UM DIÁLOGO ENTRE PEIRCE E BION SOBRE UMA

SEMIÓTICA PSICANALÍTICA.
Cpc"Octkc"Iwkoct«gu"Lqtig
Hwpfc›«q"Ctocpfq"Cnxctgu"RgpvgcfqÎHCCR1UR."Eqqtfgpcfqtc"fq"Itwrq"fg"Guvwfqu"go"HknquqÝc"fc"
Ogpvg"cÝnkcfq"cq"Egpvtq"Kpvgtpcekqpcn"fg"Guvwfqu"Rgktegcpqu0
ana.gui@terra.com.br

Octkc"Cwiwuvc"Pqiwgktc"Ocejcfq"Fkd
Rguswkucfqtc"fq"Itwrq"fg"Guvwfqu"go"HknquqÝc"fc"Ogpvg"cÝnkcfq"cq"Egpvtq"Kpvgtpcekqpcn"fg"
Guvwfqu"Rgktegcpqu0"Ruke„nqic"g"Rukecpcnkuvc0
jmdib@uol.com.br

Resumo: Ug"woc"fcu"tgitcu"hwpfcogpvcku"fcu"ek‒pekcu"fi"qdugtxct"cvgpvcogpvg"qu"
hgp»ogpqu"rctc"gpvgpfgt"q"swg"j "fg"ocku"igtcn."qw"cswknq"swg"cuuko"kpukuvg"go"
ug"ocpkhguvct."pc"rukeqnqikc"rukecpcn vkec."qu"qdlgvqu"fg"guvwfqu"rtkoqtfkcku"u«q"c"
rctvkewnctkfcfg"fc"ogpvg"g"fq"eqorqtvcogpvq"jwocpqu"ocpkhguvqu"pq"rtqeguuq"fg"
eqpuvtw›«q"fc"uwdlgvkxkfcfg0
Ejctngu" Ucpfgtu" Rgkteg" *3:5;/3;36+" eqpegdgw" wo" ect vgt" n„ikeq" ekgpv Ýeq" "
ÝnquqÝc."g"Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"Dkqp"*3:;9/3;9;+"kpxguvkiqw"q"ect vgt"n„ikeq"ekgpv Ýeq"
fc" rukecp nkug." codqu" fguvceco/ug" eqoq" rgpucfqtgu" swg" vcodfio" dwuectco" c"
xgtfcfg"¿nvkoc"cvfi"swg"gpeqpvtctco"c"xgtfcfg"guvfivkec0"Ugwu"guhqt›qu"fg"rguswkuc"
eqpvtkdw tco"eqpukfgtcxgnogpvg"rctc"c"ek‒pekc"fc"eqipk›«q."gurgekcnogpvg"swcpvq"
u"uwcu"pq› gu"fg"rgpucogpvq"go"c›«q"ogpvcn"g"fg"gzrgtk‒pekc"eqoq"cigpvg"fq"
rgpucogpvq"g"fqu"rtqeguuqu"fg"crtgpfk|cigo."pq"gueqrq"fg"uwcu"tgurgevkxcu"vgqtkcu"
fq" eqpjgekogpvq0" Pc" fqwvtkpc" n„ikec" qw" Ugok„vkec" fg" Rgkteg." vqfq" rgpucogpvq"
ug"f "go"ukipqu"g"rqt"ogkq"fc"gzrgtk‒pekc="pc"fqwvtkpc"rukecpcn vkec"fg"Dkqp."q"
crtgpfk|cfq"ceqpvgeg"pc"gzrgtk‒pekc0"Codqu"qu"cwvqtgu"vcodfio"fkcnqico"swcpvq"
ao lócus da mente como tópos"cqpfg"c"gzrgtk‒pekc"ug"hc|"eqipk›«q"g."ocku"ckpfc."
eqpegdgpfq" qdlgvkxq" g" uwdlgvkxq" uqd" q" oguoq" swcftq" vqrqn„ikeq" eqpvkpwkuvc"
*TQUC"uf<"545+0"
Q"xgkq"fc"eqttgpvg"rukecpcn vkec"htcpeguc."tgrtgugpvcfq"rqt"Lceswgu"Ncecp"*3;23/
3;:3+." godcucfq" go" Ukiowpf" Htgwf" *3:78/3;5;+." vgo" hqtpgekfq" dcugu" rctc"
woc" Ugok„vkec" Rukecpcn vkec" eqpukuvgpvg0" Gpvtgvcpvq." c" rtqrquvc" fguug" ctvkiq" fi"
crtgugpvct"c"rquukdknkfcfg"fg"woc"Ugok„vkec"Rukecpcn vkec"eqo"dcugu"pc"vtcfk›«q"
rukecpcn vkec" kpinguc" fg" Dkqp" g" uqd" c" rgturgevkxc" ugok„vkec" fg" Rgkteg0"Cuuko." c"
gueqnc" rukecpcn vkec" kpinguc" tgrtgugpvcfc" rqt" Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" Dkqp" eqo" uwc"
qtkikpcn" grkuvgoqnqikc" rukecpcn vkec." ewlqu" rtkpe rkqu" guv«q" godcucfqu" pc" qdtc"
fg"Htgwf"g"fg"Ogncpkg"Mngkp"*3::4/3;82+."rgtokvg"vtc›ct"crtqzkoc›«q"gpvtg"qu"
rtkpe rkqu"eqipkvkxq/vqrqn„ikequ"fc"c›«q"ogpvcn"pcu"vgqtkcu"fg"Dkqp"g"fg"Rgkteg0"
Rcncxtcu"Ejcxg<"Gzrgtk‒pekc."Rgpucogpvq."Ogpvg."Vqrqnqikc."Eqipk›«q0

C" FKCNQIWG" DGVYGGP" RGKTEG" CPF" DKQP" QP" C" RU[EJQCPCN[VKE"

UGOKQVKEU0
Abstract:"Kh"qpg"qh"vjg"dcuke"twngu"qh"uekgpegu"ku"vq"qdugtxg"kpvgpvn{"vjg"rjgpqogpc"
to understand what it has of more general, or what it insists on remaining, in
12ª Jornada Peirceana

psychoanalytic psychology, the objects of primordial studies are the individuality

and the particularitity of the manifest human mind and the behavior in the process
of the construction of the subjectivity while it becomes related with the world.
Ejctngu"Ucpfgtu"Rgkteg"*3:5;/3;36+"jcu"eqpegkxgf"c"uekgpvkÝe"nqikecn"ejctcevgt"
vq" vjg" rjknquqrj{." cpf" Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" Dkqp" *3:;9/3;9;+" jcu" kpxguvkicvgf" vjg"

18 ago 2009 83
 uekgpvkÝe" nqikecn" ejctcevgt" qh" vjg" ru{ejqcpcn{uku." dqvj" ctg" fkuvkpiwkujgf" cu"
vjkpmkpi"vjcv"vjg{"jcf"ugctejgf"vjg"wnvkocvg"vtwvj"cu"cguvjgvke"vtwvj0"Kvu"tgugctejŁu"
efforts had contributed considerably for the science of the cognition, especially
to its slight knowledge of thought in mental action and experience, inside of its
tgurgevkxg"vjgqtkgu"qh"mpqyngfig0"Kp"vjg"nqikecn"fqevtkpg"qt"Ugokqvkeu"qh"Rgkteg."
all thought are signs by means of the experience; in the psychoanalytic doctrine
qh" Dkqp." ngctpkpi" jcrrgpu" kp" vjg" gzrgtkgpeg0" Dqvj" cwvjqtu" cnuq" fkcnqiwg" cdqwv"
n„ewu"qh"vjg"okpf"cu"v„rqu"yjgtg"vjg"gzrgtkgpeg"ocmgu"kvugnh"eqipkvkqp<"eqpegkxkpi"
qdlgevkxg" cpf" uwdlgevkxg" wpfgt" vjg" eqpvkpwkuvke" vqrqnqikecn" rkevwtg" *TQUC" uf<"
545+0
The lode of the French psychoanalytic chain, represented by Jacques Lacan
*3;23/3;:3+."dcugf"kp"Ukiowpf"Htgwf"*3:78/3;5;+."jcu"uwrrnkgf"dcugu"eqpukuvgpv"
vq"Ru{ejqcpcn{vke"Ugokqvkeu0"Jqygxgt."vjg"rtqrqucn"qh"vjku"ctvkeng"ku"vq"rtgugpv"vjg"
rquukdknkv{"qh"c"Ru{ejqcpcn{vke"Ugokqvkeu"wpfgt"Gpinkuj"ru{ejqcpcn{vke"vtcfkvkqp"
qh" Dkqp" cpf" wpfgt" vjg" rgturgevkxg" qh" RgktegŁu" Ugokqvkeu0" Vjwu." vjg" Gpinkuj"
ru{ejqcpcn{vke" uejqqn" tgrtgugpvgf" d{" Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" Dkqp" ykvj" kvu" qtkikpcn"
psychoanalytic epistemology, whose principles are based in the workmanship
qh" Htgwf" cpf" Ogncpkg" Mngkp" *3::4/3;82+." cnnqyu" vq" vtceg" crrtqcej" gpvgtu" vjg"
eqipkvkxg/vqrqnqikecn" rtkpekrngu" qh" vjg" ogpvcn" cevkqp" kp" vjgqtkgu" qh" Dkqp" cpf"
Peirce.
Mg{yqtfu<"Gzrgtkgpeg."Vjqwijv."Okpf."Vqrqnqi{."Eqipkvkqp0"

Kpvtqfw›«q"
Q" swg" j " fg" ocku" igtcn" pqu" hgp»ogpqu" fi" swguvkqpcogpvq" tgngxcpvg" rctc"
qdugtxc›«q"g"kpxguvkic›«q"ekgpv Ýecu"pc"eqorquk›«q"fg"wo"fkuewtuq"eqgtgpvg."gÝekgpvg."
swg"fguetgxc"q"eqorqtvcogpvq"fcswgngu"hgp»ogpqu"swg"kpukuvgo"go"ug"ocpkhguvct0"
Eqoq"fkuewtuq"uqdtg"c"ek‒pekc."c"ogvcek‒pekc"fgugpxqnxg"wo"fkuewtuq"kpvgtpq"fg"ect vgt"
eqpuvkvwvkxq."cinwvkpcpfq"qpvqnqikc."grkuvgoqnqikc."n„ikec"g"ogvqfqnqikc"fc"ek‒pekc."g"
wo"fkuewtuq"gzvgtpq"fgugpxqnxkfq"pcu"fkuekrnkpcu"fg"ÝnquqÝc."jkuv„tkc."uqekqnqikc"g"
rukeqnqikc" fcu" ek‒pekcu" *XKGKTC" G" UCPVCGNNC." 422:<" 38+0" Fgpvtq" fguug" gueqrq"
eqpuvkvwvkxq"fc"ogvcek‒pekc."c"qpvqnqikc"Ðkpxguvkic"c"guu‒pekc"qw"ugpvkfq"fq"gpvg"h ukeq"
qw"pcvwtcn."fq"gpvg"ru swkeq."n„ikeq."ocvgo vkeq."guvfivkeq."fivkeq."vgorqtcn."gurcekcn."
gve0Ñ0"Ejcw "cetguegpvc"c"guuc"fgÝpk›«q<"ÐC"rgtiwpvc"ÐQ"swg"fi"kuvq"swg"fiAÑtghgtg/ug"cq"
oqfq"fg"ugt"fqu"gpvgu"pcvwtcku."ctvkÝekcku."kfgcku"g"jwocpqu="c"rgtiwpvc"“Para quem é
isto que é?”tghgtg/ug"cq"ugpvkfq"qw" "ukipkÝec›«q"fguugu"gpvguÑ"*4222+0"Uqdtg"q"vgtoq"
qpvqnqikc"uqd"xkfiu"Ýnqu„Ýeq"g"ekgpv Ýeq."Xkgktc"g"Ucpvcgnnc"*422:<"39+"eqpukfgtco"swg"
c"qpvqnqikc"ekgpv Ýec"fg"wo"rqpvq"fg"xkuvc"ukuv‒okeq"guv "ukpvqpk|cfc"eqo"c"ugok„vkec."
g"cÝtoco."eqo"dcug"go"Ngeqwtv."swg"cq"ngt

q"vgtoq."q"Ýn„uqhq"vgo"c"vgpf‒pekc"fg"kpvgtrtgv /nq"eqoq"wo"ugt="l "q"rguswkucfqt"q"kpvgtrtgvc"

eqoq"wo"eqpegkvq."pq"swcn"q"ugt"ug"tguqnxg"pq"ukuvgoc"fg"tgnc› gu"go"swg"ug"kpuetgxg0"]000_"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

84 18 ago 2009
 Fkhgtgpvgu"fqu"Ýn„uqhqu."ewlqu"ukuvgocu"v‒o"go"xkuvc"crgpcu"c"tgcnkfcfg."qu"ekgpvkuvcu"dwueco"
qticpk|ct"ukuvgocu"eqpukuvgpvgu"swg"oqfgnco"c"tgcnkfcfg"vgpfq"go"xkuvc"egtvqu"Ýpu0

C"rukeqnqikc"rukecpcn vkec"crtgugpvc"eqoq"qdlgvq"fg"guvwfqu"c"rctvkewnctkfcfg"
fc" ogpvg" g" fq" eqorqtvcogpvq" jwocpqu" ocpkhguvqu" pq" rtqeguuq" fc" eqpuvtw›«q" fc"
uwdlgvkxkfcfg." ukvwcpfq" ugwu" qdlgvqu" fg" kpxguvkic›«q" pqu" ukuvgocu" jwocpqu0" Go"
eqpvtcrctvkfc." pc" qdtc" rgktegcpc." qu" eqpegkvqu" fg" ugpvkogpvq." fg" rgpucogpvq." fc"
ogpvg."fgpvtg"qwvtqu."crtgugpvco"gzvgpu«q"p«q"nkokvcfc"cqu"ukuvgocu"jwocpqu"g"uwcu"
qtkigpu"ug"guvgpfgo"fcu"dcugu"qpvqn„ikecu." u"hgpqogpqn„ikecu"g" u"ugok„vkecu."q"swg"
rgtokvg"fct"wo"rcpqtcoc"fc"eqipquekdknkfcfg."rgteqttgpfq"fc"ukvwc›«q"ipqukqn„ikec"
rtfi/et vkec"cvfi"q"eqorngzq"eqipkvkxq"fq"rgpucogpvq"cwvqeqpvtqncfq"g"fgnkdgtcfq0
C"N„ikec."pc"eqpuvkvwk›«q"fq"fkuewtuq"ekgpv Ýeq"kpvgtpq."kornkec"dwuect"hqtocu"
fg"gzrtguu«q"ocku"hqtocku."ukod„nkecu."qw"oguoq"vqrqn„ikecu."ukoknctgu" u"nkpiwcigpu"
igqofivtkecu" g" ocvgo vkecu0" Rgkteg" g" Dkqp" gpvgpfgpfgtco" c" korqtv¤pekc" fc" n„ikec"
swg."eqphqtog"Ycpgt"g"Equvgpcdng"*3;;8+."c"ocvgo vkec"p«q"fi"uqogpvg"ctkvofivkec."
p¿ogtqu."qw"igqofivtkec."hqtocu."rqku"gpxqnxg"Ðswcnswgt"qdlgvq"swg"rquuc"ugt"gzrtguuq"
ukodqnkecogpvg"rqt"ogkq"fg"tgitcu"rtgekucu"fg"ocpkrwnc›«q"fguugu"u odqnqu0"]000_"g"c"
n„ikec"fi"rctvg"fc"ocvgo vkec."ocu."cq"oguoq"vgorq."fi"c"nkpiwcigo"fc"ocvgo vkecÑ0"
Pguvg" ctvkiq." eqphqtog" c" cÝpkfcfg" eqpegkvwcn" fg" Rgkteg" g" Dkqp" swcpvq" cq" crtgpfgt"
rqt"ogkq"fc"Ðgzrgtk‒pekcÑ"fc"c›«q"ogpvcn"go"oqxkogpvq. j "fg"ug"fkcnqict"uqdtg"q"
curgevq" hgpqogpqn„ikeq" fq" lócus da mente como tópos" cqpfg" c" gzrgtk‒pekc" ug" hc|"
eqipk›«q"uqd"q"oguoq"swcftq"vqrqn„ikeq"eqpvkpwkuvc"*TQUC"uf<"545+0
Grkuvgoqnqi{" *kpin0+" *Ncncpfg." 3;;;<" 535+" fi" ukp»pkoq" fg" Ðvgqtkc" fq"
eqpjgekogpvqÑ"qw"ÐipqukqnqikcÑ"g"épistémologie"*Htcp0+"fi"ukp»pkoq"fg"ÝnquqÝc"fcu"
ek‒pekcu"swg"hc|"c"et vkec"fqu"rtkpe rkqu."fcu"jkr„vgugu"g"fqu"tguwnvcfqu"fcu"fkxgtucu"
ek‒pekcu."fgvgtokpcpfq"c"uwc"qtkigo"n„ikec."q"ugw"xcnqt"g"c"uwc"korqtv¤pekc"qdlgvkxc0"
¡"q"guvwfq"fc"pcvwtg|c"fq"eqpjgekogpvq"g"fc"lwuvkÝec›«q0"Vcpvq"c"qpvqnqikc"swcpvq"c"
grkuvgoqnqikc"*PGYVQP"FC"EQUVC."3;;9+"guv«q"uqd"vgttkv„tkq"fq"fkuewtuq"kpvgtpq"
fc" ogvcek‒pekc" g" q" eqorctvknjco" eqo" c" ÝnquqÝc" fc" ek‒pekc." tgegdgpfq" fgnc" ugwu"
rtkpe rkqu" *CNDWSWGTSWG" G" UCPVCGNNC." 422:<" 39" g" 3;+0" J " kpvgp›«q" fg" ug"
kpxguvkict"cu"eqpfk› gu"fg"etgp›c."fg"xgtfcfg"g"fg"lwuvkÝec›«q"fqu"ctiwogpvqu"swg"
crtqzkoco"dcugu"ugok„vkecu"rgktegcpcu"fcu"dcugu"fc"rukeqnqikc"rukecpcn vkec"dkqpkcpc0"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

18 ago 2009 85
 Pguvg" ctvkiq." go" gurge Ýeq" rctc" kp ekq" fq" godcucogpvq" eqpegkvwcn." qeqttgt " kpvgt/
tgnc›«q"fqu"ugiwkpvgu"eqpegkvqu<"hcvqu"gzvgtpqu"Î"gzrgtk‒pekc"/"c›«q"ogpvcn0"

30"Crtgugpvc›«q"fg"Y0"T0"Dkqp"g"E0"U0"Rgkteg<
Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" Dkqp" *3:;9/3;9;+3 kpkekqw" uwc" hqtoc›«q" cecf‒okec" pc"
Wpkxgtukfcfg"fg"Qzhqtf"*Kpincvgttc+."okpkuvtcpfq"c"fkuekrnkpc"Jkuv„tkc."eqorngvcpfq"
uwc"vkvwnc›«q"g"ogfkekpc"*Nqpftgu+"eqo"fguvcecfc"rtgokc›«q"go"ektwtikc0"Gurgekcnk|qw/
ug" go" rukswkcvtkc." hg|" hqtoc›«q" go" rukecp nkug" *cp nkug" fkf vkec" eqo" Ogncpkg"
Mngkp+." ckpfc" ug" crtqhwpfcpfq" go" jkuv„tkc" oqfgtpc." nkegpekcpfq/ug" go" Ngvtcu" g"
eqorngvcpfq"guvwfqu"cxcp›cfqu"go"HknquqÝc"g"Vgqnqikc0"Rquuw c"eqpjgekogpvqu"fg"
nkpi¯ uvkec."n piwcu"itgicu"g"ncvkpcu."ugpfq"kpvgtguucfq"ngkvqt"fqu"en uukequ"fc"nkvgtcvwtc."
gurgekcnogpvg" Ujcmgurgctg." g" fqu" Ýn„uqhqu" pqv xgku." gurgekcnogpvg" Mcpv" fg" swgo"
tgÞgvkw" nqpicogpvg" uqdtg" c" o zkoc" ÐKpvwk›«q" ugo" eqpegkvq" fi" egic." g" eqpegkvq" ugo"
kpvwk›«q" fi" xc|kqÑ0" Crtgekcxc" cu" Kpxguvkic› gu" Hknqu„Ýecu" fg" Ykvvigpuvgkp" rqtswg"
eqpukfgtcxc" swg" pguvc" qdtc" guvg" Ýn„uqhq" ocku" fq" swg" rtqewtct" gpwpekct" woc" vgug."
dwueqw"enctkÝect"wo"rgpucogpvq"qdlgvkxcpfq"ug"nkxtct"fcu"ctocfknjcu"fc"nkpiwcigo0
Ejctngu" Ucpfgtu" Rgkteg" *3:5;/3;36+." Ýn„uqhq" n„ikeq" ogvch ukeq." pcueg" go"
Ecodtkfig." nkegpekc/ug" go" ek‒pekcu" g" ug" fqwvqtc" go" Sw okec0" Ngekqpc" N„ikec" pc"
Wpkxgtukfcfg"fg"Lqjp"Jqrmkpu"g"vtcdcnjc"eqoq"ekgpvkuvc"pc"W0"U0"Eqcuv"cpf"Uwtxg{"
cvfi" 3:;30" Oqttg" fgueqpjgekfq" go" Ctkudg" cqu" 97" cpqu" gpswcpvq" vtcdcnjc" go" ugwu"
ocpwuetkvqu0" Ekgpvkuvc" fg" qewrc›«q" g" vtgkpcogpvq." gng" cngicxc" vgt" etguekfq" pwo"
ncdqtcv„tkq0" N„ikeq" tkiqtquq." Rgkteg" p«q" rqfgtkc" cfokvkt" swg" c" gzrgtk‒pekc" ngxcuug"
c" rtqxcu" cduqnwvcu." pgo" rqfgtkc" fgueqpukfgtct" qu" fguxkqu" g" gttqu" fg" qdugtxc›«q0"
Wo" Ýn„uqhq" ukuv‒okeq." uwc" ÝnquqÝc" dwuecxc" kpxguvkict" woc" ufitkg" fg" swguv gu" go"
tgcu" fkxgtucu<" qpvqnqikc." equoqnqikc." h ukec." sw okec." gve." pc" igtc›«q" u ipkec" fq"
eqpjgekogpvq0"Eqoq"ekgpvkuvc."gng"vgo"kpvgtguug"pqu"ofivqfqu"fg"tcekqe pkq"fc"n„ikec"

3" Jqogo"fg"xcuvc"g"rtqhwpfc"hqtoc›«q"jwocp uvkec"g"u„nkfc"ewnvwtc"igtcn."hqk"wo"crtgekcfqt"

fcu"ctvgu."tgxgnqw"vcngpvq"rctc"c"rkpvwtc"kortguukqpkuvc."g"p«q"njg"rcuuqw"fkuvcpvg"kpvgtguug"g"
eqpjgekogpvq"ukipkÝecvkxq"go"ocvgo vkec"*Ec{ng{"g"U{nxguvgt+"g"go"n„ikec"*Htgig+0"Fqku"ecucogpvqu."
eqo"oqtvg"rtgocvwtc"fg"uwc"rtkogktc"gurquc."fwcu"Ýnjcu."c"rtkogktc"rukecpcnkuvc"g"c"ugiwpfc"nkpi¯kuvc."
g"wo"Ýnjq"ofifkeq"cpguvgukuvc0"Cnkuvc/ug"xqnwpvctkcogpvg"rqt"fwcu"xg|gu"pq"gzfitekvq"dtkv¤pkeq"rctc"
c"Rtkogktc"g"c"Ugiwpfc"Iwgttcu"Owpfkcku0"Cqu"3:"cpqu"kpvgttqorgw"ugwu"guvwfqu"g"eqo"65"cpqu"
kpvgttqorgw"uwcu"cvkxkfcfgu"rtqÝuukqpcku"pc"En pkec"Vcxkuvqem0"Qewrqw"vqfcu"hwp› gu"fc"Uqekgfcfg"
Dtkv¤pkec"fg"Rukecp nkug."ugpfq"ugw"rtgukfgpvg"gpvtg"3;84"g"3;870"Go"3;8:"guvgxg"pc"Cofitkec"Ncvkpc."
tgcnk|cpfq"kpvgpuc"rtqitcoc›«q"ekgpv Ýec"pc"Cuuqekc›«q"Rukecpcn vkec"Ctigpvkpc0"Guvgxg"pq"Dtcukn"
go"3;95."3;96."3;97"g"3;9:."tgurgevkxcogpvg"go"U«q"Rcwnq."Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq"g"U«q"Rcwnq."Dtcu nkc."g"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

U«q"Rcwnq."tgcnk|cpfq"eqphgt‒pekcu."fgdcvgu."ugokp tkqu"en pkequ."guvgu"swg"tguwnvctco"pc"rwdnkec›«q"

das Conferências brasileiras13;950"Eqo"q"vtcdcnjq"kpvkvwncfq"ÐQ"i‒ogq"kocikp tkqÑ"Dkqp"ug"vqtpqw"
ogodtq"fc"Uqekgfcfg"Dtkv¤pkec"fg"Rukecp nkug<"Ðc"hwp›«q"fq"i‒ogq"kocikp tkq"fi."rqtvcpvq."pgict"woc"
tgcnkfcfg"fkhgtgpvg"fgng"rt„rtkqÑ"*3;72.3;²"Î"rquvgtkqtogpvg"rwdnkecfq"go"Second Thoughts."3;89+0"

86 18 ago 2009
fcu"ek‒pekcu."guvwfqu"fq"swcn"hqk"fgtkxcfc"c"ek‒pekc"fqu"ukipqu."qw"Ugok„vkec0"Go"3;32."
N„ikec"g"Ugok„vkec"ug"eqpuqnkfco"eqoq"ukp»pkoqu"pc"qdtc"rgktegcpc0

40" Dcug" Qpvqn„ikec" g" Hgpqogpqn„ikec<" Fqu" Hcvqu" Gzvgtpqu" Eqoq"

Gzrgtk‒pekc
2.1 Como Peirce fundamenta a realidade dos fatos externos?
Q" ect vgt" ekgpv Ýeq" fc" Hgpqogpqnqikc" rgktegcpc" ug" fgxg." fg" wo" ncfq." "
wpkxgtucnkfcfg" fguucu" ecvgiqtkcu" fc" gzrgtk‒pekc" g." fg" qwvtq." " uwc" rgewnkctkfcfg"
jkrqvfivkec." fguxkpewncfc" fc" tgcnkfcfg" fq" ceqpvgekogpvq" hgpqo‒pkeq." g" ug" Ðgpeqpvtc"
gzcvcogpvg"pcu"htqpvgktcu"fc"rwtcogpvg"jkrqvfivkec"ek‒pekc"fc"ocvgo vkec000Ñ"*PGO<"
3;8+0" C" Ocvgo vkec" p«q" crgnc" cq" wpkxgtuq" hcevwcn." gzvtckpfq" fg" uk" jkr„vgugu" g"
eqpugs¯‒pekcu" *PGO<" 3;5+0 Cuuko." c" rt„rtkc" tgnc›«q" n„ikec" fg" fgrgpf‒pekc" fq"
ugiwpfq"rctc"q"rtkogktq"fi"dcug"rctc"cu"ek‒pekcu"pqtocvkxcu0"C"kuuq"ug"fgxg"c"pqogc›«q"
fc" Hgpqogpqnqikc"eqoq"ek‒pekc"fcu"crct‒pekcu."rqku"pgeguukvc"swg"c"N„ikec"xcnkfg"
ugwu"ctiwogpvqu."rqtvcpvq."uwc"pcvwtg|c"fi"ocku"nkicfc" "fc"Ocvgo vkec"swg"rtguekpfg"
fqu"hcvqu0
Pq"Yj{"Uvwf{"NqikeA."fq"vtgejq"Vjg"Hcnnkdknkv{"qh"Tgcuqpkpi"cpf"vjg"Hggnkpi"
of Tcvkqpcnkv{." fg" 3;24." Rgkteg" gpvgpfg" swg" rctc" q" guvwfq" fc" tgcnkfcfg" hgpqo‒pkec"
j " fg" ug" gpvtct" pq" gueqrq" fc" Ogvch ukec" swg." rqt" uwc" xg|." vcodfio" pgeguukvc" swg" c"
N„ikec"xcnkfg"ugwu"ctiwogpvqu"*ER"4038:"g"PGO<"3;5+, cÝpcn."Ðc"n„ikec"fi"c"vgqtkc"fq"
tcekqe pkq"eqttgvq."fg"eqoq"q"tcekqe pkq"fgxg"ugt."p«q"fg"eqoq"gng"fi000Ñ"*ER"409+."qw"
melhor, no texto Consciousness."uf0."q"cwvqt"fkt <

C"n„ikec"fi"wo"tcoq"fc"ÝnquqÝc0"¡"q"oguoq"swg"fk|gt"swg"gnc"fi"woc"ek‒pekc"gzrgtkgpekcn"
g"qw"rqukvkxc."qw"uglc."woc"ek‒pekc"swg"p«q"ug"cr„kc"go"qdugtxc› gu"gurgekcku"]000_"ocu"pqu"
hgp»ogpqu"swg"guv«q"cdgtvqu" "qdugtxc›«q"fg"vqfq"jqogo000"J "fqku"tcoqu"rtkpekrcku"fc"
ÝnquqÝc."c"N„ikec."qw"c"ÝnquqÝc"fq"rgpucogpvq."g"c"Ogvch ukec."qw"c"ÝnquqÝc"fq"ugt"*ER"
90748+0

Wo" rqweq" cpvgu." pq" The Three Categories, trecho Triads." fg" 3:;8." Rgkteg"
tgÞgvg"uqdtg"q"ect vgt"qpvqn„ikeq"fc"N„ikec."pq"kpvgtkqt"fc"Ogvch ukec."eqoq"eqpfwvqtc"
fq"tcekqe pkq"*ER"306:9"g"ER"4038:"g"PGO<"3;5+0"Ug"c"gzrgtk‒pekc"uwigtg"wpkfcfg."
j "fg"ug"rgpuct"uqdtg"uwc"tgcnkfcfg0"C"ogvch ukec"ekgpv Ýec"fq"cwvqt"guv "godcucfc"pc"
qdugtxc›«q."fg"oqfq"eqpuekgpvg"qw"p«q."g"ug"hwpfcogpvc"pc"qdugtxc›«q"fg"hgp»ogpqu"
eqvkfkcpqu."eqoq"fk|"q"cwvqt<
12ª Jornada Peirceana

Cu"eqkucu"fgueqdgtvcu"rqt"swcnswgt"ek‒pekc"guv«q"cnfio"fq"cnecpeg"fc"qdugtxc›«q"fktgvc0"P«q"
ug"rqfg"xgt"c"gpgtikc."pgo"c"cvtc›«q"itcxkvcekqpcn."pgo"cu"oqnfiewncu"xqcfqtcu"fqu"icugu."pgo"
q"fivgt"nwokp hgtq."pgo"cu"Þqtguvcu"fc"gtc"ectdqp egc."pgo"cu"gzrnqu gu"fcu"efinwncu"pgtxqucu0"

18 ago 2009 87
 Uqogpvg"cu"rtgokuucu"fcu"ek‒pekcu"u«q"fktgvcogpvg"qdugtxcfcu"g"p«q"uwcu"eqpugs¯‒pekcu"*ER"
804+0

Go" 3;25." pq" Preface, trecho The Problems of Metaphysic." fg" 3;25." cq"
guvwfct" qu" Ðcurgevqu" ocku" igtcku" fc" tgcnkfcfg" g" fqu" qdlgvqu" tgckuÑ" *ER" 808+." Rgkteg."
kpÞwgpekcfq" rgnq" tgcnkuoq" fg" L0" F0" Ueqvwu." gpvgpfg" swg" c" tgcnkfcfg" fi" cswknq" swg" fi"
kpfgrgpfgpvgogpvg"fq"swg"ug"rquuc"fgnc"rgpuct."qw"ugt"tgrtgugpvcfc"rqt"cniwoc"ogpvg."
go"rctvkewnct0"Guug"rtkpe rkq"jcxkc"ukfq"rtgpwpekcfq"pq"HtcugtÓu"Gfkvkqp"qh"Vjg"Yqtmu"
qh"Igqtig"Dgtmgng{. no trecho Hqtowncvkqp"qh"Tgcnkuo."fg"3:93."fq"ugiwkpvg"oqfq<"qu"
Ðqdlgvqu"guv«q"fkxkfkfqu"go"Ýe› gu."uqpjqu."gve0."fg"wo"ncfq."g"tgcnkfcfg."fg"qwvtq0"Qu"
rtkogktqu"u«q"cswgngu"swg"gzkuvgo"crgpcu"rqtswg"xqe‒."qw"gw."qw"cniwfio."qu"kocikpc="
qu"¿nvkoqu"u«q"cswgngu"swg"v‒o"woc"gzkuv‒pekc"kpfgrgpfgpvg"fc"uwc"qw"fc"okpjc"ogpvg."
qw"fcswgnc"fg"swcnswgt"rguuqcÑ"*ER":034+0"
Cuuko."qdlgvqu"kocikpcfqu"p«q"v‒o"woc"hqt›c"eqorwnukxc"kpukuvgpvg"rctc"c"
eqpuek‒pekc"pq"ugpvkfq"fg"tgc›«q"kogfkcvc"c"cniq"gzrgtkgpekcfq."qw"ugiwpfq"igpw pq"
rctc"c"eqpuek‒pekc0"Cq"ug"tgrtgugpvct"q"wpkxgtuq"qp tkeq."gng"ug"oqnfc"eqoq"qdlgvq" "
tgrtgugpvc›«q0"Eqoq"Kdtk"gphcvk|c<"Ðcq"ug"fguhc|gt"c"tgrtgugpvc›«q."fguhc|/ug"eqo"gnc"
q"qdlgvqÑ0"Cuuko."Ctvg"g"Ocvgo vkec"Ðug"cuugognjco"rqt"gpigpftctgo"fgpvtq"fg"uk"q"
qdlgvq"fg"uwcu"tgrtgugpvc› guÑ"*KDTK"3;;4<"48+0
Ckpfc"go"3;24."pq"Rctvkcn"U{pqruku"qh"c"Rtqrqugf"Yqtm"kp"Nqike, ao evitar
o psicologismo, mas assimilando a noésis"fcu"eqkucu"eqvkfkcpcu."q"eqpegkvq"ogvch ukeq"
rgktegcpq" fg" Tgcnkfcfg" vgo" rtqhwpfc" eqttgnc›«q" eqo" uwc" Ugok„vkec" ekgpv Ýec."
qw"N„ikec."fg"vcn"oqfq"swg"gng"cÝtoc"swg"Ðcswknq"eqo"swg"guvcoqu"nkfcpfq"p«q"fi"
ogvch ukec<"fi"n„ikec"crgpcuÑ"*ER"40:6"3;24."crwf"RGKTEG"3;;2<"44+0"Rqfg/ug"cÝtoct"
eqo"q"cwvqt."swg"Ðqu"ectcevgtgu"fcu"eqkucu"tgcku"kpfgrgpfgo"fg"pquucu"qrkpk gu."ocu"
chgvco"pquuqu"ugpvkfqu."ugiwpfq"ngku"tgiwnctguÑ."rtgokuuc"cpvgtkqtogpvg"eqpegdkfc"pq"
Vjg"Hkzcvkqp"qh"Dgnkgh."fg"3:99<

J " eqkucu" tgcku." ewlqu" ectcevgtgu" kpfgrgpfgo" rqt" eqorngvq" fg" pquucu" qrkpk gu" c" tgurgkvq"
fgncu="guugu"tgcku"chgvco"pquuqu"ugpvkfqu"ugiwpfq"ngku"tgiwnctgu"g."eqpswcpvq"pquucu"ugpuc› gu"
uglco"v«q"fkxgtucu"swcpvq"pquucu"tgnc› gu"eqo"qu"qdlgvqu."rqfgtgoqu."xcngpfq/pqu"fcu"ngku"
fc"rgtegr›«q."cxgtkiwct."cvtcxfiu"fq"tcekqe pkq."eqoq"ghgvkxc"g"xgtfcfgktcogpvg"cu"eqkucu"u«q="
g"vqfq"jqogo."fgufg"swg"vgpjc"gzrgtk‒pekc"dcuvcpvg"g"tcekqekpg"uwÝekgpvgogpvg"cegtec"fq"
cuuwpvq."ugt "ngxcfq" "eqpenwu«q"¿pkec"g"xgtfcfgktc0"C"eqpegr›«q"pqxc"swg"ug"kpvtqfw|"fi"c"fg"
Tgcnkfcfg"*ER"7057:/:9"3:99."apud"RGKTEG"3;;5<":7+0

2.2 Como Bion fundamenta a realidade dos fatos externos?

12ª Jornada Peirceana

Fg" wo" oqfq" igtcn." Y0" T0" Dkqp" ug" fgfkeqw" cq" fgugpxqnxkogpvq" fg" woc"
grkuvgoqnqikc" rukecpcn vkec" fg" ewpjq" tgcnkuvc." c" rctvkt" fcu" eqpegr› gu" fg" Ukiowpf"
Htgwf." g" fc" rukecp nkug" kphcpvq/lwxgpkn" fg" Ogncpkg" Mngkp." kpvtqfw|kpfq" eqpegr› gu"

88 18 ago 2009
uqdtg"c"tgnc›«q"vgtcr‒wvkec"gpvtg"cpcnkuvc"g"cpcnkucpvg0"Dkqp"cÝtocxc"q"hcvq"fg"swg"c"
tgnc›«q"vgtcr‒wvkec"gpvtg"cpcnkuvc"g"cpcnkucpvg"fgxg"ceqpvgegt"fg"oqfq"ukipkÝecvkxq"c"
Ýo"fg"rtqxqect"vtcpuhqtoc› gu"pgeguu tkcu."pq"ugpvkfq"oguoq"fq"etguekogpvq"ogpvcn."
rqt"ogkq"fq"Ðnkxtg"rgpuctÑ"fguuc"fwrnc"fwtcpvg"c"uguu«q"rukecpcn vkec0"C"„vkec"dkqpkcpc"
xcnqtk|c" uqdtgocpgktc" cu" tgnc› gu" xkpewnctgu" g" c" gzrgtk‒pekc" goqekqpcn" ocpkhguvcu"
fwtcpvg"c"uguu«q"cpcn vkec."rqtswg"vcn"gzrgtk‒pekc"fgxg"guvcdgngegt"woc"tgnc›«q"guvtgkvc"
eqo" qu" hcvqu" fc" xkfc" eqvkfkcpc0" Q" eqorqtvcogpvq" fq" cpcnkucpvg" pq" oketq" owpfq"
gurc›q/vgorqtcn"fc"uguu«q"rukecpcn vkec"tgxgnc"ugw"eqorqtvcogpvq"pq"ocetq/owpfq4
eqvkfkcpq"swcpvq"cqu"ugwu"rgpucogpvqu."xcnqtgu"g"ugpvkogpvqu0"Uqdtg"c"xkxcekfcfg"fc"
gzrgtk‒pekc"g"fc"nkpiwcigo"eqnqswkcn"fgpvtq"fc"tgnc›«q"cpcn vkec."gng"fct "‒phcug"cq"
swguvkqpcogpvq:

Gpvgpfgt"c"xkfcA"Dkqp"hc|"dgo/jwoqtcfc"ogv hqtc<"c"tgcnkfcfg"p«q"rqfg"ugt"gpvgpfkfc"fc"
oguoc"hqtoc"swg"p«q"ug"rqfg"ecpvct"dcvcvcu0"Rqfg/ug"rncpv /ncu."fguecue /ncu."eq|kpj /ncu."
ocu"p«q"ecpv /ncu0"Rqfg/ug"xkxgt"c"xkfc."c"tgcnkfcfg."woc"tghgk›«q."woc"uguu«q"fg"cp nkug0"G"
c"guetkvc"fg"wo"cwvqt"tgcn."swg"kocikpg"uko"c"rctvkt"fg"woc"gzrgtk‒pekc."ocu"c"rctvkt"fg"woc"
gzrgtk‒pekc" tgcn." p«q" fg" uwc" ogpvg0" P«q" ug" vtcvc" fg" gnkvkuoq." pkpiwfio" gurgtc" swg" ngkvqtgu"
fg"wo"ocpwcn"fg"rknqvcigo"fg"cxk gu."fg"nkxtqu"fg"eq|kpjc"qw"fg"ctvgu"ug"vqtpgo"rknqvqu."
eq|kpjgktqu"qw"ctvkuvcu"go"hwp›«q"fc"ngkvwtc0"ÐQ"gtwfkvq"fi"woc"rguuqc"swg"ucdg"swg"wo"guetkvq"
fi"fg"Htgwf"g"Mngkp."ocu"Ýec"egiq"rctc"c"eqkuc"fguetkvcÑ"*UCPFNGT."u1f<"9+0

GurgekÝecogpvg."pc"ffiecfc"fg"82."Dkqp"ug"fgfkec"cqu"hgp»ogpqu"rgtvkpgpvgu"
"i‒pgug"g" "pcvwtg|c"fqu"rgpucogpvqu."pqu"curgevqu"pqtocku"g"rcvqn„ikequ."kpkekcpfq"
woc"hcug"ocku"rtqh ewc"fg"uwc"qdtc0"Ugo"lcocku"fgkzct"fg"ug"kpvgtguuct."fg"rtcvkect."g"
fg"guvgpfgt"uwcu"eqpegr› gu"rukecpcn vkecu"cq"ecorq"fc"tgnc›«q"fq"kpfkx fwq"eqpukiq"
rt„rtkq." eqo" qu" itwrqu" cqu" swcku" rgtvgpeg" g" eqo" c" uqekgfcfg0" Dkqp" wnvtcrcuuqw" q"
kpvgtguug"mngkpkcpq"swcpvq" "korqtv¤pekc"fc"tgcnkfcfg"gzvgtpc."rqku"cetgfkvcxc"swg"go"
kfcfg"rtgeqeg"l "crtgpfgoqu"c"Ðugt"p„u"oguoquÑ"qw"c"Ðswgo"fgxgoqu"ugtÑ."rqtswg"
owkvq" egfq" go" pquucu" xkfcu" tgegdgoqu" t„vwnqu." fkcip„uvkequ" g" kpvgtrtgvc› gu" dgo"
guvcdgngekfqu"rgnqu"qwvtqu"cegtec"fg"swgo"uqoqu0"Uqdtg"q"ect vgt"hgpqogpqn„ikeq"fq"
crtgpfgt"eqo"c"gzrgtk‒pekc<

Dkqp"guvcxc"eqpxgpekfq"swg"c"cp nkug"rguuqcn"gtc"c"¿pkec"hqtoc"gÝec|"fg"hqtoct"rukecpcnkuvcu0"
Rctc" gng." c" uguu«q" cpcn vkec" eqpuvkvwk" c" rtkogktc" hqpvg" fg" eqpjgekogpvq" gzrgtkogpvcn." g"
p«q" rqfgtkc" jcxgt" pgo" q" crtgpfgt/eqo/c/gzrgtk‒pekc" pgo" q" etguekogpvq" ogpvcn" ugo" wo"
eqpvkpgpvg"ocvgtpq"pq"kp ekq"fg"vwfq0"C"o«g"oqfwnc"c"xkx‒pekc"goqekqpcn0"C"rêverie materna
ug" fgugpxqnxg" eqorngvcogpvg" go" fqku" tgikuvtqu<" goqekqpcn" g" kpvgngevwcn" *fkuvkpiwkfqu"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

4" Dkqp"vcodfio"cetgfkvcxc"swg"vcpvq"q"oketq/owpfq"fc"rukecp nkug."swcpvq"q"ocetq/owpfq"fc"

xkfc"pq"ugw"vqfq."rqfgtkc"ugt"gpvgpfkfc"g"gzgtekfc"cvtcxfiu"fg"vt‒u"xfitvkegu"*rqpvqu"fg"xkuvc+<"tgnkikquq/
o uvkeq."ocvgo vkeq/ekgpv Ýeq."g"guvfivkeq/ctv uvkeq0

18 ago 2009 89
 crgpcu" rgnc" pgeguukfcfg" fg" gzrquk›«q." rqku" pc" xgtfcfg" u«q" kpgzvtkecxgnogpvg" nkicfqu+"
*DN¡CPFQPW."3;;5<"37415+30

C"kpukuvgpvg"eqttgnc›«q"g"eqpuvcpvg"rctcngnq"swg"Dkqp"hc|"gpvtg"cu"qeqtt‒pekcu"
fqu"hgp»ogpqu"goqekqpcku"fgpvtq"fq"gurc›q/vgorq"fc"uguu«q"cpcn vkec"g"pc"tgnc›«q"
gpvtg"cpcnkuvc/cpcnkucpvg."eqo"cu"qeqtt‒pekcu"fqu"hgp»ogpqu"goqekqpcku"gzrgtkgpekcfqu"
eqvkfkcpcogpvg."guv "nkicfc"cq"swg"gng"fgpqokpc"x pewnq"fq"eqpjgekogpvq."qw"rwnu«q"
fq"ucdgt."cnfio"fqu"x pewnqu"fg"coqt"g"fg"„fkq."eqoq"wpkÝecfqt"fc"tgnc›«q"gzvgtpq"g"
kpvgtpq0"Uqdtg"guug"vgtegktq"x pewnq."Dkqp"kt "fk|gt<

Gpswcpvq" Htgwf" cnkegt›qw" uwc" vgqtkc" guugpekcnogpvg" pcu" rwnu gu" nkdkfkpcku." g" Mngkp." pcu"
tgnc› gu"qdlgvcku"citguukxcu."tgrtgugpvcfcu"rgnc"kpxglc"rtko tkc"g"fgtkxcfqu."Dkqp"cetguegpvqw"
wo"vgtegktq"x pewnq"hwpfcogpvcn"cnfio"fq"coqt"g"fq"„fkq<"q"x pewnq"fq"eqpjgekogpvq."fg"
korqtv¤pekc" hwpfcogpvcn" pc" rt vkec" en pkec." rqtswg" xcnqtk|c" uqdtgoqfq" ucdgt" eqoq" qu"
rcekgpvgu"ug"tgncekqpco"eqo"cu"xgtfcfgu."hcnukfcfgu."hcnukÝec› gu"g"ogpvktcu0"Dkqp"ejgic"c"
cÝtoct"swg."vcn"eqoq"q"eqtrq"pgeguukvc"fg"cnkogpvqu"g"fg"qzki‒pkq"rctc"uqdtgxkxgt."vcodfio"q"
rukswkuoq"ug"cnkogpvc"g"etgueg"eqo"cu"xgtfcfgu."g"ugo"gncu."eck"go"guvcfq"fg"kpcpk›«q"g"rqfg"
Ýect"eqttq fq"rgnq"xgpgpq"fcu"ogpvktcu"g"hcnukÝec› gu"*¥KOGTOCP."u1f<"42/44+

Go" Dkqp." c" cvkvwfg" fg" eqpuvcpvg" dwuecfqt" fq" eqpjgekogpvq" g" fc" xgtfcfg."
uqd" rgtocpgpvg"guvcfq"ogpvcn"fg"kpvgttqic›«q"g"cdgtvwtc" "fgueqdgtvc."u«q"cvkvwfgu"
rtqr ekcu" "c›«q"fq"ekgpvkuvc"g"fq cpcnkuvc"fwtcpvg"uguu«q"fg"cp nkug."rqtswg"tgxgnco"
woc" ewtkqukfcfg" ucfkc" g" woc" eqtcigo" rctc" q" gphtgpvcogpvq" fcu" xgtfcfgu" vcodfio"
fqnqtqucu."swg"fguxgngo"cu"hcnucu"knwu gu"pctekukuvcu"fcu"xgtfcfgu"Ýpcku<

C" rquvwtc" ekgpv Ýeq/Ýnqu„Ýec" rtgeqpk|cfc"rqt" Dkqp" rqfgtkc" dgo" ugt" ejcocfc"fg" Ðcvkvwfg"
uqet vkecÑ." vgpfq" go" xkuvc" swg" U„etcvgu." ugiwpfq" c" fguetk›«q" swg" fgng" hc|go" Rncv«q" g"
Ctkuv„vgngu." hqk" q" rtkogktq" c" rtqrqt" c" guugpekcnkfcfg" fq" Ðeqpjgegt/vg" c" vk" oguoqÑ" g" swg."
rctc" ug" ejgict" c" kuvq" Ðp«q" gpukpcxc" xgtfcfgu" vgtokpcfcu." ugp«q" swg" gpukpcxc" c" crtgpfgt0"
U„etcvgu"kpvgttqic."ocu"p«q"tgurqpfg0"C"xgtfcfg"fi"fkh ekn"rqtswg"f„k0"Rctc"eqpjgegt."hc|"hcnvc"
vgt"vqngt¤pekc"cpvg"q"uqhtkogpvq."g"xcnqt"rctc"ugiwkt"cfkcpvg"ugo"eckt"go"ogpvktcu"uqdtg"p„u"
oguoqu000Ñ0"Dkqp"ugortg"fguvceqw"swg"q"qdlgvkxq"rtge rwq"fg"woc"cp nkug"fi"q"etguekogpvq"
ogpvcn"fq"cpcnkucpfq"*¥KOGTOCP."u1f<"44+0

Etguekogpvq"ogpvcn."go"xg|"fg"ewtc."woc"pqxc"rgturgevkxc"kpvtqfw|kfc"pc"
fqwvtkpc"rukecpcn vkec"rqt"Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"Dkqp."swg"ceqpvgeg"pc"dwuec."eqphtqpvq"g"
eqpswkuvc"fc"xgtfcfg"rgnc"xgtfcfg"uqd"q"x pewnq"fq"eqpjgekogpvq."kfgpvkÝecfq"cr„u"

5" C"o«g"tgcn"*swg"oqfwnc"c"xkx‒pekc"goqekqpcn+"fi"q"rtkogktq"eqpvkpgpvg"gurc›q/vgorqtcn"fc"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

etkcp›c."uwc"rtkogktc"tgnc›«q"xkpewnct"qdlgvcn"g"eqowpkecekqpcn="g"c"ecrcekfcfg"fg"t‒xgtkg"ocvgtpc"
*rgtegr›«q."kpvgtrtgvc›«q"g"fgxqnw›«q1tgvqtpq"cqu"ukpcku"gokvkfqu"rgnq"dgd‒+"fguvc"o«g"cq"ugw"dgd‒"
pguvc"tgnc›«q"Î"ugtxkt«q"fg"rtqv„vkrq"fcu"tgnc› gu"xkpewnctgu"fg"coqt."„fkq"g"eqpjgekogpvq"gpvtg"qu"
owpfqu"kpvgtpq"g"gzvgtpq."fqu"qdlgvqu"kpvgtpq"g"gzvgtpq."fcu"tgnc› gu"qdlgvcku"eqo"q"owpfq."g"ngxcfcu"
"tgnc›«q"fg"cp nkug0

90 18 ago 2009
qu"fqku"x pewnqu"crqpvcfq"rqt"Ukiowpf"Htgwf"g"Ogncpkg"Mngkp"Î"coqt"g"„fkq4."rqtswg"
Ðc"xgtfcfg"fi"q"cnkogpvq"fc"ogpvgÑ<

Guvcdgngegoqu"rtqxkuqtkcogpvg"swg"c"fkhgtgp›c"gpvtg"wo"rgpucogpvq"*q"rgpuct+"xgtfcfgktq"g"
woc"ogpvktc"*c"p«q/xgtfcfg"qw"eqorwnu«q+"eqpukuvg"pq"hcvq"swg"wo"rgpucfqt"fi"nqikecogpvg"
pgeguu tkq"rctc"c"ogpvktc."ocu"p«q"rctc"q"rgpucogpvq"xgtfcfgktq0"Pkpiwfio"rtgekuc"rgpuct"
q"rgpucogpvq"xgtfcfgktq<"guvg"ciwctfc"q"cfxgpvq"fq"rgpucfqt"swg"ug"rgtuqpkÝec"cvtcxfiu"fq"
rgpuct"xgtfcfgktq0"C"ogpvktc"g"ugw"rgpucfqt"u«q"kpugrct xgku0"Q"rgpucfqt"p«q"vgo"pgpjwoc"
korqtv¤pekc" rctc" xgtfcfg." ocu" c" xgtfcfg" fi" nqikecogpvg" pgeguu tkc" rctc" q" rgpucfqt0" Uwc"
ukipkÝec›«q" fgrgpfg" fg" gng" gpvtgvgt" qw" p«q" q" rgpucogpvq." ocu" q" rgpucogpvq" rgtocpgeg"
kpcnvgtcfq0"Cq" eqpvt tkq." c" ogpvktc" icpjc" gzkuv‒pekc" grkuvgoqnqikecogpvg." go" xktvwfg" fc"
gzkuv‒pekc"fq"ogpvktquq0"Qu"¿pkequ"rgpucogpvqu"rctc"qu"swcku"fi"cduqnwvcogpvg"guugpekcn"wo"
rgpucfqt"u«q"cu"ogpvktcu0"C"v ekvc"uwrquk›«q"fg"Fguectvgu."fg"swg"q"rgpucogpvq"rtguuwr g"
wo" rgpucfqt." u„" fi" x nkfc" rctc" c" ogpvktc" *qw" c" p«q/xgtfcfg+0" *DKQP." 3;95<" 335" g" 3;;3<"
336+0

Fkhgtgpvgogpvg"fg"Fguectvgu."rctc"swgo"q"rgpucfqt"rtggzkuvg"cq"rgpucogpvq."
Dkqp"cetgfkvcxc"swg"q"rgpucogpvq"rtggzkuvg"cq"rgpucfqt"g"q"eqpjgegt"guv "rctc"cnfio"
fg"gpvgpfgt"g"fg"gzrnkect0"Eqpjgegt"fi"crtqzkoct/ug"vcpvq"swcpvq"rquu xgn"fc"xgtfcfg."
qw"uglc."fi"wo"rtqeguuq"fg"eqpjgegt"Ðcswknq"swg"fiÑ."fi"wo"crtqzkoct/ug"fc"tgcnkfcfg"fqu"
hcvqu0"Q"rtqeguuq"fg"eqpjgegt"*M"/"know+"vgpfg"c"gxqnwkt"rctc"wo"eqpjgekogpvq"ocku"
rtqhwpfq"*Q+."ÐQÑ."u odqnq"rtqrquvq"rqt"gng"rctc"c"Ðeqkuc"go"ukÑ."ugiwpfq"Mcpv."qw"cu"
ÐhqtocuÑ."ugiwpfq"Rncv«q50"Uqdtg"c"tgnc›«q"gpvtg"tgcnkfcfg"g"rgpucogpvq<

Dkqp" uwigtg" swg" q" rgpucfqt" p«q" etkc" qu" rgpucogpvqu=" ocu" swg" q" crctgnjq" fg" rgpuct" ug"
fgugpxqnxg"rtguukqpcfq"rgnc"tgcnkfcfg0"Cetgueg"ocku"wo"iqnrg" "qpkrqv‒pekc"jwocpc."cqu"fg"
Eqrfitpkeq."Fctykp"g"Htgwf0"Qu"rgpucogpvqu"Ðl "guv«q"n Ñ."ciwctfcpfq"wo"rgpucfqt"swg"qu"
rgpug0"Eqorctq"c"ukvwc›«q"cq"qzki‒pkq."swg"l "guv "n ."gurgtcpfq"wo"rwno«q"swg"q"tgurktg0"C"
rukecp nkug"l "gzkuvkc"cpvgu"fg"wo"Htgwf"rgpu /nc."fk|kc"Dkqp0"Woc"cpcnqikc<"c"tgncvkxkfcfg"l "
gzkuvkc."vtknj gu"fg"cpqu"cpvgu"fg"wo"Gkpuvgkp"rgpu /nc"*UCPFNGT"E0."u1f<32+0

Uqw"wo"rgpucogpvq"dwuecpfq"wo"rgpucfqt"swg"og"f‒"pcuekogpvq0"Fguvtwktgk"q"rgpucfqt"
cuuko"swg"q"gpeqpvtct0"Uqw"c"Qfkuufikc."c"Kn cfc."c"Gpgkfc000"gw"uqw"q"gvgtpcogpvg"xkxq000"Ogw"
vtkwphq"fi"c"ogpvg000"Uqw"q"rgpucogpvq"ugo"rgpucfqt"g"q"rgpucogpvq"cduvtcvq"swg"fguvtwkw"

6" Cu"xcn‒pekcu"cvkxcfcu"rgnqu"uwrquvqu"d ukequ"fc"ogpvg"hwpekqpco"eqoq"xgtfcfgktqu"xfitvkegu"

fg"eqpfw›«q"fqu"x pewnqu"fg"coqt"g"fg"„fkq"l "rtgeqpk|cfqu"rqt"Htgwf"*g"tghqt›cfqu"rqt"Mngkp."eqo"
‒phcug"pq"„fkq+."g"ckpfc."ugiwpfq"q"cetfiuekoq"kpvtqfw|kfq"rqt"Dkqp."q"x pewnq"fq"eqpjgekogpvq0"Q"
okvq"fg"¡fkrq"egpvtcfq"pc"vtcififkc"fg"wo"etkog"ugzwcn"Î"kpeguvq."rcttke fkq"g"cpi¿uvkc"fg"ecuvtc›«q"/"
pc"vgqtkc"rukecpcn vkec"fg"Htgwf."ugt "vcodfio"tgfkogpukqpcfq"rqt"Dkqp"swg"q"xgt "ocku"fq"swg"egpvtc/
12ª Jornada Peirceana

fq"pc"swguv«q"fc"ugzwcnkfcfg."egpvtcfq"pc"swguv«q"fc"ewtkqukfcfg"g"fq"eqpjgekogpvq"g"fc"cpi¿uvkc"fg"
cpkswkncogpvq"Î"gpeqpvtq"eqo"c"guÝpig"swg"rtqr g"gpkiocu"uqd"woc"cogc›c"oqtv hgtc"/"g"rqt"Dkqp"
guswgocvk|cfq"pc"vt cfg<"30"Cttqi¤pekc="40"Ewtkqukfcfg"ugo"nkokvgu="50"Guvwrkfg|"ogpvcn0
7" Dkqp"guvcxc"kpvkocogpvg"eqpxgpekfq"fc"Ðkorqtv¤pekc"fc"hqtoc›«q"fq"u odqnq"rctc"q"fgugp/
xqnxkogpvq"fq"giqÑ"*DN¡CPFQPW."3;;5<"338+0

18 ago 2009 91
 ugw"rgpucfqt."v«q"u dkq"swcpvq"Pgyvqp."q"eqpvkpgpvg"swg"coc"ugw"eqpvg¿fq"cvfi"c"fguvtwk›«q="
q"eqpvg¿fq"swg"gzrnqfg"ugw"eqpvkpgpvg"rquuguukxq"*DKQP."3;:;<"68+0

3. Eqpukfgtc› gu"Rctekcku<
Eqoq"Rgkteg"g"Dkqp"tgncekqpco"c"tgcnkfcfg"fqu"hcvqu"gzvgtpqu"pq"gueqrq"fcu"
c› gu"ogpvckuA
Rgkteg"g"Dkqp"crtgugpvco"go"uwcu"qdtcu"q"rtkpe rkq"fg"tgcnkfcfg"hgpqo‒pkec"
fqu"hgp»ogpqu"swg"guv«q"cdgtvqu" "qdugtxc›«q."q"rtkpe rkq"fq"korwnuq"kpuvkpvkxq"fq"
eqpjgekogpvq"g"q"fc"tgnc›«q"gpvtg"eqpjgekogpvq"g"etguekogpvq0"GurgekÝecogpvg."go"
Dkqp."c"tgnc›«q"cpcnkuvc/cpcnkucpfq"ewortg"c"hwp›«q"kpxguvkicvkxc."g"jgwt uvkec."fg"p«q"
eku«q"fq"eqorqtvcogpvq"fq"kpfkx fwq"gpswcpvq"fgpvtq"qw"hqtc"fc"uguu«q"fg"cp nkug0"
Eqpvwfq."guuc"fgÝpk›«q"fg"c›«q"grkuv‒okec"ug"godcuc"pc"eqpvkpwkfcfg"g"pc"qdlgvkxkfcfg"
fq"rgpucogpvq."qw"oguoq"fc"c›«q"ogpvcn."swg"p«q"ug"qtkikpc"pq"cvq"kphgtgpekcn"fq"
rgpuct"jwocpq"g"owkvq"ogpqu"guv "tguvtkvq"c"guug"cvq0"Cuuko."q"rgpucfqt"fi"rtguukqpcfq"
rgnc"tgcnkfcfg."rqku"qu"rgpucogpvqu"ecrvwtco"wo"rgpucfqt"swg"qu"rgpug."qw"ognjqt<

Dkqp" uwuvgpvcxc" swg" q" rtkpe rkq" fc" tgcnkfcfg" hwpekqpcxc" ugortg" ukownvcpgcogpvg" eqo" q"
rtkpe rkq"fq"rtc|gt0"É"ogfkfc"swg"icpjc"go"tgcnkuoq."c"rukswg"uwduvkvwk"rgnq"rgpucogpvq"c"
fguectic"oqvqtc"wvknk|cpfq/c"rctc"oqfkÝect"q"codkgpvg0"Dkqp"eqpukfgtqw"qu"ÐrgpucogpvquÑ"
eqoq" grkuvgoqnqikecogpvg" cpvgtkqtgu" " Ðcvkxkfcfg" fg" rgpuctÑ0" Uwuvgpvcxc" swg" c" rukswg" fi"
qdtkicfc"c"rgpuct"rqku"ug"fgrctc"eqo"rgpucogpvqu"swg"cpvgegfgo"c"rt„rtkc"gzkuv‒pekc"fgnc"
*DN¡CPFQPW."3;9;<"362/364+0

Pc"qdtc"fg"Rgkteg."pq"The Categories Continued, no trecho Vjg"Kttgfwekdknkv{"

of the Categories."fg"3;24."crguct"fg"c"Tgcnkfcfg"ugt"vgoc"fg"kpxguvkic›«q"pq"ecorq"fc"
Rukeqnqikc"gpswcpvq"ek‒pekc"gurgekcn"fi"korqtvcpvg"fguvcect"c"fkuvkp›«q"gpvtg"Rukeqnqikc"
g"N„ikec."godqtc"q"cwvqt"vcodfio"tgncekqpg"q"rukeqnqikuoq"jwocpq"eqo"c"swguv«q"fq"
kpuvkpvq<"

Q"rtqdngoc"rukeqn„ikeq"guv "pcswknq"swg"rtqeguuc"g"rgteqttg"c"ogpvg0"Ocu"c"swguv«q"n„ikec"fi"
ug"c"eqpenwu«q"swg"ugt "cnecp›cfc."cq"crnkect"guvc"qw"cswgnc"o zkoc."guvct "qw"p«q"fg"ceqtfq"
com o fato0"Rqfg"ugt"swg"c"ogpvg"guvglc"fg"vcn"oqfq"eqpuvkvw fc"swg"cswknq"swg"pquuq"kpuvkpvq"
kpvgngevwcn" crtqxc" ugt " xgtfcfgktq" pc" fkogpu«q" rctc" c" swcn" guvg" kpuvkpvq" c" crtqxc0" Ugpfq"
cuuko."guvg"fi"wo"hcvq"kpvgtguucpvg"uqdtg"c"ogpvg"jwocpc."ocu"p«q"vgo"go"cduqnwvq"tgngx¤pekc"
rctc"c"N„ikec"*ER"70:7"3;24+0

Wo" rtkpe rkq" n„ikeq" fc" kpxguvkic›«q" rgktegcpc" fc" tgcnkfcfg" guv " go"
eqortggpfgt"q"hcvq"tgcn"fg"swg"Ðqu"oguoqu"qdlgvqu"swg"guv«q"kogfkcvcogpvg"rtgugpvgu"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

em nossas mentes na experiência, realmente existem, tal como são experimentados,

hqtc"fc"ogpvgÑ"*ER":038"3:93."apud"RGKTEG"3;;2<"544+0"Rgkteg"kpswktg"uqdtg"q"rqfgt"
swg"cu"eqkucu"gzvgtpcu"v‒o"uqdtg"fgvgtokpcfqu"eqorqtvcogpvqu"c"rctvkt"fg"ugpuc› gu."

92 18 ago 2009
go" fkogpu«q" jwocpc." crtgugpvcpfq" q" gzgornq" fc" eqpuvcvc›«q" fg" swg" Ðas pessoas
dormem depois de tomar ópioÑ"*ER":034"3:93."apud"RGKTEG"3;;2<"543+0"Guuc"kffikc"
ug" gxkfgpekc" pguvc" kpfcic›«q<" ÐSwcn" q" poder" swg" v‒o" cu" eqkucu" gzvgtpcu" fg" chgvct"
qu" ugpvkfquA" ]000_" p«q" fi" c" gzkuv‒pekc" rtgugpvg" fg" ug" rqfgt" qwvtc" eqkuc" swg" p«q" woc"
tgiwnctkfcfg"go"gxgpvqu"hwvwtqu"tgncekqpcfqu"eqo"woc"egtvc"eqkuc"gpectcfc"eqoq"wo"
gngogpvq" swg" fgxg" ugt" eqpukfgtcfq" fg" cpvgo«q." pc" eqpegr›«q" fcswgnc" eqkucAÑ" *ER"
:034"3:93."apud"RGKTEG"3;;2<"543+0
Pq"ecuq"fg"Dkqp."q"vgtegktq"rgt qfq"grkuvgoqn„ikeq."rctc"kpxguvkic›«q"fq"swg"
rqfgtkc"ugt"q"kfgcn"fc"rukecp nkug"ekgpv Ýec."ngxqw/q"c"cfgpvtct"q"wpkxgtuq"fc"ogpvg"
jwocpc."fq"rgpucogpvq"*g"ugwu"fkuv¿tdkqu+."gncdqtcpfq"woc"vgqtkc"fc"c›«q"ogpvcn."qw"
woc"vgqtkc"uqdtg"q"eqpjgekogpvq"gzrgtkogpvcn."uqdtg"c"pqvc›«q"rukecpcn vkec."uqdtg"
qu"fkuv¿tdkqu"fq"eqpjgekogpvq"g"etguekogpvq"ogpvcn0"Gng"guvcdgngegw"Ðnc›qu."fg"wo"
ncfq."eqo"c"rukecp nkug"g"fq"qwvtq"eqo"c"ÝnquqÝc."c"ocvgo vkec."c"h ukec."c"ctvg000Ñ"
*DN¡PCPFQPW." 3;9;<" 33+0" Go" ugw" rtkogktq" rgt qfq." ckpfc" crtgpfgpfq" eqo" qu"
itwrqu."Dkqp"qdugtxqw"swg qu"hgp»ogpqu"fg"kpvgtc›«q"go"itwrqu"jwocpqu"gxkfgpekco"
eqoq"cu"tgnc› gu"kpvgtrguuqcku"g"kpvtcrguuqcku"guv«q"kogtucu"go"uwrquvqu"d ukequ"swg"
u«q"eqocpfcfqu"rgnc"ogpvg"rtkokvkxc"qw"rtqvqogpvg0"Pgnc"u«q"cvkxcfcu"xcn‒pekcu*6+,
qw"xfitvkegu"fg"eqpfw›«q."vcku"eqoq"q"fg"cwvqocvkuoq"ogpvcn"g"qpkrqv‒pekc."eqphqtog"
ug"f "pq"etguekogpvq"ogpvcn"g"pc"eqpswkuvc"fc"cwvqpqokc"tgncekqpcfcu"c"eqpÝiwtc› gu"
fg"fgrgpf‒pekc."iwgttc"g"kf nkq."eqo"oqxkogpvqu"fg"cvcswg"g"hwic."tkxcnkfcfg"jquvkn."
etwgnfcfg"rqn‒okecu."kpxglc"g"xqtcekfcfg"ekwogpvc."uwurgkvcu"rctcp„kfgu"fg"ncxcigo"
egtgdtcn"g"fqwvtkpcu"kfgqn„ikecu."cnk u."swg"rqfgo"fguvtwkt"hwp› gu"fc"xkfc"ogpvcn0"
Go"u pvgug."Dkqp"qdugtxqw"pguvcu"fkp¤okecu"q"en uukeq"godcvg"gpvtg"q"pcteku/
kuoq"g"q"uqekcn/kuoq"g"c"rtgugp›c"fg"wo"ekenq"fg"fgugpxqnxkogpvq"g"etguekogpvq"fc"
fkp¤okec"ogpvcn"swg"ug"f "rqt"hwp› gu"g"ecvgiqtkcu"fq"rgpucogpvq0"Fq"rgpuct"go"okvqu"
g"vgt"uqpjqu"fkwtpqu"g"pqvwtpqu"fg"x xkfc"swcnkfcfg"rkev„tkec"cvfi"qu"eqpegkvqu"cduvtcvqu."
rqt" gng"encuukÝecfqu"g"fkuvtkdw fqu"pc"ÐItcfgÑ."fgugpxqnxkfc"pc"qdtc"Gngogpvqu"fg"
Rukecp nkug."fg"3;85."ocu"swg"p«q"ugt«q"guvwfcfqu"pguvg"ctvkiq0
Rctc"Dkqp."c"pgic›«q"fc"tgcnkfcfg"kornkectkc"c"korquukdknkfcfg"fg"kpvgitc›«q"
g" rgtegr›«q" fcu" fkhgtgpvgu" rctvgu" fg" wo" oguoq" vqfq" g" fq" fgugpxqnxkogpvq" fq"
rgpucogpvq" xgtdcn." jkr„vgug" hqtowncfc" go" uwc" vgqtkc" fq" eqpjgekogpvq" c" rctvkt" fc"
cp nkug"fqu"fkuv¿tdkqu"fq"rgpucogpvq"g"fc"vgqtkc"fcu"tgnc› gu"fg"qdlgvq."dgo"eqoq."pq"
gueqrq"fc"tgnc›«q"gpvtg"c"rquk›«q"ruke„vkec"g"c"qrquk›«q"dkp tkc"*xgt"DN¡CPFQPW."
12ª Jornada Peirceana

3;9;<"355"g"356/35:+0"C"etgp›c"dkqpkcpc"fc"eqpvkpwkfcfg"gzrgtkgpekcn"g"kphgtgpekcn"
fg" nkic›«q" eqo" cu" tgcnkfcfgu" gzvgtpcu" fqu" hgp»ogpqu" pq" owpfq" ug" eqcfwpc" eqo" c"
eqpegr›«q" rgktegcpc" fq" fgugpxqnxkogpvq" hwvwtq" fc" gzrgtk‒pekc" eqoq" wo" xkt/c/ugt
eqoq" woc" rtqitguukxc" eqpetg›«q" fqu" j dkvqu" fg" kphgt‒pekc." qtkikp tkc" pc" n„ikec"

18 ago 2009 93
 kphgtgpekcn"cdfwvkxc."vgpfgpfq."vgngqnqikecogpvg."rctc"ugwu"Ýpu."ugo"swg"kuvq"kornkswg"
swcnswgt"fgvgtokpkuoq."rqku"c"eqphqtog"Ucpvcgnnc<

000"cegkvc›«q"eqpuekgpvg"fg"wo"j dkvq"fg"kphgt‒pekc"gpxqnxg"woc"gzrgevcvkxc"fg"swg"q"ewtuq"
hwvwtq"fc"gzrgtk‒pekc"vqtpct "cswgng"j dkvq"gÝec|0"Cuuko."c"fkuvkp›«q"pqtocvkxc"gpvtg"woc"dqc"
qw"o "kphgt‒pekc"gpxqnxg"tghgt‒pekc"p«q"crgpcu"cq"Ýo"kfgcn"fq"rgpucogpvq."ocu"vcodfio" "
kpfcic›«q"ug"c"gzrgevcvkxc"ugt "rtggpejkfc"qw"p«q0"Woc"xg|"swg"Rgkteg"cetgfkvcxc"pq"Ðnqpiq"
ewtuqÑ"fq"vgorq."rctc"gng."q"Ýo"kfgcn"fq"rgpucogpvq"pcuegtkc"cvtcxfiu"fc"gzrgtk‒pekc"hwvwtc0"
Cuuko"ugpfq."cu"ek‒pekcu"pqtocvkxcu"vgtkco"rqt"vctghc"gzcokpct"cu"ngku"fg"eqphqtokfcfg"fcu"
eqkucu"cqu"Ýpu."guvc"c"tc|«q"rqt"swg"hqtco"ejcocfcu"fg"pqtocvkxcu."swgt"fk|gt."woc"ek‒pekc"
pqtocvkxc"fi"q"guvwfq"fq"swg"fgxg"ugt"*ER"3043:+."q"swg"gzenwk."eqpugs¯gpvgogpvg"fg"ugw"
ecorq."vcpvq"c"eqorwnu«q"kpeqpvtqncfc"swcpvq"q"fgvgtokpkuoq"t ikfq."woc"xg|"swg."eqoq"
pqu"ngodtc"Rqvvgt"*3;;8<"9"g"7/54+."fi"ugortg"rquu xgn"ug"cikt"eqpvtctkcogpvg"cq"swg"fgxg"ugt"
*UCPVCGNNC"3;;5<"439+0

C" gzenwu«q" vcpvq" fc" eqorwnu«q" kpeqpvtqncfc"swcpvq" q" fgvgtokpkuoq"t ikfq"

u«q"ectcevgt uvkecu"rtgugpvgu"pc"qdtc"fg"Rgkteg"g"fg"Dkqp0"C"cÝtoc›«q"fg"Rgkteg"swg"
ug."rqt"wo"ncfq"qu"ectcevgtgu"fcu"eqkucu"tgcku"p«q"fgrgpfgo"fg"pquucu"qrkpk gu."rqt"
qwvtq."g"cq"oguoq"vgorq"chgvco"pquuqu"ugpvkfqu"*ER"7057:/:9+"guv "eqpvgorncfc"pc"
vgqtkc"fg"Dkqp0"Rgkteg"l "jcxkc"rtgpwpekcfq."go"3:8:."swg"Ðvqfcu"pquucu"eqpegr› gu"
u«q" qdvkfcu" rqt" cduvtc› gu" g" eqodkpc› gu" fg" eqipk› gu" swg" qeqttgo" kpkekcnogpvg"
pqu"lw |qu"fc"gzrgtk‒pekc0"]000_"Rqt"eqpugiwkpvg."q"ocku"gngxcfq"eqpegkvq"swg"ug"rqfg"
cvkpikt"rqt"cduvtc› gu"c"rctvkt"fqu"lw |qu"fc"gzrgtk‒pekc"Î"g."rqtvcpvq."q"ocku"gngxcfq"
eqpegkvq"swg"rqfg"ugt"cvkpikfq"go"igtcn"Î"fi"q"eqpegkvq"fg"cniq"swg"fi"fc"pcvwtg|c"fg"
woc"eqipk›«q"*ER"70477/479"fg3:8:+0
Ug" Rgkteg" dwueqw" tgurquvc" cq" gpkioc" fq" wpkxgtuq." swg" owkvq" vgo" c" pqu"
gpukpct."cq"tgurqpfgt" "guÝpig"itgic"swg"cqu"ecokpjcpvgu"pq"gpvtqpecogpvq"fg"Vgdcu"
cdqtfcxc"rtqxqecvkxcogpvg."Dkqp"kiwcnogpvg"ug"gpvtgiqw"c"guvc"gzrgtk‒pekc."g"codqu"
ug"wvknk|ctco"fg"vt cfgu"rctc"p«q"ugtgo"fgxqtcfqu0"Uqdtg"guucu"pqu"fgfkectgoqu"go"
vtcdcnjqu"rquvgtkqtgu0

Pqvcu<
*3+"Jqogo"fg"xcuvc"g"rtqhwpfc"hqtoc›«q"jwocp uvkec"g"u„nkfc"ewnvwtc"igtcn."hqk"wo"crtgekcfqt"fcu"
ctvgu."tgxgnqw"vcngpvq"rctc"c"rkpvwtc"kortguukqpkuvc."g"p«q"njg"rcuuqw"fkuvcpvg"kpvgtguug"g"eqpjgekogpvq"
ukipkÝecvkxq"go"ocvgo vkec"*Ec{ng{"g"U{nxguvgt+"g"go"n„ikec"*Htgig+0"Fqku"ecucogpvqu."eqo"oqtvg"
rtgocvwtc"fg"uwc"rtkogktc"gurquc."fwcu"Ýnjcu."c"rtkogktc"rukecpcnkuvc"g"c"ugiwpfc"nkpi¯kuvc."g"wo"Ýnjq"
ofifkeq"cpguvgukuvc0"Cnkuvc/ug"xqnwpvctkcogpvg"rqt"fwcu"xg|gu"pq"gzfitekvq"dtkv¤pkeq"rctc"c"Rtkogktc"
g"c"Ugiwpfc"Iwgttcu"Owpfkcku0"Cqu"3:"cpqu"kpvgttqorgw"ugwu"guvwfqu"g"eqo"65"cpqu"kpvgttqorgw"
uwcu"cvkxkfcfgu"rtqÝuukqpcku"pc"En pkec"Vcxkuvqem0"Qewrqw"vqfcu"hwp› gu"fc"Uqekgfcfg"Dtkv¤pkec"fg"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

Rukecp nkug."ugpfq"ugw"rtgukfgpvg"gpvtg"3;84"g"3;870"Go"3;8:"guvgxg"pc"Cofitkec"Ncvkpc."tgcnk|cpfq"
kpvgpuc"rtqitcoc›«q"ekgpv Ýec"pc"Cuuqekc›«q"Rukecpcn vkec"Ctigpvkpc0"Guvgxg"pq"Dtcukn"go"3;95."
3;96."3;97"g"3;9:."tgurgevkxcogpvg"go"U«q"Rcwnq."Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq"g"U«q"Rcwnq."Dtcu nkc."g"U«q"
Rcwnq."tgcnk|cpfq"eqphgt‒pekcu."fgdcvgu."ugokp tkqu"en pkequ."guvgu"swg"tguwnvctco"pc"rwdnkec›«q"fcu"
Conferências brasileiras13;950"Eqo"q"vtcdcnjq"kpvkvwncfq"ÐQ"i‒ogq"kocikp tkqÑ"Dkqp"ug"vqtpqw"

94 18 ago 2009
ogodtq"fc"Uqekgfcfg"Dtkv¤pkec"fg"Rukecp nkug<"Ðc"hwp›«q"fq"i‒ogq"kocikp tkq"fi."rqtvcpvq."pgict"woc"
tgcnkfcfg"fkhgtgpvg"fgng"rt„rtkqÑ"*3;72.3;²"Î"rquvgtkqtogpvg"rwdnkecfq"go"Second Thoughts."3;89+0"
*4+"Dkqp"vcodfio"cetgfkvcxc"swg"vcpvq"q"oketq/owpfq"fc"rukecp nkug."swcpvq"q"ocetq/owpfq"fc"xkfc"
pq"ugw"vqfq."rqfgtkc"ugt"gpvgpfkfc"g"gzgtekfc"cvtcxfiu"fg"vt‒u"xfitvkegu"*rqpvqu"fg"xkuvc+<"tgnkikquq/
o uvkeq."ocvgo vkeq/ekgpv Ýeq."g"guvfivkeq/ctv uvkeq0
*5+"C"o«g"tgcn"*swg"oqfwnc"c"xkx‒pekc"goqekqpcn+"fi"q"rtkogktq"eqpvkpgpvg"gurc›q/vgorqtcn"fc"etkcp›c."
uwc"rtkogktc"tgnc›«q"xkpewnct"qdlgvcn"g"eqowpkecekqpcn="g"c"ecrcekfcfg"fg"rêverie ocvgtpc"*rgtegr›«q."
kpvgtrtgvc›«q"g"fgxqnw›«q1tgvqtpq"cqu"ukpcku"gokvkfqu"rgnq"dgd‒+"fguvc"o«g"cq"ugw"dgd‒"pguvc"tgnc›«q"
Î"ugtxkt«q"fg"rtqv„vkrq"fcu"tgnc› gu"xkpewnctgu"fg"coqt."„fkq"g"eqpjgekogpvq"gpvtg"qu"owpfqu"kpvgtpq"
g"gzvgtpq."fqu"qdlgvqu"kpvgtpq"g"gzvgtpq."fcu"tgnc› gu"qdlgvcku"eqo"q"owpfq."g"ngxcfcu" "tgnc›«q"fg"
cp nkug0"
*6+Cu"xcn‒pekcu"cvkxcfcu"rgnqu"uwrquvqu"d ukequ"fc"ogpvg"hwpekqpco"eqoq"xgtfcfgktqu"xfitvkegu"fg"
eqpfw›«q"fqu"x pewnqu"fg"coqt"g"fg"„fkq"l "rtgeqpk|cfqu"rqt"Htgwf"*g"tghqt›cfqu"rqt"Mngkp."eqo"
‒phcug"pq"„fkq+."g"ckpfc."ugiwpfq"q"cetfiuekoq"kpvtqfw|kfq"rqt"Dkqp."q"x pewnq"fq"eqpjgekogpvq0"Q"
okvq"fg"¡fkrq"egpvtcfq"pc"vtcififkc"fg"wo"etkog"ugzwcn"Î"kpeguvq."rcttke fkq"g"cpi¿uvkc"fg"ecuvtc›«q"
/"pc"vgqtkc"rukecpcn vkec"fg"Htgwf."ugt "vcodfio"tgfkogpukqpcfq"rqt"Dkqp"swg"q"xgt "ocku"fq"swg"
egpvtcfq"pc"swguv«q"fc"ugzwcnkfcfg."egpvtcfq"pc"swguv«q"fc"ewtkqukfcfg"g"fq"eqpjgekogpvq"g"fc"
cpi¿uvkc"fg"cpkswkncogpvq"Î"gpeqpvtq"eqo"c"guÝpig"swg"rtqr g"gpkiocu"uqd"woc"cogc›c"oqtv hgtc"/"
g"rqt"Dkqp"guswgocvk|cfq"pc"vt cfg<"30"Cttqi¤pekc="40"Ewtkqukfcfg"ugo"nkokvgu="50"Guvwrkfg|"ogpvcn0"
*7+"Dkqp"guvcxc"kpvkocogpvg"eqpxgpekfq"fc"Ðkorqtv¤pekc"fc"hqtoc›«q"fq"u odqnq"rctc"q"
fgugpxqnxkogpvq"fq"giqÑ"*DN¡CPFQPW."3;;5<"338+0

Tghgt‒pekcu"Dkdnkqit Ýecu<
Qdtcu"fg"DKQP."Y0"T0<

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*3;;3+0"Q"Crtgpfgt"eqo"c"gzrgtk‒pekc0"Vtcf0"Lc{og"Ucnqo«q0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"
Kociq0

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*4226+0"Gngogpvqu"go"rukecp nkug0"Gngogpvu"qh"Ru{ejq/Cpcn{uku0"*3;85+."Vtcf0"
Lc{og"Ucnqo«q."Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0"

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*4226+0"Vtcpuhqtoc› gu."Vtcf0"Rcwnq"Eguct0"Ucpfngt0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0"

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*3;95+0"Cvgp›«q"g"kpvgtrtgvc›«q. Vtcf0"Ectnqu"Jgngqfqtq"R0"Chhqpuq0"Tkq"fg"
Lcpgktq<"Kociq0

DKQP."Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" *3;;3+0"Cvgp›«q" g" kpvgtrtgvc›«q. Vtcf0" Rcwnq" Fkcu" Eqtt‒c0" Tkq" fg" Lcpgktq<"
Kociq0

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*3;97+0 Conferências brasileiras,"Vtcf0"Rcwnq"Eqtt‒c0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0"

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*3;:;+0 Uma memória do futuro,"5"Xqnu0"K"Î"Uqpjq"*3;97+0"Rtkogktc"Gfk›«q"

Dtcukngktc."K/"Q"Uqpjq0"Vtcf0"Rcwnq"E0"Ucpfngt0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0"

DKQP."Yknhtgf"Twrtgejv"*3;;4+0"Eqpxgtucpfq"eqo"Dkqp."Vtcf0"Rcwnq"Ucpfngt0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0

DKQP." Yknhtgf" Twrtgejv" *4222+0" Eqikvc› gu." Vtcf0" Guvgt" Ucpfngt" g" Rcwnq" Ucpfngt0" Tkq" fg" Lcpgktq<"
Kociq0"
12ª Jornada Peirceana

Qwvtcu"Qdtcu<

DN¡CPFQPW." Ifitctf" *3;;5+0" Yknhtgf" T0" Dkqp<" c" xkfc" g" c" qdtc0" Vtcf0" Ncwtkeg" Jqqt{" (" Octegnnc"
Oqtvctc0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0

18 ago 2009 95
 HTGWF."Ukiowpf"*3;98+0"Gfk›«q"uvcpfctf"dtcukngktc"fcu"qdtcu"rukeqn„ikecu"eqorngvcu"fg"Ukiowpf"
Freud. Vtcf0"Lc{og"Ucnqo«q0"30"gf0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"Kociq0

MNGKP."Ogncpkg"*3;:3+0"Eqpvtkdwk› gu" "rukecp nkug0"Vtcf0"Okiwgn"Oknngv0"40"gf0"U«q"Rcwnq<"Oguvtg"

Lqw0

UCPFNGT."Guvgt"Jcfcuuc"*u1f+0"Fk nqiqu"kpvgtokvgpvgu0"Go"Wo"hwvwtq"inqdcn0"Eqng›«q"ogo„tkc"fc"
rukecp nkug."xqn080"Fwgvvq0"

UCPFNGT."Rcwnq"E0"*3;::+0"Kpvtqfw›«q"c"ÐWoc"ogo„tkc"fq"hwvwtqÑ."fg"Y0"T0"Dkqp0"Tkq"fg"Lcpgktq<"
Kociq0

UCPFNGT."Rcwnq"Eguct"*u1f+0"Yknhtgf"T0"Dkqp<"Woc"qdtc"go"ogv hqtc0"Go"Wo"hwvwtq"rnwtcn0"Eqng›«q"
ogo„tkc"g"rukecp nkug."xqn080"Fwgvvq0"

UCRKGP¥C." Cpvqpkq" *u1f+0" Q" ctswg„nqiq" fc" ogpvg0" Go" Wo" hwvwtq" rnwtcn0" Eqng›«q" ogo„tkc" g"
rukecp nkug."xqn080"Fwgvvq0

¥KOGTOCP."Fcxkf"G0"*4226+0"Dkqp."fc"vgqtkc" "rt vkec0"Rqtvq"Cngitg<"Ctvgu"Ofifkecu0

¥KOGTOCP."Fcxkf"G0"*u1f+0"Uma vida dialética."Go"Wo"hwvwtq"rnwtcn0"Eqng›«q"ogo„tkc"g"rukecp nkug."

xqn080"Fwgvvq0

Qdtcu"fg"RGKTEG."E0"U<

RGKTEG."Ejctngu"U00"Collected papers of Charles S. Peirce."E0"Jctvujqtpg."R0"Ygkuu"*gfu0+."x0"3/8."g"Y0"

Dwtmu"*gf0+."x0"9/:0"Ecodtkfig<"Jctxctf"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;53/3;7:0

RGKTEG."Ejctngu"U00 Ejctngu"U0"Rgkteg<"eqpvtkdwvkqpu"vq"vjg"pcvkqp0"M0"N0"Mgvpgt="L0"G0"Eqqm"*gfu0+."x0"
3/6."Nwddqem."Vgzcu"Vgej"Rtguu."3;97/3;:90

RGKTEG." Ejctngu" U00" The new elements of mathematics by Charles S. Peirce0" Ectqn{p" Gkugng" *gf0+0"
Dgtnkp<"Oqwvqp."3;980

]GKUGNG." Ectqn{p" *gf0+0" The new elements of mathematics by Charles S. Peirce." Dgtnkp<" Oqwvqp."
3;980_

RGKTEG."Ejctngu"U00"Semiótica."U«q"Rcwnq<"Rgturgevkxc."3;990

RGKTEG."E0"U00"Ugok„vkec"g"ÝnquqÝc0"Vtcf0"fg"Qevcpp{"Uknxgktc"fc"Oqvc"g"Ngqpkfcu"Jgigpdgti0"U«q"
Rcwnq<"Ewnvtkz."OEONZZX"/"C0

RGKTEG."Ejctngu"U00"Semiótica0"4²"gf0."U«q"Rcwnq<"Rgturgevkxc."3;;70

Qwvtcu"Qdtcu<

EJCWë."Octkngpc"*4222+0"Eqpxkvg" "ÝnquqÝc0"U«q"Rcwnq<"èvkec0"

EQUVC."Pgyvqp"fc"*3;;9+0"Q"eqpjgekogpvq"ekgpv Ýeq0"U«q"Rcwnq<"Hcrgur1Fkuewtuq"Gfkvqtkcn0

FKD."Octkc"Cwiwuvc"Pqiwgktc"Ocejcfq0"A agathotopia de Charles Sanders Peirce."Vgug"fg"Fqwvqtcfq"

go"HknquqÝc0"RWE1UR0"422:0

KDTK."Kxq"Cuucf0"M„uoqu"pqgv„u"/"c"ctswkvgvwtc"ogvch ukec"fg"Ejctngu"U0"Rgkteg0"U«q"Rcwnq<"Rgturgevkxc1
J„nqp."3;;40
12ª Jornada Peirceana

LQTIG."Cpc"Octkc0"Vqrqnqikc"fc"c›«q"ogpvcn"/"kpvtqfw›«q" "vgqtkc"fc"ogpvg0 U«q"Rcwnq<"Cppcdnwog."

42280

XKGKTC."Lqtig"C0"("UCPVCGNNC."Nwekc"*422:+0"Metaciência."U«q"Rcwnq<"Ofitkvq0

96 18 ago 2009
YCPGT." U" g" EQUVGPCDNG." U0" T" *3;;8+0" Kpvtqfwekvqp" vq" nqike." jvvr11<rgqrng0jqhuvtc0gfw1Uvghcpa
Ycpgt1Tgcnyqtnf1nqike1nqikekpvtq0jvon0

TQUC." Cpvqpkq" O" *qti0+00" Ejctngu" Ucpfgtu" Rgkteg" Î" cpvqnqikc" Ýnqu„Ýec0 Guvwfqu" igtcku0" Ufitkg"
Wpkxgtukv tkc"Î"En uukequ"fc"HknquqÝc0"Nkudqc<"Kortgpuc"Pcekqpcn"Ecuc"fc"Oqgfc."uf00

UCPVCGNNC."N¿ekc0"Ogvqfqnqikc"ugok„vkec"/"hwpfcogpvqu0"U«q"Rcwnq."Vgug"fg"Nkxtg"Fqe‒pekc."GEC1
WUR."3;;5c0

UCPVCGNNC."N¿ekc0"C"rgtegr›«q"/"woc"vgqtkc"ugok„vkec0"U«q"Rcwnq<"Gzrgtkogpvq."3;;5d0

12ª Jornada Peirceana

18 ago 2009 97