Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Editorial Bolina
editorial@saudecoletiva.com.br
ISSN (Versión impresa): 1806-3365
BRASIL
2007
Mara Julia Fragoso Pereira / Luzinete Pereira / Maurício Lamano Ferreira
OS BENEFÍCIOS DA TERAPIA ASSISTIDA POR ANIMAIS: UMA REVISÃO
BIBLIOGRÁFICA
Saúde Coletiva, abril-maio, año/vol. 4, número 014
Editorial Bolina
São Paulo, Brasil
pp. 62-66
http://redalyc.uaemex.mx
4ERAPIAS NATURALISTAS
0EREIRA -*& 0EREIRA , &ERREIRA -, /S BENEFÓCIOS DA 4ERAPIA !SSISTIDA POR !NIMAIS UMA REVISÎO BIBLIOGRÉFICA
/ #²/ 2/$/,&/ $! 2!£! ,!"2!$/2 %- 5-! $% 35!3 6)3)4!3 ° #!3! $% 2%0/53/ 02¼ ,)&%
4(9(1<30(-9(.6:67,9,09(
,UMLYTLPYH
THYHFQ\SPH'OV[THPSJVT
3<A05,;,7,9,09(
,UMLYTLPYH
S\WWLYH 'OV[THPSJVT
4(<9Ð*063(4(56-,99,09(
4LZ[YHUKVLT,JVSVNPH=LNL[HSWLSV0UZ[P[\[VKL)V[oUPJHKL
:qV7H\SV:4(TH\LJVSVNPH'`HOVVJVTIY
2ECEBIDO
!PROVADO
7HYH HZ ]PZP[HZ ZLYLT YLHSPaHKHZ L_PZ[L \T WYV[VJVSV H ZLY TH[LYPHSIPISPVNYmMPJVUVZLU[PKVKL]LYPMPJHYLTX\LTLKPKHV
ZLN\PKV VUKL VZ JqLZ KL]LT LZ[HY JVT H ]HJPUHsqV L ]LYTP VIYHJVUZ\S[HKHPU[LYLZZH]HHWLZX\PZH(W}ZPZZVOV\]LSLP[\YH
M\NHsqVLTKPHUqVWVKLTWVZZ\PYW\SNHZULTPUNLYPYJHYUL ZLSL[P]HUHX\HSWYVJLKLZLHZLSLsqVV\ZLQHnKL[LYTPUHsqV
JY\HLSLP[LUqVWHZ[L\YPaHKV6ZJqLZKL]LTLZ[HYZHKPVZSPT KVTH[LYPHSX\LKLMH[VPU[LYLZZHnWLZX\PZH+Hx]LTHSLP[\YH
WVZLLZJV]HKVZL[VTHYIHUOVUVKPHHU[LYPVYHStTKL]PZP[HZ HUHSx[PJH X\L t V TVTLU[V KL VYKLUHY L Z\THYPaHY HZ PUMVY
WLYP}KPJHZHV]L[LYPUmYPV THsLZJVU[PKHZUHZMVU[LZKLMVYTHX\LLZ[HZWVZZPIPSP[LTH
(ZWLZZVHZX\LWHY[PJPWHYLTKHPU[LYHsqVLU[YLLSLZZLQHT VI[LUsqVKLYLZWVZ[HZHVWYVISLTHKHWLZX\PZH
WHJPLU[LZ HJVTWHUOHU[LZ LUMLYTLPYVZ V\ TtKPJVZ KL]LT
SH]HY HZ TqVZ HU[LZ L KLWVPZ KV JVU[H[V JVT V HUPTHS i UL 9,:<3;(+6:
JLZZmYPV L]P[HY X\L V HUPTHS LU[YL LT JVU[H[V JVT ZLJYLsLZ (UPTHPZ ZqV \[PSPaHKVZ JVTV \TH PU[LY]LUsqV LT T\P[VZ Ux
JVTV\YPUHZHSP]H]TP[VLMLYPKHZKVZWHJPLU[LZHStTKPZZV ]LPZKLJ\PKHKVLKLWLZZVHZJYPHUsHZHK\S[VZLPKVZVZJ\PKH
VHUPTHSUqVWVKLZLHSPTLU[HYJVTVZ\[LUZxSPVZKVWHJPLU[L KV HN\KV L JYUPJV YLHIPSP[HsqV JVT\UPJHsqV [HU[V UH WYL
i ULJLZZmYPV X\L V JqV ZLQH Z\WLY]PZPVUHKV V [LTWV PU[LP ]LUsqVJVTVUHJ\YH(PU[LY]LUsqVtIHZLHKHUHPKtPHX\LV
YV WLSV ZL\ JVUK\[VY L HStT KPZZV KL]LTZL L]P[HY LZ[xT\SVZ ]xUJ\SVOVTLTHUPTHSWVKLZLY\[PSPaHKVJVTV\T[VKVPU[L
X\L SL]LT V JqV H TVYKLY L LT JHZV KL TVYKPKHZ KL]LZL NYHUKVLHWYV_PTHUKVVJ\PKHKVLYLHIPSP[HsqVKLPUKP]xK\VZL
JVT\UPJHY PTLKPH[HTLU[L HV LUMLYTLPYV V\ H X\HSX\LY V\[YH Z\HZMHTxSPHZJVTHZLUMLYTPKHKLZJYUPJHZLPUHW[PKqV
WLZZVHYLZWVUZm]LSWHYHH]HSPHYHNYH]PKHKLKHTVYKPKHLWYLZ (;((tHWSPJHKHLTKP]LYZVZLZ[\KVZJHYKPV]HZJ\SHYLZJVT
[HYVZVJVYYVULJLZZmYPV(ZZPTVJqVKL]LZLYH]HSPHKVWVY\T WLZZVHZKLKPMLYLU[LZPKHKLZZL_VLOmIP[VZ,U[YLLSLZKLZ[H
[YLPUHKVYWHYHZHILYZLHPUKHWVKLWLYTHULJLYMHaLUKV]PZP[HZ JHZL V LZ[\KV KL>\ L[ HS X\L MVP MLP[V U\T OVZWP[HS WLKP
iPTWVY[HU[LMHaLYVYLNPZ[YVKH]PZP[HKHZH[P]PKHKLZYLHSPaHKHZ m[YPJV H[YH]tZ KL \T WYVNYHTH KL ]PZP[HsqV KL HUPTHPZ VYNH
LKVZH]HUsVZHSJHUsHKVZVX\LWLYTP[L UPaHKV WVY \T NY\WV ( ]PZP[HsqV K\YH]H
H]HSPHYHLMPJPvUJPHKV[YH[HTLU[V LU[YLHTPU\[VZJVTPU[LYHsqVLU[YL
(;((tJVU[YHPUKPJHKHLTJHZVZLT VZ HUPTHPZ L HZ WLZZVHZ;YvZJHJOVYYVZMP
X\L V WHJPLU[L HWYLZLU[L HSLYNPHZ WYV aLYHTWHY[LKLZ[LWYVNYHTHLVWISPJVHS]V
ISLTHZ KL YLZWPYHsqV TLKV KL HUPTHPZ MVP JYPHUsHZ HJPTH KL ZLPZ TLZLZ KL PKHKL
MLYPKHZ HILY[HZ WHJPLU[LZ JVT IHP_H YL H[tHKVSLZJLU[LZ[VKVZJVTWYVISLTHZJHY
ZPZ[vUJPH HUPTHPZ JVT aVVUVZLZ HStT KxHJVZ5qVMVYHTVIZLY]HKHZZPNUPMPJHU[LZ
KLWLZZVHZJVTJVTWVY[HTLU[VHNYLZZP]V T\KHUsHZLZ[H[xZ[PJHZUHZMYLX vUJPHZYLZ
X\LWVKLTTHJO\JHYVZHUPTHPZ (JYLZ WPYH[}YPHZ L JHYKxHJHZ KVZ WHJPLU[LZ HW}Z
JL H PZZV H ULJLZZPKHKL KL \T JVU[YVSL HZ]PZP[HZWVYtTMVYHTPKLU[PMPJHKHZHSN\
YxNPKV KL PUMLJsqV L aVVUVZLZ X\L WVKL THZHS[LYHsLZULZZHZMYLX vUJPHZK\YHU[L
ZLY YLHSPaHKV WLSH LX\PWL KL JVU[YVSL KL H]PZP[HKVZHUPTHPZVX\LX\LYKPaLYX\L
PUMLJsqV KV OVZWP[HS Q\U[V n LX\PWL YLZ h! 6)3)4! $% #!#(/22/3 %- HWYLZLUsHKLZZLZJHJOVYYVZWVKL[LYLMLP
WVUZm]LSWLSH[LYHWPHL\T]L[LYPUmYPV #%.42/3 #)2Â2')#/3 4)2! 5- [VZYLSH_HU[LZV\LZ[PT\SHU[LZUHZJYPHUsHZ
)HZLHKV UH SP[LYH[\YH L UH PTWVY[oU
0/5#/ ! )-!'%- #!22%'!$! $% LHKVSLZJLU[LZ7VYV\[YVSHKVOV\]L\TH
JPH X\L ZL [LT KL WYVTV]LY V J\PKHKV NYHUKLHJLP[HsqVWVYWHY[LKVZWHPZLWH
PU[LNYHS L O\THUPaHKV HV WHJPLU[L HStT (/30)4!)3 % 423 5- #,)-! JPLU[LZ H YLZWLP[V KV WYVNYHTH \TH ]La
KV KtMPJP[ KL JVUOLJPTLU[V UH SP[LYH[\YH -!)3 #!3%)2/ 0!2! /3 X\L[L]L\THPU[LYHsqVWVZP[P]HLU[YLHUP
IYHZPSLPYH LZZL LZ[\KV [LT JVTV VIQL[P]V 0!#)%.4%3 / 15% /3 ,%6! ! THPZLWHJPLU[LZ
MHaLY \TH YL]PZqV IPISPVNYmMPJH ZVIYL VZ <T LZ[\KV YLHSPaHKV UH (\Z[YmSPH LT
ILULMxJPVZKH;((JVTVTHPZ\TYLJ\YZV
5-! -!)/2 $)342!£²/v JVTWHY[PJPWHU[LZKL\TWYV
UHHZZPZ[vUJPHHVWHJPLU[L NYHTHKLZLSLsqVJHYKPV]HZJ\SHYTVZ[YV\
X\L WHJPLU[LZ KVUVZ KL HUPTHPZ WVKLT [LY ZPNUPMPJHU[L KPTP
4,;6+636.0( U\PsqVUVZxUKPJLZKLWYLZZqVHY[LYPHSL[YPNSPJtYPKLZKVZX\LVZ
( WLZX\PZH LT X\LZ[qV JVUZ[P[\PZL U\T SL]HU[HTLU[V KL W\ UqVKVUVZKLHUPTHPZSL]HUKVLTJVU[HMH[VYLZKLYPZJVJVTV
ISPJHsLZ JPLU[xMPJHZ YLSHJPVUHKHZ JVT V [LTH UV WLYxVKV [HIHNPZTVL_LYJxJPVZLU[YLV\[YVZ7VYtTtWYLJPZVTHPZLZ[\
LU[YL H(ZIHZLZMVYHTJVUZ\S[HKHZLU[YLTHYsVH KVZWHYH]HSPKHYVZYLHPZILULMxJPVZX\LVHUPTHSWVKLWYVTV
ZL[LTIYV KL ZLUKV LSHZ! :JPLSV 4LKSPUL L 7\I4LK(Z ]LYHVOVTLT
WHSH]YHZJOH]LZMVYHTJY\aHKHZKL[YvZTHULPYHZKPZ[PU[HZ¸(UP (SSLU L[ HS YLHSPaHYHT \T LZ[\KV WHYH H]HSPHY ZL H HX\P
THS(ZZPZ[LK;OLYHW`¹¸7L[;OLYHW`¹L¸7L[6^ULYZOPW¹(WL ZPsqV KL \T HUPTHS KL LZ[PTHsqV WVKLYPH YLK\aPY MYLX vUJPH
ZHY KPZ[V V LZ[\KV ]LYZH ZVIYL \TH YL]PZqV IPISPVNYmMPJH UqV JHYKxHJH WYLZZqV HY[LYPHS LT \T NY\WV KL PUKP]xK\VZ JVT OP
ZPZ[LTH[PaHKH WLY[LUZqVJVTWYVMPZZLZKLHS[H[LUZqV+VPZNY\WVZWHY[PJPWH
7HYHHUmSPZLLZxU[LZLKVTH[LYPHSVIZLY]HYHTZLVZZLN\PU YHTHTIVZJVT\ZVKL3PZPUVWYPSWVYtTU\TNY\WVJHKHPU
[LZ WYVJLKPTLU[VZ! SLP[\YH L_WSVYH[}YPH X\L t \TH SLP[\YH KV [LNYHU[LHKX\PYP\\THUPTHS-PZPVSVNPJHTLU[LVZHUPTHPZ[vT
THPVYPUMS\vUJPHUHZYLZWVZ[HZZPTWm[PJHZ LHTV[P]HsqVX\LVZHUPTHPZWYVTV]LT
X\LV3PZPUVWYPSZVaPUOV/V\]LYLK\sqV :PLNLS YLHSPaV\ \T LZ[\KV K\YHU[L \T
KL MYLX vUJPH JHYKxHJH WYLZZqV HY[LYPHS HUVJVT WHY[PJPWHU[LZJVTHUVZV\
WHYH V NY\WV X\L HKX\PYP\ V HUPTHS LT THPZ WHYH H]HSPHY H MYLX vUJPH X\L VZ WHY[P
ZP[\HsLZKLLZ[YLZZL JPWHU[LZ PHT HV TtKPJV LU[YL WYVWYPL[mYPVZ
6\[YV LZ[\KV YLHSPaHKV WVY (SSLU L[ L UqV WYVWYPL[mYPVZ KL HUPTHPZ 6Z WHY[PJP
HS WHYH H]HSPHY YLZWVZ[HZ JHYKPV]HZJ\ WHU[LZ WYVWYPL[mYPVZ KL HUPTHPZ ZL YLWVY[H
SHYLZ UH WYLZLUsH KL HTPNVZ JUQ\NLZ L ]HTTLUVZHVTtKPJVK\YHU[LVHUVKVX\L
KLHUPTHPZTVZ[YV\X\LWYVWYPL[mYPVZKL HX\LSLZX\LUqVWVZZ\xHT6ZHUPTHPZWHYL
HUPTHPZ [P]LYHT ZPNUPMPJHU[L KPTPU\PsqV JPHTHQ\KHYZL\ZWYVWYPL[mYPVZLTTVTLU[VZ
UH MYLX vUJPH JHYKxHJH LUX\HU[V VZ X\L KL LZ[YLZZL L LZ[PT\SH]H ZL\Z KVUVZ H MHaL
UqV WVZZ\xHT HUPTHPZ UqV [P]LYHT NYHU h!#2%$)4! 3% 15% $%6)$/ ° &!,4! YLT L_LYJxJPVZ 6\[YV LZ[\KV ULZZL TLZTV
KLZ HS[LYHsLZ 5V[V\ZL [HTItT X\L VZ JVU[L_[VMVPYLHSPaHKVWVY.HYYP[`L[HSWHYH
WYVWYPL[mYPVZ KL HUPTHPZ ZL YLJ\WLYH]HT
$% #/.(%#)-%.4/ % $% ).&/2-! H]HSPHY VZ HUPTHPZ JVTV MH[VY KL Z\WVY[L UH
JVTTHPZYHWPKLaLTZP[\HsLZKLLZ[YLZ £À%3 3/"2% / !335.4/ ./ "2!3), ZHKLKVZPKVZVZ,ZZLLZ[\KVZ\NLYLX\LHUP
ZLKVZX\LUqVVZWVZZ\xHT 0/5#!3 ).34)45)£À%3 54),):!- THPZLZ[qVYLSHJPVUHKVZH\TLZ[HKVLTVJPV
,TIVYH HSN\UZ [YHIHSOVZ KLTVUZ
[YLT YLZWVZ[HZ JHYKPV]HZJ\SHYLZ WVZP[P
%33% -³4/$/ #/-/ 4%2!0)! !,³- UHSLX\LWVKLTWYVTV]LYZ\WVY[LZ\MPJPLU
[L WHYH KPTPU\PY V ZVMYPTLU[V LTVJPVUHS KL
]HZ7HYZSV^ 1VYTKLZLU]VS]LYHT\T $! 2%3)34´.#)! $% #/,/#!2 !.) PKVZVZX\LWVYT\P[HZ]LaLZ]P]LTZVaPUOVZ
[YHIHSOV JVT WLZZVHZ X\L MVYHT -!)3 %- ).34)45)£À%3 (/30)4!,! LWLYKLYHTZL\ZLU[LZX\LYPKVZ
KP]PKPKHZLTKVPZNY\WVZ"\TJVTPKHKL 6ZHUPTHPZ[HTItT[vTZPKVILT]PUKVZ
2%3 0%,! #2%.£! 15% /3 !.)-!)3
LU[YL HUVZ L V\[YV UH MHP_H L[mYPH LT \UPKHKLZ WZPX\Pm[YPJHZ VUKL LZ[\KVZ YLH
LU[YL HUVZ +LZZL [V[HS WVZ 42!.3-)4!- ).&%#£À%3v SPaHKVZKLTVUZ[YHTYLZ\S[HKVZWVZP[P]VZ)H
Z\xHT HUPTHPZ LT JHZH 5LZZL LZ[\KV YHRL[HSKLZLU]VS]LYHT\TLZ[\KVJVT
LSLZ UqV WLYJLILYHT ULUO\TH HS[LYHsqV PKVZVZJVTLZX\PaVMYLUPHVUKLVZWYPUJPWHPZ
JHYKPVS}NPJH X\L MVZZL JHWHa KL L_WSPJHY H WYLZLUsH KVZ HUP WVU[VZ H]HSPHKVZ MVYHT V JVU[H[V PU[LYWLZZVHS" JVT\UPJHsqV"
THPZ7VYtTUV[V\ZLX\LLU[YLVZWLZX\PZHKVZX\LWVZZ\xHT H[P]PKHKLZKVKPHKPHJVTVOPNPLULWLZZVHSH\[VJ\PKHKV"WVY
HUPTHPZ OV\]L \TH THPVY WYLZZqV KPHZ[}SPJH KV X\L UVZ KL \TH LZJHSH JOHTHKH :JHSL MVY :VJPHS (KHW[H[P]L -\UJ[PVUPUN
THPZ L PZZV MVP Q\Z[PMPJHKV WLSVZ H\[VYLZ KL]PKV HV MH[V KLSLZ ,]HS\H[PVU:(-,+V[V[HSKLPKVZVZKLaPU[LYHNPYHTJVTJH
JHYYLNHYLTHSN\UZ]xJPVZJVTVVJVUZ\TVKLJPNHYYVZLILIP JOVYYVZLKLaUqV(WHY[PYKVZL_[VTvZWKLZLUV[HYHSN\UZ
KHZHSJV}SPJHZHStTKL[LYLT\TTLUVYNYH\KLPUZ[Y\sqV LMLP[VZX\LMVYHTTHU[PKVZH[tVMPTKVLZ[\KV,U[YLLSLZKLZ
( ]PZP[H KL JHJOVYYVZ LT JLU[YVZ JPYYNPJVZ [PYH \T WV\JV [HJHTZLVH\TLU[VKHPU[LYHsqVZVJPHSTLSOVYOHIPSPKHKLKL
HPTHNLTJHYYLNHKHKLOVZWP[HPZL[YmZ\TJSPTHTHPZJHZLPYV JVU]LYZHsqV WHY[PJPWHsqV KVZ NY\WVZ ZVJPHSPaHsqV JVTWYV
WHYH VZ WHJPLU[LZ V X\L VZ SL]H H \TH THPVY KPZ[YHsqV 0ZZV TPZZVZZVJPHPZHTPaHKLZLSHaLY7VYV\[YVZxUKPJLZKHLZJHSH
WVKL ZLY ILT HWSPJHKV WYPUJPWHSTLU[L LT JHZVZ KL WHJPLU[LZ JVTVH\[VJ\PKHKVLJVU[YVSLKLPTW\SZVZUqVOV\]LZPNUPMP
X\L Qm LZ[qV LT JLU[YVZ JSxUPJVZ Om IHZ[HU[L [LTWV V\ X\L JHU[LZT\KHUsHZ
WLYTHULJLYqVULSLZWVY[LTWVPUKL[LYTPUHKV 5\TLZ[\KVYLHSPaHKVWVY)HYRLY +H^ZVUWHJPLU[LZ
(;(( WVKL ZLY PTWSHU[HKH UV J\PKHKV WYtVWLYH[}YPV KL WZPX\Pm[YPJVZ JVT KPHNU}Z[PJVZ KL KLWYLZZqV [YHUZ[VYUV HML[P]V
WHJPLU[LZH[YH]tZKHZ]PZP[HZKLJqLZ[YLPUHKVZVX\LWVKLYL IPWVSHYLZX\PaVMYLUPHWZPJVZLL[YHUZ[VYUVZKLO\TVYMVYHTKP
K\aPYVLZ[YLZZLHU[LYPVYnJPY\YNPH[VYUHYZL\ZWLUZHTLU[VZV[P ]PKPKVZLTKVPZNY\WVZ!\TJVTH[P]PKHKLZKLYLJYLHsqVLV\
TPZ[HZ WYVTV]LUKV \T TLSOVY W}ZVWLYH[}YPV L YLK\aPUKV H [YV JVT H;(( ,U[YL VZ WHJPLU[LZ X\L WHY[PJPWHYHT KH H[P]PKH
ULJLZZPKHKLKLTLKPJHTLU[VZWHYHKVY KLKLYLJYLHsqVHWLUHZVZX\LWVZZ\xHT[YHUZ[VYUVZKLO\TVY
*VSL .H^SPUZRP PTWSHU[HYHT H;(( LT \TH <UPKHKL VI[P]LYHTNYHUKLKPTPU\PsqVKHHUZPLKHKLWVYtTHX\LSLZX\L
KL;LYHWPH0U[LUZP]HLYLHSPaHYHT\TLZ[\KVK\YHU[LZLPZTLZLZ HWYLZLU[H]HT[YHUZ[VYUVZKLO\TVYWZPJVZLZLZX\PaVMYLUPHLU
JVT\T[V[HSKL]PZP[HZKLJqLZ(W}ZV[tYTPUVKVLZ[\KV [YLV\[YVZX\LWHY[PJPWHYHTKH;((VI[P]LYHT\THZPNUPMPJHU[L
VZWHJPLU[LZYLZWVUKLYHTH\TX\LZ[PVUmYPVWHYHH]HSPHYVNYH\ KPTPU\PsqVKHHUZPLKHKL7HYHH]HSPHYVYLZ\S[HKVMVP\[PSPaHKHH
KLZH[PZMHsqV:LN\UKVHLZJHSHHTHPVYPHKVZWHJPLU[LZTVZ LZJHSH:[H[L;YHP[(U_PL[`0U]LU[VY`HU[LZLKLWVPZKHZ[LYHWPHZ
[YV\ZLIHZ[HU[LZH[PZMLP[VMLSPaJHSTVTLUVZZVaPUOVTLUVZ 9PJOLZVUYLSH[V\VZLMLP[VZKH;((UHPU[LYHsqVZVJPHSLT
HUZPVZVLZ\NLYPYHTX\LH]PZP[HKL]LYPHZLYTHPZMYLX LU[L JVTWVY[HTLU[VZHNP[HKVZKLPKVZVZJVTKLTvUJPH,ZZLLZ[\
(UPTHPZ WVKLT WYVTV]LY \T H\TLU[V KV ILTLZ[HY WHYH KV MVP KP]PKPKV LT [YvZ MHZLZ! PUPJPHS ( HU[LZ KH PU[LY]LUsqV
HSN\UZPKVZVZ6ZLMLP[VZKHZVJPHSPaHsqVWVKLTZLYPTWVY[HU JVTHUPTHS"W}Z[LZ[L)HW}ZHZ[YvZZLTHUHZKLPU[LY]LUsqV
[LZ WHYH PKVZVZ X\L WLYKLYHT ZL\Z HTPNVZ L TLTIYVZ KH MH L HJVTWHUOHTLU[V* HW}Z [YvZ ZLTHUHZ KV MPT KH PU[LY]LU
TxSPH LZWLJPHSTLU[L HX\LSLZ X\L ZLU[LT MHS[H KL JYPHUsHZ V\ sqV( WLZX\PZH MVP N\PHKH WVY X\H[YV OPW}[LZLZ! VZ LMLP[VZ KH
LZ[qVPZVSHKVZKHZVJPLKHKLHZZPTJVTVHYLK\sqVKVLZ[YLZZL ;(( WVKLT KPTPU\PY JVTWVY[HTLU[VZ HNP[HKVZ KH MHZL PUPJPHS
2EFERÐNCIAS
.HYJPH9**VU[YVSLKLWVW\SHsLZ YHW`(T15\YZ;L_HZ]UW ZOPWHUKYPZRMHJ[VYMVYJHYKPV]HZJ\SHY VM (UPTHS (ZZPZ[LK [OLYHW` VU (U_PL
KLJqLZLNH[VZLTmYLH\YIHUH!\TH KPZLHZL! HUV[OLY SVVR ;OL 4LKPJHS [` 9H[PUNZ VM OVZWP[HSPaLK WZ`JOPH[YPJ
L_WLYPvUJPH PUV]HKVYH UH .YHUKL :qV *VUUVY241(UPTHS(ZZPZ[LK[OL 1V\YUHS VM (\Z[YmSPH (\Z[YmSPH WH[PLU[Z 7Z`X\PH[YPJ :LY] ,<(" !
7H\SV:HKL*VSL[P]H]UW YHW`! HU PUKLW[O SVVR +PTLUZ *YP[ O[[W!^^^TQHJVTH\W\ISPJPZ 1\U
1HULPYVKL *HYL5\YZ" !4HP1\U Z\LZ F FWHYF 9PJOLZVU 5, ,MMLJ[Z VM (UPTHS
3L]PUZVU -4 7L[ WZ`JOV[OLYHW`! .PS(**VTVLSHIVYHYWYVQL[VZKL MTO[TS(JLZZVLTKLTHP (ZZPZ[LK;OLYHW`VUHNP[H[LKILOH]PVYZ
\ZLVMOV\ZLOVSKWL[ZPU[OL[YLH[TLU[ WLZX\PZHZ:qV7H\SV([SHZ 4PSSLY 1 0UNYHT 3 7LYPVWLYH[P]L HUK ZVJPHS PU[LYHJ[PVUZ VM VSKLY HK\S[Z
VM ILOH]PVY KPZVYKLYZ PU JOPSKOVVK (SS (* L[ HS (UPTHSZ /VYZLIHJR U\YZPUN HUK HUPTHS HZZPZ[LK [OLYHW` ^P[O KLTLU[PH! HU L]PKLUJLIHZLK
7Z`JOVSVNPJHS 9LWVY[Z" ! 9PKPUN HUK 0TWSPJH[PVUZ MVY 9LOHIP (6951V\YUHS! [OLYHWL\[PJ YLJYLH[PVU PU[LY]LU[PVU
+La SP[H[PVU ;OLYHW` 1V\YUHS VM 9LOHIPSP *VSSL 24 .H^SPUZRP ( (UPTHS (T 1 (SaOLPTLYZ +PZ 6[OLY +LTLU
+H]PZ 4=HSSH -9 ,]PKLU [H[PVU O[[W!^^^MPUKHY[PJSLZ (ZZPZ[LK;OLYHW`PU[OL0U[LUZP]L*HYL ,<("!5V]+LJ
JL MVY KVTLZ[PJH[PVU VM [OL KVN JVTWHY[PJSLZTPFTPZFFHPF <UP[(Z[HMMU\YZLþZKYLHTJVTL[Y\L 3H\U 3 )LULMP[Z VM 7L[;OLYHW` PU
`LHYZ HNV PU [OL UH[PVU VM (JLZZVLTHNV 5\YZ*SPU5VY[O(T,<("! +LTLU[PH /VTL /LHS[O 5\YZL ,<("
0ZYHLS 5H[\YL O[[W!^^^ >\ (: L[ HS (JJLW[HIPSP[` HUK :L[ ! 1HU
PWHTPUJ\S[\YHW[JPWHaVVW\IZ 0TWHJ[ VM 7L[=PZP[H[PVU VU H 7LKPH[YPJ /HY[ 3( ;OL 9VSL VM 7L[Z PU ,K^HYKZ5,)LJR(4(UPTHS(Z
:PTVU +H]PZ 5H[\ *HYKPVSVN` 0TWH[PLU[ <UP[ 1V\YUHS VM ,UOHUJPUN /\THU>LSSILPUN! LMMLJ[Z ZPZ[LK;OLYHW`HUK5\[YP[PVUPU(SaOLP
YL+VN+VT WKM (JLZZV LT ZL[ 7LKPH[YPJ5\YZPUN6\[ MVYVSKLYWLVWSL+LS[H:VJPL[` TLY þZ KPZLHZL>LZ[ 1 5\YZ 9LZ ,<(
(UKLYZVU>7L[HS7L[V^ULYZOPW O[[W!^^^KLS[HZVJPL[`VYNKV^USVHK ! V\[
;\RL : +LZJYPW[PVU VM [OL 9L HUK YPZR MHJ[VYZ MVY JHYKPV]HZJ\SHY KP OHY[Y[M(JLZZVLTKLQ\S 1HJVIZVU . L[ HS -PZO (X\HYP\T
[YLH[ 7\I 4LK O[[W!^^^ ZLHZL 4LK 1 (\Z[" ! :PLNLS 14 :[YLZZM\S 3PML ,]LU[Z (UPTHS (ZZPZ[LK ;OLYHW` HUK 0[Z 0U
W\ITLKJLU[YHSUPONV]HY[PJSLYLUKLY ZL[ HUK \ZL VM 7O`ZPJPHU :LY]PJLZ HTVUN MS\LUJL VU *SPLU[Z ^P[O 4\S[PWSL
MJNP&HY[PK$ (JLZZVLTKL (SSLU 2 L[ HS 7L[ 6^ULYZOPW I\[ [OL,SKLYS`![OLTVKLYH[PUNYVSLVMWL[ :JSLYVZPZ 9LZLHYJO 5\YZPUN 7YHJ[PJL
HNV 5V[ (*, 0UOPIP[VY ;OLYHW` )S\U[Z V^ULYZOPW1V\YUHSVM7LYZVUHSP[`HUK O[[W!^^^NYHK\H[LYLZLHYJO
+V[[P1;LYHWPHLHUPTHPZ:qV7H\SV /VTL )SVVK 7YLZZ\YL 9LZWVUZLZ [V :VJPHS7Z`JOVSVN`,<(" JVT.1HJVIZVUO[T (JLZZV LT
5Vt[PJH 4LU[HS :[YLZZ (TLYPJHU /LHY[ (ZZV ZL[
:PS]LPYH50THNLUZKV0UJVUZJPLU JPH[PVU O[[W!O`WLYHOHQV\Y .HYYP[` ;- L[ HS 7L[ 6^ULYZOPW /LPTSPJO2(UPTHSHZZPZ[LK[OLYH
[L9PVKL1HULPYV(SOHTIYH UHSZVYNJNPJVU[LU[HIZ[YHJ[ HUK([[HJOTLU[ HZ :\WWVY[P]L -HJ[VYZ W` HUK [OL ZL]LYLS` KPZHISLK JOPSK! H
6^LU 6. 7L[ [OLYHW`! 7H^Z MVY (JLZZVLTKLZL[ PU [OL /LHS[O 6M;OL ,SKLYS` (U[OYV X\HU[P[H[P]L Z[\K` .YHK\H[L 3P[LYHY`
[OV\NO[5\YZ;PTLZ]UW FFFFFF *HYKPV]HZJ\SHY 9LHJ[P]P aVVZ,<("! (^HYK >PUULY ¶ (IZ[YHJ[ 1V\YUHS VM
[` HUK [OL 7YLZLUJL VM 7L[Z -YPLUKZ )HYHR@L[HS(UPTHS(ZZPZ[LK;OL 9LOHIPSP[H[PVU6\[KLa O[[W!
1VMYt34=PZP[H[LYHWv\[PJHKLTHZ HUK :WV\ZLZ! ;OL ;Y\[O (IV\[ *H[Z YHW`MVY,SKLYS`:JOPaVWOYLUPJ7H[PLU[Z! ^^^MPUKHY[PJSLZJVTWZLHYJO&X[$HUP
JV[HZ LT OVZWP[HSLZ 9L] *OPS 0UMLJ[ HUK +VNZ 7Z`JOVZVTH[PJ 4LKPJPUL" HVUL`LHYJVU[YVSSLK[YPHS(T1.LYPH[Y THSHZZPZ[LK[OLYHW` [I$HY[ TW$HUP
:HU[PHNV"!:L[ ! 7Z`JOPH[Y`0ZYHLS" ! THSHZZP[LK[OLYHW` XM$!HSS (JLZZV
:[HUSL` 441 (UPTHS HZZPZ[LK [OL 7HYZSV^ 9( 1VYT (- 7L[ V^ULY )HYRLY:)+H^ZVU2:;OLLMMLJ[Z LTKLHNV