Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1
MSc, Professor, Universidad Pedagógica Nacional, Bogotá, Colombia.
2
PhD, Professor, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, Universidade de São Paulo, WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research
Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil.
Correspondence
Marlene Fagundes Carvalho Gonçalves
Universidade de São Paulo. Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto
Departamento de Enfermagem Psiquiátrica e Ciências Humanas
Av. Bandeirantes, 3900
Bairro: Monte Alegre
CEP: 14040-902, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brasil
E-mail: mgoncalves@eerp.usp.br
Castaño-Peñuela AM, Gonçalves MFC. 127
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
SMAD, Rev. Eletrônica Saúde Mental Álcool Drog. Sept.-Dec. 2014;10(3):126-34. 128
The phenomenon of drug addiction has not to emphasis the extraordinary dimension which
been outside of the psychoanalysis movement Freud adds to the object, coca.
that has been occupied theorizing about certain In the above mentioned text, Freud presents
aspects enabling the etiology to be taken into ac- a study on cocaine chloride, highlighting its his-
count and have elaborated certain postures con- tory, its medicinal effects, its anesthetic proper-
cerning a possible clinical approach. So far there ties, its effects on animals and how it increases
is no consensus on the psychoanalysis frame- the subject’s capacity to work. He then presents
work that accounts for this phenomenon, be it cocaine chloride as an object worthy of attention
a symptom, some type of discomfort, a passage and animatedly describes with fascination its
à l’acte, a manifestation of the death instinct or effects, suggesting that he favors consumption
whether there is any clinical structure in which of this narcotic for the great benefits it imparts.
drug addiction is privileged as with perversion, Freud maintains a belief in this object’s magical
psychosis or neurosis. However, from the route properties and it is evident that “Freud’s personal
psychoanalysis has already taken with this topic, interest in this drug transmits his enthusiasm, eu-
it is possible to introduce certain notions and phoria and illusion concerning its powers to re-
categories that contribute to understanding drug solve whatever ails.”(2) This is worth noting as it
addiction and the way in which the phenomenon marks the starting point for Freud’s perception of
has been approached. psychoactive substances, viewing these as great
When talking of psychoanalysis, though, it objects producing various delightful sensations,
is difficult and inconvenient to exclude the the- besides being a powerful medicine able to solve
oretical planning of the one who invented it. the most enigmatic conditions.
Thus, certain points on “intoxication”, raised Jean Allouch(3) proposes that the explana-
by Sigmund Freud, will be introduced and the tory context in which this initial work of Freud
contributions they have made to studying the is framed is in the traumatic medical model sus-
approaches to this phenomenon. Likewise, fol- taining all medical work at that time. This model
lowing the historical development of one of the proposes that each condition corresponds to the
strands of psychoanalysis, the aim is to study existence of an injury to an organ in order to es-
some new features that have been introduced re- tablish cause, and this organ has not been fully
cently by some lay authors*. identified. Thus, for what were then known as
nervous illness, it was supposed that some part of
Freud’s contribution to intoxication the brain had been injured. Contextualized in this
model, Freud supposed that cocaine had an ef-
In the pre-historical period of psychoanaly- fect on the supposed injury causing the disorder.
sis, Freud’s work on the effects of cocaine chlo- In “Über Coca”, this is how he describes the me-
ride stand out, work in which we can identify his dicinal properties of cocaine for a diverse range
medical and personal interest in this substance. of conditions that had no established explanation
Freud conducted a series of experiments with co- at the time, such as hysteria, melancholy, inhibi-
caine, administering it to himself, enabling him tion and hypochondria, among others. For Freud,
to develop s series of theories. This proximity to cocaine functioned as a powerful medicine capa-
the hallucinogen resulted in his giving cocaine ble of counteracting various illnesses, a quality
a privileged place in his particular way of refer- that established cocaine in a superior position
ring to the substance. Some sections of his text compared to the other medicines, as merely ad-
entitled “Über Coca”(1) from 1884, stand out. ministering cocaine would cure them all.
This text is a collection of his reflections on this Likewise, Freud stated that rather than caus-
experience, from which we intend particularly ing addiction, cocaine could actually be used as
a medicine in overcoming morphine or alcohol
dependence, if administered in small doses.
“It seems to me worth pointing out – what
* Oriented by the teachings of Jacques Lacan, French I and others capable of judging such aspects
psychoanalyst. have discovered – that neither a single dose nor
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
Castaño-Peñuela AM, Gonçalves MFC. 129
repeated doses of coca produce an overwhelming changing it, in his imagination, into a powerful
desire to use the stimulant again; on the contrary, object capable of creating the illusion of needing
one experiences a certain unmotivated aversion nothing. Viewing the phenomenon thus, addic-
to the substance.”(1) tion is not a chronic disease but rather a relation-
From the beginning of his approach to co- ship system between the subject and an object
caine chloride, Freud does not confer the capacity constructed from the imagination, driven by the
of creating addiction on the substance, but rather feeling the subject confers on the narcotic.
appears dazzled by the powers he sought from it. What can be concluded from this episode on
Freud describes in detail the effects of co- cocaine presented by Freud in the pre-history of
caine on the human body, of which only certain psychoanalysis, is that the view of the substance
ones will be highlighted in the analysis proposed as a powerful object is an imaginary construct; it
here. He argues that doses of 0.05 to 0.10 milli- is an illusion arising from the sense the subject
grams of cocaine chloride produce a feeling of confers on the narcotic and the place he autho-
optimism not present in the normal euphoria of rizes it to take in both his psychic economy and
someone who has not consumed it, and the expla- in his desire.
nation of this phenomenon is that the coca does Freud’s reflections on the topic of intoxica-
not directly stimulate the body in the manifesta- tion are not limited to this pre-history of psycho-
tion of euphoria, but rather makes the elements analysis but continued to consolidate themselves
that cause depression, impeding the expression throughout his work. It is worth noting that, as in
of euphoria, vanish. Even more interesting is the “Über Coca”, the approach to psychoactive sub-
antagonistic role allocated to the narcotic: stances is on the level of consumption, not yet
“During this stage of the effects of cocaine, that of addiction.
undistinguished by anything else, symptoms ap- Several of Freud’s works are dedicated to
pear that are generally described as coca’s mar- the subject’s relationship with the culture and
velously stimulating power. It is at this point that the possible consequences of this relationship.
prolonged, intense labor can be realized, both Freud states that there is a double determination
mental and physical, without feelings of fatigue. in the subject’s suffering: unconscious and cul-
It is as if the need to eat and sleep, which would ture. This double determination adds a signifi-
make themselves peremptorily felt at certain cant element to the discussion on which this text
points of the day without the coca, are completely is based, as in addition to the particularity of the
eliminated. Whilst the effects of the cocaine last, subject, the culture from which the subject con-
if one desires, one can eat copious amounts; but structs his suffering in relation to the possibili-
one has the distinct feeling that food is unnec- ties offered also plays an important role.
essary. Likewise, when the effect of the coca One of Freud’s most celebrated texts, in
begins to wear off, nothing impedes one from which he deals with civilization and its conse-
sleeping, but it is possible to overcome the tired- quences, is “Civilization and its Discontents”
ness, without any unpleasant consequences…”(1) (1930 [1929]), in which he also reflects on the
One notable aspect is the way of referring role of intoxication for the subject, a far-reach-
to the drug’s effects as the marvelously stimulat- ing reflection with great contributions. In the
ing power that simultaneously allows and does text, Freud states that the aim of life is to pursue
not allow: one can eat or not eat, sleep or not happiness, which he presents organized into two
sleep, an aspect that Allouch describes as the aspects: on the one hand, absence of pain and
lack of limits in consumption. Likewise, cocaine unpleasantness and, on the other, experiencing
is presented as something which excludes im- intense feelings of pleasure. But he argues that,
possibility, prevents faintness, presented from an unfortunately, happiness is unachievable as it is
imaginary place, giving the subject that which in disaccord with the whole world, both in the
he lacks. Freud describes cocaine as an object macrocosm and the microcosm. To these strong
with superior characteristics, making it an al- words, Freud adds that happiness is merely pos-
luring object. What we are talking about here is sible as an episodic phenomenon. Why, how-
the sensation the substance gives to the subject, ever, does Freud argue that permanent happiness
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
SMAD, Rev. Eletrônica Saúde Mental Álcool Drog. Sept.-Dec. 2014;10(3):126-34. 130
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
Castaño-Peñuela AM, Gonçalves MFC. 131
one talks about toxicomania and not drug depen- of childhood and is subject to one’s own history
dence, pharmaco-dependence, drug addiction and the history of one’s ancestors.
etc. as what is described here is a state of mania It would be wrong to think that, by saying it
provoked by using a narcotic, manifesting capri- is determined by the unconscious, psychoanaly-
cious concern for said narcotic. sis tries to avoid the subject’s responsibility for
After reviewing these works by Freud, one their actions, on the contrary, psychoanalysis
can now compare them to extract their central the- suggests that the subject is at stake in absolutely
ses on which they are based so as to account for all that happens in life, in such a way that it gives
what occurs with the subject. First, it should be the appearance of being outside. Freud had said
emphasized that, in both texts, Freud points out to his famous patient, Dora(7): what has that got
two emotional states to which the subject attrib- to do with what you’re complaining about?, thus
utes a bodily process that goes beyond the intro- placing subjective responsibility.
duction of the drug: Euphoria and Mania. Freud This is essential to understanding the topic
argues precisely, in both texts, that these states we are approaching, as introducing the notion of
can be felt without the need for a toxic substance. the subject implies ceasing to consider the “pa-
Freud deals with intoxication in two differ- tient” in a passive place, putting them in an active
ent facets in each text, facets that are related to place. In the case of drug addiction, then, we are
each other. “Über coca” deals with a problem not talking about a victim of drugs, but an active
with desire. The substance is presented as a su- subject who, for some reason, has constructed
preme object that offers the subject the possi- a special relationship with the drug object: thus
bility of not needing anything. Using the drug, the subjective responsibility. In each measure,
one can go without eating, sleeping, affection, then, this is not a cause and effect relationship,
company, work, rest, etc. as everything the sub- but rather between cause and effect is the subject
ject needs to be happy can be found in that ob- doing something with those things.
ject. Once in possession of this precious object, In this panorama, one of the difficulties in
there is nothing more to be desired. Whereas in the traditional approach is annulling the subject
“Civilization and its Discontents” the narcotic from the framework of understanding and inter-
presents an escape from the pain and suffering vention. In these approaches, the drug is treated
caused by life. The drug object offers happiness. as an active entity, with power over the passive
It is, then, presented here as abolishing desire via subject. The substance is presented as a malign
the illusion of completeness and treating pain spirit (5) taking control of the subject’s body, turn-
through satisfaction. ing him into its servant, creating physical and
It is important to highlight that, while Freud psychological dependence. Although we are not
confers an important role on the narcotic, what ignorant of the fact that the substances have an
is at stake in both of the texts is the notion of the effect upon the body, presented in this way, the
subject, and the drugs appear in the scene merely subject is excluded from the act of consumption.
as a means of suspending desire and achieving Throughout his life, Freud developed this
satisfaction. work exposing clinical findings on the psyche.
He describes it as a complex device, living in the
Some categories of analysis for understanding unconscious to which no physical space or organ
the phenomenon representing it can be attributed (8). This device will
be the process enunciating the logic of the func-
Subject tioning of the unconscious, which will later serve
as a support on which Jacques Lacan structured
One of the contributions made by psycho- the concept “subject of the unconscious”, a term
analysis is the notion of the subject. This concept not used by Freud. Yet, “…this belief in the om-
comes from the French psychoanalyst Jacques nipotence of the “Pharmacon-substance”, which
Lacan, accounts for the unconscious determi- treats the psyche as if it were an organ, may well
nation that rules human lives. This unconscious appear as an attempt to eliminate the subject which
determination drives us from the earliest years is the very topic of psychoanalysis!”(5). The current
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
SMAD, Rev. Eletrônica Saúde Mental Álcool Drog. Sept.-Dec. 2014;10(3):126-34. 132
attempt to place psyche on the same level as the “…it is as if they were absorbed in treating
brain, reducing all mental and thinking processes an organism, many drug addicts no longer have
that occupied philosophers, Freud and other think- any interest in their objects of love or even in
ers to a simple, manipulable organ. To that extent, their own needs. Sexual desire appears to have
it is in the approaches and models of understand- absented itself, nor does hunger make itself
ing that constitute an approach to consumption felt. In effect, when certain drug addicts retire
and to the psyche as an intoxicated organ(5). from the world to give themselves over to inces-
Another noteworthy element inherited from santly treating their own body, this is a form of
social discourses is the fact how patient presents narcissism that only brings them hallucinatory
themselves through their consumption: “I’m an satisfaction.”(5).
addict”, “I’m a pothead”, “I’m a cokehead”, etc. The subject appears to be trapped in “auto
statements that define it as the subject, in which erotic” enjoyment that gives him independence
the symptom manifests itself ascribed to the I. from the outside world, from his own needs and
This holds difficulties, as the subject is neither a form the objects of his love. A proof of this, as Le
man or woman, child or parent, friend or worker, Poulichet mentions, is the complaints made dur-
a subject with desires, dreams, difficulties or ing abstinence. The recovering subjects report
symptoms, but rather a drug addict represented feeling that something is missing, that they have
by what he consumes. lost something and this loss gives them pain. “It
is, without a doubt, a form of powerlessness that
Etiology of drug addiction manifests itself when lacking the narcotic, as if
instead of modelling itself on signifying chains,
After having introduced the notion of sub- the body demands the restitution of an organ that
ject, we can see what psychoanalysis can con- would “link” to the excitement.”(5). The drug ad-
tribute to understanding the phenomenon, dict subject is under the illusion of having created
continuing what has been worked on from the an organ that enables them to suppress desire and
Freud’s perspective. eliminate pain, this is exactly how the narcotic
As indicated previously concerning Freud’s operates, a way of dispensing with castration.
reflections evince that there is a central point of We are not talking about the powers of the
desire at stake in drug addiction. Psychoanalysis object but rather the imaginary construction
proposes that the subject is a being with desires, elaborated by the subject to fill his lack. In con-
but achieving these desires is an impossible task, sequence, hence why certain treatments are con-
as desire always shifts from one side to another. cerned with substituting the drug object for an-
Lacan(9) proposes that desire appears through other object with supreme qualities.
accepting castration, which is to say, through Psychoanalysis supposes that the subject is
accepting that we are incomplete and there is constituted from a structural lack, giving him
nothing that can complete us, there is nothing the possibility of desiring, as one only desires
that fills us up, makes us think that nothing else what one does not possess. To this extent, we
exists. The subject keeps looking for an object human beings organize our lives based on a se-
that makes him feel fully satisfied but is always ries of emotional, work or academic etc. dreams
disappointed, as that longed-for object does not that function as a motor for living each day and
exist, although the subject tries to confer certain unconsciously developing interest in the power
qualities upon it that he himself lacks, as in the to eliminate the lack that is inherent to the sub-
case of romantic partners. ject’s condition. Even with desire, however, as
It seems that something different presents conceived in psychoanalytic theory, the condi-
itself in drug addiction, as the subject has the tion implies that it is never achieved, as nothing
feeling of having found that long lost object exists that corresponds to it or fills it completely.
that completes him and enables him to dispense We would, then, like to raise more strongly
with all the rest, thus manifesting that desire is the idea that there is something of desire at stake
not cyclical. This is the illusion that produces in drug addiction, and this has great implications
addiction. on the subjective. “This is arresting desire to dull
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
Castaño-Peñuela AM, Gonçalves MFC. 133
the suffering”(5). As quoted from Freud, above, phenomenon and the addicted subject. This change
there is nothing in either the macrocosm or the of position means no longer viewing addiction as
microcosm to achieve the sought after happi- a problem, a scourge, something for the sick or
ness. The implication for subjectivity is that with the crazy, and coming to think of it as a subjec-
the suspension of desire at stake in addiction, tive phenomenon constructed within a framework
drug addiction appears to abandon its condition of the possibilities the culture offers. Likewise,
of desiring subject. placing the subject at the center of the intervention
also means understanding that the subject of drug
Final considerations addiction can teach us something about the act of
consumption. Having said this. A difficulty has to
Freud suggests that deciphering the uncon- be mentioned, given the complexity of studying
scious is like the work of an archeologist who drug addiction as in many cases the subject rejects
has to excavate ever deeper layers in order to help, has no intention of talking about the act or
find the precious object lying submerged by the does not trust in the tie the therapist offers him.
tides of history. In the case of drug addictions, There is another important factor to bear in
this means working on what lies behind the met- mind regarding this phenomenon, and it is the
aphor of consumption, discovering what corre- relationship between drug addiction and culture.
sponds to this act. Drug addiction is not a phenomenon that has de-
In this respect, they may try to establish cer- veloped in isolation from the culture, as the con-
tain parameters enabling a possible approach. sumer society has changed our relationship to
Studying drug addiction evinces the need to objects and our forms of satisfaction, constantly
center the intervention around the subject, his inviting us to an excess of satisfaction through
constructs, meanings and history. From this per- advertising. This cultural transformation has
spective, the importance lies not in whether the given rise to new forms of unpleasantness and to
subject consumes or not, nor in what they con- the appearance of new phenomena.
sume or with what frequency, but rather in the Likewise, when considering the phenome-
meaning that he confers on this consumption, non related to the prevailing discourse in each
how it benefits him, how he perceives it. age also implies adjusting the therapist’s attitude,
It is about making the subject the protago- as it would no longer be considered as a disease,
nist in order to work on his history, his thoughts a scourge, a problem but rather as an alternative
and feelings and lack of feelings, without aim- that the subject constructs in order to articulate
ing to cure or to help or to resolve the problem, their discomfort with social ties.
but rather to open up a space for the subject to
construct particular knowledge about the act of References
consuming. “Instead of being about (curing drug
addiction), we are led to making new formations 1. Freud S. Sobre la cocaína. Barcelona: Editorial
appear, containing the subject’s fundamental Anagrama; 1884.
questions”.(10) 2. Fleischer D, Warjach D. Freud y el episodio de
It is also about looking at desire, its position la cocaína. Un criterio de delimitación del campo
as the subject, aiming at locating subjective re- de las adicciones y su cura. Comunidad Russel.
sponsibility. It is about studying the subject of Inédito; 2007.
the unconscious, divided through lack, through 3. Allouch J. Letra por letra. Trascribir, traducir,
incompleteness, through being unable to find transliterar (1984). México: Editorial Epeele;
any element enabling the expected enjoyment to 2009. 309 p.
correspond with the enjoyment achieved. 4. Freud S. El malestar en la cultura (1930 [1929]).
Understanding drug addiction as a subjective 2. ed. Buenos Aires: Amorrortu Editores; 2007.
construction with its own particular meaning for 290 p. Obras completas v.21.
those who consume, be it a symptomatic formation 5. Le Poulichet S. Toxicomanías y psicoanálisis.
or an act, requires a change in the therapist’s posi- Las narcosis del deseo. Buenos Aires: Amorrortu;
tion, a modification in the way they approach the 1987.
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
SMAD, Rev. Eletrônica Saúde Mental Álcool Drog. Sept.-Dec. 2014;10(3):126-34. 134
www.eerp.usp.br/resmad
Copyright of SMAD Revista Electronica Salud Mental, Alcohol y Drogas is the property of
Universidade de Sao Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirao Preto and its content may not
be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.