Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Washington Luis Souza - Mestrado
Washington Luis Souza - Mestrado
PUC-SP
MESTRADO EM FILOSOFIA
SÃO PAULO
2008
PONTIFCIA UNIVERSIDADE CATÒLICA DE SÃO PAULO
PUC-SP
MESTRADO EM FILOSOFIA
SÃO PAULO
2008
Banca Examinadora
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
Com carinho e
agradecimento pela
compreensão, apoio e
incentivo dedico este
trabalho a Conceição,
Werneck e Wellington.
Agradecimentos
Este estudo tem por objetivo, a partir da leitura da obra de Michel Foucault,
apresentar a transição da medicina clássica (séculos XVII e XVIII) à medicina
moderna (séculos XIX e XX), como momento de ruptura, em oposição à tese da
evolução teleológica proposta pela historiografia médica tradicional. No plano
institucional, serão abordadas as dicotomias entre as práticas médicas e as
instituições hospitalares clássicas, situando o nascimento do hospital médico
terapêutico como um fato próprio da modernidade.
Introdução.......................................................................................... 1
Primeiras considerações.................................................... 12
1.1. A medicina classificatória................................................ 13
1.2. O hospital no
classicismo............................................................................. 19
Últimas considerações........................................................ 22
Primeiras considerações.................................................... 23
2.1. As epidemias e o nascimento da medicina
social..................................................................................... 24
2.2. A medicina social e a medicina
classificatória......................................................................... 26
2.2.1. A medicina social na
Alemanha....................................................................... 27
2.2.2. A medicina social na
França............................................................................ 30
2.3. As epidemias e a consciência política da
doença................................................................................... 33
Últimas considerações........................................................ 35
Capitulo 3. A Revolução Francesa, os hospitais e o nascimento
da clínica moderna.
Primeiras considerações.................................................... 36
3.1. O fim dos 37
hospitais.................................................................................
3.2. O fim dos estabelecimentos de ensino da 40
medicina................................................................................
3.3. O nascimento do hospital e da clínica 42
modernos...............................................................................
Últimas considerações. ...................................................... 50
Primeiras considerações.................................................... 51
4.1. A protoclínica do século XVIII......................................... 52
4.2. A clínica do final do século XVIII..................................... 54
4.3. A anátomo-clínica do século
XIX........................................................................................ 60
4.4. As contribuições da fisiologia de François
Broussais.................................. 64
Últimas considerações........................................................ 68
Conclusão. ........................................................................................ 69
Bibliografia......................................................................................... 75
!"##!"###$
!#! !!$ % &
' &
( ) *
+ ( %
( + + ( (
23435' - 6 7-3 89* ' :
;;;;;;;;;; ' < => < ?
3(*@@A
*
23435' B5C C D(##
=@EF=* ;;;;;;;;;; B5 + !"### G ( ## A F *9
;;;;;;;;;; B5 D ( ## *@9 F **E 23435'
( ##H I I& J (
?+ 5-K 88L' . :;;;;;;;;;;B2
D 88F ;;;;;;;;;; B % M
!"### 8AN*@9;;;;;;;;;;B2 D
98N8E23435' 2
< L> < ? .K 888
A
& + + B + D
/ + & ( 1 + +
2+ .
& ( :23435'
& '(! -K 89*Q :;;;;;;;;;;
' ? '4 *> / - -(8E8
" (B D#:<"5? ) " * - *@@*
Q :;;;;;;;;;;; * + '
< K Q 14 - (4 5 1/ 4 *@@=*L'
34S#5/ ' B D* , ,
/ - .5 T *@@L*AFA
L
23435' - =P
=
& '(!
P
23435' $ . / 0! - K 8EL
;;;;;;;;;;;; $ . /) -K 8EL' .
: ;;;;;;;;;;;; $ . , 0 % '
' 14 + + < ? K 8E=;;;;;;;;;;;; $
. , ' ' 14 + + < ? K
8E=
9
" ( ( & / ' B
) D* , ,/ - .5 T *@@L8F*@
BQ( + &
+
+ 1
U F
: &
& &
& +
% + , & V
.+ & (
+ U & F
F &1 & M + (
*
& D
E
34S#5/ ' * , A9
8
4& I53W K *0 0)3 ' 4 /C / - X
8EE99
@
23435' - & "F!" 7 2
-& "##F!"###
23435' )'1 ! -K 8P88F*E' :
23435' ! 2" ' 5 1 X Q( < ?
F3(89*8F*9
*
# - &!##72 -& !"
3 1 F
& + (F R
( &
&( 2 + + :
B & + Y(% C
+ % M +
+ & ,
& . 'F
Y( (C Y (C + Y&C
Y C DA
? & )'1 ! 2
:
BI + &
Y 1C & F
&1 & +
( 1 , ( +
1V + &
+ &(
( & +
+
.
) DL
A
34S#5/ ' B& & % &7 0D* ,
,*9
23435' )'1 ! -K 8P8*' :
23435' ! 2"' 5 1 XQ(< ?
F3(89*L
2 & &
/ E +
-
( &+
& ( -
+ & & )
. O % +
& Q( B D1
=
4& 23435' B< 4 C D 1 ' 4 8 -
8PE@
P
23435' )' ! L7 ! 2"P
9
23435' BQ1 D *
4&- & (:23435' )'
-K 89<Q4SI + -<2\S2<#//<23//5](
4 $B C D# * -H
4- 889*@AF**23435' %1,* $.31
-1 ' ? 5X - 8E@=LFP*
<"5? ) " * A@7* +A
<"5? ) " * =7* +*@
23435' B/ ( D#5,-K " A*AA
' :23435' B/ D#5,$ ,
4 BI ^ D( "21 X
' #, I X < ? 3(
*@@L=P
R .
1 ( +
1 F (
& ) (
F
U ( ) ( +
**
) 1 / , .? <(
:
BC C YC O Q
& ( (1 +
( +
( ,+
1 + Y ( C
+ + I 1 Y C
F + 1 2&
: R
*A
( D
4&<"5? ) " * L87* +9@
<"5? ) " * P7* +*
___
B C ( FF F
C ) N +
C C (C&
CG < G & (
+ (G R ` C T :
& R
C
& & ( C
+ D*L
*L
/#QI#QK4 B5 + D))' / 5 K
? O 88*=8FP@
*=
- B (D + + + & (
& + (
% & %(
R
F + &( 4 6
+ ( %
( + (
*P
5"/I2Q/4 * 5 / - *@@*=@
*9
4& " % B4 &D #: 23435' ) 1 0 1 !
1 - K 8PP A9F9P ' :;;;;;;;;;;;
- + ! 61 ' / ' E>
/ - 8889F**=" % B3+
D #: 4SI2 < * , 6 " A> < ? W
*@@PE9F@8
___
4&23435' )' ! LF*@7 ! 2"LF8
*8
23435' =*72 =E
A@
4 + &+ .+ % ,
& &, 1
89L )' '17 1 ! +
,
"23435' B5C C D
( ## =@EF=* ' :;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; B2
D 98N8E
2 + B &
D ( B 1 D & %
A
Q (% &
&
+ + & ( )
& & + (,
& ,
B & 1 D &
!#! + R ,
%A*
A
23435' *72 *
A*
4&#F*7#F*
AA
B D N & + & ( (
( ( V B% D N
, ( R & % V B D N &
#:31 4/
4 TQ - 8LAL*L@=A
$ & / ,
1 1 U
(
N + & ,
N +
%( R 1 +
+ O + ,
$ Q +
+ (
B &
DAL# + R
, +
&
( B& D-
+ & (
1 (
+ B DA=
2 +
( & + 1 B
&O 1DAP &F &F %(
F
*$ B 1 D R + :
%( & &
& %& 06
B D B D + 0 B D
, & +
& V + (
AL
# P7#2 P
A=
#97#E
AP
#E7#E
A9
#EF87#8
( :B
& DAE
A$ B 1 D , 1 R
1
AE
#7#*
A8
4#*
L@
#*7#A
L
4&#*FA7#L
L*
#=7#P
LA
#=7#9
LL
& % /
& 1. )
( + ( R
& (F &%
2( O ) &( &%
Q + &
!"####:#9FE7
#8F*@
L=
#9FE7#8F*@
LP
4&#P7#E
L$ + M B 1 D ,
&F 1 +
& &
3 + 1 &% +a,
( F (
+
#( ) M
+ %
!"### (%
B : (
.( 1 +
% &1 (% +
DL8( (
H 1 +
.
& (
L9
#E7#E
LE
#97#EF8
L8
#87#*
# $
=@
B5C C O D(F
S K . (1
( &. . &
=
4&#B5C C O D(##=@7B2
D @
=*
2 1
< (( V
SO FI -V .
4 U ' 5 4 Qa 3
+ + & (
+ + #:# & '(! *F*L7
8 F* I -% 4
& : % < F -8,
( ( & !"###$F
+ M #:# 87# E9V
+ 1 % F S K #:#
P9F9*7# L=FL8" 34S#5/ ' B2 2 :&
5 D2 ,* A9NLE
=A
#B5C C O D(## =
B2 D @*
+ 1 ) + R
2 % B
D + B
M D
+ + ( +
( (: (
&. BD )
B+ & 1 (% +
(D=LV , ( &
V+ (
B, D +
BK< D . ( ==
=L
#=*7#@*
==
3 ( )
!"### - &1 F @ @
* 4&# &"72
& "##
=P
4&# & '(! L7
@@
2 S K , +
) ( (
4 Q )(
( B, D (
P@
#E7#EP
# & '('
P
23435' *72 *A
P*
#**7#*L
PA
4&#*L7#*P
PL
#**F*A7#*LF*=
P=
) ( (
+ 1 &
+ & 23435' B5
D *@9F*@E7B2 D
98FE@
PP
Q + # (
& !#! +
) ( ,%
23435' =*72 =E
Q #
+ ( ( ,
B + ) V
& % D PE1.
& &
+ & !#! B
) + F F +
DP8 + (( & + % &
.& V
+ ( % +
&&
B& D9@
( ( O !"## + &1 +
) :
PE
23435' B5 D * 7 B2
D E@FE
P8
#*7#E
9@
#*7#E
9
#*7#E
+ ( 1
& &+ 1 % O
9*
#*7#E*
9A
#*L7#EL
9L
#*L7#EL
+ ( ( .
&O , 7, V *$ 1
& (
( . B
D( + 1
V A$ 1
( :
L$ + )
. +a
R 1
I & +
!"### F
&) %
& 1 (1 +
& !"### 1
( (
B %& D + (
( ( (.
( F
(
9=
#*L7#EL
9P
1- .
99
23435' B5 D *= 7 B2
D E=
9E
#*P7#EP
98
#*P7#E9
E@
#*PF*97#E9
E
4&#*9F*87#E9FE8
2 & &
(% , F
+ %EA
'F + B
(
: . & V
EL
. ( ,D 1
B 1
M %( (% DE=
E*
4&#**@F***7#8@N8*
EA
#***7#8*
EL
#***7#8*
E=
#**A7#8A
EP
# B5 + !"### G D ( ## PF9 7 # B %
M !"### &% 89
E9
#PF97#89
EE
. % -% 4 4R %1 :
B O &
. & R $V
( U (% ( (
$V R + ,
R( 1 $D#PF97#89
+ ( (
( + DE8
% . &
M + ( + + %
E8
23435' *= 7 23435'
*9N*E
8@
4&#*PF*97#*8
8
4&#*97#A@
8*
#*E7#A
8A
4& 5"/ I 2Q/4 * 5 / - *@@*
=*
% )( <(
+ & !"### .
. +
( M (%
. & &
( .
+ )(( 1 %
( &
+
& ( 2
. ( B D (
- (1
S K . ) % B O F
(1 %D8L
? ( R
+ ) (
% &
( 1 + ) &( (
. 8=
, . , &
& &
5"/I2Q/4 * / - 5 *@@*=*
8=
4&23435' B5C C O D
(##=*723435' B2 D @*
8P
" + ( O
4&% *8
8E
4&% *9 LL
B2 + ' ) & H
& % : Y& C+
&%
V Y C + &
Y
+ ( C&%
+ ( 1
& %&
%
, %
1 + ,
Y &
+ + (
( (1 &
& CD@
88
4&23435' B5C C O D
(##=723435' B2 D @
@@
4&% *8F*
@
23435' L7#2 LP
#LA7#LE
4&#LA7#LPFLE
4&#AAL*FLA
B . & V O
R ,
R ( $V Z[
Z[V F
V & V
@=
2 T , 9@9 (
& & !"###4&#LL7#LE
@P
4&#LL7#L8
@9
B :*P*92 I T K )'1
,Q U 99*'##=EFED4&# LL7
L8
B ( ( % :
+ & ,)&
( (
+
+ ( +
@
@E
23435' LL7#2 L8
#LP7#=
#=@F=7#=P
1 ,
% 1 &
B & )
1 O2&&1F
( + %
) + ( O
&U2 % 5
( V ( +
/ 1 (
% & %(
+ !"### & B
( DL
) 1 B
1F ) & M
( %(
F D=I :
(% & +
1 &
&V ( ( (
) 1
) 1 V( (%
( B
(& D F
BU DV (%
& %( ( & &% +
+ F 1F ) F 1F
P
L
#==7#@=
=
#==7#@=
4&#=97#@9
9
2+ + ( &,
% *
B O
& .
& R $V
( U (%
$V R
+ , R (
1 $E
B
. ( + + %
T 5(
#B5 + !"###G (##97B %M
!"### 89
+ %
+ 1
/ + 1
) + & 1 &
( !"###
+ + (
)
% 1
.
1 Q
%& ( (&
*@ (. 1
R . +
*
( 1 % +
( + +
& . ) B
& + +
+ + + )
& & , D**
$ . &
( 1
, & (
(1 +
1 ,
/ (1 (
+ ( 99@ & +
Q & !"###(B D
+ :
B/ PE@ ( SO FI - (
!"### ( + ( +
( ( (R (V+ (
( ( V + ( (
& 99@ + (
(+ +
*A
( + D
2 . &
&( B & (D
+ ( (
( B ( & + +
& ( + :
&D*L
#=87#@8
*L
#=*@7#@
& ) ) +
, (
& + , ( ,
- SO FI 9E=(
% , )(
( ,Q ,
& F
*=
#=*@7#@
*P
4&#=*7#
<( O & R .
& ( ,
. + M ( & &
+
% )
& !"###& *9 %
( M
(R .
% R
( %
*9
4&# =9F=E7 PLFP=
.$
4&4SI2< * +6"A> < ? :W *@@P
8@
Q % B" + D
1 ( % )
!"# P=E +
5X % 5T
! 2
X (
!"### % B % X (+
9*@ & 3( %
5TV 5 2& 4 I D*8
) &
2
&
!"### + <(
%
*8
23435' =PF=97 ,PA
A@
4&#=E7#P=
-X :B2 $ + &
N F N+ &DA
A
X#5523'-* ' X1/ 5/
- *@@AL8
A*
4&#=87#PP
AA
#=@FP@7#P9
AL
4&4SI2< :6"A> < ? :W *@@P
8
& ( )
.A=
Q % B ! D &
%( ( / &
F R+
: % 4
5 (
% 4
( %
5
A=
23435' P7 ,PE
% & !"### (
( %( +
& F R
& ,
BQ + % % +
:
( 1V & &
( + Y C + & &
AE
D
A9
4=7#@E
AE
B4 ? '! 1 A ,#$'#
*=*D
/ < & & 4 R
+
%
a% 4 & F +
& $ + &$
B %( &D A8 I
% ) +
%( , a% 2
& ( %&
& % & !"###
( 7 ( L@ + :
B % 1 & 4 (
%
& & & +
L
, D
4W#@A
L@
4&4SI2< :6"A> < ? :W *@@P
8AF8=
L
23435' 8=7 ,@E
L*
4SI2< * +6"8*
& & 4 % & !"###
: 5 /
+ % ( (
& & F
( ) &
& ) +
B% (D I
( &+ (
% . (
+ % LA/ &
4 /:B C C
& & + ) + R + (
C C DLL
$ / +
, + & + ,
R %
& + .
) ( Q B &+ Z[
% + M (
& + DL=
+
LA
4& 23435' 897 ,@
LL
/#QI#QK4 B5 + D))' / 5
K ? O 88*PE
L=
23435' 8EF887 *
B & &O + &
& %
: F
V & +
& . .: &+ 1
Z[ (1 1 Z[ Z[
(Z[& + ,
LP
& D
$ Q (. (
+ & , Q % (.
( % + 1
& ( )
B% (,D+ & (
( + &1
% L9
$ Q % 1
, & B
D -
LP
4&#@@7#L
L9
4&#@7#=
LE
/ a % &
1 ( R(
& 4&#@AF@L7#9FE
L8
#*A7#A8
=@
#L87#P9FPE
=
4&#*=7#L
B % , % : +
+ , %
=*
#*7#*
=A
#*97#LAFLL
=L
4&#*P7#L*
==
#*=F*P7#LFL*
=P
#*P7#L*
X ) 9P@ ( "
( + ( R
&.
( &
(( & % !"###'(F
& + (
( &
& & U B& D&
1 +
!(X
-
1
1 + I B
&&1 V
& ( 1 D =E
1 &
. / B. &D
+
X 3 " E@@ !
E@ O %
1 & +
. =8 Q
X + & & & 1 + +
%( + &
&
#*97#LL
=E
#*E7#LL
=8
4&#*EFA@7#LL7LP
< & &
X &:
B+ % (&
%
X & # + &(
+ ( ((1 U
&
O (
P@
+ D
BX % &
N &
2 ( R
+ %5( H 1
P
R D
P@
4&4SI2< :6"A> < ? :W *@@P
8P
P
X#5523'-* ' X1/ 5/
- *@@AL8
BH ( ( +
%& (% +
H+ O
) ,
, (
P*
&, D
B + + (
& (
1 I%
& & ( : F%
&
+ 1
PA
D
P*
23435' *@@F*@7 ,**9
PA
4SI2< * , *> < ? ? W
*@@=9
B + , &
. ( : + + + &
& &% & &
P8
U D
/ 1 ( 1 & .
4 / :
B + 1 X + %
( 1X
( 5C&
PP
#E*7#*@L7*@=
P9
4&#E*7#*@=
PE
4&#EA7#*@P
P8
#EA7#*@P
C+ ) C+ C, (
+ &&
5 T + G + +
9@
F ( D
B U + .
&O O &
+ ( :%
,
9
, D
9@
/#QI#QK4 B5 + D))' / 5
K ? O 88*PE
9
#8L7#*E
9L
/
& %( (:/#QI#QK4 B5 + D)
)' / 5 K ? O 88*=8FP
1
Q & %
F
R : a%
& 2 F % (
)
( ( 3 ( +
& 3 (
+ , &
( ( +
%( & ( (
)( F &( &%:
B R ( %(
% R +
R , + O
1 (% D 9=
/ ( + & %(
, % +
B ) ) D9P
23435' *@7 ,**9
#*@7#**9
___
99
/ + .+ ( (
(: - I / ( $ 1 * + !
-: \ *@@ / 5 K 1 * +))' H ? O
88*I + /- c ](< 4 $
* H 4- -889I 2-1 $*
+ C / - *@@9
5"/I2Q/4 BS % D#:
I 2-1 $* + C /
- *@@9=8
98
4&#B5 DD(##**AF**E7B2
D 8AF8E
0-'!
2)
x 0 1 ! ! = -:
-3889 ' < A
< ? : F3(8E9
x & '(! -: K 89*
' X ? '4 Q
*/- :-(8E9
x 41 ! - : -3 8P* B
! ' 5% < / < ?
' X 8EL
x ) 1 0 1 ! 1 -
K 88E - 0 ! 6
1 ' / ' / -
8E
x )'1 ! - K 8P8 ! 2"
' 5 % X Q( < ? F
3(89*$
x 2 - K 89= #!
' <+ < - " 1899
x $ 8 + ) - K 89=
$ , + " '
x B3 D#-:K 88L(A9F8
x B- ( D#-:K 88L(*9=LF9P@
x B5 ( ,&+ D#-:K 88L(
AAPEFAE*
x B5 ( &D#-:K
88L(*9*=F9A
x B5 ) ( B#-:K 88L(L***F
*LA
x B/ C D#-:K 88L(
P8PF9A
x B5 + ( B # -: K
88L(LEAFE*E
x B5( &UB#-:K 88L(A
*A9F*=A
x =" $ = $ -
K 8E* ="+ 1 '
# T < ? : (8E*
x ) $4 4 G:89LF89=-:K V5
/ 888 ' X /
- *@@
x )' H. >! *8EN8E*-
K 7/ *@@6 HN >! *,
x X -* -:5X 5888
x X?? 2" 2.2"* <
? :< FI *@@@
x 4 ( * < ? : 3(
8EE
x 4 / 1 / 5 1 * . , H,
$6X :4) *@@@
x Ic 2 )'5 . * '1 ! '
-:\ *@@@
x I 1 K * ' 4 /C / - :
X 8EE
x I . , DKPE
' 4 3(I488L
x ;;;;;;;;;; . 2!, DKQRSDKPP
' 4 3(488A
x I 1 * ' S / - :
4 588@
x H(1 * '1 H -:XF
5 88=
x J * + ' 4
5 :"88A
x - I / ( $ 1 * +
!-:\ *@@
x TTTTTTTTTTTTT ) ' H K 5
-:? O 88*
x / ' * , / - : 5 T
*@@L
x TI1 * -:K 88L
x <BC + 2 BC
= < ? :K 89E
x ;;;;;;;;;;;* + < ? :W *@@@
x ;;;;;;;;;;; :6"< ? :W *@@P
x + ?K1 * < ? :Q (
8E=
x 2 % $6 * -& I ?
4 < ? :K 888
x 2 -1 I $ * + C
/ - *@@9
x - )24 1 1+* 8 -:\
88P
x - -- ) %C/
- :X 8E8
x - " 4 X K $ N * <
? :Q *@@@
x <) ?* +)" * ' 4 <
? :W 8E9
x < <? $N * / - X 8E=
x < /- 2$ 1 ! 1
* < ? ' X 4 A$ 89
B( D9FL*$
x < - ? 1 * -: K
88*
x / (' 1'2 H ? BC.? - :
" 1A888
x '?1 * 1K U3K34K8EE
x ' # $* 4- 8E9
x "T- 1* 1L
' X \X% :3X88E
$ 4
x 31 4 / 4 T
Q - 8L