJQRUDTXH90pSRGHURVR
QRYRVVR,PSpULRHDYRVVDIRUoDUHVLGHQDDGPLQLVWUDomRUHFRQKHFLGD
HQRDPRUVLQFHURGRYRVVRSRYR
-iDEROLVWHRWUi¿FRPDVHVVDPHGLGDpLQFRPSOHWDXPDSDODYUDXPD
YRQWDGHGH90SRGHPWUD]HUDOLEHUGDGHGHGRLVPLOK}HVGHKRPHQV3R
GHLVGDURH[HPSOR6HQKRUHWHQGHDFHUWH]DGHTXHVHUHLVDFRPSDQKDGR
SRUTXHR%UDVLOQXQFDROKRXDVHUYLGmRFRPRXPDLQVWLWXLomRGLYLQD

$*XHUUD&LYLODOWHUDUDSRUFRPSOHWRDVSHUVSHFWLYDVGDHVFUDYLGmR

 -RDTXLP1DEXFRUm estadista do Império. Nabuco de Araújo - sua vida, suas opiniões, sua
épocaY5LRGH-DQHLUR*DUQLHUYSSYSS%DUPDQImperador
cidadãoSS

 0DOKHLURA escravidão no BrasilYS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 47

afro 51.indb 47 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 QDV$PpULFDVDEULQGRDIHQGDTXHSHUPLWLULDDEROLODGHYH]HP&XED
HQR%UDVLOHLVDPHQVDJHPHVVHQFLDOGRVDEROLFLRQLVWDVIUDQFHVHV6RE
D&RQVWLWXLomR,PSHULDOGH'3HGUR,,QmRSRGHULDWRPDUIRUPDO
PHQWHDVUpGHDVGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRFRPRDFUHGLWDYDPRVIUDQFHVHV
YLYHQGRVRERUHJLPHGH1DSROHmR,,,RXPHVPRUHVSRQGHUDXPDPLV
VLYDFRPRHVWD$UHVSRVWDGRPLQLVWURGDV5HODo}HV([WHULRUHV0DUWLP
)UDQFLVFR 5LEHLUR GH$QGUDGH WRGDYLD HVWDYD SOHQDPHQWH D¿QDGD j
YLUDGDRFRUULGDHPQRFRUDomRGRSRGHULPSHULDO³DHPDQFLSDomR
GRVHVFUDYRVFRQVHTXrQFLDQHFHVViULDGDDEROLomRGRWUi¿FRQmRSDVVD
GHXPDTXHVWmRGHIRUPDHGHRSRUWXQLGDGH´
$RSRVLomRHVFUDYLVWDHPYHULDQDUHVSRVWDjFDUWDGRFRPLWr
IUDQFrVGHHPDQFLSDomRTXHHQFRQWURXHQRUPHUHSHUFXVVmRQDLPSUHQVD
EUDVLOHLUDRLQtFLRGRSURFHVVRSDUODPHQWDUTXHUHVXOWDULDQDDSURYDomRGD/HL
GR9HQWUH/LYUHHXPDPDQLIHVWDomRFDEDOGRFKDPDGR³LPSHULDOLVPR´GH
'3HGUR,,LVWRpGHVXDSRVLomRSUyDWLYDDQWLFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHPDVVXQWRV
SROtWLFRVTXHQmRGL]LDPUHVSHLWRjHVIHUDGR3RGHU0RGHUDGRU$VJHVW}HV
GRPRQDUFDQRVHQWLGRGHFRPSHOLURVSROtWLFRVLPSHULDLVDFRORFDUHPQD
DJHQGDGR3DUODPHQWRDTXHVWmRGRYHQWUHFDGDYH]PDLVHYLGHQWHVSHODV
QRWtFLDVFRUUHQWHVQDLPSUHQVDWHULDPGHHVSHUDUR¿PGRFRQÀLWRSDUDJXDLR
(PXPDHVIHUDTXHHVWDYDGHQWURGDDOoDGDGRSRGHUGRLPSHUDGRUHODVDSD
UHFHUDPDQWHV6HVRERJDELQHWHGRMDUTXrVGH2OLQGDQmRIRUDSRVVtYHO
VXEPHWHURSURMHWRGH3LPHQWD%XHQRDR&RQVHOKRGH(VWDGRLVVRWRUQRXVH
SRVVtYHOVRERJDELQHWHGH=DFDULDVGH*yLV1DVVHVV}HVGHHGHDEULOGH
RVFRQVHOKHLURVGHEDWHUDPORQJDPHQWHRSURMHWRGHHPDQFLSDomRGR
YHQWUHjGLVSRVLomRGHVGHMDQHLURGH&RPRRWHPDIRLEHPH[DPLQDGR
por outro historiador,FDEHPHDSHQDVGHVWDFDUGHPRGREUHYHFRPRRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRVDSDUHFHUDPQDVGLVFXVV}HV
$ IDOD PDLV LPSRUWDQWH D HVVH UHVSHLWR IRL D GH -RVp 0DULD GD
6LOYD3DUDQKRVTXHHPWUrVDQRVUHFHEHULDRWtWXORGH9LVFRQGHGR5LR
%UDQFR,QLFLDOPHQWHHOHSURFHGHXDXPDHUXGLWDDYDOLDomRGRSURFHVVR
GH DEROLomR QRV LPSpULRV EULWkQLFR H IUDQFrV QRV TXDLV D HVFUDYLGmR


 0DOKHLURA escravidão no BrasilYS

 -HIIUH\'1HHGHOOThe Party of Order. The Conservatives, the State, and Slavery in the Brazilian
Monarchy, 1831-18716WDQIRUG6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS

 6DOOHVE o Vale era o escravoSS

48 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 48 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 VHQGR PDWpULD FRORQLDO H QmR QDFLRQDO FRP SRSXODo}HV FDWLYDV EHP
LQIHULRUHVjGR%UDVLOIRLREMHWRSRUDQRVD¿RGHORQJDVGHOLEHUDo}HV
FXMDVGLVFXVV}HVS~EOLFDVHVWLPXODUDPFRPIUHTXrQFLDOHYDQWHVHVFUDYRV
(PPDUoRGHD(VSDQKDDLQGDQmRKDYLDFKHJDGRDXPDVROXomR
SDUD&XEDH3RUWR5LFR6HQRFDVRGDVSRWrQFLDVFRORQLDLVHXURSHLDV
KRXYHUDXPDSUHVVmRDEROLFLRQLVWDVXEVWDQWLYDTXHOHYDUDjVVROXo}HV
UDGLFDLVGHHQIUHQWDPHQWRGDHVFUDYLGmRHVVDDPHDoDHUDLQH[LVWHQWHQR
%UDVLO(TXDQWRDRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV³~QLFRSDtVSDUDRTXDOHVVDTXHVWmR
WLQKDLPSRUWkQFLDFRPSDUiYHOFRPDGR%UDVLO´"6DEHVHTXH³DOLFXVWRX
ULRVGHVDQJXHXPDJXHUUDFLYLOWUHPHQGDFXMDVFRQVHTXrQFLDVQmRVH
SRGHPDLQGDSUHYHU3HORTXHUHVSHLWDjFRQGLomRGRVOLEHUWRVWDPEpP
HVVDH[SHULrQFLDQmRHVWiDLQGDFRQVXPDGD´³2H[HPSORGRV(VWDGRV
8QLGRV´QmRSRGHULDVHUYLUGHHVWtPXORSDUDTXHVHWRPDVVHPPHGLGDVLP
SHQVDGDVFRQWUDDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDHOHDLQGDHUDQDTXHOHPRPHQWR
>@XPDFRQWHFLPHQWRQmRFRPSOHWRXPDVROXomRLPSRVWDSHODIRUoD
GHXPDPHWDGHGD1DomRFRQWUDRXWUDVROXomRHPTXHSUHSRQGHURXR
DQWDJRQLVPRSROtWLFRHQmRDTXHVWmRKXPDQLWiULD(VWHH[HPSORSRURUD
SDUHFHPHPDLVIDYRUiYHODRVWDWXVTXR GRTXHjLQRYDomRTXHDWXDOPHQWH
VHSUHWHQGHQR%UDVLO1mRKiHQWUHQyVXPSDUWLGRTXHWRPDVVHDSHLWR
DDEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmR
$GHPDLVDH[SHULrQFLDGHOLEHUWDomRHPPDVVDGRVHVFUDYRVQRUWHD
PHULFDQRVYLQKDVHQGRREVHUYDGDFRPUHVHUYDVPXQGRDIRUD&LWDQGR
XPGLVFXUVRSURQXQFLDGRQR3DUODPHQWREULWkQLFRHUDGHVHUHFHDUTXH
a emancipação fosse
>@ DFRPSDQKDGD GH JUDQGHV PDOHV HP FRQVHTXrQFLD GD SUHJXLoD H
SULYDo}HV GRV SUHWRV HPDQFLSDGRV TXH SRXFD FRQVFLrQFLD WrP SRU RUD
GRVGHYHUHVTXHOKHVLPS}HDFRQGLomRGHKRPHQVOLYUHVIRUPDPLGHLDV
H[DJHUDGDV GRV GLUHLWRV DGTXLULGDV SHOD OLEHUGDGH H SRGHP IDFLOPHQWH
WRUQDUVHXPSHULJRVpULRWDQWRSDUDRV(VWDGRVDTXHSHUWHQFHPFRPR
SDUDR*RYHUQRGD8QLmR>@2HVWDGRDWXDOGDVRFLHGDGHEUDVLOHLUDRX
DHQFDUHPRVSHORODGRSROtWLFRHLPRUDORXDFRQVLGHUHPRVVREUHSRQWR
GHYLVWDGRVLQWHUHVVHVHFRQ{PLFRVQmRLQFLWDDXPSDVVRSUHFLSLWDGRQR
WHUUHQRGHVVDTXHVWmRVRFLDOSHORFRQWUiULRID]UHFXDUFRPWHUURUDQWHHOD


 -+5RGULJXHVRUJAtas do Conselho de Estado, Y%UDVtOLD6HQDGR)HGHUDO
YS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 49

afro 51.indb 49 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 2 TXH 3DUDQKRV HQWHQGLD SRU ³XP DFRQWHFLPHQWR QmR FRPSOH
WR´"(PTXHSHVHDUDWL¿FDomRGD(PHQGDHPGH]HPEURGH
D FKDPDGD 5HFRQVWUXomR 3UHVLGHQFLDO GH$QGUHZ -RKQVRQ GHL[DUD R
statusGRVOLEHUWRVHPVLWXDomRGHSURIXQGDLQFHUWH]DDRORQJRGH
2VVLJQL¿FDGRVGDOLEHUGDGHRHVWDWXWRFLYLOHRVGLUHLWRVSROtWLFRVGRV
H[HVFUDYRVRDFHVVRGHOHVjWHUUDSUySULDRVDUUDQMRVGHWUDEDOKRR
OXJDUGRVOLEHUWRVQDHFRQRPLDHQDVRFLHGDGHVXOLVWDDVSHUVSHFWLYDV
GHUHFXSHUDomRHFRQ{PLFDGRDOJRGmRWXGRLVVRSHUPDQHFLDHPDEHUWR
XPDQRDSyVR¿PGD*XHUUD&LYLO+DYLDDLQGDDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHRV
H[VHQKRUHVUHFXSHUDUHPUDSLGDPHQWHRSRGHUSROtWLFRQRV(VWDGRVGR
6XOHPGHFRUUrQFLDGDSROtWLFDGHSHUGmRDRV&RQIHGHUDGRVDGRWDGDSRU
-RKQVRQ R TXH WUD]LD D DPHDoD GH UHDEHUWXUD GRV FRQÀLWRV PLOLWDUHV
6RPHQWHFRPRLQtFLRGD5HFRQVWUXomR5DGLFDOWRFDGDSHOR&RQJUHVVR
)HGHUDORimpeachment GH-RKQVRQHPIHYHUHLURGHHDHOHLomR
GH8O\VVHV*UDQWQR¿PGRDQRpTXHHVVDVTXHVW}HVHQFRQWUDULDPXPD
UHVSRVWDPDLVDFDEDGD
$DYDOLDomRGH3DUDQKRVVREUHDLQFRPSOHWXGHGDHPDQFLSDomR
DPHULFDQDIRLHVSRVDGDSHORHVFULWRUHSROtWLFR-RVpGH$OHQFDUHPVXDV
Novas cartas políticas de ErasmoSXEOLFDGDVFRPRSDQÀHWRVHUHXQLGDV
HPOLYURDLQGDHP(PSHoDGDWDGDGHGHMXOKRSRUWDQWRWUrV
PHVHVDSyVRGHEDWHQR&RQVHOKRGH(VWDGROLDVHTXH
>@RIDWRGDDEROLomRGRWUDEDOKRHVFUDYRQR6XOGD&RQIHGHUDomRGHFUH
WDGRSRUYLROHQWDJXHUUDFLYLODLQGDQmRVHGHYHFRQVLGHUDUFRQVXPDGR
$PLVpULDHDDQDUTXLDDSHQDVFRPHoDPDGHVGREUDUVHQDTXHOHSDtV
RQWHPÀRUHVFHQWHQLQJXpPVDEHGDVFHQDVGHKRUURUTXHSRUYHQWXUD
VHUYLUDPGHSHULSpFLDDRGUDPDVDQJXLQROHQWR

1mRREVWDQWHDRSRVLomRDRSURMHWRVREUHDOLEHUWDomRGRYHQWUH
H[SRVWD SRU 3DUDQKRV H SRU RXWURV PHPEURV GR &RQVHOKR GH (VWDGR
RSRVLomRTXHFRPRDFDEDPRVGHOHUHQFRQWURXUHVSDOGRIRUDGRyUJmR
GR3RGHU0RGHUDGRUSUHGRPLQRXQDVVHVV}HVGHHGHDEULOGH
DYLVmRGHTXHRLVRODPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOFRPSHOLDR%UDVLODHQFDPL


Eric Foner, 5HFRQVWUXFWLRQ$PHULFD¶V8Q¿QLVKHG5HYROXWLRQ1HZ<RUN+DUSHU 
5RZSS

 -RVpGH$OHQFDUCartas a favor da escravidão, LQ7kPLV3DUURQRUJ6mR3DXOR+HGUD
S

50 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 50 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 QKDUXPDVROXomRSDUDR¿PGRFDWLYHLUR)LFDYDQRDUHQWUHWDQWRXPD
PHQVDJHPGDVIDODVGHGHIHVDGDHVFUDYLGmRGH3DUDQKRVHGH$OHQFDU
GHDJRUDHPGLDQWHRVGHVGREUDPHQWRVGD5HFRQVWUXomRVHULDPDFRPSD
QKDGRVFRPFXLGDGRQR%UDVLOHSRGHULDPVHUSROLWL]DGRVSHORVFDPSRV
em disputa.
$FRQMXQWXUDFUtWLFDGD*XHUUDGR3DUDJXDLHPDFRQYHUWHXHP
SULRULGDGHPi[LPDSDUDRLPSHUDGRU2JDELQHWH=DFDULDVFXMDVVLPSDWLDV
SHORSURMHWRGHOLEHUWDomRGRYHQWUHHVFUDYRHUDPLQHJiYHLVIRLHQWmR
VXEVWLWXtGRSHORFRQVHUYDGRU9LVFRQGHGH,WDERUDtVDTXDUHPDKLVWyULFR
RSRVLWRUGHTXDOTXHUPHGLGDUHODWLYDjHPDQFLSDomRSRUpPYLVWRFRPR
PDLVFDSD]GHFRQGX]LURVDVVXQWRVPLOLWDUHVQR3UDWD$VIUDJLOLGDGHVGR
,PSpULRQRFRQÀLWRGHFRUULDPHPJUDQGHSDUWHGDVGL¿FXOGDGHVGHPRQWDU
XPH[pUFLWRGHEDVHVQDFLRQDLVHPXPDVRFLHGDGHHVFUDYLVWDFRPRDGR
%UDVLOVHQGRHVVDVGL¿FXOGDGHVHODVSUySULDVYHWRUHVGHDJUDYDPHQWRGD
FULVHGDHVFUDYLGmR3RURXWURODGRWHQGR¿QDOPHQWHREWLGRVXFHVVRQR
WHDWURGDJXHUUDRJDELQHWH,WDERUDtFRQJHORXWRGDVDVPHGLGDVUHODWLYDV
jWUDPLWDomRGRSURMHWRHPDQFLSDFLRQLVWDHQWUHH
(PPHLRDRDFLUUDPHQWRGDVWHQV}HVHQWUHRPLQLVWpULRVDTXDUHPD
H'3HGUR,,HPGHPDLRGHXPDFRPLVVmRGD&kPDUDGRV
'HSXWDGRVFRPHoRXDWUDEDOKDUHPWRUQRGRSURMHWRGH3LPHQWD%XHQR
VREUHDOLEHUWDomRGRYHQWUHHVFUDYR0HVPRHQIUHQWDQGRREVWUXo}HVGH
WRGDRUGHPHODDSUHVHQWRXVHXUHODWyULR¿QDOHPGHDJRVWR3DUDRV
WUrVGHSXWDGRVTXHGHQWURGDFRPLVVmRYRWDUDPDIDYRUGRUHODWyULRRV
GRLVYRWRVFRQWUiULRVHUDPGHGHSXWDGRVYLQFXODGRVDRVsaquaremas
DREUDGDHPDQFLSDomRVHULDEHPPDLVVLPSOHVQR%UDVLOGRTXHIRUD
QRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGDGDDDXVrQFLDGHSRODUL]DomRVHFFLRQDOHPWRUQR
GDHVFUDYLGmR6HQR%UDVLOQmRKDYLDSDUWLGRDEROLFLRQLVWDWDPSRXFR
KDYLDSDUWLGRHVFUDYLVWD2VGHSXWDGRVLQGLFDYDPDXUJrQFLDGRDVVXQWR
HPUD]mRGDVUHFHQWHVGHOLEHUDo}HVGDV&RUWHVGD(VSDQKDVREUHDHVFUD
YLGmRHP&XEDH3RUWR5LFR&HUWDPHQWHDUHIRUPDHUDDUULVFDGDSRUpP
QDGDID]HUQDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVFRUUHQWHVVHULDDLQGDPDLVDUULVFDGRSRU
DXPHQWDURSRWHQFLDOGLVUXSWLYRGDFULVHPXQGLDOGDHVFUDYLGmRSDUDR
%UDVLO(PWRPHVSHUDQoRVRRVVLJQDWiULRVGRUHODWyULRDVVLQDODYDPTXHD


 9HUDUHVSHLWR6DOOHVGuerra do ParaguaiSSH&RVWDA espada de DâmoclesSS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 51

afro 51.indb 51 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 WUDMHWyULDGD5HFRQVWUXomR5DGLFDOFRQWUDULDUDRVSURJQyVWLFRVQHJDWLYRV
DQWHVFRUUHQWHVQR%UDVLO
>@ RV UHVXOWDGRV TXH YmR DSUHVHQWDQGR RV (VWDGRV GR 6XO GD 8QLmR
$PHULFDQDHPUHODomRDRWUDEDOKRGRVOLEHUWRVVmRGHRUGHPWDOTXHWrP
H[FHGLGRDH[SHFWDWLYDGRVRWLPLVWDVQHVWDPDWpULD$SyVDYLROHQWDFULVH
SRUTXHSDVVDUDPDTXHOHV(VWDGRVHGDTXDVHFHVVDomRGRWUDEDOKRDJUt
FRODYHLRDUHDomRIDYRUiYHOHRVOLEHUWRVWrPVHHQWUHJDGRDRVWUDEDOKRV
UXUDLVGHIRUPDWDOTXHDSURGXomRGRDOJRGmRYDLVHDSUR[LPDQGRDR
TXHHUDDQWHVGD*XHUUDGH6HFHVVmR

'RUDYDQWH RV VXFHVVRV GD 5HFRQVWUXomR WRUQDUVHLDP SHoD

LPSRUWDQWHQDVXVWHQWDomRGDSODWDIRUPDDQWLHVFUDYLVWD1RHQWDQWRDR
VHUYRWDGRHPSOHQiULRRSDUHFHUGDFRPLVVmRIRLGHUURWDGRSHOD¿UPH
SRVLomRHVFUDYLVWDGRJDELQHWH,WDERUDt3DUDDSURYDURYHQWUHOLYUHVHULD
QHFHVViULDDGLUHomRGHRXWURJDELQHWH(VVDIRLDUD]mRSDUDDUHQ~QFLDGH
,WDERUDtHPVHWHPEURGHHDSyVXPFXUWRLQWHUYDORVRERFRPDQGR
GH3LPHQWD%XHQRVHPKDELOLGDGHVSROtWLFDVQHFHVViULDVSDUDFRVWXUDU
DSRLRQRFKmRGR3DUODPHQWRSDUDDDVFHQVmRHPIHYHUHLURGH
GRJDELQHWHGRDJRUD9LVFRQGHGR5LR%UDQFR
$YLUDGDSROtWLFDGH3DUDQKRVTXHHPPRVWUDUDVHFRQWUi
ULRDRSURMHWRGH3LPHQWD%XHQRVXUSUHHQGHXPXLWRVGHVHXVDQWLJRV
FDPDUDGDVGR3DUWLGR&RQVHUYDGRUHVHULDPRWLYRGHiFLGDVFUtWLFDVQRV
GHEDWHVGHVREUHDLei do Ventre LLYUH$FLVmRGRDWpHQWmRFRHVR
JUXSRSROtWLFRFRQVHUYDGRUQDTXHVWmRGRYHQWUHpXPDGDVPDLRUHVH[
SUHVV}HVGDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmRHGDSUySULDPRQDUTXLDDSDUWLUGDGpFDGD
GH'3HGUR,,TXHGHYHUDjVIRUoDVHVFUDYLVWDVDPRQWDJHPGR
DSDUDWRLQVWLWXFLRQDOGR6HJXQGR5HLQDGRDJRUDVHFRORFDYDDEHUWDPHQWH
FRQWUD HODV 3DUDQKRV5LR %UDQFR WDOYH] VHMD D JUDQGH SHUVRQL¿FDomR
GHVVDUXSWXUD&RPRFRPSUHHQGrOD"$H[SHULrQFLDGLUHWDGH3DUDQKRVQR
3DUDJXDLDRWHUGHOLGDUHPFRPRVSUREOHPDVGHDOLVWDPHQWR
HFRPDQGRGHH[HVFUDYRVHPXPDDOLDQoDPLOLWDUPXOWLQDFLRQDOQDTXDO
R%UDVLORFXSDYDDSRVLomRGH~QLFDQDomRHVFUDYLVWDFRPyEYLRVGHVGR


 ³5HODWyULR¿QDOGD&RPLVVmRHVSHFLDOGD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRVHQFDUUHJDGDGHGDUSDUHFHU
VREUHRHOHPHQWRVHUYLOGHDJRVWRGH´LQA abolição no Parlamento: 65 anos de luta
(1823-1888)Y%UDVtOLD6HQDGR)HGHUDOYS

 7RGRVHVVHVWUkPLWHVSROtWLFRVVmREHPFRQWH[WXDOL]DGRVSRU1HHGHOOThe Party of Order, SS

52 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 52 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 EUDPHQWRVSDUDDD¿UPDomRGR,PSpULRQRFRQFHUWRUHJLRQDOFHUWDPHQWH
WHYHLPSRUWkQFLDPDVRTXDGURJOREDOUHVXOWDQWHGRVFRQWtQXRVHIHLWRV
GD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQDDLQGDPDLV(PGHMXOKRGHD
(VSDQKDDSURYRXDFKDPDGD/HL0RUHWTXHOLEHUWDYDRYHQWUHHVFUDYRHP
&XEDH3RUWR5LFRPDLVXPGRVUHVXOWDGRVGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQR
$FRQH[mRHQWUHXPHYHQWRHRXWURHVXDVLPSOLFDo}HVSDUDR,PSpULR
GR%UDVLOGHUDPDVXEVWkQFLDGRGLVFXUVRGHGHMXOKRGHFRPR
TXDO5LR%UDQFRDEULXDSULPHLUDURGDGDGHGLVFXVV}HVGD/HLGR9HQWUH
/LYUHQD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRV
2H[HPSORGHXPSRYRDPHULFDQRHGHPRFUiWLFRFRPRRGRV(VWDGRV8QL
GRVHUDDUJXPHQWRPXLWRIRUWHHPTXHVHSRGLDPDSRLDUHHPTXHGHIDWR
VHHVWULEDUDPDURWLQDRSUHFRQFHLWRHWRGDVDVSUHRFXSDo}HVGRLQWHUHVVH
LQGLYLGXDO3RLVEHPVHQKRUHVDLGHLDGDHPDQFLSDomRIRLDGLDQWHHD
8QLmR$PHULFDQD~OWLPRH[HPSORGHSRLVGHXPDJXHUUDFLYLOTXHIH]
FRUUHUULRVGHVDQJXHDEROLXGHFKRIUHWRGDDVXDHVFUDYLGmR(VSDQKD
QmRS{GHUHVLVWLUDHVVDLQÀXrQFLDTXHOKHVDWXDYDGHWmRSUy[LPRHD
DEROLomRGRHVWDGRVHUYLOWRUQRXVHXPIDWRTXDVHXQLYHUVDO

2DFRQWHFLPHQWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOHGDHPDQFLSDomRSHODIRUoDGDV
DUPDVGHPDLVGHPLOK}HVGHHVFUDYRVHQWmRFRQYHUWLGRVHP
FLGDGmRVFRPSOHWDUDVH

Os debates de 1871
(PRXWXEURGHIRLFRORFDGDjGLVSRVLomRGRS~EOLFREUDVLOHLURXPD
JUDQGHQRYLGDGHHGLWRULDO3XEOLFDGRHP1HZ<RUNRSHULyGLFRPHQVDO
O Novo Mundo SUHWHQGLD IRUQHFHU DRV OHLWRUHV EUDVLOHLURV DV ~OWLPDV
QRYLGDGHVSROtWLFDVHFRQ{PLFDVHDUWtVWLFDVGDSXMDQWH5HS~EOLFDGRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRVHPSURFHVVRGHFUHVFLPHQWRHGHPRGHUQL]DomRDFHOH
UDGRVDSyVRWpUPLQRGRFRQÀLWRVHFFLRQDO6HXSURSULHWiULRHUHGDWRU
-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVWHULDXPDORQJDFDUUHLUDFRPRMRUQDOLVWDHHGLWRU
3DUDRVSDGU}HVGRVpFXOR;,;O Novo Mundo WHYHERDGXUDomRVHQGR
SXEOLFDGRLQLQWHUUXSWDPHQWHGHD'HSRLVGHIHFKDURSHULyGLFR
HGHL[DURV(VWDGRV8QLGRV5RGULJXHVIRLRSULQFLSDOFRUUHVSRQGHQWHHP

Discussão da Reforma do Estado Servil na Câmara dos Deputados e no Senado, Y5LRGH
-DQHLUR7\SRJUDSKLD1DFLRQDOYSS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 53

afro 51.indb 53 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 Londres do prestigioso Jornal do Commercio, TXHHOHSUySULRFRPSURX
DSyVDSURFODPDomRGD5HS~EOLFDHP
0DLVLPSRUWDQWHSDUDQRVVRV¿QVpRIDWRGHHOHWHUVLGRGXUDQWHDV
GpFDGDVGHHRSULQFLSDOLQIRUPDQWHGRPRYLPHQWRDEROLFLR
QLVWDEUDVLOHLURVREUHRDQGDPHQWRGD5HFRQVWUXomRGR6XO Já em seu
primeiro número, O Novo Mundo WURX[HGXDVQRWtFLDVFDVDGDVTXHEHP
HVFODUHFLDPDGLUHomRHGLWRULDOTXHVHJXLULD1DSULPHLUDGHODVUHSRUWD
YDVHTXHQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVRSODQWLRGHDOJRGmRVHUHFXSHUDYDQmR
REVWDQWHSUREOHPDVSRQWXDLVGHUHFRPSRVLomRGDIRUoDGHWUDEDOKRGRV
OLEHUWRV2TXDGURSRVLWLYRHUDHPJUDQGHSDUWHGHFRUUHQWHGDSUHVLGrQFLD
de Grant, após o caos da administração de Andrew Johnson:
>@ HP GH]RLWR PHVHV D 8QLmR HVWi UHRUJDQL]DGD D SURVSHULGDGH Mi
UHQDVFHXQR6XOPDLVYLoRVDDLQGDGRTXHHVWDYDDQWHVGD*XHUUDR
negro, apesar de tanta antipatia de uma grande minoria, o negro é um
FLGDGmRQDH[WHQVmRGHWRGDVVXDVSUHUURJDWLYDV²DOHLWHPVLGRH[H
cutada com todo o rigor.
1DPHVPDSiJLQDKDYLDXPDUWLJRQRTXDORVHYHQWRVQRUWHD
PHULFDQRVHHVSDQKyLVWRUQDYDPDTXHVWmRGDDEROLomRXUJHQWHSDUDR
,PSpULRGR%UDVLO
>@KiTXDWURDQRVTXDQGRR6U'3HGUR,,GHFODURXTXHLULDWRPDU
PHGLGDVSDUDDEROLUTXDQWRDQWHVRHOHPHQWRVHUYLOGR,PSpULRWRGDD
LPSUHQVDHVWUDQJHLUDH[XOWRXGHXPVLQFHURM~ELORSRUYHUR%UDVLOLU
DFHLWDQGRWmRGHSUHVVDDPRUDOGDJXHUUDLQWHVWLQDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
³(D(VSDQKD´VHGLVVHHQWmR³VHUiR~OWLPRSDtVFRPHVFUDYRV´)H
OL]PHQWHD(VSDQKDMiGHFUHWRXTXHTXHPTXHUTXHpQDVFLGRQRVVHXV
GRPtQLRVpOLYUHPDVLQIHOL]PHQWHR%UDVLOGHL[RXj(VSDQKDDSDOPD
TXHOKHHUDGDGRGHDEROLUSULPHLURDHVFUDYLGmR
(PIDFHGDVUHVLVWrQFLDVGRPLQLVWpULRHPHQFDUDUDTXHVWmRR

 6REUHDWUDMHWyULDGH-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVHVHXSHULyGLFRO Novo Mundo, YHU&KDUOHV$QGHUVRQ
*DXOG³-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHV2SDWULDUFDGDLPSUHQVDFDULRFD´Revista de HistóriaQ
SS*DEULHOD9LHLUDGH&DPSRV³2OLWHUiULRHRQmROLWHUiULRQRVWH[WRVHLPDJHQVGRSHULy
GLFRLOXVWUDGRO Novo Mundo 1RYD,RUTXH´'LVVHUWDomRGH0HVWUDGR8QLYHUVLGDGH
(VWDGXDOGH&DPSLQDV0{QLFD0DULD5LQDOGL$VFLXWWL³8POXJDUSDUDRSHULyGLFRO Novo
Mundo 1RYD,RUTXH´'LVVHUWDomRGH0HVWUDGR8QLYHUVLGDGHGH6mR3DXOR

 6REUHDVFRQH[}HVSHVVRDLVGH5RGULJXHVFRPXPGRVPDLVHPLQHQWHVDEROLFLRQLVWDVEUDVLOHLURV
SLRQHLURGRPRYLPHQWRYHUDFDUWDTXH/XL]*DPDOKHHQGHUHoRXHPGHQRYHPEURGH
LQ/LJLD)RQVHFD)HUUHLUDRUJCom a palavra Luiz Gama. Poemas, artigos, cartas, máximas
6mR3DXOR,PSUHQVD2¿FLDOGR(VWDGRGH6mR3DXORSS

54 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 54 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 MRUQDOLVWDVHUHIHULDDRJDELQHWH,WDERUDtGHUUXEDGRXPPrVDQWHVR
VDFULItFLRVHULDJUDQGHVHQmRFRPSDUiYHODRTXHRFRUUHUDQRV(VWDGRV
8QLGRV2ULVFRSRUpPYDOLDDSHQD
1DYLUDGDGHSDUD-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVFRQWLQXRX
DSXEOLFDUDUWLJRVFRPHVVHWRP1DVSiJLQDVGHO Novo Mundo apare
FHUDPFUtWLFDVDRLPSHULDOLVPRHVFUDYLVWDHVSDQKROQD$PpULFDGR6XOH
QR&DULEHQRFXUVRGD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQDORJRVRODSDGRSHOD
YLWyULDGD8QLmRHORJLRVDRVVXFHVVRVHFRQ{PLFRVVRFLDLVHSROtWLFRVGD
DEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVDQHFHVVLGDGHGHR3DUODPHQ
WREUDVLOHLURDEULURTXDQWRDQWHVDVGHOLEHUDo}HVVREUHDHPDQFLSDomR
VDEHQGRVHTXHHODH[LJLULDGRV ID]HQGHLURVGHVSUHQGLPHQWRQR FXUWR
SUD]RDVHUUHFRPSHQVDGRFRPDSRVWHULRURUGHPGRWUDEDOKROLYUH
6REUHVVDLQHVVHVHVFULWRVRFRQWUDVWHHQWUHDDSUHFLDomRIDYRUiYHOGD
UHRUJDQL]DomRGRWUDEDOKRHGDUHFRPSRVLomRGDVH[SRUWDo}HVDOJRGRHL
UDVVXOLVWDVHDDSUHHQVmRQHJDWLYDGDHPDQFLSDomRQR&DULEHEULWkQLFR
HIUDQFrVTXHSUHGRPLQDUDQR%UDVLOQDVGpFDGDVGHH1D
SULPHLUDpSRFDRROKDUGLUHFLRQDGRSDUDIRUDGR,PSpULRKDYLDVLGRXPD
SHoDLPSRUWDQWHSDUDDGHIHVDGDHVFUDYLGmRQDFLRQDODJRUDHP
RFDPSRDQWLHVFUDYLVWDSRGLDD¿UPDUTXHDHPDQFLSDomRQRPDLRUSDtV
HVFUDYLVWDGDV$PpULFDVHUDXPVXFHVVRHFRQ{PLFR
(VVD PRGL¿FDomR QD SHUFHSomR GD WUDMHWyULD SyVDEROLomR GRV
HVSDoRV DPHULFDQRV FRQIRUPDULD RV GHEDWHV SDUODPHQWDUHV GH 
'XUDQWHRDQROHJLVODWLYRDEHUWRHPPDLRVHXWHPDFUXFLDO²SRGHVH
GL]HUTXDVHTXHH[FOXVLYR²IRLDGHOLEHUDomRDUHVSHLWRGRSURMHWRPL
QLVWHULDOGHOLEHUWDomRGRYHQWUH1RYDPHQWHRTXHQRVLQWHUHVVDVmRRV
SDGU}HVEiVLFRVGHOHLWXUDGDH[SHULrQFLDQRUWHDPHULFDQDQRVGLVFXUVRV
YHLFXODGRVQR3DUODPHQWRHQDLPSUHQVDEUDVLOHLUD
&RPRRVPHPEURVPDLVLPSRUWDQWHVGRJDELQHWHRVVHQDGRUHV


 ³8PDGPLQLVWUDGRUPRGHOR´³$HPDQFLSDomRGRVHVFUDYRV´O Novo Mundo, QS

 9HUUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH³$+HVSDQKDHR&KLOLR3HUXD%ROtYLDHR(TXDGRU´O Novo Mundo, Q
S³2DQRGH´O Novo MundoQSRQGHVHOLDTXH³DREUDGD5HFRQV
WUXomRHVWiFRQFOXtGDRQHJURQmRVypXPOLEHUWRpXPFLGDGmRHDVULTXH]DVPDWHULDLVGRSDtV
UHFXSHUDPVHVREDDWLQDGDHSDFt¿FDDGPLQLVWUDomRGDTXHOHPHVPRTXHIRLRTXHFDOFRXSDUDVHPSUH
DWHUUtYHOKLGUDGDHVFUDYLGmR´³$JRUDpRWHPSRDSUD]DGR´O Novo MundoQS

Parron, A política da escravidãoSS3DUDRFRQWH[WRPDLVDPSORYHU6H\PRXU'UHVFKHU
The Mighty Experiment. Free Labor versus Slavery in British Emancipation1HZ<RUN2[IRUG
8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 55

afro 51.indb 55 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 9LVFRQGHGH5LR%UDQFRPLQLVWURGD)D]HQGDHSUHVLGHQWHGR&RQVHOKR
GH0LQLVWURVH)UDQFLVFRGH3DXOD1HJUHLURVGH6DLmR/REDWRWLWXODU
GDSDVWDGD-XVWLoDIRUDPRVJUDQGHVGHIHQVRUHVGRSURMHWRQD&kPDUD
HQR6HQDGR8PDGDVHVWUDWpJLDVHPSUHJDGDVIRLDGHUHFRUUHUjDPHDoD
GR H[HPSOR GRV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV (P LQWHUYHQomR QR 6HQDGR HP 
GHPDLRFXMRDUJXPHQWRIRLUHSLVDGRQD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRVRQ]H
GLDV GHSRLV 6DLmR /REDWR D¿UPRX TXH VH RV VHQKRUHV GH HVFUDYRV H
VHXV UHSUHVHQWDQWHV SDUODPHQWDUHV UHVLVWLVVHP DR FDPLQKR UHIRUPLVWD
GRYHQWUHOLYUHHPEUHYHSRGHULDYLUDDEROLomRVHPLQGHQL]DomRSRU
PHLRVUHYROXFLRQiULRV(UDH[DWDPHQWHLVVRRTXHSUH¿JXUDYDDWUDMH
WyULDQRUWHDPHULFDQDGHXPUHIRUPLVPRLQVLVWHQWHPHQWHEDUUDGRSHOR
6XOHTXHOHYRXjUHYROXomRGH Rio Branco, por seu turno,
UHWRPRXRSRQWRGRLVRODPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOGR%UDVLO²VHJXQGRHOH
XPDSHUFHSomRFRPSDUWLOKDGDSRUWRGRVLQFOXLQGRRVTXHVHFRORFDYDP
FRQWUDRSURMHWR²FRPRLPSXOVRSDUDDOHLGRYHQWUH
9HLRDJXHUUDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHGXUDQWHHVVDOXWDFRORVVDOQHQKXP
KRPHPUHÀHWLGRGR%UDVLOGHL[RXGHGL]HUFRQVLJRPXLWDVYH]HV³9DLVH
R~OWLPRH[HPSORTXHSRGLDVHUYLUQRVGHDSRLRPRUDOQRPXQGRFLYLOL
]DGRFRQWUDDDYHUVmRTXHH[FLWDDHVFUDYLGmR([WLQWDDHVFUDYLGmRQRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRVpSUHFLVRSHQVDUTXHHODQmRGHYHH[LVWLUQR%UDVLO´
1mRIRLHVWHRSHQVDPHQWRJHUDO"


 2VGLVFXUVRVGH6DLmR/REDWRSRGHPVHUOLGRVQRDiário do Rio de JaneiroGHMXQKRGH
SS5HFXUVRUHWyULFRVHPHOKDQWHIRLXWLOL]DGRSRU)UDQFLVFR6DOOHV7RUUHV+RPHPQR6HQDGR
HPGHVHWHPEUR³$VJUDQGHVUHIRUPDVVREUHWXGRDVTXHHQYROYHPDH[SLDomRGHJUDQGHVIDOWDV
GRSDVVDGRQmRVHRSHUDPVHPGRUHVHVHPSHVDUHV2VDFULItFLRpDFRQGLomRSURYLGHQFLDOGH
WRGRRSURJUHVVRpDFRQGLomRGHUHGHQomRGDKXPDQLGDGHHPFDGDXPGRVJUDQGHVSDVVRVTXH
WHQWDGDUSDUDPHOKRUDUDVXDVRUWHSRGHDWHQXiORPDVQmRHYLWiOR>@&RPRSRGHUtDPRV
SRUWDQWRDGPLWLUTXHVHPDQWLYHVVHXPDVLWXDomRSRUWDQWRVPRWLYRVDPDOGLoRDGRVySRUTXH
DOJXQVLQF{PRGRVGDPXGDQoDSXGHVVHPYLUDRVSURSULHWiULRV">@2VHXGHVSHLWRDVXDUHVLV
WrQFLDTXHDVUXLQVSDL[}HVVXJHUHPQmRSRGHULDPVHUYLUVHQmRSDUDGREUDUHDJUDYDURVSHULJRV
3HUJXQWHVHjKLVWyULDRTXHDFRQWHFHXDWRGRVDTXHOHVTXHRXYLQGRURGDUGHSHUWRRFDUURGR
SURJUHVVRWHQWDPRSRUVHjVXDSDVVDJHPLUUHVLVWtYHO3HUJXQWHVHDHVVHVDUURJDQWHVSODQWDGRUHV
GR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVTXHUHSHOLQGRWRGRVRVFRPSURPLVVRVHHPSHUUDGRVHPVXDVLOXV}HV
EODVRQDYDPGHGLODWDURVWHUULWyULRVGDHVFUDYLGmRGHVGHRW~PXORGH:DVKLQJWRQDWpRSDOiFLR
GH 0RQWH]XPD" 4XDQGR PHQRV HVSHUDYDVH R HGLItFLR GHVDERX VREUH HOHV VHSXOWDQGROKHV
IRUWXQDVLQWHLUDVGHEDL[RGDVUXtQDVHQVDQJXHQWDGDVSRUXPDJXHUUDGHYDVWDGRUD´$6
YS-RVpGH$OHQFDUSRUVXDYH]FRQWHVWRXGXUDPHQWHWDOHVWUDWpJLDHPGLVFXUVRGHGH
MXOKRQD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRV³1D,QJODWHUUDQD)UDQoDQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVQXQFDVHVHUYLX
GDDPHDoDGDUHYROXomRFRPRPHLRGHHYLWDUDUHVLVWrQFLDGRVSURSULHWiULRVHVWDYDUHVHUYDGR
LVWRSDUDRJRYHUQRGR%UDVLO´Diário do Rio de Janeiro, GHMXOKRGHS

Diário do Rio de Janeiro, GHMXQKRGHS

56 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 56 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 2 FDPSR SUyHVFUDYLVWD UHFRQKHFLD TXH GH IDWR R HYHQWR QRU
WHDPHULFDQR KDYLD DOWHUDGR SURIXQGDPHQWH DV FRQGLo}HV SROtWLFDV GD
HVFUDYLGmRGHQWURGRHVSDoRQDFLRQDO8PGRVGLVFXUVRVPDLVUHOHYDQWHV
DUHVSHLWRIRLRGRGHSXWDGRVDTXDUHPD-RmRGH$OPHLGD3HUHLUD)LOKR
SURQXQFLDGRHPGHDJRVWR
4XHPKiDQRVSRGHULDSHQVDUTXHQyVHVWiYDPRVWmRSUy[LPRVGHXPD
UHYROXomRVRFLDOFRPRHVWDTXHWHPQDWXUDOPHQWHGHRSHUDUDSURSRVWD
GRJRYHUQRFRPRVHDFKDIRUPXODGD")XLPLQLVWURKiDQRVHFRQIHVVR
TXHQXQFDYLWUDWDUVHVHULDPHQWHGHVWDJUDYtVVLPDTXHVWmR

'HXPDVLWXDomRHVWiYHOSURVVHJXLD3HUHLUD)LOKRDHVFUDYLGmR
EUDVLOHLUDSDVVRXSDUDDGHLQVWDELOLGDGHQRPRPHQWRHPTXHDMXQWD
IUDQFHVDGHHPDQFLSDomRLPSXOVLRQDGDSHODDEROLomRQRV(VWDGRV8QL
GRVHQYLRXHPMXOKRGHDFDUWDD'3HGUR,,3LRUIRLDUHVSRVWD
R¿FLDOGRJRYHUQREUDVLOHLURTXHDEULXXPWHUUtYHOSUHFHGHQWHGDTXHOH
SRQWRHPGLDQWHR%UDVLOWRUQRXVHYXOQHUiYHOjSUHVVmRH[WHUQDPHVPR
TXHDLGHLDGDHPDQFLSDomRQmRFRQWDVVHFRPVXSRUWHQDRSLQLmRS~EOLFD
QDFLRQDO$HVFUDYLGmRHUDRIXQGDPHQWRGDULTXH]DPDWHULDOGR%UDVLO
HDVH[SHULrQFLDVSUpYLDVGHDEROLomRQRPXQGRDWOkQWLFRLQGLFDYDPTXH
HODVHULDSHUGLGDFRPDDSURYDomRGDOHLGRYHQWUH7RGRVRVHVSDoRV
WURSLFDLVDPHULFDQRVTXHVHYLUDPIRUoDGRVDDEGLFDUGREUDoRHVFUDYR
UHJUHGLUDPHFRQRPLFDPHQWHLQFOXVLYHR6XO
2V(VWDGRV8QLGRVTXHH[SRUWDUDPXPDQRDQWHVGD*XHUUDFHUFDGH
FLQFRPLOK}HVGHEDODV>Lpbales@GHDOJRGmRDLQGDKRMHDSHVDUGHWHUHP
FRQFHQWUDGRDDWHQomRHVSHFLDOPHQWHVREUHHVWDFXOWXUDTXHFRQVLGHUDP
PDLVIiFLOHYDQWDMRVDDSURGXomRQmRFKHJRXDWUrVPLOK}HVGHEDODV
QRWDQGRVHTXHLVWRpDJRUDMiPXLWRVDQRVGHSRLVGD*XHUUD>@6HOi
QRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVRQGHKiFDQDLVH[WHQVDVUHGHVGHFDPLQKRVGHIHUUR
RQGHKiXPDQDYHJDomRFXLGDGDXPDLQG~VWULDIDEULOULYDOGD(XURSD
RQGHKiLQVWUXomRSUR¿VVLRQDODFRQWHFHLVVRRTXHGHYHDFRQWHFHUD
HVWHLQIHOL]SDtV"


Diário do Rio de Janeiro, GHDJRVWRGHSS2XWURH[HPSORGHTXHRVGHIHQVRUHV
GDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDUHFRQKHFHUDPTXHD*XHUUD&LYLOUHSUHVHQWDUDXPSRQWRGHYLUDGDHVWi
QRGLVFXUVRGR%DUmRGH7UrV%DUUDVSURQXQFLDGRQR6HQDGRHPGHVHWHPEURGH2
GLVFXUVRHVWiUHSURGX]LGRQRVAnexos aos Annaes do Senado - 1871, Rio de Janeiro: Typographia
1DFLRQDOVHPSDJLQDomR

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 57

afro 51.indb 57 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 2GHSXWDGRQmRIRUQHFHXDIRQWHGRVGDGRVVREUHRDOJRGmRHQLQ
JXpPQRSOHQiULRUHWUXFRXVXDYHUDFLGDGH'HWRGRPRGRVXDLQWHUYHQomR
VXJHUHTXHRVHVFUDYLVWDVEUDVLOHLURVDSRVWDYDPQDUHJUHVVmRHFRQ{PLFDGR
6XOSDUDIUHDUDVLQLFLDWLYDVFRQWUDDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO'DtDLPSRUWkQFLD
SDUDRVDQWLHVFUDYLVWDVGHGHPRQVWUDURVXFHVVRGD5HFRQVWUXomR3RXFRV
GRFDPSRHVFUDYLVWDQRHQWDQWRDFHLWDUDPRGHVD¿RGHSURYDUTXHDH[
SHULrQFLDSyVHPDQFLSDomRQRUWHDPHULFDQDHUDXPIUDFDVVRHFRQ{PLFR
WDOYH]SRUUHFRQKHFHUHPVXDLJQRUkQFLDVREUHRWHPD
eRTXHVHSRGHYHUL¿FDUHPXPDUHSUHVHQWDomRGRVSURSULHWiULRV
GH9DVVRXUDVXPDGDVPXLWDVTXHIRUDPFRPSRVWDVSHORVVHQKRUHVGH
HVFUDYRVGR9DOHGR3DUDtEDFRQWUDDLei do Ventre LLYUH1DGpFDGD
GHHVVHVPHVPRVID]HQGHLURVRXVHXVSDLVKDYLDPSHWLFLRQDGR
DR3DUODPHQWREUDVLOHLURFRQWUDDOHLDQWLWUi¿FRGHGHPDQGDQGRD
UHDEHUWXUDGRWUi¿FRQHJUHLURWUDQVDWOkQWLFR1RTXHDOLiVIRUDPPXLWR
EHPVXFHGLGRVSRLVMDPDLVR(VWDGREUDVLOHLURTXHVWLRQRXDSURSULHGDGH
LOHJDOGRVPDLVGHDIULFDQRVLQWURGX]LGRVQR%UDVLOHQWUH
H(PWRGDYLDDFRUUHODomRGHIRUoDVHUDGLVWLQWDPHVPR
com a demonstração maciça de descontentamento de todos os grandes
ID]HQGHLURVGHFDIpGDUHJLmRFRPRSURMHWRGHOHL²RTXHHTXLYDOLDD
GL]HURVPDLRUHVSURGXWRUHVPXQGLDLVGRDUWLJR²RJDELQHWH5LR%UDQFR
VHJXLXDGLDQWHFRPDWUDPLWDomRSDUODPHQWDU'DtDOJXQVKLVWRULDGRUHV
FRQVLGHUDUHPRHSLVyGLRGHFRPRRLQtFLRGRGLYyUFLRGDPRQDUTXLD
EUDVLOHLUDHPUHODomRjVVXDVEDVHVVRFLDLV
'DVPDLVGHGXDVGH]HQDVGHUHSUHVHQWDo}HVOHYDGDVDR3DUODPHQ
WRFDWRU]HIRUDPSXEOLFDGDVQDVSiJLQDVGRDiário do Rio de Janeiro, o
yUJmRGHLPSUHQVDTXHH[SUHVVRXDPDLVDJXHUULGDRSRVLomRGRSURMHWRGR
YHQWUH'HVVDVDSHQDVGXDVPHQFLRQDUDPEUHYHPHQWHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
$UHIHUrQFLDQDUHSUHVHQWDomRGH%DQDQDODSHQDVD¿UPRXTXHQR%UDVLO
QmRKDYLDSDUWLGRHVFUDYLVWDFRPRQD5HS~EOLFDQRUWHDPHULFDQD$GH
9DVVRXUDVDOpPGHUHSLVDURDUJXPHQWRFRQVHQVXDOGHWRGDVDVUHSUHVHQ


 &RPEDVHHPSHUVSHFWLYDVWHyULFDVGLVWLQWDVHVWDpDLQWHUSUHWDomRGH-RVp0XULORGH&DUYDOKR
A construção da ordem/Teatro de sombras5LRGH-DQHLUR&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDS
HDGH6DOOHVE o Vale era o escravo, SS. 6REUHDDWXDomRHPEORFRGRVID]HQGHLURVGR
9DOHGR3DUDtEDFRQWUDDLHLGR9HQWUH/LYUHYHUWDPEpP/DXUD-DQDUJLQ3DQJ³7KH6WDWHDQG
$JULFXOWXUDO&OXEVRI,PSHULDO%UD]LO´7HVHGH'RXWRUDGR9DQGHUELOW8QLYHUVLW\
SS

58 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 58 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 WDo}HVGR9DOHGR3DUDtEDDUHVSHLWRGDTXHEUDGDVREHUDQLDGRPpVWLFDH
GRVGLUHLWRVGHSURSULHGDGHHPEXWLGRVQRSURMHWRPLQLVWHULDOFULWLFRXR
JRYHUQRSHODDXVrQFLDGHGHEDWHSUpYLRFRPRVID]HQGHLURV(UDSUHFLVR
VDEHUTXDLVDVSHUVSHFWLYDVSyVFDWLYHLURHPRXWURVHVSDoRVSDUDTXHRV
SURSULHWiULRVEUDVLOHLURVSXGHVVHPVDEHUHPTXHFKmRHVWDYDPSLVDQGR
>@HVWDEHOHoDVHFRPRQR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHGHVGHMiFRPLVV}HV
LG{QHDVSDUDLQGDJDUGRVPDOHVTXHVREUHYLHUDPjDEROLomRGRPRGR
SRUTXHIRUDPFRQMXUDGRVSDUDREVHUYDUTXDQWRSRVVDLQWHUHVVDUGHVVD
HQRUPHUHYROXomRTXHUHOD[RXKiSRXFRGRFDWLYHLURHODQoRXGHUHSHQWH
QRPHLRGHXPDVRFLHGDGHOLEpUULPDTXDWURPLOK}HVGHHVFUDYRV

(PTXHSHVHDVROLFLWDomRGH9DVVRXUDVSRUGDGRVPDLVSUHFLVRV
acerca do andamento da Reconstrução, a estratégia dos defensores da
HVFUDYLGmRHPIRLDGHHQIDWL]DUDIDFHORFDOGRSUREOHPDMXVWDPHQWH
SDUDVDLUQRWHUUHQRHPTXHRJDELQHWH5LR%UDQFRFRORFDUDDGLVFXVVmR
LVWRpRLVRODPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOGR%UDVLO1HVVHVHQWLGRDLQWHUYHQomR
GH'RPLQJRV$QGUDGH)LJXHLUDpEHPVLJQL¿FDWLYDSRLVHOHIRLTXLoi
RSULQFLSDOSRUWDYR]GHQWURGD&kPDUDGRV'HSXWDGRVGDVDVSLUDo}HV
GRVID]HQGHLURVGHFDIpGR9DOHGR3DUDtEDQDTXHODFRQMXQWXUD'HVGH
QKDQGRRDUJXPHQWRGHTXHR%UDVLOWHULDSUREOHPDVSRUHVWDUVR]LQKR
QRPXQGRDRPDQWHUDHVFUDYLGmR$QGUDGH)LJXHLUDD¿UPRXQDVHVVmR
GHGHDJRVWRTXH
>@QmRVyQmRH[LVWHSUHVVmRH[WHUQDPDVTXHQmRpSRVVtYHOH[LVWLU$V
QDo}HVSULQFLSDLVQHVVDFUX]DGDDQWLHPDQFLSDGRUDQHVWHVpFXORVmRD
,QJODWHUUDHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVMXVWDPHQWHDTXHODVFRPTXHPDQWHPRV
DVPDLVH[WHQVDVUHODo}HVFRPHUFLDLV

2V LQJOHVHV WLQKDP XPD HQRUPLGDGH GH FDSLWDLV HPSDWDGRV QR

%UDVLOQRVHUYLoRGDGtYLGDHHPHPSUHHQGLPHQWRVGLUHWRVIHUURYLDV
FRPSDQKLDVGHQDYHJDomREDQFRVHWF


 $UHSUHVHQWDomRGH%DQDQDOIRLSXEOLFDGDQRDiário do Rio de Janeiro no dia GHMXQKRGH
DGH9DVVRXUDVQRGLDGHMXOKRSUHFHGLGDGHRXWUDGRPHVPRPXQLFtSLRHPGH
MXOKR$VGHPDLVWRGDVSXEOLFDGDVHPQRPHVPRSHULyGLFRVDtUDPHPGHPDLR3DUDtED
GR6XOGHMXQKR3LUDtGHMXQKR&RQVHUYDWyULDGHMXQKR&RUSRGR&RPpUFLRGR
5LRGH-DQHLURGHMXOKR9DOHQoDGHMXOKR&DPSLQDVGHMXOKR&OXEHGD/DYRXUD
HGR&RPpUFLRHGHMXOKRDPEDVGH&DQWDJDORGHDJRVWR-XL]GH)RUDGHDJRVWR
6mR/XLVGR3DUDLWLQJD

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 59

afro 51.indb 59 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 4XDQWRDRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVD&kPDUDVDEHTXHDTXHODJUDQGH5HS~EOLFD
FRPYLVWDVGHODUJRVIXWXURVHVWiUHDOL]DQGRDSUiWLFDGHDEDL[DUDWp
H[WLQJXLUFRPSOHWDPHQWHRVGLUHLWRVGHLPSRUWDomRODQoDGRVVREUHRV
JrQHURVGHQRVVDSURGXomR2UDpXPSDtVGHVWHVTXHQRVSRGHWHUPi
YRQWDGHSRUFDXVDGDHVFUDYDWXUD"eXPSDtVGHVWHVTXHSRGHYLULPSRU
QRVDDEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmR"

'HVVDVFRQVWDWDo}HV$QGUDGH)LJXHLUDWLUDYDDFRQFOXVmRGHTXH
>@DTXHVWmRpLQWHLUDPHQWHGRPpVWLFDHGHYHPRVUHVROYrODGHVSUHR
FXSDGRV QmR Vy GR JRYHUQR H[WHUQR FRPR GH TXDOTXHU VRFLHGDGH GH
HPDQFLSDomRHVWUDQJHLUDGHYHPRVUHVROYrODLQVSLUDGRH[FOXVLYDPHQWH
SHORVJUDQGHVLQWHUHVVHVQDFLRQDLVFRPSUXGrQFLDFRQVXOWDQGRDHVVHV
LQWHUHVVHVHYLWDQGRDEDORVHSHUWXUEDo}HV

$HVWUDWpJLDGH³QDFLRQDOL]DU´RGHEDWHUHFXVDQGRRHQIUHQWDPHQWR
GRJDELQHWHFRPEDVHQDH[SHULrQFLDGHRXWURVSDtVHVIUDFDVVRXYDOHQ
GRVHGHYiULRVH[SHGLHQWHVRPLQLVWpULR5LR%UDQFRORJURXDSURYDUR
SURMHWRVREUHDOLEHUWDomRGRYHQWUHQDVGXDVFDVDVHDOHLIRLVDQFLRQDGD
SHORSRGHULPSHULDOHPGHVHWHPEURGH

Norte x sul: a Reconstruoão a recon¿Juraoão

da economia mundial e o surgimento
do movimento abolicionista brasileiro
$V DFXVDo}HV GH TXH D YLWyULD GR JRYHUQR HP  IRUD EDVHDGD HP
SUiWLFDVGHFRRSWDomRHSDWURQDJHPSURFHGHPPDVSRUVLVyHODVQmR
H[SOLFDPDGLYLVmRUHJLRQDOTXHSHUPLWLXDSDVVDJHPGDOHL1D&kPDUD
RQGHVHMRJRXDEDWDOKDGHFLVLYDDVEDQFDGDVGRQRUWH3LDXt&HDUi
5LR*UDQGHGR1RUWH3DUDtED3HUQDPEXFR$ODJRDV6HUJLSH%DKLD
YRWDUDPHPSHVRSHODDSURYDomRFRPSRUWDPHQWRTXDVHLQYHUVRjVGR
VXO(VStULWR6DQWR0LQDV*HUDLV5LRGH-DQHLUR6mR3DXORTXHYR
WDUDPSHODUHMHLomR3RUpPQmRQDSURSRUomRGDVSURYtQFLDVQRUWLVWDV
HQTXDQWRQRQRUWHSDUDVHLVGHSXWDGRVXPYRWRXFRQWUDQRVXOSDUD
WUrVGHSXWDGRVXPYRWRXDIDYRU1RXWURVWHUPRVSDUDRJDELQHWH5LR


Diário do Rio de Janeiro, GHDJRVWRGHS

Conrad, Os últimos anos da escravatura$SrQGLFH7DEHOD

60 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 60 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 %UDQFRREWHUVXFHVVRHOHWHYHGHFRQWDUFRPRVXSRUWHTXDVHXQkQLPH
QR QRUWH H FRP DOJXPDV GHIHFo}HV QR VXO 1mR p H[DJHUR GL]HU TXH
HPDPDFURUUHJLmRGDEDFLDGRULR3DUDtEDGR6XOSUDWLFDPHQWH
FRORFRXVHFRQWUDWRGRR%UDVLO
(VVDH[SHULrQFLDSROtWLFDFRUSRUL¿FRXGHIRUPDFODUDRVULVFRV
FRQWLGRV QD SRODUL]DomR UHJLRQDO GD HVFUDYLGmR EUDVLOHLUD UHPHWHQGR
DRV ROKRV GRV VHQKRUHV GDV SURYtQFLDV GR VXO j WUDMHWyULD SUpYLD GRV
(VWDGRV8QLGRV2GHVFRPSURPLVVRFUHVFHQWHGDVSURYtQFLDVGRQRUWH
FRPDHVFUDYLGmRMiHUDUHVXOWDGRGRVÀX[RVQHJUHLURVTXHVHDWLYDUDP
LQWHUQDPHQWHQR%UDVLOORJRDSyVRIHFKDPHQWRGDIURQWHLUDDWOkQWLFDGH
HVFUDYL]DomR1DGpFDGDGHDDOWDGRVSUHoRVGRFDIpGUHQRXSDUD
DVID]HQGDVGR5LRGH-DQHLURGH6mR3DXORH0LQDV*HUDLVHVFUDYRV
GHSHTXHQDVSURSULHGDGHVUXUDLVGDSHFXiULDHGDVFLGDGHVGRQRUWHH
GRSUySULRVXOFRPDDOWDQRVSUHoRVGRDo~FDURVVHQKRUHVGHHQJHQKR
QmRYHQGHUDPVHXVHVFUDYRVSDUDDFDIHLFXOWXUD$WHQGrQFLDVHDOWHURX
QDGpFDGDVHJXLQWHHPXPDFRQMXQWXUDGHEDL[DGRWUi¿FRLQWHUQRRFD
VLRQDGDSRUXPODGRSHODVTXHEUDVGDVDIUDGRFDIpQRLQtFLRGDGpFDGD
HSHODUHGXomRGDGHPDQGDQRUWHDPHULFDQDQRFXUVRGD*XHUUD&LYLOH
SRURXWURSHOD³IRPHGHDOJRGmR´PXQGLDOJHUDGDFRPDVDtGDGRV&6$
GRVPHUFDGRVJOREDLV&RPHIHLWRRQRUWHGR%UDVLOIRLXPDGDVUHJL}HV
PDLVEHQH¿FLDGDVSHORTXDGURLPHGLDWRGRFRQÀLWRQRUWHDPHULFDQRFRP
DH[SDQVmRGRVDOJRGRDLVGH3HUQDPEXFRDR0DUDQKmR
1mRREVWDQWHDUHODWLYDUHWUDomRGRWUi¿FRLQWHUQRQDGpFDGDGH
HUDYLVtYHOHPDRVDWRUHVSROtWLFRVHHFRQ{PLFRVDFUHVFHQ


 &RPREHPUHVVDOWRXRKLVWRULDGRU(YDOGR&DEUDOGH0HOORO norte agrário e o Império, 1871-
1889, 5LRGH-DQHLUR1RYD)URQWHLUDS³RDSRLRGLVSHQVDGRSHODVEDQFDGDVQRUWLVWDV
jVXDDSURYDomR>GDOHL5LR%UDQFR@pTXHIH]QDVFHUHQWUHRVUHSUHVHQWDQWHVGDVSURYtQFLDV
FDIHHLUDVDVSULPHLUDVGHVFRQ¿DQoDVFRPUHODomRDRWUi¿FR>LQWHUQR@RVSULPHLURVWHPRUHVGH
TXHHOHRSHUDVVHHPGHWULPHQWRGRVLQWHUHVVHVHVFUDYRFUDWDV´

 -DFRE*RUHQGHUO escravismo colonial, 6mR3DXOR)XQGDomR3HUVHX$EUDPRSS
$SHULRGL]DomRSURSRVWDSRU*RUHQGHUpFRQ¿UPDGDSHORGHWDOKDGRHVWXGRGH5REHUW:6OHQHV
³7KH%UD]LOLDQ,QWHUQDO6ODYH7UDGH5HJLRQDO(FRQRPLHV6ODYH([SHULHQFHDQGWKH
3ROLWLFVRID3HFXOLDU0DUNHW´LQ:DOWHU-RKQVRQ RUJThe Chattel Principle: Internal Slave
Trades in the Americas 1HZ+DYHQ<DOH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS9HUWDPEpP
-RVp)OiYLR0RWWD(VFUDYRVGDTXLGDOLHGHPDLVDOpP2WUi¿FRLQWHUQRGHFDWLYRVQDH[SDQVmR
cafeeira paulista, 6mR3DXOR$ODPHGDSS6REUHDVSURIXQGDVDOWHUDo}HVQRPHU
FDGRPXQGLDOGRDOJRGmRFRPRFRPHoRGD*XHUUD&LYLOYHU6YHQ%HFNHUW³(PDQFLSDWLRQDQG
(PSLUH5HFRQVWUXFWLQJWKH:RUOGZLGH:HERI&RWWRQ3URGXFWLRQLQWKH$JHRIWKH$PHULFDQ
&LYLO:DU´The American Historical ReviewYQSS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 61

afro 51.indb 61 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 WHFRQFHQWUDomRGHHVFUDYRVQDVSURYtQFLDVFDIHHLUDVGRVXOGR%UDVLO
WHQGrQFLDTXHVHDSURIXQGDULDQRVDQRVVHWHQWDRSLFRGRWUi¿FRLQWHUQR
GHHVFUDYRV&RPDFKHJDGDGDVIHUURYLDVjVIURQWHLUDVFDIHHLUDVDQRYD
LVHQomRGHWD[DVGHLPSRUWDomRGRFDIpQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGHFUHWDGD
HPGXUDQWHD*XHUUD&LYLORSURGXWRYROWDUDDVHUWD[DGRFRPR
SDUWHGRHVIRUoRGHUHFRPSRVLomRGDV¿QDQoDVGD8QLmRHHPHVSH
FLDODIRUWHDOWDGRVSUHoRVFRPDUHWRPDGDGRFUHVFLPHQWRGDGHPDQGD
QRUWHDPHULFDQD DV FRPSUDV GH HVFUDYRV QR PHUFDGR LQWHUQR SHORV
FDIHLFXOWRUHVVXELUDPQRWDYHOPHQWH(PUHDOLGDGHDSDUWLUGDGpFDGD
GHDVUHODo}HVHQWUHRVSURGXWRUHVEUDVLOHLURVHRVFRQVXPLGRUHV
QRUWHDPHULFDQRVGHFDIpFXMDFRQVWUXomRVHLQLFLDUDQDGpFDGDGH
WRUQDUVHLDPFDGDYH]PDLVHVWUHLWDVHLVVRDGHVSHLWRGRIDWRGHDGH
PDQGDQRUWHDPHULFDQDWHUHVWLPXODGRYiULRVRXWURVSDtVHVGD$PpULFD
Latina a entrarem no mercado.
2FUHVFLPHQWRHFRQ{PLFRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVDSyVD*XHUUD&LYLO
DOWHURXDVFRQGLo}HVGHHVWDELOLGDGHGRVLVWHPDHVFUDYLVWDEUDVLOHLURMi
EDVWDQWHDEDODGRHPFRQVHTXrQFLDGDDSURYDomRGD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUH
9HMDPRVDPDWpULDFRPRIRFRYROWDGRDRVVHWRUHVFDIHHLURDoXFDUHLURH
DOJRGRHLUR(PRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHUDPRVPDLRUHVLPSRUWDGRUHV
DEVROXWRVGHFDIpGRJORERFRPRPDLRUFRQVXPRUHODWLYRper capita.
1RFXUVRGDVWUrVGpFDGDVDQWHULRUHVRXVRGDEHELGDGLVVHPLQDUDVH
JHRJUi¿FDHVRFLDOPHQWHOLJDGRDRFUHVFLPHQWRGHPRJUi¿FRDRDYDQ
oRGDDJULFXOWXUDFRPHUFLDOHPWRGRRSDtV1RUWH6XO0HLR2HVWHH
GDSURGXomRPDQXIDWXUHLUDGR1RUWH$SyVD*XHUUD&LYLORFRUUHUDP
LQRYDo}HVFUXFLDLVQDHVIHUDGDFRPHUFLDOL]DomRHGLVWULEXLomRGRDUWLJR


 6REUHDFKHJDGDGDVIHUURYLDVjV]RQDVFDIHHLUDVYHU3LHUUH0RQEHLJPioneiros e fazendeiros de
São Paulo, 6mR3DXOR+XFLWHFSS2GLORQ1RJXHLUDGH0DWWRVCafé e ferrovias. A
evolução ferroviária de São Paulo e o desenvolvimento da cultura cafeeira, 6mR3DXOR3RQWHV
SS-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHV QRWLFLRXDLVHQomRGDVWD[DVGHLPSRUWDomRGRFDIpQR
PHUFDGRQRUWHDPHULFDQRFHOHEUDQGRDHPO Novo Mundo, QS6REUHRVSUHoRV
GRFDIpQRPHUFDGRQRUWHDPHULFDQRYHU0DXUR5RGULJXHVGD&XQKD³$SrQGLFHHVWDWtVWLFR´LQ
(GPDU%DFKDH5REHUW*UHHQKLOO RUJV150 anos de café5LRGH-DQHLUR0DUFHOLQR0DUWLQV
(-RKQVWRQSVREUHFRPSUDVGHHVFUDYRV6OHQHV³7KH%UD]LOLDQ,QWHUQDO6ODYH
7UDGH´S

 6REUHR~OWLPRSRQWRYHU5REHUW*:LOOLDPVStates and Social Evolution. Coffee and the Rise
of National Governments in Central America&KDSHO+LOO7KH8QLYHUVLW\RI1RUWK&DUROLQD
3UHVVSS0DUFR3DODFLRVEl café en Colombia, 1850-1870. Una historia económica,
social y política, %RJRWi3ODQHWDS:LOOLDP5RVHEHUU\Coffee and Capitalism in the
Venezuelan Andes$XVWLQ8QLYHUVLW\RI7H[DV3UHVVSS

62 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 62 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 SDUDRFRQVXPLGRU¿QDOFRPRDLQWURGXomRGHHPEDODJHQVGHSDSHOSDUD
DYHQGDGHFDIpWRUUDGRQRYDUHMRDQWHVRFRQVXPLGRU¿QDOHUDREULJDGR
DFRPSUDURVJUmRVYHUGHVFRPRVYDUHMLVWDVWRUUDQGRRVHPFDVDHD
FULDomRGHPDUFDVUHJLVWUDGDVFRPYiULDV¿UPDVRSHUDQGRQDLPSRUWDomR
HGLVWULEXLomRSRUDWDFDGRHPHVFDODQDFLRQDO6RPDGDVjUHGXomRGRV
FXVWRVGHWUDQVSRUWHVHPHVFDODJOREDOHDRFUHVFLPHQWRSRSXODFLRQDOH
GHUHQGDQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVIUXWRGDLQGXVWULDOL]DomRDFHOHUDGDHGD
FUHVFHQWHFRPHUFLDOL]DomRGDDJULFXOWXUDIDPLOLDUHVVDVQRYDVSUiWLFDV
DMXGDUDPDDPSOLDURPHUFDGRFRQVXPLGRUQRUWHDPHULFDQR$VLPSRU
WDo}HVGHFDIpH[SORGLUDPQRV~OWLPRVWULQWDDQRVGRVpFXOR;,;GH
SDUDOLEUDVWHQGRRFRQVXPRper capita mais
TXHGREUDGRGHSDUDOLEUDVDQXDLV
1DGpFDGDGHR~QLFRPRGRGHRVFDIHLFXOWRUHVEUDVLOHLURV
DWHQGHUHPDHVVDGHPDQGDFRQVLVWLDHPDPSOLDUDiUHDGHFXOWLYRHP
GLUHomRjV]RQDVGHIURQWHLUDDGTXLULQGRHVFUDYRVQRPHUFDGRQHJUHLUR
LQWHUQR1HVVHSRQWRYHPRVDVRXWUDVGXDVIDFHVGRLPSDFWRGDHFRQRPLD
QRUWHDPHULFDQDpostbellum VREUHDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUD2VPHVPRV
IDWRUHVGHEDVHFUHVFLPHQWRSRSXODFLRQDOLQGXVWULDOL]DomRXUEDQL]DomR
FRPHUFLDOL]DomRGDVUHODo}HVVRFLDLVQRFDPSRHQDFLGDGHTXHSX[DUDP
DGHPDQGDQRUWHDPHULFDQDSRUFDIpR¿]HUDPWDPEpPSDUDRDo~FDU$
GHUURWDGRV&6$WURX[HGXURUHYpVSDUDDLQG~VWULDDoXFDUHLUDGD/RXLVLD
QDHRPHUFDGRQRUWHDPHULFDQRWRUQRXVHLQWHLUDPHQWHGHSHQGHQWHGDV
LPSRUWDo}HV2FRQVXPRQRUWHDPHULFDQRVDOWRXGHWRQHODGDVGH
Do~FDUHPSDUDWRQHODGDVYLQWHDQRVGHSRLV$RORQJR
GHVVHSHUtRGR&XEDIRLDSULQFLSDOIRUQHFHGRUDSDUDRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
7DOFRPRQRFDVRGRFDIpEUDVLOHLURHVVDUHODomRHUDDQWLJDGDWDYDGR
FRPHoRGRVpFXOR;,;HVHHVWUHLWRXDSyVD*XHUUD&LYLOFRPWURFDV
FDGDYH]PDLVDIXQLODGDVSDUDDFRO{QLDHVSDQKROD1DGpFDGDGH
FHUFDGHGDVH[SRUWDo}HVFXEDQDVGHDo~FDUIRUDPSDUDRPHUFDGR
QRUWHDPHULFDQRTXHRDWHQGLDHPGRFRQVXPRQDGpFDGDGH
DSURSRUomRGHH[SRUWDo}HVFXEDQDVGHDo~FDUSDUDRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV


 0LFKDHO)-LPpQH]³µ)URP3ODQWDWLRQWR&XS¶&RIIHHDQG&DSLWDOLVPLQWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV
´LQ:5RVHEHUU\/*XGPXQGVRQH06DPSHU.XWVFKEDFK RUJV Coffee, Society
and Power in Latin America %DOWLPRUH7KH-RKQV+RSNLQV8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS
9HUWDPEpP$QW{QLR'HO¿P1HWWRO problema do café no Brasil6mR3DXOR8QHVS)DFDPS
SS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 63

afro 51.indb 63 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 VXELXDLQFUtYHLVTXHUHSUHVHQWDYDPQRHQWDQWRDSHQDVGR
PHUFDGRFRQVXPLGRUQRUWHDPHULFDQR(TXDQWRDR%UDVLO"'XUDQWHWRGR
RVpFXOR;,;VHXSULQFLSDOPHUFDGRHVWHYHQD*Um%UHWDQKDTXHIRL
WRPDGRSHORDo~FDUGHEHWHUUDEDQDGpFDGDGH$RYROWDUVHSDUD
RV(VWDGRV8QLGRVRSULQFLSDOFRPSUDGRUGRDo~FDUEUDVLOHLURQRVDQRV
RSURGXWRQDFLRQDOWDPSRXFRIRLFDSD]GHID]HUIUHQWHjSRVLomR
FXEDQDHGHRXWURVH[SRUWDGRUHV
3RU¿PpSUHFLVRGHVWDFDUDSUySULDUHFXSHUDomRDOJRGRHLUDGR
6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV(PDSURGXomRIRUDGHPLObales,
FDLQGR SDUD PDLV GD PHWDGH DR ¿P GD *XHUUD &LYLO$ UHWRPDGD QmR
GHPRURXPXLWRFRQWDQGRFRPRVHVDEHFRPDLQWHUGLomRGRDFHVVRj
WHUUDDRVH[HVFUDYRVDPRQWDJHPGRVLVWHPDGHWUDEDOKREDVHDGRQR
sharecropping HXPFUHVFHQWHHQGXUHFLPHQWRGDVUHODo}HVUDFLDLV(P
DSURGXomRTXDVHFKHJRXDRQtYHOantebellum PLObales
HPRVXSODQWRXDWLQJLQGRGH]DQRVGHSRLV²TXDQGRVHDEROLXD
HVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO²RSDWDPDUGHFHUFDGHPLObales.
$WUDMHWyULDHFRQ{PLFDGR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVQDGpFDGDGH
IRLDPSODPHQWHQRWLFLDGDQDVSiJLQDVGHO Novo MundoFRPRH[HPSORFD
EDOGRVXFHVVRGDSROtWLFDGD5HFRQVWUXomR-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVDQRWRX
SRUYH]HVDFUHVFHQWHYLROrQFLDUDFLDOSURPRYLGDSHOD...RVFRQÀLWRVHP
WRUQRGDDWXDomRSROtWLFDGRVOLEHUWRVHPDVVRFLDomRFRPRVcarpetbaggers
GHUUDSRXQDVYLV}HVUDFLVWDVTXHDÀRUDUDPFRPIRUoDFUHVFHQWHDR¿QDO
GDSUHVLGrQFLDGH8O\VVHV*UDQWHFRQVLGHURXDHOHLomRGH5XWKHUIRUG%
+D\HVFRPRXPDFRUUHomRGHUXPRHFRPRRWHUPR¿QDOGRVFRQÀLWRV
seccionais nos Estados Unidos, encampando, assim, a crescente opinião
QRUWLVWDFRQWUiULDDRDEROLFLRQLVPRUDGLFDOGRVDQWLJRV5HSXEOLFDQRVTXH
GHXRULJHPjUHFRQFLOLDomRSyVHDR¿PGD5HFRQVWUXomR(PTXH


 $FHUFDGHVVHVPRYLPHQWRVFRQVXOWDU³$+LVWRU\RI6XJDU0DUNHWLQJ´U. S. Department of
Agriculture$JULFXOWXUDO(FRQRPLF5HSRUWQSS0DQXHO0RUHQR)UDJLQDOV
O engenho. Complexo sócio-econômico açucareiro cubanoY6mR3DXOR+XFLWHFY
SS3HWHU/(LVHQEHUJModernização sem mudança. A indústria açucareira em Pernam-
buco, 1840-19105LRGH-DQHLUR3D] 7HUUDSS

Department of Commerce/Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States, 1789-
1945. A Supplement to the Statistical Abstract of the United States, :DVKLQJWRQ86*RYHUQPHQW
3ULQWLQJ  S )RQHU Reconstruction, SS *HQH 'DWWHO Cotton and Race in
the Making of America. The Human Costs of Economic Power1HZ<RUN,YDQ5'HH
SS8Pbale HTXLYDOHDOLEUDVLVWRpNJ

64 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 64 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 SHVHWXGRLVVRVXDDYDOLDomRHPQR~OWLPRDQRGRSHULyGLFRHUDGH
TXHDH[SHULrQFLDWRGDIRUDH[WUHPDPHQWHSRVLWLYDHLQVWUXWLYDGRFDPLQKR
DVHVHJXLUQR%UDVLO2,PSpULRVHPRUDFLVPRQRUWHDPHULFDQRWRPDULD
XPD VHQGD EHP PDLV WUDQTXLOD SDUD DEROLU D HVFUDYLGmR PDQWHQGR WDO
FRPRRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVVXDFDSDFLGDGHDJURH[SRUWDGRUD
3DUDDOpPGRRWLPLVPRGH-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVTXDQWRjOLomRTXH
DUHWRPDGDDOJRGRHLUDGR6XOIRUQHFLDDRVVHQKRUHVGHHVFUDYRVEUDVLOHL
URVRFUHVFLPHQWRGDSURGXomRQRUWHDPHULFDQDGRDUWLJRIRLXPDSHoD
LPSRUWDQWHQRDSURIXQGDPHQWRGDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO&RPRVH
YLXQDGpFDGDGHRÀX[RGHHVFUDYRVSDUDRVXOFDIHHLURGLPLQXtUD
HPSDUWHSHODFDSDFLGDGHTXHRQRUWHWHYHGHUHWrORVQDUHJLmREDVWDQWH
EHQH¿FLDGDSHODPRPHQWkQHDERQDQoDGRDOJRGmR&XUWDWRGDYLD(P
PHDGRVGDGpFDGDGHRDOJRGmRGRQRUWHGR%UDVLOYROWRXDVHUH[
FOXtGRGRVPHUFDGRVJOREDLVSHODUHFXSHUDomRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV$FULVH
IRLVREUHPRGRDJUDYDGDSHODGXUtVVLPDVHFDTXHDWLQJLXDUHJLmRDSDUWLU
GH2VSHTXHQRVODYUDGRUHVGHDOJRGmRHPDQWLPHQWRVSRVVXLGRUHV
GHSRXFRVHVFUDYRVIRUDPFRPSHOLGRVDYHQGrORVSDUDRVXOFDIHHLUR
(P UHVXPR R GHVHPSHQKR HFRQ{PLFR GRV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV QR
WHUoR¿QDOGRVpFXOR;,;DRFRORFDUGHXPDYH]SRUWRGDVRFUHVFLPHQWR
GDHFRQRPLDFDIHHLUDGR%UDVLOVREVXDyUELWDDRPHVPRWHPSRHPTXH
DMXGDYDDH[FOXLURDo~FDUHRDOJRGmREUDVLOHLURVGRPHUFDGRPXQGLDO
IRLXPDHQJUHQDJHPLPSRUWDQWHSDUDRDSURIXQGDPHQWRGDVGHVLJXDOGDGHV
UHJLRQDLVGHQWURGR,PSpULR1DGpFDGDGHDPDLRUH¿FLrQFLDGDSUR
GXomRFDIHHLUDVHWUDGX]LXQDFRQFHQWUDomRFUHVFHQWHGDIRUoDGHWUDEDOKR
FDWLYDQDVID]HQGDVGHFDIpGR5LRGH-DQHLURGH0LQDV*HUDLVHGH6mR
3DXORHVHXGHFUpVFLPRQDVID]HQGDVHVtWLRVGHDOJRGmRHHQJHQKRVGH
Do~FDUGRQRUWHGRSDtV²HSRUWDQWRQDHURVmRSURJUHVVLYDGRFRPSUR
PHWLPHQWRQDFLRQDOFRPDLQVWLWXLomRMiYLVOXPEUDGDSHORFRPSRUWDPHQWR
GRVGHSXWDGRVLPSHULDLVGXUDQWHDYRWDomRGD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUH

 ³'DFRQGLomRHFRQ{PLFDGR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV´O Novo MundoQS³3UR
gresso dos negros”, O Novo Mundo, QS³2DVSHFWRSROtWLFR´O Novo Mundo,
QS³2WUDEDOKRGRVHPDQFLSDGRV´O Novo MundoQS³5HYLVWD
americana”, O Novo MundoQS³2VHVWDGRVGR6XOHRVOLEHUWRV´O Novo
MundoQS³2VHPDQFLSDGRVFRPRSROtWLFRV´O Novo MundoQS
³2WUDEDOKRGRVOLEHUWRV´O Novo MundoQS³2VEHQHItFLRVGDHPDQFLSDomR´
O Novo MundoQS

 6OHQHV³7KH%UD]LOLDQ,QWHUQDO6ODYH7UDGH´S

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 65

afro 51.indb 65 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 $LQGD QHVVH SODQR p SRVVtYHO LGHQWL¿FDU RXWUD GHFRUUrQFLD GD
*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQDSDUDDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUD$OJXQV
DQRVDSyVVXDDSURYDomRRVGHVGREUDPHQWRVSROtWLFRVGD/HLGR9HQWUH
/LYUHDOWHUDUDPVHQVLYHOPHQWHDVFRQGLo}HVGDVOXWDVHQWUHVHQKRUHVH
HVFUDYRV$LQVWLWXLomRSHUGHUDPXLWRGHVXDOHJLWLPLGDGHHP2V
SUySULRVVHQKRUHVGHHVFUDYRVTXHVHRSXVHUDPjOHLVHHQFDUUHJDPGR
VHUYLoRDRSURSDJDUHPDRVTXDWURYHQWRVTXHR(VWDGRHVWDYDVRODSDQGR
DDXWRULGDGHGHOHVHTXHDLQVXERUGLQDomRHVFUDYDFUHVFHULDHPUHVXO
WDGR GD PHGLGD$OpP GR PDLV D FRQFHQWUDomR HVFUDYD QDV ID]HQGDV
GHFDIpQmRIRLDSHQDVTXDQWLWDWLYDPDVWDPEpPTXDOLWDWLYDHPVXDV
FRPSUDVQRPHUFDGRLQWHUQRRVFDIHLFXOWRUHVSULYLOHJLDUDPDDTXLVLomR
GHMRYHQVGRVH[RPDVFXOLQRQDVFLGRVQR%UDVLOHDSDUWDGRVGHUHGHV
IDPLOLDUHVFRQVROLGDGDV1DVID]HQGDVSDUDDVTXDLVIRUDPHQFDPLQKDGRV
RVSDGU}HVGHWUDEDOKRHUDPPXLWRPDLVGXURVGRTXHQDVDWLYLGDGHVD
TXHHVWDYDPDFRVWXPDGRVHPVXDV]RQDVGHSURFHGrQFLD Não foi por
DFDVRSRUWDQWRTXHRIRFRPDLVDJXGRGHUHVLVWrQFLDHVFUDYDWHQKDVLGRD
IURQWHLUDFDIHHLUDGDSURYtQFLDGH6mR3DXOR1HVVD]RQDRSURWDJRQLVPR
GRVXMHLWRHVFUDYL]DGRFUX]RXVHSHODSULPHLUDYH]QDKLVWyULDGR%UDVLO
FRPXPPRYLPHQWRSROtWLFRVLVWrPLFRGHDWDTXHIURQWDOjLQVWLWXLomR
2PRYLPHQWRDEROLFLRQLVWDEUDVLOHLURVXUJLXQDHVIHUDS~EOLFDGR
,PSpULRHPHPJUDQGHSDUWHFRPRUHVSRVWDjVIUXVWUDo}HVFRP
RVUHVXOWDGRVGD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUHLURQLFDPHQWHWUDQVIRUPDGDHPSHoD
GHUHVLVWrQFLDGRFDPSRHVFUDYLVWD$SULPHLUDYLWyULDGRDEROLFLRQLVPR
YHLRQRFRPHoRGHTXDQGRDV$VVHPEOHLDVGH0LQDV*HUDLV5LR
GH-DQHLURH6mR3DXORDSURYDUDPWD[DVSURLELWLYDVSDUDDLQWURGXomRGH
HVFUDYRVGHRXWUDVSURYtQFLDVRTXHSDUDWRGRVRVHIHLWRVLQWHUGLWRXGH
YH]RWUi¿FRLQWHUSURYLQFLDOQR%UDVLO$LQLFLDWLYDHPUHDOLGDGHQmRIRL
GRVDEROLFLRQLVWDVDRSURSRUHPDPHGLGDRVGHSXWDGRVGDTXHODVWUrV


 5LFKDUG *UDKDP ³$QRWKHU 0LGGOH 3DVVDJH" 7KH ,QWHUQDO 6ODYH 7UDGH LQ %UD]LO´ LQ :DOWHU
-RKQVRQ RUJ The Chattel Principle. Internal Slave Trades in the Americas 1HZ +DYHQ
<DOH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVS:DUUHQ'HDQRio Claro. Um sistema brasileiro de grande
lavoura, 1820-19205LRGH-DQHLUR3D] 7HUUDS

 3DUDDFRPSUHHQVmRDEUDQJHQWHGDDOLDQoDHVFUDYRV DEROLFLRQLVWDVYHU(PLOLD9LRWWLGD&RVWD
Da senzala à colônia 6mR 3DXOR %UDVLOLHQVH  H7RSOLQThe Abolition of Slavery. Ver,
WDPEpP0DULD+HOHQD370DFKDGRO plano e o pânico. Os movimentos sociais na década
da abolição6mR3DXOR(GXVS(G8)5-H(OFLHQH$]HYHGRO direito dos escravos.
Lutas jurídicas e abolicionismo na província de São Paulo&DPSLQDV(G8QLFDPS

66 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 66 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 SURYtQFLDVSUHWHQGLDPEDUUDURDYDQoRGDSODWDIRUPDDQWLHVFUDYLVWDSRU
PHLRGDPDQXWHQomRGRHPSHQKRQDFLRQDOFRPDHVFUDYLGmR2H[HPSOR
GR&HDUiXPDGDVSURYtQFLDVTXHPDLVSHUGHUDPHVFUDYRVSDUDDVID
]HQGDVGHFDIpQRVDQRVHDSULPHLUDQDTXDOHFORGLXRPRYLPHQWR
DEROLFLRQLVWDGHPDVVDHPSUH¿JXUDYDH[DWDPHQWHDH[SHULrQFLD
SUHWpULWDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGHXPQRUWHDEROLFLRQLVWDHGHXPVXOHV
FUDYLVWD(VVHDOLiVIRLXPGRVSULQFLSDLVDUJXPHQWRVTXHVXVWHQWDUDP
DGHIHVDGDSURLELomRGRWUi¿FRLQWHUSURYLQFLDOQD$VVHPEOHLDSDXOLVWD
(PHPSOHQDHIHUYHVFrQFLDGR&HDUiHFRPRSDUWHGDDUWL
FXODomRHPHVFDODQDFLRQDOGRPRYLPHQWRDEROLFLRQLVWDIXQGRXVHQD
FDSLWDOGR,PSpULRRSHULyGLFRO Abolicionista, HDWUDGLFLRQDOGazeta
da TardeWDPEpPSXEOLFDGDQDFRUWHDEUDoRXIRUWHPHQWHDFDXVD8PD
HVWUDWpJLDGHSURSDJDQGDTXHIRUDGHVHQKDGDQRVGHEDWHVGD/HLGR9HQWUH
/LYUHFRQYHUWHXVHHQWmRHPXPGRVSRQWRVIRUWHVGDFDPSDQKDFRQWUD
DHVFUDYLGmRRGHVHQODFHEHPVXFHGLGRGD*XHUUD&LYLOGDDEROLomRH
5HFRQVWUXomR QRV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV FRPR H[HPSOR SDUD R %UDVLO 3DUD
WDQWRRPRYLPHQWRDEROLFLRQLVWDFRQWRXMiHPFRPXPDOLDGR
LQVXVSHLWR(PRXWXEURGDTXHOHDQRRGHSXWDGR-RDTXLP1DEXFRVROL
FLWRXDRUHSUHVHQWDQWHQRUWHDPHULFDQRQR,PSpULRGR%UDVLO+HQU\:
+LOOLDUGXPDDYDOLDomRGRTXHIRUDDH[SHULrQFLDGHHPDQFLSDomRHP
VHXSDtVHDUHOHYkQFLDGHODSDUDRVEUDVLOHLURV6XDSUHVHQoDQR,PSpULR
HUDHPVLXPVLQDOGR¿PGD5HFRQVWUXomRSURSULHWiULRGHHVFUDYRV
GR6XODQWHVGD*XHUUDGLSORPDWDGHUHQRPHHGHSXWDGRQR&RQJUHVVR
)HGHUDO+LOOLDUGDOLRXVHDRV&6$HP$GHUURWDPLOLWDUROHYRX
DRRVWUDFLVPRSROtWLFRGRTXDOVyVDLXFRPDSROtWLFDGHUHFRQFLOLDomR
SURPRYLGDSRU+D\HVTXHRLQGLFRXSDUDRFDUJRQR%UDVLOHP
+LOOLDUGUHVSRQGHXD1DEXFRSRUPHLRGHXPDORQJDFDUWDHPUHDOLGDGH
XPDGHIHVDHQIiWLFDGRVVXFHVVRVGDDEROLomRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGH
VHXVUHVXOWDGRVVRFLDLVDOLEHUGDGHSDUDRVHVFUDYRVVHPJXHUUDGHUDoDV


 &pOLD0DULD0DULQKR$]HYHGROnda negra, medo branco. O negro no imaginário das elites,
século XIX 5LR GH -DQHLUR 3D]  7HUUD  SS 2 WUDEDOKR GH -RQDV 0DUoDO GH
4XHLUy]³'D6HQ]DODj5HS~EOLFDWHQV}HVVRFLDLVHGLVSXWDVSDUWLGiULDVHP6mR3DXOR
´'LVVHUWDomRGH0HVWUDGR8QLYHUVLGDGH(VWDGXDOGH&DPSLQDVWUD]XPFRUUHWLYR
LPSRUWDQWHDRUHODWLYL]DURSHVRGRDUJXPHQWRVREUHRULVFRGDVHFFLRQDOL]DomRGDHVFUDYLGmR
EUDVLOHLUDQDLQWHUGLomRGRWUi¿FRLQWHUSURYLQFLDOHPPDVDR¿FDUPXLWRSUHVRjDQiOLVH
GDVHVWUDWpJLDVSROtWLFDVGRVGHSXWDGRVHGDUHWyULFDFRUUHVSRQGHQWHGHL[DHVFDSDURDJXoDPHQWR
UHDOFRQFUHWRGDVWHQV}HVHVFUDYLVWDVQDIURQWHLUDFDIHHLUDGH6mR3DXOR

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 67

afro 51.indb 67 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 HHFRQ{PLFRVDH[SDQVmRDOJRGRUHLUDSyVHTXHWUD]LDDLQGDD
UHFRPHQGDomRGHTXHR%UDVLODFDEDVVHFRPDHVFUDYLGmRHPVHWHDQRV
HPGHVHWHPEURGH$PLVVLYDHQ¿PYHLFXODYDDSRVLomRR¿FLDO
GDDGPLQLVWUDomR+D\HVGD5HFRQVWUXomRFRPRXPDREUDHQFHUUDGD
1DEXFRSXEOLFRXDFRUUHVSRQGrQFLDQRJornal do Commercio em
GHRXWXEURGHVRERWtWXOR³$HPDQFLSDomRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV´
$UHDomRHVFUDYLVWDIRLLPHGLDWDPDVDRLQYpVGHTXHVWLRQDUDYLVmRGH
TXHD5HFRQVWUXomRIRUDEHPVXFHGLGDOLPLWRXVHDGL]HUTXHDHPDQFL
SDomRVHULDPDLVGLItFLOQR%UDVLOHTXHSRUWDQWRRPRGHORQmRVHUYLD
2PRYLPHQWRDEROLFLRQLVWDFRQWLQXRXDFDSLWDOL]DURWHPDDRSURPRYHU
XPJUDQGHEDQTXHWHHPKRPHQDJHPD+LOOLDUGHPXPKRWHOGHFRUDGR
FRPXPJUDQGHTXDGURGH/LQFROQODGHDGRSRUVHXVHFUHWDULDGR6HZDUG
8VKHU&KDVHHWFGXUDQWHDOHLWXUDGD3URFODPDomRGH(PDQFLSDomR
1RGLVFXUVRGHUHFHSomR1DEXFRDSUHVHQWRXDVFUHGHQFLDLVGH+LOOLDUG
>@UHSUHVHQWDQWHSRUPXLWRVDQRVQR&RQJUHVVRGHXPGLVWULWRDJUtFROD
HPTXHRWUDEDOKRHVFUDYRHUDR~QLFRHPSUHJDGRPHPEURSURHPLQHQWH
GDFRPXQKmRVXOLVWDVHQKRUGHHVFUDYRVDQWHVGD*XHUUDVROGDGRGD
&RQIHGHUDomRHSRU¿PUHSUHVHQWDQWHGD&RQFLOLDomRHDSD]LJXDPHQWR
GRSUHVLGHQWH+D\HVTXHPPDLVLPSDUFLDOPHQWHHFRPPDLRUFRQKH
FLPHQWR GH FDXVD SRGLD IDODU GD HYROXomR HFRQ{PLFD H VRFLDO TXH D
(PDQFLSDomRGHWHUPLQRXQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV"

(VVDDSUHFLDomRWUDGX]LDDSHUFHSomRHTXLYRFDGDHQWUHRVDEROL
FLRQLVWDVEUDVLOHLURVFRUUHQWHDWpGHTXHDDGPLQLVWUDomR+D\HV
QmRIRUDXPUHWURFHVVRHPUHODomRjREUDGD5HFRQVWUXomR2PRYLPHQWR
DEROLFLRQLVWDEUDVLOHLURFRQWLQXDULDDXViODFRPRPRGHORSDUDR%UDVLO²
FULVWDOL]DGRDHPVXDREUDPi[LPDGHUHÀH[mRHSURSDJDQGD²DSHVDU
GHHODMiVHUFRLVDGRSDVVDGRQRFRPHoRGDGpFDGDGHHGHR6XO
GRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHVWDUDSDVVRVODUJRVSDUDRPXQGRGH-LP&URZ

 2HSLVyGLR+LOOLDUGpDQDOLVDGRSRU&RQUDGOs últimos anos da escravatura, SSH$]H
YHGRAbolicionismoSS3DUDLQIRUPDo}HVELRJUi¿FDVSRVLomRSROtWLFDQRV(8$HYLVmR
SUySULDVREUHRVHSLVyGLRVQR%UDVLOYHUDDXWRELRJUD¿DGH+HQU\:+LOOLDUGPolitics and Pen
Pictures at Home and Abroad, 1HZ<RUN*33XWQDP¶V6RQV

 $SRVLomRHVFUDYLVWDIRLGHVFULWD²HFULWLFDGD²SRU-RVpGR3DWURFtQLRQRDUWLJR“A emanci
SDomRQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHQR%UDVLO´Gazeta da Tarde, GHQRYHPEURGHS

 ³2EDQTXHWHDEROLFLRQLVWD´Gazeta da Tarde, GHQRYHPEURGHSS

 5H¿URPHDROLYURGH-RDTXLP1DEXFRO abolicionismo, 5LRGH-DQHLUR1RYD)URQWHLUD
SSSXEOLFDGRRULJLQDOPHQWHHP

68 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 68 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 2HSLVyGLR+LOOLDUGFULWLFDGRQR3DUODPHQWREUDVLOHLURFRPRXPD
LQWHUIHUrQFLDH[WHUQDHPDVVXQWRVQDFLRQDLVIRLDOJRUHODWLYDPHQWHtPSDU
SRUpPQmRVHWUDWRXGHHSLVyGLRLVRODGRGDFDPSDQKDDEROLFLRQLVWD$R
ORQJR GRV DQRV RLWHQWD SRGHVH QRWDU D FRUUHLD GH WUDQVPLVVmR HQWUH D
DWLYLGDGHHGLWRULDOGH-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHVjIUHQWHGHO Novo Mundo,
TXDQGRHOHIRLRSULQFLSDOGLYXOJDGRUSDUDRS~EOLFREUDVLOHLURGRDQGD
PHQWRGD5HFRQVWUXomRHDLPSUHQVDDEROLFLRQLVWDTXHRWLQKDQDFRQWDGR
SULQFLSDOHVSHFLDOLVWDHPDVVXQWRVQRUWHDPHULFDQRV Os heróis da Guerra
&LYLOWRUQDUDPVHRVKHUyLVGRDEROLFLRQLVPREUDVLOHLURVHPDQDDVHPDQD
HQFRQWUDYDVHQDLPSUHQVDGRPRYLPHQWRPHQo}HVD/LQFROQ6XPQHU
6HZDUG*UDQW6WRZH'RXJODVVHDVVLPSRUGLDQWH2TXHFRQWUDVWDFRP
RSURIXQGRVLOrQFLRGRVGHIHQVRUHVGDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLODUHVSHLWRGR
TXHRFRUUHUDQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVVLOrQFLRDQWHYLVWRSRURFDVLmRGRVGHED
WHVVREUHD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUH2DEROLFLRQLVPREUDVLOHLURWHQWRXDFDGD
SDVVRFRQVWUXLUSRQWHVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVSDUDFRPEDWHUDLQVWLWXLomRQRSDtV
DSyVRLVRODPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOGR,PSpULRIDYRUHFHXDHVWUDWpJLD
3DUDRVHVFUDYLVWDVWDORSomRHUDLQYLiYHODRFRQWUiULRGRTXHVHGHUDQDV
GpFDGDVGHHTXDQGRRH[HPSORGR6XOIRLFHQWUDOSDUDDGHIHVD
GDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDQRVTXDGURVGRVLVWHPDPXQGLDO
3DUD¿QDOL]DUJRVWDULDGHUHJLVWUDUGXDVGLPHQV}HVHVSHFt¿FDVGR
LPSDFWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQDVREUHDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDFDGD


 9HU DV FRQWULEXLo}HV GH 5RGULJXHV SDUD R SULPHLUR Q~PHUR GH O Abolicionista QRYHPEUR GH
IHYHUHLURGHHDVFRQVWDQWHVPHQo}HVDRVHXWUDEDOKRQDGazeta da Tarde, GH
HPGLDQWH(PDJRVWRGHDRGLVFXUVDUQD&kPDUDGXUDQWHDGLVFXVVmRGR3URMHWR'DQWDVTXH
SUHWHQGLDOLEHUWDURVHVFUDYRVFRPPDLVGHDQRV5XL%DUERVDWUDWRXORQJDPHQWHGRSUREOHPD
GRGHFOtQLRHFRQ{PLFRHPVRFLHGDGHVSyVDEROLomRFRQWUDVWDQGR R&DULEHEULWkQLFRHIUDQFrV
FRPR6XOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV8PDGHVXDVIRQWHVIRL-RVp&DUORV5RGULJXHV$RXWUDDREUDGH
*HRUJH::LOOLDPVHistory of the Negro Race in America from 1619 to 18801HZ<RUN
DSULPHLUDKLVWyULDGDHVFUDYLGmRHGRSyVDEROLomRHVFULWDSRUXPQHJURQRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
SDUWLFLSDQWHGLUHWRWDQWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOFRPRGDSROtWLFDGD5HFRQVWUXomR³3DUHFHUGR'HSXWDGR
5XL%DUERVDDR3URMHWR'DQWDVDSUHVHQWDGRQDVHVVmRGHGHDJRVWRGH´LQA abolição no
Parlamento: 65 anos de luta (1823-1888)Y%UDVtOLD6HQDGR)HGHUDOYSS

 8PH[HPSORRRELWXiULRGH8O\VVHV*UDQWQDRevista IlustradaQSSFRPXPD
ERQLWDLPDJHPGRJHQHUDOSUHVLGHQWHRFXSDQGRWRGDDSULPHLUDSiJLQDGRSHULyGLFR

 2DVVXQWRWHPUHFHELGRERDDWHQomRQRV~OWLPRVWHPSRVHPHVSHFLDOQDKLVWRULRJUD¿DFRQFHU
QHQWHD-RDTXLP1DEXFR9HUGHQWUHRXWURV/HVOLH%HWKHOOH-RVp0XULORGH&DUYDOKRRUJV
Joaquim Nabuco e os abolicionistas britânicos (Correspondência 1880-1905), Rio de Janeiro:
7RSERRNV$QWRQLR3HQDOYHV5RFKDAbolicionistas brasileiros e ingleses. A coligação
entre Joaquim Nabuco e a British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society (1880-1902), 6mR3DXOR(G
8QHVS%UD]LOLDQ%XVLQHVV6FKRRO$QJHOD$ORQVR³2DEROLFLRQLVWDFRVPRSROLWD-RDTXLP
1DEXFRHDUHGHDEROLFLRQLVWDWUDQVQDFLRQDO´Novos Estudos CEBRAP, QSS

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 69

afro 51.indb 69 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 TXDOFRPWHVVLWXUDVWHPSRUDLVGLVWLQWDV(PSULPHLUROXJDURLPSDFWR
GLUHWRREVHUYiYHOSHORVDWRUHVFRHYRVFRPGHVGREUDPHQWRVHYLGHQWHVQR
HQFDPLQKDPHQWRSROtWLFRGDPDWpULD)RLHVVHLPSDFWRTXHOHYRXWDQWRj
SURSRVLomRHDSURYDomRGD/HLGR9HQWUH/LYUHFRPRjFRQIRUPDomRGH
XPFDPSRGHH[SHULrQFLDVTXHRULHQWRXDDWXDomRGRVDWRUHVSROtWLFRVH
VRFLDLVGR,PSpULRGR%UDVLODSyV$FDGDGHEDWHS~EOLFRHPTXHVH
HYRFDYDRSDVVDGRHRSUHVHQWHJOREDLVDH[SHULrQFLDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
LQIRUPDYD RV KRUL]RQWHV GH DWXDomR GLVSRQtYHLV DRV DWRUHV EUDVLOHLURV
0HVPRTXHWHQKDVLGRXWLOL]DGDTXDVHTXHH[FOXVLYDPHQWHSHORVDEROLFLR
QLVWDVDWUDMHWyULDQRUWHDPHULFDQDHVWDYDDEHUWDDP~OWLSODVOHLWXUDVFRPR
H[HPSORFRQFUHWRHFRPRDUPDUHWyULFD(PVHJXQGROXJDURLPSDFWRGD
UHRUJDQL]DomRGDHFRQRPLDPXQGLDOTXHVHVHJXLXj*XHUUD&LYLO3RXFR
FRPSUHHQGLGDSHORVFRQWHPSRUkQHRVWDOYH]HVVDWHQKDVLGRDIRUoDPDLV
GHFLVLYDDFRQIRUPDURFDPSRGHDWXDomRGLVSRQtYHODRVEUDVLOHLURVGDTXHOD
pSRFD$FULVHGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDFRPSRODUL]Do}HVUHJLRQDLVDWUDYH
MiODDFDGDSDVVRGHYHVHUFRPSUHHQGLGDFRPRXPDFULVHHFRQ{PLFDFRP
GLPHQV}HVJOREDLVTXHHVWDEHOHFHUDPRVOLPLWHVGRSRVVtYHOQRSURFHVVR
GHWUDQVIRUPDomRKLVWyULFDORFDO
$DEROLomRGDHVFUDYLGmRHPUHVXOWRXGHDo}HVHGHFLV}HV
WRPDGDVGHQWURGRVPDUFRVGR(VWDGRQDFLRQDOEUDVLOHLURSRUP~OWLSORV
atores sociais.0DVVHPRDFRQWHFLPHQWRGD*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHUL
FDQDR¿PGDHVFUDYLGmRGR%UDVLOQmRWHULDVHGDGRFRPRVHGHX0XLWR
SURYDYHOPHQWHDLQVWLWXLomRWHULDHQWUDGRYLJRURVDQRVpFXOR;;²H
VDEHVHOiTXDQGRWHULDVLGRDEROLGD

&RPRROHLWRUWHUiSHUFHELGRDRORQJRGHVWHWH[WRQmRWUDWHLGDSROtWLFDH[WHUQDGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
HPUHODomRDR%UDVLO(ODWHYHLPSRUWDQWHVSRQWRVGHIULFomRQRVDQRVGD*XHUUD&LYLOFRPRQD
TXHVWmRGDGHSRUWDomRGHQHJURVQRUWHDPHULFDQRVSDUDR,PSpULRDDEHUWXUDGDOLYUHQDYHJDomRQR
5LR$PD]RQDVDHPLJUDomRGHFRQIHGHUDGRVSDUDR,PSpULR0DVFRPRLQtFLRGD5HFRQVWUXomR
UDGLFDOR%UDVLOVXPLXGRIDUROGH:DVKLQJWRQFRPRGHUHVWRSUDWLFDPHQWHWRGDD$PpULFD/DWLQD
SDUDUHJUHVVDUDSHQDVQDVHJXQGDPHWDGHGDGpFDGDGH2XVHMDGXUDQWHRVDQRVFUXFLDLVGD
FULVHGDHVFUDYLGmREUDVLOHLUDLQH[LVWLXSUHVVmRGLSORPiWLFDQRUWHDPHULFDQDVREUH
R%UDVLO6REUHHVVHSRQWRYHU/DUV6FKRXOW]Beneath the United States. A History of the U. S.
Policy Toward Latin America, &DPEULGJH+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS

 'HDFRUGRFRPRSUHFLVRFRPHQWiULRGH5RELQ%ODFNEXUQThe American Crucible. Slavery,
Emancipation and Human Rights, /RQGRQ9HUVRS³1R$WODQWLFVWDWHVWRRGDORQH
RURXWVLGHWKHHEEDQGÀRZRIFRPPHUFH(DFKZDVSURIRXQGO\PDUNHGE\WKHVSUHDGRILGHDV
DQGWKHFRPSHWLWLRQIRUUHVRXUFHVDQGHVWHHPZLWKLQWKHZLGHU$WODQWLFVSDFH%XWWKHVWDWHIRUP
UHPDLQHGRIFULWLFDOLPSRUWDQFH(DFKVWDWHVHUYHGDVDFRQWDLQHURIVRFLRHFRQRPLFIRUFHVDQG
DSODFHRIUHVROXWLRQRIWKHPRPHQWRXVEDWWOHVRYHUVODYHU\7KLVPHDQVWKDWHPDQFLSDWLRQZDV
DOZD\VZRUNHGRXWLQQDWLRQDOKLVWRULHV´

70 Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71

afro 51.indb 70 26/08/2016 09:09:16

 Texto recebido em 29 de março de 2014 e aprovado em 30 de outubro
de 2014

Resumo
O artigo procura entender como D*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQD
FRQIRUPRXRTXDGURGDFULVHGDHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLO3DUDWDQWRHOHpGHVHQ
YROYLGR HP GRLV SODQRV 2 SULPHLUR VH UHIHUH DR LPSDFWR SROtWLFR GLUHWR GD
*XHUUD&LYLOGDDEROLomRHPHGD5HFRQVWUXomRVREUHRGHEDWHSROtWLFR
HDVGHOLEHUDo}HVSDUODPHQWDUHVUHODWLYDVjHVFUDYLGmRQR%UDVLOFRPDVOHQWHV
HVSHFLDOPHQWHYROWDGDVSDUDRSHUtRGRGHD2VHJXQGRVHUHSRUWD
DRLPSDFWRGRQRWiYHOFUHVFLPHQWRHFRQ{PLFRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVpostbellum
VREUHDVUHODo}HVVRFLDLVHVFUDYLVWDVGR,PSpULRGR%UDVLODSyVDDSURYDomRGD
Lei do Ventre LLYUHHP
Palavras-chave: HVFUDYLGmRDEROLomR*XHUUD&LYLOQRUWHDPHULFDQD,PSpULR
GR%UDVLO

Abstract
Abstract: The article seeks to understand how the U.S. Civil War (1861-1865)
triggered the crisis of slavery in Brazil. It explores two main aspects of this
SURFHVV¿UVWWKHSROLWLFDOLPSDFWRIWKH&LYLO:DU86VODYHHPDQFLSDWLRQLQ
1865, and Reconstruction on the political debates and parliamentary decisions
regarding slavery in Brazil, especially in the period between 1861 and 1871;
second, the impact of U.S. postbellum economic growth on the social relations of
slavery in the Brazilian empire, after the passing of the Free Womb law in 1871.
Keywords: slavery, abolition, US Civil War, Brazilian Empire

Afro-Ásia, 51 (2015), 37-71 71

afro 51.indb 71 26/08/2016 09:09:16

afro 51.indb 72 26/08/2016 09:09:16