Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Reviso: 01
Identificao
DATA: 30 de maro de 2011
DESCRIO:
Esta anlise tem como objetivo verificar o comportamento estrutural do disco de freio na configurao
original e modificada para definir se o disco modificado est apto ou no para uso.
ELABORAO:
Pablo A. B. Silva
Engenheiro
Folha de reviso
REVISO: 01
DESCRIO:
DATA: 03/05/2011
ELABORAO:
Pablo A. B. Silva
Engenheiro
ndice
Contedo
Pgina
1 Objetivo: ................................................................................................. 5
2 Descrio:............................................................................................... 5
3 Resultados: .......................................................................................... 23
3.1 Anlise Trmica: .................................................................................................. 23
3.2 Anlise Esttica: .................................................................................................. 25
3.3 Anlise Modal: ..................................................................................................... 30
3.4 Anlise de Choque: ............................................................................................. 47
3.5 Anlise Randmica: ............................................................................................ 64
4 Comentrios: ........................................................................................ 76
5 Concluses: ......................................................................................... 77
6 Desenvolvimento: ................................................................................ 78
7 Referncias: ......................................................................................... 79
ndice de figuras
Figura
Pgina
1 Objetivo:
Esta anlise tem como objetivo verificar o comportamento estrutural do disco de freio na
configurao original e modificada para definir se o disco modificado est apto ou no para uso.
2 Descrio:
A anlise estrutural do disco de freio feita com base nos dados de operao fornecidos pela
Faiveley e na norma IEC 61373. As anlises contempladas nesta norma que caracterizam as condies
de trabalho do equipamento so as anlises randmicas (long life test) e de choque (shock testing
conditions).
A anlise estrutural executada atravs do mtodo dos elementos finitos com o programa
COSMOS, sendo os desenhos utilizados como referncia fornecidos pela Faiveley.
66 GPa
0,27
7.200 kg/m
240 MPa
Fig 2.2 - Variao do coeficiente de condutividade trmica [W/(m C)] x temperatura [C].
Fig 2.4 - Variao do coeficiente de dilatao trmica [10-6 C-1] x temperatura [C].
CARREGAMENTOS CONSIDERADOS:
Os carregamentos considerados so os seguintes:
Carregamento trmico
O processo de caldeamento envolve a unio de duas peas de mesmo material ou materiais
diferentes, atravs da aplicao simultnea de temperatura e presso.
Desse modo, ocorre um processo de fuso localizada na juno de duas peas. Essa fuso torna o
contato perfeito, eliminando praticamente a resistncia de contato. No caso em questo, essa
hiptese ainda mais realista, visto que se trata de duas peas de materiais com composio muito
parecida (ao e ferro fundido, que so basicamente ligas F-C, onde o ferro ultrapassa o teor de
90%). Isso garante que, aps algum tempo, mesmo nos setores onde a fuso no ocorreu totalmente,
a difuso deve garantir a unio.
Conforme anlise trmica realizada anteriormente (ref. 7.5 e 7.6), a maior temperatura alcanada
pelo disco acontece quando se considera uma viagem de ida e volta apenas com frenagens de atrito,
seguida de uma aplicao de emergncia.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
Freio de
Emergncia
15 s
Freio de
Servio
18,5 s
27,5 kN
22 kN
41,8 kN
33,4 kN
Fig 2.5 - Fluxo de calor (kW/m) por tempo (s) Percurso de ida e volta.
Fora normal por pastilha
considerada a carga normal mxima por pastilha de freio. Esta carga aplicada como presso na
regio onde ocorre o contato da pastilha com o disco.
Os dados utilizados para o clculo so os seguintes:
Item
Freio de
Emergncia
27,5 kN
Freio de
Servio
22 kN
41,8 kN
33,4 kN
350 cm2
350 cm2
10
Fora de frenagem
considerada a fora de frenagem tangente mxima no disco. Esta fora aplicada nas paredes do
disco, na regio onde h contato com a pastilha.
Os dados utilizados para o clculo so os seguintes:
Item
FF mnima => Fora Frenagem tangente no Disco, sobre o
dimetro de frenagem de 482,6 mm, para desacelerao
mnima (1,2 m/s2 freio serv. e 1,5 freio emerg.)
FF mxima => Fora Frenagem tangente no Disco com
desacelerao mxima (1,44 m/s2 freio serv. e 1,8 freio
emerg.)
Freio de
Emergncia
10,45 kN
Freio de
Servio
8,36 kN
12,54 kN
10,03 kN
Descrio
Carregamento referente s temperaturas em cada n no momento em que
se atinge a temperatura mxima.
Fora Normal
Fora tangente
Velocidade Angular
Para a anlise de choque e vibrao ao longo da via considerado um modelo para cada uma das
condies a seguir:
Carregamentos dinmicos de choque (ref. 7.4):
a)
b)
c)
d)
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
11
PSD Acc
Em 10 Hz
20-100 Hz
Em 500 Hz
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
12
ASDh
=
ASDl fl
Fig 2.7 - Carregamento randmico [Y, vertical] Excitao de base Grfico dilog.
13
Fig 2.8 - Carregamento randmico [X, transversal] Excitao de base Grfico dilog.
Fig 2.9 - Carregamento randmico [Z, longitudinal] Excitao de base Grfico dilog.
14
15
16
17
18
Fig 2.17 - Detalhe dos ns selecionados (resposta dinmica) Modelo com a configurao original.
Fig 2.18 - Detalhe dos ns selecionados (resposta dinmica) Modelo com a configurao
modificada.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
19
Fig 2.19 - Modelo de elementos finitos Carregamento trmico Conveco atravs da estrutura do
disco.
Fig 2.20 - Modelo de elementos finitos Detalhe da conveco atravs da estrutura do disco.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
20
Fig 2.21 - Modelo de elementos finitos Carregamento trmico Fluxo aplicado nas faces.
Fig 2.22 - Modelo de elementos finitos Detalhe do fluxo aplicado nas faces.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
21
22
3 Resultados:
3.1 Anlise Trmica:
Os principais resultados obtidos na anlise trmica podem ser vistos nas tabelas e figuras a
seguir:
23
MODELO ORIGINAL
24
Tenso de
Escoamento [MPa]
Tenso Admissvel
[MPa]
Tenso mxima
Von Mises [MPa]
Configurao
original
219,2
175,4
222,7
Configurao
modificada
219,2
175,4
224,7
25
MODELO ORIGINAL
Fig 3.2.2 - Tenses (Von Mises) limitadas em 175,4 MPa Modelo com geometria original.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
26
Fig 3.2.3 - Tenses (Von Mises) Detalhe - Modelo com geometria original.
Fig 3.2.4 - Tenses (Von Mises) limitadas em 175,4 MPa Cubo - Modelo com geometria original.
27
MODELO MODIFICADO
Fig 3.2.6 - Tenses (Von Mises) limitadas em 175,4 MPa Modelo com geometria modificada.
CEMEF Engenharia e Consultoria
Av. Alfredo Penido, 305/1204 - S.J.Campos SP-12246/000 Tel (0__12) 3923-1668 Fax (0__12) 3921-5902
Home Page: http://www.cemef.com.br E-mail cemef@cemef.com.br
28
Fig 3.2.7 - Tenses (Von Mises) Detalhe - Modelo com geometria modificada.
Fig 3.2.8 - Tenses (Von Mises) limitadas em 175,4 MPa Cubo - Modelo com geometria
modificada.
29
A seguir podem ser visualizadas as figuras referentes deformao do disco, que semelhante
para ambas as configuraes:
30
31
32
FREQUENCY
NUMBER
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
FREQUENCY
(RAD/SEC)
0.1520931E+04
0.1522558E+04
0.2696254E+04
0.2710076E+04
0.3142714E+04
0.4507984E+04
0.5062107E+04
0.5063806E+04
0.6033071E+04
0.6036049E+04
0.6850713E+04
0.7293491E+04
0.7490415E+04
0.7506550E+04
0.8320519E+04
0.9082545E+04
0.9092550E+04
0.9630328E+04
0.9631379E+04
0.1102939E+05
0.1126815E+05
0.1129487E+05
0.1150109E+05
0.1152781E+05
0.1199773E+05
0.1200226E+05
0.1314141E+05
0.1357311E+05
0.1373130E+05
0.1374805E+05
0.1512726E+05
0.1513798E+05
0.1540441E+05
0.1540675E+05
0.1608663E+05
0.1678639E+05
0.1679093E+05
0.1679882E+05
FREQUENCY
(CYCLES/SEC)
0.2420636E+03
0.2423227E+03
0.4291222E+03
0.4313220E+03
0.5001784E+03
0.7174680E+03
0.8056594E+03
0.8059298E+03
0.9601930E+03
0.9606670E+03
0.1090325E+04
0.1160795E+04
0.1192137E+04
0.1194704E+04
0.1324252E+04
0.1445532E+04
0.1447124E+04
0.1532714E+04
0.1532882E+04
0.1755382E+04
0.1793382E+04
0.1797635E+04
0.1830455E+04
0.1834708E+04
0.1909498E+04
0.1910219E+04
0.2091521E+04
0.2160228E+04
0.2185404E+04
0.2188070E+04
0.2407579E+04
0.2409285E+04
0.2451688E+04
0.2452060E+04
0.2560267E+04
0.2671637E+04
0.2672359E+04
0.2673616E+04
PERIOD
(SECONDS)
0.4131145E-02
0.4126729E-02
0.2330339E-02
0.2318453E-02
0.1999287E-02
0.1393790E-02
0.1241219E-02
0.1240803E-02
0.1041457E-02
0.1040943E-02
0.9171579E-03
0.8614785E-03
0.8388301E-03
0.8370271E-03
0.7551435E-03
0.6917869E-03
0.6910257E-03
0.6524373E-03
0.6523661E-03
0.5696766E-03
0.5576058E-03
0.5562866E-03
0.5463122E-03
0.5450460E-03
0.5236979E-03
0.5235001E-03
0.4781210E-03
0.4629141E-03
0.4575812E-03
0.4570237E-03
0.4153550E-03
0.4150609E-03
0.4078822E-03
0.4078204E-03
0.3905843E-03
0.3743024E-03
0.3742012E-03
0.3740254E-03
33
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
0.1722945E+05
0.1730410E+05
0.1779312E+05
0.1806862E+05
0.1932011E+05
0.1932327E+05
0.2005663E+05
0.2062137E+05
0.2098046E+05
0.2118116E+05
0.2119212E+05
0.2219726E+05
0.2220063E+05
0.2239369E+05
0.2240658E+05
0.2420736E+05
0.2457916E+05
0.2465967E+05
0.2469003E+05
0.2479046E+05
0.2480290E+05
0.2527153E+05
0.2529883E+05
0.2544537E+05
0.2583641E+05
0.2593480E+05
0.2594972E+05
0.2619337E+05
0.2623293E+05
0.2625433E+05
0.2627393E+05
0.2628468E+05
0.2628828E+05
0.2629449E+05
0.2633916E+05
0.2635615E+05
0.2637352E+05
0.2638057E+05
0.2640603E+05
0.2641754E+05
0.2642550E+05
0.2642892E+05
0.2645217E+05
0.2645810E+05
0.2646985E+05
0.2647529E+05
0.2649788E+05
0.2652999E+05
0.2654277E+05
0.2656740E+05
0.2657097E+05
0.2659088E+05
0.2660428E+05
0.2662055E+05
0.2663305E+05
0.2663820E+05
0.2666901E+05
0.2667616E+05
0.2667671E+05
0.2668805E+05
0.2669703E+05
0.2669865E+05
0.2742152E+04
0.2754032E+04
0.2831863E+04
0.2875710E+04
0.3074890E+04
0.3075394E+04
0.3192112E+04
0.3281993E+04
0.3339144E+04
0.3371086E+04
0.3372830E+04
0.3532803E+04
0.3533340E+04
0.3564066E+04
0.3566118E+04
0.3852721E+04
0.3911895E+04
0.3924709E+04
0.3929540E+04
0.3945524E+04
0.3947504E+04
0.4022089E+04
0.4026433E+04
0.4049756E+04
0.4111992E+04
0.4127652E+04
0.4130026E+04
0.4168804E+04
0.4175100E+04
0.4178506E+04
0.4181626E+04
0.4183336E+04
0.4183909E+04
0.4184898E+04
0.4192008E+04
0.4194711E+04
0.4197476E+04
0.4198599E+04
0.4202651E+04
0.4204482E+04
0.4205749E+04
0.4206294E+04
0.4209993E+04
0.4210938E+04
0.4212807E+04
0.4213674E+04
0.4217268E+04
0.4222379E+04
0.4224413E+04
0.4228333E+04
0.4228901E+04
0.4232069E+04
0.4234202E+04
0.4236793E+04
0.4238781E+04
0.4239601E+04
0.4244505E+04
0.4245642E+04
0.4245730E+04
0.4247535E+04
0.4248963E+04
0.4249221E+04
0.3646770E-03
0.3631039E-03
0.3531245E-03
0.3477402E-03
0.3252149E-03
0.3251616E-03
0.3132722E-03
0.3046929E-03
0.2994779E-03
0.2966403E-03
0.2964869E-03
0.2830613E-03
0.2830183E-03
0.2805784E-03
0.2804169E-03
0.2595568E-03
0.2556306E-03
0.2547960E-03
0.2544827E-03
0.2534518E-03
0.2533246E-03
0.2486270E-03
0.2483588E-03
0.2469284E-03
0.2431911E-03
0.2422685E-03
0.2421292E-03
0.2398770E-03
0.2395152E-03
0.2393200E-03
0.2391414E-03
0.2390437E-03
0.2390109E-03
0.2389545E-03
0.2385492E-03
0.2383954E-03
0.2382384E-03
0.2381747E-03
0.2379451E-03
0.2378415E-03
0.2377698E-03
0.2377390E-03
0.2375301E-03
0.2374768E-03
0.2373714E-03
0.2373226E-03
0.2371203E-03
0.2368333E-03
0.2367193E-03
0.2364998E-03
0.2364681E-03
0.2362910E-03
0.2361720E-03
0.2360276E-03
0.2359169E-03
0.2358712E-03
0.2355988E-03
0.2355356E-03
0.2355307E-03
0.2354306E-03
0.2353515E-03
0.2353372E-03
34
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
Mx
---MASS
0.511E-08
0.253E-06
0.692E-06
0.513E-06
0.378E-06
0.730
0.650E-05
0.674E-06
0.189E-05
0.819E-06
0.737E-07
0.543E-06
0.240E-06
0.175E-06
0.448E-07
0.492E-07
0.652E-09
0.938E-08
0.670E-08
0.579E-06
0.354E-07
0.375E-06
0.101E-06
0.829E-08
0.113E-05
0.248E-06
0.782E-01
0.342E-01
0.840E-05
0.351E-05
0.182E-05
0.129E-06
0.510E-06
0.174E-06
0.808E-04
0.242E-06
0.172E-08
0.122E-08
0.169E-05
0.279E-07
0.143E-06
0.744E-06
0.124E-07
0.471E-07
0.225E-05
0.129E-06
0.106E-07
0.711E-09
0.235E-08
0.239E-07
0.345E-07
My
---MASS
0.161
0.467E-01
0.550E-06
0.328E-06
0.455E-05
0.220E-06
0.218E-05
0.491E-06
0.739E-01
0.601
0.598E-06
0.166E-09
0.168E-04
0.106E-05
0.250E-05
0.345E-08
0.217E-08
0.209E-02
0.283E-01
0.117E-04
0.886E-07
0.706E-07
0.133E-07
0.310E-07
0.159E-08
0.130E-07
0.192E-09
0.352E-09
0.822E-07
0.219E-07
0.812E-07
0.132E-05
0.381E-03
0.144E-02
0.124E-06
0.334E-03
0.320E-02
0.211E-03
0.131E-07
0.491E-08
0.120E-05
0.293E-06
0.297E-04
0.710E-05
0.802E-06
0.695E-08
0.544E-08
0.438E-09
0.639E-09
0.574E-08
0.111E-07
Cum. Mx
------MASS
0.466E-01
0.161
0.385E-06
0.354E-06
0.113E-07
0.329E-05
0.210E-06
0.174E-04
0.601
0.739E-01
0.607E-06
0.489E-05
0.519E-06
0.451E-06
0.151E-07
0.187E-05
0.428E-07
0.281E-01
0.201E-02
0.186E-05
0.495E-07
0.357E-06
0.233E-08
0.104E-05
0.654E-09
0.445E-07
0.119E-09
0.142E-06
0.613E-08
0.116E-05
0.123E-05
0.510E-06
0.143E-02
0.381E-03
0.847E-07
0.340E-02
0.317E-03
0.222E-04
0.163E-07
0.376E-06
0.948E-05
0.546E-06
0.758E-05
0.298E-04
0.665E-08
0.187E-09
0.579E-09
0.642E-08
0.929E-07
0.212E-08
0.768E-10
Cum. My
------MASS
0.511E-08
0.258E-06
0.951E-06
0.146E-05
0.184E-05
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.730
0.809
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.161
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.281
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.885
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.915
0.915
0.915
0.918
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
Cum. Mz
------MASS
0.466E-01
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.208
0.809
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.883
0.911
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.913
0.915
0.915
0.915
0.918
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
35
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
0.559E-08
0.154E-08
0.348E-07
0.186E-07
0.194E-07
0.722E-08
0.157E-09
0.157E-08
0.118E-07
0.118E-07
0.251E-06
0.210E-06
0.784E-08
0.385E-07
0.215E-08
0.926E-07
0.919E-07
0.104E-08
0.734E-09
0.397E-09
0.302E-06
0.485E-08
0.212E-07
0.891E-07
0.264E-06
0.908E-07
0.412E-08
0.236E-06
0.401E-08
0.216E-06
0.238E-06
0.144E-07
0.170E-07
0.268E-06
0.833E-05
0.345E-06
0.338E-04
0.386E-07
0.709E-06
0.380E-08
0.860E-06
0.109E-07
0.123E-05
0.711E-07
0.503E-06
0.204E-08
0.576E-07
0.463E-08
0.178E-06
0.105E-08
0.444E-10
0.832E-08
0.187E-05
0.902E-06
0.151E-05
0.699E-07
0.940E-09
0.314E-06
0.675E-07
0.123E-05
0.278E-04
0.830E-06
0.257E-09
0.287E-08
0.881E-07
0.162E-07
0.261E-08
0.824E-07
0.802E-09
0.773E-07
0.482E-09
0.258E-07
0.994E-07
0.175E-06
0.225E-07
0.321E-09
0.176E-06
0.192E-07
0.207E-07
0.224E-07
0.617E-07
0.120E-06
0.808E-11
0.723E-06
0.656E-07
0.226E-05
0.178E-07
0.114E-06
0.133E-09
0.139E-06
0.193E-09
0.831E-07
0.344E-07
0.787E-07
0.830E-08
0.194E-07
0.125E-07
0.605E-09
0.332E-09
0.465E-08
0.133E-06
0.155E-05
0.381E-06
0.161E-05
0.746E-07
0.116E-06
0.294E-05
0.772E-06
0.274E-04
0.663E-06
0.238E-07
0.674E-08
0.244E-07
0.202E-09
0.231E-06
0.190E-10
0.777E-07
0.106E-09
0.648E-08
0.818E-07
0.189E-07
0.247E-07
0.959E-08
0.206E-11
0.386E-07
0.692E-08
0.351E-09
0.209E-07
0.687E-08
0.515E-08
0.244E-07
0.341E-08
0.596E-07
0.555E-07
0.252E-06
0.115E-08
0.159E-07
0.133E-09
0.348E-08
0.236E-07
0.185E-06
0.306E-08
0.325E-08
0.791E-09
0.332E-07
0.147E-07
0.275E-08
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.843
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.919
0.843
0.919
0.919
36
37
38
FREQUENCY
NUMBER
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
FREQUENCY
(RAD/SEC)
0.1486399E+04
0.1489232E+04
0.2664326E+04
0.2676886E+04
0.3148130E+04
0.4476053E+04
0.5018440E+04
0.5018724E+04
0.6033290E+04
0.6035873E+04
0.6771677E+04
0.7225256E+04
0.7469366E+04
0.7480737E+04
0.8347969E+04
0.8998094E+04
0.9006810E+04
0.9461696E+04
0.9467789E+04
FREQUENCY
(CYCLES/SEC)
0.2365677E+03
0.2370186E+03
0.4240407E+03
0.4260397E+03
0.5010405E+03
0.7123859E+03
0.7987096E+03
0.7987548E+03
0.9602278E+03
0.9606390E+03
0.1077746E+04
0.1149935E+04
0.1188787E+04
0.1190596E+04
0.1328620E+04
0.1432091E+04
0.1433478E+04
0.1505876E+04
0.1506845E+04
PERIOD
(SECONDS)
0.4227120E-02
0.4219079E-02
0.2358264E-02
0.2347199E-02
0.1995847E-02
0.1403734E-02
0.1252020E-02
0.1251949E-02
0.1041420E-02
0.1040974E-02
0.9278626E-03
0.8696142E-03
0.8411939E-03
0.8399153E-03
0.7526604E-03
0.6982796E-03
0.6976038E-03
0.6640654E-03
0.6636381E-03
39
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
0.1100732E+05
0.1114033E+05
0.1117916E+05
0.1131699E+05
0.1132281E+05
0.1187224E+05
0.1187552E+05
0.1296774E+05
0.1336733E+05
0.1366339E+05
0.1367473E+05
0.1499132E+05
0.1499319E+05
0.1535757E+05
0.1535966E+05
0.1602794E+05
0.1666028E+05
0.1666247E+05
0.1674453E+05
0.1704062E+05
0.1716929E+05
0.1762499E+05
0.1778694E+05
0.1927517E+05
0.1929147E+05
0.1971357E+05
0.2052782E+05
0.2090226E+05
0.2124086E+05
0.2125034E+05
0.2217688E+05
0.2217963E+05
0.2224516E+05
0.2225035E+05
0.2404070E+05
0.2430131E+05
0.2459624E+05
0.2461952E+05
0.2501824E+05
0.2503040E+05
0.2528665E+05
0.2529987E+05
0.2575310E+05
0.2614862E+05
0.2624286E+05
0.2629788E+05
0.2643682E+05
0.2663089E+05
0.2665191E+05
0.2670360E+05
0.2671312E+05
0.2672116E+05
0.2672960E+05
0.2674107E+05
0.2674569E+05
0.2675763E+05
0.2677677E+05
0.2678752E+05
0.2679451E+05
0.2680774E+05
0.2682924E+05
0.2684133E+05
0.1751869E+04
0.1773039E+04
0.1779219E+04
0.1801155E+04
0.1802080E+04
0.1889526E+04
0.1890047E+04
0.2063881E+04
0.2127476E+04
0.2174596E+04
0.2176400E+04
0.2385942E+04
0.2386240E+04
0.2444233E+04
0.2444566E+04
0.2550926E+04
0.2651565E+04
0.2651914E+04
0.2664975E+04
0.2712098E+04
0.2732577E+04
0.2805105E+04
0.2830880E+04
0.3067739E+04
0.3070332E+04
0.3137511E+04
0.3267104E+04
0.3326698E+04
0.3380587E+04
0.3382096E+04
0.3529561E+04
0.3529998E+04
0.3540427E+04
0.3541253E+04
0.3826196E+04
0.3867674E+04
0.3914613E+04
0.3918318E+04
0.3981777E+04
0.3983712E+04
0.4024495E+04
0.4026600E+04
0.4098733E+04
0.4161682E+04
0.4176680E+04
0.4185438E+04
0.4207550E+04
0.4238438E+04
0.4241784E+04
0.4250010E+04
0.4251525E+04
0.4252805E+04
0.4254148E+04
0.4255973E+04
0.4256709E+04
0.4258610E+04
0.4261655E+04
0.4263366E+04
0.4264478E+04
0.4266584E+04
0.4270006E+04
0.4271930E+04
0.5708189E-03
0.5640033E-03
0.5620444E-03
0.5551992E-03
0.5549142E-03
0.5292334E-03
0.5290873E-03
0.4845242E-03
0.4700406E-03
0.4598555E-03
0.4594743E-03
0.4191216E-03
0.4190694E-03
0.4091263E-03
0.4090705E-03
0.3920145E-03
0.3771357E-03
0.3770861E-03
0.3752380E-03
0.3687182E-03
0.3659549E-03
0.3564929E-03
0.3532470E-03
0.3259730E-03
0.3256977E-03
0.3187240E-03
0.3060814E-03
0.3005984E-03
0.2958066E-03
0.2956746E-03
0.2833214E-03
0.2832863E-03
0.2824518E-03
0.2823859E-03
0.2613562E-03
0.2585533E-03
0.2554531E-03
0.2552115E-03
0.2511441E-03
0.2510222E-03
0.2484784E-03
0.2483485E-03
0.2439778E-03
0.2402875E-03
0.2394246E-03
0.2389236E-03
0.2376680E-03
0.2359360E-03
0.2357499E-03
0.2352936E-03
0.2352097E-03
0.2351389E-03
0.2350647E-03
0.2349639E-03
0.2349233E-03
0.2348184E-03
0.2346506E-03
0.2345564E-03
0.2344953E-03
0.2343795E-03
0.2341917E-03
0.2340862E-03
40
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
0.2684414E+05
0.2685950E+05
0.2686463E+05
0.2686818E+05
0.2687719E+05
0.2688326E+05
0.2688876E+05
0.2688965E+05
0.2690424E+05
0.2691749E+05
0.2693741E+05
0.2693896E+05
0.2694676E+05
0.2694931E+05
0.2696116E+05
0.2697050E+05
0.2697721E+05
0.2698959E+05
0.2702618E+05
0.4272377E+04
0.4274822E+04
0.4275638E+04
0.4276204E+04
0.4277638E+04
0.4278603E+04
0.4279479E+04
0.4279621E+04
0.4281942E+04
0.4284051E+04
0.4287222E+04
0.4287468E+04
0.4288710E+04
0.4289116E+04
0.4291002E+04
0.4292488E+04
0.4293557E+04
0.4295527E+04
0.4301350E+04
0.2340617E-03
0.2339279E-03
0.2338832E-03
0.2338523E-03
0.2337739E-03
0.2337211E-03
0.2336733E-03
0.2336656E-03
0.2335389E-03
0.2334239E-03
0.2332513E-03
0.2332379E-03
0.2331703E-03
0.2331483E-03
0.2330458E-03
0.2329651E-03
0.2329071E-03
0.2328003E-03
0.2324852E-03
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Mx
---MASS
0.906E-07
0.331E-07
0.325E-06
0.161E-06
0.810E-06
0.739
0.201E-06
0.152E-03
0.321E-07
0.645E-06
0.350E-07
0.337E-06
0.410E-07
0.949E-08
0.293E-08
0.117E-07
0.253E-08
0.556E-09
0.186E-07
0.399E-07
0.132E-06
0.253E-06
0.304E-06
0.505E-06
0.283E-06
0.199E-05
0.101
0.496E-02
0.120E-05
0.737E-06
0.569E-06
My
---MASS
0.180
0.293E-01
0.548E-05
0.683E-07
0.134E-07
0.107E-05
0.183E-05
0.118E-06
0.182E-01
0.650
0.125E-08
0.277E-05
0.521E-04
0.219E-05
0.242E-07
0.669E-06
0.183E-05
0.317E-01
0.286E-02
0.209E-05
0.820E-07
0.107E-07
0.230E-07
0.224E-11
0.858E-08
0.660E-07
0.951E-08
0.767E-08
0.282E-06
0.289E-07
0.642E-07
Cum. Mx
------MASS
0.292E-01
0.180
0.466E-06
0.520E-05
0.630E-07
0.153E-07
0.600E-05
0.455E-05
0.650
0.182E-01
0.172E-04
0.527E-05
0.203E-05
0.332E-04
0.206E-07
0.209E-07
0.169E-07
0.292E-02
0.315E-01
0.662E-06
0.141E-07
0.450E-07
0.477E-07
0.492E-07
0.107E-07
0.424E-08
0.271E-10
0.689E-08
0.156E-08
0.139E-05
0.758E-06
Cum. My
------MASS
0.906E-07
0.124E-06
0.448E-06
0.609E-06
0.142E-05
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.739
0.841
0.845
0.845
0.845
0.845
0.180
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.228
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.909
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
Cum. Mz
------MASS
0.292E-01
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.209
0.860
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.878
0.881
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
0.912
41
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
0.363E-06
0.296E-07
0.861E-08
0.456E-04
0.934E-08
0.220E-08
0.221E-08
0.557E-06
0.589E-07
0.805E-06
0.246E-07
0.152E-07
0.361E-07
0.231E-07
0.135E-06
0.124E-08
0.422E-09
0.269E-08
0.389E-07
0.230E-07
0.110E-07
0.135E-08
0.896E-06
0.121E-08
0.825E-08
0.834E-07
0.194E-08
0.107E-07
0.173E-08
0.365E-09
0.113E-07
0.115E-05
0.113E-07
0.193E-07
0.252E-04
0.762E-07
0.107E-06
0.121E-06
0.540E-07
0.258E-10
0.772E-07
0.103E-07
0.292E-07
0.434E-07
0.551E-08
0.442E-12
0.387E-09
0.119E-07
0.278E-07
0.819E-09
0.683E-07
0.376E-07
0.115E-06
0.103E-07
0.408E-07
0.986E-11
0.713E-07
0.174E-08
0.260E-07
0.108E-08
0.966E-07
0.213E-07
0.187E-06
0.210E-02
0.500E-04
0.127E-06
0.168E-02
0.202E-02
0.951E-06
0.120E-07
0.614E-08
0.159E-06
0.248E-08
0.104E-04
0.269E-04
0.792E-06
0.375E-08
0.177E-07
0.471E-09
0.255E-08
0.135E-09
0.704E-08
0.798E-10
0.283E-08
0.169E-06
0.231E-06
0.300E-07
0.128E-07
0.585E-07
0.697E-08
0.512E-07
0.261E-07
0.123E-05
0.213E-04
0.178E-06
0.969E-07
0.425E-05
0.203E-06
0.417E-07
0.108E-07
0.171E-07
0.104E-06
0.680E-11
0.144E-07
0.117E-07
0.140E-08
0.113E-07
0.415E-08
0.176E-07
0.830E-13
0.233E-07
0.441E-07
0.207E-07
0.264E-07
0.129E-06
0.977E-07
0.303E-08
0.210E-07
0.139E-07
0.904E-07
0.483E-08
0.155E-07
0.131E-06
0.116E-06
0.411E-06
0.493E-04
0.207E-02
0.277E-06
0.201E-02
0.169E-02
0.721E-08
0.687E-08
0.219E-06
0.515E-05
0.101E-06
0.261E-04
0.102E-04
0.361E-07
0.125E-07
0.379E-07
0.123E-07
0.245E-08
0.177E-08
0.112E-07
0.164E-07
0.281E-07
0.550E-06
0.117E-05
0.130E-07
0.115E-06
0.467E-07
0.930E-07
0.601E-06
0.162E-07
0.188E-04
0.984E-06
0.682E-08
0.151E-08
0.202E-05
0.101E-06
0.194E-06
0.122E-07
0.136E-08
0.683E-09
0.203E-08
0.115E-07
0.771E-10
0.148E-08
0.322E-09
0.214E-08
0.935E-09
0.285E-07
0.576E-07
0.901E-08
0.171E-06
0.157E-07
0.169E-07
0.112E-06
0.160E-07
0.251E-07
0.135E-07
0.976E-07
0.243E-07
0.834E-07
0.237E-07
0.445E-08
0.845
0.845
0.845
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.912
0.914
0.914
0.914
0.916
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.912
0.912
0.914
0.914
0.916
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
42
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
0.105E-06
0.769E-08
0.629E-07
0.769E-07
0.723E-10
0.842E-07
0.107E-07
0.463E-08
0.355E-09
0.164E-07
0.335E-09
0.707E-07
0.323E-07
0.601E-08
0.289E-07
0.845E-08
0.277E-09
0.194E-06
0.457E-08
0.656E-08
0.550E-10
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.846
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.918
0.846
0.918
0.918
43
44
45
242,1
236,6
2 Modo
242,3
237,0
6 Modo
717,5
712,4
9 Modo
960,2
960,2
10 Modo
960,7
960,6
46
Choque X
Choque Y
Choque Z
Tempo da
mxima
resposta
(ms)
17,6
18,1
18,1
Fig 3.4.1 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque X (tempo = 0,0176 s).
47
Fig 3.4.3 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque Y (tempo = 0,0181 s).
48
Fig 3.4.5 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque Z (tempo = 0,0181 s).
49
50
51
52
53
54
MODELO MODIFICADO
Choque X
Choque Y
Choque Z
Tempo da
mxima
resposta
(ms)
17,6
18,1
18,1
Fig 3.4.16 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque X (tempo = 0,0176 s).
55
Fig 3.4.18 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque Y (tempo = 0,0181 s).
56
Fig 3.4.20 - Tenses Von Mises [Pa] Choque Z (tempo = 0,0181 s).
57
58
59
60
61
62
Choque X
Choque Y
Choque Z
Configurao Modificada
Mxima tenso
(Von Mises) [MPa]
Mximo
deslocamento
resultante [mm]
Mxima tenso
(Von Mises) [MPa]
Mximo
deslocamento
resultante [mm]
23,2
0,07
23,4
0,07
50,7
0,63
62,3
0,67
54,6
0,63
59,3
0,67
63
Random (y)
0,4 mm
Random (z)
0,2 mm
Random (y)
RMS = 36,5 MPa
3,0 RMS = 109,5 MPa
Random (z)
RMS = 15,1 MPa
3,0 RMS = 45,3 MPa
64
65
66
67
68
Random (y)
Random (z)
0,02 mm
0,5 mm
0,2 mm
Random (y)
RMS = 39,3 MPa
3,0 RMS = 117,9 MPa
Random (z)
RMS = 17,1 MPa
3,0 RMS = 51,3 MPa
69
70
71
72
73
Configurao Modificada
Mxima tenso
Mxima tenso
Mximo deslocamento
(Von Mises
(Von Mises
resultante (Valor 3xRMS)
valor 3xRMS)
valor 3xRMS)
[mm]
[MPa]
[MPa]
Random X
Random Y
Random Z
16,8
109,5
45,3
0,06
1,2
0,6
16,8
117,9
51,3
Mximo deslocamento
resultante (Valor 3xRMS)
[mm]
0,06
1,5
0,6
74
Carregamento
Tenso
Tenso
mxima (Von Margem de mxima (Von Margem de
Tenso
Admissvel Mises) [MPa] segurana Mises) [MPa] segurana
[MPa]
[%]
[%]
Configurao
Configurao
modificada
original
Cargas trmicas
175,4
214,6
Fora normal
Fora tangente
175,4
175,4
Velocidade angular
175,4
24,0
12,9
6,3
Direo X
Choque
Direo Y
Direo Z
Random X
Randmica Random Y
Random Z
175,4
175,4
175,4
175,4
175,4
175,4
23,2
50,7
54,6
16,8
109,5
45,3
Ver item
5.2
217,0
Ver item
5.2
86
93
24,8
15,9
86
91
96
6,4
96
87
71
69
90
38
74
23,4
62,3
59,3
16,8
117,9
51,3
87
64
66
90
33
71
( admissvel mximo )
admissvel
Onde:
Ms = Margem de segurana
admissvel = Tenso admissvel
mxima = Tenso mxima encontrada
75
4 Comentrios:
4.1 -
4.2 -
4.3 -
4.4 -
Os valores RMS obtidas nas anlises randmicas so multiplicados por 3,0 de forma a
garantirem-se valores reais inferiores a (3,0 x RMS) ocorrendo em mais de 99,7% do tempo.
4.5 -
So efetuadas anlises estticas com as cargas mecnicas e trmicas atuando isoladamente para
fins de comparao. Nestas pode-se perceber que as tenses elevadas (acima dos valores
admissveis e mesmo do escoamento) so causadas pelo efeito trmico isolado. Para os outros
carregamentos mecnicos no so encontradas tenses superiores aos valores admissveis.
76
5 Concluses:
5.1 -
5.2 -
5.3 -
5.4 -
5.5 -
5.6 -
Com exceo do carregamento trmico (ver item 5.2), todas as margens de segurana so
aceitveis (conforme tabela 3.6.1).
77
6 Desenvolvimento:
No modelo principal executado so utilizados elementos slidos (TETRA4R) todos com quatro
graus de liberdade por n.
MODELO ORIGINAL
Total de ns: 17870
Total de elementos: 62600
MODELO MODIFICADO
Total de ns: 18488
Total de elementos: 64161
Arquivos:
DISCO_ORIGINAL_INTEIRO_SEM_GAP.gen
DISCO_MODIFICADO_INTEIRO_SEM_GAP.gen
MODAL_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
MODAL_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K_FINAL.gen
CHOQUE_X_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
CHOQUE_Y_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
CHOQUE_Z_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
CHOQUE_X_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
CHOQUE_Y_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
CHOQUE_Z_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_X_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_Y_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_Z_DISCO_ORIGINAL_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_X_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_Y_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
RANDOMICA_Z_DISCO_MODIFICADO_128K.gen
78
7 Referncias:
7.1
7.2
7.3
Normas AISC.
7.4
7.5
7.6
Documento ECT-BR07162_Rev00.
7.7
Documento ECE-BR07162_Rev00.
7.8
Documento CT-BR07091_Rev01.
7.9
Normas ASME.
79