Você está na página 1de 12

Public transport in a small island of a developing country1, 2

Transporte público em uma pequena ilha de um país em desenvolvimento

eISSN 2175-3369
Licenciado sob uma Licença Creative Commons
M. Shafiq-Ur Rahman

!!"#$%&'()*"+'!!"*,(-')%*&.'/&("+(0*1%/(%/2(3'4$"/%5(65%//$/4,(7%8%/4$*/%4%*(0/$9'*!$&:,(-8%;%(<(=%/45%2'!8,('.%$5>(
!8%?$@AB*)C:%8""D#".

Abstract
E8$!()%)'*('F)5"*'!(&8'('F$!&$/4(+"*.!("+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!:!&'.(%/2(&8'$*(!'*9$#'!(%!(G'55(%!(&*%9'5()%&&'*/(
"+()'")5'($/(H$@B$I"*(6*"9$/#',(%/($!5%/2("+(&8'(68$5$))$/'!D(J"B!'8"52(@B'!&$"//%$*'(!B*9':,($/&'*9$'G("+(
&8'()%!!'/4'*!("+(9%*$"B!()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!(%&(&8'$*(!&%&$"/!,(%/2(%(2'&%$5'2()%*&$#$)%&"*:("1!'*9%&$"/(
G'*'(#"/2B#&'2(+"*(&8'(*'!'%*#8D(=B!,(I'')/':K,('%!:*$2'L,(&*$#:#5'M,(%/2(8%1%58%1%5N(%*'(&8'(%9%$5%15'()B15$#(
&*%/!)"*&(!:!&'.!($/(&8'($!5%/2D(J"G'9'*,(&8'!'(!'*9$#'!(2"(/"&()*"9$2'(&*%9'5(&$.',(G%$&$/4(&$.',(%9%$5%1$5$&:(
"*(+*'@B'/#:,(#".+"*&,(%/2(!%+'&:(&8%&($!(*'@B$*'2(1:()%!!'/4'*!D(O%I"*$&:("+(&8'()'")5'(."!&5:()*'+'*(&8'(
'%!:*$2'(+"*(#".+"*&(%/2(5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'(G8$5!&(&8'(1B!(+"*(#".+"*&D(P"/!$2'*$/4(&8'(&*%9'5()%&&'*/,(!"#$"<
'#"/".$#(!$&B%&$"/(%/2(&")"4*%)8$#(#"/2$&$"/,(&8'(*'!'%*#8(&*$'2(&"($2'/&$+:(G8$#8(+"*.("+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(
!:!&'.(G"B52(1'(%))*")*$%&'(+"*(&8'($!5%/2D(Q&(G%!(+"B/2(&8%&(1B!($!(%))*")*$%&'(+"*(5"/4'*(&*$)!(G8$5'('%!<
:*$2'(+"*(&8'($/&'*<.B/$#$)%5(&*$)!(%/2(8%1%58%1%5(+"*(&8'(&*$)!($/(."B/&%$/(%*'%!D

Keywords>(=%*%/4%:D(R%!:*$2'D(J%1%58%1%5D(7'')/':D(E*$#:#5'(D

Resumo
Este artigo aborda os sistemas de transporte público, os serviços por eles ofertados e o padrão de deslocamen-
to das pessoas na Província de Siquijor, uma ilha das Filipinas. Para o desenvolvimento desta pesquisa foram

S( E8'('%*5$'*(9'*!$"/("+(&8$!()%)'*(G%!()*'!'/&'2($/(&8'(TT&8(U"*52(P"/4*'!!("+(E*%/!)"*&(3'!'%*#8(VUPE3W(P"/+'*'/#',(XL<XY(7B/'(
XZZ[,(P%5$+"*/$%,(0H D
\( #;/"G5'24'.'/&!>(E8'(%B&8"*(%#;/"G5'24'!(&8'(!B))"*&(+*".(&8'()*"9$/#$%5(4"9'*/.'/&("+(H$@B$I"*($/(+%#$5$&%&$/4(&8'(?$'52(G"*;(
%#&$9$&$'!(+"*(2%&%(#"55'#&$"/D(E8'(*"5'("+(]'*.%/(E'#8/$#%5(P"")'*%&$"/(V]E^W($!(%5!"(*'#"4/$_'2(+"*(+B/2$/4(&8'(&*%9'5('F)'/!'!(%/2(
%()%*&("+(&8'(2%&%(#"55'#&$"/('F)'/!'!D(E8'(%B&8"*(%5!"(&8%/;!(&G"(%/"/:."B!(*'9$'G'*!(+"*(&8'$*(9%5B%15'(#"..'/&!(%/2(!B44'!<
&$"/!,(%/2( /_$*(=""2"(VQEH,(0/$9'*!$&:("+(`''2!W(+"*(8$!(4'/'*"!$&:("+(R/45$!8(%/2(4*%..%*(*'9$'GD
a( Q&(#".'!(+*".(&8'(G"*2(bI'')cd()%!!'/4'*(#%)%#$&:(."!&5:(XL()'")5',(G8$5'(+'G(G$&8(Te("*(XT("*(KK()'")5'D((
f( E8'(!.%55'*(9'*!$"/("+(7'')/':(V%5!"(#%55'2(b.B5&$<#%1gW(G$&8()%!!'/4'*(#%)%#$&:("+(TX()'")5'D
h( O"&"*#:#5'(G$&8(%/(%&&%#8'2(!$2'<#%*(%/2(%(G8''5(V&8*''<G8''5'*W,(B!B%55:(#%**:(L(&"(N()'")5'(2')'/2$/4("/(!$_'(%/2(2'!$4/D(
i( O"&"*#:#5'(+"*(8$*'(%/2(")'*%&'(%!(%()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(V"*("+&'/(5$;'(%(&%F$W(."2',(5"#%55:(;/"G/(%!(b8%1%58%1%5gD(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
62 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

utilizados formulário de pesquisa domiciliar, entrevistas com passageiros dos diversos meios de transporte
público e uma minuciosa observação participativa. Ônibus, jeepney, easyride, triciclo e habalhabal são os sis-
temas de transporte público disponíveis na ilha. Contudo, estes serviços não proporcionam o tempo de viagem
e espera, disponibilidade ou frequência, conforto e segurança demandados pelos passageiros. A maior parte
das pessoas opta por se utilizar do easyride em função do conforto e do menor tempo de espera, ao passo que
optam pelo ônibus em virtude do conforto oferecido. Considerando o padrão de viagens, situação socioeconô-
mica e condições topográ icas locais, este trabalho buscou identi icar qual o sistema de transporte público mais
apropriado para a ilha. Observou-se que o ônibus é o meio mais adequado para trajetos longos, enquanto o
easyride se destaca nas viagens intermunicipais e o habalhabal nos trajetos em áreas montanhosas.

Palavras-chave: Barangay. Easyride. Habalhabal. Jeepney. Triciclo.

Introduction '&#DW,(G8$5!&($/&'*/%5(+%#&"*!($/#5B2'(&8'($/&B$&$9'(2'<
#$!$"/(.%;$/4(%&&*$1B&'!("+(%(B!'*,("/(G8$#8(8'j!8'(
E8'(.%I"*$&:("+()'")5'($/(&8'(2'9'5")$/4(#"B/< 8%!(#"/&*"5(V$D'D($/#".',(+%.$5:(!$_',('&#DWD(E8'!'(+%#<
&*$'!(2')'/2("/(%++"*2%15'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!'*9$#'!( &"*!(&8%&(2'&'*.$/'(!'5'#&$"/("+(%()%*&$#B5%*(&*%9'5(
%/2(/"/<."&"*$_'2(&*%/!)"*&(VkOEW(+"*(&8'$*(&*%9'5( ."2'(#"B52(1'(4*"B)'2(%!(&8'(#8%*%#&'*$!&$#!("+(&8'(
VUn3`-( = kl,( TeeNWD( `"G'*<.$225'( %/2( 5"G'*( b&*$)g,( &8'( b&*$)( .%;'*g,( %/2( &8'( b&*%/!)"*&( !:!&'.g(
$/#".'( 4*"B)!( %*'( '!)'#$%55:( 8'%9$5:( 2')'/2'/&( V3 JO k,(XZZ[%,(XZZYWD(
"/()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(VJnHH Qk,(XZZNWD(-')'/2'/#'( k'9'*&8'5'!!,(&*%9'5(2'.%/2($!(%5!"(2'&'*.$/'2(
"/()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&($!(.%$/5:(1'#%B!'("+(5"G("G/< 1:(#$&:()")B5%&$"/(!$_',(4*"G&8(%/2(!&*B#&B*',(#B5<
'*!8$)( "+( )'*!"/%5( 9'8$#5'!D( J"G'9'*,( 2'!)$&'( &8'( &B*%5( %/2( G"*;( 8%1$&!,( $/#".',( %/2( B*1%/( !)%&$%5(
$.)"*&%/#'("+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&,($&!(!'*9$#'!(%*'("+< )%&&'*/( V `R60^,( TeeKd( OQE3QP,( TeeTd( HJRHlQk,(
&'/( )""*( $/( 2'9'5")$/4( #"B/&*$'!( V] lRkJRQOR3,( TeeTWD(O"*'"9'*,(&8'(#$&:("*(*'4$"/($!("+&'/(!8%)'2(
TeeeWD(Q/(B*1%/(%*'%!,()%*&$#B5%*5:($/(&8'(.%I"*(#$&< 1:( &*%/!)"*&( )*$"*$&$'!( VO 3PJREEQ,( TeeLW,( "*(
$'!,("+&'/(&8'(2'.%/2(+"*()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(+%*("B&< vice-versaD(m"*('F%.)5',()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&($/(H"B&8<
!&*$)!( &8'( !B))5:D( P"/!'@B'/&5:,( %!( ]%;'/8'$.'*( R%!&( !$%/( #$&$'!( 8%!( 1''/( %/( $.)"*&%/&( '5'.'/&(
VTeee,()D(N[TW(%*4B'2,(&8'(p."1$5$&:(%/2(%##'!!$1$5< "+( &8'$*( *'!)'#&$9'( B*1%/( !:!&'.!( VQU E ,( TeeMWD(
$&:(%*'(2'#5$/$/4(*%)$25:($/(."!&("+(&8'(2'9'5")$/4( J'/#',( %( 1%5%/#'2( )*"9$!$"/( "+( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'!(
G"*52qD(Q/(*B*%5(%*'%!,("/(&8'(#"/&*%*:,(&8'(!$&B%&$"/( G$&8( %( 5$/;( &"( 5%/2( B!'( $!( %( ;':( &"( !B!&%$/%1$5$&:(
.$48&(1'(2$++'*'/&(G8'*'(5"G(2'.%/2($!(8$/2'*$/4( VkRUO kd(lRkUn3EJo,(TeYeWD(E8B!,(&8'()*"9$<
)*"9$!$"/("+(+*'@B'/&()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!'*9$#'!($/(%( !$"/("+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(+"*(%(#$&:("*(*'4$"/(!8"B52(
#"!&<'++'#&$9'(.%//'*D((( 1'(.%&#8'2(G$&8(&8'(2'9'5").'/&(5'9'5(%/2(&*%9'5(
( /B.1'*( "+( +%#&"*!( $/?5B'/#'( &8'( !8%)'( "+( &8'( )%&&'*/("+(&8'(#$&:D
)B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!:!&'.("+(%(#$&:("*(*'4$"/D(m"*($/< E8'("1I'#&$9'("+(&8$!()%)'*($!(&"('F)5"*'(&8'('F$!&<
!&%/#',(%##"*2$/4(&"(H$.)!"/(VTeeLW,(&8'(!$_'("+(#$&:,( $/4()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!$&B%&$"/(%/2(&8'(&*%9'5()%&&'*/(
5'9'5( "+( 2'9'5").'/&( "*( B*1%/$_%&$"/,( &*%9'5( )%&< $/(%(!.%55(2'9'5")$/4($!5%/2("+(%(2'9'5")$/4(#"B/&*:D(
&'*/,( %/2( 5%/2( B!'( %*'( &8'( ."!&( !$4/$?$#%/&( +%#&"*!( P"/!$2'*$/4( &8'( &*%9'5( )%&&'*/( "+( )'")5'( %/2( &8'$*(
$/?5B'/#$/4(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!:!&'.D(E8'(5'/4&8( 'F)'#&%&$"/(*'4%*2$/4(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&,(&8'()%<
"+( I"B*/':!( %/2( /%&B*'( "+( &*%9'5( +"*( &8'( .%I"*$&:( )'*(%5!"(&*$'!(2'&'*.$/$/4(&8'(%))*")*$%&'(+"*.("+(
%*'($.)"*&%/&(+%#&"*!("+(2'&'*.$/$/4(&*%9'5(.'%/!( )B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(+"*(&8'($!5%/2(%/2(4B$2'5$/'!(&"()*"<
V= 3UR``('&(%5D,(TeYMWD(H'5'#&$/4(&*%9'5(."2'("+($/< 9$2'(p!B$&%15'q()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(+%#$5$&$'!D(pHB$&%15'q(
2$9$2B%5()'*!"/g!(&*$)!($!($/?5B'/#'2(1:($/&'*/%5(%/2( $/( &8$!( )%)'*( *'+'*!( &"( '+?$#$'/&( V$/( &'*.!( "+( &*%9'5(
'F&'*/%5(+%#&"*!(V3 JO k,(XZZ[%WD(RF&'*/%5(+%#&"*!( &$.'(%/2(G%$&$/4(&$.'W(+"*.%5()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!'*<
%*'(&8'(%&&*$1B&'!(*'5%&'2(&"()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!'*9$#'( 9$#'!("/(?$F'2(*"B&'!(%&(!#8'2B5'2(&$.'!,(G8$#8(%*'(
%/2( &8'$*( ")'*%&$"/,( G8$#8( %*'( "+&'/( 1':"/2( &8'( %9%$5%15'(%/2(%++"*2%15'(+"*(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+()'")5'D(
#"/&*"5("+(&8'(B!'*(V$D'D(!'*9$#'(*"B&',(8'%2G%:,(+%*',( E8'(!&B2:(#"/?$/'!($&!'5+("/5:(&"(5%/2(&*%/!)"*&D

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
Public transport in a small island of a developing country 63

H$@B$I"*,(%/($!5%/2()*"9$/#'("+(&8'(P'/&*%5(s$!%:%!( J"G'9'*,(&8'(*'!'%*#8($!(.%$/5:(1%!'2("/(8"B!'<
$/(&8'(68$5$))$/'!,($!(&8'(!&B2:(%*'%(+"*(&8'(*'!'%*#8D( 8"52($/+"*.%&$"/(G$&8(%22$&$"/%5($/+"*.%&$"/(+*".(
`%/2( %*'%( "+( &8'( $!5%/2( $!( %1"B&( KTY( ;.X,( .%$/5:( &8'()%!!'/4'*($/&'*9$'G!D(="&8(@B'!&$"//%$*'!(B!'2(
."B/&%$/"B!(%/2(*B*%5($/(/%&B*'(G8'*'(*"#;:(/"/< 8%2(!'9'*%5(!'#&$"/!(&"(#"55'#&(!"#$"<'#"/".$#(%/2(
%4*$#B5&B*%5( 5%/2( %/2( +"*'!&<#"9'*( %*'( *'!)'#&$9'5:( 2'."4*%)8$#( $/+"*.%&$"/,( 2'&%$5!( %1"B&( '%#8( &*$)(
Mr( %/2( TNr( "+( &8'( %*'%( VRPn`n]QP `( 63nmQ`R,( .%2'("/(&8'()*'9$"B!(2%:,(%/2(2'&%$5!("/(&8'$*(B!%4'(
XZZKd(63nsQkPQ `(6JoHQP `(m3 ORUn3l(6` k(t( "+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(V$D'D('F$!&$/4(!'*9$#'!,()*"15'.!,(
66m6,(XZZLWD( 2.$/$!&*%&$9'5:(&8'($!5%/2($!(2$9$2'2( &8'$*( 'F)'#&%&$"/!,( '&#DWD( ='!$2'!( &8'!',( &8'( 8"B!'<
$/&"( !$F( .B/$#$)%5$&$'!( VH$@B$I"*,( `%*'/%,( R/*$@B'( 8"52(!B*9':(@B'!&$"//%$*'(8%2(%(!')%*%&'(!'#&$"/("+(
s$55%/B'9%,(O%*$%,(`%_$,(%/2(H%/(7B%/W(%/2(TKL(ba- H&%&'2( 6*'+'*'/#'( @B'!&$"/!( &"( 'F)5"*'( )*'+'*'/#'(
rangay[(V]Rn]3 6JQP `( E` H,(XZZZd(66m6,(XZZLWD( %."/4( 9%*$"B!( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'!,( %!( G'55( %!(
E8'($!5%/2(#$*#B.+'*'/&$%5(k%&$"/%5(3"%2,(&8'(.%I"*( 2$++'*'/&( !#'/%*$"!( "+( &$.'( %/2( +%*'( +"*( &*%9'5( "/(
%*&'*$%5,(5$/;!(%55(.B/$#$)%5$&:(#'/&*'!D(E8'(1B$5&<B)( 9%*$"B!( ."2'!D( -$!#B!!$"/!( G'*'( %5!"( #%**$'2( "B&(
%*'%("+(&8'($!5%/2($!("/5:(XDMr("+(&8'(&"&%5(5%/2(%/2( G$&8(*'!)"/!$15'(%4'/#$'!,()"5$&$#%5(*')*'!'/&%&$9'!,(
5"#%&'2(%5"/4(&8'(k%&$"/%5(3"%2d(%/2(B*1%/()")B5%< %/2(&*%/!)"*&(%!!"#$%&$"/!,(%/2(*'5'9%/&(2"#B.'/&!(
&$"/($!("/5:(TTr(V66m6,(XZZLWD(E8'*'(G'*'(%(&"&%5("+( %/2()*"I'#&(%#&$9$&$'!(+*".(&8'()*"9$/#'(8%9'(1''/(
YT,MeY()'")5'($/(XZZT(5$9$/4($/(T[,[[M(8"B!'8"52!( *'9$'G'2(%/2(!&B2$'2D
V= HR`QkR(3R6n3E,(XZZXWD(E8'('#"/".:("+(&8'($!<
5%/2($!(."!&5:(1%!'2("/(%4*$#B5&B*'D( 9'*%4'(+%.$5:(
$/#".'( $/( :'%*( XZZZ( G%!( 6'!"Y( V6W( [e,TTe( G8'*'( Transport in Siquijor island
%*"B/2(XZr(+%.$5$'!(1'5"/4(&"(&8'($/#".'(1*%#;'&(
"+( 6XZ,ZZZ<KZ,ZZZ( VRPn`n]QP `( 63nmQ`R,( XZZKd( -'!)$&'(&8'(9'*:(5"G(8"B!'8"52($/#".'(&8'*'($!(%(
k EQnk `(HE EQHEQPH(nmmQPR(t(kHn,(XZZXWD #".)5'&'(%1!'/#'("+(#:#5'<*$#;!8%G(V#%55'2(b)'2$#%1g(
$/(&8'(68$5$))$/'!W(%/2(1$#:#5'($/(&8'(H$@B$I"*($!5%/2D(
(#$&:("*(*'4$"/($/(&8'(68$5$))$/'!("*($/("&8'*(#"B/<
Research methods and data collection &*$'!(8%9$/4(&8'(!"#$"<'#"/".$#(#"/2$&$"/!(!$.$5%*(&"(
H$@B$I"*(8%!(1$#:#5'!(%/2(#:#5'<*$#;!8%G!(%!(#".."/(
(#".)*'8'/!$9'(?$'52(!B*9':("+(8"B!'8"52!(G%!( ."2'D(k'9'*&8'5'!!,(&8'(8$55:(&")"4*%)8:("+(H$@B$I"*(
#%**$'2("B&(+"*($/9'!&$4%&$/4(&8'(&*%9'5()%&&'*/!("+(&8'( .$48&( 1'( &8'( *'%!"/( +"*( &8'( %1!'/#'( "+( #:#5'<*$#;<
)'")5'("+(H$@B$I"*($!5%/2D(-B'(&"(*'!"B*#'(#"/!&*%$/&!( !8%G(%/2(1$#:#5'D(3%8.%/(VXZZYW(%5!"(*')"*&'2(8$55:(
"/5:(TNK(8"B!'8"52!(VZDeKr("+(&8'(&"&%5W(G'*'(!'5'#&< &")"4*%)8:(%!(&8'(#%B!'("+(5"G(1$#:#5'(%/2(*$#;!8%G(
'2(B!$/4(%(H&*%&$?$'2(H:!&'.%&$#(3%/2".(6*"1%1$5$&:( B!'D(E8'(/B.1'*("+(*'4$!&'*'2(9'8$#5'!("+(&8'($!5%/2(
H%.)5$/4( .'&8"2( %/2( .'.1'*!( "+( &8'( !'5'#&'2( G%!(M,XNN($/(XZZK,(G8$#8($!(."*'(&8%/(2"B15'(&8%&(
8"B!'8"52!( "9'*( TZ( :'%*!( "+( %4'( G'*'( $/&'*9$'G'2( "+($/(TeeL(V"/5:(T,eXKW,(G$&8(."&"*#:#5'!(%/2(&*$#:<
$/(XZZ[D( (&"&%5("+(KeM($/2$9$2B%5(*'!)"/2'/&!(G'*'( #5'!(#".)*$!$/4("9'*(YZr("+(&8'(9'8$#5'!(V3 JO k,(
+"B/2(9%5$2(%/2(#"/!$2'*'2(+"*(&8'(%/%5:!$!D XZZ[%WD( 6*"9$/#$%5( 6*"?$5'( VXZZZW( *')"*&'2( &8%&(
='!$2'!(&8'(8"B!'8"52($/&'*9$'G,(%(2'&%$5'2("1< &8'*'(G'*'("/5:(XYe(9'8$#5'!(+"*(8$*',("+(G8$#8("/5:(
!'*9%&$"/(G%!(.%2'("+(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!:!&'.!( YK( G'*'( B&$5$&:( 9'8$#5'!( %/2( XZZ( &*$#:#5'!,( &"( !'*9'(
%/2(%()%*&$#$)%&"*:("1!'*9%&$"/(G%!()'*+"*.'2(&"( %*"B/2(YT,MZZ($/8%1$&%/&!("+(&8'($!5%/2D(
4%$/($/!$48&!($/&"(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(!'*9$#'!(%/2( E8'( +"55"G$/4( !'#&$"/!( 1*$'?5:( 2'!#*$1'( 'F$!&$/4(
!B))"*&$/4( $/+*%!&*B#&B*'( +%#$5$&$'!D( 6%!!'/4'*!( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( !:!&'.!( "/( &8'( $!5%/2,( )'")5'g!(
G%$&$/4(%&(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(&'*.$/%5(G'*'(%5!"( &*%9'5()%&&'*/!(%/2(&*$)(#8%*%#&'*$!&$#!,(!'*9$#'(5'9<
$/&'*9$'G'2( &"( %!!'!!( !'*9$#'( 5'9'5!( %/2( NN( )%!< '5!( %/2( )'")5'g!( )*'+'*'/#'!( "+( &8'( 'F$!&$/4( )B15$#(
!'/4'*!(B!$/4(2$++'*'/&(."2'!(G'*'(!'5'#&'2(*%/< &*%/!)"*&( V%&&$&B2'( &"G%*2!( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&W,( %/2(
2".5:( +*".( &8*''( .%I"*( &'*.$/%5!( V$D'D( H$@B$I"*,( ?$/%55:(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!g('F)'#&%&$"/!(%1"B&(&8'(!'*<
`%*'/%,(`%_$WD( 9$#'!("+(9%*$"B!()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!D(

u( HB12$9$!$"/("+(&8'(.B/$#$)%5$&:(V&8'(!.%55'!&()"5$&$#"<%2.$/$!&*%&$9'(B/$&W($/(&8'(68$5$))$/'!D((
v( 68$5$))$/"(6'!"(V6W(MZ(G%!('@B$9%5'/&(&"(0HwT($/(:'%*(XZZZD

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
64 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

Public transport systems +B*&8'*(%8'%2("/(&8'(1"*2'*("+(H%/(7B%/(Vm$4B*'(TWD(


n/( &8'( "&8'*( 8%/2,( %*"B/2( XM( '%!:*$2'!( %*'( ")'*<
RF$!&$/4( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( ")'*%&$/4( $/( H$@B$I"*( %&$/4("/(&8'(`%*'/%(<(R/*$@B'(s$55%/B'9%(*"B&'(%/2(
$!5%/2(#%/(1'(4*"B)'2($/(&G"(#%&'4"*$'!>( ixed-route '9'*:(2%:()*"9$2'(%*"B/2(XZ(&*$)!($/('%#8(2$*'#&$"/(
services( V1B!,( I'')/':( %/2( '%!:*$2'W,( %/2( door-to- G$&8(%/(%9'*%4'(8'%2G%:("+(TY(.$/B&'!D(J"G'9'*,(
door services(V8%1%58%1%5(%/2(&*$#:#5'WD ."*'( +*'@B'/&( !'*9$#'( V$D'D( 8'%2G%:( 5'!!( &8%/( TZ(
=B!'!( %/2( I'')/':!( ")'*%&$/4( $/( &8'( $!5%/2( %*'( .$/B&'!W( "/( '%!:*$2'!( $!( %9%$5%15'( $/( &8'( ."*/$/4,(
!$.$5%*($/(&'*.!("+(&8'$*()%!!'/4'*(#%)%#$&:,(!'*9$#< )%*&$#B5%*5:( 1'&G''/( Y>ZZ( %.( %/2( e>ZZ( %.D( E8$!(
'!(%/2(+%*'D(E8'(!$_'("+(1B!'!(")'*%&$/4($!(9'*:(!.%55( $!(2B'(&"(8'%9:(2'.%/2(#*'%&'2(1:(&8'(5%*4'(/B.<
V#%)%#$&:("+(LX(!'%&!WD(n/5:(+"B*(.$/$1B!'!(%*'(")< 1'*("+(!&B2'/&!(&*%9'55$/4(&"(&8'$*(#"55'4'($/(`%*'/%D(
'*%&$/4("/(&8'(`%*'/%(<(`%_$(V9$%(R/*$@B'(s$55%/B'9%( -'!)$&'( &8'( )'*.$!!$"/( &"( ")'*%&'( B)( &"( R/*$@B'(
%/2( O%*$%W( *"B&'( %/2( 2%$5:( )*"9$2'( %*"B/2( '$48&( s$55%/B'9%( 6"15%#$"/,( %!( G$&8( &8'( "&8'*( *"B&',(
&*$)!($/('%#8(2$*'#&$"/D(EG"('F$!&$/4(I'')/':(*"B&'!( &8':(")'*%&'(N(;.(%8'%2(B)(&"(1%*%/4%:(`"&5"&"/D(
%*'(H$@B$I"*(<(H%/(7B%/(<(`%_$(%/2(`%*'/%(<(R/*$@B'( ='&G''/(`%*'/%(%/2(R/*$@B'(s$55%/B'9%(6"15%#$"/,(
s$55%/B'9%(<(O%*$%(<(`%_$D(n/5:(TM(I'')/':!(%*'(")< %( 2$!&%/#'( "+( TX( ;.,( '%!:*$2'( &%;'!( %*"B/2( KZ<LZ(
'*%&$/4("/(&8'(H$@B$I"*(<(`%_$(*"B&'(G8$5'(XL("/(&8'( .$/B&'!( G$&8( %( +%*'( "+( 6YD( 0!B%55:( '%!:*$2'!( %*'(
`%*'/%(<(`%_$(*"B&'()*"9$2'(%*"B/2(TN(&*$)!(2%$5:($/( %9%$5%15'(1'&G''/(N>ZZ(%.(%/2(N>ZZ().(%/2(&8'*'(
'%#8( 2$*'#&$"/D( ="&8( &8'( 1B!( %/2( I'')/':( !&")( +*'< $!(/"(!)'#$?$#(&$.'<!#8'2B5'("*(!&"))$/4()"$/&!D
@B'/&5:( %&( %/:( &$.'( %/2( %/:( )5%#'( $+( %( )%!!'/4'*( E*$#:#5'( $!( !B$&%15'( +"*( !8"*&<2$!&%/#'( &*$)!( $/(
G%/&!(&"(4'&("++(V%5$48&W("*("/(V1"%*2W,(G8$#8(!$4/$?$< 5'!!(8$55:(%*'%!(%/2()*"9$2'!(2""*<&"<2""*(!'*9$#'!(
#%/&5:(%++'#&!(&8'(&*%9'5(&$.'(%/2(")'*%&$"/(!)''2("+( 1'&G''/(N>ZZ(%.(%/2(N>ZZ().D(J"G'9'*,(!".'&$.'!(
9'8$#5'!D( 9'*%4'(&*$)(&$.'(+"*(%(2$!&%/#'("+(KZ(;.( %(+'G("+(&8'.(")'*%&'("/(#'*&%$/(?$F'2(*"B&'!D( 1"B&(
1'&G''/(`%*'/%(%/2(`%_$(V9$%(O%*$%W($!(eZ(.$/B&'!( KZX( &*$#:#5'!( %*'( ")'*%&$/4( "/( &8'( $!5%/2( %/2( )5%:(
"/(1B!(%/2(eZ(&"(TXZ(.$/B&'!("/(I'')/':D(E8"B48( %( .%I"*( *"5'( $/( &*%/!)"*&( $/( %/2( %*"B/2( H$@B$I"*(
&8'( ")'*%&"*!( "+( 1B!( %/2( I'')/':( 8%2( 2'#$2'2( "/( 6"15%#$"/(%/2(`%*'/%(6"15%#$"/(V3 JO k,(XZZYWD(
%( 8'%2G%:( "+( KZ( .$/B&'!( +"*( 1"&8( *"B&'!( %/2( $/( ='#%B!'( "+( &8'( 8$55:( &")"4*%)8:,( 9'*:( +'G( &*$#:<
'%#8( 2$*'#&$"/,( $/( )*%#&$#',( 2*$9'*!( G%$&( ."*'( &$.'( #5'!( %*'( ")'*%&$/4( $/( &8'( .B/$#$)%5$&:( "+( R/*$@B'(
V.%;$/4( 2'5%:W( $/( "*2'*( &"( 4'&( ."*'( )%!!'/4'*!D( s$55%/B'9%,( O%*$%,( %/2( `%_$D( m%*'!( +"*( &*$#:#5'!( %*'(
E8'(+%*'($!(2'&'*.$/'2(1:(&8'(`%/2(E*%/!)"*&%&$"/( 2'&'*.$/'2(1:(&8'(5"#%5(4"9'*/.'/&(B/$&(V`]0W("/(%(
m*%/#8$!'( %/2( 3'4B5%&"*:( ="%*2( V`Em3=W( "/( %( )'*( ;.(*%&'(1%!$!D(J"G'9'*,(&8'(2*$9'*("+(%(&*$#:#5'(B!B<
;.( *%&'D( H&%/2%*2( +%*'( +"*( %( I'')/':( +*".( H$@B$I"*( %55:(2'&'*.$/'!(&8'(+%*'(2')'/2$/4("/(&8'(/B.1'*(
6"15%#$"/( &"( H%/( 7B%/( 6"15%#$"/( V%1"B&( TX( ;.W( $!( "+()%!!'/4'*!(*$2$/4(t(8$48'*(+"*(!$/45'()%!!'/4'*!(
6TX(G8$5!&(+"*(1B!(+*".(`%*'/%(6"15%#$"/(&"(R/*$@B'( G8$5'(5'!!($+(!8%*'2(G$&8("&8'*!D(
s$55%/B'9%(6"15%#$"/(V%1"B&(TK(;.W($!(6TKD(E8'(+%*'( J%1%58%1%5($!(&8'("/5:(."2'(G8$#8($!(%##'!!$15'(
$!(!%.'(+"*(1"&8(I'')/':(%/2(1B!(%/2(&8'$*(!'*9$#'( $/(."B/&%$/"B!(%*'%!(G8'*'("&8'*(."2'!(V$D'D(1B!,(
5'9'5($!(%5!"(!$.$5%*D I'')/':,('%!:*$2',(&*$#:#5'W(%*'(/"&(%##'!!$15',(%/2($/(
R%!:*$2'($!(+%!&'*(&8%/(I'')/':("*(1B!(%/2(%(#".< '%#8(%/2('9'*:()%*&("+(&8'($!5%/2('9'/(G8'*'("&8'*(
."/(."2'("/(&8'(/%&$"/%5(*"%2("+(H$@B$I"*,(`%*'/%,( ."2'!(%*'(%5!"(")'*%&$/4D(E8'*'(%*'(%1"B&(N[L(8%<
R/*$@B'( s$55%/B'9%,( %/2( H%/( 7B%/( .B/$#$)%5$&$'!D( 1%58%1%5($/(&8'($!5%/2(V3 JO k,(XZZ[%W,(%9%$5%15'(
E8'( ` 3HQxH kOn-R( !!"#$%&$"/( *'4$!&'*'2( e[( +"*(%(*$2'(%&(%/:(&$.'d(8"G'9'*,(%(9'*:(8$48(+%*'(V2'<
'%!:*$2'!( +"*( ")'*%&$/4( "/( &8'( `%*'/%( t( H$@B$I"*( <( )'/2$/4("/(1%*4%$/W($!(%))5$'2(%+&'*(N>ZZ().D(R9'/(
H%/(7B%/(*"B&'d(8"G'9'*(/"&(%55(%*'(")'*%&$/4(/"GD( &8"B48( +%*'!( "+( 8%1%58%1%5( %*'( /"&( ?$F'2,( &8'( 2*$9<
0!B%55:(&8'*'(%*'(LZ(&*$)!($/('%#8(2$*'#&$"/('9'*:(2%:( '*!( %5."!&( %5G%:!( +"55"G( %( !$.$5%*( +%*'( !&*B#&B*'D(
1'&G''/(H$@B$I"*(%/2(`%*'/%(1:('%!:*$2',(&%;$/4(KZ( E8'(per(;.(+%*'($!(8$48'*(+"*(5"/4'*(2$!&%/#'(&*$)!(
&"(LZ(.$/B&'!(+"*(%(2$!&%/#'("+(TX(;.D(n1!'*9%&$"/( #".)%*'2(G$&8(!8"*&'*("/'!D(Q/&'*'!&$/45:,(&8'(+%*'(
"+( '%!:*$2'!( %&( H$@B$I"*( &'*.$/%5( 4%9'( %/( %9'*%4'( +"*(&8'(!%.'(2$!&%/#'(B)8$55($!(."*'(&8%/(2"G/8$55d(
8'%2G%:("+(KM(.$/B&'!D(-'!)$&'(&8'()'*.$!!$"/(+"*( 'D4D( 6"15%#$"/( H$@B$I"*( &"( 6"/"/4( $!( 6XZ( G8$5'( $/(
")'*%&$/4( '%!:*$2'( "/5:( B)( &"( H%/( 7B%/( 6"15%#$"/d( &8'(*'9'*!'(2$*'#&$"/($&($!(6TMD(m%*'!("/(8%1%58%1%5(
!".'&$.'!(&8':(4"(B)(&"(1%*%/4%:(P%&B5%:%/,(Y(;.( %*'( .B#8( 8$48'*( #".)%*'2( G$&8( "&8'*( ."2'!D( m"*(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
Public transport in a small island of a developing country 65

123°30’ 123°35’ 123°40’

PROVINCE OF SIQUIJOR
Map No.
EXISTING EASY RIDE ROUTE
9°15’ 9°15’
Legend:
Town Proper
Municipal Boundary
Barangay Boundary
Municipal Road
National Road
Other Roder

Easy Ride Route 1


Easy Ride Route 2
Easy Ride Route 3
Easy Ride Route 4
9°10’ 9°10’ Easy Ride Route 5

Source:
New Major Roads:
GPS survey conducted by SIMU.
February 2004

N Digital Mapping by:


2000 0 2000 4000 Siquijor Information Management
Scale : 1 : 150 000
Unit (SIMU)
Meters
Date of Preparation:
123°30’ 123°35’ 123°40’ June 2004

Figure 1 - Road network and the existing route of easyride service


Source: SIQUIJOR INTEGRATED RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PROJECT – SIRMAP, 2007.

'F%.)5',( H$@B$I"*( &"( `%*'/%( $!( 6KZ( "/( 8%1%58%1%5( %/"&8'*( XXr( .%;'( "/5:( "/'( &*$)( )'*( G'';( G8$5'(
G8'*'($&($!("/5:(6Y("/(I'')/':("*('%!:*$2'D &8'(*'.%$/$/4(*'!)"/2'/&!(&*%9'5(9'*:(*%*'5:(V"/5:(
%(+'G(&*$)!($/(%(."/&8WD(E8'(.%I"*$&:(VMYrW("+()%!<
!'/4'*!( $/&'*9$'G'2( %5!"( 4%9'( %( G'';5:( &*$)( +*'<
Travel pattern of the respondents @B'/#:( "+( B)( &"( +"B*D( Q&( G%!( +"B/2( &8%&( ."*'( &*$)!(
%*'(.%2'(1:(8$48'*($/#".'(4*"B)!("*()'")5'(8%9$/4(
H"#$"<'#"/".$#(%/2(2'."4*%)8$#()*"?$5'("+(&8'( %(8"B!'8"52(9'8$#5'D(E8$!("1!'*9%&$"/($!(9'*:(#".<
!%.)5'( )")B5%&$"/( %*'( %5."!&( !$.$5%*( &"( &8'( !'#< ."/(%/2($/(5$/'(G$&8(&*%/!)"*&(5$&'*%&B*'D(J"G'9'*,(
"/2%*:( $/+"*.%&$"/( "+( &8'( $!5%/2,( G8$#8( *'9'%5!( $/( !".'( #%!'!( V2')'/2$/4( "/( !"#$"<'#"/".$#( #"/<
&8%&(&8'(!%.)5'($!(*')*'!'/&%&$9'("+(&8'(G8"5'()")< 2$&$"/(%/2(#$&:(!$_'("*()%&&'*/W,(&8'("19$"B!("1!'*<
B5%&$"/D(n/5:(LXr("+(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(8%9'(+%.$5:( 9%&$"/("+(&*%/!)"*&(5$&'*%&B*'($!(/"&(%9%$5%15'($/(&8'(
"G/'2(9'8$#5',(."!&5:(."&"*#:#5'!(V[ZrW(G8$5'(%( 2'9'5")$/4( G"*52D( m"*( $/!&%/#',( 9'8$#5'( "G/'*!( 2"(
+'G(8%9'(&*$#:#5'!(VTZrWD( 9'*%4'(."/&85:(8"B!'< /"&(.%;'(."*'(&*$)!(#".)%*'2(G$&8("&8'*!(%/2(&8'(
8"52('F)'/2$&B*'(+"*(&*%/!)"*&($/(H$@B$I"*($!(6MKM( +*'@B'/#:("+(&*$)(+"*(1"&8(8$48'*<$/#".'(4*"B)(%/2(
G8$5!&( TXr( !)'/2( 5'!!( &8%/( 6MZ( %/2( TZr( !)'/2( )""*<$/#".'(4*"B)($!(%5."!&(!$.$5%*($/(&8'(#'/&*%5(
"9'*(6T,ZZZD( %*'%("+(l8B5/%(#$&:($/(=%/45%2'!8(V3 JO k,(XZZKWD(
*"B/2( KYr( "+( &8'( 8"B!'8"52( *'!)"/2'/&!( E8'*'( %5!"( 'F$!&( !$4/$?$#%/&( 2$++'*'/#'!( $/( &*$)( +*'<
B!B%55:(.%;'(1'&G''/(?$9'(%/2(&'/(&*$)!()'*(G'';,( @B'/#:(G$&8("##B)%&$"/($/(H$@B$I"*($!5%/2(t(!&B2'/&,(
%1"B&( XXr( .%;'( &G"( &"( +"B*( &*$)!( )'*( G'';,( %/2( &'%#8'*,( %/2( 4"9'*/.'/&( '.)5":''!( 8%9'( 8$48'*(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
66 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

&*$)(+*'@B'/#:d(G8$5'(8"B!'G$9'!,(1B!$/'!!()'")5',( Trip characteristics


%/2(+%*.'*!(8%9'(5"G'*(+*'@B'/#:("+(&*$)!D(
OB5&$)5'( "*( #"//'#&'2( &*$)!( "/( &8'( $!5%/2( %*'( R%#8( $/2$9$2B%5( &*$)( 8%2( 1''/( #"/!$2'*'2( $/(
9'*:(+'G,("/5:(Nr("+(&8'(&"&%5D(O"*'"9'*,(&8'(*'!$< &8'(%/%5:!$!("+(&*$)(#8%*%#&'*$!&$#!(%/2(&8'*'(G'*'(
2'/#'(%!(&8'("*$4$/("+(&8'(?$*!&(&*$)(%/2(&8'(2'!&$/%< %(&"&%5("+(eZL(&*$)!D(E*$)(2$!&%/#'(*'9'%5!(&8%&(&8'(
&$"/("+(&8'(!'#"/2(&*$)(V$/(."*'(&8%/(eXr("+(#%!< )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'!( 2".$/%&'( +"*( 2$!&%/#'!(
'!W,($/2$#%&'!(&8%&(&8'(&*$)!(%*'(p8".'<1"B/2qD(E8'( 1'&G''/( T( %/2( TM( ;.( Vm$4B*'( XWD( HB*)*$!$/45:,(
.%I"*(2'!&$/%&$"/!(%*'(#"..'*#$%5(#'/&*'!(VXLrW( &*$)!("/()*$9%&'(9'8$#5'!(8%9'(1''/(+"B/2(+"*(9'*:(
%/2('2B#%&$"/%5(#'/&*'!(VTYrW,(%/2(!B1!'@B'/&5:( !8"*&(2$!&%/#'!(!B#8(%!(5'!!(&8%/(ZDX(;.(V&8"B48(
&8'(.%I"*(&*$)()B*)"!'!(%*'(G"*;(VXKrW,(!8"))$/4( "+( #"B*!'( $/( 9'*:( +'G( #%!'!WD( J"G'9'*,( &8'( /B.<
VXZrW(%/2('2B#%&$"/(VTLrWD(E8'(.%I"*$&:("+(&*$)!( 1'*( "+( &*$)!( "/( )*$9%&'( 9'8$#5'!( $/#*'%!'!( $+( &8'(
"*$4$/%&'( +*".( 8".'( %/2( !&%*&( 1'&G''/( [>ZZ( %.( &*$)( 2$!&%/#'( $!( 5"/4'*D( m"*( $/!&%/#',( &8'( /B.1'*(
%/2(TZ>ZZ(%.(G8$5!&(&8'(*'&B*/(&*$)!(&"(8".'(%*'( "+( &*$)!( 1:( )*$9%&'( 9'8$#5'( $!( ."*'( &8%/( &8%&( "+(
%*"B/2(/""/(%/2(1'&G''/(L>ZZ().(%/2(M>ZZ().D( )B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(G8'/(&8'(2$!&%/#'($!("9'*(TM(;.D(
E8"B48( %9'*%4'( &*$)( 2$!&%/#'( $!( MDKN( ;.,( %5."!&( E8'(/B.1'*("+(&*$)!("/()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&($/#*'%!<
KMr(&*$)!(%*'(!8"*&'*(&8%/(T(;.(%/2("/5:(Lr(%*'( '!("9'*(G%5;$/4($+(&8'(2$!&%/#'($!(."*'(&8%/(T(;.(
5"/4'*(&8%/(TM(;.D( %/2( &8%&( &*'/2( #"/&$/B'!D( E8"B48( &8'( G%5;$/4(
O"2%5( !8%*'( "+( &*$)!( *'9'%5( &8%&( KKr( %*'( 5$.$&($!(M(;.,(%5."!&(YZr("+(G%5;$/4(&*$)!(%*'(5'!!(
G%5;'2,( XKr( 1:( )*$9%&'( 9'8$#5'!( V$D'D( ."&"*#:#5',( &8%/(X(;.(%/2(&8'()'*#'/&%4'("+(G%5;$/4(&*$)!(2'<
#%*,(9%/,('&#DW,(%/2(LLr("/()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!( #*'%!'!(2*%.%&$#%55:($+(&8'(2$!&%/#'($!(."*'(&8%/(
VTLr( 8%1%58%1%5,( TMr( &*$#:#5',( [r( '%!:*$2',( [r( T(;.(Vm$4B*'(KWD
I'')/':,( %/2( "/5:( Tr( 1B!WD( E8'( 8$48( )"*&$"/( "+( E*$)!("/()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!(*'9'%5(&8%&(%55(
G%5;$/4( &*$)!( $/( H$@B$I"*( $!5%/2( $!( 1'#%B!'( %5."!&( &8'(&*$)!(G$&8$/(ZDM(;.(%*'(.%2'("/5:("/(8%1%58%<
8%5+("+(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(VLXrW(.'/&$"/'2(&8%&(B!B< 1%5("*(&*$#:#5'd(%/2(&8'*'($!(/"(&*$)("/(I'')/':("*(
%55:( &8':( G%5;( $+( &8'*'( $!( /"&( %/:( %9%$5%15'( )B15$#( 1B!(+"*(%(2$!&%/#'("+(5'!!(&8%/(X(;.(Vm$4B*'(LWD(E8'(
&*%/!)"*&d( %!( /"&'2( '%*5$'*( &8%&( KMr( "+( &*$)!( %*'( &*$)!( 1'&G''/( TZ( %/2( TM( ;.( 2$!&%/#'( %*'( ."!&5:(
!8"*&'*(&8%/(T(;.(G8$#8(#"B52(1'(&*%9'55'2('%!$5:( .%2'( "/( '%!:*$2'D( R9'/( &8"B48( 8%1%58%1%5( &*$)!(
1:(G%5;$/4D(( %*'(%9%$5%15'(1"&8(+"*(!8"*&(%/2(5"/4(2$!&%/#',(&8'(
E8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(8%2(1''/(%!;'2(&8'(*'%!"/(+"*( .%I"*$&:(VYYrW(%*'(1'&G''/(T(%/2(TZ(;.D(-'!)$&'(
B!$/4( &8'$*( &*%9'5( ."2'( %/2( %5."!&( 8%5+( "+( &8'.( &8'(.%I"*$&:("+(&*$#:#5'(&*$)!(VLTrW(1'$/4(5'!!(&8%/(
.'/&$"/'2('$&8'*(bB/%9%$5%1$5$&:("+(%/:("&8'*(."2'g( T( ;.,( &8'( /B.1'*( "+( G%5;$/4( &*$)!( $!( !&$55( .B#8(
"*( b#"/9'/$'/&gD( J"G'9'*,( &8'( *'%!"/!( %*'( 2$9'*!'d( 8$48'*(&8%/(&*$#:#5'("9'*(&8$!(2$!&%/#'(*%/4'D
+"*( $/!&%/#',( b!8"*&( 2$!&%/#'g,( b8%9'( /"( ."/':g( "*( k"(!$4/$?$#%/&(*'5%&$"/!8$)(G%!(+"B/2(1'&G''/(
b/"( &*%/!)"*&( %9%$5%15'g( %*'( 4$9'/( 1:( )'2'!&*$%/!,( $/#".'( %/2( #8"$#'( "+( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'( $/(
G8$5!&( b#"/9'/$'/&g( "*( b8%9'( +%.$5:,( 8'/#'( #8'%)'*g( H$@B$I"*($!5%/2D(J"G'9'*,(."!&("+(&8'(!&B2'/&!(*$2'(
%*'( 4$9'/( +"*( )*$9%&'( 9'8$#5'!D( n/( &8'( "&8'*( 8%/2,( &*$#:#5'!("*('%!:*$2'!(G8$5'(9'*:(+'G("+(&8'.(G%5;(
8%1%58%1%5( B!'*!( ."!&5:( .'/&$"/'2( bB/%9%$5%1$5$&:( "*(B!'(1B!'!D(E8$!($/2$#%&'!(&8%&(!&B2'/&!(.%:()*'<
"+( %/:( "&8'*( ."2'g( "*( b4"y'!z( #5"!'( &"( 2'!&$/%&$"/g( +'*(+%!&'*(&*%/!)"*&(G$&8(5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'D( 5."!&(
"*(b5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'g(G8$5'(&*$#:#5'(B!'*!(.'/&$"/'2( MNr("+(&*$)(.%;'*!(2"(/"&(/''2(&"(G%$&(+"*(&*%9'5(
b5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'gD(Q/(#"/&*%!&,(b!%+'&:g("*(b5'!!(&*%9'5( %!( &8':( %*'( '$&8'*( G%5;$/4( "*( B!$/4( %( )*$9%&'( 9'<
&$.'g("*(b5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'g(+"*('%!:*$2'd(b#8'%)'*g("*( 8$#5'D( E8'( G%$&$/4( &$.'( +"*( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( G%!(
b#".+"*&g( +"*( I'')/':d( %/2( b#".+"*&g( "*( b!%+'&:g( +"*( +"B/2(&"(1'(8$48'*(+"*(&8'(&*$)!(G$&8(5"/4'*(&*%9'5(
1B!(8%9'(1''/(*')"*&'2(1:(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+()%!!'/< &$.'d( 8"G'9'*,( %( +'G( &*$)!( "9'*( !8"*&'*( 2$!&%/#'!(
4'*!D(U8%&'9'*,(%(P8$<H@B%*'(&'!&(!8"G'2(%(!$4/$?$< $/9"59'2(%(5"/4(G%$&$/4(&$.'D(m"*($/!&%/#',(+'G()%!<
#%/&(2$++'*'/#'(1'&G''/(4'/2'*(%/2(&*%9'5(."2'(t( !'/4'*!( *')"*&'2( &8%&( &8':( 8%2( &"( G%$&( LZ( &"( NZ(
%."/4(&8'(&*$#:#5',('%!:*$2',(%/2(I'')/':(B!'*!(&8'( .$/B&'!("*('9'/(NZ(&"(TXZ(.$/B&'!(+"*(%(&*$)("+(5'!!(
/B.1'*("+(G".'/($!(."*'(&8%/(.'/,(G8$5!&(*'9'*!'( &8%/(M(;.("*(%(I"B*/':("+(XZ(&"(LZ(.$/B&'!("*('9'/(
$!(&*B'(+"*(8%1%58%1%5()%!!'/4'*!(%/2()'2'!&*$%/!D( M(&"(XZ(.$/B&'!D(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
Public transport in a small island of a developing country 67

Mode of the trip


HB*)*$!$/45:,($&(G%!(+"B/2(&8%&(%(+'G()%!!'/4'*!(
B!$/4(8%1%58%1%5,(&*$#:#5'(%/2('%!:*$2'(2"(/"&()%:(
Walking Private Vehicle Public Transport
120 &8'( +%*'( %!( $&( $!( &8'$*( *'5%&$9'( "*( +*$'/2g!( 9'8$#5'D(
."/4(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!,(.%I"*$&:("+(&8'(
100
&*$)!(#"!&!(%*'(1'5"G(6TZD(m%*'!(+"*(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+(
80 &*$#:#5'( &*$)!( %*'( 1'5"G( 6M,( G8$5'( +"*( '%!:*$2'( "*(
Count

60 I'')/':(&*$)!(%*'(4'/'*%55:($/(&8'(6N(&"(6TZ(*%/4'D(
40
s'*:( +'G( &*$)!( #"!&( ."*'( &8%/( 6XZ,( &8'!'( G'*'( 1:(
8%1%58%1%5("*(I'')/':D(
20

Public transport: service level,


Be

0.2

0.5

1.1

2.1

3.1

5.1

10

15

Ab
ove
low

.1

.1
1

-2

-3

-5

-1
-0

-1

-1

-2

2
0.2

0k
km

km

km

0k
.5

5k

0k
km

passengers’ usage and preference


km

m
m

Distance of the Trip

Figure 2 - Frequency of trip on different mode and distance *"B/2( [Zr( "+( &8'( *'!)"/2'/&!( $/( H$@B$I"*( $!<
Source: RAHMAN, 2007b. 5%/2(B!'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&D(E8'(*'.%$/2'*(/'9'*(B!'(
)B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( 1'#%B!'( &8':( '$&8'*( G%5;( "*( B!'(
Mode of the trip )'*!"/%5(V+%.$5:("G/'2("*("+?$#'W(9'8$#5'!D(Q/(#"/<
Walking Private Vehicle Public Transport &*%!&,(%1"B&(KZr(B!'*!("+(&8'()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(8%9'(
40
+%.$5:("G/'2(9'8$#5'D(
J%1%58%1%5(B!'*!(."!&5:(5$9'($/(."B/&%$/"B!(%*<
30
'%!("*($/(1%*%/4%:!(G$&8(/"(/%&$"/%5("*()*"9$/#$%5(
Percent

*"%2( %##'!!D( J"G'9'*,( ."!&( "+( &8'.( *')"*&'2( &8%&(


20
8%1%58%1%5($!("+&'/(%9%$5%15'(%&(&8'$*(8".'("*(G"*;(
)5%#'( G$&8$/( ?$9'( .$/B&'!,( &8"B48( !".'( %5!"( .'/<
10
&$"/'2( 8%9$/4( &"( G%$&( XZ( &"( LZ( .$/B&'!( "*( !".'<
&$.'!(LZ(&"(NZ(.$/B&'!D(O"*'(&8%/(8%5+(VMKrW("+(&8'(
0 8%1%58%1%5( B!'*!( B!'( $&( '$&8'*( "/#'( "*( &G"( &"( +"B*(
Be

0.2

0.5

1.1

2.1

3.1

5.1

10

15

Ab
ove
low

.1

.1

&$.'!( )'*( G'';( G8$5!&( %( !$4/$?$#%/&( )"*&$"/( VKKrW(


1-

1-

-2

-3

-5

-1

20
0.2

0.5

1k

0k

15

20
km

km

km

km
m

km

km
km

Distance of the Trip B!'( $&( "/5:( "/'( &"( &G"( &$.'!( )'*( ."/&8D( E8$!( 5"G(
+*'@B'/#:( "+( &*$)!( "/( 8%1%58%1%5( $!( 1'#%B!'( &8':(
Figure 3 - Percentage of Trips for Different Distance %5!"( B!'( "&8'*( ."2'!D( E8'( .%I"*$&:( "+( 8%1%58%1%5(
Source: RAHMAN, 2007b. B!'*!( %*'( !%&$!?$'2( G$&8( &8'( %9%$5%1$5$&:( %/2( #".<
+"*&,( 1B&( %5."!&( 8%5+( "+( &8'.( %*'( G"**$'2( %1"B&(
Mode of the trip !%+'&:D(HB*)*$!$/45:,(%5."!&(&8*''<@B%*&'*!("+(B!'*!(
Walking Private Transport Habalhabal
.'/&$"/'2(&8%&(&8':(G"B52(/"&(B!'($&($+(&8'*'(G%!(%(
Tricycle Easyride/Multicab Jeepney Bus
I'')/':("*('%!:*$2'("*(1B!(!'*9$#'(%9%$5%15'D(
100 H$.$5%*5:,( &8'( +*'@B'/#:( "+( &*$#:#5'( B!%4'( $!( '$<
80
&8'*( "/#'( "*( X( &"( L( &$.'!( )'*( G'';( %/2( $&( $!( "+&'/(
%9%$5%15'(%&(8".'("*(&8'(G"*;()5%#'D(J"G'9'*,("/'<
Count

60
@B%*&'*("+(&8'.(.'/&$"/'2(&8%&(&8':(8%9'(&"('$&8'*(
40
G%5;("*(*$2'(8%1%58%1%5(+"*(%(#'*&%$/(2$!&%/#'(V*%/4<
20 $/4(+*".(T(&"(Y(;.W(&"G%*2!(&8'(/'%*1:(.%$/(*"%2(
0
%/2(G%$&(&"(#%&#8(%(&*$#:#5'D(E8'(.%I"*$&:("+(&*$#:#5'(
B!'*!( 8%9'( *')"*&'2( G%$&$/4( &$.'!( "+( 5'!!( &8%/( XZ(
Be

0.2

0.5

1.1

2.1

3.1

5.1

10

15

Ab
ove
low

.1

.1
1-

1-

-2

-3

-5

-1

-1

-2

20
0.2

0.5

1k

0k
km

km

km

5k

0k

.$/B&'!,(%/2(+"*(%5."!&(eZr("+(&*$)!,(&8'(#"!&($!(5'!!(
km
m

m
km

Distance of the Trip


&8%/(6M(V2B'(&"(&8'(!8"*&(2$!&%/#'(&*%9'55'2WD(O"!&(
Figure 4 - Number of trips on various public transport modes for different distance "+(&8'(&*$#:#5'(B!'*!(%*'(p!".'8"G(!%&$!?$'2q(%1"B&(
Source: RAHMAN, 2007b. $&!(%9%$5%1$5$&:(%/2(#".+"*&D(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
68 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

R%!:*$2'(B!'*!(."!&5:(5$9'($/(6"15%#$"/("*(#"%!&%5( &$.'!()'*(."/&8(+"*(&8'(.%I"*$&:D(O"*'(&8%/([Mr("+(
%*'%!($/(&8'(.B/$#$)%5$&:("+(H$@B$I"*,(`%*'/%,(H%/(7B%/( 1B!()%!!'/4'*!(%5!"(8%9'(&"(4"(&"G%*2!(&8'(.%$/(*"%2(
%/2(R/*$@B'(s$55%/B'9%D(m*'@B'/#:("+('%!:*$2'(B!%4'( "*(&'*.$/%5(&"(#%&#8("/'(%/2(8%9'(&"(G%$&(LZ(&"(NZ(.$/<
$!('$&8'*("/#'(%(G'';("*("/'(&"(&G"(&$.'!()'*(."/&8( B&'!,(!$.$5%*(&"(I'')/':()%!!'/4'*!D( !(G$&8(I'')/':,(
+"*(."!&("+(&8'(B!'*!D(E8"B48($&($!(%9%$5%15'(%&(8".'( &8'(.%I"*$&:("+(1B!()%!!'/4'*!(%*'(9'*:(8%)):(%1"B&(
"*(G"*;(+"*(%(+'G,(%1"B&(&G"<&8$*2!(8%9'(&"(G%5;("*( !%+'&:(%/2(#".+"*&(2'!)$&'($&!()""*(%9%$5%1$5$&:D(
*$2'(8%1%58%1%5(V+"*(9%*$"B!(2$!&%/#'!W(&"G%*2!(&8'( E"( 'F)5"*'( &8'( ."!&( )*'+'*%15'( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&(
/'%*'!&(.%$/(*"%2("*(&'*.$/%5(&"(#%&#8(&8'('%!:*$2'D( ."2'( +"*( &8'( $!5%/2,( &8'( *'!)"/2'/&!( G'*'( %!;'2(
-'!)$&'(%(G%$&$/4(&$.'(*')"*&'2(1:(."*'(&8%/(eZr("+( G8$#8(."2'(&8':(5$;'(."!&D( ."/4(&8'(%9%$5%15'()B1<
'$&8'*(?$9'(&"(XZ(.$/B&'!("*(XZ(&"(LZ(.$/B&'!,(%5."!&( 5$#(&*%/!)"*&,(&8'(."!&()*'+'*%15'(."2'(G%!(8%1%58%1%5(
%55(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(%*'(b9'*:(8%)):g(%1"B&(&8'(#".< VKXrW(+"55"G'2(1:('%!:*$2'(VKZrW(%/2(&*$#:#5'(VT[rWD(
+"*&,(!%+'&:,(%/2(%9%$5%1$5$&:("+('%!:*$2'D( J"G'9'*,($&(!8"B52(1'(/"&'2(&8%&(8%1%58%1%5(8%!(1''/(
7'')/':( B!'*!( %*'( !)*'%2( &8*"B48"B&( &8'( $!5%/2( *')"*&'2(."!&5:(1:(&8'()'")5'(G8"(8%9'(/"("&8'*(."2'(
%/2( &8'$*( +*'@B'/#:( "+( B!%4'( $!( !$.$5%*( &"( B!'*!( "+( %9%$5%15'(+"*(&*%9'5D(m"*(&8$!(*'%!"/,("+(&8"!'(G8"(.'/<
'%!:*$2'( t( "/#'( )'*( G'';( "*( "/'( &"( &G"( &$.'!( )'*( &$"/'2(8%1%58%1%5(%!(&8'(."!&()*'+'*%15'(."2',(."*'(
."/&8(+"*(&8'(.%I"*$&:D(EG"<&8$*2!("+(&8'(I'')/':(B!< &8%/(8%5+("+(&8'.(*')"*&'2(&8%&(&8':(G"B52(/"&(B!'($&($+(
'*!(8%9'(&"(4"(&"(&8'(/'%*1:(.%$/(*"%2("*(&'*.$/%5( &8'*'(G'*'(I'')/':,('%!:*$2'("*(1B!(!'*9$#'!(%9%$5%15'D(
&"(#%&#8(%(I'')/':,(%/2(."!&5:(&8':(G%5;D(n+&'/(&8':( J'/#',($&($!($.)"*&%/&(&"(5"";(%&(&8'(#%B!'!(1'8$/2(
8%9'(&"(G%$&(LZ(&"(NZ(.$/B&'!(%/2(%*'(#"/!'@B'/&5:( &8'( )*'+'*'/#'!( VE%15'( TWD( E8'( .%I"*$&:( .'/&$"/'2(
b/"&( 8%)):g( %1"B&( %9%$5%1$5$&:D( k'9'*&8'5'!!,( ."*'( b%9%$5%1$5$&:g( %/2( b#".+"*&g( G8$5'( &8'( *'!&( %5!"( )"$/&<
&8%/(eZr("+(&8'()%!!'/4'*!(%*'(9'*:(8%)):(%1"B&(&8'( '2(&"(b!%+'&:g,(b5'!!(&*%9'5(&$.'g,(b5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'g(%/2(
!%+'&:(%/2(#".+"*&("+(I'')/':D( b#8'%)'*g( %!( *'%!"/!D( E"( !".'( 'F&'/&,( &8$!( $!( !$.$5%*(
=B!( )%!!'/4'*!( ."!&5:( 5$9'( $/( &8'( .B/$#$)%5$&$'!( &"(&8'(!&B2:(?$/2$/4!("+( /2%5''1(VXZZ[W,(G8"(+"B/2(
"+( `%*'/%,( R/*$@B'( s$55%/B'9%,( O%*$%,( %/2( `%_$d( %/2( b#".+"*&(5'9'5g(%/2(bG%$&$/4(+%#$5$&$'!g(8%9'(!$4/$?$#%/&(
&8'(+*'@B'/#:("+(B!%4'($!(9'*:(*%*'(t("/5:("/'("*(&G"( '++'#&!( "/( 1B!( )%!!'/4'*!g( !%&$!+%#&$"/( $/( 2'9'5")$/4(

Table 1 - Most preferable public transport mode and the reason for preference

Best preference
Reason
Habalhabal Tricycle Easyride Jeepney Bus Total

Cheaper 4 20 4 28
Only available 54 14 5 6 79
Nearby available 2 1 3
Comfortable 2 4 46 6 12 70
Safe/Less accident 1 8 3 1 13
Go all places (close to destination) 13 16 1 30
Fast/Less travel time 15 7 1 23
Less waiting time 2 4 10 16
Own/Family have 1 1 2
More space/Carry goods 2 2 1 5
Convenient 1 5 1 7
More people (interaction) 1 1 2

Total 90 48 83 38 19 278

Source: RAHMAN, 2007a.


Note: Value in the cells represents the frequency of the respondents. Empty cell means no respondent mentioned about that.

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
Public transport in a small island of a developing country 69

#"B/&*$'!D(Q&($!("19$"B!(&8%&(&8'(*'%!"/(+"*()*'+'*'/#'( %/2(!&"))$/4()"$/&!,(%9%$5%1$5$&:("+(!'*9$#'!($/(#'*<
$/( H$@B$I"*( $!5%/2( 2"'!( 9%*:( 4*'%&5:( 1'&G''/( ."2'!D( &%$/(%*'%!,(5"/4(G%$&$/4(&$.'!,(5%#;("+(#".+"*&(%/2(
m"*( $/!&%/#',( &8"!'( G8"( 8%9'( *')"*&'2( '%!:*$2'( %!( "9'*#*"G2$/4d( &8'!'( %*',( 8"G'9'*,( #".."/( $!!B'!(
&8'$*(."!&()*'+'**'2(."!&5:(#8""!'($&(+"*(b#".+"*&g("*( $/( 2'9'5")$/4( #"B/&*$'!D( J"G'9'*,( &8'( .%I"*$&:( "+(
b5'!!( G%$&$/4( &$.'g( "*( b5'!!( &*%9'5( &$.'gD( n/( &8'( "&8'*( &8'( *'!)"/2'/&!( 'F)'#&( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( &"( 8%9'(
8%/2,(b4"(#5"!'(&"(2'!&$/%&$"/g(G%!(&8'(."!&($.)"*&%/&( G'55<!)'#$?$'2(*"B&'(%/2(!&"))$/4()"$/&!,(."*'(#"9<
+"*(&*$#:#5'(G8$5!&('$&8'*(b#8'%)'*g("*(b#".+"*&g(+"*(1"&8( '*%4',(%/2(!#8'2B5'2(!'*9$#'D(
I'')/':( %/2( 1B!( G'*'( &8'( ."!&( #".."/( *'%!"/!( $/( E8'( *'!)"/2'/&!( 8%2( 1''/( %!;'2( +*".( %( 4$9'/(
&8"!'(#%!'!D(J"G'9'*,($&(!8"B52(1'(/"&'2(&8%&(b#".+"*&g( !'&( "+( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'!( V$+( &8"!'( %*'( %9%$5<
8'*'(2"'!(/"&(.'%/(&8%&(I'')/':("*(1B!(!'*9$#'!(%*'( %15'W(G8$#8(&8':(G"B52(!'5'#&(+"*(&8'$*(&*$)D( ."/4(
9'*:(#".+"*&%15'd(*%&8'*(&8$!($!(!".'8"G(1'&&'*(#".< &8'( I'')/':( %/2( '%!:*$2'( B!'*!,( ."*'( &8%/( 8%5+( "+(
)%*'2(G$&8("&8'*(."2'!(%9%$5%15'($/(H$@B$I"*($!5%/2D( &8'.( VMMrW( G"B52( #8""!'( '%!:*$2'( 1'#%B!'( "+(
n/5:(XX[(*'!)"/2'/&!(4%9'(&8'$*(!'#"/2()*'+'*< #".+"*&,(!)''2(%/2(*'2B#'2(G%$&$/4(&$.'d(8"G'9'*,(
'/#'(VG8$#8(.'%/!(&8':(*')"*&'2(B!$/4(."*'(&8%/( ."*'( &8%/( %( @B%*&'*( G"B52( )*'+'*( I'')/':( V1'$/4(
"/'(."2'WD(Q/(&8"!',(1B!(G%!()*'+'**'2(1:(&8'(.%< #8'%)'*W( G8$5!&( &8'( *'.%$/2'*( #"/!$2'*'2( 1"&8( %!(
I"*$&:( +"55"G'2( 1:( '%!:*$2'( %/2( I'')/':D( Q/( ."!&( '@B$9%5'/&D( ."/4( &*$#:#5'( %/2( 8%1%58%1%5( B!'*!,(
#%!'!(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(*')"*&'2(%!(&8'$*(."!&()*'+< &8'(.%I"*$&:(G"B52()*'+'*(&*$#:#5'(1'#%B!'("+(#".<
'*%15'(."2'(&8'("/'(&8':(B!'(."!&("+&'/D +"*&(%/2(!%+'&:D(n/(&8'("&8'*(8%/2,($+(1"&8(%*'(%9%$5<
%15',(&8'(.%I"*$&:(G"B52()*'+'*('%!:*$2'("9'*(&*$#:<
#5'(+"*(#".+"*&(%/2(!)''2(G8$5'(%(+'G(G"B52(#8""!'(
Expectations about public transport service &*$#:#5'(+"*(5'!!(G%$&$/4(&$.'D( 4%$/,(%5."!&([Zr("+(
&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(G"B52()*'+'*(1B!("9'*(I'')/':(2B'(
E8'( .%I"*( )*"15'.!( "+( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( $/( &"(#".+"*&(%/2(!%+'&:D(E8$!(2$!#B!!$"/("+()*'+'*'/#'(
H$@B$I"*( %*'( &8'( %1!'/#'( "+( G'55<!)'#$?$'2( *"B&'!( #"B52(1'(!B..%*$!'2(%!($/(E%15'(XD

Table 2 - Preference of Public Transport Modes with Respect to Different Factors

Preference of the Travel Modes


Factors Highest Lowest
Fare rate : Habalhabal > Tricycle > Easyride > Bus > Jeepney
Comfort : Bus > Easyride > Jeepney > Tricycle > Habalhabal
Safe : Bus > Jeepney > Easyride > Tricycle > Habalhabal

} Easyride
Go all places or
: Habalhabal > Tricycle > Jeepney
go close to destination
Bus
Fast/ less travel time : Habalhabal > Easyride > Bus > Jeepney > Tricycle
Waiting time : Bus > Jeepney > Easyride > Tricycle > Habalhabal
Bus
More space or
easy to carry goods
:
Jeepney } > Easyride >

}
Tricycle > Habalhabal

Jeepney
Convenient : Easyride > Habalhabal >
Tricycle
Jeepney
Bad odor and noise :
Tricycle } > Easyride

Source: RAHMAN, 2007a.

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
70 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

m*".(&8'(%1"9'(2$!#B!!$"/("+()*'+'*'/#',($&(#"B52( ."2'!("+()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&,(&8"B48(."!&()'")5'()*'<
1'(!''/(&8%&()'")5'("+(H$@B$I"*(!''.(&"()*'+'*(5%*4'< +'*(#".+"*&%15'(%/2(#8'%)'*(."2'!(&8%&(4"(#5"!'(&"(
"##B)%/#:( 9'8$#5'!( %/2( &$.'&%15'2( !'*9$#'!( +"*( &8'$*(2'!&$/%&$"/!D(
5"/4<8%B5(I"B*/':!D(O"*'"9'*,(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+(&8'.( E8'( !&B2:( +"B/2( &8%&( G".'/( 2"( /"&( 5$;'( 8%1<
G%/&( ."*'( !)'#$?$#( *"B&'!( %/2( &$.'&%15'!( +"*( 1B!,( %58%1%5( 1B&( )*'+'*( &*$#:#5'( G8$5!&( .'/( )*'+'*( 8%<
I'')/':( %/2( '%!:*$2',( %/2( %5!"( !)'#$?$#( *"B&'!( +"*( 1%58%1%5D( E8'( !&B2:( #"/#5B2'!( &8%&( &8'( )'")5'( "+(
'%!:*$2'D( J"G'9'*,( &*%/!)"*&%&$"/( )5%//$/4( 5$&'*%< H$@B$I"*( %*'( 1$%!'2( t( &8':( )*'+'*( %/2( G%/&( $.<
&B*'($.)5$'!(&8%&(%#&B%5(1'8%9$"B*($!("/'<@B%*&'*("+( )*"9'.'/&( $/( &8'( ."2'( G8$#8( &8':( B!'( ."!&( "+<
&8'('F)*'!!'2(1'8%9$"B*%5($/&'/&(VHJRHlQk,(TeeTWD( &'/D( J"G'9'*,( &8'*'( %*'( %5!"( !".'( "&8'*( +%#&"*!(
E8B!,( $&( G"B52( 1'( .B#8( ."*'( %))*")*$%&'( $+( "/5:( 5$;'(%9%$5%1$5$&:,(#"!&,(#".+"*&('&#D($/9"59'2($/(&8$!(
&8'()%!!'/4'*!("+(%()%*&$#B5%*(."2'(%*'(#"/!$2'*'2( )*'+'*'/#'D(
+"*('F)5"*$/4(&8'$*('F)'#&%&$"/!(%1"B&()B15$#(&*%/!< 6"5$#:( 4B$2'5$/'!( !8"B52( 1'( 2$*'#&'2( &"G%*2!(
)"*&D(='#%B!'("+()""*(%9%$5%1$5$&:(%/2(#"/!'@B'/&5:( )*"9$2$/4( #".+"*&%15',( #8'%),( %/2( +%!&( )B15$#(
5"/4(G%$&$/4(&$.'d(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+('%!:*$2',(I'')/':( &*%/!)"*&( &"( %55( G$&8( 5'!!( G%$&$/4( &$.'( &"( %22*'!!(
%/2(1B!(B!'*!(G%/&(."*'(!)'#$?$#(*"B&'!,(!#8'2B5'( &8'( )*'+'*'/#'( %/2( 'F)'#&%&$"/!( "+( &8'( .%I"*$&:D(
%/2( !&"))$/4( )5%#'!( +"*( &8'( *'!)'#&$9'( ."2'!( V%5< *"B/2( KMr( "+( &8'( 8"B!'8"52( *'!)"/2'/&!( B!'(
."!&(eZr(+"*('%!:*$2'(B!'*!WD(k'9'*&8'5'!!,(%(+'G( 8%1%58%1%5( %/2( %."/4( &8'( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( &*$)!(
"+( &8'( *'!)"/2'/&!( &8$/;( &8%&( !)'#$?$'2( &$.'&%15'!( $&!( #"/&*$1B&$"/( $!( %5!"( KMrD( U$&8"B&( 8%1%58%1%5,(
+"*('%!:*$2',(I'')/':(%/2(1B!(.%:($/#*'%!'(G%$&$/4( G%5;$/4( $!( &8'( "/5:( %9%$5%15'( ."2'( "+( &*%9'5( $/(
&$.',( !"( 2"( /"&( G%/&( &8'.,( %/2( .%/:( 2"( /"&( '9'/( ."B/&%$/"B!( %*'%!( +"*( &8"!'( G8"( 8%9'( /"( +%.<
G%/&( !)'#$?$'2( !&"))$/4( )5%#'!( +"*( %/:( ."2'( 1'< $5:( "G/'2( 9'8$#5'D( R9'/( &8"B48( )5%:$/4( %( #*B#$%5(
#%B!'(&8':(G%/&()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(%&(&8'$*(2""*!&')!D( *"5'( "+( &*%/!)"*&,( 8%1%58%1%5( $!( $55'4%5( V#"5"*B.WD(
HB*)*$!$/45:,( "/'<&8$*2( "+( 8%1%58%1%5( B!'*!( G%/&( J"G'9'*,( 2B'( &"( $2'/&$?$#%&$"/( %/2( $.)5'.'/&%<
."*'( !)'#$?$'2( *"B&'!( G8$5'( ."*'( &8%/( 8%5+( "+( &8'( &$"/( )*"15'.!,( $&( .%:( /"&( 1'( )"!!$15'( &"( *'!&*$#&(
&*$#:#5'(B!'*!(G%/&(!)'#$?$'2(*"B&'(%/2(."*'(#"9'*< $&( %&( &8'( .".'/&( V3 JO k,( XZZ[%WD( Q+( !".'8"G(
%4'D( E8$!( $/2$#%&'!( &8'( B!'*!( "+( %( )%*&$#B5%*( ."2'( &8'!'( )*"15'.!( #"B52( 1'( !"59'2( %/2( &8'( 8%1%58%<
.%$/5:(G%/&($.)*"9'.'/&!($/(G8%&(&8':(%*'(%5*'%2:( 1%5(1'#".'!(*'!&*$#&'2,(!".'()'")5'(G$55(5"!'(&8'$*(
B!$/4D(E8'(.%I"*$&:("+(&8'(*'!)"/2'/&!(.'/&$"/'2(%( G"*;( %/2( '%*/$/4!( G8$5'( )'")5'( 5$9$/4( $/( ."B/<
2'!$*'(+"*()%!!'/4'*(!8'5&'*!(G$&8(!'%&$/4(+%#$5$&$'!( &%$/"B!(%*'%!,(G$&8"B&(%(+%.$5:("G/'2(9'8$#5',(G$55(
%&(&'*.$/%5!D 8%9'(&"(G%5;('9'/(TM(;.(&"(4"(&8'(/'%*'!&(.%*;'&(
&"()B*#8%!'(+""2D(
E*%/!)"*&%&$"/(!:!&'.!,(%!(O%#%*$"(VXZZTW(!B4<
Conclusions and recommendations 4'!&!,(/''2(&"('!&%15$!8(&8'(&*%2'<"++!(1'&G''/(9%*<
$"B!( 2$.'/!$"/!( %##"*2$/4( &"( &8'( !"#$"<'#"/".$#(
R9'/(&8"B48(&8'(.%I"*$&:("+()'")5'("/(H$@B$I"*( %/2( #B5&B*%5( *'%5$&:( "+( '%#8( !)'#$?$#( '/9$*"/.'/&D(
$!5%/2( B!'( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&,( &8'( /B.1'*( "+( )B15$#( E8B!,( #"/!$2'*$/4( &8'( !"#$"<'#"/".$#( #"/2$&$"/(
&*%/!)"*&(9'8$#5'!($!(5'!!(&8%/(Mr("+(&8'(&"&%5(/B.< %/2( &")"4*%)8$#%5( +'%&B*'!,( &8$!( !&B2:( *'#".<
1'*("+(9'8$#5'!(*'4$!&'*'2(V3 JO k,(XZZ[%WD(E8$!( .'/2!(&8'(5'4%5$!%&$"/("+(8%1%58%1%5(%&(5"#%5(5'9'5(
!$&B%&$"/($!(!$.$5%*(&"("&8'*(2'9'5")$/4(#"B/&*$'!D( VOB/$#$)%5( ]"9'*/.'/&W( %!( G$&8( &*$#:#5'!D( E8'(
O"!&( )'")5'( %*'( 2')'/2'/&( "/( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( )*'!$2'/&("+(&8'(8%1%58%1%5(%!!"#$%&$"/($/(H$@B$I"*,(
+"*( &8'$*( &*%9'5( 1B&( $&!( %9%$5%1$5$&:( $!( 5$.$&'2( %/2( `%*'/%,(O%*$%,(%/2(`%_$(%5!"(!"B48&($&!(5'4%5$!%&$"/D(
!'*9$#'(#%/(1'(9'*:()""*(V] lRkJRQOR3,(TeeeWD( `"#%5( ]"9'*/.'/&( 0/$&!( V`]0!W( %*'( %G%*'( %1"B&(
='!$2'!,( &8'*'( $!( %( #".)5'&'( %1!'/#'( "+( )B15$#( &8'( 5"#%5( $!!B'!( %/2( #"/#'*/!,( %/2( '%#8( `]0( 8%!(
&*%/!)"*&(!B))"*&($/+*%!&*B#&B*'D( &8'$*( "G/( !&%&B&"*:( )"G'*( &"( '/%#&( &*%/!)"*&( *'<
5."!&( 8%5+( "+( &8'( )'")5'( $/( H$@B$I"*( .%;'( 5'!!( 5%&'2(*B5'!D(`'4%5$_$/4(8%1%58%1%5(#"B52(1'(2"/'(1:(
&8%/(+"B*(&*$)!()'*(G'';(%/2(%*'(."!&5:(!)'/2(5'!!( !&*'/4&8'/$/4(&8'('F$!&$/4(2*$9'*!g(%!!"#$%&$"/(%/2(
&8%/( 6TZ( )'*( &*$)D( 9%$5%1$5$&:( "+( 1B!( %/2( I'')/':( )*"9$2$/4(5"4$!&$#%5(!B))"*&(+*".(&8'(`]0($+(5$#'/#<
$!()""*(G8$5'(8%1%58%1%5($!(/"&(#"/!$2'*'2(!%+'(+"*( $/4("+($/2$9$2B%5(")'*%&"*!($!(&*%/!+'**'2(+*".(`]0(
&*%9'5D( R%!:*$2'( %/2( 1B!( %*'( &8'( ."!&( )*'+'*%15'( &8*"B48(&8'(%!!"#$%&$"/D( (+''(+"*(*'4$!&*%&$"/(#"B52(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
Public transport in a small island of a developing country 71

1'($.)"!'2d(1B&(&8$!(!8"B52(1'(;')&(5"G,("&8'*G$!'( 3nHPJ` 0,( TeYMWD( E8$!( )%)'*( *'#"..'/2!( +"*.<


8%1%58%1%5(2*$9'*!(.%:(&*:(&"(%9"$2(*'4$!&'*$/4D( $/4( %/( %!!"#$%&$"/( +"*( '%#8( &*%/!)"*&( ."2'( &"(
]$9'/( &8'( 9'*:( !)'#$?$#( /%&B*'( "+( H$@B$I"*,( &8$!( .%/%4'( &8'$*( ")'*%&$"/!,( %!( G'55( %!( %/( $/&'4*%&'2(
!&B2:(*'#"..'/2!(")'*%&$/4(1B!("*(I'')/':($/(&8'( &*%/!)"*&(%!!"#$%&$"/(1'&G''/(2$++'*'/&(."2'!(V%!<
/%&$"/%5(*"%2(#$*#5$/4(&8'($!5%/2,('%!:*$2'("/5:("/( !"#$%&$"/( "+( &8'( %!!"#$%&$"/!WD( `En( "+?$#$%5!( !8"B52(
$/&'*<.B/$#$)%5(#"**$2"*!,(&*$#:#5'("/5:(G$&8$/(.B< %5!"(1'($/#"*)"*%&'2($/(&8$!(#"..$&&''(G8'*'(`]0(
/$#$)%5$&$'!g( *"%2!,( %/2( 8%1%58%1%5( "/5:( $/( ."B/< "*( 66n( V)*"9$/#$%5( )5%//$/4( "+?$#'W( #"B52( )5%:( &8'(
&%$/"B!( %*'%!D( J"G'9'*,( $+( &8'( *"%2( /'&G"*;( %/2( *"5'( "+( +%#$5$&%&"*( "*( #""*2$/%&"*D( E8$!( $/&'4*%&'2(
#"/2$&$"/( $!( $.)*"9'2( $/( &8'( +B&B*',( 8%1%58%1%5( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( %!!"#$%&$"/( G$55( 1'( &8'( %)'F( 1"2:(
.$48&( 1'( *')5%#'2( 1:( J$48( n##B)%/#:( s'8$#5'!( +"*(2'#$!$"/<.%;$/4($/(&8'()*"9$/#'D(
VJns!WD( E8'( 'F$!&$/4( .$/$1B!( !'*9$#'( "+( `%*'/%( <( E8'( !&B2:( %5!"( *'#"..'/2!( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&(
`%_$(*"B&'(#"B52(1'('F)%/2'2(&"(&8'(G8"5'(#$*#B.< .%/%4'.'/&( %/2( )*"9$!$"/( "+( !".'( )B15$#( &*%/!<
+'*'/&$%5( /%&$"/%5( *"%2( %+&'*( %( 2'&%$5'2( ?$/%/#$%5( )"*&<!B))"*&$/4( $/+*%!&*B#&B*',( $D'D( %&( 5'%!&( "/'(
+'%!$1$5$&:(!&B2:D( G%$&$/4( !8'5&'*( G$&8( !'%&$/4( +%#$5$&$'!( %&( '%#8( .B<
R%!:*$2'( !8"B52( ")'*%&'( "/( !)'#$?$'2( *"B&'!( /$#$)%5(&'*.$/%5(!"(&8%&()%!!'/4'*!(#"B52(*'!&(G8$5'(
"/5:D( HB1I'#&( &"( +B*&8'*( *'!'%*#8( "/( #"!&<1'/'?$&( G%$&$/4D( 9'/B'!(+"*(+B*&8'*(*'!'%*#8(#"B52($/#5B2'(
%/%5:!$!,( '%!:*$2'( !'*9$#'( #"B52( 1'( 'F)%/2'2( "/( &8'(")'*%&$"/("+(2$++'*'/&()B15$#(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!("*(
!".'(.%I"*(*"%2!(5$;'(`%*'/%(<(=%!%#(<(O%*$%d(%/2( )*')%*$/4(%(5"4$!&$#(*'4*'!!$"/(."2'5("+(8"G()'")5'(
$/("&8'*(.B/$#$)%5$&$'!(+"*($/&'*<.B/$#$)%5(#"//'#< G$55(#8""!'(."2'D(
&$"/!D(E8*"B48(&8'(&*$#:#5'(%!!"#$%&$"/,($&($!()"!!$15'(
&"( %!!$4/( !".'( &*$#:#5'( *"B&'!( #"//'#&$/4( &8'( .B<
/$#$)%5( #'/&*'( &"( 1%*%/4%:( "*( 4*"G&8( #'/&*'!D( E8'( References
!&B2:(!B44'!&!(%55"G$/4(8%1%58%1%5(")'*%&$"/("/5:(
$/(."B/&%$/"B!(%*'%!(1B&(*'!&*$#&$/4(&8'.($/(&8'(%*< k- `RR=,(HD(HD(3'+"*.$/4($//'*<#$&:(1B!(&*%/!)"*&%&$"/(
'%!(G8'*'("&8'*(&*%/!)"*&(."2'!(%*'(%9%$5%15'D(E8$!( $/(%(2'9'5")$/4(#"B/&*:D(Journal of Public Transporta-
.%:( 4$9'( %( &G"<G%:( 1'/'?$&>( ."*'( 8%1%58%1%5( G$55( tion,(9D(T,(/D(T,()D(T<XL,(XZZ[D
1'(%9%$5%15'($/(8$55:(%*'%!(%/2(&8'(#"/?5$#&("+($/&'*<
`R60^,( OD( =$#:#5'!( "9'*&%;'!( 1B!'!( &*%9'5( $/( J%9%/%D(
'!&(G$&8("&8'*(&*%/!)"*&(."2'(")'*%&"*!(G$55(1'(.$<
The Urban Age,(9D(X,(/D(T,(TeeKD
/$.$!'2D(J"G'9'*,(&8$!(!8"B52(1'(2"/'(&8*"B48(&8'(
2*$9'*!g( %!!"#$%&$"/( "+( 9%*$"B!( ."2'!( G$&8( .B&B%5( = 3UR``,(QD('&(%5D(Rural transport in developing coun-
1$5%&'*%5(B/2'*!&%/2$/4D triesD( `"/2"/>( Q/&'*/%&$"/%5( E'#8/"5"4:( 6B15$#%&$"/!,(
E8'( !&B2:( *'#"..'/2!( +"55"G$/4( !)'#$?$'2( TeYMD
&$.'!("+(XZ(.$/B&'!($/&'*9%5(+"*('%!:*$2'(!'*9$#'!D(
= HR`QkR( 3R6n3ED( Baseline study report of Siquijor
E8'( !&B2:( +B*&8'*( !B44'!&!( &8%&( 1B!,( I'')/':,( %/2(
province. H$@B$I"*>( H$@B$I"*( Q/&'4*%&'2( 3'!"B*#'(
'%!:*$2'( !8"B52( +"55"G( !)'#$?$'2( &$.'( !#8'2B5'!D(
O%/%4'.'/&(6*"I'#&(t(HQ3O 6,(XZZXD(
J"G'9'*,( $+( &8'( 9'8$#5'( $!( +B55:( "##B)$'2( 1'+"*'(
&8'( !)'#$?$'2( &$.',( $&( .%:( 2')%*&( &8'( &'*.$/%5( $.< RPn`n]QP `( 63nmQ`RD( Ecological pro ile of Siquijor
.'2$%&'5:D( O"*'"9'*,( &8'( +*'@B'/&( !&"))$/4( "+( 1B!,( provinceD(H$@B$I"*>(y!D/Dz,(XZZKD
I'')/':,( %/2( '%!:*$2'( !8"B52( 1'( *'2B#'2( &"( 1'( $/(
]Rn]3 6JQP `( E` HD( Geographic atlas of SiquijorD
!)'#$?$'2( 5"#%&$"/!( "/5:D( E8'( .$/$.B.( !)%#$/4( "+(
6*"9$/#$%5(]"9'*/.'/&("+(H$@B$I"*,(XZZZD
!&")!(#"B52(1'(X(;.(+"*(1B!(%/2(I'')/':(%/2(T(;.(
+"*('%!:*$2',(G8'*'%!(&*$)!("+(5'!!(&8%/(T(;.(#"B52( ] lRkJRQOR3,( 3D( 0*1%/( ."1$5$&:( $/( &8'( 2'9'5")$/4(
1'(!'*9'2(1:(&*$#:#5'("*(G%5;$/4D( G"*52D( Transportation Research Part A - Policy &
6B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( "+( H$@B$I"*( ")'*%&'!( )*$9%&'5:( Practice,(9D(KK,(/D([jY,()D(N[T<NYe,(TeeeD
%/2( $/2$9$2B%55:( G$&8"B&( %/:( #""*2$/%&$"/( %."/4(
JnHH Qk,( OD( E8'( $!!B'!( %/2( *'%5$&$'!( "+( =3E( )5%/<
")'*%&"*!( "+( 2$++'*'/&( ."2'!( %/2( '9'/( G$&8$/( &8'(
/$/4($/$&$%&$9'!($/(2'9'5")$/4( !$%/(#$&$'!D(Journal of
."2'D( Q+( %( .$F&B*'( "+( 2$++'*'/&( ."2'!( "++'*( !8"*&<
Public Transportation, =3E(!)'#$%5('2$&$"/,()D(Ne<Y[,(
2$!&%/#'( &*%/!)"*&,( &8'$*( $/&'**'5%&$"/!8$)!( %*'(
XZZND
#*B#$%5(+"*(!'*9$#'(@B%5$&:(V60PJR3d(l03EJ,(TeeNd(

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012
72 RAHMAN, M. S. -U.

QU E ,( HD( -'9'5").'/&( %/2( !B!&%$/%1$5$&:( "+( )B15$#( 3 JO k,(OD(HD(0D(-'&'*.$/$/4(%))*")*$%&'()B15$#(&*%/!<


&*%/!)"*&%&$"/($/(H"B&8'%!&( !$%/(#$&$'!D( Journal of the )"*&( !:!&'.( 4$9'/( &8'( 5'9'5( "+( 2'9'5").'/&jB*1%/$_%<
Eastern Asian Society for Transportation Studies &$"/>(&8'(#%!'("+(H$@B$I"*()*"9$/#'D Q/>(Un3`-(Pnk]3RHH(
(EASTS),(9D(T,(/D(X,()D(ML[<MNL,(TeeMD( nm(E3 kH6n3E(3RHR 3PJ(t(UPE3,(TTD,(XZZ[D(Proceed-
ings{ P%5$+"*/$%>(UPE3,(XZZ[%D(V6%)'*(Q-(TKTWD
O P 3Qn,(3D(0)4*%2$/4(@B%5$&:($/(B*1%/(."1$5$&:(!:!&'.!D(
Managing Service Quality,( 9D( TT,( /D( X<N,( )D( H[L[<H[MK,( 3 JO k,( OD( HD( 0D( ( Household surveyD( H$@B$I"*,( XZZ[1D(
XZZTD 0/)B15$!8'2(!B*9':D

O 3PJREEQ,( PD( /&8*")"5"4$#%5( $/9%*$%/&!( $/( &*%9'5( 3 JO k,( OD( HD( 0D( ( ))*")*$%&'( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( !:!<
1'8%9$"B*D(Technical Forecasting and Social Change, &'.(+"*(1'&&'*('/9$*"/.'/&D(Q/>(]06E ,(lD(3D('&(%5D(VR2DWD(
9D(L[,(/D(T,()D([M<[Y,(TeeLD( Global environment problems and policiesD( k'G(
-'58$>( &5%/&$#( 6B15$!8'*!( %/2( -$!&*$1B&"*!,( 9D( K,( )D( eN<
OQE3QP,( HD( P*$!$!( %/2( *'#"9'*:>( B*1%/( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&D(
TZ[,(XZZYD((
Q/>(k EQnk `(3RHR 3PJ(Pn0kPQ`(<(E3 kH6n3E EQnk(
3RHR 3PJ( =n 3-D( Public transit research>( .%/%4'< 3nHPJ` 0,( OD( UD( Public transportation in the prov-
.'/&( %/2( )5%//$/4D( U%!8$/4&"/>( E*%/!)"*&( 3'!'%*#8( inces>( %( !&B2:( "+( $//"9%&$"/,( 2$++B!$"/( %/2( #"/?5$#&( $/(
="%*2,(TeeTD( &8'( 68$5$))$/'!D( P%/1'**%D( TeYMD( E8'!$!( V-"#&"*%&'(
$/( E*%/!)"*&%&$"/( ]'"4*%)8:W,( B!&*%5$%/( k%&$"/%5(
kRUO k,( 6D( UD( ]Dd( lRkUn3EJo,( 7D( 3D( Cities and auto-
0/$9'*!$&:,(TeYMD
mobile dependenceD( 52'*!8"&>(]"G'*,(TeYeD
HJRHlQk,( QD( OD( 3'5%&$"/!8$)( 1'&G''/( !B*9':'2( 1'<
k EQnk `(HE EQHEQPH(nmmQPR(t(kHnD(Census of popula-
8%9$"B*%5( $/&'/&( %/2( %#&B%5( 1'8%9$"B*( Q/>( k EQnk `(
tion and housing> H$@B$I"*D(3')"*&(k"DK<[M]>(!"#$"<'#"<
3RHR 3PJ( Pn0kPQ`( t( E3 kH6n3E EQnk( 3RHR 3PJ(
/".$#(%/2(2'."4*%)8$#(#8%*%#&'*$!&$#!D(O%/$5%>(k%&$"/%5(
=n 3-D( Public transport research>( .%/%4'.'/&( %/2(
H&%&$!&$#!(n+?$#',(XZZXD
)5%//$/4D( U%!8$/4&"/,( -D( PD>( E*%/!)"*&%&$"/( 3'!'%*#8(
63nsQkPQ `( 63nmQ`RD( Region VII> P'/&*%5( s$!%:%!D( ="%*2,(TeeTD
O%/$5%>(H$@B$I"*(6*"9$/#',(XZZZD
HQO6Hnk,(=D(7D(Urban public transport todayD(`"/2"/>(R(
63nsQkPQ `( 6JoHQP `( m3 ORUn3l( 6` k( t( 66m6D( |(mk(H)""/,(TeeLD
Provincial physical framework plan (PPFP) of
HQx0Q7n3( QkER]3 ER-( 3RHn03PR( O k ]RORkE(
SiquijorD( H$@B$I"*>( 6*"9$/#$%5( ]"9'*/.'/&( "+( H$@B$I"*,(
63n7RPE( t( HQ3O 6D( Road network and the exist-
XZZLD
ing route of easyride serviceD( H$@B$I"*>( 6*"9$/#$%5(
60PJR3,( 7Dd( l03EJ,( HD( s'*;'8*!9'*1B/2>( &8'( !B##'!!( ]"9'*/.'/&("+(H$@B$I"*,(XZZ[D(
"+( *'4$"/%5( )B15$#( &*%/!)"*&( $/( ]'*.%/:,( B!&*$%( %/2(
Un3`-( = klD( Development in practice>( !B!&%$/%15'(
HG$&_'*5%/2D( Transport Policy,( 9D( X,( /D( L,( )D( X[e<XeT,(
&*%/!)"*&D(U%8!$/4&"/,(-DPD>(E8'(U"*52(=%/;,(TeeND
TeeND

3 JO k,( OD( HD( 0D( m%#&"*!( $/?5B'/#$/4( &*%+?$#( 4'/'*%&$"/( Received>(ZLjZMjXZTT


$/(&8'(&"G/(#'/&*'("+(%(*'4$"/%5(#$&:>(%(!&B2:("/(l8B5/%( 3'#'1$2">(ZMjZLjXZTT
.'&*")"5$!( "+( =%/45%2'!8D( Jahangirnagar Planning
Review,(9D(T,()D(MT<NK,(XZZKD Approved>(TTjXXjXZTT
)*"9%2">(XXjTTjXZTT

urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana (Brazilian Journal of Urban Management), v. 4, n. 1, p. 61-72, jan./jun. 2012

Você também pode gostar